Chapter Text
They eat at the table. Carl can’t remember the last time he sat at it with anyone other than Cassy. Even when Mike comes they always eat at the counter. After Beth died it had seemed like a deliberate avoidance, her empty seat too hard for either of them to look at, but the last few years he supposes it’s just become habit. Sitting down to eat at the dinner table always feels kind of formal, like there’s some kind of occasion, and now looking down at his plate and silverware he supposes maybe there is. A really strange kind of occasion. He has visitors - houseguests - for the first time in almost a decade, and it seems that at least one of them has something to celebrate.
“To our miraculous survival,” Hannibal says, and raises his glass in a toast.
Regarding him from under raised eyebrows, Will carefully spears a piece of the lake trout with his fork.
“Don’t you know it’s bad luck to make a toast with water?”
The older man sets the glass back down on the tablecloth, and picks up his cutlery.
“I’ve never considered you a superstitious man, Will.”
“I’m not. But I’m willing to bet our host here is.”
His eyes move to Carl’s face questioningly, and the old man gives him a wan smile.
“It’s ok. Last time I took a foot off dry land was eight years ago. Don’t need to worry too much about drowning these days. Except maybe in my bathtub.”
Hannibal’s lips twitch at that and for a moment he almost looks human,
“You were a naval man Mr. Orr?”
Carl nods, chews carefully before he attempts a reply.
“Warrant Officer First Class.”
“Navigator?”
Will’s eyes on him are curious and warm and after a moment Carl hums a grudging acknowledgement, gives his head a little amused shake.
“Mind telling me how it is you manage to pick up on these things?”
He taps the tines of his fork on his plate a little nervous now at asking, and watches as the younger man’s expression clouds with something like discomfort before looking away. Leaning forward in his seat, it’s Hannibal who meets his eye instead, as if he’s moved in to shield him.
“Will has quite the gift for reading people. One of his many singular talents.”
His head bowed to his place, Will gives a dry laugh and delicately spears another piece of fish.
“Sure. Many. I also make a mean catfish quesadilla.”
After dinner the other two men clear the dishes away, and after a few minutes Carl realises from the soft snatches of conversation and the sounds of crockery that they’re washing and drying them together in the kitchen. Looking down at Cassy he shakes his head again in bemusement. The novel he’s been reading for the last week or so lies open on the arm of his easy chair, and after a second to consider the continuing oddness of the situation he decides that there’s no reason not to follow his usual routine.
Sinking down into the chair, he opens the book to the last place and attempts to concentrate on the story, but finds he can’t help craning his head to catch what’s being said next door. It’s deliberately soft he knows, but every now and then a discernible phrase manages to leak out.
Will’s voice, firm and yet also deeply weary:
“You know him Hannibal. He won’t stop. He’ll need to see bodies.”
And then a lower murmur followed by a sharply terse reply from Hannibal:
“You really think you have any right to ask me that?”
For a while after that there’s silence, and unless he’s very much mistaken, a low-level tension that bleeds out of the room into the rest of the house. On the rug at his feet, Cassy’s ears are pressed flat to the side of her head, and her eyes look at at him beseechingly.
“This dog needs walking,” Carl says loudly, and after a second or two Will appears at the doorway wiping his hands on a towel.
“We could take her down to the beach?”
He steps aside as Hannibal limps past him heading back towards the guest room. His movements are purposeful enough, but the lines of his face looks strained and tired. Watching him go, Will looks equally exhausted, but then as the other man closes the door behind him he seems to gather himself.
“He should probably rest his leg for a while anyway. Maybe when we get back we can work on his cast.”
It’s just starting to get dark out, or ‘dimpsy’ as his Scottish mother used to say. Although the moon isn’t up yet a few stars are already out, and opening the gate to the cliff path Carl watches as Cassy scurries down it ahead of them, her sturdy black shape almost disappearing against the rockface. Closing it, Will steps after him, his shape squarer and sturdier in the padded jacket he’s borrowed. They walk down to the sand in silence, and Carl can’t help but remember the exact same journey just twenty-fours hours previously. It hardly seems possible that so little time has passed between now and then.
“You lived here a long time?”
He can’t see Will’s face too clearly in the growing dark, but he nods in his general direction.
“Moved here in ’91 just after the kids left home for good. Had some fool idea about the sea air being good for Beth’s lungs. Didn’t think too much about how it’d be for her, looking out at this all day every day for the rest of her life.”
Will makes a soft sound of understanding,
“She got to hate the sea when you used to go away.”
And Carl sighs, because it seems so obvious now in retrospect.
“Never said it outright, but yeah. Ate her up I think. Wondering when I’d give in to it again. Thinking it was just a matter of time.”
In the dark he throws a piece of driftwood for Cassy and watches as she bounds away into the glowing breakers to find it.
“You didn’t talk about it?”
“Sure!”
And Carl laughs softly, because the younger man makes it sounds so damned simple.
“We talked about it. Talked around it at least. Told her I was done, that I just wanted to stay home with her now, but I guess she was alone a long time. Alone with the kids when they were growing up, and then later alone in the house.”
He runs a hand back through his thinning hair,
“Maybe it just didn’t feel safe for her to believe me.”
Ahead of them Cassy jumps in and out of the waves, her tongue lolling as she prepares to play ‘keep away’ with her stick.
“After she got sicker it was worse. Like she didn’t dare believe I would always be there for her, like any minute she could turn her head and I’d be gone,” warm breath mists in front of him, “It’s an awful thing to love someone, know they love you, and still have them push you away like that. Like being without you is somehow less painful than waiting for you to go.”
He sees Will come to a stop beside him and turn to look towards the cliffs, up the coastline. He still can’t see him too clearly but he thinks he looks sad, wistful even.
“What about you?” he asks him,“You married?”
“Uh huh,” and his right hand comes up to twist unconsciously at the ring on his left, “It’s not like…that though. We hadn’t been together that long.”
The use of past tense in his reply doesn’t escape Carl’s notice, but he decides not to comment on it. Will’s expression is wide open again as he looks upwards, cranes his neck back to squint for the North Star.
“I like to think I was honest with her, that I was my best self when we did it. And maybe I was. Maybe that was the one good thing I did. Marrying her. Trying to help her raise…”
He stops and draws a quick breath,
“I think on some level I knew though. From the start. I always told myself that I was trying to keep us out of the shadows, but in the end it really took…so little. Maybe I was always just waiting for an excuse to drag them back over me again.”
His eyes glitter in the darkness as he turns back to Carl,
“Like a warm familiar blanket,” he says.
They walk up along the sand for half a mile or so more before turning back, by which time the moon has come up in full to paint the sea with her milky light. They don’t talk again, just take it in turn to throw sticks for the excited lab and help her find new ones whenever they fall too far from shore for her to swim to. It’s a cool, perfectly still night and the beach is beautiful etched in silver, and Carl surprises himself by how comfortable he feels in the company of this quiet stranger, who even now carries his own loaded service pistol tucked into his waistband.
Starting back up the path towards the house, he glances back at him as Will lags behind, appearing to search the surface of the water, before winding back his arm to throw something far out into the waves. Whatever it is Cassy can’t seem to find it, and after a moment of two of excited jumping she gives up on the task and trots quietly to Carl’s heels.
“You still ok to help me with this cast?”
Will’s request at his shoulder sounds genuine, like he actually has a choice in the matter, and Carl nods thoughtfully.
“Only ever watched it done before, but sure. You?”
“Put one on a half-feral Doberman once, years back,” teeth glint in the darkness, “Thinking that was easier than this will be.”
They reach the cottage gate and Will stretches past him to push it open, and the sight of his bare left hand in the moonlight stops Carl dead in his tracks for an instant. Seeing him looking, the younger man looks too, flexes his fingers before he stands aside to let him walk past.
“Just didn’t feel right there any more,” he says.
