Chapter Text
As the days passed, Bilbo and Amaranth gradually became acquainted with everyone staying in the Last Homely House. There was not much opportunity to socialise with everybody all at once. Meals, for example, were only served twice a day! Breakfast was eaten rather late at nine o’clock, and it was an informal affair not attended by many. Dinners at seven o’clock in the evening were a more formal occasion when one was most likely to meet the majority of those who dwelled in Imladris, or at the gathering in the music hall after, during which the elves would sing late into the night. Yet, attendance was never mandatory anywhere at any time - in the Last Homely House, all were free to do as they wished.
The hobbits spent a lot of time in the kitchens. They could not eat as little as two meals a day; their bodies required at least three times as much food. Thus, Bilbo and Amaranth prepared their own additional meals, often baking pies or cooking stews, sometimes soups. The kitchen staff liked to tease them about their high appetite, but the hobbits did not mind it, as it was done in good humour. In fact, Amaranth soon grew to prefer interacting with the kitchen staff to anyone else; they were cheerful and liked to joke, which made them less intimidating than most other inhabitants of Rivendell.
It would not take extraordinary insight to know why Amaranth found herself intimidated. Many elves of Imladris were ancient beings, etherally beautiful, who carried themselves with dignity and poise. The half-elves - lord Elrond himself and his twin sons Elladan and Elrohir - were hardly any different. The Rangers, a community of who lived in Rivendell, could intimidate one also, for they resembled the elves and half-elves in their tall posture, proud countenance, and the look of millennia worth of wisdom in their eyes. These characteristics could be found even in the young ones among them, most notably Estel, the ward of lord Elrond loved by all, whose bearing brought to mind the noble and mighty kings of old.
Bilbo himself had already been around such people and was not as affected by their presence as Amaranth, though he easily sympathised with her. He remembered very well how he had felt when he had been in Rivendell for the first time, and there also remained one elf who never ceased to intimidate Bilbo even at present - Glorfindel. This elf appeared to emanate a glow from within, air as if shifted around him, and nature hushed in his proximity. Glorfindel’s light and power awed other elves into silence, leave alone the hobbits. Bilbo dared not look at Glorfindel for too long and the mere thought of striking a conversation with him was inconciveable, epsecially after he heard about Glorfindel’s life and accomplishements. From Elladan, Bilbo found that Glorfindel had been born long enough ago to have gazed at the Two Trees of Valinor. Elrohir told Bilbo that Glorfindel had slain a Balrog, a freasome demon created though corrupting a Maia and one that matched the Maiar in power. Estel said that from the fight with the Balrog, Glorfindel had suffered death, but the Valar restored Glorfindel’s spirit for his brave deeds, and he returned to the world of living, gifted with powers almost level with those of a Maia.
Amaranth’s shyness was no wonder indeed. Bilbo did not fault her for it and understood it when he was the only one whose company she was comfortable with seeking. In fact, he welcomed this, for the two of them got along well. They spent many hours of the day with each other, eating together, enjoying the peace and quiet, or taking walks around all parts of Rivendell. Amaranth remained in constant awe of where she was and never tired of discovering new nooks and crannies in the House.
"I feel as though I had lived my whole life with my eyes closed,” she said to Bilbo while they explored how vast the collection of books, tomes and scrolls was in the library, "And only opened them when I entered the Valley. Does that make sense to you, Bilbo? Have you felt the same?”
Bilbo confirmed that he had shared her experience and thoughts. To hobbits like them, who came from a race that in general seldom did or wish to interact with the world outside of the Shire, Rivendell could be nothing but enlightening. In their eyes, Imladris seemed at once ancient and yet somehow untouched by time, as though there was a certain power present that continuously healed it from any dent of passing of years and preserved it in its best state. Indeed, Rivendell, if anything, was a place of healing and sanctuary. Here, even the most troubled could find true rest and breathe easy. Bilbo and Amaranth saw this effect on their own eyes whenever they met Halbarad at dinners: a man who they had got to know as grim now smiled quite often and at times even laughed. They could observe Rivendell’s influence in themselves as well - they had the best sleep of their lives and every day woke with more energy and joy.
A place such as this was bound to open a hobbit’s eyes to how vast and full of unknown wonders the world was. Amaranth’s curiosity was a perfectly normal reaction, and indulging it was no hardship to Bilbo. He quite enjoyed both imparting his knowledge of the elves and their history - for she wished to learn all there was to know about them - as well as strolling around the Last Homely House and the Hidden Valley. There was only one spot in the whole of Imladris that he avoided - the landing of stairs where he had stood with Thorin when they had talked about their childhoods and fireflies and then overheard the conversation between Gandalf and Lord Elrond about the madness in the line of Durin. Bilbo did not ever show that part of the House to Amaranth nor went near it himself. He pushed all thoughts and memories of Thorin out of his mind altogether whenever any appeared.
Yet, it was inevitable that Amaranth would want to walk those stairs and enjoy the view from the landing at some point. And so that day finally came: Amaranth, during an afternoon walk with Bilbo, pointed to the very landing of stairs that Bilbo could not bear to even glance at.
"Oh, look!” she exclaimed. "Why, the sights from there must be exquisite! Let us go there now!”
"I would rather not, if you don’t mind,” Bilbo replied, his heart pounding hard in his chest.
Bilbo had never had any trouble denying the wants and needs of those he did not care for or respect. When those toward whom he held opposite feelings were concerned, however, the matter was entirely different. Bilbo waited for Amaranth’s response with bated breath, terribly anxious about her taking offense.
Amaranth merely shrugged her shoulders. "All right,” she said. "I shall go there by myself some other time.”
Neither her tone nor expression indicated in any way that she had felt insulted. There was no hint of disappointment or upset in her demeanour. Bilbo was so relieved to see her indifference that he sighed out loud.
"Are you well, Bilbo?” Amaranth said, watching him with worry.
"I am,” Bilbo replied, his face alight with a smile.
He was very well indeed, at that moment. A certain lightness lifted his spirit. He had done it, he thought with joy, he had prioritized his own wishes! In fact, now that he had managed this, he could hardly believe how easy it had been!
Soon, the initial elation left him and disbelief took its place. Had doing this been so easy all this time, Bilbo wondered incredulously. Amaranth’s graceful reaction notwithstanding, was refusing others truly not nearly as challenging as he had feared? It now seemed so and he began to feel that he had been really rather silly. For so long, he found himself unable to follow the wishes of his heart and it could have been simple? Foolish indeed!
A morose mood overtook him. Once Amaranth retired to her rooms to rest after their walk, Bilbo returned to the fateful flight of stairs. He stood at the bottom and stared at the landing where, unbeknowst to him at the time, his heart had been set on the course that would change it forever.
Oh, how he had failed his own heart! There had been so many occasions when he could have talked with Thorin and yet he had not confessed. How could he forgive himself for wasting all the possible opportunities, he wondered. Tears of anger and despair rolled down his face.
Affected by these emotions, the hobbit heard footsteps approaching from behind him far too late. Before he could hide, the person noticed him and his state.
"Master Baggins!” Estel cried and rushed to Bilbo’s side. "Has something happened?”
The hobbit wiped his wet cheeks with his sleeve hastily.
"It is nothing,” he said, lowering his head in embarrassment.
"Is there any way in which I could help you? You are upset.”
"I do not think there’s anything you could do.”
"Are you certain?”
Bilbo was too surprised by the sound of genuine concern in Estel’s voice to continue averting his eyes. He regarded Estel and noted that there was such earnestness in the young Rnger’s gaze. Now the hobbit understood completely why everyone adored him. One who could care for others so easily, deeply and genuinely was bound to gain people’s affection. Bilbo himself could now feel fondness blooming in his heart for the lad.
"You are still young, are you not?” he said.
"I am not yet twenty.”
Estel could have either come of age recently or was soon about to, Bilbo suspected, though he did not know for sure when the Rangers were considered to reach maturity. When he thought of himself at the stage of life where now Estel was, his past self seemed still so very young to him. Bilbo around the age of thirty-three had had no conception of what awaited him in life. He felt an ache as he recalled how innocent he had been, without any worry, for at that time there had been nothing at all he could be concerned about.
"Then, in all your years to come,” Bilbo said, "May your heart never know what mine has got to know.”
"If I may,” the young Ranger replied. "I would like to hear what your heart has endured.”
Bilbo shook his head, as reluctant to discuss the matter as ever. "I don’t think I should trouble you with it.”
"I assure you it is no trouble at all, and speaking of it might ease your pain.”
The hobbit sighed, fondly exasperated by Estel’s insistence. Very well then, he thought. It would probably do no good to speak of this to a person who was so unlikely to understand what he had experienced - or so Bilbo sincerely wished for Estel’s sake - but he could not blame the lad for being curious. There was also the fact that one could find a certain comfort in sharing their greatest sorrows with a distant aquaintance; without familiarity, what one revealed did not hold the same weight. Estel would not know what and who Bilbo was referring to, and that gave the hobbit courage to speak of the matter at last.
"Love that could have been,” he said, his voice hushed and strained, “But never was and now cannot be. I hope your heart never knows that, Estel. The regret of not having chosen that love when I had the chance, the knowledge that I will never know what it’s like to have that love returned... it’s truly unbearable, sometimes.”
Estel bent down on one knee in front of Bilbo and squeezed the hobbit’s shoulder with his hand in a comforting gesture.
"I am sorry,” he said gently. "You carry a great burden in your heart indeed. I see how acute your pain is and so I understand that the love it has been caused by is just as strong, is it not?”
Bilbo could only nod in agreement, fresh tears welling in his eyes.
"Young I may be, but in my ten and nine years, I have met many different sorts of peoples and creautres as I tavelled Eriador, and heard of others from my kin. Thus, I know that there are many in this world who live their whole lives with no love in their hearts, sometimes even without any trace of genuine feeling. It is not so common to have loved as wholly and greatly as you have, or to be able to. No small blessing were you given, especially considering the short time we have to walk this world. It might ease your heart, I should hope, to recall what you have had instead of what you are wanting. That is the way in which elves soothe the ache of lack in their hearts; most of them experience it in their eternal lives. I believe it could help you. It has helped me, too.”
Bilbo did not know how to respond. He was stunned by Estel's wisdom - even though the lad being so wise was not so surprising when one remembered that he was Lord Elrond’s foster son - and deeply moved by his kindness. Greatitude almost overwhelmed him and he struggled to find the words to thank Estel but the young Ranger only smiled warmly and said that he was glad he could help.
The conversation left Bilbo in a daze for quite a long time. He could not stop pondering on what Estel had said. If he were to think about what he had been given, his blessings were indeed many. He had grown up in the peaceful Shire, in comfort and with two loving parents. After they passed, Primula, her family and the Gamgees supported him steadfastly. He had gone on the Quest, survived all its dangers, and returned to the Shire in one piece. He had met many people of different races who were kind, loyal and brave and whom he could call friends.
Even his love for Thorin, though difficult, he was grateful for. Bilbo did not wish to imagine never having met Thorin. What a privilege it was to have got to know the remarkable dwarf! The odds of the two of them meeting in the first place had been very low - as they came from two starkly different backgrounds and environments - let alone them sharing their singular friendship, trust and respect. It was such a gift indeed, Bilbo realised, to have admired and loved Thorin as he had; if the Valar kept returning him to the Middle Earth to relive his lifetime, he would do it all over again every time.
He shed tears as he reached this understanding but these tears were not bitter; they were tears of joy and relief, and at last, the storm in his heart calmed.
