Actions

Work Header

Identically Different

Chapter 2: His Final Gift

Summary:

In which Jack discovers Will's disappearance, Will debates whether he is finally going insane, and Hannibal Lecter plays a game.

Chapter Text

Hannibal Lecter feels a sudden surge of fondness as he gazes down at Will's limp body. He has missed Will; it's something he can easily admit to himself. Hannibal believes firmly that one's true self can only be elevated to its fullest potential when one is capable of accepting their deepest, darkest secrets and urges.

Hannibal understands himself, and Hannibal's potential is magnificent.

He half-carries, half-drags Will out of the door and around the back of the house, the other man's boots leaving drag-marks in the dust and snow. Hannibal doesn't bother to cover them. He is careful to leave Will's shattered glasses lying visibly in the centre of the room, and leaves a small puddle of chloroform on the floorboards. There should be clues enough to guide even Jack Crawford to enlightenment,

The door bangs plaintively against the frame in a sudden squall of wind, but Hannibal doesn't bother to shut it. Instead, he carefully eases Will into the passenger seat of the nondescript car he purloined for this.

Will's head lolls back against the headrest, and Hannibal observes the classic beauty in his features, marred only slightly by his scars: the jagged stab wound in his cheek, courtesy of the Dragon; a slim, neat scar by his left temple, received from that oaf Cordell; and, of course, a brief cut across the forehead, from Hannibal himself. Will looks like an ethereal spirit, the kind found drifting serenely through the paintings of the great masters. Hannibal is always able to appreciate beauty.

He slides into the driver's seat of the car, and shoots a glance at Will, looking so uncharacteristically peaceful, his dark curls bright against the pallor of his skin. In sleep, at rest, Will Graham is a masterpiece.

Typically, Hannibal rules his life with two iron qualities: power and control, the twin sisters of success. Once upon a time, he'd exerted both over Will. But now Will has broken free, and has proven too strong to be confined by these bonds, and Hannibal feels genuine respect for that.

This is why he has decided to stop playing. This is why he starts the car. And this is why - finally, inevitably, reverently - Hannibal Lecter prepares to give his final gift to Will.

 

***

 

Alana is fretting. She holds a wineglass tensely in her hand, rolling the stem between her fingers. She flexes, slightly, almost ready to break the fragile glass, and -

"Probably a bad idea," Margot murmurs, gently pulling the glass from her fingers. "What's troubling you?"

Alana sighs in defeat. She can never hide her thoughts from Margot. "It's just...Will was supposed to call over two hours ago, to tell me he got back alright but he's not answering his phone. He was visiting Wolftrap today."

Margot places a soft kiss against Alana's neck. It's not a seduction, nor an enticement - it's merely a reassurance, once that Alana desperately needs. "Maybe he forgot."

"But it's so unlike him," Alana says, frowning. "I mean, not anymore. He always remembers to call these days."

The candles are burning softly in the hearth, in place of a fire. It's cold outside, but in here Alana and Margot have each other for warmth. Alana is thankful for it.

And Margot - her beautiful, gorgeous, exquisite wife - takes Alana's hand in hers. They fit perfectly together.

"Maybe you should call someone," she says, and Alana knows all too well who that someone is.

"I should," Alana admits. "Just - just in case. It's probably nothing."

"Of course," Margot reassures her, gently kissing her shoulder.

Alana pulls out her phone. She hopes Will just fell asleep, or forgot to charge his phone, and he'll ring her any moment now, apologetic, bashful.

She presses in the number without thinking. The phone rings only for a moment before her call is picked up.

"Hello?"

"Hi, Jack," she says.

 

***

 

Will wakes groggily, his limbs feeling heavy as lead. Wherever he's sitting seems to be swaying rhythmically, and for a moment he wonders if he's back in the icy-cold embrace of the water at the bottom of the cliff, clutching the Chesapeake Ripper in his arms. He can't feel his fingers.

It takes all his effort to crack his eyes open with a quiet groan, and he stares blearily ahead, trying to make sense of the fuzzy images. He's not wearing his glasses, but he doesn't have the faintest idea how he lost them in the first place, or how he even ended up here. Everything is a blur.

He swallows, and his vision sharpens, and Will recognises that he's in a car. Memories pierce his brain and he winces, suddenly recalling the fight in Wolftrap. It's dark now, early evening, and Will knows that they must be miles by now.

There is a quiet, discreet cough next to him, and Will freezes. Terrified of what he might see, he inches his eyes left, dragging them to the person in the driver's seat. His mouth is dry. Fear swamps him. He finally turns his head enough to face the driver and stops abruptly.

"Hello, Will," says Hannibal Lecter.

He has a smile on his face, directed at Will; that stupid, stupid, fond smile, the smile that he uses whenever Will's done something particularly clever or pleasing. The smile that makes Will feel humiliatingly like a well-trained dog.

Will lets out his breath in a sigh, easing his head back against the headrest. He looks ahead at the dark road ahead of them, floodlit by brilliant headlights.

"Hannibal," he says, like an acknowledgement. He's not quite sure what to think. "I thought you were dead."

Relief curdles in his gut, but Will's desperate for some kind of feeling, so he clings to it desperately, until it is swallowed by annoyance.

Hannibal drives serenely onwards. Even the way he drives is elegant. "Thankfully, I am not. It is good to see you, Will."

"You too," Will mutters, and Hannibal gives another satisfied smile.

Will doesn't quite feel connected to the world. Hannibal's presence next to him is so real, so solid, that it almost overwhelms him. It makes him shiver.

"How did you survive?" he asks quietly, not expecting an answer. Somewhat surprisingly, he gets one.

"My wounds were not so severe as yours," Hannibal explains conversationally, as if they were discussing wine over dinner. "You took the brunt of the impact of the rocks with your back. When we reached the bottom, I was relatively unharmed, although you had fractured your skull at some point on the journey down."

The streetlights make Hannibal look otherworldly as he speaks. Will is transfixed, and he doesn't quite trust himself to speak. Against his better judgment, he contemplates simply running away with the doctor, away from the FBI, away from this life, away from everyone they would leave behind.

Maybe they still can. That is, if Hannibal doesn't plan on killing him first.

"I swam along the current with you until we reached a small bay a mile down from my house. The route was familiar to me. I pulled you up onto the sand and then made my escape. The sea covered my footprints."

Will takes a moment to consider Hannibal's motives for saving him. A part of him hopes it is because Hannibal sees him as an asset. Another part knows it is because Hannibal enjoys the power he exerts over Will. And yet another part - a deeper, darker part - whispers a poisonous tale of love into his ears.

Will isn't sure which option scares him more. He isn't sure which option excited him more, either.

There is a pause, during which Will settles into his seat a little more, and Hannibal's eyes dart over to examine him.

"Your face has healed well," Hannibal observes. "The scarring, I see, was minimal. Your doctors did a good job."

Will reaches up, a little self-consciously, with his right hand to touch his cheek. He halts abruptly, however, when his hand is pulled up short with a clink. He looks down; his right hand is handcuffed to the car door.

"What's with this?" Will demands, tugging fruitlessly at the cuffs. "What was the point of chloroform, anyway? All you had to do was ask, Hannibal. You know I would have come with you. You only had to ask."

Hannibal looks positively smug by now, but schools his face into an expression of sympathy that Will knows only too well. He swallows a groan. He knows he's not going to get any straight answers out of Hannibal for the time being.

"I'm sorry, Will," Hannibal says, "but it was necessary."

"Oh, really?" Will makes no attempt to hide the sarcasm in his voice.

"Yes. This whole charade must paint you as the unwilling victim. How better to do that than to make it real?"

"The unwilling - what?"

"It is possible that the less you know, the better, Will. This is being done for your benefit, after all."

"For my benefit -" Will actually has to take a moment to let the words sink in. "So how exactly is drugging me and chaining me to your car going to help me?"

There's that smile again, and frustration bubbles in Will. Hannibal is enjoying this, and he's not even attempting to hide it. He's toying with Will.

"It will become clear soon, my dear Will. Everything does eventually, in that beautiful mind of yours." Hannibal's hands shift a little on the steering wheel, and he stares calmly ahead at the never-ending strip of road. "Relax, Will. You worry too much. This journey serves a purpose far greater than you imagine."

Will doesn't even need to ask, at this point. He just cocks his head inquisitively, like one of his dogs, and Hannibal answers.

"Soon, I promise, you will understand." Hannibal's eyes gleam, and Will feels suddenly a little cold, despite still wearing his jacket. "This is my final gift to you, Will."

 

***

 

Alana's phone call takes Jack by surprise, it's true, but he still feels relatively confident that Will is fine. Most likely he forgot, or fell asleep before he could call. It's happened before, after all.

He pulls up the car outside Will's hotel - the same one Will has been staying at for the past two weeks. It's not something Jack would have picked - too cold and drab for his tastes - but he knows Will has always preferred the simpler aspects of life.

Jack ponders this phrase as he enters the lobby. The simplest aspect of life, he supposes, must be the act of living itself. It's funny, really, how something so simple can be so hard. How something so easy can hurt so much.

The receptionist is bored. She has blonde hair and is painting her nails a bright, bubblegum pink, a small crease marring the acre of skin between her perfectly waxed eyebrows. She looks up dully as Jack approaches the desk.

"Can I help you?" she recites in a practiced monotone, still somehow managing to continue painting her nails. Jack is almost impressed.

"I'm looking for a friend," he says. "Has Will Graham returned to his room today?"

Looking irritated, she abandons her nails in order to drill the commands into her computer. "No, sir," she tells him. "Mr. Graham's door hasn't been unlocked since ten-thirty this morning."

Jack feels dread dig into his stomach, and guilt swamps him yet again. He wills his body to calm down as his adrenalin level begins to spike.

"Thank you," he says to the receptionist, already turning away.

"No problem," she replies, resuming her nail-painting.

Jack wishes, not even close to the first time, that Beverly Katz was still alive. She knew Will so well. She could probably find him in a heartbeat. Not to mention that Jack has to go to Wolftrap, and he wishes he didn't have to go alone.

 

The snow is thick underfoot when Jack finally arrives outside Will's cabin in Wolftrap, Virginia. It has always been a desolate sort of place, but these days it looks sad and bedraggled; even pathetic. A nasty little voice in Jack's head points out that Will Graham and his house are just alike.

The first thing that Jack notices is Will's hire car, parked just in front of the porch. The engine and lights are off, and when Jack places an ungloved hand on the hood, it's cold to the touch. If Will's still here, then he hasn't touched it in hours.

The second thing he notices is that the front door is banging against the frame.

Jack's instantly on edge.

He pulls his gun from its holster and flicks on his flashlight, making his way cautiously up the steps. He's careful to avoid stepping in the clear footprints that are marked in both the snow and dust. He pushes through the door.

The third thing Jack notices is the cracked pair of glasses lying abandoned on the floor.

He fumbles for his phone. He doesn't bother checking for intruders; he knows they're long gone. Fear drops into his stomach like lead.

Jimmy Price answers the call. His voice is blurred with irritation.

"Hello?"

"I need forensics down here in Wolftrap, stat. Get the team on the case."

"Why, what happened?"

Jack feels pure dread seal itself in his heart and bury itself there. It's trapped so deep he knows he'll need a shovel to dig it out.

"Will Graham is missing."

 

Jack paces feverishly for over an hour while he waits for backup to arrive. He feels like berating Will for choosing such a remote location for his hideaway.

To pass the time, he talks to himself, talks to the ghosts of Will that roam this sad excuse for a home. He calls Alana. She is duly horrified. He alerts Molly. She is duly terrified. He tries to think of someone else to call, before realising that the only other person who would care if something happened to Will is a serial killer who Will threw off a cliff over three months ago.

This, to Jack, points to how seriously fucked up Will Graham's life is.

He tells Will this, as he watches the shadow of him bend over a fishing fly. The Will of his memories gives a little laugh, but then Jack realises that all of Will's laughs sound forced. So he stops soon after.

Eventually, the convoy of vehicles march like ants in formation through the woods and fields surrounding Will's cabin, right down to the driveway itself. The forensics team scurry out, eager to preserve the crime-scene while it's still relatively fresh.

Jack dislikes the idea of Will's house being labelled a crime-scene, if only because it makes his guilt rear its head once more.

He waits another hour, tense and on edge. At one point, he almost checks his pockets for aspirin, before he realises who he is acting like, and stops. Will is everywhere in this house, permeating every surface; it's like his ghostly presence is possessing all those who stand in its walls. Jack shivers.

"You ok, Jack?"

It's Jimmy Price, concern marring his features. It's not a good look on him. Jack prefers it when he's being sarcastic.

"Fine," Jack tells him. "What have we got?"

Price gestures for Jack to accompany him, and he does. They duck around bright wreaths of police tape and skirt morbidly cheerful yellow evidence markers, all the way to Will's front door. Brian Zeller is there, impatiently tapping his feet.

"You took your time," he says crossly to Price, who rolls his eyes.

"Who cares?" Price shrugs. "We're onto the good stuff now. Lead the way, hotpants."

They bustle to the porch, where the footprints are, thankfully, still partially visible.

"So Graham drives up the road, stops the car, gets out," Price narrates. "He climbs the porch steps, comes through the door. Doesn't bother to shut it, the lazy bastard. He keeps on walking, right? Stops in the centre of the room, right there."

They've reached the main room, where Will's footprints stop abruptly. Zeller continues.

"Our attacker doesn't come in through the front door; he drives around the back. Must have been a while ago, now - there aren't any tyre tracks to show that he arrived recently. We reckon he's been living upstairs."

"Can we get to the point?" Jack growls impatiently.

"Uh, yeah. Sorry." Price looks almost a little embarrassed. "Ok, so the attacker sneaks up behind Graham - musta been real quiet, these floors creak like hell - then grabs him..."

"...and puts the chloroform to his face - see that puddle over there. And Graham struggles, his glasses fly off, then land right there on the boards. The attacker -"

"- must be pretty tall, at least three inches taller than Graham. See these scuffs in the dust? That's where Graham's toes must have scraped the floor when he was struggling. Anyway -"

"- the attacker waits until Graham's out before pulling him away. Drags him through the dust and round to the back door...mind your step there, Jack...through the snow, and puts him in a car. We know it was the passenger seat -"

"- because of the relation of where the drag marks end and the placement of the wheel indentations. So then the attacker gets in - without bothering to tidy up, mind you - then drives off without a word."

Price stops his verbal tirade in order to get his breath back, but Zeller gallantly steps in to finish it off.

"He must know his way around here pretty well to be able to pull off a stunt like that, Jack. He managed to sneak up behind Graham without making a sound, which ain't easy to do. I know he's been in hospital and all, but Graham's still the twitchiest guy I ever met, hands down. Anyone who could sneak up on him would have to be -"

"You say the attacker was male," Jack interrupts. "Why?"

"Shoe size," Price says smugly, "and height, not to mention strength. Added together, I think it's safe to assume -"

"When you assume, Jimmy, you make an 'ass out of u and me'. You ever hear that expression?"

Price shrugs. "Balance of probability."

Jack resists the urge to sigh. "Stay here. Try to get anything from upstairs - see if the attacker left prints behind. I need to get back to my office."

Price and Zeller nod. Jack turns and strides for the door, collecting members of his team as he goes.

Yes, he thinks: the simplest part of life is living, but it's also the hardest.

 

***

 

Despite the stress of suddenly waking up in a car after being drugged by Hannibal Lecter, the gentle hum of tyres against the road ends up lulling Will into a light doze. He feels far more relaxed than he ought to in Hannibal's company.

Hannibal, meanwhile, drives serenely onwards, making even life on the road look elegant.

He's not wearing one of his usual suits, which even now Will manages to find jarring. Without the usual three-piece, he seems somehow even more powerful; the tightly-cut fabric of his jumper easily accentuates the thick muscle that Will can't believe he never noticed before. When you want to believe hard enough, he supposes, you end up doing so.

They've been driving two hours when Hannibal pulls into a lonely gas station. The night is starting to set in, and it is bitterly cold. The moon hangs fat and full in the star-filled sky.

Hannibal climbs out of the car, and Will winces as the cold air cuts across his face. Temperature change still makes his cheek ache.

"What are you doing?" he asks, his voice sounding a little cracked.

"One moment," Hannibal says, and then he shuts the door.

Will sits still in his own seat for the moment, hampered by the handcuff around his wrist. He debates opening his own door for a moment, then jumps as Hannibal does it for him. The gleam in Hannibal's eyes when he sees Will startle reminds Will of that of a fox.

"Come," Hannibal says, unlocking the handcuff from the door. "It is time we put on a little show."

Will barely has time to relish his taste of freedom before Hannibal clicks the empty cuff over his left wrist, binding his hands together. He is about to protest and ask what Hannibal means by a show, when he suddenly feels the ice-cold butt of a pistol at his temple, and the words die in his mouth.

"This way," Hannibal announces, exerting quiet but firm pressure on the gun, and Will has no choice but to follow.

The gas station is deserted at this hour. Oddly, even the small store inside is empty, despite the lights inside blazing brightly like a lighthouse before a storm. Perhaps the staff are in the back room. Will stumbles a little as they traverse the uneven Tarmac, but Hannibal's tight grip on his collar prevents him from falling.

The choice of a gun is unexpected. Guns are inelegant, distanced - their impersonal death seems almost rude with its bluntness. It's not the sort of weapon Will ever expected Hannibal to use. Hannibal's choice weapons are his scalpel, his hands, and his slick and buttery words.

Will's still pondering this as they near the empty store. It all seems so clumsy for Hannibal. If the doctor wants him dead, then he would have died the second they fell off that cliff. If Hannibal wants him spirited away somewhere, then Will has no doubt that they would have already arrived. No, if Hannibal Lecter is doing this the hard way, then Will has no doubt that he has some ulterior motive in mind.

This thought is both comforting and terrifying.

Guiding Will past the bright and empty store, Hannibal presses the gun into the back of his head. "Smile, Will," he says.

Will follows his gaze to the security camera fixed to the wall of the building. The red light blinking at them reminds Will a little of a large and ugly beetle.

The second Will locks eyes with the camera, he hears the click of the safety from the gun pressed to his skull. His breath catches. Fear drips into his features. Hannibal wouldn't shoot him. Surely he wouldn't bring Will all this way only to shoot him in the head in the dark. It's not exquisite enough for Hannibal, not as precise. Hannibal wouldn't shoot him, surely...

Hannibal, upon feeling Will freeze in terror, laughs quietly. "Fear not, Will. This is only a precaution. I would not want Uncle Jack to get the wrong idea about our little adventure."

He presses on, and Will, shaking now, stumbles forward on trembling legs.

Sweat begins to to gather on Will's skin as he and Hannibal clear the store. He begins to wonder if he was wrong before, about Hannibal not planning to shoot him. He's been wrong before. He hopes, though - more than ever - that for once he is entirely right about Hannibal Lecter.

Around the back of the store is another car, this one a modest dark blue with West Virginia plates. Hannibal opens the passenger door.

"You first," he says, amusement glittering in his eyes.

Will clambers awkwardly in, settling into his seat with a sigh of relief. Clearly, Hannibal has no intentions of killing him just yet.

After attaching Will's handcuffs to the door handle, Hannibal walks round to the driver's side, climbs in and starts the car.

"Where are we going?" Will asks, once he feels he can trust himself to speak again.

Hannibal gives him one of those smiles, sharp as a knife across his face. "You'll find out soon enough."

As they slip once more into the cover of night, Will wonders if he really wants to know.

 

***

 

Back at base, Jack gets his team onto CCTV footage. It's a long shot, but Jack figures that whoever kidnapped Will drove away in a car, and that means that sooner or later, they're going to need to stop for gas.

It's over an hour an a half before Jack gets a result - and he spends that drinking terrible coffee and tensely barking orders. It's one of his trainees, Ardelia Mapp, who finds it.

"Sir, I've got something," she calls. Immediately, she is surrounded by spectators.

"What's this?" Jack asks, squinting at the footage on the screen. The quality is good enough, but he has to peer past the reflection of himself on the screen to see the details.

"Footage from a gas station an two hour's drive from Will Graham's house, sir," she says. "It's from three hours ago."

"Well, come on, then, let's see it," says Jack impatiently, nerves ticking in his skull. Mapp clicks play.

For the first five seconds, the patch of Tarmac outside the gas station remains empty. Jack is about to tell Mapp to fast forward, but the words crumble to ashes in his mouth as the two figures come into view.

The taller person has his face obscured by shadow, but Jack can clearly see the cold glint of the gun barrel that he is pressing into the shorter figure's head. The smaller man in front stumbles more than once, but he doesn't fall, saved by the firm grip the man behind him has on his jacket collar. Jack notices, with a cold rush of unease, the bright flash of metal around the shorter man's wrists.

When the pair reach the middle, they slow, and the revolver guides the man in front's head around, enough to face the camera. The face is contorted with fear.

Ardelia Mapp pauses the feed, zooms in on the face of the man in front.

Jack knows that face.

His mouth is suddenly dry.

"Send a team out there," he orders no one in particular. "Mapp, you keep monitoring footage. I need to make a call."

 

***

 

Hannibal carefully eases the car around a wide-eyed deer as he drives steadily through the night. Will, in the passenger seat, has fallen asleep again. Hannibal is glad. Will Graham has always been far more pliable when relaxed.

The look of fright on Will's face when Hannibal drew the gun on him had been both surprising and gratifying. Perhaps a part - the smallest, most inconsequential part - of him feels a little guilty for unnecessarily scaring Will so badly, but another, stronger part revels in the power he can still exert over the empath. It's crude, but power still excites Hannibal almost as much as control.

In any case, Hannibal understands how power differentiates. He knows that it is not overly difficult to scare someone; it is in fact much harder to have the power to relax them in his presence.

He glances over at the sleeping form in the passenger seat. Will is gorgeous when trusting.

Sticky satisfaction settles in Hannibal's stomach as he admires the man next to him. Will's eyelids flutter as he dreams; no doubt his nightmares still have hold over him, even now. His dark curls are limp over his forehead. Hannibal notices, with a blend of amusement and distaste, that Will is still wearing that ridiculous aftershave, although it is mostly smothered by the pervasive scent of chloroform that still clings to him.

Will shifts and mutters a little, before relaxing once again. A magnificent creature, indeed.

Hannibal considers how simple it would be to kill the man next to him. He could do it kindly, tenderly; a quick snap of the neck, and it would be over. Or perhaps he could be indulgent: Will's blood looks wonderful on his pale skin, and Hannibal has always favoured knives. Or maybe even Hannibal could kill him lovingly, with his hands tight and precious against Will's long, slim neck; he could watch the light leave Will's eyes and soak it up into his own skin.

But no, Hannibal decides, he won't. Will has earned his freedom, and Hannibal intends to give it to him. Will has proved himself worthy of Hannibal's gift.

Even so, he wonders, briefly, what Will would look like dying. He wonders how he would feel. Triumphant? Perhaps. Sorrowful? Definitely. Although he would feel a sudden burst of euphoria, of power, it would soon be weighted with regret. Killing a creature such as Will would be like killing a stag: magnificent, exhilarating...and yet a terrible crime indeed.

What a waste it would be.

Hannibal steers himself and his charge swiftly through the slick black night. Outside the safety of their little island, it is cold and quiet and desolate. Beside him, to his satisfaction, Will sleeps quietly on.

Some people, he knows, believe that the simplest aspect of life is living itself, but Hannibal is not some people. What Hannibal knows beyond doubt is that the simplest aspect of life is not living, but dying.

Hannibal has never been one to take the easy route.