Actions

Work Header

Fighting for Love

Chapter 2: Contemplating Decisions

Chapter Text

When the cab was gone John looked down at the ring. It looked like a class ring from first glance, but upon closer inspection it had the family crest of the Durin family. Overlaying the crest was an oak tree, which was specific to Thorin's ring. Fili and Kili's rings each had representations of themselves, also overlaying the family crest. It was tradition that the Durin males would receive their rings from their parents when they turned fourteen. John remembered when Thorin had first given it to him to wear. The ring was too big for John's finger so he wore it on a chain around his neck. When him and Thorin had fought John had given the ring back. It had broken his heart to do it and he knew it must have devastated Thorin when he had done it.
John looked down at the ring again and then let it fall from his fingers to rest against his chest. He had to admit to himself that the familiar weight was like coming home.
When John finally walked inside Sherlock was back and was going through cold case files. He looked up at John and let a slight smirk out when he realized John was alone. However the smirk quickly fell when he noticed the new piece of jewelry around John's neck. He knew John hadn't been wearing it when he had left because John never wore a necklace. He didn't even wear his dog tags. But the ease and familiarity with which John wore the necklace and played with it spoke of habit.
"How was lunch," asked Sherlock rearranging to try and get a look a what pendant John must've been playing with.
He almost let out a gasp when he realized it was a ring.
"Its was good. We enjoyed ourselves," said John with a smile, pleased that Sherlock was taking an interest.
"Good for you."
Or not, thought John at Sherlock's dismissive tone.
"What is that you're wearing," asked Sherlock as John moved to his computer.
"Something Thorin gave me years ago. He just gave it back after I returned it to him last I saw him," said John as he checked his emails.
Sherlock was still trying to lean around to look at the ring. Finally he gave up and just asked which caused John to smirk.
"Its his family ring."
"Family ring," repeated Sherlock in mild confusion.
"Yes. It has the family crest and an oak tree which is his symbol. Kili has an arrow on his and Fili has an axe on his."
"Where do you get symbols like that," asked Sherlock derisively.
"Their parents chose their symbols.”
Sherlock made a face at that.
“Oh don’t give me that face. Just because you and Mycroft and your parents aren’t on the best of terms all around does not mean that everyone else is the same way. The Durin family was very close,” said John quietly with a sad expression.
“Was,” repeated Sherlock.
“Thorin’s father and grandfather died in the Gulf War. Then his mum died giving birth to his younger brother, who died a month later. And then his sister, the boys’ mother, died a little over a year ago. Its just Thorin and his nephews now,” said John with tears in his eyes.
“I’m sorry John for my snide attitude before. Did you know his family well?”
“Quite well. They became a second family to me when my parents died and Harry and I grew apart,” said John.
“How did you meet them,” asked Sherlock finally taking a real interest.
“Well, now that is a funny story.”
Over the next few hours Sherlock learned that John had met Thorin when a mutual friend of theirs had decided to throw a party at John’s house. Of course the friend had forgotten to inform John and with no warning his house had been invaded by ten guys he had never met. Thats also how he met Fili and Kili. Their mother had dropped the two youngsters off and had told John to tell Thorin to have them home at a reasonable hour. John had no idea who Thorin was or a clue as to why this woman would leave her two sons in the care of a man she had never met. Apparently she knew the other guys at the party
Finally, before Thorin showed up, their friend, who everyone called G. Grey, showed up and explained that they were just having a party. John apparently had not been amused. That was until Thorin showed up. John told Sherlock how there had been an instant attraction, but how they always seemed to rub each other the wrong way. Even when John started hanging out with their group, him and Thorin just never seemed to click. That was until John had punched a guy named Azog (“What kind of name is that,” asked Sherlock. “No idea,” said John) in the face to stop him from punching Thorin. From that day on they had been inseparable friends. You rarely saw one without the other and when they weren’t in school you often found them running around with Thorin’s nephews and occasionally his sister.
When Thorin told John he was going to join the military, John had kissed him and said okay. The day Thorin left for training and John joined him, complete with fatigues and dog tags, Thorin told him he loved him and gave him his ring. They had trained and fought together and their relationship grew from there. They had their disagreements, but at the end of the day they still loved each other.
“What split you guys up,” asked Sherlock after hearing about some of the things John and Thorin had fought about.
“Thorin was very possessive. He got jealous and I liked it a bit. Its always nice feeling wanted, but it got to the point where he just wanted to hide me away and not let me have a life and I couldn’t be that for him. I couldn’t give up everything and devote myself solely to him like that. I needed my own life as well as the life I had with him. He didn’t like that and we broke up. I gave him his ring and we didn’t talk for a few months. Then he almost died and he apologized and I accepted, but then I got transfered.”
“If you hadn’t been transfered do you think you would have tried again,” asked Sherlock needing to know this answer.
“Yes. I believe we would have tried. Whether it would have worked is another question,” said John with a small laugh.
“Why did he give you his ring today,” asked Sherlock realizing that he seemed to be in a competition for John’s affections that he was rapidly losing.
“He says its mine. He also wants to get back together. Says he’s changed because I am too important to not try,” revealed John.
Sherlock sat there for a moment, watching as John played with the ring. He could declare his feelings right now and ask that John consider him over Thorin. But then Sherlock had to stop and think. John and Thorin hadn’t worked out because Thorin had been very possessive and hadn’t wanted to share John. Sherlock realized he was the exact same way with John right now and they were only friends. He couldn’t imagine what he would be like if him and John were together.
Thats how Sherlock realized he couldn’t be with John. No matter how much he desired John and felt deeply for him, it wouldn’t work. He would want to keep John all to himself and never let him near others. He also knew that he wouldn’t change. No matter if their relationship smothered John, which he never wanted to do, he couldn’t change his ways. Plus John had this whole family with Thorin already. Anyone could see that Fili and Kili looked at Thorin and John as fathers, not uncles. And Thorin and John just worked with each other. They lit up when they saw each other. Sherlock couldn’t say the same about John and him. Sure he was happy to see John, but not in the way Thorin was happy to see John. There was just too much history to compete with.
So thats what Sherlock told John. He explained how he had feelings for John, but they weren’t serious and that he couldn’t change for John. He also explained how John and Thorin were like together and how they were with Fili and Kili. Sherlock told John to go for it with Thorin and that they would still be friends and that he expected John to continue to work with him and Lestrade on cases.
John was a bit surprised to say the least as Sherlock suddenly let his feelings out. However, he listened patiently and by the end he knew what he needed to do. So John got up and walked over to Sherlock in his chair. Much to Sherlock’s surprise, John gave him a chaste kiss on the lips before saying thank you. He then grabbed his coat and headed out the door, calling Thorin to meet him.
When Thorin got to Regent’s Park, John was already there. He got out of the cab and looked at John concerned as to what was wrong at eleven o’clock at night. As he approached John and made an attempt to ask what was wrong, John surprised him by kissing him. It took only a moment for Thorin to respond. His mouth easily fitting over John’s and quickly dominating the kiss. When they finally pulled away it was for air.
“Does this mean what I think this means,” asked Thorin breathless as he stared into John’s eyes.
“Yes.”
“Oh thank the Gods,” said Thorin with a grin as he leaned down and placed another kiss on John’s lips.
“I’ve missed you,” said John with a small smile as he leaned his forehead against Thorin’s.
“And I you. What made you say yes,” asked Thorin, truly not caring, but curious all the same.
“It was Sherlock,” admitted John.
“Sherlock,” questioned Thorin, pulling away form John.
John let out a disgruntled sound and pulled Thorin back in, resting his head on Thorin’s broad chest.
“Yes. He told me that he had feelings for me, but that we would never work. He said that he is too possessive and that he feared he would smother me and he couldn’t do that to me. So, he told me to go for it with you,” said John with a grin.
That grin quickly faded, however, as he saw the look on Thorin’s face.
“So does this mean that you are only choosing me because things wouldn’t have worked out with your precious Sherlock,” demanded Thorin, angry and more then a bit hurt.
“No Thorin. It means I am with you because you’re the one I love. You’re the one who I’ve always loved.”
“So what did Sherlock’s admittance have to do with you choosing me,” asked Thorin trying to calm down and let John explain.
“I didn’t chose you Thorin...”
Thorin’s face quickly fell and John hastened to finish his sentence.
“There was never any choice. Its always been you for me. Even when you were possessive and attempting to lock me away from the world, I still would have gone back to you in a heartbeat. Sherlock’s admittance made me realize that while I could not tolerate that treatment from anybody, I would put up with it for you. I love you and despite everything I want to be with only you.”
Thorin’s smile quickly returned and he hugged John closer to him.
“That doesn’t mean, of course, that you are now allowed to be overly possessive and lock me away. I have a life. One that does include Sherlock and solving crimes,” added John before Thorin could distract him with the butterfly kisses he was raining down on John’s neck.
“I understand love. As long as I am allowed to be part of your life you may do whatever you wish,” said Thorin nuzzling under John’s chin.
“Hmmmm I’ve missed this,” said John as he nuzzled Thorin right back.
“As have I my Bilbo. As have I.”