Chapter Text
Vala's Design: The King's Intended Queen and the Serpent's Motives
The core of the treason lay in tradition, status, and blinding envy.
The conspirators—Borin (driven by the shame of a hobbit Consort) and Gróri (driven by the fanaticism of the Old Ways)—found their ideal weapon and leader in Vala, Daughter of Runi.
Vala: The Intended Queen
Vala was a figure of proud Dwarrow nobility, directly descended from a secondary line of the House of Durin, positioning her as the de facto choice for Thorin's Queen.
She was formidable, physically arresting, and cultivated an image of martial and political strength.
With thick black hair heavily braided with intricate jade beads and heavy gold torcs. Her eyes were a striking, polished emerald green—rare and commanding.
Unlike many Dwarrow women who preferred simple, heavy robes, Vala often wore fitted, dark leather and embroidered silk beneath her ceremonial armor, designed to leverage a physical appeal that few at court could ignore.
Her very presence was an assertion of power.
Before the Quest, Vala and Thorin had maintained a political and romantic alliance expected to culminate in marriage upon the recapture of Erebor. Before Thorin unwisely dismissed her.
Vala had stood by Thorin in the Blue Mountains, believing herself the indispensable partner to the exiled King.
She saw herself not just as a bride, but as the foundation of the restored throne, offering the King stability, purity of bloodline, and political gravitas.
The Serpent's Motive: A Cure for the King's "Illness"
Vala's betrayal was born from profound, arrogant entitlement. She did not desire gold; she desired the throne and the King's validation.
She viewed Bilbo not as a lover, a Consort, or even a friend, but as a temporary, sentimental "pet," a lapse in judgment brought on by the trauma of the Quest and the lingering taint of dragon sickness.
For Vala, Bilbo represented everything weak and foreign: his softness, his lack of martial skill, his disregard for ancient Dwarrow law.
Her motive was to force a permanent, public choice. She was utterly convinced that when faced with a crisis—his Kingdom's stability versus the life of his small, frail, foreign Consort—Thorin would be forced to choose duty, tradition, and her own strong hand.
She saw herself as the political cure, believing that by exposing Bilbo as a vulnerability, she could offer herself as the powerful, traditional alternative that Thorin must choose to secure his legacy.
Her ultimate design was a political ultimatum: "Send away the trinket, or it breaks."
She sought to engineer a scenario where Thorin publicly disavowed Bilbo, ensuring Vala's position was cemented as the King's true, rightful companion and co-ruler.
The kidnapping was merely a means to secure her own rightful place at the King's side.
The Serpent in the Stone
Six months into the enduring peace, Bilbo Baggins had become the cornerstone of Erebor's renewed joy.
His presence was a source of light, but to a small, bitter faction of Dwarrow loyalists, he was an unwelcome, soft intrusion.
Borin, the faction leader, and Gróri, his brute, cornered Bilbo near a disused watchtower. Borin’s envy had finally poisoned his loyalty.
Bilbo was quickly subdued and dragged into a dark, unstable mine shaft. Tied cruelly to a wooden support beam, he shivered in the damp, frigid air.
“You have made a grave mistake, Masters,” Bilbo said, straining against the ropes. “King Thorin will find you. And when he does, you will regret ever touching me.”
Borin sneered, his axe resting heavily on his shoulder. “He will find us, yes. But only when he has heard our terms. You are the ransom, Halfling."
Now snapping, "And the price is not gold, but purification. You are a shame to the line of Durin, a weed choking the heart of the mountain!”
“Nonsense!” Bilbo retorted, his fear giving way to sharp indignation.
“I am the one who pulled Thorin from his dragon sickness! I am the one who came with the Company, fought in the battle, and saved his nephews! You call that shame? You call loyalty to your King’s happiness a stain?”
“We call it weak!” Gróri roared, stepping forward. “We value strength and tradition, not some soft, foreign creature who turns the King into a lovesick fool!"
"The King was meant for a Dwarf Queen, for blood and power, not for a creature who smells of sun and daisies!” He finished.
“You mistake devotion for weakness, Master Gróri,” Bilbo countered, though he felt a tremor of fear at the giant Dwarf's intensity.
“And you mistake King Thorin's love for a lack of strength. He chose love over gold, and he chose me. You think threatening me will change his choice? No."
"It will only confirm to him that you are a rot that must be excised from his kingdom. What exactly are your terms, beyond this melodramatic outrage?” Bilbo knew he was every inch a consort, and they hated him for.it.
Borin slammed his fist against the beam near Bilbo's head. “The King is to renounce you publicly, send you away forever, and swear to marry a suitable, noble Dwarrow. If he refuses, the mountain will swallow its shame whole.”
He paused, eyes glittering with cruel malice. “But before that, we must ensure that any light you think you possess is thoroughly extinguished.”
Gróri approached, wrenching Bilbo’s chin up with a brutal grip. “The King thinks you are pure, a shining jewel. We will show him what happens when foreign dirt is rubbed on Durin’s gold. We will break the softness.”
Gróri’s actions were brutal, fueled by the desire to inflict deep, spiritual damage.
Bilbo fought with a primal ferocity—kicking, screaming, biting—his internal chants a desperate mantra: I am Bilbo Baggins of Bag End! I am loved! This is their filth, not mine! They will not take my light! Thorin is coming!
Bilbo fought back, shouting and struggling, spitting defiance. “Get your hands off me, you foul traitor! My King loves me! He loves me, and you are nothing!”
The ensuing silence was filled only with the sounds of Bilbo's desperate resistance and the heavy breathing of the traitors, a testament to the darkness they had brought into the mountain.
Thorin's Fury and the Search
In the Great Hall, Thorin was a portrait of contained destruction. The report of the shattered walking stick and the bound guards had turned his fear into a cold, lethal resolve.
He paced the length of the hall, his hand constantly gripping the hilt of Orcrist.
“They dared,” Thorin hissed, his voice so low it was barely audible above the panic of the Dwarrow guards. “They dared to lay hands on him. Balin, tell me how this could happen! How could they bypass my security on the Western Watch?”
Balin stood firm, though his face was etched with worry. “Your Majesty, traitors within the walls are the hardest to root out. They knew the shift changes."
He wrung.hia hands together, "They knew the blind spots. We are already mobilizing, Thorin. Dwalin is taking the main tunnels. But we need a quiet approach.”
Thorin stopped pacing and looked at his friend, his eyes blazing blue. “Quiet? Balin, I will tear the stone from the mountain if I must! He is my heart, my life!"
"He is the one thing I love more than Erebor itself! I failed him once before, when I cast him out from the ramparts."
Thorin was distraught, "I swore I would never let harm come to him again. I swore I would be his shield! And look! Look what my weakness and my trust have wrought!”
“Your Majesty, your strength is in your clear mind now,” Balin countered gently.
“Rage is what the traitors want. They want you distracted. We need Nori. If anyone knows how to find a rat hiding in a dark crevice, it is the best spy in Erebor."
Balin turned, "Fíli, Kíli, find Nori, and tell him failure is not permitted.”
Fíli stepped forward, his expression grim. “He is already being fetched, Uncle. And do not worry. We will bring him home. As for the traitors... their sentence is already passed. They will regret being born into this mountain.”
Kíli nodded, his hand resting on his bow. “Nori will deliver the location. We will deliver the reckoning.”
The Serpent's Motives, Old Flames, and Traitors
The small, extremist faction of Dwarrow loyalists, led by Borin, had leaned heavily on Vala, a respected artisan from a prestigious family.
“The location is guarded, Your Majesty,” Nori reported, having used a coded message planted by the traitors. “They are demanding a personal meeting. They want to see you waver."
Nori hesitated, "The message states: ‘The price is not gold. It is recognition of your mistake. Send away the trinket, or it breaks.’"
Just then, a lone figure strode into the hall. It was Vala, her robes impeccable, her posture defiant.
She knelt, but her eyes held a challenge. “My King, I have risked much to bring you the full terms. Borin and Gróri are fanatics, but they speak for many who fear the weakening of our line.”
Thorin’s gaze was lethal, but he maintained control. “Speak, woman. You dare speak treason upon occupying yourself in my hall and live to tell of it. Explain yourself.”
Vala stood slowly, meeting his eyes, an almost arrogant confidence radiating from her.
“Your false consort is currently held in an unforgiving, cold place. He is… suffering." She was entirely too pleased sounding from Thorins point of view.
"They have two demands: The first, demand is public renunciation. The second, is a promise to marry a Dwarrow Queen by the end of the year.”
Vala's voice dropping, intimate,“I see the hunger in your eyes even now, the same hunger you had before the Quest."
She was attempting her dancing seduction again, "I know I hold the physical truth you crave, the kind of beauty that asserts itself. We have history, we have blood, we share the weight of the crown.”
A collective gasp went through the hall. Fíli and Kíli looked ready to tear her apart, but Thorin raised a hand, stopping them.
Thorin stared at Vala, his blue eyes intense. The only way to him is through her vanity. I will play the fool.
“You are very bold, Vala,” Thorin said, letting a flicker of doubt touch his voice. “A Queen must be bold. Tell me why I should not have you cast into the dungeons for this insolence.”
“Because, my King,” Vala countered, placing a hand lightly on his hip, her gaze holding his, “deep down, you know I speak the truth of your blood. You feel the pull of duty and the heat of ambition.," she whispered against his lips.
"You miss the strength of a true Dwarrow companion. I am strength. I am lineage. And I am willing to forgive your brief lapse in judgement," trying to coax his hands onto her body.
Thorin let out a sigh that sounded like the collapse of a stone pillar, leaning into her proximity. The contact—the intimacy—captured her.
Vala pressed her chest closer to his, her voice still dropped and intimate. “Those long, cold nights of exile. My offer as a presence was the one true fire that never dimmed. You were always drawn to strength.”
Thorin fought the urge to flinch, forcing a return whisper. “You speak of necessity, Vala, and the words cut deep because they are true."
He was going to gut her.
"My judgment was clouded by the Quest. You are right to challenge the choice of a foreign Consort. A momentary lapse of duty must be corrected for the sake of Erebor.”
Vala smiled, a predatory expression of absolute victory. “I knew the little hobbit was merely a passing fancy, my King."
She falsely lowered her lashes in shyness, "I am the mountain made flesh. What stability can a soft creature bring you that I cannot? I will secure your legacy."
She wriggled against him, "I will bear the next Kings and Queens of the Mountain. We will forge an empire of true Durin steel.”
Thorin took her hand, his thumb stroking her knuckles in a gesture of false commitment. "You require public validation. I understand."
He sunk the last stone in his trap, "Once I have the location and retrieve the prisoner, I will issue a decree. I will announce to the court that the period of sentimentality is over."
Thorin was a clever prince at court in Erebor's past, and made ruthless in his fierce and jealous love of Bilbo.
"I will publicly recognize the superiority of your lineage and confirm our political alliance in front of the entire court." He raised her hand like he would next poison himself to kiss her.
"Is that the reassurance you need?"
Vala was ecstatic.
Thorin wrapped his free hand around her other wrist, “Tell me the precise location now, Vala. Give me proof of your loyalty, and I will issue the decree immediately after the threat is neutralized."
Vala gave him the location, detailing the obscure tunnel entrance of Gamma-Seven, and immediately dispatched a swift message to Borin and Gróri: The King has chosen the bloodline and confirms the alliance.
Dispose of the foreign weakness.
As soon as the last word was spoken, Thorin seized her wrists and flung them aside with a violence that shocked her.
The mask of temptation shattered, revealing the furious King. The contrast was devastating.
“You have served your purpose, rock-brained fool,” Thorin’s voice was venomous, a low rumble of absolute contempt that cut Vala to the core.
“You mistook my desperate urgency to save my true love for lust for you." He advanced on her like an orc and she retreated.
"You thought your vanity and your cheap seduction were enough to make me betray the finest, bravest, most beloved creature in all of Middle-earth?”
If Dwalin had placed his sword in his hand, Thorin would've killed her then.
He spat the words, his rage a physical heat. “You call yourself Durin steel? You are thin, chipped iron! Bilbo—my Amrâzu—he is true, tested Mithril!"
"He took a dragon's fire and walked away with my heart!" Vala had tripped on the hem of her ridiculous clothes.
"You, Vala, sought to defile his place and my love for him. That is the greater treason, and you will live in my deepest dungeon contemplating your pathetic failure!”
Balin dragged the petrified courti trollip back to a waiting guard.
Alliance Intrigue: Teasing and The Crush
“Gamma-Seven, Your Majesty. It's a dead end, full of unstable supports. They are waiting for your terms, but the conditions are deteriorating fast. We must move now,” Nori reported, his usual shifty manner replaced by sharp focus.
Simultaneously, Thranduil, alerted by Bard to Thorin's widely known meltdown and situation with Bilbo, arrived at Dale to find the King of Men preparing for war.
Thranduil surveyed the frantic preparation with a knowing smirk. “My dear King Bard, such urgency. Is the fate of the world truly dependent on a little hobbit’s constitution?”
Bard scowled, adjusting his armor awkwardly. He knows I’m flustered. He always knows.
“Your Majesty, it is dependent on keeping the King Under the Mountain sane. And frankly, the little hobbit is worth more than all the gold in Erebor," Bard reminded the elf.
"He is the reason for the peace. We ride because if we do not, the Dwarves will tear the alliance apart in their grief and vengeance." Tightening his vambrace.
"It is a strategic move," hensaid more gently. "Your Majesty, though I admit, I am also personally quite fond of Master Baggins.”
Thranduil approached Bard, his pale eyes studying the Man's flushed face. “Ah, fondness."
Thranduil reached out tomtighten Bard's other arm, "A dangerous emotion. And yet, one must admire the intensity of Durin’s affection."
His mouth turned to a small smile, "Tell me, Bard of Dale, in your opinion, is such absolute, possessive devotion an appealing trait in a King?”
Bard swallowed, feeling heat rise under his collar. He is definitely, deliberately provoking me.
“In a King, it implies focus and loyalty, Your Majesty. In a person… it is admirable, if perhaps a little overwhelming.” Bard neutrally added.
Bard's mind screamed, Gods, just look at the perfect line of his jaw.
He pointed out, “I believe it is time to move, King Thranduil.”
Thranduil’s lips curved into a subtle, feline smile. “Indeed. We should rescue the little darling. But tell Thorin: I am the healer. He is the brute. He is to contain his fury until I have secured the patient."
His long fingers tucking a piece of Bard's hair back into place, "I too would want to watch the world burn if someone is so cherished was brutalized with no other motive than power."
Bard almost swallowed his own tounge.
"Let us show them the true strength of an alliance—the readiness to protect what is beloved,” and the elf strode off.
The Vengeance of the Durins
The rescue party—Thorin, Dwalin, Fíli, Kíli, and the Elven squad—breached the shaft. Thorin’s bellow of righteous fury when he saw Bilbo was a sound that shook the weakened stone.
Thorin did not speak. He moved with the focused, terrible speed of a King protecting his mate. Borin was dispatched not with ceremony, but with a swift, brutal force, his traitorous ambition extinguished in a heartbeat.
Gróri, the brute who sought to defile, found himself trapped between the two Princes of Erebor, their faces hard and cold.
“You came to teach us a lesson about weakness, Dwarf,” Kíli hissed, his arrow aimed at Gróri’s thigh.
“But all you taught us is that true strength lies in what you protect, not what you destroy.”
“You targeted the one who taught us mercy and honour,” Fíli added, his sword a flashing line of silver.
“You thought he was soft. You thought you could leave a mark on our family and call it purification.”
Gróri lunged, but the brothers were relentless. They moved with the deadly harmony of warriors who had fought side-by-side since childhood, fueled by the deepest protective love. Gróri fell, cut down by their precise, unforgiving blades.
Thorin, having secured the chamber, rushed to Bilbo. He carefully cradled the hobbit, his large hands trembling.
“Amrâzu! My heart’s desire,” Thorin choked out, burying his face in Bilbo’s hair. “I have you. They are gone. You are safe. Look at me, little one.”
Bilbo weakly grasped the beard that meant home and safety. “You came. You always come. I am here, Thorin. Just hold me. I need to feel your armor, your strength. Their touch… it was just filth. It never touched us.”
The Healing and the Vow of Consent
Thranduil knelt beside Bilbo, his Elven eyes assessing the deeper, unseen wounds. He administered a potent, calming elixir and spoke with quiet authority.
“The body will mend, Master Baggins. But the memory of the violation must be separated from the sanctity of your true bond,”
Thranduil instructed. “Take the light I offer, and hold onto the love you possess. You are whole, never forget that.”
Later, after the physical wounds were dressed, Thorin insisted on caring for Bilbo alone in their private chamber.
He stripped off his armor, feeling vulnerable and deeply ashamed that he hadn't been there.
“My King, you look like you’re about to fight a dragon,” Bilbo murmured weakly, watching Thorin pace.
Thorin stopped at the bedside and knelt, resting his arms on the mattress, not daring to touch Bilbo without invitation.
“I feel like I lost one, Ishmel,” Thorin confessed, his voice ragged.
“I should have been here. I should have protected you from my own kin. I want to hold you, to smother you with affection, but I cannot. Not yet."
His smile was Grimm "I need to know that every touch I give you, every moment of intimacy, is entirely, absolutely on your terms. You must be the one to decide when, and how, and how much.”
Bilbo reached out, placing his small, trembling hand on Thorin’s beard.
“Thorin, I want you. I want your love more than air. But yes. I need to feel that safety again. I need to know that your possessiveness is about devotion, not dominion."
Bilbo's voice turned urgent, "Promise me that if I ever pull away, even in my sleep, you will stop instantly, without question.”
Bilbo spoke again, his voice weak and full of lingering doubt.
“The meeting, Thorin… Vala… I heard… a report. She is beautiful, Thorin. She is everything a Dwarf King is supposed to need."
"Did you… did you truly consider her terms? Did you ever, for a moment, think she was a better fit?” he finally asked.
Thorin leaned close, his massive frame radiating warmth. He held hand, kissing the knuckles repeatedly.
“My foolish, brave Ishmel,” Thorin whispered, his voice thick with emotion.
“I risked your trust to save your life. I allowed her to touch me because her vanity was the only key to your location," he wanted to wash her very touch from his body immediately after this.
"I played a role, and for that, I apologize from the deepest part of my soul, for I should have protected you from that lie, too.” Thorin hung his head, long dark hair hiding his face.
He then met Bilbo’s gaze, his eyes shining with absolute honesty. “Vala was a handsome Dwarf, yes. But she is cold."
"She was duty in The Blue Mountains, when I thought Erebor lost forever and you, my One not in reach."
He dropped to.his knees beside his only reason to breathe, "You, Bilbo, are love. You are fire. You are joy. When she touched me, I felt nothing but utter revulsion and a deep, possessive longing for you."
His breath was almost panicking, "You are not replaceable. You are not a temporary fancy. You are the King’s Consort, and I love you—your softness, your strength, your small hand, your immense heart—more than any gold or throne.”
Thorin took Bilbo’s hand and kissed it, a deep, reverent pressure against his skin. “I swear it, by the stone and the stars, and by the love I hold for you."
"You have absolute control. Your consent is my law, my love. They tried to take your agency, but I will spend every day of my life giving it back to you. You are whole. You are sacred. And you are mine, freely given and freely taken.” his blueneyes burned with his words.
He gently kissed Bilbo, a kiss of complete, consensual adoration, erasing the memory of the filth. “She offered me strength without a soul. You gave me a soul. You are my home, Bilbo. I choose you. Always.”
Meanwhile, the alliance continued in Dale, where Bard and Thranduil met.
“Your Elven medicine is truly magnificent, Your Majesty,” Bard commented, trying not to stare too long at the way the torchlight caught the silver of Thranduil's hair.
I am crushing like a schoolboy.
Thranduil inclined his head. “It requires a strong spirit to heal, and Master Baggins possesses that."
"And speaking of strong spirits, King Bard, you showed admirable focus under extreme duress. You maintained your calm while the King Under the Mountain was having a glorious fit of possessive jealousy." He moved closer to Bard.
Running a finger down Bard's lewther clad arm, "I find that stability… quite compelling.”
Bard, completely flustered, gave a small, nervous laugh. “I try, Your Majesty. I just try to manage the chaos.”
“And you do it beautifully, King of Men,” Thranduil said, his eyes holding Bard’s a moment longer than necessary, his smile hinting at many unsaid things.
Found Family and The Light Endures
The recovery was long but steady, sustained by the endless affection of the Company.
Dwalin maintained a near-constant presence outside the door, his silence a comforting fortress.
Bofur brought a miniature carved wooden hobbit and placed it by Bilbo’s bedside. “Welcome home, lad. We’ll just sit right here until all the bad dreams are chased out. And if you’re hungry, I’ve got twice-baked potatoes and the thickest stew in all of Erebor.”
Fíli and Kíli spent hours on the floor nearby, polishing weapons and talking loudly about mundane mountain life, ensuring the silence couldn't sneak in.
“Did you see the look on Borin’s face, Kíli?” Fíli asked, polishing a helmet. “The disbelief! He genuinely thought his pitiful plot would succeed.”
“Pathetic,” Kíli scoffed. “They never understood. They thought Uncle Thorin loved Bilbo for some political reason. They didn't realize that Uncle Bilbo is the reason. He is the King’s weakness, which makes him the mountain’s greatest strength.”
Bilbo smiled, nestled safely in Thorin’s embrace, receiving soft, consensual kisses on his forehead.
Surrounded by his fiercely protective family, he knew the darkness had failed. He was home, and he was loved—wholly, truly, and with absolute consent. The mountain's heart beat strong again.
Kili got a mischievous sparkle in his eye watching them, "Dearest Uncles! Did we ever tell you about the time Fili, Ori and I played the ultimate prank?"
Ori, having just walked in with a new stack of books for Bilbo, immediately pushed them in Dwalins hands and made to escape.
