Actions

Work Header

Rose of My Heart

Chapter 5: Ring of Fire

Summary:

Matthew works himself almost to the bone trying to fill Will Graham’s request.

Notes:

The taste of love is sweet / When hearts like ours meet / I fell for you like a child, / Oh, but the fire went wild / I fell into a burning ring of fire, / I went down, down, down as the flames went higher / And it burns, burns, burns / The ring of fire, the ring of fire

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

It’s the look on Chilton’s face as it correlates with the look on Will Graham’s face that captivates Matthew completely. Maybe he has a penchant for taking in strays or helping the needy, but he gravitates toward distress like a sailor steering his ship to the North Star.

Will Graham can be Matthew’s project for as long as he needs this favor from him, and then he will go back to drifting. Both of them will, probably.

Wouldn’t it be interesting if…

No, Matthew.

He backs off hypotheticals and conditional statements. They’re half-promises. By the time he completes them and turns them into realized thoughts, he’ll be disappointed. It’s not a new pattern. The habit is burned into his brain, and he needs to forget it.

Matthew uses his lunch break to rig a false audio feed into Chilton’s computer for when he goes to spool through the day’s conversations later. It’s just a bunch of old recordings spliced together, and anyway, they’ve had a slow day today. After Will Graham and his compatriots left, Chilton made a fortress out of his office, told Matthew not to buzz anyone through without clearing them with him first, and basically shut the hospital down altogether.

Even if he hadn’t already been contracted to help, Matthew would have tracked Will Graham down and begged for the commission just to get to the bottom of Chilton’s agitation. Nothing against the boss or anything, but Matthew’s always been an ambitious kind of character. He likes to be in with the strongest player on the board, and if his alliance with Graham can give him something over Chilton, even if he can never use it or understand the essence of the problem itself, he wants in.

Knowledge rules his heart — the pursuit of it does.

After he’s done switching off all the cameras and replacing the live surveillance with looped material, he makes his rounds. They have a dozen patients behind the door Graham specified. Matthew’s happy to have the suspect pool narrowed down to twelve, but he still has no idea what he’s looking for.

He can’t ask for specifics, can’t ask for a direction. All Graham gave him, all he seemed capable of giving him, was an identifiable gender. His initial sweep doesn’t give him anything useful either. No one’s riled in the slightest by Will Graham’s visit. They have no way of knowing Chilton has fallen into a state of crisis, and so they don’t react to said state of crisis. Matthew sees that their lunches are all delivered and lingers a while longer, watching and cataloguing.

None of them pay him any mind. They’re used to his invasions by now.

Not to be deterred by their apathy, he starts with Falkenrath, just pulls up a chair and sits outside his cell and waits to be acknowledged. It takes a while, but Falkenrath cracks. He stops halfway through his sandwich and asks, roughly, “What?”

“What’d you do before you ended up here, Peregrine?”

Matthew knows his file back and forth; he knows he studied mechanical engineering at Columbia, graduated with honors, and never got married, though he’d been with the same woman for twelve years when police arrested him for seven counts of murder. They had four kids and a German shepherd at the time. The woman’s name was Calista Borgnino.

Falkenrath’s lawyer shot himself their second week in court, and the judge ordered a mistrial. He’s been in this same cell for six years.

“Delivered newspapers in my formative years — good for casing neighborhoods,” he says sardonically with his mouth full. “Before that I caught insects in my grandmother’s backyard and pulled their wings off. That what you want to hear, Sir?”

“When’d the SZA first hit you? That’s not in the file.”

Falkenrath rolls his eyes. Matthew can’t imagine Will Graham would need anything from him. He scoffs and glances pointedly at the walls and under his cot. Matthew waves his hand.

“Just you and me for now, Perry.” Matthew waits for Falkenrath’s pensive nod. “So when was the first time?”

“First week of grad school, must have been.” He shrugs. “Moved out of the dorms, got myself an apartment, worked at a newspaper that really shouldn’t have hired me, met Callie…”

“You were up and down a lot,” Matthew prompts. “Highs and lows.”

“You ever see Goya’s Black Paintings?”

“Like The Forcibly Bewitched?”

“Same artist, different period of his life.”

“The Black Paintings came after?”

“Yeah, dark stuff.” He drinks his milk and pushes his tray away. “Why’d you cut the feeds?”

“Chilton’s not the only one with a vested interest in you gents.”

“That so?”

“Yeah, that’s so.”

“Well, I’m honored.”

Falkenrath stares blankly at Matthew for a while, not fidgeting or eating or blinking. A smile tugs at Matthew’s lips.

“Anyone ever tell you your name literally means Falcon Falcon-keeper?”

The answering sigh tells him yes. “Got a thing for birds, Brown?”

“More a hawk man myself.” He shrugs. “One more question.”

“Yeah.”

“Why didn’t you marry her?”

Falkenrath closes his eyes and pinches the bridge of his nose. “I didn’t want her to be a widow when the end came.”

“Well, she still writes you letters. She’s hardly a widow.”

The hand obscuring Falkenrath’s face drops away, and the other smartass comments Matthew could probably make shrivel right off his tongue.

“I’ll be back for your tray, Perry.”

“Yeah.”

He repeats this process, and it takes him the better part of an hour just clearing one side of the hall. Weary, he retreats downstairs to archives and goes through each man’s file alphabetically, trying to find a detail somewhere in the stitching that doesn’t agree. The regular archives guy has to be bribed to switch positions with him and man the front desk, but Matthew manages to talk him into it with a mere promise for coffee next week. It’s a small price to pay.

Matthew reads with his back hunched over and his face near the files for close to two hours before deciding he’s coming at the problem from the wrong angle. He can’t find anything bizarre in the files because he’s too familiar with them, knows all their contents as intimately as he knows the streaks in the wood of the front desk.

He searches Will Graham on his phone.

There’s alarmingly little to find — at least on the Will Graham that came in with Agent Crawford and Dr. Bloom. The flood of pages his search engine tries to give him is overwhelming, too expansive for his timetable. He searches Will Graham and Jack Crawford together and gets TattleCrime.com.

“If Angels Really Could Fall from Heaven,” he reads with an incredulous laugh. “Oh, my God, Will Graham, what did you do to get on this woman’s radar…”

Freddie Lounds’ blog links to the Times-Picayune, and Matthew reads sparingly about a freak lightning storm and bloody serial killings. Will Graham helped Jack Crawford catch the killer and her accomplice. He’d been shot in the process — people had crept into his hospital room and snapped photos of him while he was still on the mend.

He looks a bit like what Matthew remembers from that morning, only more sallow under the camera’s flash. It isn’t a very flattering shot. He surmises it wasn’t meant to be.

The walkie-talkie at his hip crackles with static; regular archives guy is clocking out. Matthew’s needed back at the desk. Frantic with the need to make the best of this trip, he grabs the last two files he hadn’t skimmed to the point of memorization. He grabs the files on Conleth MacCailín and Abel Gideon, criticizing himself as he goes for not starting with them. Upstairs Regular Archives says something clever to Matthew on his way out like he was waiting for him to come up so he could say goodbye.

“See ya tomorrow,” Matthew enthuses, a bit over the top with it if he’s being honest.

Regular Archives likes it fine enough. He smiles and heads off on his merry way. Matthew reads until it’s dinnertime and sits across from Conleth MacCailín like he did with the first six patients on the other side.

“Hello, Matthew,” he says brightly, plucking a piece of boiled cauliflower off the tray with his fingers. “How’s tricks then?”

“What do you think, Mr. MacCailín?”

Conleth chuckles, brings his legs up onto the cot, and eats an apple slice, still using his fingers. He’s a bit too attuned to Matthew’s eyes on him, much more than the others had been. The scrutiny makes it harder to intimidate. Nearly every man in this ward can beat Matthew — and Chilton — in a staring contest.

None of them speak with Conleth MacCailín’s accent.

“Well, I hear you put the taps to bed. If that’s true, Matty, I think you’ve gone snooping behind daddy’s back. Not good for trust-building, is it?” Conleth hums and spears a macaroni noodle with his spork. “But I guess Frederick already trusts you enough to put the taps up in the first place, doesn’t he.”

“How do you know I didn’t put them back on after I left the first time?”

“Did you?” Conleth smiles when Matthew doesn’t answer right away. “No, not you, Matty. Unfinished business; I can see it glinting in your eyes like a peat briquette the moment before it catches fire.”

He leans forward on his cot and gives Matthew the unearthly sensation of being much closer to him than he actually is. Matthew swallows, crosses his legs.

“What’re you looking for, Matthew?”

Matthew resists the urge to scrub his hands over his face and give away his position. “Someone that might not even exist.”

“A ghost.” Conleth eats another piece of cauliflower with his fingers. “In here.”

“I got a tip.”

Conleth laughs, loud, and sneers, “A journalist?”

“Police.”

“Oh, well, naturally,” Conleth says, voice dripping with sarcasm. “My first move if I was helping cops would be to cut the cameras, too.”

“Not exactly legal, are they,” Matthew muses, uncrossing his legs and leaning forward in his chair. He chides himself for taking this exchange lightly, for treating it like a frivolity when he’s supposed to be working — in two senses of the word. “Tell me about your life before this.”

“The condensed version?”

“Just the part when you knew.”

Calm shudders unevenly over Conleth’s face. He’s got a few years on Matthew, but he looks older when he sits still; he could use a shave, but he hasn’t asked for one in weeks.

“When I knew I was crazy, that’s what you mean?” Conleth doesn’t wait for Matthew to respond. “Uh,” he sighs, blustery, “I was nineteen.” He fixes his eyes on a spot near Matthew’s feet, glossy eyes. “Tried to…I was in Liverpool when this happened, just a fuckin’…punk kid, dirt poor, drunk all the time.”

“What did you do?”

Conleth flicks his eyes up at Matthew, and he looks betrayed.

“What’s it to you anyway, Matty? You gonna talk to the powers that be, get me a reduced sentence for that bloke I stabbed?” He laughs, a wet sound. “Doesn’t matter when I noticed. Everything’s ruined now.”

Matthew holds his ground. He doesn’t have anything he can offer; still has no fucking clue what he’s looking for and can see that Conleth has no idea why he’s even agreed to tell him what he has so far. He didn’t ask the right question. They need a push in another direction.

“What was…” Matthew licks his lips, uncertain. “What was your happiest moment, before?”

The eyes looking back at him are blue. Matthew always used to think they were that impossible shade Liz Taylor had. He’d heard before that it was impossible to have eyes like that, violet eyes.

Another beat skips by and Matthew asks, “Well, what was it?”

“My grandparents took me to the Leeds and Liverpool Canal when I was a boy.”

“What were their names?”

“Darragh and Aoife MacCailín.”

“Your father’s parents?”

“Yes.”

Matthew nods, clocks Conleth’s half-eaten dinner. “How would you go about finding a ghost?”

With a disinterested nibble at an apple slice, Conleth says, “You’ve got to summon him.”

“Yeah, but how?”

“Going off your crazed air right about now I’d say somebody’s already summoned him.” Matthew doesn’t shrink away from Conleth’s curious, probing stare. “Who was it asked you to look into this ghost?”

“Concerned third party. Guy’s a nobody.”

“Doubt that,” Conleth muses wryly. “No one halfway ordinary ever catches your attention, Matty boy.”

Provoked and not caring to show that he is, Matthew deflects, “Think this ghost’ll be ordinary?”

“Are any of us ordinary.”

Seriously, Matthew asks him, “Is it you?”

“Had my chance for that and botched it,” Conleth says around a shrug. “Guess you wouldn’t know if it was me.”

“Would you know?”

“Guess I would, probably.”

“Are you sure it’s not you?”

Conleth smirks, pops a grape into his mouth.

“When do you think you’ll have the feeds up and running again?”

“Either tonight or tomorrow morning.”

“Tonight like after lights-out?”

“Yes, Mr. MacCailín.”

Conleth nods, takes up a thick apple slice, and rises from the cot. He approaches the bars separating him from the open corridor and keeping him from crossing into Matthew’s space. Matthew’s read his file up and down, and various behavior patterns suggest he might transgress if given half a chance. Some incidents in the past suggest he’d shrink away from any opportunity. Conleth MacCailín is a wildcard. He’s only been with them for something like four months.

His voice goes gentle. “Is calling me Mr. MacCailín supposed to emphasize the disparities in our stations?”

Matthew stands when Conleth stops right at the place where he can’t go any farther. The chair scrapes behind him.

“Does it work?”

Damn it, he sounds breathless.

“How’s it feel when I call you Sir?”

Shit.

The corners of Conleth’s eyes crinkle. “Not much better then?”

Matthew rolls his eyes, starts to fold up his chair.

“Hey, if they don’t give me life in prison at my hearing next month,” Conleth says, sounding incongruously hopeful. “Take me out for a drink.”

Matthew’s heart sinks, but he forces himself to smile. “All the drinks you want, Connie.”

The smile the nickname earns him actually breaks his heart, but he doesn’t react. He just carries the chair to the wall, quietly advises Conleth to finish his dinner, and heads for the final cell left unexplored, that of Abel Gideon.

He instructs Gideon to approach the bars and face the opposite wall, cuffs him, and escorts him, alone, to the cages. One of the guards has a questioning look on his face, but Matthew waves him off with some excuse about Chilton calling in a profiler to come talk at Gideon for some thesis or dissertation. They let him go through, bored and ready to clock out for the night.

Matthew sits Abel Gideon in his personal favorite cage, the middle one nearest the windows on the other side of the room. He goes quietly, doesn’t speak a word until the door is shut and locked. Once Matthew’s settled, Gideon murmurs, “I’ll say, bit of a fumble bringing me to a room with no eyes or ears anywhere.”

“You and I’ve got eyes and ears,” Matthew retorts with a calm smile on his face. It was helpful seeing Conleth first. He feels lightness in his chest with a twist of deep solemnity a little bit deeper. “How long have you been here, Dr. Gideon?”

Matthew knows the answer to this question, too.

“One year, three months, Mr. Brown.” He smiles, not a friendly gesture. “Just a little bit longer than you.”

Matthew nods, doing speedy calculations in his head and coming up with the number that corroborates Gideon’s statement. “Yeah, that’s right.”

Gideon stares for a moment, gears turning behind stony blue-gray eyes. His expression shifts, hardens in some untraceable way that Matthew can’t define until Gideon speaks, a quirk of emotion drifting into his tone that’s only just more than idle curiosity. “A little bird told me you’ve got some sort of independent curiosity in our lot of misguided youths-turned-old-men.”

“You’re not old, Doctor.”

“Not young either, I’m afraid,” he sighs. Whimsical, he adds, “Time does tick by.”

It feels like a clue. Maybe it doesn’t mean anything, but he’s made it into a common theme by now, asking about memories and origins, childhoods, the onset of mental illness.

“Time’s a funny thing,” Matthew starts, feeling his way and going into it perfectly sightless and unsteadied.

Gideon waits, and the title from Will Graham’s page in Freddie Lounds’ blog comes back to him.

If Angels Fall Really Could Fall from Heaven.

“I’ve heard that mankind created time. Do you think it exists after death?”

“Time, Mr. Brown, or Creation?”

“Either.”

“Both do.”

Matthew lets a pause rest between them and answers his unasked question when Gideon makes no move to do so. “Decomposition lends itself to biological creation, I can see that. But time?”

Gideon’s drawl is unimpressed. “It’s all a matter of perspective.”

“What about Heaven?”

“What about it?”

Matthew watches, and he thinks he sees Gideon’s jaw tighten up and lock. The reaction lasts a few seconds, if that, before the tension gives way to boredom.

“Do you think it exists?”

Gideon doesn’t answer.

“I mean, if all we can contribute after death is some organic mulch for the plants and the earthworms, then what’s the soul got to do with it? Do we even have souls?”

The laugh Gideon grants him is terse, impatient. “Did you bring me out here to philosophize about life and death?”

“I brought you out here because I think you’re the ghost.”

There’s no reaction to this blatant surrendering of the truth. Gideon’s already assimilated himself to Matthew’s inquiries, his halfhearted accusations. His eyes look especially flat, too much of an effort to exude disinterest.

“This is all very cryptic and mystical, Mr. Brown, but I have no idea what you’re talking about.”

“Fair enough.” Matthew straightens up in his chair. “What do you know about Will Graham?”

Right on time he answers, “Never heard of him.”

“Really? Because he came here this morning to talk to Chilton, freaked out, and demanded to see you instead. It was almost like he thought he knew you from somewhere.”

“He asked to see me,” Abel says, disbelief evident in his tone, “Abel Gideon.”

“He didn’t ask to see any of them.”

“Didn’t ask to see you either, did he? Shame.” Gideon tuts. “Conleth MacCailín is permanently unattainable and Stephen from Archives makes your lip curl, and not in the tasty way.”

Distracted, Matthew says, “There’s a tasty way to…” He clicks his tongue. “You know how I know Will Graham meant you, Doctor?”

“Do tell. I’m salivating for your completely circumstantial proof.”

“You didn’t ask why I cut the cameras.”

Gideon’s face drops, maybe a hair, before correcting. He looks away, a smile fluttering on his lips. “I like to be original. Eleven other patients had already asked you the same question by the time you brought me out here.”

Matthew shakes his head, at the end of his rope already with the endless circles he’s run around these twelve men — thirteen if he counts Chilton.

“Will Graham thinks there’s something he recognizes in you. Is there any way that could be true?”

For a moment, he thinks he’s lost the battle. He’s prepared to take Gideon back to his cell and groan and gripe in his car for the next six to eight hours until he has to shower and shave for work the following morning. For a protracted moment, he thinks Abel Gideon is going to assign that fate to him.

Abel’s frown deepens, and he intones, about three times more serious than he usually is just by default, “This Will Graham, what exactly did he say to you?”

“He said there was a patient in your corridor that he needed to see; he didn’t have a name, but he specified male and said it was important that he and this person met.”

The shift in Gideon’s demeanor is dynamic. He becomes almost professorial, diplomatic, to an extent.

“Why did he come here?”

“He had to see Chilton about something. They looked at each other, Chilton said something to him, Graham got upset…”

“Did you hear what he said?”

“Um…he said ‘you’re welcome’ and then a name. I couldn’t hear it right, but it wasn’t English.”

Gideon stands. “What was the name?”

“Jeez, uh,” Matthew mumbles, searching the reel of his memory for the scene that morning.

He’d been listening, but Chilton had dropped his voice, had obscured the word almost beyond coherency for the sake of secrecy. His lips hadn’t moved much to form the name, so it was comprised of only a few syllables, maybe even one — but no, his lips had pulled back around a second syllable and that had been the end of it. It was a two syllable name.

You’re welcome…

Was it?

“I don’t know, I can’t…Will Graham would know, if you spoke to him.”

Gideon’s frown changes and he rolls his eyes. “There’s the rub.”

“I’m bringing him back to see you. It’s happening; there just isn’t a date yet.”

“Good luck okaying that with Chilton,” Gideon teases, all sarcasm.

“Don’t underestimate me.”

It’s very nearly a threat. Matthew doesn’t know what he would do to follow through with it; switch Gideon’s medication, sneak laxatives into his food? The ploys would be unsophisticated and childish. Gideon, maybe tracking Matthew’s thoughts, smirks, pleased with himself. Matthew huffs a long, tired sigh and moves Gideon back to his cell.

Chilton is still brooding like a stolen princess in his office, so Matthew skips that part of his assignment for tonight. He’s done enough damage where damage needed doing until tomorrow, maybe even until next week.

When he clocks out he has a text message on his phone from a number he doesn’t recognize asking him to call when he’s free. He presses dial. Matthew doesn’t know the voice that answers, but that problem is quickly remedied when the unidentified male speaker hands the phone off to Will Graham.

“Matthew Brown?”

“Yeah, hi. Mr. Graham.”

“Were you…I know it was an impossible task I asked of you.”

“No, it wasn’t,” Matthew reassures him, rubbing at his eyes and stifling a yawn. “I found someone who I think fits your not-profile.”

“My…who is it?”

“Name’s Abel Gideon. Guy used to be a surgeon. Snapped one day and killed his wife and her family.”

Morosely, Graham replies, “That’s awful.”

“Um.” Matthew locks his car doors and slides his key into the ignition without turning the engine over. “It was, I guess. Do you think he could be your guy?”

“I’ve never heard of him before.”

“Oh.”

“No, I mean — yes is what I mean. If he is who I think he is, then I wouldn’t expect to know him by his name.”

“That’s…very strange and complicated.”

Will Graham sighs, “So I’ve been told.”

“Look, I can’t make any promises, but I’m going to try and work something out with Chilton. He’s a stubborn guy when he wants to be, so it could take weeks, maybe longer until the man comes around.”

“I appreciate your looking into it, Matthew.”

Matthew wakes up a bit when his name trips intimately in his ear riding the wavelengths of Will Graham’s voice. It should be illegal to sound so completely informal when just saying another person’s name.

This thing Matthew has for men with violent lives is really not doing him any favors.

“Well, anything to help a friend,” Matthew says, starting his car so he won’t have to pay attention to the sad little dip making his heartbeat semi-erratic. He gets the heater going and turns off the radio, already turned down very low anyway. “Besides, it’s every orderly’s dream to do some heavy-duty sleuthing for a mysterious stranger.”

“I hadn’t introduced myself when I asked for your help. Lloyd said that was bad manners on my part.”

Lloyd must be the first voice Matthew heard on the phone.

“I didn’t take it personally, Mr. Graham. You looked pretty discombobulated at the time.”

There’s a stutter of silence. Graham clears his throat and asks, “Dr. Chilton?”

“Guy’s been holed up in his office since you left.” An idea occurs to Matthew. “He, um, said something to you before it all went south. I heard part of it, but I missed the name.”

“It was just a misunderstanding.” Matthew doesn’t think he imagines the bitter chord in Will Graham’s voice.

“Abel Gideon was very interested in that name. I couldn’t tell him what it was, but he sat up and paid attention when he thought I would.”

“I can’t tell you what it was.”

Faking nonchalance, Matthew says, “Chilton might if you don’t.”

“That’s his prerogative,” comes the answer with just as much nonchalance.

Matthew frowns and leans back in his seat. “I’ll call you tomorrow, Mr. Graham.”

He hangs up and goes to take the car out of park when he remembers the cameras. Matthew sighs, switches the car off, and goes running back up the steps. The lot is deserted, and the interior was just the same when Matthew left it. In another hour or so the graveyard shift would filter in and monitor the quiet hours from midnight to morning. The patients would sleep or they wouldn’t.

Standing at the front desk with his back to Matthew is Chilton himself, removed at last from his tower. “You must think I’m a fool,” he says without turning around.

Matthew waits, shuffling a bit on his feet and crossing his arms uncertainly.

“Well, Mr. Brown? Let’s hear it. You think I’m a fool.”

“I don’t.”

“No?” Chilton spins around, keeps his eyes on his hands, which throw down two files that Matthew forgot to take back to archives: Conleth MacCailín’s and Abel Gideon’s. “You told Will Graham you’d help him find a patient this morning. One of these men?”

Matthew doesn’t ask how Chilton could know that. The main cameras had been fully operational that morning.

“The guy didn’t know what he was looking for. It was a dead-end.”

“Is that so?” Chilton’s eyes slide up to Matthew’s face, and he looks genuinely, fantastically pissed. “If I listen to tonight’s recordings, will I agree with your judgment?”

“I was going to conduct interviews in the morning. It took all day and most of the night narrowing it down to those two.”

“And yet,” Chilton muses, pressing his finger to the files splayed on the front desk, “you managed to find them at all; these two caught your eye enough to be singled out. That’s hard to do without so much as a profile. I heard Will Graham tell you this morning he didn’t know anything about the man in question.”

Matthew waits, and Chilton stares him down.

“Do tell, Mr. Brown, what it was about these two patients in particular that drew your attention?”

“It’s just gut feelings,” Matthew tries to laugh.

“Like your gut feelings for Mr. MacCailín, Mr. Brown?” Chilton speaks through the chill racing down Matthew’s spine and settling in his stomach: “I’ll level with you, of course. He is a handsome, damaged individual, with a rugged sort of allure—Mr. MacCailín, that is, although I suppose,” Chilton murmurs, rounding the desk, “that is a shoe that fits Will Graham just as well as it does Conleth MacCailín.”

Matthew keeps his mouth shut, fully aware that the ball’s been ripped out of his court.

“Listen to me very carefully, Mr. Brown.” Chilton extends the files to Matthew and stays just outside of his personal space. “I’m not going to fire you for your insubordination, which this clearly was or else you would have come to me.” He indicates the files with a nod and continues, “Besides, I don’t want to have to train somebody new in the art of wiretapping. It’s tedious work, and you do it so well, obviously.”

“What, then? Suspension?”

“Oh, no, no, no. That’d be tedious work, too, finding someone to fill in and take care of the business I usually have you carry out. No,” Chilton says again with a small shake of his head. “No, if you don’t share your findings with me I’ll have no choice but to remove Mr. MacCailín from this hospital.”

He pauses as if giving Matthew a chance to interject with a declaration of opposition. Matthew bites down on his cheek and doesn’t give him the satisfaction.

“Really, what’s the difference, he’ll be transferred to a proper prison by the end of next month anyway. I think,” Chilton taunts lightly, tapping his chin with one finger, “they might be pushing for life after all. Best case scenario he gets out in twenty years, assuming he doesn’t get brutally murdered in his cell.”

Chilton extracts Conleth’s file from Matthew’s hand and flips through it callously.

“Yes, it seems we may be unable to accommodate him further. I’m sure I could call someone in Traverse City, or maybe they’d like him back home in Wales.”

“Liverpool,” Matthew corrects him, voice about half as strong as he needs it to be.

“Hmm?” Chilton walks around his shoulder. “What was that, Mr. Brown?”

“Conleth’s from Belfast.”

“Was that before or after he lived in Liverpool?” It’s so clearly a test it makes Matthew’s blood turn cold in his veins. If he doesn’t answer it’s just as good as abandoning Conleth, just as good as refusing him.

“Before.”

Chilton hums, satisfied, and comes to stand in front of Matthew again. He points at Gideon’s file with Conleth’s still in his hand. “A life for a life, Mr. Brown?”

“I’m telling you,” he enunciates, speaking around the places in his mouth that cause him to lisp when he’s under the gun like this. “I couldn’t glean anything definitive from them.”

“But you did conduct interviews, you admit it?”

“Yes, and I’m still not sure I wasn’t missing something else with the other patients.”

“I’m sorry,” Chilton chuckles, “do you lie to your mother with that mouth?”

“It’s not a lie!” Matthew insists, shoving Gideon’s file into Chilton’s hands. “It’s not. If you want to talk to them, I’ll sit in with you and ask them all the same questions, and you’ll see that there’s no way to tell what the hell we’re dealing with or if we’re even seeing it when it’s right under our noses.”

Chilton goes silent, doesn’t deflate but wilts slightly like he might go faint in the next instant. Matthew starts to turn away, thinking maybe he’s bought time, but Chilton grabs his arm and pulls him back. His grip isn’t hard and the motion isn’t quick or violent, but it still causes the files to go tumbling out of his hands.

“What did you say?”

“What?”

“You said there was no way to tell what we’re dealing with. What do you mean by that?”

Matthew takes his arm back. Chilton lets him. Their mutual silence is another test, but the power has returned to Matthew.

“Conleth stays.”

Chilton shows his palms and consents immediately. “Tell me what you know, and he stays.”

“Abel Gideon won’t talk to you,” Matthew says slowly, giving him the answer and letting it sink in before laying down his terms. “He’ll talk to Will Graham, but he won’t talk to you.”

“Why?” He’s asking why Gideon will talk to Will Graham more than he’s asking why Gideon won’t talk to him. They both know Gideon’s bored of talking to Chilton by now. “Why Will Graham?”

“I honestly have not the foggiest idea.” Matthew shakes his head. “But whatever that name Graham said to you, Gideon knew it, too.”

It’s a lie more than it is the truth, but Chilton is too desperate to believe it to question it. He makes a beeline for the door and leaves Matthew with the files on the floor. Matthew gathers them quickly, tosses them back onto the desk where he left them, and goes to follow Chilton to Gideon’s corridor. The guards pass him up on his way in and they don’t let Matthew through.

He detours to the control room and sets about switching the audio feeds back on. Chilton is right up against Gideon’s bars demanding that he tell him about someone called Ose.

Matthew holds his breath. That had been the name.

“Will Graham came here looking for Ose,” Chilton repeats when Gideon just stares back at him blankly from his cot. “He thought I was Ose, as if I were possessed. You know something about it all. I know you do.”

“Judging by your agitation, Frederick, I’d wager you don’t know much of anything.”

Chilton huffs, deep, long breaths like he’s just been running or yelling. He sounds like he might burst into frustrated tears or scream. “Will Graham is going to come and see you, and when he does, you’ll tell him what you refuse to tell me.”

“And you’ll be listening in, is that how it works, Doctor?”

“Do you find the thought distasteful, Gideon?” He holds onto the bars and presses his face in between them. “Well, I find conspiracy theories and malicious automatism distasteful.”

The two men watch each other on the monitor. Gideon stands from his cot, back ramrod straight and hands at his sides. Chilton takes his hands and face away from the bars, but he doesn’t back away. If Gideon approached him and stuck his arms out, he could probably grab him. Matthew doesn’t think Chilton would flinch, not right now. Gideon does move forward, not far enough to reach Chilton, by Matthew’s estimations, but close enough for his exchange with Chilton to read as intimate.

“I’ll see this Will Graham of yours, but if it turns out he doesn’t know me or we don’t happen to talk about what you want to hear, then I’m afraid you’ll have to be sorely disappointed.”

“I am thoroughly prepared to be disappointed,” Chilton assures him flatly. Matthew can’t see his face on the camera, but he sounds defeated.

“Hope deferred makes the heart sick,” Gideon says, taking a step closer to the bars. “But a longing fulfilled is a tree of life.”

“What if someone poisons the roots.”

“Then you replant, Doctor.”

Matthew watches for more, but Chilton leaves without another word. Gideon glances out of his cell at the ceiling for the camera where Matthew’s watching him. He winks.

Chilton’s nowhere to be seen when Matthew leaves the tiny claustrophobic room. He takes the files back down to archives and returns, exhausted, to his car.

He calls the number from before and Will Graham answers on the fifth ring.

“You’re in,” Matthew says without bothering to drop a polite greeting.

There’s an overjoyed moment of energetic silence that precedes the grateful words, “Thank you.”

“I hope he’s the one you were looking for.” Matthew shrugs, starting his car for the second time and getting the heat going. “If you wanted Ose you’re going to have to go somewhere else.”

Graham sucks in a quiet breath. Matthew’s not proud of himself for playing dirty, but no one in the ring with him fights fair. Sue him if he wants to know why he was playing detective for this guy.

“For all our sakes, it’s best that he stays where I can’t find him.”

“You’re a scary guy when you want to be,” Matthew muses, smiling even though he feels like shit. “I think Chilton’s planning on contacting Jack Crawford with the meet-up time — him or Dr. Bloom. You should know ahead of time, Chilton bugs the cells. The whole hospital is under surveillance.

“He’ll hear everything we say?”

“Yeah, you’ve got to be careful how you talk. If you don’t want him to know something, you’ll have to speak in code. Gideon always talks in circles anyway, but be ready for that.”

A bit farther from the phone Will says, “Do you speak code?”

Lloyd tells him, “I’ll show you when you get off the phone.”

“I have to go. You’ve given me an amazing opportunity. I know what it would have cost you if it hadn’t worked out.”

“It wasn’t so bad,” Matthew lies.

“I’m…will you be there, when Chilton sends for me?”

“Maybe. I’m usually around.”

“All right.”

Matthew waits, eyebrows raised. “Um, well, good night, then, Mr. Graham.”

“Good night, Matthew.”

The line goes dead. Matthew sighs, tosses his phone in the passenger seat, and throws the car into reverse to back out of his spot.

Long Goddamn night.

Notes:

“Hope deferred makes the heart sick, but a longing fulfilled is a tree of life” from Proverbs 13:12