Actions

Work Header

Songs of Erebor

Summary:

AU The Arkenstone was never found, Thror's gold fever never got bad, and Smaug never attacked.
Thorin is the royal heir, and he is rather bored, until he hears a dwarf singing, and he falls in love. But as it turned out, getting Bofur to love him back the easy part of it.
Especially once a hobbit appeared in their lives.

Chapter Text

Thorin, son of Thrain, was by nature a suspicious dwarf. He was also a proud one, and his quick temper could have done with some work. And there was something to be said for his vanity and his enjoyment of good clothes and nice furs. But he was, after all, Prince under the Mountain, and he felt he had some right to be as he was. The kingdom he would someday rule was the greatest of all Middle Earth, his father was respected as a wise king by dwarves, elves and men alike, and Thorin himself had proved himself in battle against the goblins years ago. If that didn't allow him to have a few defects, then he didn't see what the point of being royalty even was.

And it wasn't as though he only had bad sides, really. He was kind to those below him -that was to say, every living creature, except his father. He was well read, though out of necessity more than pleasure, and his interests laid more in treaties and stories of great battles, than in novels and foolish tales. He had also been told often enough that he was as good a friend as ever was, and his lover had never yet had to complain of the way he was treated by the prince.

Though things had not always been easy with Bofur. For a prince of Erebor to fall for a miner, and a male one at that, had been rather scandalous. Not that dwarves shared the ridiculous ideas of men about two male lying together, but a prince was expected to continue the line of course. Thorin had disagreed. He had a brother and a sister to take care of such things for him, and by the time he had fallen in love, Dis had been with child for the second time. The line of Durin had nothing to fear.

And it was not as though he had decided whom he had fallen for, really.

 


 

He had been walking with Balin around the lowest levels of the mountains, inspecting some of the mines. They had heard of some problems there, and Thrain feared they had been digging too deep, the way it had happened in Khazad-dûm. His son had offered to see it for himself, feeling bored out of his wits. Peace was a nice thing, but not one that kept him very entertained. Some days he wished for something, anything, to happen, so that he may not die of boredom before he even reach a hundred and thirty.

The inspection had gone well enough. Balin and him had agreed that it would probably be wiser to close the lower tunnels, since the stone there seemed too fragile to work safely. They were going up again, discussing and laughing, when Thorin's ears had caught a little tune, coming from a tunnel they were passing by. He had frozen on the spot.

The prince, who had heard the best singers of the kingdom, who had been at celebrations held by humans and elves, who knew the best voices of Middle Earth, had never known anything to sing like that. It was a voice deep and soft, one that reminded him of the purest mithril; something that could have all at once the greatest beauty and a strength that nothing could defeat. Thorin had felt like whoever owned that voice had put a spell on him. He simply had to find that dwarf, and to never let him go.

Following the song, the young prince had arrived near a group of miners having their lunch. They did not seem to care much for the singer, as if they were so used to the beauty of his voice that they no longer heard it. Thorin swore to himself that, once he had made that dwarf his, he would always make it clear what a gift that voice was. But first, he needed to put a face on that voice, as the singer had his back turned to him. He took a few more steps toward the group, and all the miners rose to their feet when they recognize the royal heir. The last one to notice anything was his singing dwarf, who seemed too taken by his melody to see his companions moving. One of the others had to take his shoulder to take him out of his little world of music, and only then did he turn to face the prince.

He could not have been more than eighty or ninety, and it made Thorin feel almost guilty to still want him when he was so young. But he was the most charming young dwarf he had ever seen, with a fine moustache growing, and hair in two braids that turned upward at the end. He would have wanted to take him in his arms right there and then, bring him to his rooms, and never let go of him.

“May we help you, your highness?” had asked one of the miners.

“I had heard the singing,” Thorin mindlessly answered, still unable to take his eyes off the young dwarf.

“Did our little Bofur disturb you?” another miner worried, putting a hand on the singer's shoulder. “He's got himself a good voice that one, but not much taste for the songs he chooses I'm afraid. We'd told him elven ballads didn't have their place in dwarven mines. See, laddie? Even the prince disapproves.”

Thorin had wanted to protest. The prince did not disapprove anything. The boy would have sung goblins' songs and still be lovely. But that would have been improper of course. One did not act so bluntly in matters of love, especially not when one was a royal prince.

“Indeed, it is rather sad that he does not know more proper songs,” Thorin said, trying to look stern, then wanting to hug the boy when he saw the sad look on his face. “But he has a good voice, yes, and he should be trained. I will have a word with competent people to see if something can be arranged for it.”

The others thanked him for that, praising his generosity, requesting that Bofur, as they had called him, be properly thankful of the chance he was been given. But the young dwarf had only shot a dark look to the prince, the look of someone who knew he needed no training, and that the whole business was strange. That had pleased Thorin almost as much as his voice had. It seemed his little singer had a good brain as well as a great voice.

 


 

 

"Ye're a stupid assbutt, and I don't need yer stupid lessons. I sing great, and this is all stupid."

The singing master shot a pleading look to Thorin, who sighed. The old dwarf had done nothing to deserve a student like Bofur, but then again, Bofur was right: he didn't really need lessons.

"I am your prince, and I say you are to learn," Thorin reminded him, cringing as he said it. It was about the worst way to gain the younger dwarf affections, and he knew it, but Bofur was making this so difficult.

The dwarf prince had had a very nice plan prepared to court the young miner. He had decided to come to as many of his music lessons as possible, giving him an occasion to compliment him on his voice, and from there, to ask him about his family, his hobbies, the sort of gems he preferred. It would have been nice and easy.

Instead, he found himself facing an angry teenager who thought it was perfectly normal to be insulting a prince. Thorin tried to hide it, but he found it... refreshing. And anger was a better thing than indifference, wasn't it?

"I don't wanna sing today, and ye cannae make me!" Bofur yelled at his unfortunate master, who looked at Thorin as if to beg for help.

"You have to, lad," the exhausted old dwarf sighed. "It is important that you master your voice, and..."

"I don't wanna be a singer! I ain't a stupid singer, and I ain't a miner, and I swear I'm leaving this moment and never coming again, 'cause this is all bollocks!"

And before either Thorin or the music master could react, the boy had stormed away, slamming the door behind him.

"I won't see that one again," the master said with some regret. "Nice voice he had, but if I may dare a comment, my prince, you should not have sent him to me against his will."

"A voice like that must be trained."

"A voice like that must be enjoyed by those that boy likes, and none other, if that is what he wishes. If you ever want to hear him again, then I suggest you try actually talking to him. He's clever enough, when he forgets he's supposed to hate everyone, and if you give him a chance to talk to you, he might do more than throw insults at you."

 Thorin refused to answer, fearing the other dwarf was right.

 


 

As the old master had foreseen, Bofur had not come for his next lesson, nor the following, though Thorin remained sure the boy would come to his senses. There was some respect due to a prince, and certainly the boy's family would not approve of him refusing a royal order very long.

But weeks passed, and the boy never came again. The music master asked Thorin for permission to consider their classes cancelled, and the prince had to agree. He felt like he had lost his chance, and dared not go to Bofur. There was no point in explaining what he had trully intended, after all. The boy had made it clear that he hated him, and it would have been pathetic of him to insist.

And so it was only through sheer luck that, in the following months, Thorin found himself having to inspect this of that tunnel near the place where he had first seen Bofur. And if he stopped everything he was doing whenever he heard someone singing, well, who could blame him, really? Once or twice, he was lucky, and he recognized the voice of his young miner. But he never dared to approach, knowing only too well that his attentions were unwelcome, and...

“Are you going to talk to that damn boy, or do I have to do it myself?” Balin grumbled next to him on one of those lucky occasions. “I like you, Thorin, but I swear if you make me come down here one more time, only to sigh after a dwarf you've barely ever spoken to, I'll have to hit you.”

“I don't know what you...”

“I'll use my brother's hammer too,” Balin threatened. “Trust me, it should knock come sense into you. So stop bothering me and talk to the boy. He's got a nice enough voice, I'll admit it, but it's been more than a year and we're all tired of seeing you pinning for him from a distance.”

“And when you say we, you mean...”

“Gandalf and me of course,” Balin said as if it were the most obvious thing in the world. Which it was. Balin and that strange old wizard that sometimes came to Erebor had, over the year, become friends. It was well known that they took a great interest in the romances of others, to the point of betting on such things.

“I do not approve of you and that old fool messing with my life,” Thorin protested. “Things are difficult enough as it is, and...”

“And you're too much of a coward to go to that boy and tell him that you messed up with that stupid idea of singing lesson, that you were only trying to find an excuse to see him, and that you want to spend the rest of your life with him. So, as I was saying, go talk to him, or your skull will meet my brother's mace.”

Thorin throw him a dark look.

“I'm your future king, you know. You're not supposed to talk to me like that. But fine, I'm going. Because I want to, and I have decided it is time I talk to him, not because of you.”

Balin sniggered at that, but the prince chose to ignore it. Refusing to gratify his old friend with even a look, he left and went toward his young miner's voice.

Each new step made him more nervous. This was, clearly, a terrible idea. The boy had a wonderful voice, but so far he had shown a terrible personality. Balin was right, he barely knew him. He was a miner, they had nothing in common. It was the worst idea of his entire life. It was a mistake. It was...

Thorin stopped. Just a few feet away, Bofur was sitting on the floor, singing some sort of nursery rhyme while carving a bit of wood with a knife. That caught Thorin's attention almost as much as his voice did. Few dwarves worked with wood. It was not their element. Wood was for elves and humans, and other such weak creature that didn't have the strength to work intensively with minerals. Carving wood was admitting your own weakness, it was claiming you were less than a dwarf, that you were choosing the easy way out, that you did not have the patience and talent to work with gold or stone.

Or so Thorin had always thought, until then.

What Bofur seemed to be carving was a small, delicate little figure of a dwarf, as detailed as any made of stone that the prince had ever seen. It looked like it had requested quite as much skill and patience as it would have if made of metal.

“That looks rather nice, what you're doing,”Thorin said, walking closer to the boy. “I didn't know you could make anything like that out of wood.”

The effect on the boy was entirely unexpected. Bofur jumped when he heard the prince's voice and when he recognized him, the young miner quickly stood up and threw both the knife and the wooden toy away from him.

“Don't tell me parents! They'll get so mad if ye tell them, please! I'll even go back to the lessons if ye want, just don't tell!”

“Why would I...”

“Swear ye won't tell!” Bofur insisted, looking mad from panic. “I'll do anything ye want!”

“Calm down, lad,” Thorin said, putting a hand on his shoulder. “I won't tell anyone anything, though I don't see why you mind so much. You're a dwarf of many talent, master Bofur.”

The young miner threw him a suspicious look.

“That ain't what ye're s'pposed to tell me. Ye're s'pposed to tell me I'm the shame of the entire race, 'cause no proper dwarf would ever work with... that.” He gestured toward the little wood dwarf, disgust and regret clear on his face. “I know I shouldn't, but that's what I like.”

“You can't help what you like, lad. And if what you like allows you to create something this nice, then who cares about being a proper dwarf. You've got talent.”

Bofur gave him another wary look.

“Ye're not s'pposed to say that either. In fact, ye're not s'pposed to talk to me at all. Me mom said the singing lessons were 'cause ye had intentions. Of the wrong sorts, if you know what I mean. 'Cause otherwise, a prince like ye wouldn't even look twice at someone like me. Ye know. A commoner.”

“My intentions are perfectly honourable!” Thorin protested. “And I don't see why you being a commoner is any problem at all. Balin's grand-parents were miners and stone cutters, and yet he is my friend.”

“Ye're telling me ye really have intentions?”

Bofur started laughing, as if it were the most ridiculous idea he had ever heard, and Thorin felt rather embarrassed. That was not at all how people were meant to react when they learned a royal prince wanted them as a companion. They were supposed to be flustered, blushing a lot, and then to say they didn't deserve such honour. You didn't laugh when a son of Durin made you a proposition. It was not done.

But Bofur had a rather nice laugh, and being merry made his eyes sparkle in a most enticing way, Thorin had to admit it.

“Well, I imagine I should be glad that my interest bring you joy of some sort,” the prince said, trying to sound offended. “This is no joke, though. I truly like you, and I wish to court you, if you will allow it, so that I might know you better, and allow you to know me.”

“Wait, ye mean like an official, proper courtship?” Bofur asked, his laughter suddenly gone. “From ye? To me? But why...”

“You've got a lovely voice,” Thorin admitted. “It might sound like a silly thing to base a courtship on, but your voice has captivated me since the first moment, and everything I have discovered about you since that day only made you more interesting.”

“I don't even know ye. I mean, until ten minutes ago, ye were just that boring prince who didn't like me singing. I don't know a thing 'bout ye.”

“I believe that is the whole point of courtship. I get to know you, and you get to know me. What do you have to lose?”

The young dwarf seemed to think about it for a moment. He did not seem convinced by the whole idea, and for a moment Thorin feared he would reject him. But just as he was losing hope,Bofur smiled at him.

“Well, I s'ppose it's worth a try, yeah? But ye're doing this the proper way, I'm warning ye. Me mum raised me well, ye know.”

 


 

The first step of a courtship properly done was to meet Bofur's friends, and let the lad meet Thorin's.

As it happened, Bofur's friends mostly meant his cousin Bifur (a strange, brooding lad who didn't talk a lot, but whose dark glares made it clear that Thorin would have great problems if he ever hurt Bofur) and his younger brother Bombur (a large boy with a large smile and a fondness for large meals). They were both rather nice, and though they were clearly surprised that the royal heir had taken a sudden interest in Bofur, they made not comments on it.

“Don't you have friends outside of your family?” Thorin asked afterward. “I remember the first time we met, you were with others...”

“Co-workers aren't friends. They're all right, but not to the point that I'd want them to meet you.”

Thorin remembered how the dwarves around Bofur that first time had all immediately assumed that his song must have bothered him. He did not ask again to meet them.

Things went quite as well when Bofur came to meet Balin, Dwalin and Frerin, though the young miner was clearly intimidated to be in the presence of such important people. It was one thing to know you were courted by a prince, and quite another to meet his advisor, his self-proclaimed bodyguard, and another prince. Thorin knew that Balin did not entirely approve the match, and that had worried him for a while, but the older dwarf remained as civil as ever. Dwalin was not quite as quiet, but that was to be expected, and he assaulted Bofur with all sorts of questions on his trade, offering to train him with weapons. From him, that was a true offer of friendship, and Thorin was relieved when Bofur agreed.

Things went even better with Frerin. The young prince had a certain fondness for the elves, with whom he got along more than fine, and when he learned that Bofur knew some of their songs, he was delighted.

“I'll have to take you with me to the Greenwoods then! And Thorin said you had a most wonderful voice too, we could show them dwarves can sing just as well as they do!”

“Thanks, highness,” Bofur had shyly mumbled. “ 'm not that good though, really. I just do it as a little bit of fun.”

“So do the elves, so don't you worry about that. They're rather proud of themselves, but I think we're just as good with music as they are. And it'd be fun! I've been trying to convince Thorin for years to come with me at one of king Thranduil's parties and sing a song or two, but he just won't do it. Says it's not proper for the heir.”

“Well, it's not!” Thorin grumbled.

“Ye can sing?” Bofur asked, clearly surprised. “Ye never said”

“I'm not much good at it, really.”

“Don't you listen to him!” Frerin exclaimed. “He's got a voice that could make stones fall in love. If he weren't a prince, my brother would be a great bard. He plays the violin too, did he tell you that? Really, Thorin, how can you hope to seduce the lad if you don't tell him a single good thing about you? Don't tell me I'll have to be the one to make you look your best! You're just as bad as Dis.”

After that, Thorin complained a lot about his brother's lack of respect for his elders, and how he would never have dared talking like that to his older brother if he had had one, but his smile betrayed his good mood. Frerin and Bofur seemed to get along rather well, maybe because there wasn't much difference in their age, and that was good news for the future.

“You'll have to meet Dis next time,” the prince said as he walked Bofur back to his home. “She's got a terrible temper of course, but my nephews are the sweetest little dwarflings that ever were.”

“I'd love that,” Bofur assured him with a bright smile. “But you'll have to come and see Bombur again, he said you tell the best of stories, and I think he quite likes you.”

Thorin smiled back. Things were going well.

 


 

The next step was to announce their courtship to their families. That part made them both terribly nervous, and it took them nearly a year to get there. Thorin found that time was not wasted though, as it gave him many occasions to spend time with his young miner and to know him better. They were rarely alone of course, as that would have been improper at such a stage of courtship, but Bifur was the best chaperon they could have asked for, and he seemed quite happy to play that part for them.

Thorin thought it a proof of Bofur's trust that, after a few weeks, the younger dwarf started sculpting wood when they were together. He did it involuntarily the first few times, taking a piece of wood from his pocket as the prince was talking, then quickly hiding it as soon as he realized what he had been doing. But Thorin encouraged it, asking him what he was working on at the moment, requesting to see some of his creations. At first Bofur seemed suspicious, and no doubt he must have believed that to be a ploy to seduce him, but the prince's interest was genuine, and after a while the younger dwarf stopped worrying.

“I could find you a master, you know,” Thorin suggested one day, as they were alone with Bifur. “If working wood is what you desire, there are many men in Dale that could teach you. You're good at this, they'd all want you as an apprentice.”

“Not a very dwarvish trade, though.”

“We are mordern dwarves, we can do as we please. And if wood is not our usual tool, you still use it for dwarvish subjects, isn't that what matters?”

Bofur fidgeted the little figure he'd been carving, clearly uncomfortable. “Bad enough that you're courting a miner,” he mumbled. “But a woodcarver, for the heir to the throne? No one would ever allow it. And my family would never agree...”

“I would agree,” Bifur said behind them, making them both jump. “The princeling is right, you're good at that. Let him find you a master. Even if things don't work out for the two of you, you'll know a craft you enjoy.”

Thorin threw him a dark look, offended that Bofur's cousin thought his affections so shallow that the disapprobation of their families could change his mind. He wanted Bofur, and he wanted him happy, and if that meant taking the risk of pissing off a few traditionalists, then he'd do it gladly, and he said as much.

Bofur stuttered and mumbled and insisted that it was not necessary, but he was still smiling, and in the end, he agreed to let Thorin look for a master for him.

 


 

Meeting Bofur's parents had been nice enough, and they had been very welcoming, though worried that the boys hadn't first announced their intentions to Thrain. But if the king allowed the courtship to continue, they would be glad to accept it too.

 


 

Thrain was not quite as happy. He had rather hoped his eldest son would settle with a woman, and give more heirs to their line. He had also expected Thorin to choose someone of noble blood, though of course there was nothing wrong as such with marrying a commoner. The news that his potential son in law was now training to sculpt wood was just the last drop.

“I can't give you my blessing, and I can't agree to that courtship,” he declared severely when they declared themselves to him. “I'm surprised you even thought it worth asking, Thorin. That lad is not for you.”

“I believe you are mistaken about my reason for talking to you, father,” Thorin coldly answered. “I did not come for your blessing, but merely to state my intentions. It saddens me that you do not approve, yes, but that will not stop me from having the dwarf I want. There is only one who can convince me to stop my attentions to Bofur, and that's Bofur himself.”

Thrain threw a dark look to the poor miner, who blushed and lowered his head. But when Thorin took his hand, Bofur looked at him and smile shyly, and that was all the encouragement the prince needed.

“I love him and I want him,” Thorin repeated. “Your agreement is not necessary for that.”

“It is if you want to marry him,” Thrain reminded him. “Or are you willing to let that boy be called your whore for the rest of his life?”

That made Thorin hesitate. He had not thought of that, of course. He had rather hoped that, at that point, his father would have been overwhelmed but the truthfulness of his feelings, and that he'd say he agreed to anything they wanted. Clearly, things weren't going according to plan.

But then, he felt Bofur's hand move in his, and their finger tangled as the younger dwarf proudly raised his head.

“I am willing to be called anything at all,” Bofur claimed, “if that means I can stay with him.”

Angry by that unexpected turn of events, Thrain had sent them away, claiming that he had made his choice, and would not change it. Thorin decided he didn't care, and when they were alone again, the only thing that stopped him from kissing Bofur was his promise that he would go about this courtship the right way.