Actions

Work Header

Assurance and Authority

Chapter 21: XXI

Notes:

I'm so sorry this chapter took so long!! Life has been quite busy and when it was not, I was out of inspiration. I managed to produce this chapter finally, though with great pains. I hope you enjoy 💕

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

On the third day of the stay of the unexpected dwarrow guests in Rivendell, Bilbo rose and readied himself for the day early enough to meet Amaranth, Lady Yani and Lady Dís in the dining room. As they broke their fast together, he told Amaranth of having invited Seis and Umi to the afternoon tea, to which Amaranth reacted with warm enthusiasm. She asked Lady Yani if she would join them for the tea as well, but the dwarrowdam declined. She claimed to still have a lot of sketches to complete and was not persuaded by Amaranth’s offer to help her with sketching again so that she could spare some time in the afternoon.

Bilbo wondered if Yani’s refusal could be attributed to avoidance; after all, the company of the parents of her lost beloved could bring her pain. Umí and Seis might return this same sentiment, he realised. This would also explain the reluctance of the couple to join the tour of Rivendell with Lady Dís, as they had surely expected the lady-in-waiting to be present.

Having understood this, Bilbo did not insist on Lady Yani coming to tea and gently steered Amaranth away from her pursuit of convincing the dwarrowdam, who promptly asked to be excused to continue with her sketching until dinner. Lady Dís granted her permission at once. Amaranth offered to accompany Lady Yani, which the dwarrowdam agreed to. The two finished breakfast and took their leave quickly after.

Once they left, Lady Dís said, "Have you formed any judgment regarding the concerns I shared with you, Master Baggins?”

"Not yet, my lady. I shall need to observe Amarnath’s behaviour around Lady Yani further, and if this doesn’t lead me to any conclusion, I might need to have a conversation with Amarnath.”

"I see. I was about to ask you to accompany me, as I am to take Master Loar around Rivendell. I told him of the tour you gave me, and he asked to be shown around as well, and I’m certain you would make a far better guide than I, but if you’d rather be with your cousin, then by all means feel no obligation to join us.”

Bilbo quickly decided that there still should be enough opportunities to observe Amaranth and Lady Yani. He did not wish to intrude as he would today without any prior arrangement; he would rather make plans together with them tomorrow. Therefore, he accepted Lady Dís’s invitation. Even though he had already promised a tour to Seis and Umí, he did not mind giving one more tour than he had planned, for he anticipated Loar to be an appreciative subject. Since the dwarf had demonstrated such curiosity in hobbits, Bilbo supposed he would enjoy learning more about elves as well.

It soon became clear that Loar was at most politely interested in elves, and seemed to pay more attention to Bilbo than to what Bilbo was showing in the House or describing. Only once they entered the smithy and Lady Dís told him of the techniques she had seen the elven smiths use did Loar finally show genuine interest. Then, Lady Dís noted that one work station was unoccupied, and she promptly began inspecting it.

"This is just the kind of hammer and anvil my brother enjoys working with,” she said. "If only anything could stop him from fulfilling his duties all the time! Say, Master Baggins, have you any idea what I must do to tear him away from his correspondence, constant planning and preparing, so that he would spend an afternoon to his own enjoyment?”

Bilbo hummed, considering the question. "I suppose you would have to hide all his letters, ink and parchment, teach his raven not to listen to him anymore, then threaten him with assigned bedrest under watch if he doesn’t take a break. You would also need to brace yourself for a staring match and him invoking his authority as King not to listen to you.”

Lady Dís roared with delighted laughter. "Oh, but you know him so well! You could make him do anything, how splendid!”

Bilbo blushed at this remark. "I think we both know that it is not possible to force Thorin to do anything. One can merely... influence his options.”

Lady Dís laughed again.

"It seems you do know His Majesty very well,” Loar said, a touch cooly.  

"Well, that was an inevitable outcome, if one takes into account what we’ve been through together on the Quest. Such trials could only create the strongest of friendships! Everyone in the Company has become great friends with each other.”

Bilbo’s response warmed Loar’s demeanour significantly, though the hobbit did not take much note of it, as his heart and mind became filled with sadness. Remembering the friendships among the Company made him miss his friends dearly, especially because he had not seen some of them since he had left Erebor eight years ago. Not for the first time, but perhaps with the greatest strength of feeling so far, he wished he could reunite with all of his friends.

The tour concluded soon after. Bilbo left his two companions to have a quick lunch in the kitchens. As he was leaving, he came across Elrohir.

"Master Baggins, I am so glad that I have found you!” the half-elf said. “I wished to let you know that we shall invite our dwarrow guests to an evening performance of the songs of the elves and the men, which would take place after dinner. I was wondering if we could count on your attendance, if you would be willing to join?”

"Why, yes, of course!”

"Excellent,” Elrohir said and took his leave.

Bilbo thought it a bit strange that Elrohir had to confirm Bilbo’s attendance, but he could not guess the reason for it, and thought of it no more. He quickly found Seis and Umí, who were again resting where they had been accommodated with all the other dwarrow whom Bilbo had met the day before. They greeted Bilbo warmly and invited Bilbo to sit with them and exchange more stories.

"But we must away!” Umí said. "I’m rather curious about what you’re going to show us, Bilbo.”

"Aye, lead the way!” Seis added.

Bilbo was more than happy to oblige. As he began showing his friends around Rivendell, he found them as appreciative as he had thought Loar should be; they listened to what Bilbo told them of elves and their history carefully, and even asked questions. When Bilbo guided them to the smithy, he expected them to like that place the most of all in the Last Homely House. Yet, he certainly did not expect to receive a lengthy lecture from Seis in which he explained to Bilbo exactly how some of the techniques the elven smiths were using were of dwarven origin, and how some of their ways were different. Seis spoke at length about how ores were smelted, various melting points of metals, and many more particulars of metalwork that Bilbo could not begin to comprehend it all.

When Bilbo was approaching the point when his head would start spinning from the overload of information, Umí laughed good-naturedly and said to her husband, "My dear, but you shall make our Bilbo detest the very word ‘metal’ if you say it one more time! Save your passion to share with one less struggling to understand you, my treasure. What would you like us to see next, Bilbo?”

The bell had rung a quarter to three some time ago, so Bilbo showed to where they should have tea. There, Amaranth was already waiting with a teapot and a plate of biscuits. The table was not yet set, and Bilbo took care of it quickly. 

As they sat down together and began enjoying the tea and refreshments, the conversation centred on Rivendell. Seis and Umí told Amaranth of all the places in the House they had seen, and how they had come to enjoy staying here, which Amaranth strongly seconded with her own experiences. Then, Seis raised the subject of the journey ahead of them and asked Bilbo about what they could expect. The first thing Bilbo mentioned that he thought significant was the trek though the Misty Mountains - he warned that they should expect it to be difficult and dangerous - but the effort made when crossing the Mountains should be greatly rewarded once they find themselves on the other side and behold the mighty Lonely Mountain for the first time. As Bilbo described the great feeling of hope he had experienced when he saw the sole peak for the first time as he stood upon the Carrock and how impressive the Mountain had looked at a closer distance, Seis and Umi were smiling bright and with excitement.

"You make it sound like the most splendid sight!” Seis said. "I cannot wait to see it! Have you ever wanted to see it again yourself, Bilbo?”

"I have, yes, but there are many commitments that I have as Master of Bag End and the head of the Baggins clan, and it is a very long journey to the Mountain; I could not simply run out of my door again.”

"Oh, but you could take a break,” Amaranth said, "Now that Drogo is acting in your stead. I’m sure it would be no trouble if you wish to go.”

"Going to Erebor is no going on a picnic!” Bilbo retorted.

Before he could make his point further, Umí asked, "What does going on a picnic entail? I have not heard of such a thing.”

Her question prevented the impending debate between the two hobbits. Amaranth happily explained what picnics were and how they were practised by their kind.

"Well, a journey such as that to Erebor is no thing of leisure for sure,” the dwarrodam said once she understood picnics.

"Exactly!” Bilbo exclaimed. "And if I wanted to go to the Lonely Mountain, I’d need someone to accompany me; travelling so far alone would be silly.”

"I could be your travel companion,” Amaranth replied, "If you do decide to make that journey.”

"You’d wish to travel so far?” 

"If my accident and illness taught me anything, then it is to seize opportunities as they arise; one never knows how much time will be given to them. If you travelled to Erebor, then I would love nothing more than to go with you. My stay in Rivendell has made me want to see even more of the world.”

This gave Bilbo a lot to ponder. Amaranth’s wish to go to Erebor painted a picture of the future that at once made his heart ache and filled it with joy. On the one hand, he would miss living in Bag End with Primula and her family most terribly, and he would not see little Frodo grow up for at least a year or two while he was gone. It would also weigh on his conscience to be the one cause for Amaranth’s separation from her family for such a long time. Thirdly, Bilbo was rather reluctant to ask Drogo to fulfil the responsibilities of the Master of Bag End and head of the Bagginses for so much longer; even though Bilbo did not doubt that Drogo would be willing to do so, it was no small request.

Yet, if Drogo relieved Bilbo of his duties, then very little would stand in the way of him being able to leave for the Lonely Mountain. Now that Bilbo could see indications of King Thorin being open to rebuilding their friendship, he was no longer unsure of his welcome in Erebor. Indeed, the only thing that could prevent him and Amaranth from embarking on such an adventure would be if Amaranth did not return to full health or, Bilbo perished the thought as it appeared, her health worsened. Having this in mind, he determined that he should discuss whether it was feasible for Amaranth to travel the distance to the Lonely Mountain before he let his excitement grow. He hoped to talk to Lord Elrond at dinner to set the time for a discussion, yet the Lord was unfortunately absent (as was King Thorin and Gandalf).

During dinner, Elladan and Elrohir extended the invitation for all dwarrow to come to the music hall to enjoy the evening of singing. The best songs of elves and men would be performed, they said, and the dwarrow were also welcome to sing any songs of their people they were willing to share. This elicited a murmur of interest from the dwarrow guests, and once the dinner was finished and Elrond’s sons asked to follow them to the music hall, the majority of the dwarrow did. Bilbo went with Seis and Umí but upon reaching the door of the room, he excused himself, saying that he wished to enjoy some fresh air. From where he stood, he could see that Lord Elrond and Gandalf were already inside, seated at the high table. Lady Dís, her lady-in-waiting, Amaranth and Loar were making their way to the table following Elladan.

Bilbo knew he could join them, even talk to Elrond about Amaranth if he wanted, but he chose to linger by the entrance for a while. King Thorin simply had to have been invited, he reasoned, and he wished to see if he had accepted. Perhaps,Bilbo thought, he could mention the idea of his coming to Erebor and find Thorin’s reaction.

After a few minutes of anxious wait, Bilbo heard the familiar heavy footsteps, and the King of Durin Folk stood before him.

"Thorin! You have come for the evening singing!”

"I was hoping that Elrond could read more moon runes for me. Have I come to the wrong place?”

Thorin said this with a perfectly straight face but with a spark of good humour in his eye, and Bilbo, quite suddenly even to himself, burst into loud laughter.

"Are you truly the same Thorin I followed on the Quest?” he said jokingly. "I hardly recognise you; the Thorin I know would loath to listen to elven songs, in Rivendell especially!”

"The Thorin you had got to know should’ve already possessed the wisdom that you had at the time. Alas, I’ve tardily accepted that Elron’s generosity and hospitality are not to be slighted.”

Bilbo was much surprised by this and did not comment on the King’s unexpected humility. "Do you plan on staying long at Elrond’s?”

"Around a week more.”

"Only a week? Why, that’s hardly enough to enjoy Elrond’s hospitality! Do you not wish to stay longer?”

"Wish for it I may, but we have a few months of journey ahead of us, as you know, and my return to Erebor is anxiously awaited. Fíli says in his letters that he’s become so weary of ruling as regent that he’s going to need at least four decades to recuperate.”

"Well then,” Bilbo said weakly. His heart became heavy with terrible sorrow - there was so little time left that he could have with Thorin! "Any more delay would be most unwelcome, and I hope that Fíli will forgive you for the length of your absence. You can blame hobbits for all the time you were held up in the Blue Mountains.”

"There’s nothing else to blame for it than misfortune, do not be troubled with it.”

"And yet, I do worry how much trouble the whole affair in Blue Mountains caused, not only for you and Fíli, but for Amaranth as well.” Bilbo took a step towards the King and spoke in a hushed tone, "Your sister suspects that Amaranth might have developed affection for Lady Yani during their blooming friendship.”

The expression on King Thorin’s face darkened. "My sister has many ideas that I would not consider reasonable, Master Baggins,” he said brusquely, then paused. A glint of nervousness showed in his eyes. "And yet, there are certain matters that could remain unsaid in some friendships; one side could be withholding feelings they believe are not reciprocated, and never dare confess, for they do not wish to risk affecting the friendship they so value. I would not wish this fate for Miss Brandybuck or any friend, only foe.”

Bilbo’s heart pounded loudly in his chest. Was it at all possible, he thought anxiously, for King Thorin to know of Bilbo’s feelings for him? There was undeniable earnestness in Thorin’s gaze, which led Bilbo to understand that he spoke from experience, but whose experience was he referring to?

The hobbit did not have the chance to ponder this any more, as their conversation was interrupted by Elrohir’s appearance.

"Your Majesty, I am glad that you accepted our invitation for this evening,” the half-elf said. "May I ask you to sit with my father, brother, and me? You are more than welcome to join us as well, Master Baggins.”

Bilbo, now knowing how little time with Thorin there was left, had no qualms in accepting the offer. Offering Seis and Umi a quick apology as he passed them, the hobbit followed Elrohir to the table at the dias together with King Thorin, where Lady Dís, Lady Yani, Amaranth and Loar were already seated. The King took a seat on the side of his sister, and Amaranth gestured for Bilbo to sit next to her, which put him between her and Loar.

Just after Bilbo was seated, Elladan and Elrohir stood in the middle of the hall and thanked everyone for coming. Then, the sweet melody of harps and flutes filled the air, and the sons of Elrond began to sing the first song of the evening. Their voices were as beautiful as those of elves, and Bilbo quickly forgot all about where he was. Their singing transported Bilbo, as if by some magic, to different times and places, and painted the pictures of stories told by the verses in his mind with such clarity that he felt as though he could see the events with his own eyes. Even when Bilbo did not understand some of the Sindarin or Quenya lyrics at times, the emotion in the voices of the singers conveyed all he needed to know. The only time Bilbo had a similar experience was when he had heard King Thorin and his Company sing ‘The Misty Mountains Cold’ in Bag End.

Bilbo was shaken out of his trance by a remark from Lady Yani, which she said with great disappointment.

"They sing very well indeed, but I wish I could understand what they were singing about.”

Bilbo, with his knowledge of Quenya, provided the general context of the story told in the song, about the Fall of Gil-galad. Then, in a murmured tone, he narrated the meaning of the verses sung.

"The countless stars of... heaven’s field were mirrored in his silver shield... Translating the word into ‘heaven’ here does not convey the original sense exactly, yet no other term would make better sense, though you must take my judgement with a grain of salt; I am a poor Quenya scholar.”

"So I see you are,” Loar said. "You have only enough of the elven tongue to translate it into comprehensible Common Speech at the time of hearing it. You need not say anything more of your ignorance. There is complete proof!”

Bilbo shook his head with a smile. "I should hate to be examined by a real proficient; indeed, I have not spoken Quenya to any of the elves here.”

"You are too modest. The world knows not half of your accomplishments.”

"Master Loar, this is too much flattery.”

"I do not think I could ever flatter you enough.”

Before Bilbo could formulate a response, his attention was drawn away by the sudden movement of King Thorin rising from his seat.

"Do you take my meaning, Bilbo?’ Loar said as Bilbo watched King Thorin head towards the exit of the music hall. "Or must I translate for you?”

The dwarf’s meaning was rather lost on Bilbo, who excused himself promptly and rushed after Thorin. He stood in the King’s way just before the door. For a second, they only held each other’s gaze, while a female elf began to sing a new song.

"Are you leaving already?” Bilbo said.

"Yes.”

"But the singing is good, is it not?

"I do not much care.”

"But will you not...”

"What?” Thorin snapped.

"This is too sudden!”

"Is it?”

"What is the matter with you, Thorin?”

"Nothing,” Thorin scoffed. "Nothing at all.”

It was then that Loar approached them.

"Master Baggins,” he said, "You must come back to explain elven again. Lady Yani dearly wishes to know the words of what she is hearing.”

"I bid you good night,” Thorin said to Bilbo and moved to exit the hall. Bilbo again stood in his way.

"This is a truly beautiful song, about the love of Beren and Luthien! Besides, perhaps you could sing yourself later? Everyone should hear how beautiful you sing! That has to be something worth staying for.”

“No,” Thorin said angrily, “There isn’t anything worth my staying for.”

He was gone momentarily.

Bilbo could not help but draw a comparison between Thorin’s behaviour and the way Rufus acted out of jealousy when he had stormed away after assuming Asphodel’s interest in the King, or his own silly envy as he had noticed Thorin’s interest in Amaranth. But then, this would mean that Thorin cared for him enough to be jealous, as well as that he sincerely believed there was a cause for jealousy, that he thought Loar’s attentions could win him Bilbo’s regard! Indeed, it seemed that Thorin had to believe Bilbo so indifferent to him! The notion was unbearable, and hearing more of Loar’s flattery as the evening progressed was misery.

Notes:

I bet that if Dís knew that Elladan and Elrohir joined her in her match-making efforts, she would find it cute. She's already ten steps ahead, though, has the whole wedding planned and done already, and is at this point thinking of all the shenanigans she could get up to with Bilbo as the Consort.

Also, I want to grab Bilbo by the shoulder and shake him until he gets it. It was SO CLOSE, Thorin was LITERALLY CONFESSING to him, omggggg I want to scream

AUGUST 1st EDIT: I accidentally posted a part of the next chapter instead of saving is as draft 💀💀 I deleted it immediately but I’m SO SORRY if you guys got a notification about a new chapter being posted 💔 I’ll try my best to update this story as soon as I can