Chapter Text
PROLOGUE
When Will is woken up in the middle of the night and escorted to the infirmary by a smirking guard, at first he thinks nothing of it. It’s just another in a long line of unnecessary humiliations by doctors and nurses and guards who mock him for being caught and convicted for crimes he didn’t commit. He doesn’t even meet their eyes or try and talk to them anymore, since no one believes a word he says.
He’s not the Copycat Shrike, but no one here cares and the FBI is too busy patting themselves on the back to notice the discrepancies or check out Will’s alibi.
Still, he is aware enough to realize that whatever the doctor gives him is definitely not anesthesia, but by then the paralyzing agent is too strong for him to do anything but blink, and Will can’t even scream when the doctor slices into his throat.
He passes out from the pain, and he wakes up to the grim sight of Jack Crawford at his bedside.
“The judge overturned the verdict,” Jack says the second he sees Will’s eyes open. “You’re free to go, as all charges have been dropped. And . . . And the doctor who did this will be charged, I promise.”
Will wants to ask what the doctor did, but deep down, he already knows.
Will never does speak again, and although the doctors at the hospital press him for surgery and therapy, he just shakes his head and takes up using the tablet and voice app. It’s like anyone listened to him when his vocal cords worked anyways, so there’s really no reason to try and fix them. And besides, Will has plans that involve never talking to anyone ever again in the future, so, again, no reason to try and fix them.
The FBI pays him an embarrassingly large settlement for the wrongful conviction, wrongful imprisonment, the way his name is smeared in the press, and the way the doctor who thought he was the Copycat illegally paid off the guards to destroy Will’s vocal cords and scar his neck. Will takes the money with a smile, closes his house, and moves everyone and everything down to Florida.
His favorite moment is when he disconnects his cellphone and leaves it behind on the floor.
Will Graham is done with the FBI, he tells himself, and Jack Crawford can scream and bluster all he likes. He can find a new scapegoat now, because Will is done.
Will finds that he likes life in Florida. He buys a little house and a large plot of land where his nearest neighbors are two hours’ drive away, and his dogs are ecstatic at the warm weather, the new places to explore and dig, and the way Will has so much more time to play with them. Will fishes in the rivers, constructs his own plot of vegetables for his garden, and passes his time happily oblivious to the goings of the outer world. His only concession is a monthly stop at the local farmer’s market to purchase what he can’t make for him or his dogs, and he strikes up a relatively good understanding with the people there. They don’t say anything about how he communicates via tablet and voice app, and he pays them well for their products and their services.
The only one he regards with a small amount of affectation is a woman named Molly, who has a son named Walter who adores Will’s dogs and doesn’t care that Will himself doesn’t speak.
The only downside is that she insists that he needs to get out more to practice his slow progress at learning sign language, and although he avoids most of her suggestions due to the impracticability of a four hour drive just to mingle and be social, eventually he does cave into to one particularly interesting suggestion.
“It’ll be fun,” Molly insists, waving the flyer at him. “Pumpkin carving, Will, you love pumpkins.”
Will’s tablet speaks for him. “I’d rather stay out in my house in the woods, thanks.”
“You’re already signed up.”
Will’s mouth moves, and he winces at the pain. Sometimes, he still forgets that he’s like Ariel; no voice and invisible among the sea of normal humans, but the memory remains.
“What possessed you to do that?” Will asks finally.
“You,” Molly declares, “you need to socialize, Will, I swear to god you’re becoming like a hermit vampire out there. You’re wearing a scarf in October, it’s unnatural. You act like sunlight is going to burn you.”
“Are you going to come with me?”
“No, Walter wants to go to a haunted house. He’s dressing up as a werewolf this time.”
Will nods, because he already knows. He helped construct the costume, even though some of the tears aren’t quite as they intended because Buster got into the cloth and took a few exploratory bites. It’s a ritual in Walter and Molly’s house, to dress up and seek out candy by going trick or treating on haunted trails and haunted houses, to spend time together as the family they are, and Will doesn’t begrudge them that.
He still doesn’t want to go to a pumpkin carving class though.
Still, after much pressure from Molly and begging from Walter, Will caves.
He later regrets this when he realizes that it is a couples’ pumpkin carving class, and in a haunted mansion to boot.
Will finds out when a tall man in a three piece suit steps and heads straight for Will, offering his hand and saying, “Molly told me you would be wearing a scarf. I assume you are Will?”
Will looks from his hand to his pristine leather shoes, his waistcoat, his elegantly knotted tie, and his stupidly attractive face and promptly curses Molly in the deep dark corners of his mind. In another life, Will might’ve found this man attractive and maybe might even have mustered up the courage to talk to him, but right now, with no voice and sweating under the protective layers of his scarves, Will feels more like the man is a zombie stealing his brain or perhaps a demon or witch to steal away his voice and ability to think straight.
“Vampire stole your tongue?”
It’s awkward, but Will manages to fish out his tablet and laboriously type out his message. The man’s face lights up with understanding, but strangely, Will feels no pressure or impatience. He simply waits for Will to finish and gives every appearance of understanding and eagerness to hear what Will has to say.
“I thought the saying was ‘cat stole your tongue’.”
The man smiles. “I thought the substitution was appropriate for a pumpkin carving class, given how many vampires decorate the hallways.”
“I hate to break it to you, but those are just jack’o’lanterns with badly carved sharp teeth.”
“Including the one with the scythe?”
“I think it’s meant to be an artistic interpretation of a witch’s hat.”
“Well, I am glad to have you as my guide,” the man says with a small smile. It’s small because it hardly changes the man’s face, but he also strikes Will as a rather controlled man who doesn’t express things willy-nilly, and Will finds himself grateful for that. Part of the reason he lives like a hermit is to avoid other people and the way their emotions spill over into Will, after all.
“Hannibal Lecter.”
“Will Graham. Think you already knew that though.”
“I did, but it is still nice to meet you.”
The class gets off to a relatively warm start. The instructor is full of humor and great at giving good tips, and Hannibal is an easy person to work with. Will picks something simple and copies one of the tarot cards the instructor passes out that has easy outlines to follow, whilst Hannibal goes off on some masterpiece of something he calls a wendigo.
“You’re drawing a supernatural cannibalistic creature?”
“Is that not appropriate for a full moon?”
“You’re thinking of a werewolf.”
“Ah, my apologies.” Hannibal scans his half-completed wendigo, which has frightfully good antlers that twist and arch along the top of the pumpkin. He hasn’t gotten to the face yet, but Will has a feeling that it will turn out marvelous all the same.
Will is about to reply when someone bumps into their tablet, causing Will’s knife and his table to fall to the floor and erasing his message.
“Sorry, freak, didn’t mean to scare you,” the man says, smirking, as Will emerges from the floor with his cheeks flushed.
Hannibal doesn’t move or even twitch, but Will shies away from him all the same. Something about the cold look in his eyes is hair raising in a way that makes Will think dark thoughts, like water welling up from the deep and swallowing trespassers who tread on deceptively thin layers of ice. It’s a revelation and a tease all at once, and it makes Will want to back away to demonstrate that he is not prey and bare his throat to such a powerful predator, two conflicting desires that make him freeze in his tracks.
Hannibal leans close, touching Will along the shoulder. “Are you all right, my darling?”
Will, in his panic, forgets the table and merely taps out Morse code and half-remembered signs into Hannibal’s side, but Hannibal takes it in stride.
“This man was just about to apologize to you,” Hannibal says.
“Jesus, no need to get worked up.”
“This is the night of devils, not the son of God.”
The man turns his gaze on Will, and it’s like being scraped with sandpaper, rudeness and sadistic glee a painful slap along his senses. “Where’d you dig this one up, freak? I thought the devils only came out at witching hour.”
It’s like a backwards masquerade, where Will can feel all of his masks sliding off, Hannibal tense and fierce at his side and this man completely uncaring, revealing all of Will’s insecurities and fears to the world so that it can clamor at his strangeness, and he’s caught like a bug under a microscope, pinned and helpless and dissected for all to see.
“That is enough,” Hannibal says quietly.
Bye, Will signs quickly, because he can see the instructor heading over with a frown and he knows this isn’t going to end well and he really wishes he could’ve ended things better but right now all he wants are is dogs, his bed, and silence, so he hopes Molly will forgive him for ruining what was a nice blind date when he abruptly stands and rushes out, heading straight for his car like Cinderella fleeing the ball.
He doesn’t let himself think past that analogy, because although Hannibal is as fancy and dressed up as any Prince Charming, he doubts he’ll ever see the man again.
Will is woken up the next morning by his door being practically kicked through and his dogs causing a ruckus. When he finally gets to the door, he has one minute to comprehend that Jack Crawford is at his door before the man shoves a newspaper in his face.
The headline says it all. KILLER STRIKES AGAIN, DUBBED “JACK’O’LANTERN KILLER”
“I need an alibi,” Jack tells him. “We found blood on your door.”
Will gives him a look and fetches his tablet. “It’s fake blood.”
“For what?”
“For a séance recreation of Ghostbusters,” Will types out, and he wishes dearly for a sarcastic setting for his voice app, because everything just comes out as one tone and he can tell from Jack’s face that the sarcasm would not have been appreciated. “It’s almost Halloween, Jack, I was decorating for the trick-or-treaters.”
“That’s not an alibi. You’re coming with me.”
They leave Will with a blanket, a glass of water, and a coffee cup, and he’s there sitting in silence for a good half an hour before suddenly the door opens and Hannibal is coming in, along with a lady with a briefcase and followed by a cop who’s scrambling to keep up.
“Will,” Hannibal says, and Will’s so desperate for answers that he doesn’t flinch away when Hannibal touches his cheek, reverent and gentle.
“What are you doing here?” Will signs.
Hannibal’s eyes flicker, but apparently multilingual is another one of his many talents, because he smoothly replies, “I heard you needed an alibi.”
To the cop, Hannibal says, “I was with Will Graham all night long. The class did not end until midnight, well after your timeframe for when the victim was taken and displayed. You have no reason to detain him here like this and deprive him of the ability to reach out.”
“Suspects are not allowed to keep their tech on them, we need to examine it,” the cop blusters.
Hannibal shrugs off his overcoat and drapes it over Will’s shoulders, and Will blames the shiver that runs through him on the sudden warmth rather than the way Hannibal touches him, hands and fingers brushing along his shoulders, as he sits close by and draws Will into his arms like a guardian against the cold and police.
“Then complete your examination,” Hannibal says calmly. “You will find nothing.”
The cop tries to get more answers, but Hannibal and his lawyer stonewall them pretty effectively, so Will leaves them to it and simply curls up under the coat, grateful for the warmth.
“How did you find me?” Will signs.
Hannibal smiles wanly, but Will can feel his annoyance at the rudeness of the FBI. “You dropped your credit card in a leaf pile in your rush to leave. I thought to return it to you and instead found your house swarmed with dogs and officers.”
“Sorry.”
“It is not your fault. Besides, I had hoped to find you again. I would have liked to ask you something.”
“Like a date?”
“Your loss.”
Hannibal’s smile grows a little larger at that, and this time when he touches Will’s curls it’s less reverent and more fond, a familiar caress instead of a new one. “I think,” he says, “that you would enjoy going apple picking. I have found that it can be a calming activity.”
“ . . . What?”
The cops release Will and Hannibal shortly afterward, encouraged and badgered by Hannibal’s lawyer and refusal to admit guilt, and Hannibal’s glare is enough to keep even Jack Crawford at bay when he emerges and attempts to fail at apologizing yet again. Hannibal puts Will in his luxurious car, straps his seatbelt on, and then drives Will home, and Will doesn’t protest when he immediately starts fiddling in Will’s kitchen.
Finally, though, he has to ask, and at least now he has his tablet back.
“Why did you do that?”
Hannibal stirs calmly at whatever concoction he’s making. “Do what, Will?”
Will makes a face and switches to sign language. Better safe than sorry, if they’ve put any kind of tracking tech on Will’s tablet. Will can totally see Jack doing that, because he’s an arsehole, but he’s not devoid of common sense or good ideas from time to time.
“You lied. For me, I mean. I wasn’t there when the class ended.”
Hannibal puts down his spoon and looks at Will, and it’s like when he touched Will all over again, warmth in his gaze like the sun gazing down upon him. “You did not kill that man, Will, even though he was very rude to you.”
“You don’t know that.”
“But I do know you.”
“Do you?”
Hannibal smiles again, that strange wide smile that stands out on his normally smooth face, and when Will meets his gaze, he finds his breath scattered to the four winds. Will reads so many things in that strange, stupidly attractive face: smugness, fondness, adoration, confidence, joy, contentedness, and much more. Hannibal truly believes that he knows Will, and Will understands at once that once Hannibal makes up his mind, very little can possibly change it.
“Well,” Hannibal says, “I would like to.”
EPILOGUE
The truth comes out at the end of the month, when Hannibal throws an extravagant Halloween party and insists that Will attends. It is a costume party, of sorts, but Will flat out refuses to let Hannibal choose his costume because he’s seen Hannibal’s wardrobe and it is more terrifying to Will than anything else.
Hannibal, fortunately, is more amused by Will’s defiance than offended. “Do you truly think so little of me?” he asks.
“I’ve seen the kind of Halloween costumes people wear. I am not wearing any of those skanky things.”
“Very well. I leave the costume up to you.”
Will is very grateful for this when he runs smack into the same doctor who once wielded a knife over Will’s throat and stole his voice.
“Oh. It’s you.”
Will just holds his glass tight and wishes for Hannibal. Hannibal has an uncanny talent of popping up unexpectedly when Will needs him and guiding him out of terrible situations, yet right now he seems to be taking his damn sweet time, chatting and fake laughing with some of his psychiatrist friends.
“I won’t apologize,” the doctor says. “I don’t believe your claims to innocence.”
At that, Will loses it, and maybe something in his face tells the doctor because in a blink of an eye the doctor is halfway across the room and attempting to make excuses. Will, meanwhile, heads for the wine cellar, wishing for his dogs and his whisky.
“Will,” Hannibal says, when he finally shows up. “I apologize, I did not realize that I had invited the one who stole your voice.”
When Hannibal hugs him, Will lets the flood release, and he finds himself griping Hannibal so tightly that he’s sure to leave bruises where his fingers are pressing so desperately into his waist and shoulders, but he knows Hannibal won’t care. Hannibal enjoys it when Will becomes desperate for his touch and his guidance, he enjoys being the anchor in the ocean and the pillar in the storm, he enjoys the idea that Will, when unsettled, now comes to him first and his alcohol later. He is becoming Will’s world, and Hannibal enjoys it to an unsettling high degree.
“Don’t make the doctor into a pumpkin pie, please. It’ll make for a bad pie.”
Hannibal goes still, like a cat on the prowl with new information. “Whatever do you mean, my darling?”
“There are people in that pumpkin pie, isn’t there? I went through the records of the Chesapeake Ripper’s patterns. Three victims in such a short time period, and a dinner party afterwards to consume the evidence. You’re growing sloppy.”
“My dearest Will,” Hannibal says, low into Will’s neck, snuffling against his skin like a particularly pleased dog. Will would say he has a fondness for the way Will smells, but Will’s wearing copious amounts of cologne right now so he imagines that all Hannibal is smelling is more manufactured than real. The real sniffing happens at night, when Hannibal undresses Will and sniffs all over him to his heart’s content, gorging himself on the scent of Will whilst Will sleeps.
“Why me?” Will asks, because really, why Will? Hannibal could literally have anyone, and he chose the man who can’t speak, has seven mangy dogs, and is generally covered in sweat, engine oil, and fur.
Hannibal’s eyes flash, and for a second, Will imagines great bloody antlers emerging from his forehead, black and red like ash and blood, to match the claws of his fingers.
“A wendigo,” Hannibal murmurs, “imprints by scent. I knew you were mine from the first breath I took in your presence.”
“Weirdo,” Will signs into Hannibal’s back.
“Your scent says that you find it more charming than annoying.”
“I still want a normal people-free pumpkin pie.”
“When all our guests are gone,” Hannibal promises. “I will bake you the best pumpkin pie that you have ever tasted with the freshest ingredients I have on hand.”
Will smiles in return then, because when Hannibal promises, he more than delivers. For example, he’d promised Will to have a place for his dogs to stay when Will started living more frequently at Will’s house, and that “place” had turned out to be a fully built and furnished shed, with indoor heating and toys and a pantry to make his homemade dog food. And that doesn’t even cover the car Hannibal bought, the clothes Hannibal tailored for him, or the many gifts Hannibal has lavished upon him, like he thinks that he needs to remind Will constantly of the fact that he wants to put a ring on his finger and announce their relationship to the whole wide world.
Will’s holding off on the ring for now. He wants to find the perfect one for Hannibal before he “lets” Hannibal talk him into marriage.
But that’s neither here nor there.
Right now, Will has Hannibal, he has his dogs, and he has a party to enjoy.
“Happy Halloween, Hannibal,” Will signs.
Hannibal kisses him, sweet and soft like the person-suit-wearing monster he is. “Happy Halloween, my Will.”
FINIS
