Chapter Text
It had not been a very good day, as far as Bofur was concerned.
First of all, come morning his husband was still unconscious, and had been since the attack the day before.
Secondly, he had been forced to leave said husband's side, because some damn wizard had bullied him into getting some sleep. As if sleep was any good when Thorin was maybe dying. And he was half sure than Gandalf had spiked his tea, too, because he should never have fallen asleep that easily, not with how nervous he had been.
Thirdly, when he had finally woken up, in Frerin's room, only Dis had been there, and she had refused to give him any news of her oldest brother until he had eaten everything she was giving him.
Fourthly, just as he had learned that Thorin was awake and had a slight fever, Bilbo had come in, eyes red and face pale, to announce that he was leaving Erebor.
“But ye can't leave!” Bofur had protested, feeling heart-broken at that idea. “Ye're a hero! We're gonna have a great party for ye, soon as Thorin's well again!”
The hobbit tensed at the mention of the prince.
“I am sincerely sorry, Bofur,” he said coldly. “But there's no other way about it. I... I don't belong here. You've always lived here, you can't imagine what it feels like to not belong. But I... I've got a home, and I miss it, and I have to go back now.”
“I know ye miss yer garden, but, but if ye want I'm sure we can have something arranged. Thorin can certainly...”
The hobbit shook his head, and took Bofur's hands in his own small ones.
“I love you,” Bilbo said with a serious face. “That's why I can't stay.”
The dwarf stared at him in shock, barely registering Dis slipping out of the room to leave them alone.
“Ye can't love me,” Bofur protested after a moment. “Ye're my friend!”
Bilbo laughed sadly. “Ridiculous, I know. And you're married too. It was hopeless from the start. I thought I could live with it. And I did. Until... until recently. I was going to leave anyway, sooner or later, but then yesterday happened and I realized that... Well. Let's just say I've got twice the reasons to leave now. I've talked to Gandalf, and he has agreed to take me back. We're going at the end of the week.”
“But...”
“There's nothing to discuss, really. It's. It's decided. I've decided. I'm leaving. But I thank you for your kindness, and for how welcome you made me feel. I hope that Thorin will soon feel better, and that the two of you will be happy. You deserve all the happiness in the world, after all that has happened to you both.”
Bofur stared at the hobbit, trying to process what he'd just learned. None of it made sense.
“I'll just go then,” Bilbo said quickly. “I'm really sorry for... for bothering you with this. Good bye, Bofur.”
He left then, leaving the dwarf alone.
He hadn't felt that confused since the day Thorin had asked to court him, so many years before.
It just didn't make sense. Bilbo had always been such a great and funny companion, he had been someone with whom Bofur could feel safe, with whom he didn't always have to pretend that all was well. Bilbo had been a friend, and Bofur hadn't had many in his life.
To discover that this friend had lied to him all along hurt more than he would have expected.
He needed to see Thorin, he decided.
He needed comfort, and some good news.
“I kissed the halfling.”
That, Bofur thought, was not what people were supposed to tell you when you asked them how they were. He had expected something along the lines of “like shit” or “it's just a flesh wound”. Not... this.
“I'm so sorry,” Thorin quickly added. “It won't happen again.”
“And why did it happened this time, tell me?”
“I love you,” Thorin said, ignoring the question. “I love you, tell me you know that?”
Bofur closed his eyes and pinched the bridge on his nose. He hated that day, and at the moment he hated Bilbo, and Thorin too.
“Jewel...”
“Don't call me that. Not today. Why did ye do that? Do ye... d'ye like him?”
Thorin looked away.
“It won't happen again,” he repeated. “He told me he was leaving. He... I had a fever, I panicked, I... Bofur, I am so sorry.”
“So ye do like him, then. Does he know? Did ye tell him?”
Twice the reasons to leave, Bilbo had said.
“I didn't say anything, I just asked him not to leave and I... kissed him,” the prince said miserably. “He's not interested I'd say, thank the Maker. He didn't really react, he just... did that weird thing with his lips, and then he ran away.”
“What weird thing?”
“He... put his lips on mine,” Thorin explained, frowning and looking as if he were still trying to make sense of that. “It was very strange, really.”
Bofur took a deep breath.
“That, love, was a kiss.”
“Not it wasn't.”
“Yes, it was,” Bofur insisted. “That's how men kiss, at least, and I imagine hobbits do it too. That, or it's their way to say 'bugger off ye lecherous old thing, ye're married already and yer husband will kill us both if he discovers what ye did', but that doesn't seem too likely.”
Thorin stared at him.
“Oh.”
“'Oh' indeed. Look, I... ye seem fine, yer wound isn't infected. I'm glad yer not dying. Now I think I'll leave ye alone, and I'll go be furious at ye and that damn hobbit, somewhere where I don't have to see either of ye two idiots.”
Thorin nodded saddly.
“I... understand. I just... I love you, I really do. You have to know that, I love you. The halfling is just... a passing fancy. I love you. I want you. And no one else.”
“Good for ye,” Bofur replied dryly. “Can't say I love ye too much today.”
Bofur warned Dis that he was not to be disturbed, not by anyone.
He then picked a beautiful piece of ebony that he'd been keeping for a special occasion, and started carving. He didn't have anything special in mind, but the idea of ruining and destroying something precious seemed very appealing at the moment, and that piece of ebony was just perfect for it.
The first cut of his knife through the wood was far too violent, as were the following ones. But after a few moments of stabbing, he calmed down and started being more careful and delicate in his cuts.
Bilbo loved him. Bilbo had kissed Thorin. Thorin loved Bofur. Thorin had kissed Bilbo.
Which meant the two idiots claimed to love him, but were attracted to each other. Attracted at least. It might be more. He hoped it wasn't more.
But even if it were more, they still loved him. Thorin wasn't the sort to lie about such things. It would have required diplomacy. And Bilbo had no reason to lie. If he had just wanted an excuse to leave, he could easily have fond a better one.
Bofur looked at his butchered piece of wood. Something nice could yet come out of it. He took his saw and a ruler, and carefully cut it into three even pieces.
He loved Thorin, that much he was sure of. He had for years, and it would take more than a moment of feverish stupidity from his husband to change that. Thorin was who he belonged with, and the prince could have fucked all of Erebor that Bofur would still have loved him.
He was less sure about Bilbo. He liked the hobbit very much, and the smaller creature was a dear friend to him, as close to his heart as Frerin, Dis or even Bifur were, despite how little time they had known each other. He wouldn't have said he loved Bilbo, but there was certainly a great affection on his part, and he had hoped that the hobbit would stay a long while in Erebor, maybe even for the rest of his life. He didn't want Bilbo to leave. And if what it took to keep him was to share a little of himself and a little of Thorin with the hobbit... well, worse things had happened. Bilbo was no dwarf, but his strange, soft little body had something exotic about it that was rather interesting to say the least.
Night was falling when Bofur decided he'd worked enough for that day. His three pieces of wood were now three rough figurines. It would take him a day or two to make anything polished out of them. That was good. He could do with another day of heavy thinking.
The following evening, Bofur had three carefully carved figurines before him, two of a dwarf and one of a hobbit, and he knew what to do.
The first thing to do was to keep Bilbo around until Thorin was in a better state. The prince was not in mortal danger, but his wound did weaken him, and that might have been impeding his judgement. And Bofur needed him to be fully capable of making a decision, so as to leave no room for regrets or remorse.
That was easily done. Gandalf owed him for having drugged his tea, and at the hint that it could be very beneficial for the hobbit to stay, the wizard was sold.
“He'll be stubborn,” Gandalf warned him. “Hobbit love propriety even more than dwarves do.”
“I've lived with Thorin most of my life now. I'm used to stubbornness, and I know how to deal with it.”
“If you need any help...”
“I'm sure we can manage, thanks. Don't want any strange herbs finding their way into anyone's food, is that clear?”
Gandalf had the decency to look just a little ashamed.
Thorin had to stay in bed for a month, and all that time, Gandalf kept finding new excuses to delay their departure. First there was Thrain who insisted on throwing a feast for the hero of the day, and the wizard had insisted it was terribly impolite to refuse a king's invitation. Then there was an engagement party for Frerin and Tauriel, and what sort of friend would Bilbo be if he missed that? And then Kili was put to contribution as he almost cried when he learned that the hobbit would be present at his birthday, looking every bit like a hurt puppy, if Dis was to be trusted. She probably was. She was the one who had taught her son how to do just that, after all.
And Bofur wasn't sure if Dis knew exactly why he was trying to keep Bilbo in Erebor, but she was helping, her and the rest of the family. The hobbit had only been there for a couple of months, but they all saw him as one of them.
The only one who did not actively try to keep Bilbo in the mountain was Thorin, and that for two reason. First, the prince had not been visited by the hobbit since the day they had kissed. Secondly, now one had told him that Bilbo had not, in fact, left Erebor yet. Bofur had not asked anyone to keep that secret, but he was glad they did. Thorin felt bad enough about the whole thing as it was.
“I am despicable,” he told Bofur, a few days before the healer allowed him to move again. “I don't deserve your trust, not your forgiveness.”
“Ye're an overly dramatic idiot is what ye are,” his husband replied. “I wouldn't be here if I were still angry, would I?”
“I don't deserve you.”
“True, but I'll still lower myself to yer level. See how good I am.”
Thorin glared.
“I'm trying to be sincere and repentant, why do you have to mock me so?”
“Because ye're being ridiculous and as dramatic as an elf, love. Now eat that soup or I'm telling Oin.”
The prince had groaned.
“The soup tastes terrible, Oin hates me, and I think you enjoy seeing me in pain, because you've been in a very good mood lately.”
“I just like taking care of ye, love. Not often I get an excuse to keep ye in bed all day long, eh?”
“It's not like I'm in any state to take advantage of it, though. You keep insisting I need to rest.”
Bofur grinned.
“I'll make it up to ye when ye're in shape, love. I swear I will.”
“You had better.”
Once Oin officially allowed Thorin to leave his bed, Bofur knew he had to act quickly.
Getting his husband somewhere quiet was easy to do. After a month of nothing more than kisses, Thorin was practically begging to be taken somewhere quiet where no one would disturb them, and when Bofur told him to meet him at a certain time in one of the unused rooms of the palace, he readily agreed.
Bilbo was more of a problem. Bofur hadn't talked to him since the day of his declaration, because no matter how much he missed him, he had known that the hobbit would be embarrassed to see him, probably enough to run away from the mountain without Gandalf if he had to. Which meant that getting him to come into a room with Thorin and Bofur would require cunning and a carefully crafted plan.
Or just Ori telling him he needed some help with old books that Kili had found in a certain unused room.
Bofur would have to thank the small librarian some day.
Maybe he'd tell him that Kili seemed to look at his bottom far more than was necessary.
But first, he had a hobbit to take care of.
Bofur hoped Ori would soon bring Bilbo, because he wasn't sure how long he'd managed to retain his clothes. To say that Thorin was eager would have been the understatement of the year, especially after an entire month. And it wasn't as though Bofur himself hadn't missed their intimacy either, but if they were to have a conversation with the hobbit, it would be better to have it while still dressed.
At least at first.
He had great hopes that, if all went well, clothes would be discarded sooner or later.
So he tried to stall for time, showing his husband that beautiful book-case that he'd found, telling him about how delicate the carving in the woods were and wondering if it came from Dale or the Greenwoods or further away, because he'd never seen any work quite like that one. All the while, Thorin tried to slip hands beneath his tunic, and Bofur was feeling his self control slip away.
The knock on the door came just in time to remind him that he had a plan. Thorin threw him a questioning look, then paled as the door opened, and Ori and Bilbo came in. The hobbit had a small smile on at first, but when he saw the two dwarves there the smile disappeared as he went just as white as Thorin.
"I didn't know you'd be here!" he exclaimed, looking horrified. "I'm sorry, we didn't mean to intrude, we'll... we'll come back later!"
"Would be a shame," Bofur protested, "since ye're the reason we're here."
Both Bilbo and Thorin stared at him.
"I didn't know that," the prince said slowly. "You said..."
"I know what I said, love, and I know what I'm doing. And what I'm doing is what's right. Namely, to talk to ye and our Mr Baggins to settle a few things. If Mr Baggins doesn't mind, of course?"
"I'm not sure it's a good idea, really," the hobbit replied. "I can't imagine how anything good will come out of it, and I think we had settled it already, to be honest. What could there be left to say?"
"A great deal, really," Bofur assured him. "There's a few things ye don't know, lad, and I'm sure ye'll be glad to know it. For example, ye probably don't know that Thorin kissed ye first."
Bilbo gasped at that, and Bofur felt his husband tense at his side, the memory of this small betrayal still too recent and raw, but there was no other way about it if they wanted to keep the hobbit around.
And indeed, Bilbo's curiosity was piqued. Bofur made a small motion of the head and Ori left, silently closing the door behind him.
"What do you mean he kissed me?" Bilbo asked carefully, and Bofur was relieved that he didn't try to deny what had happened. "I happened to have been there, you know, so I'm fairly sure I'd have noticed."
"Ye'd have noticed about as much as Thorin did when ye kissed him. Dwarves don't do that the same way ye hobbits do it. We do it the logical way." To prove his point, he leant toward Thorin and kissed him. His husband tensed even more at that, but he allowed the contact anyway. Bofur turned again toward Bilbo. "See what I mean?"
The hobbit frowned. He did not understand at first, until he suddenly did, and a warm blush spread on his face.
"Oh. Oh! You mean...! That was...! Oh!"
He stared at Thorin in disbelief, but the prince was looking down at his boots, refusing to acknowledge the other two. Bofur had mercy then and took his husband's hand.
"Cultural differences, what a mess," he jokes weakly. "But at least now we now everyone wanna get in everyone's pants, so there's one less confusion. And since that bit's been cleared up, I'd say we tried to do something 'bout it, eh?"
"What do you mean by that?" Thorin asked, finally looking up. "As far as I can tell, not everyone here is having unwelcome feelings, and certainly not for everyone else."
"That's 'cause I hadn't told ye that our Mr Baggins has a soft spot for me too," Bofur replied. "As for me I don't dislike him at all, and I'm sure I could learn to more than like him easily enough, if I'm given a chance. Which is why I brought us all here today. To give ourselves a chance, if ye catch my meaning."
"You're not actually suggesting that we..."
"That would be most improper!" Bilbo squeaked. "It's... Bad enough that we... we are all males, and I know that things are different for dwarves, but in the Shire that would be unheard of! And... and you two are married, it's... married people don't do that! And I'm... and there's the problem that we're not even of the same specie, and..."
"I won't mind if ye don't."
"The ho... Mr Baggins is right, though," Thorin protested. "People are tolerating our situation now, but what you're suggesting... And you don't have to do that, jewel, I've told you already that I... it's a passing fancy, nothing more."
"That's right," Bilbo insisted. "You've said yourself I was only your friend, and I'd hate to... have you forced to tolerate such a thing for my sake. Our sake, I suppose."
That wasn't going quite as well as Bofur had expected. Though to be honest, with people as overdramatic as these two, expecting that he'd only have to say “let's all be lovers” to have them answer “yes great what an excellent idea, let's start right now”.
And to think they were the ones who had kissed each other, but he was the one having to convince them now.
"Ye're both idiots," Bofur informed them with a kind smile, "and if ye keep at this, I'll start feeling insulted, thank ye. If ye two really think I'm the sort of dwarf who'll just tolerate a lover they don't want to please my husband or my friend, ye're very mistaken. I'm suggesting this 'cause I happen to want it. Ye're right that I've never seen ye as more than a friend before, Bilbo, but as I've said I like ye, and I'm more than willing to try this."
"But..."
"What the worse that can happen, really? Ye said ye were going to leave. Well, I'm saying ye stay a little, see if that works, and if he doesn't, ye go home and ye know that at least ye tried. Better have remorse than regrets, as they say. And ye, Thorin, find a better excuse than 'people will talk', 'cause as far as anyone's concerned, Bilbo's a very good friend of mine, and everyone knows it. We three have been spending lots of time together already, no one has said anything yet, have they?"
Thorin frowned, but nodded.
"You really... want this, then?"
"Don't ye?"
The prince glanced at Bilbo, who managed to blush even redder.
"I... wouldn't be adverse to the idea," Thorin admitted. "But I think Mr Baggins is of a different mind. He rather look like a terrified rabbit, ready to run if either of us so much as approaches him."
Bilbo did look rather uncomfortable, there was no denying it. But as soon as Thorin compared him to a rabbit, the hobbit straightened up, glaring at the prince.
"You certainly know how to make yourself appreciated, prince Thorin," he said with a smile that was far too polite to be sincere. "If I had not seen how kind and caring to be toward other people, I think I would really not like you at all, considering your behaviour toward me. Implying I'm a coward, really, after what I've done for you! You're lucky to be that pretty, really."
"Pretty?"
Bilbo nodded.
"I certainly wouldn't have kissed you otherwise. You do look nice, if nothing else."
"But couldn't you have chosen a better word than pretty?" Thorin insisted, looking half offended. The other half of him looked rather pleased, Bofur noticed. His husband had always been a little vain. "There are many available, even in Westron. 'Handsome' would have done very well, or I could have tolerated 'beautiful' maybe, but pretty?"
Bilbo gave him a long look, as if to consider these options, then shook his head.
"No, I think pretty really fits better. You do have long hair. And very fine eyes.”
He dared a shy smile, to which Thorin answered with an amused smirk.
“I still don't think it's a good idea,” Bilbo said, still smiling. “Not to mention how it could work when we... well. You know.”
Bofur laughed. “If ye're willing to try this, I promise we'll find a way to make it work. Thorin can be very inventive when he wants, right, love?”
“I'm sure we'll manage, yes,” Thorin replied, his tone leaving no doubts as to the fact that he probably had thought about such things in the past.
Bilbo sighed tragically, smiling even more than before.
“Oh, well. Let's try this then. Two dwarves against one poor hobbit, what can I do, really?”
“Well,” Bilbo said a long while later.
“Same,” Bofur approved.
“Indeed,” Thorin added.
“Tales of the endurance of dwarves. Not an exaggeration, then. Not that I'm complaining. Good surprise.”
“Hobbits have nothing to be ashamed of,” Thorin assured him. “Didn't expect that.”
“Anyone up for another round?” Bofur asked. “All in favour, say aye.”
“Aye.”
“Aye!”
“Aye too. Three against zero. Great.”
