Actions

Work Header

Rating:
Archive Warning:
Category:
Fandoms:
Relationship:
Characters:
Additional Tags:
Language:
English
Series:
Part 3 of Memories and Dreams Series
Stats:
Published:
2013-03-04
Completed:
2013-03-09
Words:
5,587
Chapters:
4/4
Kudos:
91
Hits:
0

Memories: Beautiful and Painful Things

Chapter 4

Notes:

Just a heads up. This chapter contains MAJOR spoilers if you haven't read the book. It's been alluded to a couple of times, but here it gets spelled out for you. If you don't already know and don't want to know, turn back now.

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

It was at this point that Bilbo truly wished that he could stop remembering. So far the memories had been bittersweet but this was the point where they actually began to become painful. But, like water from a pond when the dam has burst, the memories refused to stop until they had reached the end.

The next to come was the one that had started this traipse down memory lane in the first place: Thorin gifting him with his mithril coat. He could still remember the way Thorin had held it out to him, almost hesitantly as though afraid Bilbo would refuse it. The way Thorin had gently helped him to remove his jacket before guiding the mail over Bilbo's head and fastening the belt with his skilled hands. But more than any of that, Bilbo could still remember the lust and love that had burned in Thorin's eyes as he had looked at the hobbit, dressed in glittering metal and surrounded by gold. That had been the last time Thorin had looked on him with lust. Not long after had come the affair with the Arkenstone.

The Arkenstone. If there was one thing in his life that he could do over, it would be what had happened with the Arkenstone. If he had had any idea what it meant to Thorin, he never would have given it to the Elf King even if he thought that he could singlehandedly end the war with the act. He had known that Thorin desired it, yes. But had he realized what it being in the possession of the elves would do to Thorin he never would have given it to the elves, even to save all their lives.

He could never stop himself from wondering what would have happened if he had not done so. Would things have turned out differently in the end? Would him still being at Thorin's side have stopped the inevitable end when a legion of dwarves from the Iron Hills could not? He doubted it, but he knew that if he had not done it, his next memory would not have happened.

He felt tears begin to sting his eyes and flow down his cheeks at the thought. He still remembered the hatred and betrayal in Thorin's eyes as he had looked at Bilbo after he learned what he had done. He had felt his heart shatter as he realized that he had just done irreparable damage to their relationship through one stupid act. Even though he knew that it was that betrayal that fueled Thorin's anger, and caused him to attempt to throw Bilbo from the mountain—which he would have done had Gandalf not interfered—Bilbo could have sworn that he saw tears glistening in the King Under the Mountain's eyes as Bilbo took his place on the side of the Elves and Men.

Even if not giving the Arkenstone to the elves would not have saved Thorin's life, he wished he would have tried to find another way to prevent the war. Even if he had lost his own life in the process. Anything would have been better than seeing the hurt and betrayal in Thorin's eyes and feeling the strong arms that had held him so tenderly so many times lift him in preparation to throw him to his death. At the time, he had hated Gandalf for interfering. He had felt that it would have been better to die than to have to live with knowing that he had broken the trust of the dwarf he loved. Sometimes he still hated Gandalf for it. If only he had died, he would not have had to see what happened next.

His memories of the time leading up to the Battle of the Five Armies were vague at best, as were his memories of his brief stint in the Battle itself. His clearest memory of that time was being led to Thorin's tent and seeing the King lying broken on a pile of blankets.

He felt his tears begin to fall freely as he remembered how fragile Thorin had looked under all those bandages. The majesty and pride that he had always worn had fallen away and all that was left was Thorin as he was. Not the King Under the Mountain or the wielder of the Oakenshield. Just Thorin.

As the light had fallen on his bruised and lacerated face, he had flinched and opened his eyes. As his pain-filled blue orbs had locked on Bilbo his expression morphed from one of agony to one of regret.

"They told me you were dead, Halfling," Thorin had said slowly, each word causing him obvious pain.

"They were mistaken," Bilbo had replied tears in his voice that were not yet in his eyes. "They told me you are dying. Were they mistaken on that count as well?" He had known even then that it was a weak hope, but it was one that he had clung to nonetheless. Thorin had said nothing, but the look in his eyes said it all. They had not lied.

"I'm so sorry," Bilbo had said tears flowing freely down his cheeks. "I've made a mess of it all. You were right about me at the beginning. I never should have come."

"No," Thorin's had replied, more than just physical pain coloring his tone. "It is I who has erred. Come, if you will. Sit with me. Until the end."

Bilbo had been unable to refuse. Despite what Thorin had tried to do to him in a blind rage, he had still loved him. In fact, he still loved him. He had walked across the tent and sat himself beside Thorin. He had sat beside the King and stroked his hair and told him stories and sang songs in an attempt to ease his passing. Numerous dwarves had filed through the tent to pay their last respects to Thorin Oakenshield, the King who had reclaimed Erebor, but Bilbo never moved from his place, nor did he cease his stroking of Thorin's black and grey mane.

Even once Thorin slipped into the sleep from which he would never awaken, Bilbo did not move. He sat with him throughout the night and was there in the grey hours of dawn when Thorin Oakenshield, King Under the Mountain, breathed his last breath. It was only then that he allowed himself to be lead away and have his own wound tended. It was then that he had learned that Thorin had not been the Company's only casualty but that Fili and Kili had joined their Uncle in death.

He could not now remember their funerals, though he supposed that they had been grand—as far as these things go. He did remember Balin telling him that if he needed proof that Thorin had loved him he need look no farther than to the coat he still wore for it had a value greater than not only his hobbit hole but the whole Shire and, perhaps, Bree as well.

He supposed that a dwarf may have been comforted by the worth of the present, but Bilbo found that thought no more comforting then than he did now. He would rather have had Thorin beside him than some expensive token of his affection. Logically he knew that even had Thorin survived the Battle they would still have had obstacles to their being together. He also knew that he still would be alone at the current time. During the quest to reclaim Lonely Mountain Thorin had been 195 years old. The average dwarf—which something in Bilbo rebelled against comparing Thorin to—lived to be 250 years old. That would have placed his death near Bilbo's 111th birthday.

Bilbo didn't know if it would have been more difficult for him to see the proud dwarf defeated by old age than it had been to see him defeated by orcs, but he didn't think that was possible for Thorin's death by old age to be more painful to witness than his actual death had been. But, as Bilbo had told Gandalf at his last birthday in the Shire, he was old now. All this remembering and the tears it had brought had tired him out.

As he laid himself on his bead and drifted to sleep he could almost imagine that he could feel Thorin's arms holding him again. As he slept, he dreamt of how things might have gone differently on his quest to help homeless dwarves reclaim their homes. That is the nice thing about dreams. In his dreams, Bilbo could have the happy ending that he never had in life.

Notes:

Well, there we are. The end of this story. If you are feeling totally depressed by this, feel free to check out the companion piece Dreams: To Stay By His Side. Even though both of these can stand alone, the second was inspired by this one and might help combat the depression since there will be more fluff (and no deaths . . . hopefully). I hope you have enjoyed reading it as much as I enjoyed writing it. Thank you for taking the time to read this story.

And if you're in a mood for smut, the scene from chapter 3 has been posted under the title, Memories of Passion: One Night With the King.

Stickdonkeys.

Series this work belongs to: