Work Text:
It is the dead of winter outside, but the kitchen at Bag End is filled with a homey warmth that makes the cold and snow seem far away.
Bilbo is in his element, dinner preparation well underway. He has already cleaned and filleted the trout he bought from the Gammidge boy that morning, and he puts it in the oven now, seasoned with butter, lemon, and just a whisper of the dried thyme he hung in bunches last summer. The smell is magnificent.
As he cooks, he hums a tune his mother used to sing, though he cannot remember the words anymore.
The vegetables steam in the good copper pot. He has timed everything precisely, so they will be ready as the fish reaches that perfect moment of flaking doneness. The potatoes wait on the side, prepared with what some might consider an irresponsible amount of butter and cream. His father always said that potatoes are merely a conveyance system for butter and salt, and Bilbo has taken this philosophy to heart.
For pudding, an apple tart cools on the windowsill. The cellar is still full of the autumn harvest, and he uses them liberally before they become wrinkly and sad at the end of winter.
For anyone who is not a hobbit, this would be an elaborate meal. But for Bilbo, this is simply Tuesday.
It is important to keep the daily rituals even if he is alone, to take care of himself the way his parents would have wanted.
He is dressed for comfort and solitude: linen shirt and breeches covered by the patchwork gown his mother gifted him for his twentieth birthday, when he finished his growth spurt, the soft burgundy and sage and mustard squares faded from years of washing. As soon as he came back from the market he’d shed the wool waistcoat and silk neckcloth that mark him as a Baggins of substance. At home, there is no need to maintain appearances, he can tap his feet to the rhythm of the tune he’s humming or talk to himself without fear of instigating Mad Baggins rumours again.
He is just coming back from the wine cellar with an old vintage bottle in hand when he hears it.
Knock, knock, knock.
It is not quite late enough to alarm him, but well past the time when respectable hobbits receive visitors.
Then, he realises he knows that knock, would recognise it anywhere. Three measured raps, firm but not aggressive, patient. The kind of knock that says the person on the other side will wait as long as necessary, but expects to be answered.
He freezes in the hallway.
It is the surprise, is all, though in truth he has long been expecting this visit, to the point he'd quite despaired he'd get to see his dwarrow friend again. Before his last visit, Thorin would visit every year or second year, and stay a few weeks before or after summer, on his way to and from the Blue Mountains.
Now it's been four years.
He's been expecting this visit, yes, had been counting the months since Thorin's last appearance, but he isn't ready now. He is wearing his oldest, almost threadbare dressing gown. His hair is probably sticking up in all directions from where he'd run his hands through it while cooking. The house smells of fish, which was lovely for dinner but not exactly…
Do dwarrow even like fish? Or eat it at all?
The knock comes again.
Knock, knock, knock.
Thorin's last visit had been different. By mere coincidence, he’d arrived just weeks after the Fell Winter had taken both his parents within days of each other. Bilbo had been living in a fog of grief so thick he could barely see through it. The house had been full of condolence visits at first, as every Baggins, Took, and Brandybuck across the four farthings had tramped through Bag End with casseroles and sympathy. But then they'd left, returned to their own lives and their own private mournings, for hobbit lives had been taken left and right that winter, and Bilbo had been alone in a house that was too big, too silent, too full of absences.
He'd stopped eating properly. Stopped sleeping regular hours. He'd wandered the smial at odd times, staring into nothingness or some small details that now shone with a new light: his mother's gardening gloves still sitting by the back door, her handwriting on recipes tucked into books, his father's favorite armchair still shaped to his body. Sometimes Bilbo would sit in that chair and cry. Sometimes he would sit in it and feel nothing at all, which was somehow worse.
The knocking had startled him that day too. He hadn't been expecting visitors. Hadn't even thought to check whether he looked presentable or whether the house was in order before he had walked to the door in a daze, wearing a shirt he'd slept in for two days, his hair unwashed, his eyes red-rimmed and hollow. He’d taken a look at Thorin and promptly fell into his open arms, his legs giving way under his weight. Having barely eaten in days, seeing Thorin again had been like reaching harbour after braving a storm.
He was safe, he let go.
Thorin had asked no questions, made no demands. He had been gentle and caring, helping Bilbo pull himself together again.
That last time, he'd stayed for four weeks, the longest he'd ever remained in the Shire.
He'd given Bilbo simple meals he could stomach, insisted he took walks outside even if he was cold or tired, sat with him through the worst of the grief, and one evening he'd told Bilbo a story about his cousin Oin had caught his forked beard in a door hinge and had to be cut free by three blacksmiths.
It was the first time Bilbo had laughed since the funerals. The sound had felt strange in his throat, almost wrong, but Thorin had looked so pleased, so relieved, that Bilbo had found himself laughing harder, and then crying, and then laughing again while Thorin held him and said nothing at all.
It had felt right.
Then, nothing from Thorin, for years.
Which means it hadn’t been right.
Not for Thorin at least.
Knock, knock, knock.
Bilbo blinks himself out of his daydreaming, takes a deep breath, sets the wine bottle on the hall table with hands that aren't quite steady and opens the door.
The air outside is significantly colder than the warmth of Bag End.
Snow has begun to pile over the fence.
Thorin Oakenshield stands on his doorstep, looking sideways to the light from the kitchen window that must have told him there's someone inside.
His sharp profile is stark against the white flurries.
Bilbo is overtaken by a full body shiver.
Thorin looks the same and yet so different. Older, though that's a strange thing to notice about a dwarf who ages so slowly. Not older in the way hobbits age, with lines and silver hair, but there's something more mature in his bearing, in the set of his shoulders.
The last time Bilbo saw Thorin there had been a searching quality to him, as though he were still finding out who he was meant to be.
That is gone now.
The dwarf before him stands with the confidence of someone who has found his answers, or at least made peace with the questions, questions a poor hobbit such as Bilbo has no hope of ever understanding.
He is wearing traveling clothes, well-made but road-worn, and carries a pack that suggests he's been walking for days. His dark hair is longer, braided in a more complex pattern than before. Interspersed here and there, there are silver beads and clasps whose shine competes with the snowflakes on his hair and shoulders. Even though he’s not knowledgeable about the subtleties of dwarrow hair style, Bilbo intuits they signify change in Thorin's circumstances. A significant change.
His jaw is shadowed with stubble, heavier than before.
Bilbo wonders if it’s itchy, and his fingertips itch to touch.
It’s not quite full enough to be called a beard though.
Bilbo remembers Thorin explaining once, with resigned humor, that despite being called the Longbeards, his family line didn't grow truly impressive beards until well into their hundreds. “Our name is something we must grow into”, he'd said. “Quite literally”.
Then their eyes meet. Thorin’s pupils flicker quickly, up and down and up again, as if he is assessing Bilbo. He seems relieved by what he finds, because his shoulders sink infinitesimally.
“Thorin”, Bilbo says, his voice smaller than he intended. “I…you're…” He gestures helplessly at his dressing gown, at his tousled hair, at the snow falling outside. “I wasn't expecting you..”
“Well met, Bilbo. I know it’s late, but I hope my presence is no bother”. Thorin's voice is deeper than Bilbo remembers, rougher, as though he's been using it less, or perhaps more. His accent seems thicker too, the rolling consonants more pronounced, as if he had been speaking more Khuzdul than Westron lately. “I can take lodging at the Green Dragon, I saw they were open when I crossed the Bywater bridge”.
“No. Yes. No! I mean…” Bilbo realizes he's babbling, standing in the doorway like an idiot. “Come in, please, come in. You must be freezing”.
Thorin steps inside, and when Bilbo closes the door and turns around, he is suddenly, acutely aware of how much bigger the dwarrow is, and how small his entrance hall feels in comparison, how close they're standing because of it.
Thorin smells of snow and pine smoke and something mineral and earthy that Bilbo associates with the mountains Thorin has told him about, though he's never seen anything higher than the Shire’s green rolling hills himself.
When Thorin shrugs off his pack, Bilbo notices the bow, axe and sword strapped to it, well-maintained and clearly used. He’s never seen Thorin so heavily armed.
“I should have sent word”, Thorin says leaning forward to untie his heavy boots. “But I was not certain of my route until recently”.
“No, no, it's fine…” Bilbo runs a hand through his hair and immediately regrets it when he feels how wild it is. “I'm glad you're here. You are always welcome here… I've been... that is, I wondered if you might…”
He trails off, because what can he say? I've been counting the months? The years! I was afraid you'd forgotten me? I think about you more often than is probably sensible?
Thorin is looking at him with those impossibly blue eyes, and Bilbo can’t read the emotion hidden deep inside them.
“You are cooking”, Thorin says, and there's the faintest hint of amusement in his voice. “It smells good”.
Bilbo blinks. “The fish! Oh blast, the fish…” He spins around and practically runs back to the kitchen, aware that he's leaving Thorin standing in the hall but unable to do anything about it because the trout is going to burn and that would be a tragedy.
He hears Thorin's footsteps following, slower and heavier than his own.
The fish is fine, but barely so, it will probably be more chewy than it should. Bilbo’d managed to rescue it not a moment too soon, pulling the tray off the heat with shaking hands. Holding it in the middle of the kitchen, the blazing heat of the ceramic barely tolerable through the layer of hastily folded cloth, he realizes that he has no idea what he's doing. Does he set another place without asking? Should he assume Thorin is here to stay? Of course he wants him to stay, what kind of question is that, but what if Thorin is expected elsewhere, what if he's only stopping by out of politeness, what if…
“I have interrupted your evening meal”, Thorin says from the doorway. He seems to fill the threshold completely, though logically Bilbo knows he cannot be that much taller or broader than an average hobbit. It's just the way he stands, the solidity of him. “My apologies”.
“Don't be ridiculous. Friends are always welcome guests at Bag End, that's what my parents always said, don’t you remember?”. Bilbo says, more sharply than he intends. He takes a breath, moderates his tone. “Can dwarrow eat fish by the way? I just realized I've never seen you eat any, and if you don't, I have some cold chicken, and there's always bread and cheese and cured meats…”
“We can eat fish”, Thorin says, and there's the faintest hint of amusement in his voice. “Though in Ered Luin, it’s mostly dry fish; we don't have such fresh catches as in the Shire”.
Ered Luin. The Blue Mountains. Where the survivors of wherever Thorin had been before had gone to rebuild. Bilbo knows this much from previous conversations, though Thorin has always been sparing with details about his people.
“I am glad you are here… I mean, there's plenty of food to share. More than plenty. I always cook too much, really, it's a terrible habit, which means I'll be eating leftovers for days unless you help me”. He's babbling again but can't shut his damned trap. “And it's nothing fancy, though the Gammidge boy does bring the best trout, and he says it would be the last one of the season before the Bywater freezes over for some weeks, you know, so I had to take my chances. I've got potatoes, and vegetables, and don’t worry, I remember your sweet tooth, there's also an apple tart cooling if you eat your veg like a good boy…”
“Bilbo”.
The sound of his name in Thorin's voice stops him mid-sentence. He blushes slightly, realising exactly what he’s just said.
“Yes?”
“I would be honored to share any of your meals”. Thorin takes a step into the kitchen, and then another. “If you will have me”.
Bilbo’s ears become suddenly fire-hot.
That fool of a dwarf doesn’t realise how utterly romantic that sounds to a hobbit.
If you will have me!
As if.
“Of course” he manages to choke. “I'll just… let me”.
He fumbles, fish tray still in his hands. Thorin reaches for it, waving away Bilbo’s protests about it being oven-hot, and sets it carefully in the centre of the table. Flustered, Bilbo busies himself with plates and cutlery, hyperaware of Thorin's presence behind him. The kitchen that had felt so comfortably warm now feels almost too hot, though that might just be the flush he can feel creeping down his neck.
“The curtains are new”, Thorin observes.
Bilbo looks up, surprised he would notice such a domestic detail. “I… yes. The old ones were getting threadbare. My grandmother gifted me these for her last birthday. She still likes doing needlework, though her sight isn’t what it used to be”.
“They are well crafted”.
It's such a simple thing to say, but it hits Bilbo like a caress, taking him back to those many afternoons they’d spent together in that very same kitchen, during those terrible weeks after his parents died.
“Thank you”, he says quietly. “For…being here. Now, and the last time. I don't think I ever properly thanked you”.
Thorin is silent for a long moment. When Bilbo risks a glance at him, he finds the dwarf watching him with such an unexpected tenderness in his eyes that he has to look away again.
“There is nothing to thank me for”, Thorin says finally. “I only regret that I could not come back sooner”.
“You came”, Bilbo says. “You’re here now. That’s enough”.
He finishes setting the table with his mother's good china (because if not for Thorin then when?). Meanwhile, Thorin has moved to the basin to wash his hands without being asked, and found the towel without being told where it is. It’s another show of familiarity that Bilbo wasn’t expecting.
Then, Bilbo remembers the wine bottle he'd brought up from the cellar, and he hesitates on the kitchen's threshold.
“I have wine”, he says. “Or I can fetch some ale, if you'd prefer? Or just water…”
“Wine is good”. Thorin says. He's seated himself at the table, but there's some awkwardness about the way he sits, as though he's not quite sure he deserves to be here.
Bilbo goes fetch the wine, and before sitting on the table he pours them both generous glasses. It’s white wine from Michel Delving, a good vintage his father had been saving for some special occasion that never came. He sits down and takes a sip, before leaning back on the chair to examine Thorin, his appreciative pout after drinking, as if he is revealing the taste.
Before sitting, Thorin's taken off his wet travel coat and hung it from an empty chair near the fire. Underneath he is wearing a simple shirt, form-fitted and worn. He seems much thinner than he used to be. Than he should be. As much as Hobbits tend to be chubby and soft, Dwarrow are meant to be solid, stocky, but Thorin looks like someone who's been working too hard and eating too little for too long.
“Please”, Bilbo says softly. “Eat”.
They begin eating, and for a moment there's only the clink of cutlery and the sound of the fire crackling in the stove. Bilbo watches as Thorin takes his first bite, and cannot help the small smile when he sees the dwarf's eyes widen slightly.
“This is excellent”, Thorin says after swallowing the morsel, and he sounds almost surprised.
“Did you think I’d forget how to cook in these four years?” Bilbo asks, aiming for lightness.
“Four years”, Thorin repeats quietly. “No… I knew you would not forget”.
Four years. Where has Thorin been all that time?
Bilbo struggles to maintain his cool, to talk without seeming as if he’s demanding any answers. “That's... quite a long time between visits”.
He doesn't mean it as an accusation, truly he doesn't, but pain, perhaps guilt flickers across Thorin's face.
“It is”,Thorin agrees. “There were... complications. Matters that required my attention”. He pauses, sets down his fork with deliberate care. “I can… explain another time. I will. Now…well, I want to hear all about you. But believe me when I say I am so sorry, Bilbo. I should have sent word”.
“I didn't even know where I would send a letter”, Bilbo admits. “You never said exactly where…”
“I know”, Thorin looks down at his plate. “I have not made it easy for you to find me”.
Bilbo yearns to ask why Thorin disappeared for so long, why he's here now, what's changed. But he's also afraid of the answers, afraid of pushing too hard and making Thorin leave again.
So instead he says, “Well. You're here now. That's what matters”.
Thorin looks up at him, eyes hopeful, and his small smile reaches straight into Bilbo’s poor heart.
“Yes”, he says. “I am here now”.
And Bilbo thinks, as he takes another bite of fish and tries to pretend his hands aren't shaking: Please stay. Please don't leave again so soon. Please…
They continue eating in silence, Bilbo watching Thorin from under his lashes, seeing the way the dwarf chews slowly,methodically, taking modest portions despite Bilbo's urging to get him to eat a proper amount.
They finish the meal, and Bilbo serves the apple tart with a pot of tea. Thorin eats his slice slowly, and Bilbo pretends not to notice how the dwarf's shoulders gradually relax, the way some of the tension leaves his facial expression.
“How long can you stay?” Bilbo asks finally, when he can't avoid the question any longer.
Thorin is quiet for a long moment. “I am not certain”, he says finally. “I have... some freedom in my movements now. More than I did”. He hesitates. “If it would not be an imposition, perhaps a few days? A week?”
“A week?” Bilbo can't keep the disappointment from his voice. “Thorin, you stayed four weeks last time. Surely if you have more freedom now, as you say, you can…” He stops, seeing something shutter in Thorin's expression. “What's happened? What's changed?”
Thorin sets his tea cup down and sighs. “Much”, he says quietly. “Much has changed, Bilbo. I am not…” He trails off, jaw working as though the words are difficult. “I am not the same person who last sat at this table”.
“I know that”, Bilbo says. “I can see that. But you're still Thorin, and you're still my friend, and you're still welcome in my home for as long as you wish to stay”.
“I do not know if I remember how”, Thorin says, so quietly Bilbo almost doesn't hear it, “to be anything other than what I must be”.
And Bilbo understands, suddenly, why Thorin has stayed away so long. Not because he forgot, or because he didn't care, but because he was afraid that whatever he'd become in those years since his last visit would be too different to fit into the easy life of the Shire.
Bilbo reaches across the table and takes Thorin's hand in his own, feeling the rough calluses, the scars, the strength.
“Then we'll remember together”, he says. “Let me take care of you the way you once took care of me”.
Thorin's hand trembles in his, and for a long moment, Bilbo thinks he might pull away, might retreat back behind his walls. But then his fingers curl around Bilbo's, holding him, and he nods.
“Thank you”, he says. “For not turning me away”.
“Never”, Bilbo says fiercely. “You hear me, Thorin Oakenshield? I would never turn you away. Not now. Not ever”.
Bilbo stands abruptly, gathering dishes with perhaps more clatter than necessary, needing movement to steady himself after such raw honesty. “Right then”, he says, voice overly bright, “these won't wash themselves”. He's barely made it to the sink when he hears Thorin rising behind him. “You'll do no such thing”, Bilbo protests as Thorin reaches for the kitchen towel. “You're a guest…”
There follows the most absurd tug-of-war over the faded bit of linen, both too polite and stubborn to give up. They finally reach an agreement: Bilbo washing and Thorin drying, falling into an easy rhythm that defies the awkwardness that should exist between two friends that haven't seen each other in years.
The storm has picked up properly while they were eating, rattling the round window above the sink, but Bilbo finds he doesn't mind it one bit. On other winter nights, alone in Bag End, such ferocious storms left him feeling small and isolated, the wind's howl a reminder of his solitude.
But Bilbo is not alone tonight.
They move to the parlour afterwards. The room sits deep in the hill, at the very center of the smial, insulated by earth and stone and the warren of surrounding chambers. It is Bilbo’s favorite room in all the smial, the heart of Bag End, as his mother used to say.
The snowstorm that Bilbo had glimpsed through the kitchen window, the flakes coming down thick and fast, cannot reach them here. There is no rattle of wind against glassplanes, no draft sneaking under ill-fitting frames. Only the solid warmth of warm oak panels and well-worn rugs, only lit by firelight. The fire has burned down to embers while they ate, but Bilbo crouches to add fresh wood now, poking at it until flames leap up again, casting dancing shadows across the ceiling.
Two armchairs flank the hearth, upholstered in burgundy velvet that's gone threadbare on the arms from years of use. Between them sits a low table, scarred and solid, perfect for resting a book or a cup of tea.
“Sit” Bilbo says, gesturing to the armchair nearest the fire. “ll just go prepare the spare room, won't take but a moment, and then we can…”
Thorin has already sunk into the chair, and Bilbo sees the way his whole body seems to sag with relief, the way his eyes drift half-closed in the warmth.
“I'll be quick”, Bilbo promises, and slips away before Thorin can protest.
The spare bedroom is down the hall, a cozy chamber that faces east to catch the morning sun. Bilbo bustles about, pulling fresh linens from the cupboard to freshen the bed. He sets out towels, a water pitcher, even a sprig of lavender in a small vase because it seems like the sort of thing that might help a very tired and uptight dwarf sleep.
He mulls. A week.
Maybe.
Thorin’s literal words had been “maybe a week”, as though that might be too much to ask. As though Bilbo would begrudge him a single day.
When he returns to the parlour, he finds Thorin exactly as he'd left him, slumped in the armchair with his head tipped back against the cushion. His eyes are closed, his breathing deep and even. In sleep, or near-sleep, his face looks soft and vulnerable.
“Thorin”, Bilbo says softly, not wanting to startle him. “Thorin, the bedroom's ready. You should go to bed properly, or else you'll wake with a terrible crick in your neck”.
Thorin's eyes open slowly, blinking in the firelight. For a moment he looks disoriented, as though he's forgotten where he is.
“Not yet”, he says finally, his voice rough with near-sleep. “Please. I would... we should talk. There are things I would tell you, before… before we sleep”.
Bilbo hesitates, torn between concern for Thorin's obvious exhaustion and his own desperate curiosity about where the dwarf has been, what he's been doing, why he looks so worn and weary.
“You're so very tired”, he says finally. “Whatever you need to tell me can surely wait until morning, when you've had some proper rest”.
“Please”, Thorin shifts in the chair, sitting up straighter with visible effort. “I have waited four years to have this conversation. I would prefer not to wait another night”.
There's an urgency in his voice, as if he fears that if he doesn’t speak now, he never will.
“All right”, concedes Bilbo, moving to the sideboard. “But your tone tells me we're going to need something stronger to drink, I reckon”.
He pulls out a bottle of Old Winyards, and two glasses. Then, after a moment's consideration, he retrieves his pipe and the pouch of Longbottom Leaf.
Thorin watches him keenly as Bilbo settles into the other armchair, and sets about pouring them to measures of amber drink.
“Here” Bilbo says, passing one to Thorin, and then he busies himself packing his pipe. “Do you have your pipe with you?” he asks.
“In my pack”, replies Thorin, but he makes no move to rise and get it.
“I can pack one for you, if you like”, offers Bilbo. “Or you can share mine, if it’s all the same to you”.
Thorin nods. And so Bilbo does exactly that. He tells himself it’s just a bother to get up from a different one, but he’s secretly thrilled by the intimacy of the act, passing the pipe back and forth, the sweet-sharp smell of the tobacco mingling with the scent of burning wood in the grate.
The silence stretches comfortably. Longbottom Leaf is already working its magic, softening the edges of the world, making everything feel slightly more distant and manageable.
“So” Bilbo says, trying to get the conversation going. “Tell me about your family. How is your little sister? I remember that one time twenty years ago when she visited and managed to get Lobelia into a fist fight of all things”.
Thorin huffs in what might have been laughter, a tobacco smoke cloud surrounding his head. “Dís is... Dís”, he says, and there's warmth in his voice despite his evident exasperation. “She is a force of nature, as always. Impossible to argue with, impossible to ignore, and absolutely certain that she knows what's best for everyone around her. It’s even worse now that she’s got her mastery in silversmithing”.
“She sounds formidable”, Bilbo says with a smile.
“She is”, Thorin takes a long draw from his pipe, exhaling smoke toward the ceiling. “She has been managing a good deal of my duties while I've been... occupied with other matters”.
“How old is she now? Has she settled?” Bilbo asks. “I am not sure what is the appropriate age for dwarrow to marry, but…”
Thorin shakes his head.
“My sister has been courted by half the dwarrow in Ered Luin at one time or another. She terrifies most of them. Currently she seems to have fixed her attention on Vili son of Nali, a weaponsmith of considerable skill. He's one of the few brave enough to argue back with her”. He pauses, takes another sip of his drink. “She is seriously considering it, I think. His suit. Though she has not said as much to me directly”.
“That's wonderful”. Bilbo says, and means it. “Everyone deserves someone who can match them, don't they? Someone who isn't afraid to stand their ground”.
“Yes”. Thorin's gaze grows distant, his fingers tightening slightly around his glass. “Yes, they do”.
Bilbo takes another draw from his pipe, letting the Longbottom Leaf steady him before asking the question that's been burning in his mind for the past couple minutes.
“And what about you?” he asks. “Are you... is there anyone courting you? Or are you courting anyone?”
Thorin winces.
It's a subtle thing, just a slight tightening around his eyes, a brief compression of his lips, but Bilbo sees it clearly. His heart, which had been doing quite well until that moment, plummets into his stomach.
“Ah”, Thorin says, and takes a long drink to buy some time. “That is... a complex issue”.
“Complex how?” Bilbo hears himself ask, though part of him wants to take the question back, wants to not know the answer.
Thorin is quiet for another moment, staring into the fire. “My position has changed” he begins explaining, finally. “I have been given... greater responsibilities. And with that authority comes certain... expectations”.
“What kind of expectations?”. Bilbo prods.
Thorin winces again.
“The kind that involves securing alliances. Strengthening ties between families. Producing heirs”. Thorin's voice is flat, almost bitter. “I am being pressured… by the council, by certain members of my family, by tradition itself… to find someone suitable. To marry”.
The word 'marry' lands like a stone in still water, sending ripples throughout.
“I see” Bilbo says, and is proud of how steady his voice sounds. “And have you... found someone in Ered Luin then? Someone suitable?”
“No”. The word is sharp, almost harsh.
“But you’re being pressured to”.
“Yes”.
“But you don't want to?”
Thorin turns to look at him then, and Bilbo feels unable to pull away from his gaze.
“What I want”, Thorin says quietly, “and what I can have are often very different things”.
Bilbo doesn’t know how to reply to that. Thorin is looking tense again, and he refuses Bilbo’s pipe when he offers it. So Bilbo huffs and puffs alone, his hand slightly shaky, his gaze lost in the merrily cracking fire.
The tobacco smoke curls around him, like a shelter.
“Bilbo”, mutters Thorin finally, a plaintive tone in his voice. “This is exactly what I wanted to talk to you about. I need to ask you something, and I need you to know you can refuse. There would be no ill will, no change between us. Do you understand?"
Bilbo startles from his reverie. What exactly is Thorin asking? The Longbottom Leaf has made everything feel soft and hazy, as though he was in a dream. “Yes”, he answers, automatically. “What can I help you with?”
“Bilbo, I… “ Thorin speaks slowly and carefully, evidently mincing his words. "I… remember one time, in my second to last visit, when you told me about how… hobbits deal with courtships. You made it sound like a learning process. Experimenting with what suits you, what feels right, with anyone”.
Bilbo remembers now he had indeed told Thorin about all the hobbits lads and lasses he’d kissed and tumbled with, over a pint in the Green Dragon. Honestly, in his late tweens he had been a bit of a twat, bragging about his conquests, but back then, before the Fell Winter, it had seemed so important to make Thorin understand he was an adult now.
“Well”, he begins, a bit embarrassed. “If you say it like that it sounds rather… promiscuous… but it's true that it is not unusual for young hobbits to explore before we settle down. It's all very casual and friendly. No one's hearts get broken because everyone understands it' just... practice, I suppose. Working out what we like, who we are”.
Thorin nods. “Dwarves do not... we do not do any of that before marriage. A kiss is a claiming. Anything more is... sacred” He swallows, and he adds.”There is no practice period, and I… wonder if you…if you would be willing to teach me”.
You, Bilbo wants to shout. I want to teach you how to court me. I want to be the one you're learning for.
Instead, he narrows his eyes and pretends he doesn’t understand: “Teach you what, exactly?”
It comes out a bit choked, as if Thorin had to force himself to talk. “How to court someone”.
“You want me to teach you how to court someone” Bilbo repeats slowly. “I am sure hobbit and dwarrow customs are very different”.
“I don’t mean… theoretically”, Thorin’s voice is now barely a whisper. “I mean practically. With you”.
Bilbo's pipe nearly falls from his nerveless fingers, and he fidgets with it on his lap.“With me” he echoes faintly.
“Yes”.
“Is this appropriate by dwarvish standards?” he asks, trying to find excuses to avoid accepting too soon, too easily. Because he is going to say yes. Eventually.
“No”, Thorin admits. “It is not. But I am asking you anyway”.
“Why me?” asks Bilbo. “Why not ask someone among your own people? Surely someone could…”
“Because I trust you”, Thorin mutters, and Bilbo really wishes he could meet his eyes, to assess Thorin’s expression as he speaks so quietly, yet so passionately, he’s unable to lift his own from his lap. “Because you see me as just Thorin, not as Durin's heir or Markhazghzarsul (Oakenshield). You are the only person who would not…” He pauses. “Who would not judge me. Who would not use it against me politically, or spread rumors that might damage my standing with the council”.
“Thorin, I…” Bilbo trails off. Takes a breath. Tries again. “If I do this… it has to be understood that this is just teaching. Just friends helping friends. Nothing more”.
Thorin leans forward, elbows on his knees, hands clasped together. The firelight catches in his hair, turns the silver beads to flame. “Of course”, he says quickly, firmly. “Nothing more. I would not presume…”
“And you have to do exactly as I say. No arguing, no dwarvish stubbornness about how things should be”.
"I will be a good student”. Thorin sounds so earnest. "I promise."
Bilbo sighs: “What exactly do you want to learn, then?”
“Dwarrow courtship is formal, ritualized. There are gifts and contracts and negotiations between families. But the actual... closeness. The intimacy of it. I don't know how to do any of that”.
“And you are sure I do?” Bilbo challenges. The cosmic cruelty of this moment is staggering. Here is everything he's wanted, Thorin asking to be close to him, asking to learn intimacy from him, and it's all in service of teaching Thorin how to love someone else. Someone suitable. Someone who isn't a hobbit. “You're asking me to... what, exactly? To hold your hand? To teach you how to embrace someone? How to… kiss someone? So you can take those lessons back to Ered Luin and use them on some dwarf-woman the council approves of?”
Thorin flinches at Bilbo's words, but he doesn't look away. “Yes”. he says simply. "That is exactly what I'm asking. I know it's selfish. I know I have no right to ask this of you. But I'm desperate, Bilbo. I feel like I'm drowning in expectations, and you're the only respite I have”.
The fire pops. Outside, the storm continues to rage, but Bilbo cannot hear it here in this windowless sanctuary. Cannot hear anything but the blood rushing in his ears and the terrible sound of his own heart breaking.
He should say no. He should absolutely say no. This is madness. This will only hurt more in the end, when Thorin leaves again, when he goes back to Ered Luin and finds someone suitable and marries them and Bilbo is left here with nothing but the memory of teaching Thorin how to love someone who isn't him.
But when he looks at Thorin, at the exhaustion in his face, at the desperate hope in his eyes, at the way his hands are clasped so tightly together that his knuckles have gone white and… Bilbo knows he's going to say yes. Because he's a fool of a Took, and because he loves Thorin, and because the chance to touch him even once, before he goes off to marry a faceless dwarrow woman and never comes back to the Shire, is a chance he is going to take.
Instead, he lets the Baggins talk. “I need to think about this before I reply”.
“Bilbo”. Thorin stands suddenly, crosses the small space between their chairs, and drops to his knees in front of Bilbo's chair. It puts them at eye level, and Bilbo can see every detail of his lovely, open facial expression. “I know what I'm asking is unfair. If you truly cannot do this, I will understand. I will not hold it against you. But tell me now. And I won’t bother you any more”.
Bilbo tries to smile reassuringly. “I'm just... trying to understand the parameters. What exactly are we talking about here? Holding hands? Walking together? Kissing? More than that?”
Thorin's cheeks flush slightly, visible even in the firelight. “I... don't know. Everything you told me about that day? Whatever you think is important”.
“Everything”. Bilbo echoes idly. Everything could mean... well. Everything.
“Only what you're willing to teach me”, Thorin amends quickly. “would never ask you to do anything that makes you uncomfortable”.
Bilbo almost laughs at that. Uncomfortable? Uncomfortable doesn't even begin to cover it.
“All right”, he says again, more firmly this time. “We'll talk tomorrow. After you've had a proper night's sleep”. He silences Thorin’s protests with a gesture. “This isn’t a no! It’s very likely a yes. But I need to sleep on it. The hour has grown so very late and I…”
Bilbo has enough sense to shut up and not finish the phrase. He’s not entirely convinced he hasn’t hallucinated the whole thing.
“And Thorin…” He reaches out, hesitates, then lets his hand rest on Thorin's shoulder. “You have to promise me something in return”.
“Anything”.
“Promise me that when this is over, when you go back to Ered Luin and find whoever it is you're meant to marry, you won't forget me".
Confusion takes over Thorin's face. “Bilbo, I could never forget you. How could you think…”
“You stayed away for four years”. Bilbo interrupts gently. “I’m just... I need to know that teaching you… this… won't make it impossible for us to be friends anymore”.
Thorin's hand comes up to cover Bilbo's where it rests on his shoulder. His palm is calloused and warm, and Bilbo has to resist the urge to turn his hand over, to lace their fingers together.
“I promise”, Thorin says, and his voice is fierce. “I swear to you, Bilbo Baggins, that no matter what happens, no matter who I marry or what duties I must fulfill, you will always have a place in my life. Always”.
It's not enough. It will never be enough. But it's what Bilbo has, and so he holds onto it.
“Then we have an agreement”, he says, and manages a smile that only trembles a little. “Now, for goodness sake, go to bed. We can begin your lessons tomorrow, after breakfast. And I warn you, I make a very thorough teacher”.
Thorin smiles, a real, almost giddy smile, that reminds Bilbo of the dwarfling he’d met on Michael Delving market more than two decades ago. “I would expect nothing less”.
They both stand up, and they're close together. If Bilbo leant forward just a bit he could rest his forehead against Thorin's chest. Could wrap his arms around the dwarf's waist and hold on tight and never let go.
He clears his throat and the moment is broken. Bilbo reaches for a light sconce and guides Thorin down the hallway to his second best bedroom.
“Thank you, Bilbo”, Thorin says from the doorway. “For everything”.
“Good night, Thorin”.
“Would you…” Thorin begins to stay, and then shuts up abruptly. “Sorry”.
“What were you going to say?” asks Bilbo.
“Nothing. Good night”.
Bilbo reminds him, voice stern. “If we’re going to do this, we need to be honest with each other”.
“Would you… kiss me good night?”
A kiss.
Bilbo's mouth goes dry. "All right," he hears himself say.
He doesn't think about how this is technically breaking the rules he’s just set himself.
A kiss is just a kiss.
He just rises on his tippy toes and leans in. Thorin bends immediately to meet him, and there's a clumsy half-second where Bilbo misjudges the angle, their noses bumping, before he corrects and presses his mouth to Thorin's.
The first contact is a shock. Thorin is so different from what he’s used to, what he expected. The stubble, simultaneously prickly and ticklish framing his thin, slightly chapped lips that instantly become pliant to Bilbo’s assault followed by a pleased rumble that Bilbo feels more than hears, pressed chest to chest as they are.
As far as kisses go, this one is pretty chaste. Innocent, even.
It lasts no more than a handful of heartbeats.
It’s just a kiss.
The kind of kiss a teen might give at a garden party.
And yet.
It shatters every fiber of Bilbo’s being, taking him back to that time, years ago, when he’d let himself fall into Thorin’s arms on a different threshold, knowing he could trust him to not let go.
But this is so much better. His lips are connected to Thorin’s and he can feel his breath tickling his nose, his thick long eyelashes caressing Bilbo’s cheek, his ribcage expanding and contracting, his lips yielding, yielding, yielding, until there’s the barest hint of an impossibly hot tongue and Bilbo has to bite back a moan and step back, clutching his dressing gown’s belt, his knees wobbly.
“Good night, Thorin”, he says, and is dimly proud that the words come out so matter-of-factly.
He turns before Thorin can respond, before he can see whatever expression might be on Thorin's face, and walks with careful, measured steps back to his own room. The lamplight bobs and wavers. His hand isn't quite steady.
When his door clicks shut behind him, Bilbo sets the lamp down on his dresser and sits heavily on the edge of his bed.
This… this was just a kiss.
And Thorin wants everything.
Bilbo's made a terrible mistake agreeing to this.
He lies awake for hours, listening to the wind rattling the window panes.
A kiss is just a kiss is just a kiss.
He lists all the ways this could go wrong.
He tries not to think how much it's going to hurt when it's over.
Outside, the snow continues to fall, high and high and higher up, until it's piled before Bag End’s bright green door, effectively trapping them inside for the days to come.
Only then does Bilbo fall asleep, and he dreams of kissing, and kissing, and kissing, someone who will never love him back.
