Chapter Text
Chapter Three
The catacombs are dank, silent, and poorly lit by lanterns fitted snugly within carved apertures in the stone walls. Each twist and turn leading Will deeper into the maze. Prompted onwards by a familiar presence, even when the passageways begin to appear iteratively similar—his return route now forever lost to the labyrinth expanding miles behind him.
Pulse pounding against his throat, Will fights against an inexplicable pressure bearing down upon him the farther he travels. Shadows simultaneously inching inwards, seeming to vibrate with sinister energies. Shivering, when his arm brushes lightly against the darkness as though it’s consolidated to form a solid black mass that's shockingly icy to the touch.
But his steps never falter. Knowing, somehow, that the man he seeks is somewhere nearby, awaiting his arrival.
It’s after a few more tentative turns, and a couple dead ends, that he finally stumbles across a chamber. Blood pooling in a thick layer over the ground, warming his bare pale feet as they plunge into it, submerging him up to an inch above the ankle. And as it sloshes against his skin, Will’s attention is drawn to his peculiar state of undress; merely clothed in a plain white shirt and charcoal grey boxer shorts. Definitely not the appropriate attire one would wear traipsing through an underground cemetery.
Two leather chairs stand positioned in a face-off, placed only feet apart—their unsullied upholsteries a stark contrast to the rocky, dull background. One of the chairs remaining partly cloaked in shadow having due to a single lantern casting light upon the room. His heart beat slowing to synchronize with an unsourced ticking reverberating from the walls.
“Hello, Will,” a man’s voice suddenly emanates from the veil of darkness; the same tone and pitch Will recalls hearing from the stag’s mouth. “You’re right on time. Please, sit.”
Will, to his own amazement, obliges and immediately heads for the closest chair with little trepidation. The blood lapping around his ankles as he seats himself, gripping the padded armrest tenaciously until his knuckles glow white.
At long last, the man reveals himself; albeit, most of his features remain obscured by darkness. Moving with dignified grace, he settles easily into the opposing chair—interweaving his fingers while he fluidly folds one leg over the other. Will’s options of study whittling down to either the bottom fraction of his brown plaid suit jacket or his oddly pristine dress shoes, given it's the only portion of him that's illuminated. Displeased, that he’s not granted any more details than that.
“Your thoughts seem to be rather…displaced,” the man observes, forcing a shocked, nervous laugh from Will. “Do you feel uncomfortable?”
“I think that shouldn’t come as a surprise, given the current situation.” Will smiles tautly, digging his nails mercilessly into the leather.
Will can practically feel the man's head tilt as he questions, “And what situation might that be?”
“What situation—?” Will repeats incredulously, muttering under his breath as he drops his gaze to his lap; despising how exposed he is. “I’m underground, my feet are soaking in blood, and I’m apparently having a sort of therapy session with some unusually familiar man.” His eyes flick up to the where the man’s face might be, hidden in the shadows. “Anyone would feel uncomfortable. In fact, anyone in their right mind would believe they’ve gone insane.”
Silence stretches for an indeterminable amount of time, save for the infernal ticking—of which its source is yet to be determined. Will jerking with alarm when the man finally decides to speak. “But you are not.”
“No,” Will agrees, swallowing thickly, lowering his gaze.
Another pause. “Where are we, Will?” he prompts, gesturing generally at their surroundings.
“Shouldn’t you know?” Will spits, a sudden, bewildering swell of anger washing over him. “You’re the one who brought me here.”
The man exhales heavily, presumably exasperated with Will’s perverse nature to play at his own game. “Insolence is unbecoming of you. I’m merely trying to help.”
The blood whirlpools sluggishly at Will’s feet, and he cringes away from it when the thought arises that he hasn’t been unduly bothered by it. It incites him to lift his legs with haste, and rest his feet on the edge of the seat—watching intently as rivers of crimson stream incessantly from the tips of his toes.
“Help me with what?”
“Simply, the truth,” he swiftly answers, clearly unfazed by Will’s reaction. “No matter how deeply we inhume our true nature in our subconscious, it can still be unearthed. And more often than not, liberates us. Tell me, Will…” Leather creaks under his weight as he bends forward, halting purposely before gracing the light. “How much longer can you afford this brazen façade?”
Will’s brows furrow in confusion. “What do you mean?”
“You can’t escape yourself, Will. Neither can you cure what you are by willful dissociation. Of course, erasing oneself could also be an act of deflection.” Reaching out his hand, the man brushes fingertips gently down the side of Will's calf. The touch sending chills up his spine. “It’s not the entirety of your life you desire to lock away, but one memory in particular. And rather chance the possibility of evoking it, you determined it safer to banish it all.”
“I can’t be whole without you,” the words flow from Will’s mouth involuntarily; though, they strangely sting with bitter truth. “I don’t want to live if you’re…” he trails off, clenching his teeth. “I can survive as I am right now.”
A responding morose sigh perforates the heavy silence that follows.
“A butterfly cannot reverse metamorphosis nor can it disguise itself as a fellow caterpillar, for it has wings. Therefore, it should never permit itself to lapse into a false sense of security, as only the truly rarest are sought for collection.” The hand tracing lines across Will’s flesh moves to rest atop one of Will’s that’s gripping his shins, and squeezes it to convey the severity of his message.
A gasp is startled from him when a new set of hands unexpectedly grasp the sides of his face from behind. Forcing his head to incline until his eyes meet the disturbingly familiar ones of the newcomer. Shocked, when he recognizes the stranger as a duplicate of himself, only drenched entirely in blood, antlers sprouting forth from the top of his skull.
“‘In all of us, even in good men, there is a lawless wild-beast nature, which peers out in sleep.'” Will hears the man quote, but he's incapable of averting his gaze from the piercingly cold, apathetic eyes staring straight through him. “It’s time to wake up, Will.”
At those words, Will’s doppelgänger wrenches Will’s head painfully to bare his neck. His lips parting to reveal pointed teeth before steadily descending upon him, aiming squarely for the jugular. The background ticking increasing in its intensity until Will swears the flesh at his skull begins to split and tear. His scream unrecognizable, even as it reverberates loudly from the dark walls—only to be abruptly silenced when fangs puncture the skin of his throat.
A shrill screech jars Will back to reality in time to experience yet another near heart attack. Aware he’s once again kneeling in the middle of the road, watching helplessly as a car skids straight for him; the blare of its high beams robbing him temporarily of sight.
Time slows to a crawl—the universe progressing at a measured pace as his senses narrow to the beating of his heart and his rasping breaths filling his lungs. Feeling a current of air sweep over his side as the vehicle swerves last minute to avoid him; barely a foot of space separating him from an unfortunate fate.
“Jesus,” someone whispers, and only after the world snaps firmly back into place does he comprehend it had been him. The gravity of everything surging upwards until his head spins, causing him to tip forward—palm scraping asphalt as he curls into himself, and violently retches what little contents remain in his stomach.
“Are you all right? Are you hurt?” A woman’s voice calls from a distance seconds before her flashlight shines brutally in his face; stabbing at his eyes, and forcing him to turn his head away, as the throbbing against his temples spikes.
“Fine,” he answers, spitting lingering traces of bile from his mouth. “I’m…I’m fine.” Shakily, he rises to his feet—mainly to prove to himself that he can—and sways imperceptibly in place. His body trembling with ebbing adrenaline.
“What’s your name?” she asks, her tone inflecting authority yet retaining an essence of gentleness. Clearly, trained to err on the side of caution, but not so much to come across as untrustworthy or unhelpful.
Law enforcement, he deduces, raising his only usable hand to shield his eyes against the glare. “Will.”
“Last name?”
He shrugs, hoping he isn’t perceived as uncooperative or defiant.
She, thankfully, doesn’t press him over it, but nevertheless carries on with the standard list of inquiries. “Do you know where you are, Will?”
He turns from the light briefly, blinking at the expansion of darkness engulfing the rural road. “Can’t say that I do.”
Gravel crunches underfoot as she takes a cautious step toward him, her flashlight keeping him partially blind. “You’re in Gloucester County, about a mile north from Dutton.”
“Dutton?” he parrots, unable to place the town.
“Virginia,” she provides helpfully. “Have you taken any drugs or medication tonight?”
“I’m, uh…” Will trails off as a shiver wracks him, his sleepwear inadequate protection against the frigid temperature. “I’m recovering from injuries, so I’ve been taking painkillers. The medication must’ve induced sleepwalking.”
She hums thoughtfully, and instructs him to stay put while she heads back to the car. The pale moonlight illuminating the letters imprinted along its backside, confirming that she is, indeed, a state trooper.
From the direction she’d been traveling when she nearly plowed into him, a pair of headlights break over the horizon. The engine roaring loudly as it accelerates towards them, but is quick to pull to a stop alongside hers. Will instantly recognizing it as Jim’s even before he exits; his gait slow and hitching as he starts toward him.
Having hardly even seated herself inside her own car for no more than a minute, the trooper clambers frantically out at the sight of Jim; hightailing it to intercept him before he has a chance to reach Will.
“Hey there, Miss Samantha,” Jim beams, his steps unfaltering. “I’m glad you managed to find my son. I was beginnin’ to worry.”
“Your son?” she questions, skeptical, spotlighting Will once more. “I haven’t seen him with you before.”
“Well," Jim starts, heaving a sigh. "He hasn’t been livin’ with me for long. He's been in an accident recently, you see, and suffers from amnesia. So, I’m caring for him ‘til he’s back on his feet,” he lies with a natural ease that equally impresses and unsettles Will greatly.
“That must be difficult for you, I’m sorry,” she sympathizes, buying into the explanation without question. “I was just about to offer him a ride to the hospital. He’s endured quite a shock.” A sheepish laugh escapes her. "I nearly ran him over."
“Is that right? Well, I wouldn't worry yourself over that. Even wildlife can take us by surprise from time to time." Jim chuckles. "And I appreciate your concern, but I’m sure he’ll be just fine,” Jim’s quick to dismiss, sidling up to Will and grasping his upper arm in a protective display. “He just needs to go home and get some rest.”
Samantha smiles genuinely, grateful to have been absolved of guilt as she lowers the flashlight, permitting Will to scrutinize her petite frame and slender face. “I know he’s in good hands.” Titling her head, she finally meets Will’s gaze. Her analyzing stare unnerving, causing him to flinch away as she says, “It’s weird, though. You seem awfully familiar. I could swear I’ve seen you somewhere.”
At that, Will feels Jim go rigid beside him. His hand convulsively tightening around Will's arm, fingers digging into his flesh hard enough that he’s certain to bruise. Will not needing to look to perceive the warning for what it is.
“There's always a possibility,” Will returns, releasing a breathy laugh.
“Maybe,” she agrees, eyes searching his face for something before turning to address Jim once more. “Well, I should let you get home, since it’s freezing out here. But I hope we’ll see you around sometime soon? Possibly, for the church potluck in a few weeks? You can definitely bring him along with you.”
“Of course," Jim assures, not bothering to relax his grip as he practically yanks Will towards the truck. “You have a good night, now. And thank you, again. I’ll make sure to keep a better eye on him.”
"Anytime." She nods, escorting them until they reach their respective vehicles. "Just glad he isn't hurt."
Will slides into the blessed warmth of the truck a couple minutes later; dazed and bit out of sorts. Observing the fading glow of Samantha’s taillights, as her car vanishes around the bend. And jerking when Jim exhales a breath of relief, his fingers drumming repetitively against the stitching of the steering wheel. Evidently, lost to his thoughts.
Minutes of tense silence tick by as they continue to sit idly; absently staring out into the night, gazing at the stars unobscured by light pollution.
“Why did you lie?” Will questions at length, growing wary of the man’s altruistic intentions toward him thus far.
Jim remains silent, gaze steadfast on some distant point in the road—the weight of unspoken words nearly palpable within the confines of the truck’s metal framework. His answer, apparently, not forthcoming, as he turns the key to the ignition, and shifts into drive.
