Chapter Text
It was extremely dark.
"Hello?" Gimizh called, and then he rubbed at his face. He could feel dirt smeared across his nose and grating in his beard (and it was a beard and not simply ambitious sideburns, no matter what Wee Thorin said!). He couldn't see his hand before his eyes. His voice bounced strangely: there was no tunnel before him anymore. "Hello? Jeri? Agur? Is anyone there?"
No answer.
Gimizh struggled to his feet, and then another shower of fine, clinging dirt came whispering from above. He froze.
His dad had been a humble miner once upon a time, before the Quest and Erebor and prosperity had hurtled him into the public eye. His dad's dad had been a miner. And his dad before him, too. Gimizh might have been descended from the aristocratic Line of Durin through his mother, but also bubbling in his veins swam generation upon generation of Broadbeam miners.
Now, alone in the dark, every single one of his instincts was awake and screaming at him.
"The whole thing's come down," he whispered to himself, and then he reached out with one hand into the stifling dark. "Air won't last. Need light, need light, need light…"
There must be a broken lamp, somewhere ahead. Gimizh could remember it hanging from a joist over the guards' heads, before he was knocked out. Somehow he knew that it was important to move as carefully and as quietly as he possibly could, in case his miraculous little pocket of space beneath the soil caved in.
His reaching hands found carven stone, and he blew out a shaky breath, and began to fumble about for the lamps. His pulse was very, very loud in his ears, but he wouldn't blubber like a baby. He was a great big Dwarf now. He could be brave – as brave as Uncle Gimli.
He wouldn't think about his Dad, trapped somewhere in all this smothering dirt.
"Ouch!" he yelped as his fingers found broken glass.
Hissssssss, went the shifting soil above him.
Gimizh's heart stopped entirely, a prayer trapped behind trembling lips. The sound of creaking wood and whispering dirt was terribly, terribly loud in the silence.
After a few breathless moments, he steeled his shaking hands and reached out again. The beam that had fallen had been toppled against the tunnel wall rather than caving in entirely, it seemed, and was now holding the wall's shoring timbers in place instead of the ceiling. That was the only reason that his little stretch of tunnel had not collapsed. Gimizh sent a fervent thanks to the Maker for that unexpected stroke of luck, and then his questing finger found the smooth cold bite of glass once more. The lamps had shattered when the beams fell, and warm lamp-fat spilled over his fingers. He wrinkled his nose. Gross.
Still, the fact that it was warm meant that it hadn't been all that long since the cave-in. Perhaps Jeri and Agur were still ahead, just underneath the greyish-brown soil of Erebor. Perhaps they were all right! They were warriors, like Aunt Orla and Uncle Gimli: of course they'd be all right.
Of course they would.
He managed to scoop up some of the tallow in the brass bowl of the lamp, and pulled at his clothes until he found the ties to his jacket. His mother would scold him, he thought ruefully as he bit through the sturdy wool and rolled it in the tallow before the stuff hardened, letting it dangle over the edge of the bowl. The broken glass around the sides bit at his fingers some more, and he stifled his whimpers. Brave Dwarves on adventures didn't cry.
The blood on his hands made the dirt into mud as he groped about by the fallen beam for the flint. There would be no tinder, and he knew that his improvised wick wouldn't last very long, but hopefully he would have light enough to make some torches.
His shin barked on the fallen beam, and he sucked in another whimper. He was a big Dwarf, he was a big Dwarf, he was a big Dwarf, he was a…
There was another hiss of shifting soil, and Gimizh was seized by a sudden sense of panic. He flung himself into the dirt around the beam, scrabbling around madly. "Where is it, where is it," he managed in a hitching whisper, his fingers sticky with blood and mud. "Where is it…"
His hand closed around the sharp, cool shape of the flints, two stones attached to each other by a length of chain.
He breathed out.
It was at that moment that Gimizh realised that what he had been hearing was not the hiss of soil.
When Thorin came barrelling through the starlight like a comet, he was greeted by pandemonium. "Thorin! Thank the Maker!" came Balin's voice through the din. "This way, this way!"
"Balin, what has…" he began, only to be interrupted.
"They shall not get in," Thrór said in a voice like dust and gravel. "They will not. We must fix this!"
"But what…"
"The tunnel that Bofur dug," rasped Thrór, and he met Thorin's eyes with dread written in the line of his lips and the stiffness of his shoulders, "they found it."
His blood curdled and his arm shot out, his hand grasping his grandfather's shoulder far, far too tightly. "They have not entered Erebor," he snarled. "They shall not enter Erebor!"
"They collapsed it," said Balin quietly. "Bofur was leading the Bizarûnh through, and then…"
To fight a foe in the dark, with the earth swallowing you at all quarters, no air, no light – Thorin shuddered. "Bofur has not arrived in the Halls," he was able to say. "Bifur would have said."
"That is good news," Balin said, and slumped.
Thorin raised his eyes to meet his old friend's, and frowned at what he found there. "That is not all."
"No," Balin said, and he took a breath. "Bofur's son is down there."
Thorin could only stare at Balin for a long, long moment. "Gimizh," he said eventually.
Gimli would be shattered.
"Thorin," said Thrór, a note of desperation in his voice. "Thorin, they may yet enter. Erebor is not whole!"
"Have they secured the entrance?" Thorin said, putting his horror aside with a massive act of will. He had no time to deal with it now.
He turned to the horde clustered at the end of the cave they stood in. Now that he looked more closely between the bodies of the workers, he was able to see that they were thronging around the entrance to a tunnel. Dirt and rocks were spilling from its mouth as though from a child's toppled bucket.
The noise was horrendous. Dwarves were shouting and screaming at each other, several were clutching terrible wounds, and one Dwarf was lax and lolling, insensible thanks to a horribly-bashed head. The miners at the tunnel-door were working furiously, and others were scurrying back and forth to take the wounded to the healers as they were brought forth from under the rubble. A great-voiced Dwarf (an Engineer, to judge by her braids) was shouting orders as the miners worked. And behind her, the King and Prince had arrived to assess the progress.
Judging from the looks on their faces, it was not going well.
"The beams have been smashed, bringing it down on our heads and theirs," said Dáin grimly. "This will be slow going."
"Orcs do not care for their own lives, only for robbing us of ours," the Stonehelm said.
"How far in have they reached?"
"Nigh thirty feet, though the new tunnel is unsafe and could come down again at any moment." The Stonehelm shook his dark-maned head. "We have little wood left with which to shore and prop the walls and roofs. They will make do with the splinters of what remains, but…"
"We've been running low for weeks, you don't need to tell me, lad," Dáin grunted. "The signal fires are being lit with my favourite writing-desk as we speak, and the forges are being fed with priceless heirlooms. Wood is more precious than gold, in these days."
They watched for a silent moment as a screaming Dwarf was brought forth by the miners and spirited away by the healers. Her leg had been shattered to smithereens, the foot totally missing.
"Well, I don't envy her what's to come," Dáin said eventually. "It stings like a bastard, from what I can remember."
At that moment, a bright pale shape came hurtling into the room. "Is it true?" demanded Laerophen, and his golden hair was disordered. No trace of his usual high-minded superiority was in his face, and he was gripping his knives in white-knuckled fists. "The little one, with the red hair – is it true?"
"What can you do if it were?" Dáin said evenly, and he turned back to his son. "We cannot draw more from the walls, we have barely enough to defend them as it is."
"I know," the Stonehelm said, his gaze fixed on the dark and sinister tunnel. "We must do with what we can spare."
"Miners, engineers, healers," Dáin muttered, and shook his head. "We've grown so complacent. Eighty years of peace! Used to be that I ran the tightest damned army in Middle-Earth. Now I must ask my people to take up shovels to defend themselves."
"I can help," Laerophen said, and he drew himself up tall. "I am an Elf, and I can see better than any Dwarf."
"Much good may it do you in pitch-darkness," the Stonehelm snapped. "You had best see to your archers."
"My second has her orders," Laerophen said, obstinately standing his ground. "Let me help."
"They're wasting time!" growled Thrór.
Thorin threw his hands in the air. "Let the damned weed-eater help, just stop arguing and get on with it!" he roared.
"Fine then, stay and be silent!" the Stonehelm burst out. Then he ran his hands through his long, black hair in frustration.
"Hold fast, lad," Balin said to him, and he looked up at Thorin with worry written all over him. "And you: keep your temper! This is tense enough as it is."
Thorin scowled at him, but did not spend his energy in useless argument.
"How did you hear?" Dáin asked the Elf.
"The messenger who told General Orla," said Laerophen. "I overheard them."
"Did anyone else hear?" demanded Dáin, and Laerophen shook his head.

Laerophen, by Mandel21
"This cannot get out," said the Stonehelm in a harsh undertone, grabbing his father's arm. "The rest of the Mountain cannot know!"
"No," Dáin said between gritted teeth, and his old sad eyes were hard as steel as he glared at the sea of diggers swarming around the mouth of the tunnel. "No they cannot. Those on the walls would lose heart immediately, and the city would panic."
"I will stay," said the Stonehelm firmly. "Go, you are our King. Go to the walls. Give them heart at the sight of you."
"Ah, there's a lad," Dáin grunted. "None would take heart at the sight of an old and creaky Dwarrow, but you do persist. We need fast messengers. Are there ravens here?"
"You know they dislike being underground," the Stonehelm said, and the shouts of the overseers rang out against the sound of shovels hitting metal. "They have found another!"
"Out of the way, out of the way!" Thorin growled, pushing past Balin, his grandfather, and the living alike, to stare at the shape thus revealed.
"That's Jeri child of Beri," said someone in a hushed voice. "Their face is like ashes!"
"Let them breathe!" snapped another. "Move back, you rats!"
"Jeri, Jeri – can you hear me?"
"Who is this Dwarf?" Thorin demanded.
"I don't know, laddie," Balin said in a subdued voice. "But that's the livery of Dwalin's own handpicked City Guard."
Thorin grimaced. "Do they live?"
"And that, I also cannot tell you," Balin sighed. "I expect we'll find out."
"Where is the messenger?" Dáin roared, and the gaggle of Dwarrows fussing over the prone Jeri began to thin as some took the stricken Dwarf away, and others returned to the digging. "To me!"
A skinny, gangling shape broke away from the diggers, their hands gripping their sleeves. "I'm assigned," said the Dwarf. "Your Majesty."
"That's Dwalin's boy," said Balin in shock.
"Thorin Dwalinul," Dáin said, and he let out a sigh, leaning heavily upon his metal peg. "Ach, Mahal curse it."
"Another child," Laerophen said, and he drew himself up with an expression of outrage and disapproval on his fine-boned face. "You still persist in this… this…"
"We have no choice!" Dáin shouted, and he closed his eyes and turned away. "Durin's beard! Of all people, I know what it is to fight too young! If you wish to be of use, Elf, then pray to your beloved starry Lady for a world in which children do not know war. Perhaps she will hear you. Mahal only knows I prayed for the same when I was younger even than this boy, and none of the precious Valar ever heard me!"
There was a ringing silence, in which Dáin wiped down his old, wrinkled face with a shaking hand.
Thorin knew that guilt. He knew the taste of it, the weight of it: to be the one left breathing in misery when others lie cold and still. "Dáin," he began, but he could think of nothing to say.
Laerophen was silent, and then he bowed his head.
The Stonehelm looked up at his father, and something hard and wise slotted into place in his eyes. "Another battle full of children, and no good choices left," he said beneath his breath. "As though we have not had our fill of such horrors. Mahal have mercy on us, I wish never to hear of, nor see another damned war for the rest of my life."
"I can help," Wee Thorin piped up. His dark face was alight with determination. "I want to help."
Dáin seemed to flinch imperceptibly at those words. For a moment, his great age could be seen upon his face. The facade of an indestructible warrior-king had cracked, and behind it could be seen a tired old Dwarrow.
"Adad," said the Stonehelm softly.
"Cousin," urged Thorin. "Cousin, you must grieve later. Come, you must take up the heavy mantle once more! Dáin, you pigheaded old idiot – there is no time!"
Dáin sighed again, and then the grizzled white head lifted. The facade slipped back into place and he appeared strong and proud once more, an ancient Dwarf of iron and teak. He turned back to look at the tall, skinny son of Dwalin and Orla. "Stay close to the Prince," he ordered Wee Thorin, his eyes grave and sad. "Any danger, I don't want you near it. I do not wish to hear that another young one has been lost, understood?"
Wee Thorin nodded, too full of worry for his best friend to protest being called "young one."
A new uproar began at the doorway, and Thrór shouted, "Thorin!"
Darting as best he could through the crowds, Thorin made his way to the entrance. The darkness in the cramped, makeshift tunnel beyond was absolute, and he peered into it. "The sounds of blades!" Thrór barked. "Orcs have survived in there!"
"Go!" snapped the Stonehelm to his father. Dáin nodded once, and then he turned and left the hall. There was no sign of his age hinted at in his angry, powerful stride. The sound of boulders crashing against the Mountain rang over the clashing of voices and shovels as he departed.
The Stonehelm watched his father leave for a moment, and then he turned back to glare at the ruins of the tunnel and grabbed Wee Thorin's hand. "Now, you stand behind me," he said in a low voice to the tall, gangling lad. "Should there be fighting, you must run for my father, understand? You are not to try any heroics."
"Yessir," Wee Thorin said, and his huge dark eyes were fixed on the tunnel mouth.
With a shout, a Dwarf spilled from the entrance into the hall, and her brow was smeared with blood. Blood also dripped from a tear in her tunic at her side, and she was pale and filthy. "They can crawl through it like worms!" she gasped, and fell in a heap.
Immediately on her heels came a slavering snarl, and two great, dirt-encrusted Orcs sprang forth. One was beheaded by the Stonehelm, and the other ended up with a pickaxe through the eye.
Laerophen ran to the injured Dwarf and quickly examined the wounds. "Broken ribs," he muttered. "Help me lift her, but keep her level!"
"Hold fast, but be wary!" the Prince shouted. "There may be more!"
"We need soldiers!" gabbled a miner as the injured Dwarf was led away.
"We do not," retorted the Stonehelm. "We are Dwarves, and this is our home. Would a soldier fight with more feeling?"
"A soldier'd probably fight with something sharper," grumbled the engineer, tugging at her pickaxe which had become embedded in the Orc's bony skull. "Give us a hand, would you?"
"Take this," Laerophen said impatiently, throwing one of his daggers to her feet. She picked it up and tested the edge, nodding in approval.
"Keep going!" the Stonehelm ordered, and he flicked the black blood from his sword. "Every second that slips away is one less breath of air for any who are trapped!"
"I heard there was Men down there too," said one miner. "Men can't hold their breaths as long as we…"
"We shall do what we can," said the Stonehelm. "But I say again: be wary!"
"Easy for you to say, you're not down there in the dark!" the panicking miner said in a high voice, clutching his hands and wringing them. "You in your shiny armour with your nice clean face, shoutin' orders! You're not grubbing in the filth and the muck and the dark! You're not looking at all your work in ruins and turned to nightmares, surrounded by screams, not knowin' if something horrible is going to come leapin' out at you and bite your head off, or eat you alive; if that noise you heard was a friend or somethin' unnatural sliming about…"
"Hregan, pull yourself together!" the engineer growled.
The Stonehelm's jaw rippled for a moment, and then he stepped forward. "Move."
"You what?" the miner said, interrupted in his hysterical ranting. "What?"
"You're in the doorway," the Stonehelm said, patient as the stone. "I need to get past you."
"You cannot be serious!" Laerophen shouted over the din. "You are their Prince!"
"And it is my duty to put myself between them and danger," the Stonehelm snapped back, "is it not, Prince Laerophen?"
The Elf gaped for a second, and then his lips pressed together and he bent his head back to the injured miner he was tending to.
"Wait, wait, I gotta stick by you!" gabbled Wee Thorin, and he clutched at the Prince's elbow. "Are we going in there?"
"You are not," the Stonehelm said. "I am."
"But the King said…"
"You will obey my orders!"
Wee Thorin's head snapped up, and his shoulders bunched. "Gimizh is my best friend! I'm going too!"
The Stonehelm's fists clenched. "I am your Prince!"
"So? I got orders from the King!" Wee Thorin folded his arms and glowered. "I. Am. Going."
Thorin Stonehelm glowered back.
Thorin scowled thunderously at them both. "Get on with it!"
Balin glanced between all three Thorins with an air of resignation, and then he turned to Thorin with his hands spread. "I don't want to have to point out the obvious here, my friend, but…"
"I swear to Mahal, this family," Thorin muttered, and put his head in his hands.
Gimizh cried out, one long ringing scream, and lashed forward with the broken lamp. Oil spilled everywhere. Some of it landed on his hand, soaking through his mitten and mixing with his blood. The rest landed in the eyes of the hissing Orc that had landed from the roof of the tunnel to snarl in his face. It reared back, howling. Gimizh screamed again, and smacked the thing in the face once more. Broken glass scattered through the air, a tinkling in the crushing blackness. The Orc gurgled in pain and its long arms reached for the terrified Dwarfling.
Gimizh gripped his lamp as hard as he could, and swung with all his might.
This time, the Orc's snarl trailed away into a dreadful choking noise, and Gimizh backed away on his bottom faster than he had ever done anything in his life. His heart was hammering like a million miners in his chest, and he felt light-headed and sick. His lamp clattered against the fallen beam, and he fumbled with the flint-chain in his bleeding hand to light his makeshift wick, praying all the while (more fervently than he had ever done before) that there was enough tallow left, that he hadn't just spilled it all.
The Orc made a horrible bubbling sound.
Gimizh sobbed, tears and snot running down his face unchecked, as he struck the flintstones against each other again and again and again, to no avail.
"Please," he whispered through numb lips. "Please."
Finally, he found the angle. A spark began to flare between the stones as he struck, and he cried in relief. Holding the stones over the wick, the spark caught and the remnants of the lamp sputtered into life, though the spilled oil sloshed about in the broken glass bowl and nearly doused the tiny flame. He blew on it unevenly, his breath hitching and catching in his heaving chest. The flame quivered for a moment, and then grew larger, steady and warm.
It was with shaking hands that Gimizh grabbed a fallen splinter of log and wrapped his filthy jacket around it. It had been new only a month ago, bought from Dori and decorated with boar's heads picked out in green and brown. He'd rather liked it.
"Oh, Mum's going to be so angry," he whimpered to himself, and then he whacked the stunned and bleeding Orc again with his unlit torch for good measure.
The jacket caught fire easily, and some of the freezing terror in his chest relaxed as he stood on wobbly legs. Gimizh picked up his lamp in one trembling hand and lifted his torch higher in the other in order to stare at his opponent.
The Orc lay across the tunnel, face covered in lamp oil and blood, twitching slightly. Glass was embedded in its head.
"I did it," Gimizh whispered. He'd killed an Orc, all by himself. Yet he didn't feel very adventurous. He felt rather ill, in fact.
Lifting his chin, he swallowed and steeled himself as best he could. He could be brave. He muffled the little voice in his chest that desperately cried to go home. He could be brave. Adventures might not be everything he had dreamed, but his father was still out there somewhere and Gimizh was going to find him or burst. Though it made his flesh crawl, he clambered over the Orc and began to trot further into the dark. He could be brave. He had killed an Orc in the darkness, all by himself! He was a mighty warrior! He was on a Quest, just like Uncle Gimli!
Wiping his filthy and bloodied hand across his forehead, Gimizh went forth into the unknown in search of his father.
The rattle of swords in the clinging darkness came seemingly from all sides. Shouts rang out, confusing the echoes, and shadows reeled and span in sickening motion as the lamps swung upon the arms of the fighters.
The Stonehelm roared and pressed forward into the crush of Orcs, his great spiked Morningstar leaving devastation in its wake. "Du Bekâr!" he shouted, and all around him the shout rose from a hundred throats, seemingly from the very earth itself: "Du Bekâr!"
Thorin charged forward through the ranks of Orcs to peer into the dark beyond. The tunnel had fallen through in several places, but the Orcs had squirmed through the softened earth like horrible moles to take their present stand. The dancing shadows made it hard to see, dark-vision be damned, but – a flicker here and there – and finally he could see the hole in the ceiling above, small and ragged and spitting Orcs. They came so thick and fast, not a single glimmer of light could be seen through the press of bodies. "There!" he shouted, and whirled back to see the Prince and Dwalin's son closing in on his position.
Wee Thorin appeared to be near-nerveless with fear as he shrank behind the Stonehelm. The deadly whistle of the great Morningstar Amradamnârab, or Death-Dealer, sang above the awful din of battle as it whirled above heads and crashed into limbs and smashed through armour and helmet and flesh. The Prince was wild with movement, his hair spinning out behind him in a graceful, deadly arc.
"Cousin!" Thorin tried. The Stonehelm blinked back sweat-crusted dirt from his eyelashes, and sent the Morningstar into the chest of an oncoming orc with a savage cry. His eyes blazed with anger. "Thorin Stonehelm, hearken to me!"
"Too far into the battle-lust, that one," Thrór panted. "Try another."
"But he is of Durin's line, our family hears me best," Thorin protested, and then he caught sight of the young son of Dwalin, hiding behind the Prince with a too-big axe in his hands.
"Thorin Dwalinul," he said blankly, and cursed beneath his breath. Then he rushed forward. "Unday! Here is the place they entered! Look up, look up!"
"No," Thrór said, shocked. Balin let out a wordless cry of outrage.
"Child, listen to me!" Thorin bellowed, pushing back through the chaos.
Balin reached him just as he made it to the lad. "Thorin, what are you doing?" he said, anger making his voice tight. "That is my nephew!"
"And you think I will have better luck reaching Dáin's son, do you?" Thorin barked back, tense and harsh. "The Stonehelm hears nothing but the voice of battle. He will not hear my words. The boy will."
"The boy, as you put it, is only thirty-seven years old!" Balin cried, and he clamped one hand about Thorin's forearm, as inflexible as steel cuffs. "Thorin, no!"
"Would you have the Orcs overrun the tunnel?" Thorin snapped back. "I like it even less than you do, but there is no other way! It must be blocked!
"Got to be blocked," Wee Thorin muttered, and he hoisted his heavy axe higher in his hands. The double-bladed head was nearly as high as he was.
Thorin gave Balin a hard look of understanding and determination. "I am sorry, old friend," he said through clenched teeth. "I cannot wait longer."
Balin's hands flexed as though they yearned for the handle of his sword, and then he grated, "do it."
Thorin span back to the boy. "Thorin," he said to him, and how odd it was, to call another by his daylight-name! "Thorin, do you see the roof where the Orcs cluster thickly?"
The boy's wide eyes, whites showing in fear, flickered up. Then he sucked in a little breath. "There!" he howled, and he ran forward, pointing up frantically. His little boots clattered as he stomped them, hollering at the top of his lungs. His voice soared above the lower bellows of adult Dwarves and the snarls of the Orcs. "There, up there, do you see? There's the entrance to their tunnel! They're using the collapsed roof as a stair down into ours! There's where they're gettin' in!"
The shout was taken up by others, and Thorin slumped back. "Thank the Maker," he said, as the defenders swarmed towards the Orc's entry-point.
But the childish shouts had drawn the enemy's attention. Balin let out a horrified cry as a great grey Orc began to prowl towards the child, a vicious-looking gutting-knife in her hands and a cruel smile on her face. "Hello, little grub," she purred, and a long, thick tongue wetted her lips in a gross slobbering display. "What a tender little morsel you are, eh? Not all tough an' gristly like these bigger 'uns, I'll wager..."
"Get you gone, you foul thing!" Thorin growled, and Wee Thorin gulped and raised his axe in shaking hands.
"Bet I taste horrible," he said bravely. "Bet I make you choke."
"Well, we won't know," sneered the Orc, picking up speed, "until we try!"
It lunged, and Wee Thorin shrieked and swung out with the axe. Too heavy, the head clattered to the ground and he managed to lift it again by staggering backwards and wrenching with all his strength. The Orc laughed, having dodged the wild swing easily. "Oooh, nasty little morsel," she cooed. "Gonna split me up the middle, are you? Gonna spill out my innards?"
"Yes," said the Dwarfling defiantly. "So go away before I chop you up into little bits!"
The Orc chortled again, low and sneering. Then she abruptly stopped, her mouth hanging open around her last laugh.
Wee Thorin blinked.
A bright shape, near-luminous in the dark, appeared over the Orc's shoulder and there was the slick sound of steel drawn out of flesh. The Orc made a surprised, soggy sound, and then keeled over onto her face.
"I thought the Prince told you to stay behind him," said Laerophen, his eyes flashing with anger.
"I thought Elves only fought with bows and arrows," retorted Wee Thorin, his axe still clutched to his chest with shaking hands. "Guess we were both wrong."
Laerophen smiled, quick and feral. "There is little light and less room for shooting in this maddening darkness," he said. "Stay close, child."
"Don't call me that," Wee Thorin said automatically, but he scurried into the Elf's wake nevertheless.
Thorin reached out and steadied Balin as he swayed in relief.
"They collapsed the tunnel beyond this point!" came the cry from the Dwarves at the beginning of the Orc's tunnel. "They were tunnelling downwards from the surface above our own – where their diggings met ours, they collapsed the roof to provide their stair down! Bofur and the Dale-Men must be beyond!"
"Can you hear them?" roared the Prince. Ragged shouts in the negative came wafting back amongst the rattle and clash of weapons.
Thorin glanced at the tumbling wall of earth that had provided the Orcs their way into the tunnel that had been such a source of hope. "Do you suppose..." he wondered aloud.
Thrór frowned in confusion, and then his eyes opened wide. "Try," he said eagerly.
"What, I'm not following," Balin said, still loose and boneless due to the unexpected rescue of his nephew. "Try what, Thorin?"
"I will walk through the earth to the trapped miners and the Bizarûnh," he said, still eyeing the wall of shattered beams, scattered rocks and earth that stood between them. "I will find them. Perhaps Bofur will hear me."
"And Gimizh?" said Balin, looking up. His face was white, and his beard was uncharacteristically mussed. "What of him?"
Thorin hesitated, a short sharp pain twisting his insides. "If I can find him," he acknowledged.
Neither of them needed to state the odds of a lone Dwarfling surviving a cave-in.
As there was nothing more to say, Thorin strode forward through the clashing combatants and laid his hand above the spilled wall of rubble. It seemed solid enough, but then, the world of Gimlîn-zâram generally felt sturdy and solid to the touch at first. Walls and floors and earth and water appeared to obey their accustomed laws for the dead watchers, until they were put to the test. The illusion was comforting, though easily broken.
Thorin swallowed and pushed his hand forward, fingers outstretched. It disappeared into the dirt up to the elbow.
No. I will not die like this, came the echo of his own voice from the distant past, cowering, clawing for breath.
He took a breath, filling his lungs near to bursting, and then plunged headfirst into the suffocating nothingness beneath the earth.
Gimizh raised his torch higher and blinked.
No, that couldn't be right.
He looked behind him at the clods of earth he had clambered over, and then ahead at the long stretch of empty tunnel in perfect order. He thought that perhaps Erebor was behind him, rather than in front. He must have been walking the wrong way.
Gimizh said a word that his mother would have pinched his ear for saying, and rubbed at his bleeding hand again. His lamp had long since gone out, but he had kept it in order to use the tallow to feed his torch. There was dirt in his eyelashes, and he could feel it scratching at the soft delicate tissues of his eyes. They were watering slightly, but he didn't dare rub at them. They were sore enough already.
He needed water. Durin's beard, but he was thirsty.

Gimizh in the tunnel, by NarukaUzumaki13
So the Orcs had collapsed the tunnel in the middle? Stupid Orcs. Now Gimizh couldn't get back home. He flopped himself onto the ground and jammed the butt of his torch into the ground, pulling at his shirt. The torch flickered feebly, and he said the bad word again. It would soon go out.
He managed to get his shirt off, smeared in tallow, and wrapped around the torch just in time. Thankfully, the fire had not died, and neither did he smother it in his clumsy haste.
Bare to the waist, he was freezing. He wrapped his bleeding hand around himself tightly, and picked up the torch again in his good one. His lamp was empty now. He gave it a regretful look. It had killed the Orc for him, but it was of no more use. He left it lying on the ground and faced the yawning tunnel again.
"Can't go back," he muttered, and waved the torch forward into the gloom. There was a bend ahead, and no sign of any other light. It seemed as though the tunnel would never end. "Got to go forward."
Maybe his dad was somewhere ahead? He hadn't seen hide nor hair of any Dale-Men. All the guards that had been waiting with Gimizh had disappeared, and he tried not to think about them smothered under the cold, clammy weight of the earth. Hopefully they had been on the other side of the cave-in, and had already been rescued. He hoped so. Jeri was nice, and Agur usually had a treat for a big-eyed Dwarfling who looked sad and sorrowful enough.
He began to trot along the tunnel once more, tremors shaking his body. One day he would have a splendid furry chest (just like Uncle Gimli!) to keep himself warm. One day, he told himself firmly, and tried not to let his teeth chatter.
Quests were stupid.
"Who's there!" snapped a voice in the dark.
Gimizh yelped, startled out of his numb and terrified thoughts. "Please don't hurt me!" he said, his breath coming fast and rough, the cold air hurting his throat. "I'm dangerous, I am! I killed an Orc, an' I'm a mighty warrior, an' I'll... I'll cut you into a million bits if you come close!"
There was a pause, and then a soft, familiar laugh. "Now there's a terrible thing."
Gimizh's breath slammed into his body like a charging Oliphaunt, crushing his chest under its weight. Then he was barrelling forward blindly, his torch left somewhere in the dirt. "Adad, adad, adad, adad," he sobbed, and his hands reached forward to touch familiar braids, a curling moustache, a thick and solid chest.
"Ooof!" said Bofur, and he was really really real! Gimizh wanted to crow from the top of the Mountain – or he would, if he could stop crying.
"What is this?" came another voice, hissing angrily, and Bofur shook his head.
"Stand down, Bard, no danger," he said. "This is my boy, Gimizh."
Unknown hands picked up Gimizh's torch, holding it high and illuminating the corridor. Gimizh couldn't find the energy to wonder who it was. He could only clutch at his father and bury his face in Bofur's chest and cry and cry and cry.
"Didn't know they actually had children," came a whisper from further along the tunnel. "Thought they were carved from stone and that..."
"You're a credulous ole simpleton then, aren't you?" someone whispered back. "That's a child if ever I saw one."
Gimizh simply couldn't seem to stop crying. "I fought an Orc, Daddy, just like Uncle Gimli, an' it didn't m-move anymore because I killed it, me, an' I promised I'd f-find you..."
"Hush, me little warrior, you found me," Bofur said, and his fingers were oddly clumsy as he felt over Gimizh's face. "You're bleeding. Why in Mahal's blessed name are y' down here?"
"The King said, w-wait by the tunnel and take messages, but I got bored an' w-went in," Gimizh babbled, and he clung to Bofur's neck as the tears trickled down his face and streaked his bare chest. "The roof came down on me, an' I couldn't find Jeri, an' I killed an Orc that hissed at me and my hand got hurt The tunnel's b-blocked, so I came this way. I f-fixed a torch, but I lost my shirt and jacket. I heard clashing. I think there's fighting on the other side."
"There's been fierce fighting this side too, me lad, but it seems they're mostly focused on gettin' into the Mountain," Bofur said, and there was a heavy reluctance in his voice. "They've all gone the other way, trusting that the limited air will do their dirty work for 'em. Thankfully it seems we're a small prize compared to Erebor- and thankfully they never reckoned with Dwarvish engineering. The sea'll rise before our air-pipes fail. That's a bit o' luck, eh?"
"I'm the happiest Dwarf in the M-mountain," Gimizh said, his face still pressed against Bofur's chest. The brocades of his father's jacket rubbed against his cheek and lips as he spoke. The familiar scent that clung to his skin underneath the smell of blood and dirt caused something to snap and unwind, deep in his stomach. The tears finally trickled to a halt as Bofur rubbed his back with one wide hand, and Gimizh wiped at his eyes, and sniffled. "Are you all right?"
"Here, take my coat," Bofur said abruptly, and he pulled away to take off his jacket and wrap it around Gimizh's shoulders. "You'll catch your death an' your mother will have my beard. Well, after she's done flaying us both alive for putting ourselves in such a damn-fool situation, that is."
"Tell him," said the Man that Bofur had called Bard in a sharp tone. "We have no time, and he must be our eyes."
"All right, keep yer hair on," Bofur retorted.
Gimizh frowned. "Dad, what aren't you saying?"
"Know me too well, don't you?" Bofur grinned, staring blankly out into the tunnel. "Now, me little lad, I'm terribly proud of how brave you are, facing that Orc an' keeping your head. I don't want to have to do this, but there's no other way. These Dale-Men don't know a damn thing about moving underground. I need you to be the bravest you have ever been."
"Very brave, the bravest!" Gimizh agreed. Then he screwed up his face. "Why?"
Bofur took a long, slow breath and said, "Gimizh, my nidoyel, you must do something for me now. You'll have to guide me."
Something struck Gimizh then. "Dad," he said slowly. "Why aren't you looking at me?"
"That's just the thing, undayuh," sighed Bofur, and he lifted his chin as though preparing himself. "When the beams came down, the Men had to drag me out from under 'em. I'm whole enough, only a broken arm, I think, but something hit my head. There was a white flash, and then everything went black, and it's been black ever since. I can't see."
Gimizh stared at his father in shock.
"Guess we just have Mahal's own luck when it comes to bein' knocked on the noggin," Bofur added wryly.
It was a nightmare made real.
Thorin pushed through the layers of dirt and rock and fallen wood, his scream trapped behind his teeth. His chest heaved, though his mind insisted that he was suffocating. He imagined that he could feel the soil and the rock and the beams gliding through skin and flesh and bone and sinew, smooth as an Elven sword through water. He retched, and clenched his eyes shut. He would press on. He would press on.
There were voices ahead. Thorin's eyes snapped open reflexively, and then he squeezed them shut again. Too soon. He had only been afforded the tiniest glimpse – barely a fraction of a second – but even that was too much.
For an underground race, this was the ultimate horror.
He staggered onwards. The sounds kept growing in volume, distorting in his ears as though through water. The echoes were smothered by the press of rock and soil, and Thorin's scream was slowly but surely crawling its way up his throat. He could taste it, crouching just behind his tongue.
Though he could breathe, his mind insisted that he was suffocating. His lungs ached like a wound. Every beat of his pulse sent the blood racing around his body in a mad dance. He could feel it in the throb behind his eyelids.
I will not die like this, cowering, clawing for breath!
"You are dead!" he growled at himself, at his foolish fears. "You are already dead! You are but a thought and a whisper in the waking world. Dís would make endless sport of you if she could see you now. Take heart. Take heart! For all your faults, you are neither craven nor coward, at least. Pull yourself together!"
Cowering, clawing for breath!
Thorin pushed on, and the sounds of battle behind him and the murmur of voices ahead began to take on a distorted, nightmarish incoherency. He let out a wordless shout of protest at the clashing in his ears, his own voice adding to the reeling cacophony of noise.
"Calm down!" said Bilbo.
"Oh, thank Mahal!" Thorin nearly collapsed, the words tripping and tumbling out of his mouth. "Bilbo, Bilbo my own, thank you, thank Mahal, thank the Maker..."
"One foot after the other," Bilbo said soothingly. "Come on then!"
Thorin staggered forward, his hands outstretched before him. The stones grated against his bones as they passed through him, and he bit his lip, hard. Blood welled in his mouth. "Bilbo!" he gasped.
"Nearly, nearly," coaxed Bilbo. Thorin wished he were brave enough to dare another peek, to see if his Hobbit slid through the earth alongside him, but he dared not risk it again. Once was more than enough. "Keep on keeping on, as Hamfast used to say."
"That is your neighbour, is it not?" asked Thorin though he knew perfectly well that it was. He could think of absolutely nothing else to say. His mind was a mess of rock and panic.
"Mmm. Young Sam's father. He tended the garden at Bag End since before my holiday, you know. Local expert on potatoes."
"Potatoes," Thorin echoed.
"Yes, potatoes," Bilbo said, and there was a smile on his lips. Thorin could hear it in the warmth of the words and feel it in the unknotting of his limbs. "White floury lumpy things that grow underground and dislike sunlight. I expect you to show some fellow-feeling."
"Are you calling me lumpy?"
"Lumpy enough. I do know what a Dwarf looks like underneath his armour, remember."
Thorin's mouth twitched. "And did the sight please you?"
"Oh, fishing for compliments now? Most dignified of you, O mighty King Under the Mountain. Besides, I might be calling you a vegetable," Bilbo sniffed.
Thorin let his laugh bubble up, drowning any lingering memory of that clawing scream. "Impertinent Hobbit."
"Pompous Dwarf. Keep moving."
art by mandolinearts
Suddenly there was air surrounding them, and Thorin's eyes snapped open again. The rock no longer closed around him, and he stumbled forward onto his hands and knees and panted, gasping.
He managed to get himself under control after a few moments, and looked up to see his young, vital One standing in the darkness. Bilbo's face was proud and his head was held at a jaunty angle.
"There, now," Bilbo said in satisfaction. And vanished.
Kíli sighed and leaned his head upon his hands.
"So great a sigh, my son?" said his Maker gently, and Kíli glanced up without thinking only to jerk his gaze away from the wise and glorious face, blinking hard.
"Ow," he mumbled, before gingerly looking up again through cautiously-narrowed eyes.
"Be careful," Mahal said. "I have repaired your eyes once already."
Kíli pulled a face, before shading his eyes with one hand. "Hobbits are really titchy. Really small, even littler than Frerin. They don't take up much room."
"So you have said before."
"And they're excellent cooks. And grow superb pipeweed. And they brew fantastic beer. You'd like it."
"No doubt."
"And I'm sure Mandos doesn't need all of them. He's being really selfish, keeping them all to himself. He should share some with you. Or y'know, at least one. They brighten up a place."
"Yes, so I have heard."
Kíli sighed again, and let his head roll forward, hitting his hands with a thud. "You're not making this easy."
"No, my son," Mahal agreed mildly. "That I am not."
Kíli grumbled under his breath for a moment, and then he shrugged and looked up once more. "So, is the glowy thing gone for good now, out and about where we can't go? Is it in the world yet? Are you gonna tell me what it was? Won't it attract a lot of notice – I can't imagine a big glowy thing being terribly inconspicuous, somehow. What was it made of? Can it burn things? I can keep on asking questions, you know. I've got hundreds more."
"Soon," Mahal said in that voice that shuddered through Kíli's very flesh. The Vala put down his hammer, and then stepped back from the anvil, his great shaggy head tipping as he regarded the shape and soul of the Dwarf he was building. Then he let out a gust of breath like a mighty wind and sat down upon a chair (or was it an embryonic mountain, complete with forests and glaciers and cloudy-headed peak, growing even as Kíli watched?), still considering his work. "Soon. The time grows ever nearer when it will emerge and be known once more. And it is not a fire as you understand one, but a spirit: a spirit reforged and burning anew. But you do not tell me why you sigh so loudly, Kíli."
Kíli's gaze skittered away. "Uh, no, well spotted there."
His Maker reached down and tugged at Kíli's mad hair. "You do not normally find it difficult to speak, Kíli. Which of your hundred questions is troubling you?"
Kíli was silent.
Mahal turned with knitted brows to fix the unnaturally quiet young Dwarf under his gaze. "Nathânûn."
A shudder ran up his spine like lightning, and Kíli blurted, "where do Elves go?"
Mahal paused with his fingers still caught in Kíli's hair.
"Because... well," Kíli checked himself, and then grasped at one of those huge, burn-scarred fingers with both hands. "You know. You have to know. I haven't said anything before. I won't ever again, if it's not right to know. But I need to try, just once. Where is she? Please."
The mighty bearded head stooped, and then Mahal murmured, "I should have foreseen this. Speaking with your uncle has brought it close, I see."
"It's always close," Kíli said, and he lifted his chin.
"Of course it is," Mahal said, and he smiled distantly. "Of course."
"So where is she?" Kíli pressed, and then he bit hard on his lip. "Can you tell me? I mean, are you allowed?"
"My brother Námo is something of a mystery," said the eternal Smith. "His Halls are ever-shifting and ever-drifting, a part of this continent and yet separate, joined to the world and outside of it all at once."
Kíli frowned.
"Men and Hobbits and those of mortal kind are not tied to this earth in the way the Firstborn are," Mahal continued. "Not even my Dwarves are so tightly connected to the earth, for all that they were made from it. You have been given this place of calm and respite before the world is remade, but Elves do not truly ever leave. All other souls go onwards, beyond Middle-Earth, to a fate that not even my brother Manwë knows. And so Men and Hobbits and Ents do not reside in the Halls of Mandos after they enter there, but are instead set free to go where we may not. It is the Gift of Eru Ilúvatar to the Secondborn."
"Not much of a gift, to be shunted around like a parcel sent to a mystery address," Kíli said impatiently, still gnawing on his lip. "Elves?"
"Elves cannot move on," Mahal said, and his thumb smoothed over Kíli's forehead. "I am sorry, Kíli. Elves do not leave the Halls the way mortal-kind does. They reside there until the ending of the world, and rarely does my brother loosen his grip. There lives an Elf in Rivendell who has passed through his doors – Glorfindel, he of the golden hair – but not since the dawn of Arda has Námo relented in his iron devotion to his given task. You might as well ask me to stop my work."
Kíli blinked. "At the ending of the world."
"Aye."
"That's the world we're standing on, right? I just want to be clear."
Mahal raised one grizzled eyebrow. "Aye?"
"The one we're meant to rebuild after Dagor Dagorath?"
The giant fingers halted in their stroking of Kíli's hair.
Kíli beamed. "Thought so."
"You would wait so long?" Mahal asked incredulously. "The years that must pass are beyond counting."
Kíli set his jaw and looked up into the radiant face of his Creator without flinching. "I would wait twice as long," he said firmly.
"Ach, brave child," said the Vala softly, "I built loyalty into your bones. I did not understand how deep it settled."
"I will see her again," Kíli said, and he beamed once more, his heart as light as air. "Who cares about the years in between? With a hope like that, I could move Taniquetil pebble by pebble! I could swim the sundering seas! I could eat a whole bowl of salad! I will see Tauriel again!"
"You found them?" asked Frerin.
Thorin collapsed in a chair. Even the sourceless grey light of the Halls was preferable to the tunnels beneath Erebor. "Aye. I need a drink."
Frís set a tankard by his hand, and Thorin drank deeply and only paused when the suds began to trickle into his beard. "Slowly," Frís cautioned him. "You'll choke."
"Bofur's really blind?" said Fíli, his voice small and shocked.
Thorin stilled, his tankard halfway to his mouth. Then he nodded. Fíli blew out a breath and slumped back in his chair. "Maker have mercy," he said numbly.
"There is little mercy in those tunnels," Thorin rasped. "Yet Gimizh lives, a miracle indeed. They are trapped somewhere beyond the fallen ceiling, and cannot reach Erebor. They must go back towards Dale and undoubtedly into the teeth of even more Orcs, or starve in the darkness."
"What about the Prince and the others, on the Mountain's side of the cave-in?" said Frerin, frowning. "Can they not dig through?"
Thorin sighed. "I returned to them and spoke to Wee Thorin. That he believes his friend to be alive is no great surprise to the others. I only bolstered his conviction. It will take fierce fighting to see off the Orcs that even now continue to pour into the tunnels."
Thrór shared a glance with Hrera, and then he closed his eyes to hide his fears. Around him, the family sat in a tense silence. None of them mentioned the other possible option: to collapse the entire tunnel and so cut off the Orcs' entry.
"You're worn-out, nadad," said Frerin, and he hastily refilled the tankard, spilling a little as his jug sloshed onto the table. "Drink that."
"What of the Fellowship?" Thorin said after he had taken a few swallows. "How is Gimli?"
"Subdued," said Frerin, and he shrugged. "He knew I was there. He greeted me by name. Still, he speaks eagerly enough to Aragorn, Merry, the Lady Éowyn and to King Théoden. They ride to Dunharrow now to meet with the muster of the Rohirrim."
"And Legolas?" Thorin lifted his eyes to meet his brother's. "Does he speak to Legolas?"
Frerin hesitated. Then he blurted, "they ride together as they have ever done, but they speak no more than necessary."
Thorin let his head fall forward. "Curse it all," he said softly, and then stood with aching limbs and set down his empty tankard. "I will see Bilbo now."
"And then bed," Frís said, eyes glinting sternly.
"And then bed," he agreed tonelessly.
The Elf was tall and elegant, with smooth dark hair and a heart-stoppingly beautiful face... but then, they all were. Thorin slumped in exhaustion beside the Elf and squinted up at him accusingly. "You could move over a little," he groused. His heart ached. His every muscle ached. His hair ached. "And your harp-playing is insipid and bland."
The Elf, naturally, could not hear him. Thorin folded his arms and glowered at where his Hobbit hovered over a board, a playing piece clutched in his little wrinkled hand. "Now, which way do these move again?" he mused.
"This way, Bilbo," said Arwen gently. Her eyes were ringed in dark shadows, and her cheeks had become hollowed. Thorin glanced over her, his brows lowering.
Bilbo peered at the board with watery eyes as she moved the piece, and then he shook his head. "No: it's no good, I shan't be able to play Lanthir, I don't understand it in the slightest. You'll have to find another victim, Lady Arwen."
She smiled. "I would prefer no other partner."
"Oh, now, that's a fib." Bilbo put down the little game-piece in his hand and yawned. "Goodness me, is that the time?"
Arwen looked up at the clock, and then back down at the ancient Hobbit with a sad sort of understanding. "It is only four hours past the midday meal, Bilbo."
"Mmmm, terribly late," he mumbled, and his head began to nod. Then he jerked his chin up, blinking hard. "No, no, I had to do something, what was it?"
Arwen shared a glance with the harpist, before she said, "perhaps you wished to water your garden?"
"I'm sure it was important," Bilbo muttered, and his withered hands plucked at the blanket over his knees. "Blast this memory – more full of holes than a doily, it is. You know, you really aren't looking well, Lady Arwen. I hope you're not coming down with something?"
Arwen's glorious eyes widened, and then she turned away with uncharacteristic sharpness. Her lips were pressed into a thin line of pain. "It is nothing," she said.
Thorin's brow furrowed. "Never seen an Elf look less than healthy," he mumbled to himself. "Yet there are dark rings beneath her eyes, and her cheeks are pale and wan..."
"I might be a little fuzzy on fine details these days, but I am neither dense nor blind!" Bilbo said crisply, and he lifted his chin in his most haughty manner. Thorin nearly smiled at it: how familiar it was, and how dear. "It is not 'nothing' – it is clearly a 'something', and I would very much like to be told what it is!"
Arwen was still for a moment, and then her head tipped forward, covering her face in a waterfall of black silk. "Indeed, you are not blind, but one hardly needs the sight of the Elves to see it," she said in her low, musical voice. "I am not well, Master Baggins. I may not recover."
"Not recover?" exclaimed Bilbo. "How now, what's this? Your father will fix you up in a trice, I'm sure. Why, if he can help soothe an old Hobbit's aching bones, no doubt he can have you back to your old self faster than you can say 'cabbages'!"
"But my father is not here," she said with a sigh, tipping her head back again. "You do not recall, but he left a month ago. He rides now to Edoras, in the kingdom of Rohan."
"He does?" Bilbo grimaced. "Blast, must have slipped my mind. Well, you're an Elf-maid at any rate: no doubt you've the constitution of an ox. I never heard of an Elf with... what is it, anyway?"
Arwen's jaw tensed.
Bilbo's breath caught and snagged in his throat, and he leaned forward. "Lady, it is not...?" he gasped.
She nodded once.
Bilbo stared at her in horrified silence, and then he slumped back against his cushions, his eyes huge in his withered face. "Good gracious," he said faintly.
"What, what is it?" Thorin demanded, and he stood up to examine the Elf more closely, though every muscle protested vociferously. "What is the matter with her?"
"Can it not be halted?" Bilbo asked, his voice quavering. "Can it be stopped?"
"You know better than that, Bilbo," she said with a bitter little smile. "You know more of our ways than the wisest of the younger races, save Aragorn himself. You know that I cannot halt it."
"But you are not wholly Elven," Bilbo protested, and he twisted his hands together, the gnarled knuckles cracking. "Perhaps that will stump it."
"No." Arwen waved a slim hand at the harpist, and he bowed his head and stood. His robes swept the floor of the autumn leaves as he left.
Arwen took his seat, and then laid her hands over Bilbo's fidgeting ones. "I cannot halt it, nor do I wish to," she said, her voice intense and her eyes blazing in her pale and ghostly face. "My father," she spat, and then she closed her eyes. "My father wished to spare me this. He wanted to send me over the seas, where no sickness dwells and no evil can touch me. But my sickness would have followed me there. I am tied to this Middle-Earth now, and no power of darkness or light can sever it."
"No!" Bilbo said hotly. "That's a dreadful thing to say! Just imagine, throwing yourself away for a silly thing like love - piffle and tommyrot! Aragorn might be quite a remarkable fellow, but he's hardly the only one around. Why, the world is full of remarkable fellows, if they're to your taste. For goodness' sake! You're too remarkable yourself to go about pining to death!"
"It is my nature," she said, and squeezed Bilbo's hands. "And I have made my choice."
"Well, choose again!" Bilbo fumed.
"As easily as that?" said Arwen softly. "So you could have accepted another Dwarf in place of your dead King, could you?"
Thorin's throat abruptly snapped closed.
"Well, now that's hardly..." Bilbo spluttered, and then he scowled. "That's not nearly the same, and you know it! At any rate, I'm still here, aren't I?"
"Yes," she said, and her eyes were full of sympathy. "You are."
"Ghivashel," Thorin breathed, and his hand rose seemingly of its own volition to cup that wasted, wrinkled cheek. If he hovered it just above the skin, he could almost believe the illusion that he was touching his Hobbit at last.
Illusion was better than nothing.
"I mean..." Bilbo flustered, and his mouth worked uselessly for a moment. "Now, wait just a moment, I never..."
"No you did not, but then Hobbits are not Elves," said Arwen, and she knelt before him, her hands still clasped over his. Her fingers appeared even more eerily white and elongated compared to Bilbo's work-worn hands, brown from the sun and with their calluses from his little garden tools. "Yet your heart went on without you, did it not? You know something of this yourself."
Bilbo regarded her evenly. "Hobbits are infinitely more sensible than Elves," he snapped. "And where my heart went is nobody else's business but my own!"
"Bilbo," said Arwen,with infinite gentleness. "You do not fool those with eyes to see it."
"Pssh, stuff and nonsense," he muttered. "Melodramatic fancies and histrionics - it's all that poetry you read, I'll wager!"
Arwen's eyebrows rose. "You write poetry yourself, do you forget?"
"Yes, yes, but I wouldn't go around dying simply because of a silly Dwarf," Bilbo continued. His tone remained indignant and huffy, but there were tears glittering in the faded eyes. "And neither should you. What rot! I mean, I had so many things to do, didn't I? I had my books, and Bag End, and my garden, didn't I? And then there was my young Frodo-lad, where would he have been if I hadn't stepped in, hmm? Lost in that dusty old labyrinth of a Smial, surrounded by a horde of bothersome Brandybucks, that's where! But I fixed that, I did, and a good thing too! Keeping busy, that's the key!"
"Bilbo," sighed Arwen. "Bilbo, mellon..."
"Take some advice, my dear," Bilbo said, his voice cracking. He dashed at his eyes with a rough swipe of his hand. "Keep yourself busy. Who needs them, eh? You've got two hands, don't you? You'll be well enough, you'll see. After a while you'll smile again. One day, you'll laugh. So what if life is a little bit greyer than before? Time marches on, and so must we. The Road isn't always smooth, but it never ends."
"Would that I had your spirit," Arwen said. "But alas, I am an Elf. And my father's blood aside, I live the life of an Elf, and so I must endure its sorrows."
"But you could live the life of a Man, you get to pick," Bilbo argued, and he shook her hands in his. "Think! Don't just lie there and wilt like a summer flower!"
She smiled, despite herself. "I have thought on it long and well, Master Baggins. And yes, that is the life I would choose. But that life grows more and more doubtful, and in my choice lies another doom."
"Melodrama and theatrics," Bilbo muttered, and he wiped at his eyes again and lifted his chin defiantly, as though daring her to comment on his tears. "Well, we can't have this at all, it simply won't do. I'll have to do something about it."
Arwen smiled again. "I truly believe that you could."
"Well, yes, you should. Did I tell you that I once rode an Eagle? I'm not one to be trifled with," Bilbo huffed. He yawned.
"Then our course is clear. We shall attack the problem tomorrow," she said, and pulled the blanket up around his knees.
"Hmm, tomorrow. Yes, I'm tired," Bilbo mumbled, and his head began to nod again. Then he opened one eye and squinted at the fading trees. "Fall came early, don't you think? It'll be apple season soon. I'll need to put a store in, remind me to talk to Toby Hornblower. I fancy making my great-grandmother's apple sauce again this year. Yes, so much to do, so much to do..."
His voice trailed off as his head bobbed on his chest, and within moments the old Hobbit was asleep.
"He tires so easily," Arwen whispered. "I should not have angered him."
"You didn't anger him," Thorin sighed. "Believe me, I know what he is like when he is angry."
No, the Elf-maid had upset him. There was a rather fine difference, but over the long years Thorin had learned to distinguish between the types of Hobbitish bluster and indignation.
Arwen stood and turned her fair face to the south. "Keeping busy, what an odd way to put it," she said to the seemingly-empty air, her black-silk hair curling about her shoulders, tugged by the cool autumn air. "I am not like Bilbo. I have gambled my life on a fast-fading hope, casting my lot with that of Men. My people now belong to history, and my fate belongs to the Ring of Power. Can I carry on as Hobbits do, even though my hope lies so far away?"
"Bilbo is right, you are far too melodramatic," Thorin muttered as she turned away and began to make her way through the dappled light towards the Last Homely House, her train trailing in the red leaves behind her.
"Oh, that's terribly rich, coming from you," came the well-loved voice once more, and Thorin's breath slammed back into his body with a jolt. A smile began to bloom on his lips, all unknowing, as he turned to see the young and vital Bilbo of his dreams standing behind him.
"Tell me, O great King, have you perchance heard the phrase, 'the pot calling the kettle black'?" laughed the Hobbit.
"Dwarves have a similar phrase," Thorin said, and he drank in the sight of the brownish-blond curls, the wry little face, the clever tilt to the mouth, the lively eyes. "Hello again, sanâzyunguh."
"Well? Don't leave it there," said the Hobbit, and he crossed his arms with an expectant look on his face. "Honestly, sometimes I think you are cryptic simply for the fun of it."
"Ah, truly you know me well," Thorin smiled. "Keep it close, I have a reputation to maintain."
Bilbo snorted. Behind Thorin, the sleeping ancient Hobbit made a soft snuffling noise. "Don't be preposterous, thank you very much. The phrase?"
"We say, 'the forge and the hearth both eat coal'," Thorin replied, and he glanced back at the sleeping Bilbo, frail and doddering. "You there, and you here. I am doubly blessed by your presence. Even if you are a trick of my mind, I find myself well content."
"I think the Hobbit phrase is better," Bilbo said, and he tipped his head. "A trick of your mind?"
"Aye," said Thorin drily. "Kinder than its usual tricks, however. Have you not noticed yourself, sitting in that chair?"
Bilbo peered around Thorin, and upon seeing the wizened old Hobbit with the flyaway white hair, his eyes went round as saucers. "Oh."
"Indeed. 'Oh'," Thorin agreed.
"But I..." Bilbo frowned.
In his nodding sleep, the old Hobbit in the chair frowned also.
"Wait," said Bilbo, and he took a step forward, staring at himself in fascination. The old Hobbit's lips moved around the word: wait.
Thorin's heart jumped, and then beat a little faster in his chest. A wild and impossible thought was forming in his muddled and weary head. "Speak again," he commanded, and he gazed intently at the sleeping Hobbit.
"A 'please' wouldn't have gone astray," Bilbo said haughtily, and sure enough, the ancient Hobbit's lips moved and his wasted face drew up into familiar lines of indignation.
Thorin's mouth slowly opened in amazement, and he turned his head from side to side, trying to stare at both Bilbos at once. "Ma mahdijn... No, it cannot be."
"That's me, isn't it," Bilbo said, and the old Hobbit mumbled in his slumber. "That's me."
"This cannot be possible!" Thorin exclaimed. "Speak, Bilbo!"
"Please," Bilbo said, and his ears were mottling in anger. "It's not such a difficult word to say! Honestly now! You're usually much more pleasant than this in my dreams. You're nearly back to your old self, and that's saying something."
Thorin whipped around to see if this speech had any effect on the sleeper – and sure enough, the aged Bilbo mumbled crossly under his breath, and then subsided back into his sleep.
"I don't understand," Bilbo said plaintively from behind him. "It's just a dream, like all the other dreams. They fade away in the morning light."
"Your dreams," said Thorin slowly. "Bilbo, I am not a dream."
"Then what are you?" Bilbo shot back. "You can't be real, you're dead as a doornail and buried under the Mountain. I know that much, I was there! I'm not so senile as all that!"
"This is not possible," Thorin said in awe. "Mahal be merciful, but let it be so!"
"If you're not a dream, how can you be here? You're dead!" said Bilbo, and he shook his head in confusion. "And I'm.. wait, I can never remember it..."
"Aye, I am long dead," said Thorin. "And it appears that you do not dream idly."
"I can never remember," Bilbo repeated in frustration, and then he paled. "Do you mean..."
"It is you," Thorin breathed, and he wanted to sing, he wanted to laugh, he wanted to weep. "In all these endless cold years of watching and wishing, I had never hoped for so much."
"Are you telling me that you've been... with me, all this time?" Bilbo said stiffly, swallowing hard.
"I have never left," Thorin said, and such great good fortune could not possibly be his - the Valar would never look so kindly upon a miserable Dwarf - it could not be so! "And you are truly my Hobbit, and not some figment of my sorrow?"
"Your Hobbit?" Bilbo whirled onto him, and his face was pinched in fury. "Your Hobbit?"
Thorin blinked in astonishment. "I... I..."
"Thorin Oakenshield, the arrogance of you!" Bilbo fumed.
"Bilbo," Thorin said, jerking back in surprise and dismay - and then Bilbo vanished. "Bilbo! Bilbo! I am sorry, Bilbo, so sorry – please, come back, please – please, idùzhibuh, please!"
But the younger Hobbit did not reappear. Thorin let out a strangled shout of frustration and loss, and fell to his hands and knees. "Bilbo!"
The old Hobbit in the chair was weeping in his sleep.
"But I made you a pen," Thorin said to the empty air, kneeling helplessly amid the windblown autumn leaves.

art by fishfingersandscarves.

But I made you a pen, by mamma-scandinavia

But I made you a pen, by fishfingersandscarves

