Chapter Text
Bilbo slept. It wasn’t the most comfortable position, crammed into the passenger seat of a rather clanky old car, but the stress of the past few weeks had worn him down. Now that he was not alone, it seemed the most natural thing in the world to just sleep, and let Thorin do the driving. From the back seat, the mingled soft breathing of the lads provided a restful background noise, and he let himself slip away with images of bright headlights on a darkened road pouring through his mind.
He woke again when they stopped, deeply confused. Thorin was climbing out of the car, and Bilbo saw that they were at a roadside pulloff, lit only by the headlights of a few scattered vehicles. He rubbed his eyes blearily.
“Where are we?” he asked, hearing the lads stir in the back.
“Doune, I think?” Kíli yawned. Bilbo glanced back at the two, who hadn’t bothered to untangle themselves from one another, collapsed in a heap of tired limbs and contrasting bright and dark hair. “Thorin’s got to figure out where Gandalf means for us to go.” Bilbo peered out the window, to see that Thorin was borrowing a mobile from Nori and stabbing deliberately at the buttons, sweeping his hair back in annoyance as he held the mobile up to one ear.
“Are you both all right?” Bilbo asked, realising that they hadn’t exactly had any after-care instructions from Beorn for looking after Kíli, and while Fíli’s head seemed to be entirely back together, there was no way to be certain. They grinned rather goofily, looking at Bilbo half upside-down.
“We’re good, Uncle Bill,” Fíli said sleepily. His fingers were curled around the sleeve of the warm hoodie he’d forced over Kíli’s head. “Can’t ask for better than this.”
Bilbo rolled his eyes. “And how long are you going to keep up this Uncle Bill nonsense? I’m not your uncle!”
“You are now,” Kíli said, a hint of glee in his expression. “You’re stuck with us. ‘S how the family works.”
“You think Bifur and Bofur and Bombur were originally related to the rest of us?” Fíli asked, and Kíli actually giggled a little. “They were Thorin’s neighbors on the mountain, and sort of fell in with us after the burning.”
“And then we adopted them,” Kíli explained. Bilbo somehow got the feeling that the ‘we’ in that sentence meant Fíli and Kíli. “Like you.”
“You’ve adopted me?” Bilbo blinked at that. It shouldn’t have been such a surprise. He certainly felt a more than friendly attachment to them, and to the whole crew, and, if he was being honest with himself, he’d guiltily allowed himself to think of the family as somehow including him these days. But that was very different than having it stated so plainly. A lump rose in his throat, and he looked out at Thorin again.
“’Course we have,” Fíli said, and now Bilbo knew they were laughing at him as well as welcoming him. He nudged the back of Bilbo’s seat with a heavy boot. “We’ve all grown attached.”
“We won’t call you Uncle Bill if it bothers you, though,” Kíli said languidly, stretching out a little further, and shoving Fíli a bit more into the corner as he did so.
“No, it’s - that’s fine,” Bilbo said, feeling more than a little flustered. “Erm, that is - what will Thorin think?”
“That’s for Thorin to work out,” Fíli said, sounding quite satisfied with himself. “Can you see him, by the way? What’s he doing?”
Bilbo peered out into the gloom. “Standing very still and glaring at the mobile,” he reported. The lads gave a simultaneous hiss of discontent.
“That’s not good,” Kíli said soberly. “He’s angry. Tell us when he throws it?”
Bilbo watched for a minute, and then nodded. “He’s just tossed it to Dwalin very hard. Coming back here now.”
“We’re asleep!” Fíli hissed, and in an instant, they were both peacefully settled on the back bench, soft, even breathing filling the car again. Bilbo rolled his eyes.
Thorin wrenched the door open and threw himself inside, clearly very angry indeed, and Bilbo let him have a moment of quiet while he got the car in gear and started back up the A84.
“So where is it we’re going, then?” Bilbo finally asked. Thorin’s fingers tightened on the wheel.
“Glen Etive,” he snarled.
“And that’s a problem?” Bilbo inquired mildly. Thorin shook his head a fraction.
“It’s who we’re going to see that’s a problem,” he said roughly. “That cantankerous old fool has found us a place to stay and rest for a while.”
“But surely that’s a good thing?”
“The problem is the person who is meant to be our host.” Thorin seethed quietly for a minute, and Bilbo could almost hear his teeth grinding. “Elrond was the leader of the police force that came with Smaug on the day he took our home. He watched us taken from our homes, our lives ruined, the houses we had grown up in burning - and he did nothing. He and his men held us back, and threatened us with worse if we resisted.”
Bilbo’s eyes were wide, and he stared at Thorin in disbelief. “And this is the man Gandalf has found to give us shelter?”
“Gandalf says that Elrond did not know the truth. That he has learned it now, and he wishes to help us to make up for what he did.” Thorin shook his head grimly. “I don’t want to accept a crumb of his courtesy, Bilbo.”
Bilbo blew out a slow breath, thinking hard. “Glen Etive, you say? I thought there was nothing there!”
“Almost nothing,” Thorin corrected. “It’s one of the most remote places I’ve known.”
“That’s a good thing,” Bilbo said gently. “I understand why you don’t want to accept anything from him, but to get a bit of peace, a bit of time when we can stop running and just think for a while - I think it’s what we need.”
“I know it is,” Thorin muttered. “I don’t have to like it, though.” He glanced in his rear-view mirror, adjusting it for a moment so he could sneak a look at his nephews. “I’m not going to commit to anything until I’m sure we’re all fit and ready.”
Bilbo glanced back at the boys as well, faking sleep with the skill of the truly professional liar, and a spark of mischief awoke in him. There had to be some sort of payback for the trick they’d pulled on him and Thorin, after all.
“These two must have kept you busy, growing up,” he said offhandedly, offering Thorin a crooked little grin when the man glanced at him in surprise at the change of topic. “You must have loads of stories to tell.” He raised an eyebrow, and the answering smile that tugged at the corners of Thorin’s mouth was worth a thousand words.
“Well,” Thorin said, slumping back in his seat a little more comfortably, “there was the time that Fíli dressed Kíli up as a little girl when we first moved to a new place. I spent six months trying to figure out how to accept compliments on my lovely little daughter.”
Bilbo nearly choked, turning it into a cough of laughter that seemed to want to tear its way out of his chest. “Oh, that must have been precious!”
“He really was quite lovely,” Thorin said, a wicked edge to his own chuckle. “Of course, then Kíli got offended and went and chopped off all his own hair so the mistake wouldn’t be made again, and then Fíli simply had to do the same, so his brother wouldn’t be maimed alone.” He frowned thoughtfully. “I’ve pictures somewhere - remind me to dig them out some day.” Bilbo agreed, snorting with laughter - but there was a warmth in his chest that wouldn’t quite go away at the idea that Thorin expected he would be around to look at their baby pictures on some random day in the future. It felt a lot like something real.
The dam on Thorin’s memories seemed to have been broken, and he talked on and on in a low, rumbling voice as they crept along the shores of Loch Lubnaig and into the wilder woods beyond, their headlights mingling with those of the rest of the family as they traveled together. Thorin told him stories of Dwalin trying to teach the lads their basic maths, and why that had been the worst idea ever, and how Ori had insisted on sending them horrible hand-knit jumpers until they were both in their teens. In return, he shared a few stories of working in the shop with his father as a lad, and about his brief time at uni before his father’s death had brought him home, and Thorin seemed to almost revel in the simple domesticity of the tales.
By the time they were passing Crianlarich, the dawn was beginning to break, and the fake-sleepy sounds from the back of the car had shifted into genuine snores. Bilbo shook his head at the sight of the lads, curled together like puppies in a litter, and Thorin raised an inquisitive eyebrow.
“It’s not my place,” Bilbo said quietly, “but - do you worry about them at all?”
“All the time,” Thorin muttered. Bilbo shook his head.
“I don’t mean just safety and keeping them out of prison and whatnot. I mean, what about the future?” He gestured vaguely to where their hands were twisted around one another’s sleeves, even in sleep. “I’m not sure I’ve ever seen two people so unable to be apart. And things like jobs and stable relationships - how does that work?”
Thorin sighed. “I don’t know. Honestly I don’t. We haven’t done much to make them fit in with normal society, I know, but the struggle has always been just to keep them safe.” He glanced back at them again, and Bilbo could see the lines that worry had etched into his face. “We lost them once, right after my sister passed away. They were taken into care, and put in separate homes because we were considered such a threat. Three weeks it took us to steal them back, and I wasn’t sure they would ever stop clinging to one another after that.”
“That’s horrible,” Bilbo said quietly. “Do they remember?”
“Fíli does. Kíli was just four, and not even speaking properly yet. I’ve never heard him mention it since.”
The statement hung in the air for a while, and Bilbo watched the light grow in the sky as they sped past Tyndrum and up toward the wild desolation of Rannoch Moor. Finally, Thorin shifted a bit in his seat, and glanced sideways at Bilbo.
“Tell me, Mr. Burglar, what is it precisely that’s made you take up with our ragged crew? I mean no offense, but I didn’t quite think to see you again after we were arrested.”
Bilbo raised his eyebrows. “Didn’t I say I’d help? I wasn’t about to leave you then!”
“You had a chance to go back,” Thorin said heavily. “You weren’t associated with us. You could have gone home and opened up your shop and gone on with your life. I don’t understand why you didn’t.”
“I’m not sure I understand it, either,” Bilbo told him soberly. “It was just that I couldn’t do it. I couldn’t leave you all there, not while there was a chance I could help.” He laughed a little. “My mother always accused me of acting before I thought, and now that seems to have gotten me adopted into your little family.”
“Yes,” Thorin said dryly. “Uncle Bill now, isn’t it?” Bilbo shook his head despairingly, and Thorin snorted. “You should have seen Bofur the day Kíli declared him family. I thought the poor man would weep.”
They drove on, across the moor, and now Bilbo could make out the details of the other vehicles in their caravan. Dwalin and Bifur and Oin had managed to steal themselves new motorbikes that they drove proudly, though their shoulders were hunched with exhaustion. Dori, Nori, and Ori seemed to have jammed themselves into a tiny, bright yellow efficiency vehicle which trailed along at the back of the pack, while Bofur drove a solid little brown car with Gloin and Balin carefully packed inside. They made for a strange-looking company all together, and Bilbo was glad they would be hidden away in Elrond’s secluded home.
They turned onto a single track road near the large, dark mountain that Thorin told Bilbo was called the Buachille Etive Mor - the Great Herdsman of Etive. He knew it was a silly superstition, but Bilbo reached his fingers out toward the mountain, almost praying for a bit of luck. They could use a watchful shepherd about now.
The road wound down into the glen, empty on all sides of everything but rocks and wildlife. The mountains rose up on either side of them as they descended, and Bilbo watched the clear flowing river reflecting the cloudless blue of the sky with a shocking sense of peace. He saw a stag up one of the steep slopes, watching them curiously. As they descended into the peace of the glen, though, passing through a lovely wooded area as they approached Loch Etive, Thorin grew tense again. The softness that had appeared in his face while he and Bilbo were talking was gone now, replaced again by the stony leader he had met the first night of their acquaintance.
They came upon the house, perched high on the hill above the loch, nestled into the face of the rock itself. It was a large house, unexpectedly graceful, that seemed almost to have grown from the hills themselves. It looked out over the peaceful face of the water, giving clear views up and down the glen, and Bilbo let out a long, slow breath. He felt like he could stay here in this peaceful place forever. Thorin’s shoulders were tense, though, and he pulled up the gravel drive without a word.
Bilbo climbed out of the car slowly, stretching muscles made stiff and weary from the long ride. The air was warm and clear, smelling of nothing but green, growing things and the wind off the water. He was soon surrounded by sore, groaning men, most of them still clad in their prison jumpsuits.
“Welcome!” Gandalf’s voice carried clearly in the stillness, and Bilbo spun around to see that he had appeared in front of the house, arms spread wide as if to embrace them. “My friends. I am pleased to see you so well!”
“Easy for him to say,” Nori grumbled. “I don’t recall him being there in prison with us.” Thorin shot him a quelling glare, and stalked forward, Fíli and Kíli hurrying to stay in his wake.
“Gandalf,” he rumbled. Thorin was very clearly not pleased. “I did not expect to see you in a place like this.”
“You’d better leave your anger at the door,” Gandalf said firmly. “Elrond has offered his hospitality, and he was not obliged to do so.”
“Actually, I rather feel that I was.” The new voice was sure, but had the weight of age behind it. Bilbo peered behind Gandalf, where their new addition was making his way down the drive to join them. The man was tall and slim, dressed with a casual elegance that Bilbo almost coveted. His hair was dark and smooth, and he wore it like a crown. Thorin’s jaw tightened. “Thorin Oakenshield. I am glad to meet you under more pleasant circumstances.”
“You’ll forgive me if I am not so pleased,” Thorin growled. “I seem to recall you holding me back from my home as it burned, Elrond. I cannot forget as easily as some.”
Elrond dropped his head in a nod of acknowledgment. “We can discuss this later. For now, I offer my apologies for what passed between us. I only knew what Smaug had told us, and I acted on that bad information. I hope to make some sort of reparation now.” He gestured toward his home gracefully. “Welcome to Rivendell. My home is at your disposal, as long as you have need of it.”
The house was as comfortable and gracious inside as the exterior had suggested, and the large windows allowed for such light and air to flow through the home that Bilbo barely felt he was indoors. Elrond offered them copious amounts of food and drink, and showed them his numerous spare rooms, allowing them to distribute themselves through the house. The exhausted Sons of Durin were soon fed and showered, and sleeping anywhere they had found room, but Bilbo could not make himself rest. He wandered back to the front of the house, and found Gandalf and Elrond seated on the wide front porch, looking out over the loch. He joined them quietly, hoping he was not unwelcome, and Gandalf smiled at him with a genuine warmth.
“Bilbo Baggins. I had no doubt that you would succeed in rescuing them, but you did so with such a facility! I think we have stumbled on the hidden treasure of our age in you, young burglar!”
Bilbo smiled awkwardly. “I didn’t exactly ask for any of this, you know. I just wanted to help.”
“And so you have,” Elrond said gently. “I only hope Thorin will allow me to offer my help as well.”
“Look,” Bilbo said, suddenly curious. “You’ve both known them - or known about them, anyone - longer than I have. A month ago, I thought they were nothing but ruffians. Criminals. Now, I know they’re a lot more, but-” he trailed off, feeling disloyal even asking the question. Gandalf and Elrond exchanged a knowing glance.
“You want to know who they really are,” Gandalf surmised, and Bilbo nodded. The old man sighed. “That is a difficult question. Are they criminals? Yes. They have stolen and lied. They are complicit in fraud and any number of underground economies. I think you’ve seen how easily they help themselves to the things they need.” He gestured meaningfully at their fleet of stolen vehicles, and Bilbo swallowed. It was true. “But what that does not tell you is who the Sons of Durin are. They operate on a very strict moral code - Thorin’s, of course - and they do none of it for greed or for the desire to hurt others.”
“I believed what I was told by Smaug,” Elrond said quietly. “He said they were avaricious, only interested in destroying the land to reach the precious metals beneath. He told us they were dangerous, vicious animals. We did our jobs and removed them from their land, without questioning any of it. If you had seen Thorin that day, you might have understood.”
“But you don’t believe that anymore?” Bilbo pressed. Elrond shook his head slowly.
“No. It was Gandalf who found me and told me the truth, and I followed the evidence myself until I was convinced. I would not wish to live their life, but I now believe that they deserve nothing but our assistance, where we can offer it.”
Bilbo turned to Gandalf, burning with curiosity. “It’s always you, isn’t it? You brought them to me, you recruited Elrond. Who are you? What is your interest in them?”
Gandalf leaned back in his chair, eyeing him strangely, then gave a little laugh. “I suppose you do deserve to know. I’m a detective. I was hired to investigate the Sons of Durin, to see if they could be apprehended by nontraditional methods. I found out too much.”
“You don’t exactly look like Sherlock Holmes,” Bilbo pointed out dryly.
“Undercover, of course!” Gandalf protested, poking at his grey rags. “You might be surprised what a homeless old man can overhear that a police official cannot. When I had uncovered the truth about Thorin and his family, I went to him personally and offered my assistance in clearing their names and taking back their home. And that is where you come in.”
“You really think I can do something to help them?” Bilbo asked, leaning forward confidentially. “Me? I’m a grocer, Gandalf. I don’t have the first clue what I’m doing!”
“And yet how many times have you helped them already?” Gandalf countered. “Would they be safe and free today, if not for you? No, Bilbo, I have chosen the right man for the job.”
Bilbo was far from convinced, but the breeze was blowing over the surface of the loch, and the heather on the hills danced, and he let it slip away, turning his face up to the sun.
They stayed in Rivendell for far longer than Bilbo had expected, given Thorin’s objections - but Bilbo watched Thorin watching Fíli and Kíli scramble up and down the rocks, splashing in the clear water of the loch and laughing like children, and he understood. Bofur’s cheeks regained their color in the gentle sunshine, and Bifur found a warm, sunny spot of soft grass where he could lie and watch the clouds roll by, and he was content. Gloin was worried, calling home whenever he could, but as the days stretched on without pursuit for him or his wife and son, he let the fear slip away, and sat on the old wooden pier over the loch with his brother, fishing for things they never caught. The whole family seemed to uncurl, somehow, in that place, and their laughter lost a bit of its desperate edge. Bilbo thought sleepily to himself one day that this was who they were meant to be. This was who they might have been, living on their own mountain, free and happy on the land that had been their home for generations.
He found Thorin one evening while the family was mostly gathered around a massive fire in Elrond’s open sitting room, toasting things on sticks and sharing teasing memories and well-meaning jests. He was seated out on the hill in front of the house, staring up at the stars on a cloudless night. Bilbo had never seen the stars so bright and clear as they were in that place, and he slipped out to sit next to Thorin in silence, letting the man take in his presence wordlessly.
“This is a good place,” Thorin finally said, not looking at Bilbo. “I have not seen my family so well in two decades.”
Bilbo made a wordless sound of agreement, watching the stars, and watching Thorin. “Can’t stay here forever, though, can we?” he asked regretfully. Thorin shook his head.
“This is the way it goes, Bilbo,” he said quietly. “We find peace and happiness, and then we throw it away. Over and over, playing out the same story. We risk it all and lose it all, and we are left trying to hold ourselves together. It ends in blood and fear and fire. We are trapped in this cycle, and we cannot get out.” He looked down and over at Bilbo. “Can you understand this?”
“No,” Bilbo said honestly. He shrugged. “I’ve never believed in any of that. Just because it’s gone wrong once, or twice, or even a hundred times, it doesn’t mean it will always be that way.”
Thorin smiled up at the sky, wistful and hopeful, and somehow younger than Bilbo had ever seen him yet. They sat in silence, watching the stars take up their positions, and Bilbo knew this time of peace was coming to an end soon, but he couldn’t regret it - not in that moment.
