Chapter Text
Weeks into their quiet life, the six companions decided to take a day trip. The shore near Alqualondë featured a magnificent reconstructed city, a tribute to the ancient glory of Númenor, built by the Noldor. It was a place of soaring white architecture, marble plazas, and shimmering fountains—a truly breathtaking spectacle.
The family was a study in comfortable contrasts: Bilbo and Thorin walked hand-in-hand, radiating quiet contentment. Kili and Tauriel were ahead, debating the structural integrity of a massive white obelisk. Frodo walked with Fili, listening with a soft, affectionate smile as the dwarf prince enthusiastically described the metallurgy of the Númenórean bridges.
They were near a large, sweeping terrace overlooking the sea when the atmosphere curdled.
A small party was approaching, dominated by a figure Frodo instantly recognized from vague childhood memories and Gandalf's descriptions: King Thranduil of the Woodland Realm, accompanied by several guards. Thranduil, impossibly tall and crowned with shimmering, intricate leaves, looked every inch the self-important king he was rumored to be.
He paused when he saw the group, his gaze freezing on Thorin and the others, his lips curling with undisguised contempt.
“Indeed,” Thranduil said, his voice carrying clearly across the silent plaza, dripping with aristocratic disdain. “It seems even here, amidst the perfection of the Undying Lands, the Elves cannot fully scrub away the unsightly dust and soot of Middle-earth. It is a profound failure of aesthetics to allow the sight of dwarves to pollute this view.”
The public insult was sharp and immediate. Kili stiffened, his hand dropping automatically to where a sword should have been. Thorin’s face turned instantly to granite, his eyes flashing with the fury of ancient memory. Tauriel stepped forward, her body tense, ready to defend her family.
Fili quietly laid a heavy, restraining hand on Kili’s shoulder. “Not worth it, brother,” he murmured.
Thranduil, satisfied with the reaction, swept past, his robes rustling with self-importance, leaving a wake of ruined joy and bitter silence.
The trip was utterly spoiled. The dwarves’ anger was palpable, simmering just beneath the surface, while Tauriel quietly cursed in a flurry of Elvish that Frodo had never heard.
The Hobbit Plot
Back in the cozy familiarity of the blue-door house, Thorin was pacing, his rage radiating outward like heat.
“The audacity! The sheer, unadulterated gall of that long-necked, empty-headed fool!” Thorin roared, slamming his fist onto the workbench.
“Hold, my King,” Bilbo said calmly, taking Thorin’s hand. “He is only powerful because we allow his words to hurt us. We are better than him.”
“We should challenge him to a duel!” Kili insisted, still fuming.
“We should lock him in a poorly ventilated mine shaft,” Fili countered, his voice quiet but intense.
Frodo, however, was silent. He exchanged a long, meaningful look with his Uncle Bilbo. The look said: Dwarves use hammers. Elves use magic. Hobbits use stealth and mischief.
“We are not warriors here,” Frodo announced, setting down his mug. “We are hobbits. And hobbits, when insulted, prefer to deal with the problem in a distinctly Shire fashion.”
“A strongly worded letter?” Tauriel asked, confused.
Bilbo winked. “No, my dear. We prefer petty vengeance combined with total anonymity. We prefer to burgle.”
The plot was hatched with the glee of a game well-played. Thranduil, being a king, had a very private residence, hidden deep within a secluded Elvish copse. That night, under the cover of the perpetual twilight, Bilbo and Frodo, moving with the practiced silence of the world’s greatest burglars, crept through the foliage.
They easily slipped past the elegant, unobservant Elvish guards. They located Thranduil’s inner sanctum—a room dedicated entirely to his magnificent golden hair. There were countless vials, essences, and serums. They found a large, ornate bottle of what looked like a rich, conditioning hair mask.
Frodo produced the two tiny vials he’d prepared: concentrated food coloring left over from a batch of ridiculously colorful Shire sweets that Bilbo had baked the week before. They emptied the contents of both vials—a vibrant, dazzling neon pink—into the Elvish conditioner, shaking it well.
“Let’s see how much he enjoys his aesthetics now,” Frodo whispered, his eyes sparkling with a delightful, criminal malice.
The Pink King and the Mediator
The next morning, the grand plaza of Númenor was interrupted by a shriek so loud and enraged it seemed to shake the very foundations of the city. King Thranduil appeared, not in majestic golden splendor, but with a crown of wet, shoulder-length hair dyed an absolutely brilliant, aggressive fuchsia.
He marched straight to Elrond’s quarters, demanding justice.
Elrond, who had aged gracefully into an even more patient and wise figure, found the sight of his frantic kinsman hilarious, though he managed to compose his features. He immediately knew who the culprits were and summoned the two hobbits to his study.
Thranduil stood vibrating with fury, pointing a manicured, pink-tinged finger at the four accused. “These… these vagrants! They have desecrated me! They have ruined my person! I demand restitution! Exile! A formal washing service, at the very least!”
Elrond raised a hand, stopping the tirade. “Calm yourself, Thranduil. We are here to mediate, not to condemn. Master Baggins, Master Frodo. Do you have anything to say about the King’s… current appearance?”
Frodo gave a look of wide-eyed innocence. “I’m afraid I don’t know what the King is talking about, Lord Elrond. Perhaps he should check his hair care products for any stray sweets?”
Elrond sighed, hiding a smile. “Bilbo. A word of truth, please.”
Bilbo stepped forward, his eyes stern, his posture straight. He looked Thranduil directly in the eye.
“We did it, yes,” Bilbo stated simply. “And we are proud of it. We did it because you came into a place of peace, where my love, my family, and my kin are finally happy and healing, and you poisoned the air with your vile, outdated prejudice against honest hearts. You belittled a King who reclaimed his home, and you insulted two princes who gave their lives for their people. You called them dust and soot, but they are gold and granite. You need to look around, Thranduil. The Third Age is over. The petty squabbles of old are gone. They are the future of Arda, and they are my family.”
Frodo stepped beside his uncle, equally serious. “And if that wasn’t enough, Thranduil, look at your own son. Legolas and Gimli, son of Glóin—a Dwarf, a Dwarf!—became the dearest of friends. Their love and loyalty saved the world, yet you still carry this stupid, tiny grudge. You need to grow up, King. You’ve been given the Undying Lands to finally learn humility.”
Elrond watched the exchange with mounting satisfaction. This was far better than any Elvish argument.
“Thranduil,” Elrond intervened, sensing the King was genuinely stung by the reference to Legolas. “The hobbits possess an antidote. I will allow them to pass it on only under one condition: You must make a public and honest apology for your egregious behavior toward King Thorin, Prince Fili, and Prince Kili. They, and their companions, deserve it.”
A Rosy Apology
The apology took place later that day on the same plaza where the insult had occurred. Thranduil, still dazzlingly pink, looked utterly miserable, but he faced the gathered crowd of Elves and his targeted family.
He spoke with difficulty, referencing the profound connection between Gimli and Legolas that had challenged his own entrenched prejudices.
“I apologize,” Thranduil said, his voice stripped of its arrogance. “I was foolish and small-minded. I allowed ancient, outdated hatred to blind me to true nobility and courage. King Thorin, Prince Fili, and Prince Kili are brave and honorable. And the Hobbits and Tauriel are welcomed here. I regret my words, and I apologize to you all.”
Thorin stepped forward, he had grown more forgiving thanks to his Hobbits pressence in his new life, his fury finally dissolved by the honesty of the admission. “We accept your apology, Thranduil, on behalf of the House of Durin. Let the old quarrels be buried.”
Fili and Kili, however, were not quite done. As the crowd dispersed, Kili elbowed his brother, already humming a tune.
“Did you hear that, brother?” Kili asked loudly. “It was a beautiful apology. A real rosy-colored apology! We must make a song about the King and his rosey-colored hair!”
Fili grinned, tapping out a rhythm on his leg. “Indeed. We should call it, ‘The Ballad of the Pink King.’ A true Dwarvish epic.”
The hobbits stepped forward and presented Thranduil with a small, clear vial.
Thranduil snatched it immediately. As he stalked back toward Elrond's dwelling, he paused only long enough to mutter under his breath, loud enough for Elrond to hear: “I cannot believe this. First my own dungeons in Greenwood, then the very river in my own halls, and now this. I am always being burgled, no matter where I live!”
Elrond simply shook his head, a genuine smile on his face, clearly delighted by the hobbit justice.
The family returned home, leaving the King of the Woodland Realm to contemplate his life choices, and the rest of Valinor to quietly enjoy the joke.
Frodo felt lighter than he had since leaving the Shire, armed with the knowledge that his new family was fiercely defended, and that sometimes, a good prank was the best medicine.
