Actions

Work Header

When We Belonged to the Sea

Chapter 5: Hello Again

Chapter Text

Food was his primary motivator when he woke the next day. A lack of supplies remained his biggest problem, but fortunately he still had his knife on him when he went into the water as any good sailor would. Will used it to fashion a crude spear and waded out into the shallows to catch breakfast. There were large formations of rock and coral all over this cove, which provide excellent shelter for all manner of sea creatures. It was an All-You-Can-Eat buffet for the experienced fisherman. Fishing was never easy. Spear fishing was even worse, but Will was a good fisherman and he'd done this before during other stints in the field. It still took him a few hours before he came up with a good, clean kill. Like all things, this would require some practice.

As Will lifted the dying fish, he noticed a pair of black eyes staring at him above the waterline and a few car lengths away. At this distance they looked matte black like a doll's eyes, and that wasn't the only difference. They...felt different too, more predatory. His skin began to itch as some primordial warning system triggered the alarm. Will backed out of the slowly water keeping a careful eye on the creature. Once he had broken free of the surf, the merman dipped beneath the surface and was not seen again for the rest of the day.

The next morning, Will went down to the shore with his spear and discovered that he had an audience. The merman sat on top of an exposed rock in the middle of the cove. His eyes and fin were dazzling under the midmorning sun, and gone was the menacing feeling from the day before. He waved to Will until Will waved back and then settled in to watch the show.

Will was so nervous about being watched that he kept missing his target. After each failure, the merman made an odd clicking sound in his throat, which Will suspected might be laughter. In fact, he become certain of it after the creature fell off his rock during one such fit.

But when Will finally caught a fish, the merman clapped excitedly and with sincerity. Feeling both proud and more confident, he caught the second fish of the day more easily to a similarly warm reception.

The creature slipped into the water at that point. The ocean was eerily calm today, and the surface of the cove was like glass. Will could tell that the merman was swimming towards him because of the ripples the creature left in his wake. Will opted for caution again and backed out of the water where he lacked the advantage.

The merman followed him and dragged himself onto the beach with an alarming amount of ease.

'So much for that advantage,' Will thought. Sea lions were particularly agile on land and could run faster than some humans.

Will sat down opposite the creature, but kept his spear close at hand. "Hello again."

The merman said nothing and barely moved except to breathe.

"I'm pretty bad at this aren't I?"

The merman nodded and clicked his tongue twice.

'Is that a yes or chuckle?' Will wondered. Probably both. Geez, what a critic. "I got better," he grumbled and was pleased when the merman nodded his agreement without the tongue clicking this time.

Will still wasn’t sure why the merman understood English so well. He knew that didn't make a bit of sense, but he wasn't going to look a gift horse in the mouth. He was talking to a goddamn mermaid after all. Logic was relative when dealing with the illogical. "My name is Will. Do you have a name?"

The merman looked contemplative then his eyes widened like this was the first time he'd ever considered the question. He shook his head and drew his fin up to his chest like a child hugging his knees.

Will felt a little guilty. He’d clearly made the creature sad, but how was he supposed to know that merfolk didn’t have names!? He scratched his head unsure of how to proceed. He was a biologist and much more comfortable working in a lab with non-sentient fish; however, he couldn’t keep thinking of this creature as just another animal or experiment. It seemed wrong and undignified. "I...could...give you a name. If you wanted one," he offered.

The merman perked up. He rocked forward and leaned into Will's space. Their faces were only two hands apart now.

“Hey! Hey, give me a minute, will you?," Will said and put his palm against the merman's shoulder. Gently he pushed the creature away. "Let me get some wood. and I’ll think of something while I'm away. You'll stay here? We can cook this fish afterwards. I’m happy to share."

A glint of menacing hunger passed through the merman’s molten eyes.

“Or we could eat first!” he quickly amended.

The merman made a pleased rumble in response.

...

The merman was not where Will left him when he returned, but he was not far off either.  Will spotted him playing in the waves just offshore.

Hel started his fire and cooked the fish. When the meat began to sizzle and char, the merman swam to shore and joined him.

Will gave him one fish and took the other for himself. The fish was bland, but it was still food. Will wolfed his down greedily and was picking bones out of his teeth while the merman continued to munch away at his slowly. Will noticed that he was very careful to hold his hand over his mouth as he chewed. Will didn’t want to give offense, but it was almost impossible not to laugh. Who knew merfolk held table manners in such high regard?

On the plus side, this gave Will more time to think up a name. He knew only something kingly would do, but Charles and Edward both seemed so pedestrian.

After plucking out the fish's eyeballs and popping them into his mouth like grapes, the merman focused his attention on Will with a serious but curious look. ‘Time’s up,’ his posture said.

"Okay, what do you think about Louis?" Will asked hesitantly.

The merman shook his head and made a face.

Charlemagne, Richard, Alexander, Tamerlane, Genghis, and Caesar were also rejected in short order. The situation was getting dire now. Will was a marine biologist not a historian. He was rapidly running out of princes and conquerors.

"How about Hannibal?" something clicked into place as soon as he said like popping your ears on an airplane to relieve the pressure.

The merman chewed on that one for a long time, but did not immediately reject it outright as he had with the others.

"Do you like that one?"

His merman finally nodded enthusiastically.

"Okay. It's nice to meet you, Hannibal,” Will said and extended his hand in greeting.

The next half-hour was spent trying to explain handshakes.

…

Days turn into weeks. Will knew the island better now, and knew that he was pretty much fucked. Hannibal had helped him to recover a lot of necessary things: a pot to boil water in, spare knives, empty plastic bottles, but he was never able to find the ship’s radio. Will assumed that Hannibal was bringing these things up from the wreckage of the ship and that sharks had gotten to his shipmates; however, Hannibal was obnoxiously unhelpful when it came to the location of the Ariadne. When Will asked him, Hannibal shrugged and merely pointed at the sea so Will had simply stopped asking. It was easier to describe what he needed and let Hannibal fetch it for him.

"I should have named you, Fido" Will joked one day.  It was three days before Will saw Hannibal again.

Will spelled out an S.O.S. in the sand with rocks, but no rescue planes came nor were any ships ever spotted on the horizon. There was no way around it: this island was going to be home for the foreseeable future. At least he had the world’s best research project to keep him busy.

Hannibal's latest hobby was mimicking Will's words and sentences, which improved their non-verbal communication as Will likewise learned to read Hannibal's lips and recognize his range of merchirps for the various emotions they represented. Hannibal tried to make the same shapes with his mouth even though he couldn’t produce the sounds, but this had led to one very unpleasant discovery. Hannibal had teeth—razor sharp, triangular teeth meant for biting and ripping through flesh.

Will suspected Hannibal had not meant to reveal this. The merman had been so careful when they ate together; however, since the revelation, his eating habits had changed drastically too. Hannibal no longer pretended to like cooked fish. When they ate together, Hannibal ate his fish raw. His table manners had vanished overnight too. Now, Hannibal made a point of showing his teeth to Will as he ate. It was unsettling to watch, but Will had learned not to react since he couldn't be sure what Hannibal's angle was with this peacocking.

Otherwise, life was oddly normal—considering that he was marooned on an island with a fairytale. Will spent most of his day hunting and fishing. The rest of his time was given to his studies of Hannibal and the local fauna, which mostly consisted of small birds and Humbolt penguins. Will liked the penguins and had named them all. They reminded him of his dogs, whom he probably wasn’t going to ever see again. In actuality, they were nothing like his dogs. His little family of strays were wild, unfriendly, and avoidant of Will's presence, but the were here and the dogs were not. The penguins were something to care about and Will needed the the distraction, needed it desperately.

It was dangerous to think of his own misery for too long.