Chapter Text
It was galling to admit it, but occasionally Thorin had to concede that his brother was cleverer than he was.
The next morning had broken and even before Thorin could line up his thoughts, Frerin had been there with bright eyes and challenging expression. In his hands was the latest of poor Ori's schedules, with crossings-out and corrections and scribbles and blotches of ink all over it. New crossings-out indicated that changes had only recently been made, and the stabbing motion of the words indicated that Ori had not done so graciously.
He gave Thorin no chance to dwell upon his recent shock, nor his behaviour over the last day or so. "Up you get, nadadel," he said, and Thorin snarled at him – and obeyed. His anger had nearly run its course, and only a dull echoing emptiness was left behind. The teetering wall of his faults loomed over him, but Frerin refused to let him lie there and wait for the inevitable avalanche. He kept up a steady stream of nonsense talk, even as Thorin dressed and washed his face.
Then he held open the door and jerked his chin, his braids swinging. "After you."
Thorin scowled, but stalked from his rooms nonetheless.
At the Chamber of Sansûkhul, Thorin was greeted by Frís, Balin, and his nephews. He sent a suspicious glance back at Frerin, who only shook the tattered schedule cheerfully in answer.
"That's who is rostered, nadad," he said, innocence radiating from every pore.
Thorin snorted. No doubt Frerin had wheedled and badgered and hung all over poor Ori until he had changed the schedule to Frerin's satisfaction, surrounding Thorin with so many of his nearest and dearest: with those who gave him strength. "Oh, I have no doubt."
Frís smoothed down his tunic absently. "Have you eaten?" she asked, and Thorin gave her a long, flat look.
Fíli screwed up his face. "That's a no, and he doesn't much care either."
"I brought bread and cheese," Kíli said, digging through his pockets.
"Can you bring food into the star-pool?" said Balin, taken aback.
"I don't know," Kíli said, shrugging and continuing to hunt. "It's in the nature of an experiment."
"You won't catch anyone eating anything that's been living in your pockets, trollbrain," Fíli grinned, nudging his brother. "That would be a far more hazardous experiment."
Kíli scowled and elbowed Fíli in return. Before they could begin a scuffle, Thorin cleared his throat sharply and said, "I am not hungry. If we are assembled?"
"You will eat when we break for a rest, my dear one," Frís said in a low voice as they moved to their places around Gimlîn-zâram, her hand grasping for his and squeezing. "I trust you, but I worry. Please."
He let out a soundless sigh, and nodded once.
She smiled, though there was no joy in it. "Good. Thank you. You make me proud, my inùdoy. This too shall pass, as all things pass."
"If my life and death have taught me anything, 'amad," Thorin said quietly, starlight reflecting from his face and shining in his hair and eyes, "it is that nothing is forever."
Her hand clamped down upon his tightly, and then the stars of Gimlîn-zâram swallowed them whole.
"Trees," he heard Balin say, somewhat confused. "More trees. What is all this? What has happened?"
Thorin was too busy blinking the blinding radiance from his eyes to answer. Shapes and shadows had been etched onto the underside of his eyelids, and the smells of Middle-Earth assaulted him all at once. "Horses, loam, granite, sandstone, obsidian, water, ashes, iron – poor quality iron, heated with green logs," he muttered, and steadied himself as his eyes adjusted. "Where are we?"
"Isengard, I suspect, laddie," said Balin, and Thorin felt his cousin's hand touch him on the shoulder reassuringly as he moved past him. "Well, bless my beard! I see why young Ori was so worked up now. What a mess!"
Thorin squinted. He could see little as yet, but he knew the reflection of light upon water. Early morning sunshine glanced off a large body of water, gilding the ripples and sending flares of gold into the air. "But Isengard has no lake."
Fíli's laugh was a little high and shrill. "It does now."
Thorin blinked some more, and then he sucked in a breath.
They were standing beside a great pillar, shaped like a forbidding White Hand. Close below them spread out the valley of Isengard, just as Thorin had heard it described in his books when he was a child. A vast stone circle tucked against the southernmost reaches of the Misty Mountains, guarding the pass between Dunland and Rohan. A great tower of blackest obsidian reached to the sky from the centre of the valley, rising up from a small isle in the middle of the circle, all enclosed by high walls of stone.
It was full of water.
"What has happened?" he demanded, but no-one answered. Thorin glanced up to see the King and Gandalf pausing by the statue of the Hand, also looking down upon the wreck of Isengard. Behind them stood their small host of Rohirrim, including Éomer and Aragorn upon their horses. Had the sea in all its fury dashed itself against the hills, it could have worked no greater ruin. "Gandalf! What has happened here?"
"The Hand is no longer white," murmured Legolas from behind Thorin, and he whirled to see the Elf perched upon Arod with Gimli, as always, tucked against his back. "Gimli, mellon, do you see?"
Gimli grunted. "I see it. Well, that augurs ill for Saruman, doesn't it?"
Legolas smiled to himself and led Arod onwards behind the Wizard and Théoden-King, the grey horse carefully picking his way hoof-by-hoof amongst the trees that crowded close. "Indeed it does."
Thorin glowered at the Elf until he caught Frerin's eye, and then he tore his gaze away to look back at the flooded valley.
Aragorn raised his hand and stopped their advance. "Hold here," he said quietly. "The doors are cracked and splintered, and there may be peril ahead. Woods have long memories, and their anger does not cool quickly. We should not enter lest we be caught up in their rage."
"Ori was very distraught," Balin whispered, and Thorin made a gruff noise of assent beneath his breath.
"Ents," mused Frís to herself, tapping at her lip. "Ents..."
"I am told they are the children of Yavanna, just as we are the children of Mahal," Balin said to her with a deferential tip of his head. Then he smiled faintly. "Made to protect the green and voiceless things that grow against wood-hungry creatures such as ourselves. I heard tell once that they were created purely because Dwarves were: because we use so much wood in our crafts and our forges. And so the Danukinh pleaded for protectors for her creations. Thus the Ents came to be."
Balin always knew the old stories, Thorin thought, looking out over the devastation of Isengard. The Danukinh, the Green Lady. Thorin repressed a shiver. "Deep roots are stronger than stone," he murmured to himself, and pressed his heels into the ground as far as he could.
"Wait," said Gimli abruptly, and then his hand took hold of Legolas' shoulder, the wide fingers nearly engulfing it. "Look! There upon the wall!"
Thorin turned, eyes darting, half expecting to see one of these great and vengeful children of the Lady of the Olvar... and spied two tiny figures lying amongst the shattered stones atop the wall, perfectly at ease, plates and bottles scattered haphazardly around them. One tipped back his head lazily, and sent a pretty blue ring of smoke soaring into the air.
"No!" Frerin said, grasping at Thorin's arm, staring at them with excitement building in his eyes. "No!"
"Elbereth Gilthoniel," Legolas breathed aloud, his whole face alight with gladness. Gimli seemed ready to explode into shouting, only he could not decide upon which word.
At that moment, the smoking figure blinked and stood atop the wall, his little grey cloak flaring behind him. He held out a hand to steady himself as he bowed very low in as stately a manner as a tipsy Hobbit possibly could. Then he threw his head back and announced, "welcome, my Lords, to Isengard! We are the doorwardens."
Gimli made a loud and very strangled noise in his throat. Legolas' eyes were dancing with laughter, and Aragorn was, for once, grinning broadly. The expression seemed almost alien upon his face.
"Meriadoc son of Saradoc is my name; and my companion, who – alas! is overcome with weariness," - and here he gave his supine friend a dig with his foot – "is Peregrin son of Paladin, of the house of Took. The Lord Saruman is within; but at the moment he is closeted with one Wormtongue, or doubtless he would be here to greet such honoured guests."
Gandalf leaned back, smiling and shaking his head. "Hobbits."
"At any rate, he is much occupied, and so our orders came from Treebeard," Merry continued with grave dignity, swaying a little upon his curly feet. "He has taken over management of Isengard. He commanded me to greet the Lord of Rohan with fitting words. I have done my best."
"And what of your companions!" Gimli burst out, no longer able to contain himself. "What about Legolas and me! You rascals, you woolly-footed and wool-pated truants! A fine hunt you have led us – through battle and blood, fire and fen, two hundred leagues without food nor rest, all to rescue you! And here we find you idling and feasting – and smoking! Hammer and tongs, if I do not burst it will be a marvel!"
"The salted pork is particularly good," Pippin interjected, opening one eye.
"Salted pork," Gimli repeated dumbly, and then he groaned and leaned his head against Legolas' back. "Mahal save us!"
"You speak for me, Gimli," said Legolas, a laugh caught in his voice. "Though I would sooner learn how they came by the wine."
"One thing you have not found in all your hunting, and that's sharper wits," Pippin said with a little sniff. "Here you find us sitting upon a field of victory, and you wonder how we came by a few well-earned comforts!"
"WELL-EARNED –" Gimli began, his face beginning to turn the colour of his hair.
Pippin lifted his mug in a lazy salute. Legolas' laughter finally rang out across the watery valley, and Gimli made a noise of utter outrage and began to struggle upon Arod's back.
"Get me off this thing: I am going to embrace them both, and then I am going to kill them," he growled, and Legolas shook his head, helpless and paralysed with laughter.
"Calm yourself, Gimli," he managed between gasps. "They are well – Nan aear adh in elin, they are alive and well!"
"Not for long!" Gimli muttered, sliding down off the horse's high back with a heavy thud of his Dwarf-boots. "Get yourselves down here at once, you little knaves, you rogues - you pair of wing-footed mischief-makers, you!"
"It cannot be doubted that we witness the meetings of dear friends," laughed Théoden. "So these are the lost ones of your company, Gandalf! Marvels walking straight from legends! Are these not Halflings, that some amongst us call the Holbytlan?"
"Hobbits, if you please, Lord," said Pippin primly. Merry nodded in grave agreement. His eyes were a little glassy.
"Hobbits?" Théoden said, eyebrows raising. "Hobbits? The word is strangely changed, and the legends do not do justice to the truth. For one thing, they do not report that Hobbits spouted smoke from their mouths."
"Ah!" Merry said solemnly, lifting a finger in a teacherly manner and puffing harder upon his pipe. "Well, that is not surprising. It is an art which we have not practised for more than a few generations. It was Tobold Hornblower, of Longbottom in the Southfarthing, who first grew the true pipe-weed in his gardens... hmm, about the year 1070 by our reckoning, wasn't it Pip?" - and here Pippin nodded owlishly, "now, just how Old Toby came by the plant is a matter of..."
"You do not know your danger, Théoden," Gandalf interrupted, smiling. "These Hobbits will sit on the edge of ruin and discuss the pleasures of the table or the small doings of their great-grandfathers to the ninth degree, if you encourage them! Merry! Where is Treebeard?"
"Oh, away on the north side, I believe," Merry waved a hand. "He went to get a drink of fresher water. Other Ents are guarding the tower. Quickbeam is there, I know."
"We will seek Treebeard," Gandalf said, nodding to the King. "He will have much to tell us."
"I am going nowhere,not now that they are finally within my sight," Gimli growled, shifting anxiously from foot to foot. Aragorn dismounted and clapped a comforting hand upon his shoulder.
"We shall stay here, we Three Hunters," he said, and Gimli glanced up at him and then his lips quirked beneath his moustache. Some of his anxious energy left him, and he deflated a little, his heavy shoulders slumping beneath Aragorn's hand.
"Aye, hunters that have found their quarry at last," he said, sighing and removing his helm. "There had better be some salted pork left, or I shall not be held accountable for my actions."
"There's plenty, but you'd best hurry," Merry told them. "Pippin isn't exactly a slouch with a fork, you know."
Legolas' nose wrinkled the slightest amount, but he met Aragorn's eyes and nodded before leaping down from Arod's back as lightly as a settling feather.
Gandalf nodded to them, and then he began to lead Théoden and his retinue around the great stone walls towards the north edge of the valley.
"So that is the King of Rohan!" Pippin said to Merry in an undertone. "A fine old fellow. Very polite."
After the Hobbits had descended from their perch and after Gimli had embraced them both so tightly that their eyes had quite nearly popped (Thorin had averted his eyes from Legolas' stiff face with a muffled growl), the Three Hunters sat down upon the grass and ate their fill as Merry and Pippin related their story. Much of it Thorin already knew from Ori's reports, but he was again struck by the resourcefulness of Pippin in a pinch. "Throwing away his brooch like that," he said approvingly, and Kíli nodded in agreement.
"Clever, wasn't it?" he said.
"Hobbits tend towards the clever and quiet," said Balin, stroking at his beard and nodding. "Perhaps Bilbo was not so very unlike the rest of his folk."
"Or perhaps Tooks are a breed apart," Thorin said, and ignored the quick, sympathetic glance that Balin sent him.
"Doesn't explain Sam, though," mumbled Kíli, and he tipped his head and sighed longingly as Gimli was presented with Pippin's spare pipe. "Ooooh, Hobbitish pipe-weed! Now that I miss!"
"Shândabi," said Fíli wistfully, watching as Gimli filled the pipe and raised it in salute to Pippin with appreciation before striking it alight with Glóin's old tinder and flint. "I can almost smell it."
Legolas wrinkled his nose. "Come now!" he said, a trifle peevishly. "Time wears on, and the mists are blowing away – or would if you strange folk did not wreathe yourself in smoke."
"You talk to trees," Gimli said placidly, puffing at his borrowed pipe.
"And that is a perfectly natural and understandable thing to do," Legolas said, a touch of his old haughtiness in his face and tone. His eyes slid away from the Dwarf, tightening around the corners as he looked out over the swaying forests.
"Now, now," Aragorn said, exhaustion in every syllable. "Let us not wrangle and chide, now that we have recovered two of our Fellowship. Let us sit upon the edge of ruin and talk. I feel a weariness such as I have seldom felt before."
"Ask Gimli and Legolas to cease bickering?" Merry laughed. "Ask the sun to stop in its orbit, or the tides to halt in the ocean bed, more like!"
"You may be surprised," Balin murmured, and smiled cheerfully in return when Thorin sent one of his blackest glares in his cousin's direction.
"Were we ever to stop, you would wonder if we were truly ourselves," Legolas told them.
Gimli barked a laugh. "Aye, we are only making sure the wee Hobbits know it is truly us, Aragorn," he said, all pretend-innocence.
"Just think upon it," Legolas said, assuming a sorrowful air. "If our doughty Dwarf were to behave as he has been recently in front of their very eyes? Why, they would question his sanity!"
Gimli's snort made the smoke eddy and whirl around his head. "Aye, perhaps all that running can addle a Dwarf's brain after all."
"And what of an Elf's brain? I ran as far and as fast as you – faster, indeed!" Legolas prodded, turning to face Gimli fully. There was no denying the sudden brightness of his expression, the light of laughter leaping in his eyes. Thorin bristled to see it, and hated that the expression upon Legolas' fair face was one he knew he himself had worn upon many a visit to Bag End.
"Ach," Gimli said, shaking his head sadly, "that is already hopelessly addled. Lost cause, laddie. As I mentioned: talks to trees. Unfortunate fellow!"
"You may wish to change your opinion on such things, Gimli, once you've met Treebeard," Merry said, laughing. Pippin was giggling into his mug, watching the to-and-fro with bright little eyes.
"It is a good thing that both Ents and Elves have the patience of the Ages," Legolas said, bending closer to Gimli and smiling broadly. His hand hovered above Gimli's broad shoulder for a moment before landing there and clasping tightly. "How else could we change a Dwarf's mind?"
"Ah, but I am an addled Dwarf, remember?" Gimli said, chuckling. "I must be, to suffer your company! Such a mind is surely soft enough to shape as you see fit."
"Would that it were, stubborn Dwarf," Legolas said in nearly a sigh, leaning back. "Would that it were."
"Oh, go discuss the weather with a shrub," Gimli said, prodding at Legolas' hand with one thick finger. "You are quite as stubborn as me, and you know it."
"No, mellon nîn, here I think you are the victor once more," Legolas countered. "No Elf could contest with a Dwarf in this particular arena."
"Truly? Then prove it," Gimli said, and smugly folded his free arm across his barrel chest, tucking the hand into the crook of his elbow. "Aha! Now if you should refuse to meet my challenge, then you are only proving yourself equally stubborn in another manner. What say you?"
Legolas opened his mouth, and then closed it with a snap!
"Neatly caught!" Merry said, clapping in delight, and Pippin was laughing openly.
"Now you must admit that we are matched in this," Gimli said, pointing his pipe-stem over at the Elf. "Go on!"
"You do realise that you are stubbornly insisting that I admit to being as stubborn as you," Legolas said dryly.
"Aye, and as you say, I was the victor of our last contest and so shall I win this one too," Gimli said with a toss of his ruddy braids. "And Dwarves have their own patience. I can wait for your answer."
"But you cannot wait so long as an Elf," Legolas countered. A flash of pain passed over his bright face, dimming his smile.
"Must you compete upon everything?" Aragorn groaned.
"Naturally," Legolas said lightly, taking his hand away from Gimli's shoulder and sending an obscurely pained look back at the Man. "How else are we to communicate?"
Aragorn shook his shaggy head, his own wry smile tugging at his lips. He leaned back, stretching his long legs out before him, his grey cloak wrapped about him and adding to the mystery of his smoke-wreathed face. "If it came to a contest of irritating your companion, I find that you are perfectly matched."
"Look!" said Pippin, nudging Merry. "Strider the Ranger has come back!"
"He has never been away," said Aragorn quietly, his eyes sliding shut. "I am Strider and Dunadan too, and I belong both to Gondor and the North."
That was surprising. Thorin took two short steps to peer down at the supine Man, frowning into the worn, weatherbeaten face. Aragorn seemed at peace here, surrounded by the wreckage of Isengard. The heavy lines of care smoothed out as a thin stream of smoke escaped his lips. "Both Gondor and the North may be your inheritance," he murmured, crouching down before the Man, "but I warn you, Aragorn Arathorn's son of the line of Elendil, an inheritance is a slippery fish to catch, and you have your rod cast for two. You may find that one, at least, escapes your nets. Arnor is a dead Kingdom, and Gondor lies under a pall of shadow. Yet you belong to them, you say. Aye, but keep something of yourself for yourself, for they will take everything you are and everything you have and hollow you out before they are done, and yet still demand more."
Gimli blinked, straightening and then his eyes darted to Legolas. The Elf's lips parted slightly, and his eyebrows lifted in enquiry. Gimli gave a barely-perceptible nod, and then his free hand moved in the familiar Iglishmêk patterns: Idmi, melekhel.
"Greetings, Gimli," Thorin replied a little stiffly, keenly aware of the Elf's immediate attention to Gimli's slight startlement and his perfect understanding of what had provoked it.
"I wonder what Gandalf is doing?" Merry said, frowning as he glanced between the Elf and Dwarf. A suspicion was dawning in his shrewd little face. "The afternoon is getting on. Let us go and look round! You can enter Isengard now at any rate, Strider, if you want to. But it is not a very cheerful sight."
"Ents," Frís mused as the small party stood and stretched after their impromptu meal, tapping out pipes (Gimli and Aragorn) and finishing off the remnants of tankards (Merry and Pippin). There was a ruined tunnel ahead and Legolas led the way upon light feet. "Such a ruin in such a short time. No wonder they were created to be the answer to Dwarrows, if they have the strength to tear stone in half like so much cram."
"Be careful!" Merry warned. "There are loose slabs everywhere. They may tilt up and throw you into a pit if you are not wary!"
Legolas nodded, and then he called out in his liquid tongue. Arod's head lifted where he grazed some distance away, and the grey horse whickered and trotted forward to him obediently.
"Hello again, beastie," Gimli said with some resignation. Then he looked up at Legolas. "I have not even been on my own feet for an hour, and you want me back up on that thing?"
"To be frank, you would do better on a horse, Gimli," Pippin said. "No Dwarf or Hobbit would be able to stand the waters anyway. They're far above our heads!"
Gimli scowled. "That wouldn't daunt me. I can swim in full armour, should there be a need."
"I do not doubt it, but here you may ride and stay dry," Legolas said, and Arod snuffled over the Dwarf's shoulder. Gimli sighed and patted awkwardly at the horse's velvet nose.
"All right. Don't think I'm going soft towards the dratted creature!"
"I would not dare," Legolas said solemnly, springing lithely into the saddle and reaching down towards Gimli with one hand. Gimli muttered under his breath in Khuzdul for a moment (which turned Balin's face nearly as white as his beard) and let Legolas hoist him up.
There was little left of the road when the riders moved through the tunnel into the crumbling circle of Isengard. Merry and Pippin clung to Aragorn as he moved Brego forward, taking the lead. Steaming pools hissed around them, reeking of foul things. There were the shapes of riders in the middle distance. Dotted sparsely around them were the still dark shapes of trees, their leaves rustling in the breeze.
"Some great foul smithing took place here," Gimli muttered, and his hand tightened upon the haft of his axe. "Smell that! They have made a mockery of the art."
"How can you tell?" asked Legolas, his face intrigued. He glanced over the flat watery plain, his eyes very piercing. "All such works smell the same to me."
"You do not know what to heed, so I forgive you those words," Gimli growled. "Base metals were tortured here, with little care for their true worth. The ore was not made clean, the fires were not kept well, and moreover they were fed with green branches and logs. Heated unevenly, warped and twisted, cast in haste and cooled over-quickly. I remember the steel of the Uruk-Hai was as dark and brittle as coal, and no time nor thought was given to its shaping but for a filing of the sharpest edge. Now the other half of that riddle appears. This is no true forge. A forge is where skill and art and function may combine to make a thing both useful and beautiful. This is a machine for death."
"Gimli!" Balin half-gasped, half-groaned. Then he put his head in his hands as Fíli patted his back sympathetically.
"Get used to it, he's gotten worse," he said.
The distant riders resolved into the shapes of Gandalf, Théoden-King, Éomer and the Éored as they neared, and Gandalf nodded to them before turning to look up at the sinister, glowering tower of Orthanc. "I was about to send for you," he said quietly to Aragorn. "Have you rested and renewed your bonds of Fellowship?"
"We listened to an Elf and a Dwarf bicker and tussle with words," Aragorn said as Éomer took Merry upon Firefoot, his horse. "So: nothing unusual. But yes, I have rested. What now?"
"I have spoken to Treebeard, and learned much, and made a few plans. Now I have one last task to do before we may depart, and not a pleasant one: I must speak to Saruman. Dangerous, and probably useless, but it must be done."
"What's the danger" asked Pippin. "Will he shoot at us or pour fire out of the windows; or can he put a spell upon us from a distance?"
"The last is the most likely," Gandalf said grimly. "Beware of his voice!"
"Treebeard?" Legolas said, a note of eagerness in his voice. "You have spoken to him?"
And then the most extraordinary being stepped forward from the shadow of Orthanc, and Thorin swore loudly and reached for a non-existent sword. "Durin's blood and bones!" croaked Fíli, and Kíli was simply gawking up – and up – and up. "That's an Ent?!"
Thorin's heart was beating at double-speed as he whirled about, staring at the motionless figures dotted about the circle of the valley. What he had taken for nothing more than trees were in fact Ents: unmoving and watchful and huge beyond anything he had ever imagined. "Nothing so large can be living," he croaked. "They... they have us surrounded."
"They are our allies," Frís said, but her voice shook nonetheless. "Our allies: they fight against the Uruks and upon the side of Men and Elves and Dwarves."
"They're bloody enormous!" Kíli squeaked.
"Yes, they are," she agreed faintly, patting his hand a shade too rapidly to be comforting, her blue eyes very wide.
Frerin had pressed himself very close to Thorin's side. "Different types of trees," he said in a hoarse voice. "Do you see? There is a fir tree, and a beech, and a rowan and a willow..."
Thorin did not trust himself to answer, instead taking both Frerin's and Fíli's shoulders in his hands and holding tightly.
"Created to guard against Dwarves, wasn't it?" Fíli asked Balin, who nodded dumbly.
"That'd do it," Kíli said, and swallowed. "Trees that fight back."
"And can rip a Dwarf in half, what's more," Fíli added.
"You can stop there," Frerin mumbled. "I don't need to know anything more about them. Ever."
Gimli's face had paled beneath his fine beard when the great Ent had stepped forward, but he kept his head and did not call out or say anything foolish. Legolas seemed to sense his friend's discomfort and reached back to touch Gimli's shin with the tips of his fingers. "Peace, mellon nîn," he murmured. "You tense up like a rabbit in the presence of a stoat. Do not be nervous."
"Nervous, who's nervous?" Gimli whispered back, and he lightly tapped at Legolas' hand. "Get off: I'm fine."
Legolas' lips tilted upwards. "You always are, my dearest friend. I do not doubt it."
"Young Master Gandalf," the Ent boomed, and Thorin was surprised at how slowly he spoke: like great rolling rivers or the deliberate creaking of wood stretching into the sky. "Wood and water, stock and stone I can master, but there is a Wizard to manage here."
Gandalf bent his head respectfully to Treebeard, before staring up at the roof of Orthanc. "Yes, from atop that tower," Thorin heard him murmur sadly. Then he drew himself tall in the saddle, his white head glowing in the sunlight. "Saruman!" he called in a great voice. "Saruman, come forth!"
For some time there was no answer. Then a voice called back, "who is it? What do you wish?"
Théoden started. "I know that voice," he said through gritted teeth. "And I curse the day when I first listened to it."
Éomer sent his uncle a quick, searching glance, but Théoden lifted a hand. "Nay, sister-son," he said, his chin lifting. "I am well enough. Content yourself!"
"I am content if my Lord is," Éomer returned.
Théoden gave him a sidelong look, and his lips were upturned despite his grim demeanour. "I find myself in far better company these days."
Éomer's back straightened, and when he turned his eyes back to the tower there was a pride in his face and in the carriage of his helm that had long been absent.
"Go and fetch Saruman, since you have become his footman, Gríma Wormtongue!" Gandalf was saying sternly. "And do not waste our time!"
"Hoom, hum!" Treebeard said, his knotty brows drawing together. "Is your business with the Wizard so very pressing, then? Do not be hasty, young master Gandalf. A little time –a decade or two, methinks – would do both Saruman and his doorman good."
"It is not to my liking, but yes, time grows ever shorter," Gandalf said, his grip tightening upon his staff. "Saruman is only a dupe, a puppet of a far greater darkness. Still, he was once most powerful and perceptive, his mind marvellously subtle and his thoughts skilled beyond compare. He was deep in the plans of the Enemy. We need him to talk."
Treebeard straightened with a gruff, "Hrum, burarum!"
"That's just his way," Merry whispered when he noticed Gimli's pale cheeks. "Don't pay it any mind. He scared the hair straight off my feet when we met: thought we were Orcs, you know. But once we persuaded him not to kill us he was perfectly friendly."
"Master Merry," Gimli said, wetting his lips with his tongue, "you are not a comfort."
Legolas hid a smile.
Then there was a flash of something pale atop the tower, and Thorin craned backwards to look up at the knifelike peaks framed against scudding grey clouds. There stood a Man, or a Manlike form at least, clad in dirty robes that flashed white one moment and every colour imaginable the next. He squinted. The bearded face was similar to Gandalf's in that an unfathomable power rested in his eyes and upon the lined and aged brow, but strands of black showed at ears and lips and there was a cruelty in Saruman's mouth that was absent from Gandalf's.
"So you are not so singular, my friend," he murmured, and Gandalf looked down at him for a moment with an unguarded expression. There was rage there, and hurt at an unlooked-for betrayal, and sorrow so deep that mountains could not contain it.
"No, I once was not. There were five, and now there are two. Time, distance and madness have stolen the rest," he said quietly, before determination stole the openness from his face. The eyes became distant: kindly and yet calculating. Once more he appeared as Gandalf, not as the spirit that Gandalf had once been. Here was the Wizard who cared for his chess pieces, and yet moved them into battle nonetheless.
"Time, distance and madness," Thorin repeated, black humour edging every word. "You have my sincere sympathies, Wizard."
Gandalf's answering smile was pained. Frerin stood on Thorin's booted foot as heavily as he could. Thorin ignored him.
"Well?" said Saruman wearily, and his voice was smooth and kindly and melodious. Everyone stood still at the sound, as though ensorcelled. His dark eyes flitted between each figure below, taking them in, assessing them with flat reptilian cunning. The look was in direct contrast to the wise and reasonable tone of the voice and the carefully benevolent expression upon the hard-carved old face. "Well? Why must you disturb my rest?"
Thorin stood his ground as Saruman's eyes flicked to him and then narrowed. He had been expecting this after his experience with the Ring. "Hold fast," he murmured as Frerin shifted uneasily and Balin's breath caught. "He cannot harm us – nothing can. We but watch. We bear witness."
Saruman's eyes widened once more, but he said nothing to answer this. Instead, he turned back to the King of Rohan. "Come now, two of you I at least know by name," he said softly, gently. "Gandalf I know too well to have much hope that he seeks help or counsel here. But you, Théoden, Lord of the Mark, are declared to me by your noble devices and by the fair features of the House of Eorl. Why have you not come before, and as a friend?"
Théoden stirred, and his eyes grew distant and shadowed.
"Ah, zuznel," Gimli groaned. "My beloved Lord, do you mark his face? The spell lies upon him still. He will go up, they will make peace, and Saruman will gain where he had all but lost."
Saruman's marvellous voice lowered to a whisper, wheedling and coaxing. So wise it seemed, and so very right. Thorin shook his head to clear it. "Is it yet too late? Despite the injuries that have been done to me, in which the men of Rohan, alas! have had some part, still I would save you, and deliver you from the ruin that draws nigh inevitably, if you ride upon this road which you have taken. Indeed I alone can aid you now."
Then Gimli broke in suddenly, his Dwarven voice loud and rough after the silkiness of the Wizard's entreaty. "The words of this wizard stand on their heads," he growled, gripping the handle of his axe. "In the language of Orthanc help means ruin, and saving means slaying, that is plain. But we do not come here to beg."
"I do not speak to you, Dwarf," Saruman said, and for a moment his voice was less suave. His harsh gaze flickered from Gimli to the dead Dwarves, to Gimli again, and then his tone softened once more, purring in satisfaction. "Far away is your home, and small concern of yours are the happenings of this unhappy land. I speak to Théoden of Rohan, my neighbour and once my friend.
"You have fought many wars and slain many men, Théoden-King, and made peace afterwards. Can we not take counsel together as we once did, my old friend? Can we not have peace, you and I?" Saruman said, and he reached out with a long-fingered hand, pale as dripping wax.
There was total silence.
"We will have peace," Théoden said in a thick voice, and several of his Riders cried out in gladness. Then Théoden's eyes flashed with fury. "Yes, we shall have peace when you answer for the burning of the Westfold and the children that lie dead there! We shall have peace when the lives of the soldiers whose bodies were hewn even as they lay dead against the gates of the Hornburg are avenged! When you hang from a gibbet for the sport of your own crows, then we shall have peace."
The voice of the King was coarse as burlap after Saruman's sweet coaxing, but the effect was as if someone had thrown a bucket of water over the listeners. Most of the Riders straightened as though emerging from a dream, and then outrage entered their faces as they realised how close they had come to being snared in Saruman's nets. "So much for the House of Eorl," Théoden said roughly. "A lesser son of great sires am I, but I do not need to lick your fingers. Turn elsewhither."
"Look at Saruman!" said Frís in a sharp tone, and Thorin turned back up to the Wizard to see his face darkening in rage. The light in his eyes kindled to a great wrath, and for a moment he seemed like a great snake about to strike.
"Gibbets and crows!" he hissed, and they shuddered at the hideous change. "Dotard! What is the House of Eorl but a thatched barn where brigands drink in the reek, and their brats roll on the floor among the dogs? Too long have they escaped the gibbet themselves. But the noose comes, slow in the drawing, tight and hard in the end. Hang if you will!"
Then he slowly drew himself upright again, his white hair disordered in the wind. The curl of his mouth was full of distaste. "I know not why I have had the patience to speak to you. For I need you not, nor your little band of gallopers, as swift to fly as to advance, Théoden Horsemaster."
"What a pleasant fellow," said Frerin faintly. Thorin snorted silently, and drew his brother close.
"Remember, he cannot harm us," he said once more.
"Who knows what a Wizard may do?" said Balin, his brows drawn tight and his lips a thin white line.
Gandalf's hand raised in the air, and then his dusty old voice rang out, clear as a cracking whip. "Your treachery has already cost many lives. Thousands more are now at risk. But you could save them Saruman. You were deep in the enemy's counsel."
"And what do you want, Gandalf Greyhame?" Saruman said, and now he was cold and haughty. "Let me guess… the key of Orthanc? Or perhaps the keys of Barad-Dûr itself? Along with the crowns of the seven Kings and the rods of the Five Wizards and a pair of boots many sizes larger than those that you wear now! A modest plan. Hardly one in which my help is needed. I have other things to do. If you wish to treat with me, while you have a chance, go away, and come back when you are sober! And leave behind these cut-throats and small rag-tag that dangle at your tail! Good day!' He turned and made to leave the balcony.
"Saruman," Gandalf said, and there was a new power in his voice that put the spell of Saruman's to shame. "I did not give you leave to go."
Saruman froze where he stood, and then slowly, reluctantly, he dragged himself back to the edge of the high tower. Fear now shone in his face.
"You have become a fool, Saruman, and yet pitiable. You might still have turned away from folly and evil, and have been of service," Gandalf said, and a hint of that hidden sorrow crossed his expression.
"You seek information?" Saruman said, animal cunning setting his eyes alight. "I have some for you."
He held aloft a large glass ball, dark as a stormy winter's night. A fire seemed to flicker in its depths. "Something festers in the heart of Middle Earth. Something that you have failed to see. But the Great Eye has seen it! Even now he presses his advantage. His attack will come soon. You are all going to die! But you know this don't you Gandalf?" Saruman laughed cruelly, and then he spat, "you cannot think that this Ranger will ever sit upon the throne of Gondor. This exile crept from the shadows will never be crowned King."
Thorin's throat closed in sudden, painful remembrance, the memories so close and vivid they were nearly drowning him. He was faintly aware that he staggered to one side. He has the right. He has the only right.
Saruman's gaze fixed upon Thorin, and then his eyes widened in recognition before they narrowed in catlike satisfaction. Malice dripped from him as he went on, his mouth twisted into a cold snarling smile. "Gandalf does not hesitate to sacrifice those who are closest to him: those he professes to love. Tell me, what words of comfort did you give the Halfling before you sent him to his doom?"
Distantly he could feel his nephews crowding close, feel the warmth of their breath against his face and smell his mother's hair in his nostrils. He held himself still, his heart clenching.
No. Bilbo is safe. Safe in Rivendell.
Frodo.
He speaks of Frodo.
Gandalf has ever been a friend to Dwarrows and Hobbits alike.
He was quick enough to use our vengeance for his own ends.
Cease this! Old bones should lie buried!
Frodo. Where is Frodo now?
Saruman's voice hissed and sneered like the Dragon's. "The path that you have set him on can only lead to death."
Aragorn's eyelids lowered, and Thorin's hands fisted by his sides. Dimly he knew Fíli's hands were wrapped around his right fist, and that Frerin had flung his arm around his waist as far as it would reach. Balin was speaking, wise words of comfort as always, and Frís was carding her fingers through his beard. "Come back," she said gently. "Thorin, my son. Come back."
He took a breath that stuttered and dragged as it made its way into his lungs. "I am well enough," he said, his voice rasping.
"You are a great big hairy mess, don't lie," Frerin said bluntly. "Are you all right now?"
"Are you?" Thorin retorted. He hated how raw he sounded.
"Are any of us?" muttered Balin, before he looked up again. "Wizards."
"I second that," Kíli said, wiping at his brow.
"I've heard enough," Gimli said, his teeth snapping at the words. There was anger and worry in his face, and Thorin wondered how much he had heard. "Shoot him! Stick an arrow in his gob!"
Legolas began to reach for his quiver, but Gandalf sent both him and Thorin a warning glance. "No! Come down, Saruman – come down, and your life will be spared!"
"Save your pity and your mercy!" Saruman sneered. "I have no use for it! Very much in the manner of Gandalf the Grey: so condescending, and so very kind. I do not doubt that you would find Orthanc commodious, and my departure convenient!"
"Stay then!" Gandalf said, and a terrible rage shook his voice, shadows gathering around him and making him appear many times taller than he was. Thorin stared, remembering the day he had seen this before.
"Are they going to fight?" whispered Kíli. "Because I don't want to see a fight between Wizards. Ents are quite bad enough."
"Behold, I am not Gandalf the Grey, whom you betrayed. I am Gandalf the White, who has returned from death. You have no colour now, and I cast you from the order and from the Council," thundered Gandalf, and Saruman quailed before his suddenly-revealed might.
Gandalf raised his hand and spoke in a clear, cold voice. "Saruman, your staff is broken."
In his long-fingered, talon-tipped hand, the long black staff suddenly snapped with a loud crack! before crumbling away into smoke. Saruman staggered back in horror, and disappeared from atop the tower.
Not seconds later, a heavy black shining thing came hurtling from the tower to splash near to Shadowfax's hooves. Pippin slid down from Brego and ran after it to pick it up. He frowned as he drew it out of the water: the crystal globe that Saruman had brandished before, dark but glowing with a heart of fire.
"The murderous rogue," Éomer snarled, but Gandalf shook his head.
"A parting shot from Master Wormtongue, I fancy," he said. "It is not a thing, I guess, that Saruman would have chosen to cast away."
"What is it?" Pippin said, peering at it with fascination.
"Here, my lad, I'll take that!" Gandalf said, leaning down and scooping the globe from his hands and wrapping it in a fold of his robe.
"Do you suppose that is the end of it?" Merry wondered. Pippin looked confused, staring at his hands as though he had never seen them before. He blinked when Aragorn lifted him neatly back into Brego's saddle, and sighed out his breath in one slow stream.
"It is the end," Gandalf said heavily.
"Well, let us get out of stone's throw, at least!" Gimli remarked, and Legolas' face, which had been cool and impassive in the manner of an Elf under threat, softened.
"Let us go, yes," Gandalf said, and the obscure sorrow was again alive in his eyes. He turned Shadowfax slowly, and led the slow careful progression across the wreckage-strewn circle back to the tunnel.
Thorin sagged, and Frís carefully kissed the lower part of his jaw.
"Do those troublesome old memories snap at your heels again like so many barking dogs?" she said softly.
"They bark very loudly at times," Thorin said, dredging up a wry smile from somewhere for his mother.
"That is the nature of a neglected dog," she said, and smoothed flat the ruffled hair upon his cheek, "Zabadâl belkul, Thorin. We love you. We are here. No matter how wildly they howl, remember that they are not nearly as persistent as we are."
"I will endeavour," he said, and bent his head so that Frís could tuck a strand of his hair back into the rough queue he had combed it into. "Thank you."
"One good thing about being dead," Frerin said as they began to pick their way across the watery valley after the Éored and their companions, "I can wade through all of this fully clothed, and not get the slightest bit wet."
"Ah, nadad," Thorin said, and to his surprise his laugh was low and genuine and not forced as it once would have been, "always looking for the mithril in the mud mine."
"Somebody has to be the balance to all your storms, nadad," Frerin countered, and Thorin reached out with a lightning-fast hand and scruffed the golden hair until Frerin hollered in protest and both their nephews were snickering.
"Hoom, hum!" Treebeard said, shaking his hoary old head as they neared the gates. "Well, I might have told you that that would be the way it would go..." Then he stopped, his strange flickering eyes sliding shut, his breath whistling like the wind through branches.
"He does this sometimes," Merry said as though apologising for an eccentric old family member. Then he cleared his throat. "Treebeard! Folks to meet you!"
"...had you taken the time to listen," Treebeard finished, his head lifting. "Saruman's heart is as rotten as a black Huorn's. Little Master Merry, barum! Friends of yours?"
"Three of my companions," Gandalf said. "I have spoken of them, but you have yet to meet them." He named them, one by one.
The Ent's eyes were very peculiar indeed; deep and dark, but with the glow of amber and of new green life. Treebeard looked at each of the Three Hunters in turn, slowly and carefully, before he turned to Legolas. "So you have come all the way from Mirkwood, my good Elf? A very great forest it used to be!"
"And still is," Legolas said smugly.
Gimli, Thorin, Balin, Fíli and Kíli all snorted loudly in unison.
Legolas' eyebrow twitched, and he sent a narrow elbow backwards into Gimli's chest. "But not so great that we who dwell there ever tire of seeing new trees. I should dearly love to journey in Fangorn's Wood."
Treebeard's eyes gleamed with pleasure. "I hope you may have your wish, ere the hills be much older," he said.
"I will come, if I have the fortune," said Legolas. "I have made a bargain with my friend that, if all goes well, we will visit Fangorn together – by your leave."
"Any Elf that comes with you will be welcome," said Treebeard.
"The friend I speak of is not an Elf," said Legolas, and he threw the words out proudly, almost defiantly, "I mean Gimli, Glóin's son here."
Gimli bowed as low as his seat upon horseback would allow, and the axe slipped from his belt and clattered on the ground.
"Hoom, hm! Ah now," said Treebeard, looking dark-eyed at him. "A dwarf and an axe-bearer! Hoom! I have good will to Elves; but you ask much. This is a strange friendship!"
"Strange it may seem," said Legolas, "but while Gimli lives I shall not come to Fangorn alone. His axe is not for trees, but for orc-necks. Forty-two he hewed in the battle."
"Hoo! Come now!" said Treebeard. "That is a better story!"
Thorin scowled. It had not escaped him that, once again, the Elf had put himself between the threat and Gimli.
"While Gimli lives?" Fíli echoed, and Frerin shrugged.
"It saddens him, to know that Gimli breathes the same air for so brief a time," Balin said, scrutinising the Elf. "For what is the life of a Dwarf to these? Ents, Elves, Wizards: we are but motes of dust that flit into their lives."
"I am afraid we must leave, and I must take your gatekeepers from you," Gandalf said, and Treebeard's shaggy head lowered.
"I shall miss them, hurried noisy little folk," he said, and stretched out his twiglike fingers to the Hobbits. "We have become friends in so short a while that I think I must be getting hasty – growing backwards towards youth, perhaps. But there, they are the first new thing under Sun or Moon that I have seen for many a long, long day. I shall not forget them."
"Nor we you!" cried Merry, and Pippin echoed him. Treebeard hummed and nodded his great head some more, and Thorin finally found himself relaxing around the huge creature, though part of him was still wary.
"Tears stone like bread-crust," he muttered to himself, and stubbornly repressed a shiver.
"Saruman shall not set foot beyond the rock," Treebeard promised, his eyes landing upon Théoden. "Ents shall watch over him. The filth of Isengard shall wash away, and new trees shall come here to live, young trees. Until seven times the years in which he tormented us have passed, we shall not tire of watching him."
Frerin shuddered violently. "Oh, that is plain disturbing."
Edoras was louder and far more bustling this time. No longer did the people stand and watch in funereal silence. Now, wagons and handcarts rolled through the streets as the Rohirrim poured back into their city. Families were weeping and laughing as they were reunited, and there were shrieks of grief that rose up into the air. Songs of victory and of mourning wove about them, echoing across the great grasslands below. Every torch was blazing, crowning the lone hilltop with golden fire that shone out in the darkness.
Thorin shook himself and looked up at the snapping horse-emblazoned pennants above as the starlight sloughed away. Beside him, Nori, Óin and Frerin all stepped forward. He looked back at them to gauge their readiness. Nori rolled his eyes, Óin folded his arms, and Frerin was still rubbing at his face, half-blinded by the stars.
"I wish I were able to predict when Gimlîn-zâram was kind and when it wasn't," he complained, and Nori snorted.
"Nobody can, an' who knows? It might always try t' be kind. We might be the ones what don't always taste so good."
"Do ye mind," Óin snapped, lifting his chin.
"Whoops, sorry about that, forgot you got et, Óin. Wasn't very wossname – tactful – of me."
Thorin ignored the pair, grabbed Frerin's arm and dragged him forward. His brother made a small noise of protest, still rubbing at his eyes. "Wait a minute," he said, but Thorin only set his teeth and moved forward.
"I will guide you," he said. "It does not last long."
"I know that," said Frerin peevishly, but he allowed Thorin to steer him through the streets of Edoras without further complaint.
"So many of 'em, must breed like fieldmice," Óin said, glancing around. "Where will we find my darn-fool nephew and the rest of the dratted Fellowship, then?"
"They will be at Meduseld," Thorin said absently, pulling Frerin closer and tucking him beneath his arm. "Keep up."
"You keep up," Óin muttered back rebelliously, and his face was as dark as a thundercloud as he followed Thorin through the crowds of celebrating and weeping Rohirrim.
When they entered the Golden Hall, they were nearly knocked back by the noise. Warriors and their families stood everywhere, and singing filled the air nearly as thickly as the smoke from the great fire-pit set in the centre of the floor. Thorin blinked as he looked around.
"Too tall, all of 'em, can't see a thing. It's a tall blond forest in here," Nori grumbled, his eyes darting from drunken Rohirrim to drunken Rohirrim. "An' this is just cruel, showing me all these easy marks and not a thing I can do about it. I could skin this lot alive and convince 'em they'd got the best of the bargain."
Thorin ignored that and made his way towards the dais and the ornate carved chair that sat before the great horse-head banners.
Théoden sat there, his fingers wrapped around a drinking-horn and his smile wide, though concern and grief were still present in his face. Beside him was Gandalf, relaxed for once as he spoke to the King with his pipe in hand, and before them stood Éowyn, a stirrup-cup in her hands. Though she did not seem as hard-carved as she normally did, her smile was not exactly peaceful as she watched the milling people before them. Great rough-hewn tables had been dragged before the throne, and upon one of them –
"Hobbits," said Óin disbelievingly.
"That is not like any dance I've ever seen," said Frerin, wrinkling his nose and peering up at Pippin and Merry, who were cavorting upon the table and singing a song about hot baths, of all things. "Where's the stamping? Who is the winner? Where are the musicians?"
"Why would anyone sing about baths?" said Nori.
"Aragorn should," Frerin murmured to Thorin, and he bit down upon the inside of his lip to stop the smile that threatened to spread over his lips.
"Bilbo wrote that," he murmured back.
Frerin glanced at him, and then his little fingers tightened around his wrist comfortingly.
Pippin whirled, ale sloshing from his ludicrously-large tankard, laughing uproariously. He nearly lurched right off the table-top, and the Men around them all stamped and cheered as an arm whipped out, lightning-fast, to catch and right him. Pippin beamed down at Legolas whose Elven reflexes had saved him from a nasty bump on the head. "Thank you very much!" he said, before waving his tankard at Legolas. "Here now, I haven't drunk a toast to you yet, have I?"
"Shame," said Merry, burping behind one raised hand.
"To Legolas, best of Elves!" Pippin said, leaning more heavily upon Legolas' shoulder and wrapping his little arm around the Elf's neck.
"Here, here!" called Merry, heartily echoed by the surrounding Men. It seemed the Hobbit had become a great favourite amongst them in very little time. Many of them appeared fascinated by the appearance of these little people of legend, full-grown but not even the height of a Rohan child.
"You are rascally drunk," Legolas laughed, "but I cannot begrudge you that after the ordeal you have undergone!"
"Me?" Pippin's eyes widened, and then he sat down upon the table with a thump. "You, say rather! You fought in the battle! I should be terrified of such things."
Legolas' eyes dropped for a moment. "I was fortunate."
Pippin's hand patted clumsily at Legolas' shining hair. "Here now," he said. "What is it?"
"Many things, my little friend, not least of which is the needless and savage death of my kinsfolk," Legolas sighed. Then he looked down at the tankard in his slender hands.
Pippin frowned, peering at Legolas' eyes. "That's not it, is it?"
"Nay," Legolas said, barely audible over the noise. "Honourable, though terrible, was the death of Haldir of Lórien. I grieve in truth, and yet it troubles me not nearly so much as that which I cannot say."
Confusion passed over Pippin's face, before it cleared and he waved his arm as he made an indelicate sound. "Legolas, Legolas! That is foolishness – and when I tell you a thing is foolish, you may be sure of it! Why not say it then? Go on, say it and have it out!"
Legolas did not move, but his breath caught behind his teeth.
"I will not feel sorry for an Elf," Óin muttered. "I will not."
"I would not have to speak to an Elf," Legolas said, his eyes growing distant. "There would be time unmeasured, all the time we desired, to sit and allow the moments to come to us as they would. I would have no need to speak, for my very presence would say all I needed. There would be no haste. I would know, and they would know, and we could savour the waiting and the pauses between words as though drinking of the finest of wines. But time races now – nay, it gallops like Shadowfax in the twilight! And I am afraid of it."
"Of time?" Pippin's face was rather lost. Thorin didn't blame him.
"Yes," Legolas sighed, and he took a sip of his mug. "Of time. An Elf, Legolas Thranduilion of the Greenwood, has learned to be afraid of fleeting, false time. It is my enemy: it speeds him from me with every second, every breath, every beat of his great heart. And I am also afeared of the words I cannot say – for how often did we wound each other with words? How often was I to say one thing and he to hear another? We cannot speak as Elves do: without speaking. We cannot let the silence tell us what we would each find needful to know. But I am wind and leaves and he is earth and rock. There is no language between us that speaks of other than ancient, deep pain and mistrust. I do not know what to do. I do not know how to say what the silence would say for me."
Pippin's eyes unfocused, his nose wrinkling. Then he shook out his curls and prodded the Elf emphatically in the chest. "You need another drink," he proclaimed.
And then a wide hand reached out from the fug and squeezed Legolas' shoulder. "Here, lad, I have already performed that duty. Another for you. No wine, I fear!"
Legolas looked up, a smile crossing his face once more. "Ah, no matter, mellon nîn. The ale is hearty enough, though it does not warm the heart as wine of Dorwinion does!"
"Ale heats the belly well enough," Gimli said, sitting down beside the Elf and putting a jug down before them, just before Pippin's curly feet. "Besides, one would think it is quite warm enough in here already!"
"It's hot!" Merry announced, flopping down beside Pippin and nearly upsetting the jug. "This dancing is thirsty work. Spare a mug for me?"
"I should think you've had quite enough," Gimli said, his eyes dancing. Thorin then noticed the forest of mugs and jugs scattered around them, and felt his mouth drop open a little.
"Did those Hobbits drink all of that?" he said, astounded.
"Never underestimate 'em when it comes to their vittles," Gimli murmured, and Thorin's eyes snapped back to his star. That was the first time Gimli had answered him directly since the Caves of Helm's Deep.
"You are not the steadiest upon your feet either, inùdoy kurdulu," he said, his heart swelling against his ribs. "Your braids are frayed. Your hair has seen better days."
"Blast my hair anyway, nuisance that it is," Gimli retorted cheerfully. "Come, Master Hobbits! Give us another song!"
The call was echoed by the surrounding Men, and Thorin spotted the tall shape of Éomer amongst them, laughing and bashing his mug against the table-tops.
"Oh, Merry!" Pippin said, lurching upright and tugging at his cousin's arm. "This one, this one!"
He tapped his foot against the floor a couple of times, and then he began to sing: "There's an inn, there's an inn, there's a merry old inn beneath an old grey hill! And there they brew a beer so brown that the Man in the Moon himself came down..."
"Oh, Frodo would have our ears!" Merry giggled, before he whirled to join Pippin, his voice raised even louder. "One night to drink his fill!"
Gimli jerked. "I know that song!" he exclaimed. And he began to clash his hobnailed boots against the floor as his voice, deeper than the deepest voices of Men, joined in;
["The Man in the Moon Stayed Up Too Late", performed by notanightlight]
"The landlord keeps a little dog
that is mighty fond of jokes;
When there's good cheer among the guests,
He cocks an ear at all the jests
and laughs until he chokes."
"When did you learn that?" Óin gasped, before he buried his face in his hands. "No, no, I dinnae ever want to know."
Thorin had a sneaking suspicion that the old drinking song might have been associated in some way with Borin's, that infamous tavern in Ered Luin. "Fíli and Kíli," he said darkly.
"No doubt," agreed Nori, before he grinned. "Though he might have heard it at my little establishment, or from his brother-in-law."
"One of these days I shall be havin' words with Bofur," Óin grumbled, before he looked back up at the two dancing Hobbits, who were linked arm-in-arm and performing some sort of skipping step that involved a great deal of lurching from Pippin and much giggling on Merry's part:
"The round Moon rolled behind the hill,
as the Sun raised up her head.
She hardly believed her fiery eyes;
For though it was day, to her surprise
they all went back to bed!"
Gimli finished with a smack of his broad palms against the table-top, and then he lifted his tankard to the Hobbits and threw half of it back. "That was excellent, as welcome as a taste o' home! Though it needs a fiddle or two, and a gittern as well to really shake the Hall," he declared loudly, grinning from ear to ear. "How did I not know that Hobbits knew of that song?"
The Men around them were cheering with even greater fervour. The addition of another voice had spurred the pair of dancers to even greater heights, and Pippin was pink-cheeked and Merry was laughing breathlessly. "The Blue Mountains lie close enough to the Shire, do they not?"
"Ah, but is it a Dwarvish song, or a Hobbitish song?" asked Legolas with a sly smile, and Gimli snorted loudly.
"Dwarvish, o' course."
"Not so, not so," Pippin said, waggling a finger. "That song has been sung by Tooks forever and a day! Why, if you cut me open you would find it carved into my heart!"
"What a peculiar thing to have carved on a heart," Gimli said in a mild voice, and Merry pushed at Pippin with a shoulder.
"Don't be ridiculous, Pip," he said, and then he grinned. "If you can help it."
Pippin poked his finger into Merry's breastbone. "I," he said with great dignity, "am a Took, a very important Took. Of course I can't."
Merry sniggered some more, and threw his arm around Pippin's shoulders. "Here, Gimli! Sing us a Dwarvish song then! My throat is dry as a bone, and this very important Took here needs another tankard. He's beginning to make sense."
Gimli chuckled. "Mahal forbid!"
"Go on, Gimli, Dwarf amongst Dwarves," Pippin wheedled, and Gimli held up his hands for a moment's peace.
"Very well, very well! But give me a chance to drink my ale, would you?"
Thorin's attention was caught by a soft word, and he turned to see Éowyn bending close to her uncle, her long hair glinting white-gold in the dim torchlight.
"Understand me, sister-daughter," Théoden said, taking her face in his rough old hands. "I do not mean to trap you."
"But you do, though you mean well," she said, and her eyes lifted to his. "Uncle, I understand you. I am no fool. You wish for me to be safe; you wish for one of our line to lead our people; you wish for the House of Eorl to continue. But you do not understand me. You do not understand at all, or you would see that all your words and wishes are but bars I must peer through at the life I want to lead."
"Bars?" he said, and his thumb smoothed down her cheek. "Éowyn. Éowyn, you are a shieldmaiden of my line. I would not cage you for all the world."
"Then why must you continue to do so, adding yet more bars with every excuse you make?" she said, and his mouth hardened.
"Do you forget yourself?"
"I know myself well, uncle," she replied lowly.
He sighed, and then he bowed his head in defeat. "Yes, I make the excuses a King must. For that is the role I play, Éowyn: mine are the decisions, for good or ill, and I have few around me to trust in these dark days, though a few more than I did when I lay smothered under the cloak of Wormtongue's whisperings. I love you, sister-daughter, and as your uncle who loves you I would give you the life you yearn for. I would give you the moon, were I able to pluck it from the sky. But I am also your King, and your King needs you elsewhere. Théoden son of Thengel cannot do as he will, for the King, and the Kingdom, are ever-hungry and ever-needy. And I am robbed of Théodred, and Éomer has the loyalty of his Éored but not of the people. He will follow me, aye. But they will follow you."
She was very still for a long second, and her eyes pressed closed tightly. "I see."
"Do you?" he said gently, and he shook his head. "For I despair that I must hurt you, as I always hurt you. I have brought to you such grief, and you give me love and duty in return and only ask for this one thing – this one thing that I may not give."
Her lips parted in astonishment, and then she shook her own fair head. "No, you do not bring me grief," she said, but it was weak and she seemed to sense it. Her gaze slid away, and then fixed upon one corner.
Thorin followed her eyeline to where he could see a figure beyond the great gold-bound doors, outlined against the sky. A pipe was held to its lips, and the head tipped back as it released the smoke.
"Aragorn," he said in realisation.
Théoden glanced over at the ranger, and then smiled gently. "I am happy for you in this, at least. He is an honourable man."
"You are both honourable men," she said in a fervent voice. With a blink, Thorin recognised the expression she wore and the light in her eyes. It was the same that shone in the faces of his nephews and family. Loyalty.
"Honour, a willing heart," he finished under his breath, and ignored the dull pang of his heart. "None could ask more than that."
"It was not Théoden of Rohan who led our people to victory," Théoden said, and he fixed his eyes upon Aragorn's silhouette with a speculative look.
Aragorn's hand lifted, as though touching something that hung about his neck.
Frerin muttered a rather nasty insult in Khuzdul, and ducked the swipe of Thorin's hand at his head. "Doesn't appreciate her," he grumbled, looking back at Éowyn with soulful eyes.

Puppy Love, (or, Frerin no) by Gremlinloquacious
"Oh, this is just gettin' ridiculous now," Óin said irritably. "Is there anyone around here who ain't gettin' sappy?"
Nori grinned. "Me. I prefer t' sort such things out on my ownsome, if you take my meaning. No need to get any others involved."
Óin made a noise of exasperation. "Good, that's a sensible way t' be, to my mind."
Thorin glanced back at them with a half-smile. "Not all of us prefer our crafts and our families, buhû."
"Well, o' course not. Who'd be satisfied with blacksmithing?" Óin sniffed.
Frerin folded his arms. "Are you mocking me?"
Óin glanced over at the young Dwarrow who was standing with his feet apart, bristling with indignation. His eyes softened. "No, lad," he said, and patted Frerin's shoulder. "No I'm not. It's not fer me, but if it makes you happy then I am glad for you."
Frerin deflated and then looked up at Éowyn. "Thank you," he mumbled, and then sighed longingly as Éowyn took the stirrup-cup and handed it to her uncle, her head bowing.
Théoden took it with gentle hands, before lifting it to the Hall. "The victorious dead," he proclaimed, and, meeting his niece's eyes, he drank.
"THE VICTORIOUS DEAD!" The Golden Hall rang with the shout.
She watched silently, and took back the cup when he had finished. Gandalf watched with glittering, unfathomable eyes as she walked through the rowdy crowds to the door, where Aragorn leaned against a pillar.
Frerin huffed and his fists tightened as she handed him the stirrup-cup with a murmured, "Westû Aragorn, hal!"
"I don't like this at all," he declared loudly.
"Strength, my brother," Thorin said quietly to him. Frerin threw him a sharp glare to see if he was being mocked, and upon seeing nothing but sincerity upon Thorin's face he deflated.
"Well, I don't," he grumbled.
Then a Dwarvish voice lifted over the din, and Frerin's eyebrows shot up as he stared at Thorin, speechless for a moment.
"He can't be singing that!" Nori said, disbelieving.
"Ach, hulhaj, hulhaj, hulhaj!" Óin moaned, and Frerin patted his back in return.
"Um. There, there," he said helplessly.
Thorin could only turn slowly to where his star was singing in his great deep voice, a song that had never in his memory been sung above stone and surely never before in the whole history of Arda before Men and Elves. Gimli's eyes were half-closed, and he was looking up at the torchlight as though his eyes saw another world, one far away and lost. His voice rolled out over the crowd, strong and low and rich:
[The Song of Beginnings, composed and performed by notanightlight]
[The Song of Beginnings, composed and performed by muchymozzarella]
"In the beginning we were stone and the stone was dead,
And the stone was hard and cold.
The stone was taken and the stone was shaped
In the darkness of the days of old.
The hands that loved us made us secret and strong;
The mind that wrought us knew we did not belong;
A discordant note in the primeval Song.
Blessed be Mahal and the mercy of the One.
In the beginning we were stone and the stone was mute
And stone has no will of its own.
Mahal gave us his will and moved us with his love,
And we thought his thoughts alone.
Then we sang with his words and we saw with his eyes;
We felt his great joys and we sighed with his sighs;
And all that we did was as he had devised.
Blessed be Mahal and the mercy of the One.
In the beginning we were stone and the stone was afraid,
For all things desire to grow.
We were found imperfect and cowered in shame,
And we discovered fear and sorrow.
And our thoughts were our own and our will was too;
Away from the fatal hammer-blow we drew,
And we wept as Mahal prepared all his work to undo.
Blessed be Mahal and the mercy of the One.
In the beginning we were stone and the stone became flesh,
And the flesh was new and pure.
The One looked at us with pity and upon Mahal with love,
And permitted us to endure.
The Seven were bound in slumber fathoms deep,
Against the coming of the Children their secrets to keep;
In darkness and in stone they were laid to sleep.
Blessed be Mahal and the mercy of the One.
In the end we will be flesh, and the flesh will fail,
And our lives will return to the stone.
The world will be renewed at the end of all days:
Again our works will be Mahal's alone.
And we will heal the great wounds in the skin of the earth;
We will sing with our words; we will prove our great worth.
We will never forget that we were stone at birth;
Blessed be Mahal and the mercy of the One."
There was a hushed pause, and then Merry said softly, "that was beautiful, Gimli. A beautiful song."
Gimli smiled. "Sounds better in Khuzdul. You made me think o' home, so you may blame yourselves for that."
"And gladly," Pippin said, his eyes wide and his chin perched upon his little hands. "Marvellous!"
"You have a fine voice, my friend," said Éomer, and Gimli waved his hand in modest dismissal and reached for the jug to fill his empty tankard. "Unlike anything we have heard. Do all Dwarves sing so low?"
Gimli shook his head. "No, not all. Barís Crystaltongue is the most celebrated singer of my generation. She can sing as high as a lark, as low as an underground lake; soft as a whisper of wind or as loud as the thundering storm, and yet always as clear as diamonds in sunlight. It is a great honour to hear her play and sing."
"I should look forward to that," said Aragorn, sending the utterly-still Legolas an amused glance. "The Elves who raised me were very fond of fine voices."
"Aye, as are Dwarves. But then, music is everywhere," Gimli said, taking another sip. "We sing from our cradles and take up instruments whenever we can. Idle hands need occupation, after all!" He grinned. "If you want to drive a Dwarf crazy, break all their fingers."
"Do you play, Master Dwarf?" Éomer seemed surprised.
"Aye, the fiddle," Gimli said, licking ale from his moustache. "My cousin taught me, ere he died. I was an indifferent student, but I am fond of it for his sake."
"No doubt it is as remarkable as your song," said Éomer jovially.
Gimli's eyes grew sheepish. "To tell you truth, I should not have sung that. Perhaps I am feeling more like a Dwarf of Erebor today, and less like one of the Three Hunters."
"Say not so!" Aragorn said, shaking his head. "You are our Dwarf, of the Three Kindreds. We need your spirit and your axe." He deliberately sent a knee into Legolas' back. "Is that not so?"
Legolas did not respond, his starry eyes transfixed upon Gimli and his mouth slack and gentle.
Thorin stepped closer, and then he found his voice. "You should not have sung the Song of Beginnings," he growled, and then he knuckled his forehead. "Oh, you will do as you wish – you always do!"
"It does not harm any for me to sing it," Gimli said, and he tipped his head back in a slightly-defiant manner that told Thorin that his complaint had been heard.
"They are our secrets to keep," Thorin said between gritted teeth.
One corner of Gimli's lip tugged to the side. "Aye, and blast our secrets. They have only ever caused suspicion and mistrust," he said, and then he deliberately turned to the Elf beside him. "All right there, laddie? You should give us one o' your songs of trees and stars and tragedy! This is a fine Hall for a song."
Thorin bristled.
Legolas, whose gaze was still glued to the Dwarf, suddenly shook himself. "I..." he began, and then he took a great gulp of his mug to hide his confusion.
"I will not feel sorry fer an Elf!" snapped Óin, and he clapped a hand over his eyes. "Oh, my brave bold nephew, you are as dense as granite!"
"You dropped him on his head," Thorin snapped back, and then a wave of consternation passed over him. "Wait, who am I defending?"
Frerin doubled over, trying to muffle his laughter.
"I do not know if my songs are fit for such a celebration," Legolas said, and he looked down at the mug that was wrapped in his fine, long-boned fingers.
"Oh mahumb," Gimli scoffed. Thorin now saw that he was far drunker than he had supposed, and the flush across the bridge of his nose and atop the apples of his cheeks was due to more than the heat. "Come on, Legolas, I have done my turn! We must represent the North, after all!"
Legolas looked up, and his gaze was soft as it rested upon the Dwarf. "True enough," he said. Then he laughed. "I do not think I can match your effort."
"Will you stop talking nonsense?" Gimli said, his hands landing upon his hips in a painfully Dwarvish manner and his head tilting expectantly. "Whoever heard of a Dwarf besting an Elf in a contest of song? Come now, raise your voice, ugbal bâhûn! I hear you warbling incessantly as we ride upon that torture-device you call a horse: surely you can manage a tune now that we no longer have Arod for an audience?"
"You speak him ill, but I know you grow fond of him," Legolas teased.
"Aye, as fond as any could be of an aching backside and stiff legs," Gimli countered. "Sing!"
Legolas laughed, and then he raised his voice. Unlike Gimli's deep subterranean rumble, Legolas' voice was cool and clear and as light as a sparkling brook:
["The Song of Lúthien and Beren", performed by notanightlight]
"The leaves were long, the grass was green,
The hemlock-umbels tall and fair,
And in the glade a light was seen
Of stars in shadow shimmering.
Tinúviel was dancing there
To music of a pipe unseen,
And light of stars was in her hair,
And in her raiment glimmering.
There Beren came from mountains cold,
And lost he wandered under leaves,
And where the Elven-river rolled
He walked alone and sorrowing.
He peered between the hemlock-leaves
And saw in wonder flowers of gold
Upon her mantle and her sleeves,
And her hair like shadow following."
There was more, but Thorin had caught the expression upon Aragorn's face as he turned away. He tapped Frerin's shoulder softly to let him know, and then moved after the Man through the crowds.
Aragorn pushed his way towards the door once more, and stood out upon the stone platform that lifted Meduseld high above the houses of Edoras. His breath was coming faster and there was a great pain in his eyes.
"You left quickly," came Éomer's voice. "Does the Elf's song offend you?"
Aragorn was silent for a moment, and then he bowed his head. "No, I took no offense. But I fear I understand it too well."
Éomer came to stand beside Aragorn, his proud face calm and unruffled. "I hear my uncle owes you a great debt."
Aragorn inclined his head. "Théoden-King is kind to say so."
"It is not the King who tells me so." Éomer cast his eyes out over the city, his yellow hair tugged by the ferocious winds of the plain. "The men of his Éored tell me that it was Aragorn son of Arathorn who led our people raging from their boltholes and into the enemy's teeth."
"I but did my part," Aragorn said quietly.
"I thank you for it, then," Éomer said.
"I hear you owe your life to a Dwarf," said Aragorn, turning to the Marshall of the Mark with a half-smile upon his lips, and Éomer chuckled softly.
"I do. When I met you in the grasslands I could not have foreseen that the Dwarf who took such immediate and fierce affront to my words should prove my saviour. Yet the world works in strange ways, and even stranger do they become in these dark days." He sent Aragorn a measuring look. "Aragorn, son of Arathorn, of the line of Elendil."
Aragorn was still for a second, and then his breath left him in a rush. "You speak truth," he replied, and the two Men stood and looked out at the sky, listening to the strange and mournful-sounding songs of the people of Rohan as they celebrated their victory and mourned their dead.

Three Kings, by witchofcake
It was very late.
Gimli was swaying quite a lot as he made his way through the corridors of Meduseld, his burly arm wrapped around the waist of an equally inebriated Elf. Every now and then he performed a little hop-step similar to the axe-dances of the Firebeards, and Legolas stumbled and laughed each time.
Thorin had sent Óin and Frerin back to the Halls of Mahal, and only Nori and he stood as witness to the bizarre spectacle. He was quite glad Óin had left. No doubt he would have exploded from embarrassment.
"You," Legolas said, lurching until he leaned somewhat against a wall with his free hand, "are a very convenient height, Master Dwarf. For an Elf. To rest upon. Against. Lean against."
"Subtle," Nori snorted.
"And you," Gimli returned, hiccupping, "are scurrilous drunk, a disgrace to Elvenkind an' I'm mortified to know ye. An' I am indeed a very good height, thank you for noticin'."
"Your accent gets thicker the drunker you are," Legolas said, and his fingers played a little over Gimli's fiery, thoroughly-mussed hair. He squinted down at it, as though only just now realising what his hand was doing. "And your hair is... coarse. Very coarse... and so thick I marvel you can pass a comb through it at all."
"Hmm?" Gimli peered upwards, before pulling his head away from Legolas' curious fingers. "Get off!"
"I did not say it was unpleasant," Legolas said, injured, and Gimli blew out a stream of air between his teeth, his whole demeanour deflating a little.
"Oh."
The pair lurched down the corridor some more.
"Can ye remember which room was ours?"
"Gandalf snores, we should be able to hear him well enough."
"Keep your ears hmm... peeled then. Your hearing is sharper than mine."
"Hold steady!" Legolas said, and rested a moment with his back pressed against a door. "You would have tipped me straight over, meleth nîn, and I doubt I have the wherewithal to put myself back upon my feet!"
"Ha!" Gimli grinned up at him. "Does this mean I win?"
"No, for I still stand," Legolas told him solemnly. Gimli's laugh was delighted and low. "Your pupils are huge and black as night in the darkness," the Elf continued in a dreamy sort of tone. "I would not have believed it. No wonder you can see in the dark, with such eyes."
"You can talk of eyes, Master Far-sight," Gimli prodded his side. "Sleep! I need it, an' now!"
"You snore worse than Gandalf."
Gimli flicked his great broad hand in dismissal. "Pfft. Lies and Elvish propaganda."
"I am afraid not, meleth nîn."
"Well, you sleep with your eyes open," Gimli retorted, and he hauled himself to his unsteady feet. "Ach, this Hall spins and turns like a child's plaything! Up you get, Master Elf!"
"Pippin said I should simply say it and have it out," Legolas mumbled as Gimli tugged him upright and began to lead him along the corridor once more. "Ai, mellon nîn, meleth nîn... Gi melin, gi melin n'uir. Nogoth vuin. Annon 'ûr nîn angin, Gimli-nîn ..."
Gimli frowned up at him. "Westron, thanking you kindly!"
art by fishfingersandscarves
"Ah, I do not think you would care to hear me say such things," Legolas said upon a sigh, and his hand wandered once more until it touched lightly upon Gimli's hair. "Would I find warm arms or hard axes waiting for me? I am an Elf, after all."
"Aye, you are Legolas, a very ridiculous Elf," Gimli corrected, his frown growing deeper. "Here now, what is this? Sighs – and tears? What is it you are trying to tell me, lad?"
"Lad," Legolas repeated with sudden bitterness, and he wound a strand of Gimli's hair around his finger slowly, watching the red shine, glossy as blood in the dim guttering torchlight. "Aye, and there is the heart of the matter. I am Elfkind. You are mortal. I was full-grown when your father's father's father was a squalling child. I was cold to Tauriel's words and to her warm heart and to their desperate plight. I locked them up and sneered, and I was glad. I was glad."
"Legolas, are you well?" Gimli put his hand over Legolas', twined in his hair. "You do not make sense! Are you grieved over Haldir?"
"Oh, he is so bloody thick, this is painful to watch," Nori burst out. Then he turned to Thorin. "Tell him. Mahal below, please tell him."
"Not Haldir, though my heart weeps for him," Legolas said, and his eyes were trained upon Gimli's huge, hard hand, wrapped securely around his own long white fingers. "That sadness shall not soon pass, but this? – O, this shall be the silent sorrow of my life, I fear."
"I do not have mercy for the fickle hearts of Elves," Thorin snarled under his breath, but he knew his voice lacked conviction.
Gimli's mouth pursed. Then his heavy jaw tensed beneath his beard and he said, "my Lord is here."
Legolas' head whipped up. There was true panic in his eyes.
"I could ask him," Gimli said, and he lifted his free hand and gently guided Legolas' fair head down to his level. "He sees much and knows more, my great King, my guardian and cousin. I could ask him what ails you so."
"Gimli," Legolas all but begged. "Meleth nîn, no."
Gimli's forehead butted up against the Elf's. "I will not," he rumbled gently. "I would not do that to you. But tell me, Legolas. What ails you? What is there to harm you here?"
Legolas' breath hitched around a sob, his fist tightening in Gimli's riotous hair – and finally, finally Gimli's eyes widened.
"Me," he said in a half-whisper. "Legolas, do I harm you?"
Nori strangled a scream in the back of his throat, tugging at the braids of his beard.
"No," Legolas said weakly, and he closed his glittering Elven eyes and leaned against Gimli's forehead with more of his weight, trusting in Gimli's great strength to hold him. "You do not harm me. You never harm me. I wish for something that cannot be, that is all."
"What cannot be? Who is it that causes you such pain, if not me?" Gimli demanded, and Thorin tensed.
"He fancies the braids off you, you stupid...!" Nori shouted. Thorin winced.
"It is nothing," Legolas sighed. "Just the night and the ale. I will be well enough, my dearest friend."

Gimli and Legolas, by valveillen
Gimli's expression was not convinced, but he allowed the Elf his wounded retreat and seemingly accepted the feeble excuse. He lifted up high upon his toes and pressed a bushy kiss upon the fair brow. "Come then, poor ale-soaked Elf, let us seek our beds."
"Aye," Legolas said, and he straightened slowly. "Hark! I can hear Gandalf."
"Which door?"
"The end one."
Gimli nodded and yawned hugely, rubbing at his eye with one fist. "Oh, my head."
"Even your head of stone must ache now and then," Legolas said with an attempt at his usual light flippancy, and Gimli grinned.
"Better that than a head stuffed with leaves! Still, I could sleep for a year or more. I will lead the way: there is someone asleep underneath a tapestry ahead, and I can show you where best to step."
Legolas nodded, and Gimli patted his arm comfortingly before he took the lead. Then he paused and looked back. "Legolas, you can tell me anything. I hope you know that. I would not mock you, nor harm you for all the mithril in Khazad-dûm."
Legolas forced a smile. "I know. I thank you. No Ellon ever had such a friend."
Gimli held Legolas' eyes for a moment, and then he nodded and began to make his unsteady way towards the end of the corridor.
Legolas' smile fell, and the look upon his face was torn beyond measure. His head dipped: the look was obscured by the golden fall of his hair. Then he walked after the Dwarf with surely the heaviest tread an Elf ever had.
As he trailed behind the Dwarf, his fingers rose and touched his brow with a delicate, questioning touch.
"He came so close to saying it," said Thorin, the tension draining out of him only to be replaced... by sadness? For the Elf? Never.
But he could not deny that he knew that expression and that pain. He knew what it was to behold your very heart before your eyes and be unable to reach out and clasp it close.
"What stopped him?" Nori said in frustration. "He'd almost said it – an' I would have won the betting pool!"
Thorin sent him a flat look.
"All right, so I've rigged it an' I'll win the betting pool anyway," Nori muttered, and he tossed his elaborately-braided head. "Still, I would have made a tidy little sum in a private matter between me an' your illustrious father."
"Adad made a private wager?" Thorin blinked. Thráin had certainly kept very hush-hush on that.
"Would have been a nice little earner, too," Nori grumbled, glaring at Gimli. "After all our many ventures, this is how you repay me? Ashamed I am, me dear. Ashamed and astonished at you. How many times did I back you in the Durin's Day tourneys?"
"You backed his rivals too," Thorin murmured.
Nori flapped his hand dismissively. "But everyone knew my main chance was the little Lordling! What stopped him? Why didn't the Elf bloody well talk? You normally can't get him to shut up!"
Thorin tried to ignore the rising lump in his throat and the mounting sympathy in his breast as he answered in a voice that was rougher than it should be: "He does not think of himself. He thinks of Gimli. He thinks of all that stands between them, all the ways by which they are divided by custom and habit and time. Did you not hear him? He spoke of mortality, and of our capture in Mirkwood and the Captain of the Guard..." He trailed off.
Kíli.
"I need to talk to my nephew," he said abruptly, and impatience was thick upon his tongue. "I need to talk to him now."
TBC...
