Actions

Work Header

One of the Possible Questions

Chapter Text

“Do you have a minute, Bilbo?” Ori leaned out hesitantly from behind a bookshelf.

“Of course. Pull up a nice soft rock.” Bilbo was in a huff because the dwarves who renovated the library had damaged his scant few cushions, and he hadn’t had a chance yet to order replacements. What the library had gained in safety, it had lost in comfort.

Ori, who’d been listening to Bilbo grumble about it for the past week, offered a faint smile as he sat down. “At least they didn’t hurt any of the books.”

“Yes, well, I believe Thorin threatened them with grievous injury if any harm befell my reading material. I should have thought of asking him to include the upholstery in his injunction.” Bilbo peered at Ori. “What’s the matter, lad?”

“The Ironfoots left.”

“Ironfeet,” murmured Bilbo, thinking fondly of his Proudfoot relations and their preferred plural. Ori gave him a quizzical look, and he waved his hand. “Sorry, go on. They left, yes, I was there. And?”

“And it was supposed to be over! You remember, right? Fíli said we could break it off however I wanted. But instead he offered me a necklace. A courting gift.”

“Oh, I see.” Bilbo managed to keep the exasperation out of his voice. When Fíli had come to him for advice, he’d counseled the young prince to take things slowly, to introduce the idea of converting their false courtship to a real one over the course of several days. But apparently Fíli hadn’t been able to wait a second.

“Why aren’t you surprised?” demanded Ori.

“Er, well, you and Fíli have been . . .” What was it Gandalf had said to Bilbo about Thorin? Oh, yes. “Your mutual interest in courting could only have been more obvious if one of you had begun gathering sticks to build a nest.”

Ori turned red and started to stammer. Bilbo, who had been in a similar position not long ago, took pity on him and moved the conversation forward. “Did you accept Fíli’s gift?”

“No! I don’t want—I can’t.” He looked at Bilbo pleadingly. “Why did you do it? You could have gone home to your own library, your own armchair, your quiet life in the Shire. How could you stay here and become the king’s consort instead?”

“You already asked me that, some months back,” said Bilbo gently. “My answer has not changed. Is there perhaps a different question that you truly wish to ask?”

Ori stared down at his hands. When he spoke, his voice was little more than a whisper. “How can you stay with Thorin after what he did to you?”

Ah, there it is, thought Bilbo. He’d suspected this might come up, and had prepared an explanation. “Thorin behaved badly because he was ill. It didn’t change my love for him, no more than the symptoms of any other illness would.”

Ori frowned. “But it wasn’t like other illnesses. He hurt you. He wanted to kill you! That’s not like sneezing on you, or even throwing up on you.”

Bilbo let out a little laugh. It was a fair point. Ori deserved more than the pat answer one might offer a child. “You’re right. He frightened me terribly, and he frightened himself. And . . . he was so wretchedly sorry afterward. For a little while he tried to punish himself by avoiding me, but that hurt me, too, and made me angry.”

Bilbo rubbed his thumb thoughtfully over the ring on his finger, Thorin's ring. The carved and hammered iron felt so much more real than the golden ring in his pocket. “I stayed, Ori, because I love him so much that I could not bear to be parted from him. Even when I have nightmares about what he did, he’s the one I look to for comfort when I wake.”

Realizing his gaze had drifted into the distance, Bilbo drew it back to Ori. “But it’s not Thorin who offered you a courting gift.”

Ori was hunched into his cowl like a turtle peering from its shell. “Fíli is of the same bloodline. He could have the same sickness.”

“He’s never shown any sign of it,” said Bilbo. “Has he?”

Ori shook his head quickly. “No, but—”

“Has he ever threatened to harm you, in any way?”

“No, never!”

“Well, then.” Bilbo folded his hands over his belly as he considered his next words. “Think of it this way. Fíli doesn’t care about your parentage, does he?”

A soft smile stole onto Ori’s lips. “No, he doesn’t.”

“Can you offer him the same courtesy?”

That startled Ori. His eyes widened and his mouth opened, then shut without speaking.

Bilbo watched him think it through. “You saw Thorin treat me very badly," he added. "It’s understandable to be afraid of going through something similar. But just as Thorin is not his grandfather . . .”

“Fíli is not his uncle,” finished Ori.

“Exactly. Also, you are not me.” Bilbo winked. “If Fíli did go mad and attack you, I have no doubt you’d give him a taste of iron up his jacksy.”

That made Ori laugh, as Bilbo had hoped. “Thank you, Bilbo. Thank you so much." He gave a decisive nod and stood up. "Gaining you as an uncle is going to be one of the best parts of marrying Fíli, I think.”

Bilbo gasped in mock astonishment. “Marriage! Aren’t you getting ahead of yourself? Last I heard, you refused Fíli’s courting gift.”

Ori winced. “I’d better go find him.”

“I believe he’s working out his feelings in the newly opened forges. If you go down there, try not to get hit by a big swinging hammer.”

“Don’t worry, I know how to handle Fíli’s big swinging ha—”

“Out.” Bilbo scowled, and Ori scampered.

Suppressing a smile, Bilbo shook his head. Really, Ori picking up rude jokes from Fíli was no worse that Bilbo picking up fierce glares from Thorin. In fact, the two habits might be equally useful in dwarven diplomacy.