Chapter Text
11.
“Where is your Hobbit? Where is Bilbo?”
A shard of icy terror pieced my heart as Gandalf’s words washed over the company. A chorus of voices raised, but the muscles of my throat were paralyzed. I’d lost him. I’d left him to the Goblins. Dear Durin—then Nori’s voice rang out, and the ice turned into bile.
He’d slipped away.
Slipped. Away.
Bilbo abandoning the company when we were safe, in a dry cave in the mountain, sheltered and whole, especially after what I’d said to him—I could understand. But slipping away, leaving us purposely to our deaths. Just—turning his back on the company.
On Bofur, who I could tell he’d struck up an unlikely friendship with.
On Balin, who’d begun treating him as a caring grandfather.
On Bombur, who he laughed and shared recipes with over months of cook fires.
On Bifur, who used a few of his sparse words and gestures to teach him to sit a pony.
On Kili, who’d lept first into the fray to save him from the trolls.
On Oin, Gloin, Nori, Ori, Dori, Dwalin, and Fili. Even on Gandalf.
And on me. After he’d—even Thranduil had not—
“What happened? Tell me!” Gandalf’s fury, directed at Nori for telling of Bilbo’s escape, caught my attention, and I felt matching anger rise, a welcome relief from the pain of betrayal I hadn’t been prepared for. The words rose, bitter and pained, and I let them pour out.
“I’ll tell you what happened! Master Baggins saw his chance, and he took it! He’s thought of nothing but his soft bed and his warm hearth since first he stepped out of his door. We will not be seeing our Hobbit again. He is long gone.”
Silence fell like an iron curtain in the wake of my words. The company looking back and forth between themselves, uncomfortable and unsure. Even Gandalf seemed shaken. I bolstered my anger, grinding out tendrils of hurt like sparks under my boot heels. I opened my mouth to tell Dwalin to take the lead, to shake the dust of these woods from our feet, when a word stopped me. Froze me in my tracks.
“No. He isn’t.”
Bilbo.
Dimly, I heard Gandalf’s exclamation. Then Fili and Kili, asking how such a thing as his escape from the Goblins was possible. Rumbles of agreement for the question, and Gandalf protesting. None of it mattered. Underneath me, my legs felt strangely weak as I pushed forward. I didn’t understand. Had he left us? Or—
“It matters,” my voice was rough, and even though I couldn’t see my own face, I knew its expression must be raw, open in a way a true King’s never should. But I didn’t care. All I could see was the Halfling. “I want to know. Why did you come back?”
For a heartbeat, he looked defiant. Then kindness softened his face, and the corners of his lips lifted in a smile. It was strange, his expression. My memories of my mother were very dim, but something about the way he looked at me sparked them. It was a strange, useless thought, but it was there nonetheless. Before I could form another thought, the Hobbit answered. Although his words could have been directed to the entire company, I knew somehow they were just for me.
“I know you doubt me. I know you always have.” He paused and tilted his head ruefully. “You’re right. I often think of Bag End. I miss my books. My armchair. My garden. See, that’s where I belong. That’s home. That’s why I came back. Because you don’t have one—a home. It was taken from you. But I will help you take it back if I can.”
And then, he waited.
Words failed me.
Failed everyone, really, even Gandalf.
From a few steps to my right, Dori, never silent long, finally sucked in a breath and whispered low enough I barely heard him. “Sire, I think it best we welcome the burglar back to the company. He seems to mean what he—”
Before I could do anything else—be it answer the Halfling or shove Dori down the hill—I heard the snarl of wargs, and the glimmer of an Elvish blade caught my eye. In the distance, I saw a pack of Orcs crest the hill above us.
“Out of the frying pan.” I whispered, horrified.
“And into the fire. Run. Run!” Gandalf yelled.
And then we were flying down the side of the mountain. I let myself fall back slightly, keeping myself at the rear of the company. As we fled, my eyes locked on the Hobbit. He would not slip away again.
12. & 13.
I had failed.
Failed my father.
Failed my grandfather.
Failed my quest and my company.
Over the roaring of the fire surrounding us, I could hear the panicked cries of the brave dwarfs who’d put their trust in me. They were falling. There was nowhere to go, no help to be found. In front of me, Azoc’s face was a deformed mask. The enemy I’d thought defeated, the vengeance I’d thought won for my line. For a moment, I wondered at the cruelty of fate and thought, perhaps, I could understand how my father and grandfather had slipped into madness.
Injured already after the battle with the Goblins, I knew I could not defeat the Defiler. But I would not meet my end cowering. I would fall in battle.
I charged toward the pale Orc.
And failed again.
As my head slammed into the rock, I struggled to remain conscious. The blade kissed my throat. Writhing, dizzy and defeated, I still reached for my sword. Fight. Fight to the end. I was of the line of Durin—I—I could not—
For a moment, I didn’t understand what I was seeing, and then the sight of the Halfling throwing himself in front of my penetrated the haze. No! I wanted to scream. I wanted to curse and rage and force him back. I struggled again, pain like a lightning bolt of fire sliced through my skull, and everything went dark. A glimmer of something like thanks slipped past my escaping conscious—if this was how I had to leave this life, a part of me was glad the stubborn line of the Hobbit’s shoulders was the last thing I saw.
* * *
From the darkness, I felt myself called back. Gandalf’s voice was leading me, and I struggled to find it. And then. There. I had it. Like wind rushing through a tunnel, I threw myself up and into awareness. My eyes opened, bright light blinding me. Even before I truly could see, I heard myself rasping.
“The Halfling?”
Gandalf’s hand anchored me to rock, and I didn’t understand what was happening. But I didn’t care. All that mattered was the assurance in his tone when he said, “He’s alright. Bilbo is here. He’s quite safe.”
Something in my chest cracked. Pain. Weakness. Exhaustion. None of it mattered. I struggled to my feet, my eyes somehow drawn to exactly where the Halfling stood, small and alone and achingly brave on the wide ledge.
I moved toward him, my company once again forgotten. My failures. My quest. Everything forgotten.
“You,” I gasped, lingering terror and outrage that he would have put himself in such danger making my voice harsh. “What were you doing? You nearly got yourself killed. Did I not say to you that you would be a burden? That you would not survive in the wild? That you had no place amongst us?” I demanded trying to hold myself steady as I staggered forward.
Bilbo’s face was a mask, frozen, clearly willing to let me say whatever I would. I took another step, and then I was falling forward, the little Hobbit catching me as I drug him against my chest and wrapped my arms around him. For a moment, I let myself sag against him. I should be holding him, shaking him, demanding that he never act so foolishly again. But I wasn’t.
“I have never been so wrong in my life.”
Behind me, my company cheered at my words. Bilbo, though, said nothing. There was a flash of surprise, and then, the little Halfling held me. A prince of Dwarfs must never show weakness, but for one moment, I was content to let the little Hobbit do the unthinkable. I allowed myself the comfort of his arms for three heartbeats, then forced myself to straighten and the Halfling away from my body.
“I am sorry I doubted you.”
There was a hint of humor and irony in his reply. “Oh no. I would have doubted me, too. I’m not a hero. Or a warrior. Not even a burglar.”
Overhead, great eagles swooped through the sky, drawing my attention up, and for a moment, my heart stopped. I didn’t realize what I was doing until I stepped forward, wrapping my fingers around the Hobbit’s arm and pulling him around. It was—I wanted him to see. I wanted to show him. My home. But I couldn’t speak. Behind us the company crowded against my back almost as though the site caused them to need comfort, as well. Gandalf spoke, understanding without being told that for a moment, none of us could.
“Erebor. Last of the great Dwarf kingdoms of Middle Earth.” His powerful voice filled the air it was enough to help me find my own words.
“Our home.”
Bilbo was a pillar of quiet strength beside me. Then Oin said, excited, “Look! The bird’s are returning to the mountain.”
“That, my dear Oin, is a Thrush,” Gandalf replied.
In my breast, my heart clenched. “We’ll take it as a sign. A good omen.” I looked down at Bilbo. Excitement shown on his features.
“You’re right! I think the worst is behind us.”
There was a heartbeat, and then Gandalf’s grisled voice again. “That, Bilbo, remains to be seen. But for this night, at least, it is true. This is the Carrock, and Gwaihir, Lord of the Eagles, has given us leave to rest ourselves in his realm for the night.”
I felt Gandalf’s eyes on my face, waiting for my reaction. If he thought I was going to protest, he was wrong. But I also knew that my company would not settle themselves until I gave my agreement. Straightening my shoulders, nodded and forced myself to step away from the Halfling, settling the mantle of authority once more upon my shoulders.
“Good. Let us go down a bit, out of the wind.”
“A sound plan,” Gandalf nodded. “The falls of the Carrock are from the river Anudin and carry with them a measure of the healing powers of Rivendell.”
I tilted my head in agreement. “Then let us find a place to camp, and then we’ll tend to our wounds.”
Somehow in the course of the conversation, Bilbo had slipped from his place by my side. He was standing at the head of the stairs carved into the face of the rock, flanked on either side by Bombur and Bofur.
“Best to stay close to us, Master Baggins,” Bofur said. “These gusts of wind are strong enough to sweep you right over the edge of the stairs.”
I felt myself flinch forward. The wind would not carry away my Hobbit. I wouldn’t allow it. Before I could move to anchor him against me, Fili’s voice caught my attention. Beside him, Kili stood, eyes fixed firmly on the ground. “Thorin?” His tone was tentative in a way I’d rarely heard from the brash young dwarf. It was enough to distract me.
“Yes?” I replied, voice clipped, eyes trained on the Halfling as he and Bofur and Bombur started down, following Balin and Gandalf. The rest of the company moving in behind them, increasing the distance between Bilbo and I.
“I—just—”
“Spit it out, Fili,” I gestured impatiently. “I’m tired and thirsty. I’m not in the mood to dawdle.”
“K-Kili and I, we should have come to your aid. It was not—Master Baggins should not have done.”
For a moment, I was tempted to agree with them. Master Baggins should not have done, but neither should they feel guilt for his actions. Not yet 75 years old, they were adults it was true, but they were not yet truly dwarf men. My sister, Dis, had fretted them coming, but it was a choice they had a right to make. Afterall, I’d been only a few years older than they when Smaug came and when I’d followed my grandfather into battle at Moria. They had never known Erebor, but they’d grown up hearing tales of its beauty. They had as much right as any other dwarf to seek their ancestral home.
I blew out a heavy breath. “Both of you have acted with honor on this quest. You’re of the line of Durin, and every step we’ve taken, you’ve proven your mettle. Do not let regret weigh on your mind.”
Fili’s eyes dropped, and he studied the ground with Kili. This time, it was my other nephew who spoke. “It seemed as though—well—Bilbo, he stood between you and Azoc. He—protected you.”
I waited. We were alone on the plateau now. Whatever they were trying to say, I was glad of the privacy. “Yes,” I prompted, not particularly wishing to think about what the Halfling had done, but also unwilling to fail to acknowledge the truth of Kili’s words.
“It seems strange, that he would do such a thing.” Fili explained.
I bit back frustration. “We all underestimated the Halfling. Me most of all.”
“No.” Kili said in a rush. “It’s more than that. He—you—were looking at him—”
“And now I’m looking at the two of you. Should I refrain from using my eyes?” I demanded. “Either come to your point or climb down the rock. The both of you are trying my patience.”
“It just seems a bit cruel,” Fili blurted. “To—”
“To what?”
“When we take back Erebor, you will be King Under the Mountain,” Kili said by way of explanation.
“Trying to hold a conversation with either of you is like attempting to unravel riddles told by halfwits. I am finished with this.” I turned and strode toward the stairs.
“Whatever thoughts you might have of the Hobbit, you know nothing can come of it.” Fili’s quiet words followed me. “His fascination with you has been clear from the beginning. It would be cruel of you to let him think there is more to your regard than gratitude. Gandalf says things are different for Hobbits. That they don’t seek lightly the pleasures of the flesh. You must know that, Uncle? That’s why you told Dwalin none of us were to—trifle—with the Halfling?”
I paused. Waited. My nephews were clearly not finished.
“Bofur feels a great measure of affection for Master Baggins,” Kili added when Fili paused. “When all of this ends, when we reclaim Erebor, I think he would—keep the Hobbit. As his mate, I mean. If you told Bilbo to seek comfort with Bofur, he would understand that anything more than friendship would not be possible with you. It’s a kindness he deserves, Uncle.”
“And what do you think reaction to that would be from our people?” I asked, voice hollow. “It’s one thing to lay occasionally with an Elf or a human. But to mate with a kind not our own would never be accepted.”
“Perhaps not by everyone,” Kili said.
“Not even by most,” Fili agreed. “But the thirteen of us, we like Bilbo. We would see that no harm or offense came to him. And it could be done—quietly. Bofur is a simple dwarf. Even with his share of the treasure, he will never lead a life of scrutiny. As long as they did not flaunt themselves, it wouldn’t cause great offense. ”
I closed my eyes. “I will consider your suggestion. Is that all?”
“Yes, Uncle,” they replied at the same time, sounding both somber and relieved.
14.
The ledge was covered with soft, sweet smelling rock and sheltered by a high circular outcrop that somehow almost felt like the inside of a mountain. In the goblin caves, we’d lost nearly everything but our lives and our weapons. And while there was no food to be found, there was plenty of fresh, good water. At Gandalf’s urging, the entire company had washed in the shelter of the falls. Already, the scrapes and cuts that covered the faces, arms, and chests of my fellows seemed to be healing.
It was a bit of an awkward thing, our washing. For all that dwarfs were open about the ways in which we sought companionship; bathing our hair and beards in particular was usually a very private affair. Gandalf must have known this. He’d chosen an area of falls set on a curve with many tall outcroppings of rock peppered around it. While there were not private rooms, the natural landscape created a handful of rocky alcoves. By unspoken agreement, each member of the company was able to take turns washing completely in the rock stalls and then redress as he saw fit and let the next dwarf have privacy to attend to his full skin.
After I left Fili and Kili, I’d glanced around looking for the Halfling. Balin had seen the sweep of my gaze and told me quietly, “Gandalf just sent him to wash. He was waiting for you.”
I’d looked at the old dwarf sharply, but for once he offered no comment, his face carefully blank. Choosing to follow his example and hold my own council, I’d taken my own turn to slip out of sight, strip, and quickly douse my entire body underneath the water. I ran over my hair, soaked my wounded shoulder, and soothed every inch of my battered, tired body. I’d tipped back my face and opened my mouth, letting it fill my throat, my nose, and my ears. For a few precious seconds, I let sight, and sound, and smell and feeling wash away in a deluge of water.
But I did not linger over long. I was eager to check on all of the others, make sure everyone was feeling as restored as I. I stepped away from the falls and began to dress. I had no toweling, but I found I did not mind the feel of the lingering moisture on my skin. Pulling my pants and boots back on, I knew it couldn’t be so, but between the wash of water against the outside of my trunk and the slide of it down the inside of my chest, I could almost feel the cracked bones of my ribs knitting together.
From the exclamations of the others around the rock barriers, I could tell I wasn’t the only one mystified by and grateful for the healing waters. I was reaching for my undershirt when I felt the weight of eyes on my back and turned around. I knew who was watching me before I looked.
The Halfling was bare chested, too, clutching the remains of his shirt and coat and vest, once so carefully kept now tattered. Though I should have looked away, I let my eyes rake over him from top to bottom. Sodden curls lay across his forehead, and I was alarmed at the site of an angry red bite. Streaks of infection were already starting to run down his shoulder, and my heart clenched. Goblin bites were poisonous, and clearly that’s what this was. I lurched forward.
“It’s alright. It’s already healing.” Bilbo’s voice was soft. He must have seen the direction of my attention. “Gandalf must have been right about the water. My whole arm was hot when I started washing, now it’s cool, and the red’s even starting to go away.”
I paused and forced myself to calm, but I didn’t back up. “Let me see,” I demanded.
The Halfling hesitated only a moment before he stepped fully around the edge of the rock he’d been behind and toward me. In the dim mist, I could see a hint of blush on his cheeks. “See?” He asked softly.
To my great surprise, I did see. Bilbo was right. The streaks of infection were drawing back up his skin in front of my eyes. It was remarkable. And I didn’t really care. Assured that he would not be lost to the poison of the bite, I reached out one finger and touched the far edge of the wound. It was far enough up his shoulder to count as his throat. Under my calloused skin, his flesh was soft and warm. I imagined I could feel Bilbo’s pulse throbbing.
“We’ll have to watch it closely,” I said, voice gruff. “If we have to cut off the arm to stop the infection—”
“I’m absolutely sure that won’t be necessary,” Bilbo interrupted, sounding somehow horrified, prim, and disgruntled all at once. “I believe I’ll be keeping all my various parts all to myself today, thank you very much.”
Behind me, the water roared. His words sparked a flash of amusement, and I felt the suggestion of a smile tilt up the corners of my mouth. No amount of laughter, though, could have distracted me from the way it felt to touch the Halfling. My eyes locked with his, and I felt time slow. From the way he swayed toward me and the soft sound he made in the back of his throat, I could sense that I wasn’t the only one so affected by whatever spell had woven between Bilbo and I.
Carefully, making sure he understood he could pull away at any time, I turned my hand so it cupped the back of the Hobbit’s neck. “All of your parts to yourself?” I asked in a hoarse whisper. “You will share none of them?”
“Thorin—”
In my head, I could hear clear as if they were standing on either side of me, the voices of my father and grandfather. Nothing can come of this. It is madness. Turn away from the Halfling and think of him no more. You are a prince, a king—you must not allow yourself to be bewitched by this small, strange creature. Stop this now, Thorin, son of Thrain, son of Thror. Stop this right now.
I’d been listening to the echoes of my ancestors all of my life, but this time, I ignored their instruction. I leaned down and carefully took the Hobbit’s mouth in a kiss that felt like nothing so much as the wash of sensation I used to get as a young man, walking through the front gate of Erebor.
It felt like coming home.
