Chapter Text
"They cannot come," said Galadriel eventually, straightening and tipping back her head. Her eyes still saw with that strange and powerful other sight. Celeborn glanced down at her Mirror, and as always, he saw his wife's face reflected back at him.
"Then what do we do?" he said aloud, and his whole soul reached for her. She touched his mind gently in reassurance, and then began to walk away from the little grove.
"I have done it before. Now I must do so again," she said softly. "It appears that the fire of the Noldor is still needed."
"Meleth," Celeborn called after her, startled.
She turned back to face him, her bare feet crushing the dew-wet grass. "Thranduil is pinned by the darkness of Dol Guldur, just as we. The Dwarves are besieged in their fortress. The Men have repelled their invaders, but now the wrath and vengeance of the Enemy will fall upon them, and swiftly."
Celeborn measured this news for a moment, felt the weight of it upon his shoulders. "But what of Lórien of the blossom?" he said eventually.
"The Blossom already fades, my love," she said into his mind, and she moved back towards him to cup his cheek with one hand. "You know that as well as I."
He could say nothing to that.

Galadriel and Celeborn, by fishfingersandscarves
"There is no saving Lothlórien," she said, sad and tender and final.
He nodded, and then he looked up into her starlit eyes. "Then let us prove that this flower yet has thorns."
"I have done so once before, and must do so again, it seems." Galadriel's eyelids lowered. "Thranduil will be wroth that I have waited so long to spend my strength."
"Thranduil does not understand the price you pay to wield it," Celeborn said fiercely. All unsaid, he knew where her mind now turned. "You mean to go to Dol Guldur."
"I do."
Celeborn linked their hands and breathed her in. Between the breaths, between the heartbeats, he could feel her wordless weariness, her great strain. Her power was the only thing that protected these golden woods. She bore it uncomplaining.
As always, she answered his thought. "I would use what power and grace is left to me in one final decisive action, before the effort of defending our borders takes me beyond all hope of deeds of might. The Elven rings are waning. I soon shall fall before the probing, relentless tendrils of Mordor. I would cast the first blow, and I would make it a costly one."
Celeborn lifted her hand and kissed it. He did not need to speak.
"If I spend my remaining strength at Dol Guldur, and fail," she said, and he knew why she had not spoken it aloud, "then Lothlórien and the Greenwood alike are doomed."
"You will not fail." It was less a reassurance, and more a prayer. "You will not."
She smiled at him, serene and beautiful and golden, a spear of light made flesh. "My tests are passed," she said, and kissed him. "I have seen temptation, and I have refused it. What is this test, compared to that? What is death compared to the corruption of the One Ring? No, do not fear for me, my silver one. Fear for Middle-Earth instead. They need it more than I."
"I need you also, and always shall and always have," Celeborn said, and leaned his head against the side of hers for a moment. She was warm and living in his arms.
"You cannot lose me," she breathed into his ear. "We cannot be parted forever, and you will find me waiting at the end of every sea. Yet I must do this."
"Yes." Celeborn squeezed his eyes shut, and felt the long centuries stretching out behind him; all those years, all those wars, all beating a path to this place and this time. "And you shall not do it alone."
It was very cold in the place of the tombs. Bombur looked about, and shivered a little. His head was still spinning from the stars of Gimlîn-zâram.
"Why here?" he wondered aloud.
"Perhaps this wasn't such a good idea," said Bifur worriedly, and he patted at Bombur's back absently as he spoke. "Perhaps it's too soon. We should…"
"I'm fine, Barufûn," Bombur said in his soft voice, and he squared his shoulders and lifted his round, pleasant face. "I'm all right."
"He'd want his braid done proper – properly, I mean," said the Dwarrowdam before them stubbornly, catching her slip of the tongue and correcting it almost absent-mindedly. "I can do it. Besides, it's not like I can do for my." She stopped, and then looked down at her fingers.
"You needn't explain it to me, child," said the Queen – no, the Queen Dowager - tiredly.
"She looks a century older," Bifur whispered, but Bombur had no eyes for anything but his eldest daughter.
"Our special little starling, our surprise baby she was," he said, staring fixedly at her. Her brown hair was caught in a plain working-braid, her beard unadorned and her dress old and threadbare. Her sleeves were rolled up to the elbow. The uniform of a nasty, mucky job.
The Dwarrowdam sighed and scrubbed at her eyes for a moment, and then returned to the business of twisting thick, white hair into two long braids. His arms ached with the need to hold his little girl again. She sniffled, and rubbed at her nose. It was red.
Bombur gripped at Bifur's arm, and his eyes stung and prickled. "Ah, Barís. Don't cry, poppet."
Baris wiped her forearm across her eyes again, and then broke off with a muttered curse to fumble for a handkerchief. The resulting blurt was embarrassingly loud in the cold and silent crypt.
"Sorry," she mumbled, and pocketed her handkerchief as her cheeks flushed a dull pink.
The Queen was seated beside her, her hand tightly clasping a cold and lifeless one. Bombur glanced down at the bench before them once more – and then hurriedly turned his eyes away from the wreck that was the remains of the King. "No apology needed," she said.
"I just." Barís waved a hand at the corpse. Bifur's warm arm under his fingers was the only thing keeping Bombur from rushing over to try and gather her up in a hug.
"No, no apology." Thira repeated, and she finally looked up at where Barís stood. "I did not lay out my parents. They were Burned Dwarves: I never prepared them to return to the stone. I've never done this before either." She swallowed hard. "I did not expect to do so for him. Not him."
Barís' eyes dropped. "He always seemed so. Well. Invincible."
Thira smiled. There was no true warmth in it. "Aye, well. He was good at seeming."
"At least you can return him to the stone," Barís said eventually. "At least you have that."
Thira laid a gentle hand on Barís' forearm. "We will retrieve them. Him. Barís, my son will see to it. I swear to you! You will have your father's body, to mourn and to bury."
Barís' lips tightened. "I wish–" she blurted, and checked herself. Then she scrubbed at her face again. "What bloody use is wishing, though? My Papa is dead, and wishing won't bring him back."
"Bombur - khulel, abbad. I'm here," said Bifur, low. "I'm here."
Bombur nearly bit through the inside of his cheek.
"If wishes were pigs, we'd all be riding," Thira said, and laughed joylessly. "He used to say that."
"He called me poppet," Barís said. Her beautiful voice was rough and wretched. "And I had that Mahal-cursed idea. And it killed him. My papa."
"Oh no, no you don't get to do that, darling girl," Bombur said with sudden heat. "Not your fault. Not your fault it didn't work, and not your fault I chose to go out there with my bum leg an' all!"
Thira's glance was hard and sharp. "You tried to save us all. No knife in your hands, Master-singer."
Barís bent her head. "I wish," she said again.
"My husband did the same as you: tried to save us all. So did your father." Thira shrugged one shoulder: a careless-looking movement, though her expression was anything but. "So did many others, many who tried and died. Will you claim their deaths as well?"
Barís' mouth contorted as she struggled with her sobs. "My uncle…"
"Aye." Thira looked back down at the pallid, drained, withered shape of her husband. Without the enormous force of his personality, it was easy to see how old he was – how tired and shrivelled. "He chose too. Chose to try to save the Bizarûnh. Do not make his choice into your failing. Will you strip them of their decisions in your haste to condemn yourself?"
Barís made a terrible broken sound, deep in her throat.
Thira kept gazing with endless longing at what had been Dáin Ironfoot, King Under the Mountain. His white beard was clean and now braided neatly, covering the terrible wounds upon his chest and arms. His skin was free of blood and mud, pale and parchment-dry to look upon, the eyelids closed, hollows beginning to sink upon his cheeks and either side of the sharp Durinesque nose.
"Sometimes things don't work," she said slowly, in a distant, almost dreamy voice. "Sometimes the best ideas, the best intentions, go wrong. And that may not be the fault of anyone – or it could be the fault of everyone. In another world, it might have worked. Who is to say? Without the tunnel, would the Dalefolk ever have made it to the sanctuary of the Mountain? Would Dale be a smoking graveyard now, if not for Bofur and Bombur and my silly old boar? Would bright little Gimizh be dead, or perhaps the Crown Prince of Dale dead, all those trapped underground slaughtered, if not for my Thorin and your father? If not for the diversion of Dáin? If Brand had not decided to ride out to meet him?
"And either way - what does that matter? Things are as they are. They are gone back to the stone, and we are here. And life goes on. We remember. You sang that song, did you not? You carry that with you always now. That moment… it's a part of you. This moment is a part of me." She tipped back her head and her eyes fixed upon the roof with its ornate and solemn carvings. "We're all just moments and choices, in the end."
"And now I know why canny, shrewd old Dáin Ironfoot chose an unknown and crowd-shy steelsmith to wed," whispered Bombur. Bifur grunted in agreement, his face serious and set.
Barís closed her eyes, and eventually she nodded. Her mouth was still pressed in an ugly line, twitching every now and then as she barely controlled her emotions. "I know, your Majesty," she said in barely a murmur. "But I still wish I'd never thought of it."
"I can sympathise. I often wish – wished – that my idiot husband didn't have a thing about saving the day at the last minute," Thira said, and smiled a little. Unlike before, it was a true smile. "Come now, Barís. We are to become family, you needn't be so deferential. My son and your sister, eh?"
"Little idiot," Barís sniffled, and tied off a long white braid, laying it respectfully down upon the King's still and lifeless chest. "I can't believe her."
"I think it's wonderful." Thira's hand fumbled for the cold, stiffened one again, and upon finding it she squeezed a little. "So wonderful. He would have been thrilled."
"Papa too." Barís rubbed her eyes one last time, and then sighed out, long and tired. "He spoiled all my nieces and nephews outrageously, and they would climb all over his chair and pull at his nose and beard and ask for sweets and stories."
"She hasn't called me Papa for thirty years," Bombur said in a faint little voice. "I was Dad or Adad, she called me… after the Quest, after the money…"
"She didn't need to, did she?" Bifur pointed out. "You've always been Papa."
"But it all changed, we all changed so much." Bombur pulled a little at his looped braid. "We… she got taught to speak more proper, and stopped calling me Papa."
"Looks like she never stopped where it counted." Bifur turned back to his cousin, and gently rubbed Bombur's back. "There there, lad. You get used to it."

Baris, by fishfingersandscarves
"The Council has been clamouring for a wedding," Thira snorted, and then shook her head and smiled down at Dáin's still face. "How you would have laughed at them, dear. Insisting on proper Ereborean protocol in the middle of war."
"Bomfrís is still panicking a little about that. Well, I say 'a little'…" Barís laughed wetly, and then sighed again. Her shoulders relaxed from their stiff, guarded posture. "What else can I help with? He's clean, and his hair is as it should be…"
Thira's dark eyes glittered. "Always so helpful, hmm?"
Barís blinked.
"Don't think I haven't missed you hovering around my forge, Master-singer. For all your grand performer's tricks, you're rather unobtrusive, aren't you? Always helpful, always willing." Thira cocked her head. "Now, what is so fascinating about my workrooms in particular, I wonder? Not a wiry old steelsmith, Durin forbid."
A flush rose on Barís' sweet, round face, and she coughed awkwardly. "I… want to be useful."
"To one of my craftsmasters in particular, hmm." Thira huffed a little laugh. "I haven't missed that either, young Alrísul. For a trained artist, you aren't exactly a consummate actor."
"Must we speak of it now? Here?" Barís said plaintively. Then she scrubbed at her eyes again. "Oh, what use is anything anyway."
"Now is the best time to speak of it," said Thira. "This is an ending. Go make a beginning, child."
"Easy for you to say." Barís glowered down at Dáin's peaceful old face.
"No. No it isn't easy for me to say." Thira said, and her voice was suddenly sharp and cold, like steel striking steel. "This is not my beginning; for me, this is an ending. My love lies here before us, without breath or life. It is not easy for me to say."
"Forgive me," Barís said quickly. "I mean, I just. I don't know where to begin. Sometimes I think Bani doesn't even know my name…"
Thira's eyes softened. Then her hand reached out once more, and she squeezed Barís' shoulder in reassurance. Her hard, thin fingers were wiry and tough. "Remember, choices and moments, Barís," she said kindly. "Bani is a single-minded sort of lass, and gets lost in her work. She gets irritated easily by any sort of interruption, and she often forgets to eat in her zeal."
Baris digested that for a moment, and then she gave the Queen Dowager a helpless sort of look. "What am I supposed to do with that?"
Thira squeezed Barís' shoulder again. "It'll come to you, child. The moment will arrive, and with it, your choice."
"Is that the one Barís has been sweet upon, then?" Bombur wondered. "Alrís wouldn't tell me."
Bifur nodded. "Bani daughter of Bana, a woodworker. Very clever, very clumsy, very impatient. And very unobservant," he added sourly.
Barís' face scrunched up with indecision. "But… what if it all goes wrong again?" she mumbled.
"Then that is the way of things, isn't it?" Thira smoothed back Dáin's shock of white hair, standing high over his forehead. Her rough fingers lingered there. "But remember this, Crystaltongue. Sometimes, if you're very brave, very honest, very lucky… sometimes, for a time, it goes right."
Then the Queen Dowager looked up and smiled at the master-singer. There was grief in that smile, naturally – but Bombur could see the shade of a young smith with steady, fire-touched eyes and smooth skin in it: the ghost of the Dwarrowdam that had captured the heart of Dáin Ironfoot. "And if you're very, very lucky?" she said softly, "it keeps on going right, and keeps on going right. And it's just - just always there, always right, all your life long. Until one day, perhaps one hundred and thirty years later, your luck finally runs out. And it ends."
Haban tried very hard not to nod in exhaustion. The Houses of Healing were too restful, and she was just so tired. She couldn't remember being this tired in either life or death – not even when her boys had been little. Her eyes actually ached. It was a new feeling.
"Are you all right?" Narvi whispered beside her. Haban jerked her head back up, blinking rapidly.
"I'm awake, I'm awake," she mumbled.
Narvi gave her a narrow look, her brows drawn together. Something – perhaps that bottomless well of anger and sorrow – was driving her, Haban thought. Narvi didn't look nearly as exhausted as she should. "You should be asleep," was all she said.
Haban yawned, and then waved a hand. "Aye, in a bit. Want to make sure he's all right."
Narvi rolled her eyes. "I doubt anything's likely to happen to him here. Unless that droning old Herbmaster bores him to death with his talk."
Haban grunted, and turned back to where Faramir lay under his coverlets, his head slightly bent. "It's not that sort of injury," she said. Narvi's glance was startled, and then she nodded with a thoughtful look in her eye.
"Aye. Not that sort of injury indeed." As always, her friend's nimble mind saw precisely where Haban's thoughts led.
"Well, I don't know what's happening," said their unexpected companion. Fris was frowning at the young Man, her foot tapping in exasperation. She had arrived to take over Haban's watch, but the Firebeard Dwarrowdam was stubbornly staying put until she was sure that Faramir would be all right.
He had impressed her, that day in the wilds of Ilthilien. And Haban did not impress easily. She gave him an approving, motherly sort of look, before stifling another yawn under her hand.
"Haban, explain it," Narvi said in that short way she had. It had taken a few misunderstandings before Haban had realised that Narvi's curtness was not actually rudeness: it was more that she was always three steps ahead of everyone, and impatient for them to catch up.
Fris' eyebrow crooked at Narvi's tone, but Haban only shrugged at the Princess with a smile. "It's just her way," she said, and rubbed at one eye. "All right, here it is: Faramir is mending well, but he still doesn't know about his father… about how he died."
Fris, bless her, caught on at once. Mahal be thanked for clever companions. "Oh," she said, and frowned at the Man. "And you wait to see how he will take the news?"
"Aye." Haban looked down at where the two little Hobbits sat, both with their pipes in hand, chatting companionably at the Man's bedside. "And with these two, it will not take long before the news is spilled."
"They are wiser than they were," Narvi added abruptly. "They'll do as good a job of work as any, with news such as this."
"If any can soften it, I suppose they can," Haban sighed. Her eyes really ached. So did her neck. Why were other folk so damnably tall! It gave one a crick in the spine that no amount of stretching seemed to help.
Fris pursed her lips for a moment. Then she nodded to where a still figure lay some distance away, unmoving beneath thick blankets. "She's listening in," she said.
"Aye, has been for a while now." Narvi crossed her arms. "She's very good at being unnoticed, but not good enough."
"I imagine she had ample opportunity to practice her skills in the Edoras of Grima Wormtongue," Fris said darkly. Then she turned back to Haban. "Why do you care so much?"
"Haban likes Faramir," Narvi said, and grinned at Haban's look of outrage and betrayal. "Thinks he's a good sort. She's been hovering over him like a stonecutter with a priceless gem ever since she found out who he was."
"He could have turned Frodo and Sam in, and he let them go," Haban said, jerking her chin up in the air. "The lad's had precious little care in his life. His brother was the only one who seemed to give a damn about him, and now he hasn't a soul left in the world. Besides, I don't often meet one who is canny enough to out-manoeuvre me at bargaining."
"See?" Narvi laughed, before she gasped and gripped Haban's arm. "Wait, what did the little one just say?"
"Something about singed foot hair?" Fris wondered, and all three leaned closer to hear.
"It's tremendously shameful, of course," Pippin said, grinning. "I shan't be able to show my face back in Hobbiton. I'll have to keep to the bounders and to Tuckborough until my feet are respectable again."
"I think we're likely to have bigger objections thrown at us than our lack of properly-combed toe-hair, Pip," Merry chuckled. "You didn't say how you lost it, though. Don't tell me you were in the battle too!"
"Oh no, no fear of that!" Pippin drew back and pointed the stem of his pipe at his cousin. "I leave that to all you foolhardy Riders and your horses and your dreadfully silly heroic stands. No thank-you! No, it was," and then he stopped, his face blanching in remembrance. His eyes flicked to Faramir before sliding away.
"Aaaand there it is," Narvi sighed.
"Oh dear." Frís pinched her nose and drew in a slow breath.
Faramir seemed to sense that Pippin's tale directly involved him in some way, and he looked between the two Hobbits with growing suspicion. "What is this?"
"Pippin!" Merry hissed, and Pippin groaned.
"I'm sorry, I am so terribly sorry, I didn't mean…"
Faramir sat up straighter in his bed. "Master Pippin, will you not tell me your meaning? It concerns me, does it not? You are referring to me in some way, it is obvious."
"He is usually very obvious," Merry agreed, glaring a little at his cousin.
Pippin winced. "Stuck my foot in it again, didn't I?"
Faramir fixed him with a level gaze for a long moment, and then his lips parted slightly in realisation and he turned away. "Ah."
"Faramir?" Pippin said tentatively. "Are. Are you all right?"
"It was not a fever-dream then," Faramir murmured, and he lay back down and drew the covers up to his shoulders. "It was true."
Merry and Pippin exchanged a worried glance. "What was?" Merry said.
"Flames," Faramir said, his voice dull. "Flames, and the face of my father all twisted in sorrow and despair. It truly happened then?"
Pippin clutched at his knee with one hand, his fingers tightening. Then he steeled himself and said clearly and with sympathy, "yes it did indeed. I was there, I rolled you away from the fire. But, your father… he…"
Faramir's eyes squeezed shut with a terrible finality. "I see. Then I have you to thank for my life."
"And Gandalf," Pippin said, and his little face was the very picture of unhappiness. "Faramir, I-"
Merry leaned over and took Faramir's hand in his, giving it a quick squeeze. "You're going to be all right," he said, clear and firm. "You are. You will make them proud."
"No," Pippin said, and his face was sincere and earnest. "You do make them proud."
Faramir's face crumpled.
Haban sucked in a quick breath, and let it out just as sharply. "Damn it all, I shouldn't care so," she growled. "Denethor's death was no loss to this world. Must be just my tiredness, making me maudlin."
"He was the boy's father, no matter how poor a job he did," Frís said gently.
"And he was poisoned by the despair of Sauron besides," Narvi spat. "If not for the Palantir and the lies of Mordor, could Denethor have been the Steward he was meant to be in the hour of need? Gandalf did say that he was once a wise and great and discerning Man…"
"Another life lost to the shadow then," Frís said finally, and the three Dwarrowdams turned back to where Faramir lay, quiet and unmoving, beneath his coverlet.
"He's all alone in the world," Haban said again into the silence. "His mother, his brother, his father – his whole family, now."
"The people love him well," Frís said. "He is cared for."
"Aye, there's that." Haban sighed out, and then a movement in the corner of her eye caught her attention. Éowyn's eyes were now open, and she was frowning up at the ceiling.
"She's still listening," murmured Narvi.
"I'm so sorry, Faramir," Pippin said miserably. "I really did try."
Faramir said nothing, but he nodded once.
Then two little Hobbits were clambering up onto the bed and holding Faramir tightly, just as they would have done for Boromir. "I'm so sorry," Pippin repeated, and Faramir made a strangled, crushed little sound deep in his throat.
"Go on and have a good cry. You'll feel better after," Pippin said, patting at Faramir's hair with awkward, gentle hands. After another half-gritted sob, Faramir did just that.

Faramir, Pippin and Merry, by kazimakuwabara
Víli rubbed at his forehead, standing before their usual table in the great eating-chamber in the Halls of Mahal. "You know that politics have never been my strong suit," he said uncomfortably. "I know the general gist, but there's undercurrents and interests and subtleties here that I'm just not grasping. I'm thinking that I might need a bit o' help on this one."
Thrór stood from the dining table at once, his brow furrowed and his eyes determined. Hrera stifled a little sigh beside him, and stood as well. "Might as well," she said in a brisk voice, and then tapped her husband on his shoulder. "And you: try not to let them rile you."
"Easier said than done," Thrór said, and shook his great bushy mane with a snort. "Right then, son, lead us there."
"I'll come too," said an unexpected voice, and Dwerís stood up from a nearby bench. The mother of Dwalin and Balin was a tall, grizzled Dwarrow with enormous shoulders and a fine brown beard with a dyed green streak down the centre and two matching ones over her temples. Her skin was littered with the marks of battle and swordplay. "I haven't checked on my youngest in some time."
"Lady Dwerís," said Víli, taken-aback. "Not like you to get involved…"
She regarded him steadily. "My husband has been bickering with his brother all this time, aye, but do not think that I have been idle. And it is not Lady, thank you kindly."
"My apologies, Warrior Dwerís," Víli said quickly, and mentally gave himself a kick. Rude!
"No offense taken, but do keep it in mind." She looked back at Thrór and Hrera, before focusing on Víli again. "What is the main thrust of the discussion?"
"Food," Víli sighed, and he rubbed his head again. Oh, politics made his head ache. "There's simply not enough for all the refugees now sheltered in the Mountain. They're all arguing over it, and there's a small contingent amongst the Dalefolk that is tremendously vocal. Bard can't seem to get any traction over them."
"Well, he's only days into his Kingship," said Hrera matter-of-factly. "He's bound to have a few teething troubles."
"We're wasting time," Thrór said, and he shifted from foot to foot.
"Calm now, dear," Hrera said, without looking back at him, though her hand settled lightly upon his wrist in a gesture of comfort. "Let us go see what all the fuss is about."
The benches around the pool of Gimlîn-zâram were crowded. It seemed that everyone was working around the clock, watching as often as they could, as events in Middle-Earth began to race and tumble towards their conclusion. There was hardly a seat left around the waters, and all four Dwarves had to crowd upon the one bench.
"Get your elbow out of my side."
"Where do you suggest I put it instead? Into your face?"
"Tetchy."
"Children," Hrera said wearily. "Don't make me send you all to your rooms."
Víli stared at the water, and willed it to hurry, hurry. Dis was still waiting, after all.
The first thing they heard, upon arriving in Arda with the starlight still sloughing from their eyes, was the sound of Dwalin's voice, grumbling. Dwerís gave a half-smile and stepped towards him.
"So like his father," they overheard her murmur – though Víli wondered at that. After all, Dwalin looked nearly the spit and image of his tall fierce mother, whereas Balin took more after his scholarly, solid father.
"…can't believe these two," Dwalin was growling. "You sure I can't put my axe through their heads? It'd save us two bloody annoying mouths to feed, after all."
Orla shook her head slightly. "No bloodshed in the throne-room."
"Pity." Dwalin glowered straight ahead, his brows drawing together in a thunderous frown.
"There, there." Orla sounded amused.
"I was third-in-line once," Dwalin muttered. "Mahal knows Balin wouldn't have had any bairns. I dodged an arrow there."
"You're second in line now, aren't you?" Jeri asked innocently. "I mean, until the little one gets here, you're now the heir."
"No fear! Listen to this self-pitying self-important drivel day in and day out?" Dwalin's scowl, if anything, grew even darker. "I'm not Dáin, I've no patience for this whining idiocy. I'd cut the dramatics out of them right quick."
Jeri grinned. "It would have been an interesting Erebor, to say the least."
Orla rolled her eyes.
"No matter how you slice it," Dori said crossly, his arms folded and his voice raised, "we simply do not have the food! All the complaining in the world will not change that fact!"
"And whose fault is that?" said a tall, beaky woman of Dale in shrill tones. "Hmm? Who sent all our soldiers away to some revolting tunnel, and left us unprotected? Who opened the Gates of Dale and sent us all running from our homes?"
"This is all Brand's fault!" said another Daleman, a greasy-faced fellow with a self-important sniff. "His! And yes, Bard – you supported him, you threatened us into silence when we objected… and look at us now!"
"I cannot survive this way," the woman moaned, "I have a delicate constitution! I shall faint!"
"Go ahead," Dwalin grunted.
"Oh, Lady Inorna my dear," cooed the oily Man, "calm yourself! Be strong!"
"Fainting won't get you more food either," Dori snapped. "There's not enough to feed even the Dwarves: do you really think we intend to starve everyone on purpose? We are sharing as fairly as possible; nobody is being singled out for preferential treatment, not even our own."
Bard's teeth were gritted as he said, "if we had stayed, our defences would have been toppled and our soldiers would have been slaughtered like pigs-"
The Stonehelm cleared his throat pointedly.
"All right, perhaps not like pigs," Bard corrected himself. "But we would have been overrun. You saw the size of that Easterling Army, just as I did. We would have been annihilated!"
"All you care for is your precious reputation!" Inorna accused tearfully. "Not us, not those who deserve so much better than this… this filthy hole in the ground, this grubby tomb! I am a noblewoman!"
Every single Dwarf, both living and dead, bristled with outrage.
"Beginning to think that Dwalin should do as he sees fit," Thrór muttered.
Hrera pinched the bridge of her nose. "Longbeards."
"We tried, yes. And we failed. But if we had remained where we were and done nothing, death and destruction and worse would have been visited upon us," said Bard, in a tightly-controlled voice. "What is done is now done. We must deal with what is."
The Lady Selga of Dale then stood from her place at the council table, her face still drawn with grief. "At least we tried," she rasped. "At least we did something."
"And failed!" the oily man sneered. "Our homes, our gold, our businesses! Lost, because of your failure!"
"Lord Krummett, I feel that the orcs may have had more to do with the loss of your precious gold than any of us here," said the Stonehelm in a mild tone.
"Ohhhh, I shall swoon, help me Krummett!" Inorna gasped, and she held her hand to her head in so overblown a pose that several Dwarves actually stifled giggles. "My heart is beating so: I need wine, I need cheese and fruit and pastries – you must help me, you must save me! Does nobody care?"
"Oh, my dear lady!" Krummett swept towards her and held her in a greasy mockery of gallantry. "There, my sweet, breathe now!" Then he turned his piggy eyes on the Council. "How dare you upset such a sweet, generous and delicate soul!"
"Generous!" Selga laughed aloud. "Oh yes, that's certainly what you're famous for, Inorna. Generosity and kindness. Oh, absolutely so."
"My King, my King," Inorna whimpered, looking up at Bard with great glistening eyes. "You must tell them – no, you must make them help me! Dearest Bard, please! I have ever believed in you!"
"She was insulting him two seconds ago," said Glóin in open-mouthed astonishment. "And what, she fancies herself a good fit as Bard's Queen all of a sudden?"
"She's done nothing but insult everyone since the minute she set foot in the Mountain, and no doubt thinks herself more special and deserving than any Queen that ever lived," Mizim said under her breath. "I want my arrows."
Glóin gave her an amused look. "Now, that's usually my line, my Jewel."
"I have sacrificed so much," Inorna whimpered, clutching at Krummett's stained doublet. "I've been so caring. I deserve so much better than this, surrounded by these vile little beasts and their greedy grasping ways…"
"How dare you," Dís said, and her mithril voice fell like a stone slab into the conversation, killing it instantly. Víli's whole heart clenched. "How dare you. You know nothing – nothing – of what we have lost. You know nothing of what we sacrificed to buy your lives."
"Dís," he said, scarcely a breath.
Thrór's hand settled on his shoulder. "I know," he said, low. "I know."
Víli took a deep breath.
"If you think," Bard said, in a voice that was barely controlled, "that you are the only Dalefolk here who have lost, and suffered-"
"Not just Dalefolk," Jeri said from their place at the throne's side, quiet and steely. "There is not a single Dwarf under this Mountain who can call themselves untouched by this siege and by our efforts to break it. Not one."
"You're alive, you twits," Bofur spoke up. "You hear that? You're ALIVE. Now, go be alive elsewhere, because you make my head hurt."
"For how long?" said Inorna, pressing her hand to her bosom, her eyes welling with tears. "This isn't living, hiding in these filthy holes!"
"I'm gonna do it," Dwalin grated.
"I might not stop you," Orla murmured. Her eyes were hard with dislike.
"And you are all in cahoots against me, it is now plain!" Inorna cried. "Why should I be singled out in this manner? I am delicate, I am special, I cannot be expected to do as the common and smallfolk do!"
"It is the brutality of the Dwarves showing through, my dear," Krummett said in what he probably thought was a stern tone. It came out as a sulky whine instead. "And you are so wise, sweet Inorna, so very wise… yes, they are all in league against us, there is no other explanation for their beastly behaviour. Brand and Bard and Dáin must have been plotting in secret, no doubt. But I am here, kind lady, lovely lady! I shall protect you from their-"
In unison, Dwalin and Orla stepped forward from where they stood at guard. Then, in eerie silence, Dwalin drew his huge battle-axe and Orla brought forward the long-handled axe that had given her its name. In perfect unity they brought out two stones and began to whet the edges.
Whisk. Whisk. Whisk.
Inorna and Krummett ceased their histrionics immediately.
"There's my lad," said Dwerís proudly.
Selga turned away from them, her lip slightly curled in disgust. "Nevertheless, the First Advisor is right. Good people paid the price to remedy our failure," she said, and her eyes fell to the ground.
Both Bard and the Stonehelm's shoulders slumped. "Aye," said the Stonehelm quietly. "They did."
"Too many," Bofur added, and his face was stony. "Too many of 'em."
Dori stamped his foot in irritation. "Excuse me! Hello? Back to the point? THERE IS NOT ENOUGH TO EAT. The Mountain is going to starve in under three weeks if we do not find another source of food!"
Glóin cleared his throat. "Aye, Dori brings us back to the meat of the matter – so to speak. What can we do? Ideas?"
Merilin suddenly made a move from the up-until-now silent Elven presence. "We still have some store of waybread. Lembas. It is filling, and nutritious, and the recipe is easily replicated. We shall share it with your cooks."
"Good, good." Glóin stroked his beard and nodded. "Now, there may be a few things squirrelled away in people's larders…"
Bard spoke then. "What about Cram? Is there flour enough?"
Bofur shuddered. "I did not risk my bloody life to eat bloody cram. I'll take my chances with the Elvish stuff before I volunteer for that boring chewing-exercise of a meal."
The Stonehelm threaded a hand into his hair and leaned on his elbow, his face creased up with thought. "It is midwinter, and there are few fish in the River Running," he said, "but there may be some. In the deep pools there are strange fish with feelers and huge eyes: we must send scouts."
"'m so sick of fish," came a petulant little grumble from near Laerophen's chair.
"You'll eat what you get, my lad," Bofur said at once.
Genild tipped her white, grizzled old head. "My wife's a dab hand at making preserves and pickles. We've got a whole cupboard full of 'em. No doubt Barur Stonebelly can make a little go a long way."
"Ma," Jeri said, wincing.
"Hush, darling, Ma's working," Genild said, and she leaned forward and stabbed at the table with a finger. "Here's a thing to consider: I know Dwarves can go a lot further on less food than Men can, though I'm not sure about Elves. P'raps Beri's preserves and pickles will help stave off some of those deficiency diseases, for a time anyway…"

Beri and Genild, by Lacefedora
"Good idea, we'll ask around the marketholders as well, no doubt some of them will have stores in place," Glóin said, and he made a little note.
"Mister Bofur, I do hate to ask you," Dori began, touching Bofur politely on the arm. Bofur sighed and let his head droop a little.
"Aye, we'll talk to Alrís, see if we can't go through Bombur's inventory. He was a great one for keeping speciality stuff. He might even have jam amongst his wares."
"I'll pay for it, then," said Inorna immediately. "I will pay for it, though heaven knows you should simply give it to me… but if I must play by your sordid rules, then I will give you gold for better rations, I am wealthy, I will…"
"Food will be shared out equally," said the Stonehelm in a voice that brooked absolutely no argument. Thrór gave him an approving nod.
"Not bought by those with means and influence," said Dori.
"And no amount of threatening or wheedling or even swooning will change that," Bard finished.
Inorna quivered, drawing herself up straight. "That… that is….!" She spluttered in outrage and thwarted self-importance.
"He's doing well," Thrór murmured to Hrera, who took his hand. "He's doing the throne proud so far."
"Bard is faring less well," she said quietly. "This pair of selfish fools do not see him as their King yet. They fear the Dwarves, however, even as they despise us. The Stonehelm must lead this sortie. He must use that fear to quell them, or they will gain a platform from which to shout down any attempts at reason."
Víli rubbed his temples. "I hate this," he grumbled. "I don't know how you put up with it."
"Practice. And ale – lots and lots of ale," Thrór said wryly, and then Hrera hushed them both.
"You see what we were up against?" Bard said, leaning in to whisper in the Stonehelm's ear. The new Kings shared a look of fellow-understanding, and then the Stonehelm patted Bard's shoulder.
"You have my deepest sympathies," he said.
"Anyway, what do you intend to use to pay for it? Buttons? Hot air?" Glóin added, a trifle rudely. Mizim chuckled.
"There's my old bear, knew you wouldn't hold your temper forever," she smiled.
Dori tapped his foot. "A-hem!"
"Right. Back to it." Dwalin scratched at his bald pate. "I think we've got some liquor and wine put away. It'll be a wrench to part with it – they're from the years our boys were born – but they're better off in Barur's hands. He'll make 'em stretch."
Bofur heaved a great sigh. "An' I suppose I've got some beer in the cool-room."
"That'll go a long way, stews and soups and the like," said Dori, nodding. Glóin made another little note.
"We need centralised distribution," said the Stonehelm, speaking over the new murmurs as this new and expanded Council began to put together a plan. "No doubt many will hide the food they have, and that is understandable. Yet others will suffer for it. We must make it plain that we stand together or not at all."
"We can make a big to-do about contributing," suggested Mizim. "Do it in public, perhaps?"
"Aye, good idea," the Stonehelm nodded. "What we haven't got is meat…"
"There's birds above the Mountain…" Laerophen said, and Glóin pulled a face.
"Aye, but if you hit a raven or a thrush, you're probably going to wish the Orcs got you."
Laerophen regarded him unblinking. "I am an Elf. If I cannot tell the difference between a duck, a pheasant, a Raven or a thrush from four hundred paces, you may file down my ears and call me a Man."
There was a giggle from under the chair. "Good one."
Glóin's mouth twitched, as though fighting a grin. "You little traitor, grandson," he said.
"If it is centralised distribution you need, then I have some experience…" Krummett began in a ingratiating sort of voice.
"Thank you for the offer, Lord Krummett, but your services will not be needed," said the Stonehelm in a tone that brooked no opposition.
"Ah, you see, you see!" Inorna shook her finger at them all. "This is BLATANT favouritism, and prejudice towards Men!"
Bard stood all at once, the scrape of his chair very loud. "Get out," he said, clearly and firmly. "Stop this posturing, stop forcing yourself where you are not wanted, and get. Out."
They balked at the look upon his face, and when Dwalin raised his axe with casual and deadly meaning, both the silly selfish popinjays turned on their heels and ran.
"Thank Mahal," the Stonehelm said fervently. "You're more patient than I, Bard."
"I would not have had the leverage to do that, were you not by my side," he answered, bowing his head. "So that victory belongs to you."
The Stonehelm grinned suddenly, a flash of white teeth amidst his cropped ginger beard. "Bet it felt good though, right?"
Bard grinned back. "I've been wanting to do that for fifteen years, but they've always been too wealthy and powerful to oust. They ran roughshod over my father in his later years, old and tired as he was. Damn. That was marvellous."
"Right, well, that's taken care of at last," Dwalin grunted, and he holstered his axe again on his back. "We could use my troops to distribute the food, if it's a centralised and coordinated lot you're after."
Dori pursed his lips. "I think not, Mister Dwalin sir," he said, thinking hard. "The Army has enough to be going on with, thank you kindly. There may be a siege on, but I don't recall declaring military law in Erebor."
"I think we're a little past that now, don't you?" said Orla.
"Possibly, possibly," Dori waved a hand. "Still, if that's the case, then as the duly elected representative of the Guilds and as the Quartermaster of Erebor's forces, I would like to offer my services. In conjunction with Barur Stonebelly and the representatives of the Men and Elves, of course…"
Dís leaned back in her chair, and then she turned to the new King. "Perfect," she said simply.
"Aye," he said, nodding. "Master Dori, you do us honour."
Laerophen, after a brief moment of whispering with Merilin, said, "my second in command Merilin is pleased to represent the Elves and to work together with Master Dori to ensure fairness and justice."
"Also, I know the recipe for lembas, and he doesn't," Merilin said drily.
"I will stand for the Dalefolk," said Selga, glancing at Bard, who nodded.
"Nobody better. May I formally introduce the Lady Selga, granddaughter of the Princess Sigrid and my cousin."
"Charmed," Dori said, with a brisk little bow. "Tea later: work first. Glóin, you seem to have begun an inventory already: may I prevail upon you to take on the numbers and record-keeping?"
Glóin chuckled. "Aye, my old friend. I've been bored stiff in retirement."
"I wanna help Dori too!" came a squeak from under Laerophen's chair.
Dori cringed, ever so slightly.
"In the interests of keeping Dori sober, perhaps not," said Dís. "Gimizh, you will assist me in telling the people about the food-collection. You and your little friends."
A petulant little sigh came from underneath the Elf's chair. "Oh, all right."
"You'll need people to guard the food-stores," said Genild, tugging at her beard-braid. "I'll do that. There's precious little to do on the walls except shoot arrows, an' I've never been an archer."
The Stonehelm turned to Laerophen and Bard, and said, "the Lady Genild is a veteran of the Battle of Five Armies, whom I have known since my childhood in the Iron Hills. Her loyalty is unimpeachable and unassailable, and I personally vouch for her. She is also a dangerous warrior."
Jeri pulled a face. "All right, I'll admit Ma is a good choice to guard the stores then."
"Wait till I tell your Amad," Genild said, her eyes sparkling in her strong, wrinkled face.
Jeri rolled their eyes. "Amad'll want to guard right alongside you."
"Mmmm. I'm counting on it."
Jeri wrinkled their nose.
Dori, Selga and Merilin eyed each other cautiously. "Well then," Dori ventured at last, "shall we begin?"
Dís stood, and began to leave. "Lady Dís?" Selga called after her. "You depart?"
"I don't expect to be very helpful to the proceedings, Lady Selga," Dís said in an expressionless voice, without so much as breaking her stride. "It could be because I haven't been very hungry lately."
Víli's heart sank just a little lower in his chest, and he fisted his hands by his sides.
"Not long," Hrera said gently, and patted his shoulder again. "Not long now."
"It's the pause between the hammer blows," Gimli murmured, and he gripped his pipe between his teeth. "I can feel it in my bones. The stones fairly shake beneath my feet."
"For a city that has been saved from ruin, there is little in the way of joy in the air," Legolas said, and he looked out over the great churned plain that was the Pelennor. They were sitting in the courtyard at the height of the seventh level, looking out over the city. The citadel was to their backs, and the icy wind blew into their faces. It had taken Gimli three tries to light his pipe.
"At least Merry is healing well," Gimli said gloomily, and he took a drag on the pipe and smoothed down the wisps of his beard that were, once again, escaping. "After all the pains they have cost us, I would be grieved if he were still lying abed."
"You would be grieved beyond the pains they cost us, you don't fool anyone at all," Legolas said, smiling.
"Aye, it was good to visit them, and to talk," Gimli conceded. "And Pippin's stash of Longbottom Leaf is a welcome taste."
Legolas wrinkled his nose. "For you, perhaps."
It was to these words and this sight that Thorin arrived: the Elf and Dwarf sitting in the thin sunshine before a withered white tree. To the casual observer, no doubt they appeared as they ever had: two friends, spending time together and taking the air. However, Thorin could now spot the subtler nuances: the way Legolas leaned slightly against Gimli's broad shoulder, the way Gimli seemed to relax against Legolas' side, the small secret trade of touches between swift hands.
They looked content enough, and the tension bled from Thorin's shoulders.
"Then they have made their peace and settled matters between them," he said, almost to himself. "Good. That is very good."
"And you were pleased to see Arod also, do not dissemble," Legolas laughed.
Gimli sniffed. "He's a horse of Rohan, isn't he? He's used to a certain standard o' living. The Rohirrim treat their horses as good as their kin, some of them. Wanted to be sure they were stabling him right, that's all."
"It was not me who brought him carrots and apples from our plates."
"I wasn't going to eat them, and it doesn't do to waste food." Gimli patted Legolas' knee. "I could have done without all the staring though. And you! Singing all the way there and back, as though you could not feel all those eyes following us every step we took!"
Legolas tipped his head. "Did they concern you? I saw you stumping along and stroking your beard…"
Gimli bit down on the stem of his pipe, and puffed a couple of times. His face was as good as an answer.
"Meleth," Legolas breathed, and he leaned down until his chin brushed the top of Gimli's fiery head. "They stare at an Elf and a Dwarf, the first they have ever seen, the strange companions of the mysterious Lord Elfstone. If I can bring some music into this sad place after the tumult of warfare and the sound of crashing boulders, why not?"
Gimli muttered something inaudible, and then patted Legolas' knee again. "Kindly said, ghivashelê. And I have no quarrel with them and their staring: I am merely tired of being a curiosity, it seems. At least here only the Citadel guards may peer at us."
"Then I may sing here?" Legolas teased.
Gimli chuckled, a gravelly rumble. "As if anyone could ever stop you from singing!"
Thorin looked up. The Citadel Guards stood about the court as usual, resplendent in their cloaks and winged helms. Half their attention was fixed on the strange couple, though they were otherwise motionless.
"He's cut his beard again," Frerin murmured at Thorin's side, and Thorin nodded and drew him closer. He was well-aware that Frerin was still shaken, still wounded, but he trusted that his canny, bright younger brother knew his own strength.
And, too, there were no battles here.
"That'd be for Dáin, I expect," Frerin continued, and his mouth tightened slightly. His hand came up to finger the shortened, rough bristles at the side of his own face, and his eyes slid to the side to brush over the third member of their little watch.
Dáin was tense-faced, and his jaw rippled. "He shouldnae done that," he muttered. "No need."
"Gimli observes the forms, even amongst outsiders," Thorin told him. Then he gave his cousin a sad half-smile. "He is as much Dwarf as he ever was, despite the company he keeps."
"As though even the love of an Elf could change that," Dáin snorted softly. Something caught his attention, and he nodded to the citadel door. "Here's something."
Frerin squinted, his young eyes keener than either of theirs. "Aragorn," he said, and then he gasped. "He looks dreadful."
Thorin's head whipped away from Dáin, and there indeed was Aragorn. His face was drained and pinched, and his eyes were awful. "Gimli," he said, sharp and short.
Gimli's head rose immediately. "My King?"
"Look to your friend," he said, and Gimli stood (with a little effort – it appeared that the aftermath of battle still left him stiff and sore), and cast his eyes about until he caught sight of their leader.
"Lad," he said low, and nudged Legolas, before breaking into a jog.
Legolas, who had been looking up at the white and wizened tree, blinked. Then he spun about to see Aragorn leaning heavily upon the citadel walls, and soon he was running towards him, overtaking Gimli with ease.
"Mellon nín, what is this?" he said, taking Aragorn's arm and bracing him.
Aragorn's head tipped back, and his eyes were bruises in his face. "I…"
"Right, sit him down," Gimli said briskly, arriving a breath or two behind Legolas. "Answers will wait, but he's about to keel over."
"Has he slept at all?" Dáin wondered. "He has been in the Houses of Healing…"
"Haban said he was to sleep after he visited there," Thorin said, scratching at his head. "I can think of no other claim upon his time, no other emergency that needs his attention. There are few who know him by sight, though no doubt the rumour is speeding its way through the city after his banner was flown atop the Black Ships. And the healers of the Houses too, Haban said they were gossips of the first order: they will have done their part, and tongues will wag long into the night. Yet only Imrahil and Faramir, of all the Men of Gondor, know his true face and name. To all else he is but the Lord Elfstone."
"Rumour is only rumour," Dáin agreed, and he chewed on his lip for a moment. "Then this is not simple exhaustion. Something else."
Gimli, who was easing Aragorn down upon the raised white stone circle that ringed the dead tree, harrumphed. "It would be very nice if we could cease all speculation until the lad has had water and air and a puff of my pipe. We'll get our answers soon enough. You lot! Be elsewhere!" He raised his voice to the Citadel Guard, who all appeared very surprised indeed to be so ordered about by a Dwarf.
Perhaps it was surprise that led them to obey, or perhaps it was Legolas adding, "we will guard the White Tree. You need fear no treachery from such as we, for did we not come to the aid of Minas Tirith in her hour of need? Stay close, but give us space, if you would."
They bowed slightly, and then left. One or two sent inquisitive looks back over their shoulder as they entered the guardhouse by the Citadel.
Aragorn's head lolled forward, and Legolas was forced to hold him via a hand to the centre of his chest to keep him from pitching forward. "I have never seen him thus," he said, turning worried eyes on Gimli.
"No; I neither," Gimli said, and he worked at his belt-pouch with clumsy, rushed fingers, bringing forth his travel-skin. "Here, water."
Legolas took it and brought the lip to Aragorn's mouth. He took two great swallows, and then slumped back. His colour seemed better: closer to his normal weather-beaten brown, rather than that sallow, sickly grey.
"Now, breathe a bit, and then tell us what in Mahal's name you've been doing to yourself," Gimli said, and he sat down beside the Man and shared a worried look with Legolas.
Aragorn took another sip of the water, and then he lifted his head with some effort. "I looked into the Palantir."
Thorin was struck dumb with horror.
Gimli was not. "You did what?!"
"Why would you do such a thing?" Legolas demanded. "That stone is turned to Sauron's will: it is the instrument of Denethor's despair! Why, Aragorn? Why, when the victory upon the field is ours?"
"The victory on this field, indeed," Aragorn croaked. "But not this war."
There was a sharp intake of breath from where Dáin stood, but Thorin could not spare his attention. Whatever his cousin had realised, it would have to wait.
"Speak to the point," Gimli said, though his gentle hands belied his words. "Do not spend your strength on reasons and whyfores. What happened?"
Aragorn closed his eyes and leaned back against Legolas and Gimli, letting them prop him up… as indeed, Thorin could now see, he had relied on them to do so all this way. "Minas Tirith is safe for now," he said, his voice faint but true. "But even such a battle as we have fought is all for nothing if the true quest does not succeed."
"Frodo and Sam," said Legolas, nodding.
"Frodo and Sam," Aragorn agreed. "We know from Faramir that they have taken the pass of Cirith Ungol. If they have escaped the notice of both Minas Morgul and the terror that lives within the pass, then they now face all the hordes of Mordor gathered together upon the plain of Gorgoroth…"
"A feint," Dáin grunted. "He's taunting the enemy, drawing him out."
"No more reasons, I said," Gimli soothed, and wetted his hands to lay them upon Aragorn's brow. "I've no skill such as you, but you are burning up. There, that must feel better."
"It does." Aragorn leaned into Gimli's rough, work-worn hands. "Who knew Dwarves had such gentleness within them?"
"He is ever a surprise to me," said Legolas tenderly, and Aragorn gave a weak little laugh.
"Took you long enough, you stubborn pair."
As Legolas' ears turned scarlet and Gimli roughly cleared his throat, Aragorn smiled and opened his eyes. "I am full of joy for you both," he said simply.
"You're full of stuff and nonsense, you daft Man," Gimli grumbled, and he patted the cool water upon Aragorn's brow some more. "And my uncle is – was – a healer. We're not stone all through, I'll have you know."
"I am sure Legolas can attest to it," Aragorn said, and his voice was a little stronger - and a little sly.
Legolas coughed. "Back to your tale. We are but a footnote."
"No happiness is ever a footnote," Aragorn said, and still he let loose a groan of defeat. "Very well."
"Take another sip," Gimli said, hovering like a bird with a poorly chick. "Then we can re-fill my pipe…"
"No, no pipe," Aragorn said, though he dutifully took another slug of water. "He is wreathed in flames and darkness and smoke. I cannot face even the familiar embers of Shire-weed."
"You spoke to him," Legolas guessed.
"I said no words," Aragorn slumped back, braced between his friends, and the water-skin dangled loosely from his hands.
"He has wrestled with the Shadow," Thorin said, and Frerin shrank against his side. "That is why he is so drained, so weary. For all his might, Aragorn is but a mortal Man, and he has now faced the will of Sauron himself."
"You saw him, then," Gimli said, and his eyes grew hard and fearful. "Lad, breathe a moment more."
"Stop cosseting, Gimli," Aragorn said, and patted Gimli's shoulder. "I will be well… in a moment or two."
"You nearly pitched forward onto your face, and don't think I haven't realised that you came looking for us," Gimli shot back. "Something in that scruffy head knows to seek your friends when you're in trouble. So shut up and let me fuss if I want to. I'd like to see you stop me – you're as fearsome as a kitten right now."
Aragorn smiled again. "Dwarves," said Legolas fondly.
Gimli sniffed, and Frerin echoed it. "Aye, all right, yes, we can all laugh at me later, when you're a little steadier," he said sternly. "If the pair of you could stop worrying the life out of me, that'd be grand. Why, we stand in a city freed of all menace, and you still find a way to turn my hairs white!"
Dáin rolled his eyes. "Oh, so he's that sort. Rude with relief."
"You'd be rude too, if your friends made a habit of scaring you half to death every so often," Gimli immediately retorted – and then a look of pure horror crossed his face as he realised he had spoken to his kin aloud before Aragorn. "Ah, I…"
"I want answers, and soon." Aragorn pushed himself up to give Gimli a long, measured look. "For why you speak as though answering the air, why you mutter to yourself every so often. I will not be put off, Gimli Glóin's son."
Gimli gulped. "Finish your tale first, and then you shall hear mine," he promised, and his voice was much more subdued than the bluster of his worry and panic.
Legolas pressed one hand against his chest, his expression earnest. "It is nothing to cause harm, I swear it," he said.
"Then you know? What am I saying, of course you know." Aragorn shook the hair from his eyes, and then wiped a trembling hand down his face. He had not had the proper tools to shave as Men did for some weeks, and his habitual scruff was beginning to form a respectable beard. It rasped beneath his palm. "My tale… it is not long. I looked into the stone, and flames carried me off to some dark realm. There he waited for me. Sauron, cloaked in shadows and crowned with fire, his Eye a terrible burning brand against my mind. I have never felt the like, never been so afraid in my life. It took all my strength, but I spoke no words to him, gave him no opening."
"But he showed you something, just as he showed Denethor?" Legolas wondered.
"He did." Aragorn's face stilled, until he looked more like the statues of the Argonath than ever. Hard, deadly, ancient and cold. "I showed him the Ring of Barahir, the Sword that was Broken. I heard him whisper my names, one after the other, all finishing with Elessar, Elessar. And it cut me through to my marrow and froze my blood, and I struggled against his whispers. Yet this was not enough to break my resolve.
"He showed me great kingdoms and armies, mine to rule and command." Aragorn's laugh was hollow. "I said nothing. When in my life have I wanted for armies and kingdoms, though they follow after my bloodline like sniffing dogs? The leathers of a Ranger of the North were enough for my forebears, and they have been enough for me. When he realised that power was no temptation for me, he tried another tactic. He showed me riches beyond belief, and told me they were mine if I would but lay down my sword. He showed me the gathered might of the Dark Tower, endless waves of Orcs all marching, marching. The Palantir cannot lie, it can only be twisted to show that which the wielder wishes. I have no doubt that these things are true: the riches, the armies, all of it. Through it all, he urged me to lay down my sword. And in that I found my courage again.
"He fears the Sword that was Broken. He fears the blood in my veins, for all its weakness." Aragorn sounded wondering and amazed. "I could feel it. The pain of losing his form has never faded, and he has never forgiven Isildur for it. How he must have rejoiced in Isildur's ruin!"
Thorin laid a careful hand on Frerin's shoulder, and let his fingers tighten protectively.
"What then did he show you, mellon?" Legolas prompted, in barely a whisper. "What is it that has wounded you so?"
"Arwen." Aragorn's lips tightened, and the little colour he had regained began to leech away from his cheeks. "He showed me Arwen."
Legolas' breath caught, and Gimli glanced up at him with unreadable dark eyes, before turning back to their friend.
Aragorn continued in a voice full of anguish, but his face remained resolute. "She has spent so much of her grace, her arts, protecting me and her home. I knew I felt her when the river Isen swept me away, I knew it."
"Explains a little more about your uncanny luck, I suppose," Gimli grunted, though his expression was still worried.
"He made promises to you," Legolas said. "And threats to her."
Aragorn gave a single, slow nod. "He whispered that I had but to lay down Andúril, and she and I would be healed, my mortal gift and mortal doom would be lifted away, and we should live together in peace for all time. But should I stay my course…"
"He lies," Gimli said staunchly.
"He lies, but in his lies are the grain of truth, and it is that which makes them so easy to swallow," Aragorn said brokenly. "She is dying. Lord Elrond told me as much, when he met with me at Harrowdale. Arwen's life is tied to the fate of the Ring… and the fate of the Ring is tied to that of two small, brave Hobbits."
Abruptly, Thorin remembered a conversation – it seemed years ago, and not mere weeks – between the aged Bilbo and the Elf-woman. Her luminous beauty had dimmed, even then, and she had seemed sad and listless and discontented. "So that is what ailed her," he muttered.
"Hobbits who face the plain of Gorgoroth before them, and that endless sea of Orcs you saw," said Gimli with a sigh. "Truth mixed with lies. I begin to understand Denethor better now. What must he have seen, to bring him to such an unhappy pass!"
"Then has showing yourself to Sauron and declaring your lineage achieved nothing? Has this removed our advantage, do you suppose?" Legolas said, and his fair brows drew together. "We have trusted in secrecy for so long. Your birthright has remained hidden, and safe, for centuries."
"A secret is only worth keeping if it protects, otherwise it is nothing but a burden. It is a necessary sacrifice, and the decision to declare myself was made when I raised my standard at the Stone of Erech." Aragorn smiled, tight and unhappy. "We have not the numbers to challenge the Black Land. We cannot invade it. We cannot break the Gate. But we can draw them out. We can force his hand."
Gimli let out a slow 'ahh' of satisfaction. "He's a vengeful sort, and if, as you say, he hasn't forgotten that sword and what it cost him, why then he'll lose his head completely. He'll want to crush you simply for being you. Pride and rage. That's a useful sort of weakness, that."
Pride and rage. Pride and rage. Crush you simply for being you. A useful sort of weakness. Pride and rage…
Frerin pinched Thorin's arm. "Stop it," he growled.
Thorin pinched back. "You stop it," he grumbled. "I am all right. Stop worrying."
Frerin raised an eyebrow at him. "You first."
"Have you spoken to Gandalf about this?" asked Legolas.
"I saw no need." Aragorn said, and his voice rang out, heavy and kingly, weary though it was. "This is my hour, though I have sought it not. The stone is my birthright, and the decision mine to make. If I make one choice for the good of Middle-Earth, let it be this one. I will save them, if I can. The duty is clear."
"That sounds familiar," Dáin murmured, and he gave Thorin a twinkling look from under his brows.
Frerin chuckled. "Doesn't it just."
"So, we are to march on the Black Gate, is that it?" Legolas said, and he hissed softly between his teeth. "A mouse challenging a lion."
The Morannon was impenetrable. They had no hope of success. Everything depended upon Frodo – as it always had. Thorin met Dáin's eyes again, and saw his own bleak conclusions reflected back at him.
"This mouse has a famous sword, and stalwart friends," Gimli said, and sat back. "You're as recovered as you're ever going to be without an ale and a good night's rest, I suppose. Please refrain from shocking me for the next hour or two, if you can possibly help it."
Aragorn laughed. It was faint, but real. "I will try, my friend."
"Then I am content."
"And now I have questions," Aragorn pushed himself up straighter, and levelled the Dwarf with a stern gaze. "Who is it you speak to when nobody is there to answer?"
"An hour, I said!" Gimli grated. "It has not even been a minute!"
"Meleth nín," Legolas murmured, and his long-fingered hand brushed against Gimli's shoulder, light as a settling leaf. "You promised."
Aragorn waited, silent and expectant.
Gimli winced. "I did." Then he let his chin drop against his chest. "Forgive me, my King."
"Tell him, Gimli. It does no-one any harm, and may help." Thorin said, and Frerin looked up at him with a questioning expression. Dáin made a noise of surprise.
"Are you sure?" Gimli pressed, and Thorin fought against the reflexive instinct to say, no, keep our secrets, keep them safe in your heart beyond the reach of those who cannot care for them.But no. There were greater things, and greater needs, than their secrets. The fate of Middle-Earth was one of them.
He lifted his chin. "You have been right before. And I trust you shall be right again. Aragorn speaks the truth: our secrecy is only a boon when it serves a purpose. Protecting our folk is one thing. Protecting Frodo's Quest is quite another. In this, you have been wiser than I, my star. You do indeed see clearly. Speak now, and give Aragorn the hope he needs."
Dáin was giving him a very searching look, but eventually he nodded as well. "Aye, tell them, laddie. Let us help in what little way we can. There are more important things than our pride."
Gimli swallowed, hard. "Very well." Then he turned to the other members of the Three Hunters, squared his jaw and his shoulders and said without preamble, "I hear the voices of the Dead."
Aragorn's eyes widened.
"Oh, for Mahal's sake, does the lad keep his brains in his biceps?" Dáin moaned. "He should have led up to that!"
"Gimli is not subtle," Frerin mumbled. He was covering his face with his hands. "At all."
"He is Glóin's son: his axe is subtler than he is, true enough." Thorin rubbed his brow. He found he was smiling a little helplessly. Oh, my star, ever you cheer me when I need it most! "Blunt and honest, that's his way."
"Blunt!" Dáin snorted loudly. "Thorin, I'm blunt, and I still manage a feint or two. Gimli is a verbal battering ram!"
"I am not," Gimli rumbled, his face torn between outrage and amusement. "Just don't see the point of chipping around the stone piece by tiny little piece. Better to cut it and have done."
"The dead?" Aragorn said carefully.
Gimli held up a hand. "Now, before you think me mad, I should explain further," he said. "The Dwarven Dead, my kin. They have some means to see us, here in Middle-Earth, through the parting mists over the sea and through death itself. I do not know how. But ever since Lothlórien - " here, Aragorn straightened in shock, "- I have known their voices, and heard their words. Over time I have grown used to their presence by my side, and can now pick out who it is that follows in my steps. One in particular has been my guide and my light…" Gimli licked his lips and his words trickled to a halt.
"The Paths of the Dead," Aragorn said, as though realising it only now. "You fell behind not only through your fear, but because you could feel them close after…"
"Aye, and see them, just as we saw the dishonoured ones, though they faded from view once we left the cursed Mountain," said Gimli. "They are here, even as we speak."
Aragorn turned to Legolas. "You believe this?"
"I have seen it with my own eyes," Legolas said, lifting his face as though defending Gimli against some criticism. "They give him tidings from other lands that he could not have possibly known otherwise, and I could make out the shapes of Dwarves in the gloom of the Stone of Erech; Dwarves whom I personally know to be dead."
"Tidings?" Aragorn pounced on the word like a hunting cat. "Then have they seen…"
Gimli nodded. "Aye. They watch it all."
"Can they tell us of Frodo and Sam?" Aragorn said at once, and Gimli grimaced.
"When and if they will. When and if they permit it."
"Frodo Baggins lives, and is free," said Thorin instantly. "He and Sam are still together. They passed into Mordor, and now make their through the Morgai towards the dark plain. Tell him, Gimli."
Gimli repeated this, and then rubbed at his forehead. "So says my King. Well, one of them. It seems I collect them."
"Thank Elbereth, I have not acted rashly and thrown everything into ruin." Aragorn deflated, and then he frowned. "Your King?"
"Thorin Oakenshield," said Gimli, proud and strong and as Dwarvish as the deep music of the earth itself. "Melhekhelê, my king of all kings, my guide, my great mentor. It is his voice I hear, loudest and clearest; his voice that brings me light and hope."
"He is dead for nearly eighty years," Aragorn said in astonishment. "I remember the tidings in Rivendell when I was but a child!"
"Aye." Gimli's voice shook with pride. "He is. But even death may not stop a Dwarf when they truly set their mind to something."
If his eyes travelled to Legolas as he spoke, well, none of them dared to mention it.
"Let me see if I have this aright. You hear the voice of a great departed hero of your people, speaking to you in your mind?" Aragorn said dubiously.
"You led us into the Golden Wood and out again, took us by the Dimholt road and commanded an army of ghouls to do your bidding, and an Elf-woman uses her arts to protect your skinny arse from half a world away," Gimli said, crossing his arms and raising his brows. "So what's your point?"
Legolas covered his smile with a hand.
"And Thorin Oakenshield is but one of the voices I hear. I have been hearing him for decades, ever since I was a rather rash and foolish tufty-beard in Ered Luin. I did not know it until Lothlórien, when I was granted leave to peer into the Lady's Mirror and saw him there. He has been joined in recent months by many more. That, or my mind's ear is sharper than it was."
"Tell me, then," Aragorn said, evidently deciding to trust Gimli's word. It seemed that the mention of Galadriel's Mirror had given him some pause for reconsideration. Thorin wondered if he found it strange that a Dwarf had been given leave to gaze into one of the great Elven mysteries.
"There is also Dáin Ironfoot, Zabadâl belkul, the Restorer of my homeland." Gimli's head dipped. "He is a new voice, and a new grief to me. My uncle I hear, too, and my cousin Balin. Nori and Ori, Lóni and Frár, all my friends and family who now sleep in the stone. They all gather close, and to me is given the great gift of sensing their nearness. I do not know how, but it makes me wonder: for how many centuries have our loved ones watched us, as near as breath itself, and as far away as the moon? And we did not know."
Legolas reached out, and his fingers clasped loosely around Gimli's thick wrist in silent reassurance.
With blinking eyes, Aragorn slowly said, "that must be a comfort. To know that you are loved, and that those who came before you are proud of you. To have your blood watch over you, and to not feel unworthy before their eyes. To fear no weakness, for their strength is part of you."
"I don't know about that," said Gimli gruffly. "I've done some mighty foolish things, and I've been powerfully afraid. They've been irritated with me as often as they have been proud, but there's nothing new about that. T'is commonly said that the word for a group of Dwarves is a Quarrel of Dwarves, and that's not far wrong. But aye, it is a comfort. I was a Dwarf alone before I knew. Now I know that no Dwarf ever walks alone, no matter how strange their path."
"Gimli," Thorin said, "tell him not to fear his blood. It is only blood. Faults and failings are not passed down through the generations like a family nose. Now that he has declared himself, let him be the King he is and not the King others were. He must rule as himself, as whatever and whoever he wishes to be. He is not the pale reflection of those who came before him; he does not need to style himself after them, nor claim their flaws." The memory of his grandfather's heavy golden armour upon his back flashed through his mind, and he brushed it aside with an almost contemptuous determination. "He is whole within himself, he is complete as he is. He is Aragorn, and Aragorn is more than enough."
Frerin pressed their shoulders together, and he could feel Dáin's steady, reassuring presence at his back.
"My King has words for you, Aragorn." And Gimli dutifully passed Thorin's message on. When he came to the end, Aragorn looked more shaken than ever.
"This is hard to believe, but I find it less confusing than your behaviour of late," he said, pale-faced, and he shook his head. "I thank you, Majesty, from my heart. But Gimli, of all answers you could have given me, this is one I never could have foreseen. Hearing the dead! I had thought that perhaps you were addled from more sun than a Dwarf can bear."
"Tch, nonsense," Gimli scoffed. "As though a little light could dazzle me."
"So speaks the one who dared to name three of the golden hairs of the Lady of Light as his desire," Legolas murmured.
"Hush your cheeky mouth, Elf," said Gimli without rancour. "Now, lad, have I sufficiently shocked you in return? Do we dare move you back into the Citadel?"
"If I go back, I must be the Lord Elfstone again. I will need to hold a council," Aragorn groaned, and he pushed himself up onto shaking legs. Gimli steadied him, and Legolas looped one of the Ranger's arms over his neck. "I need to tell Gandalf what I have done. Imrahil must be given clearer instruction about the Southrons that survived the battle. There are not enough tents, and not enough translators - and there are three or four Oliphaunts still living, if wounded, and they must be cared for as well… and Gandalf, yes, Gandalf must be told, we need his counsel, we must muster what forces we can… but not so many as to leave Gondor unprotected, for did not Éomer say that there was a second army in wait? There will be so few in number to begin with, a matter of thousands only…"
"Shh now, one foot before the other," Gimli coaxed, and together he and Legolas helped their friend over the court and back towards the great black-and-white marbled building.
"He's thinking like a King already. Poor bugger," said Dáin, with feeling.
Thorin grunted. "Aye, with all that it entails. Let us hope the crown does not weigh on him as heavily as it did you or I."
"This is why I never wanted your bloody job, Thorin."
"Yet you did it so very well, and it looked so fetching on you," Thorin shot back. The old teasing banter was easy to fall into.
"Had to do well, didn't I? You were literally haunting me," Dáin retorted, and then he smiled down at Frerin. "And of course, I didn't want to let my older cousins down."
Frerin's jaw dropped. "Older cousin?" he squeaked.
"Aye, well, you're always my big cousin, aren't you?" Dáin gave him a deferential little nod: a grizzled, heavy warrior in the prime of his life paying solemn respect to a half-grown adolescent with a half-shorn beard. "You're sixteen years my senior, after all. Some things do not change."
Frerin looked very young, and very pleased. "I am, aren't I?"
Thorin raised his eyebrows at Dáin, as if to say, I know what you are doing, you clever old coot.
Dáin gave him a barely-discernible wink. Trust me. It'll make him happy.
Thorin sighed, and turned his eyes up to the grey and churning sky.
"Big cousin," Frerin said happily to himself, and puffed out his chest.
"What's going on here?" came a new voice – and a small, bright bubble of air filled Thorin's chest. He turned to see Bilbo aiming a perplexed look at the assembled. "Who's… that's never the Dúnedan, is it?"
"If by that, you mean it is Aragorn, aye," he said. Frerin looked at him askance for a moment, and then he let out a silent 'ohhhh' of realisation.
"Hang on, what now, why's he talking like that," Dáin said in confusion, and Frerin scuttled over to their cousin and took his arm.
"I'll tell you, just be silent for a bit," he hissed, and began to whisper hurriedly into Dáin's ear. Thorin paid it no mind. All his attention was fixed on the Hobbit – the Hobbit who now held his Name in his soft, safe little hands.
"Hello Bilbo," he said, gentle and deep.
Bilbo's eyelids lowered at once, his cheeks turning pink. He cleared his throat. "Yes, er. Hello again." He tugged down the hem of his waistcoat, and then he said, "I still can't say it."
"I don't mind in the slightest," Thorin said, smiling. "I am pleased to see you."
"And I to see you, um. Dohyarzirikub."
"Nearly," Thorin said, and forced himself not to stand and smile like a simpleton at Bilbo, but to look back up at where Legolas was helping Aragorn make his way up the stairs to the great Hall. Gimli was bearing most of the Man's weight as the Elf guided them on. "Dohyarzirikhab. The last syllable. Khab."
"Khab," Bilbo echoed. "Dohyarzirikhab." Then he made one of his impatient little noises, his face full of irritation. "It is like trying to wash your mouth out with sand and grit, heavens…"
"I will tell our Maker as such, next time we speak." Thorin chuckled. "No doubt he will be offended that you think so little of the language he gifted us."
"I should think that such a description would be a compliment to him, and not an insult, or didn't he make the sand and the grit as well?" Bilbo said, and folded his arms. He looked rather pleased with his clever response… as well he might. "And the last syllable is the one that is giving me such terrible trouble."
"Perhaps now you will forgive Kíli for calling you 'Mr Boggins', hmm?"
"Never," Bilbo sniffed. A smile tugged at the edge of his lips, though.
"The Hobbit is here?" Thorin heard Dáin exclaim.
"That's your cousin, I remember him," Bilbo said, nodding at Dáin, and then he squinted up at the stairs. "Wait, and there's your lad Gimli."
My lad Gimli, he calls him, Thorin mused, and did not correct him.
"Why…" Bilbo frowned and peered closer, taking one or two steps after the departing party. Then he gasped in amazement and broke into a short run, saying, "no, no, no, that's never so! That can't be right!"
"Bilbo?" Thorin called after him, confused.
"They're holding hands?" Bilbo said, and spun around (Mahal save him, Hobbits were nimble!) in a trice to whirl back to Thorin, confusion writ all over him. "They're holding hands! But Legolas is an Elf?"
Oh, that was all it was. "Aye, they are."
Bilbo gave him an absolutely incredulous look. "And Gimli is a Dwarf!"
"It appears that your eyesight is as keen as ever, Master Baggins," he replied, dry as dust.
"But…!" Bilbo waved his hands about in the air in wordless exasperation. "Why aren't you storming about, then?"
Thorin pretended innocence, and ignored the little harrumphs of laughter that were emerging from Dáin and Frerin some distance away. "A well-read Hobbit such as yourself surely knows that Elves have taken partners from other races before," he said, as mildly as he could.
"You! But – but," Bilbo spluttered and wagged a finger in his face, and then shook it towards the now-departed trio. "That…!"
"Quite." Letting his voice drop, Thorin said, "and of course, a Dwarf cannot choose again, once they have chosen."
Bilbo gaped at him. "I don't believe you," he declared flatly, and then threw his hands out to say, as though to the whole of Minas Tirith - "I don't believe you! You confuse the life out of me, you blasted, dratted…"
"Yes, yes, silly, confounded, preposterous old Dwarf, I know," Thorin murmured, and smiled at the bewildered expression on that dear, expressive face. "To be fair to you, I have had some time to come to terms with the notion. Gimli loves where he loves. His choice was not one I would have foreseen, nor one I easily accepted. I know Legolas better than I did ere I died, however, and he has proven himself over and again. He is worthy of the best of us. They have my blessing. And I would be the greatest of hypocrites were I to castigate Gimli for loving outside our race."
Bilbo, slack-jawed and cut off mid-rant, closed his mouth with a snap. One hairy foot scratched at the ground. "Oh, um. Well then. Right," he blustered. "Er. Good? Yes, I suppose that is good."
"And of course, my nephew helped me see things rather more clearly as well." Thorin glanced to the East, where the great clouds billowed and belched over the mountain peaks. "He watches over yours, even now. We should see how he fares."
Abruptly, Bilbo was all business again. "Good," he said, his eyes full of that Hobbitish steel that always seemed to rise when circumstances were the most dire. "Let's go see how Frodo-lad is doing, yes indeed."
"In a moment. I will tell the others." Thorin nodded to him, and then began to make his way back to Frerin and Dáin (who were watching him with matching expressions of amusement).
"Wait – Kíli helped you understand?" Bilbo called after him, his tone dubious.
"He did," Thorin replied without pausing, and then reached out to give both his brother and his cousin a light slap on the shoulder. "Stop it, you dreadful pair."
"As I recall, you weren't exactly sympathy itself when I was agonising over askin' Thira to wed," said Dáin archly, and Frerin sniggered.
"You look ridiculous, making sheep's-eyes at thin air."
Thorin took a deep breath and resigned himself to being the figure of their fun for a while. "How did I forget how many pranks you two were responsible for," he growled. "Wonderful."
Dáin and Frerin only grinned wider at that.
"We must check on Frodo and Sam now," Thorin said, ignoring their gleeful faces and wickedly-gleaming eyes (he would no doubt find a metal tray, chilled nearly ice-cold, in the foot of his blankets tonight, waiting for the touch of his bare feet). "Bilbo wishes to see his nephew, and Fíli and Kíli must be given a respite."
"The way he tells it, Nori is the one who needs a break from Fíli and Kíli," Dáin said, still grinning.
"Kíli helped you understand," Bilbo muttered, shaking his head. "Well, I'm glad at any rate. Glad you are finally able to see some good in the Elves at last. Though I confess I am still rather astonished that you're not vehemently opposed to Gimli walking out with the son of the Elvenking."
"Kíli has his own store of wisdom, unexpected though it is," said Thorin, feeling as though he ought to defend his namadul.
Frerin gave him a sceptical look. "That's not what Fíli says. Fíli calls him a twit. A lot."
"Fíli has had to apologise for his brother's recklessness for nearly one hundred and fifty years," Dáin said with a shrug. "That'd do it."
"Fíli has the patience of the very stones, then."
"One word," Bilbo said succinctly. "Ponies."
"Let us go to them now." Before you all start joining forces in teasing me, Thorin did not add. He closed his eyes, and trusted the stars to gather them up and lead them into the dark.
The wind was the same, blowing icy across his face. That was all that remained the same, however, and Thorin opened his eyes again onto a scene from a nightmare. Black smoke belched into the air, and nothing grew as far as the eye could see. They stood upon a high rise, and the stones were melted into torturous shapes beneath his feet, as though Mahal's earth were struggling against the horror that had been forced onto its back. The plain stretched out before them, covered in bristling shapes of tents and the dull glint of weaponry. Every so often the glow of fires in deep pits could be seen, like dragon's mouths breathing into the night-dark sky.
And in the distance – not forty miles away – stood the slopes of the great fire-mountain itself, shouldering out of its own filthy spume, bulking massive and sullen and final. Behind it, half-hidden in the vast shadow and shrouded in its own cloak of menace, stood the vicious jagged tooth that was Barad-dûr.
Frerin froze, and the word "irrîn," fell soundlessly from his lips.
Dáin glanced down at him, and then threw a companionable arm around the young Dwarf's shoulders. "Hideous, ain't it?" he said, in a quiet but steady voice. "Ugliest damn thing I ever saw. His Monocular Nibs is no great architect, that's for sure and certain: the two of us could have done a better job of it when blindfolded and drunk. Look at how impractical it is! I hope all those useless spikes stick him right in his silly old Eye."
Frerin gave him a grateful look, and nodded.
"That's the last of it, save the Elven waybread. We've finished the food Faramir gave us," Thorin heard Sam say, and then he spotted them. They were half-covered by Sam's Lothlórien cloak, and clad in the foul leathers and armour of small tracking orcs.
Frodo's face was so thin; thinner than any hobbit's should ever be. His eyes, huge and blue, were bloodshot and haunted and staring, and bruises so deep they were nearly black were pressed into the skin beneath them. His lips were dry and cracking, and he mumbled inaudibly every so often.
Bilbo covered his gasp with trembling hands, and his eyes were utterly grief-stricken. "My lad," he whispered into his palms. His voice was heavy with guilt.
"Shh, now." Thorin wished he could embrace the Hobbit and give him comfort. "I know it is terrible. But he lives. He lives, and he has Sam still."
"What did I do to you," Bilbo breathed, and his little shoulders hunched against his sorrow.
"This was not your doing, Bilbo," Thorin said, and turned to look directly into the Hobbit's eyes. Bilbo met them reluctantly. "You are not responsible for the workings of the Ring. This is not. Your. Fault."
Bilbo's throat worked furiously as he stared up at Thorin. Then he squeezed his eyes shut.
"Here, Mister Frodo, take another sip," said Sam gently, and brought a water-skin up to Frodo's mouth. Frodo did not seem to notice when he swallowed the last of it, handing the empty skin back to Sam and falling back against the little rocky hollow they were hiding in.
"Aren't you going to have some?" he asked listlessly.
"Not so thirsty," Sam said in his plain, brave way, packing the skin away and smiling. "Leastways, it's better with you."
"Hello again, uncle, little uncle, cousin," said Fíli, and he gestured to the Hobbits. "They were nearly found, not half an hour ago. A nice little scuffle between an Orc tracker and a Morgul warrior. Still, they avoided it."
Thorin crossed to his nephew and pressed their foreheads together for a moment. "How fare you?"
Fíli smiled, though it was bleak. "Better than Frodo."
"I've had enough of this stinking desert," said Nori, and he shifted from foot to foot. "It's too open."
"Me too," Kíli grumbled, and he looked up at the slumbering fire atop Barad-dûr nervously. "I hate it when his Eye brushes past. Makes me feel… more than naked, if you take my meaning."
"Aye, I do." Thorin glanced back at Frodo and Sam. "How is the burden?"
"It calls and calls," Fíli grated. "Frodo said he sees it all the time now, like a ring of fire held before his waking eyes."
A punched-out noise came from Bilbo's direction.
"We should make another effort," Frodo said, without opening his eyes.
"Rest a moment more, dear Master," Sam said, and he gazed out across the plain with hopelessness written all over his honest face. "So many of 'em, and all as busy as a nest of insects in summertime. I don't like the look of things at all. Still, where's there's such a lot of folk there must be wells or water, not to mention food. And these are Men not Orcs, or my eyes are all wrong. Well, whatever they have to eat or drink, we can't get at it. There's no way down from this ridge save that road, and that's too open."
"Still, we shall have to try," said Frodo.
"I guess what it'll be like," said Sam glumly. "Where it's narrower the Orcs and Men will just be packed closer. You'll see, Mister Frodo."
"I dare say I shall, if we ever get so far," said Frodo and turned away.
Sam sighed and began to pack away their meagre things into the knapsack upon his back. He paused, and then asked hesitantly, "Begging your pardon, Mister Frodo, but have you any notion how far there is still to go?"
"No, not any clear notion, Sam,' Frodo answered, curled in upon himself with his arms hugging around his middle. "In Rivendell before I set out I was shown a map of Mordor that was made before the Enemy came back here; but I only remember it vaguely. I am afraid, Sam, that the burden will get very heavy, and I shall go still slower as we get nearer."
"That's just as I feared," Sam muttered, and he looked over the things in his knapsack, shaking his head. "Well, to say nothing of water, we've got to eat less, Mr. Frodo, or else move a bit quicker."
"I'll try and be a bit quicker, Sam," said Frodo, drawing a deep breath. "Come on then! Let's start another march!"
Pulling each other to their feet, they began to trudge on into the darkness. "And that's all they can do," Fili said, and his hands clenched and unclenched. "I feel so useless. All we can do is walk along beside them, hour by hour and mile by mile."
"That's all any of us can do," Thorin answered, and he cupped Fili's face. "Do not despair, namadul. They are not alone, though they do not know it. We can honour them thus."
"Much good it does them," Nori muttered, and then silence fell as on into the Black Land they stumbled.
Hour after hour passed, and the path was remorseless. Frodo staggered along, and leaned on Sam often. Thorin and his companions said nothing as they matched them step for step, and deep in his heart Thorin cried out at the injustice of this Quest and at what it had done to these two peaceful, gentle, merry creatures.
The look on Bilbo's face was too terrible to bear.
When the sun's smothered glow had nearly disappeared behind the western mountains to their backs, something changed at last. "Wait a moment now," said Sam unexpectedly, putting a hand against Frodo's chest and frowning out at the spreading armies. "Could only be the darkness playing a trick on me, but could it be that they are moving?"
At that moment a horn rang out, answered by others that rang all about the huge barren valley. Frodo swayed a little, the noise seeming to buffet him about.
"Well, there's a bit of luck," Sam said, astonished, and hoisted his pack higher upon his back. "Let's make use of it!"
"Aye, they are indeed moving North," said Dáin, and he turned to Thorin with a hard grin on his lips. "Aragorn's feint worked. His Nibs is running scared, and he's going to throw it all at the Gates."
"It has not worked yet, and Aragorn has not even mustered his forces," Thorin said, as the many camps began to fold up and long, glittering, clanking lines made entirely of soldiers began to wend their way over the plains, like armoured snakes.
"Aragorn did this?" asked Kíli, and he stood a bit straighter. "Well, thank Mahal. I didn't think they were ever going to have a chance of getting through that thicket of steel."
"Let's hope they were in too much of a hurry to take all their food with 'em," Nori added.
After another hour of carefully picking their way through the Morgai, Sam finally cursed. "There's nothing else for it, Mister Frodo," he said. "We have to take the road we saw from up above. There's no way down either east or west, and back leads us straight into that hornet's nest - only now we've poked it with a stick."
Frodo stared ahead, panting. Each breath rocked his little body.
Worry crossed Sam's brow, and he took Frodo's hand. "Mister Frodo? Mister Frodo, my dear?" he said, as gentle as could be. "We must take the road. We must take it and chance our luck, if there is any luck in Mordor. We might as well give ourselves up as wander about any more, or try to go back. Our food won't last. We've got to make a dash for it!"
"All right, Sam," said Frodo, in a dull voice that he produced with some effort. "Lead me! As long as you've got any hope left. Mine is gone. But I can't dash, Sam. I'll just plod along after you."
"Before you start any more plodding, you need sleep and food, Mr. Frodo. Come and take what you can get of them!"
Settling Frodo down again by the road's mouth, half-hidden by a ridge, Sam fed him a wafer of their precious waybread, and made a pillow of his elven cloak. Frodo ate mechanically, and when he was done he slid into a restless, twitching sleep.

Sam, Fili and Thorin, by kazimakuwabara
When he was sure his Master was asleep, Sam stood and looked down at him with a melancholy set to his lips. "Well, here goes, Master!' Sam muttered to himself. "I'll have to leave you for a bit and trust to luck. Water we must have, or we'll get no further."
"Sam," said Fíli, his jaw rippling, "has barely eaten in the last two days. He keeps giving his every morsel to Frodo."
Thorin did not dare look towards Bilbo. "Lion of the Shire," he murmured, and it was all so unfair.
Sam crept out from their little hollow, and flitted from stone to stone with a hobbit's uncanny silence and speed. No Dwarf could hope to follow him, not even ghostly ones. Bilbo turned to Thorin, and his eyes asked the question. Thorin nodded, and Bilbo disappeared after the gardener, swift and nimble and sure-footed as of old.
Thorin watched him go: a bright spot of russet and green and gold amidst the dry black dust of Mordor, and tried to ignore the little part of himself that rejoiced at just how easy it was to fall into their old partnership: to know the direction of each other's thoughts, to follow without question each other's lead.
"Thorin!" Frerin cried out, bringing his attention back to Frodo.
His brother's young eyes had spotted a skulking shape, splay-handed and whispering, creeping over the rocks by Frodo's hiding place. "Damn!" he cursed, and looked wildly after the direction Bilbo and Sam had disappeared. "They're too far away!"
"Escaped, did they," hissed Gollum, and his eyes were glowing with the fervour of the obsessed. "Well, we'll fix that, won't we precious? Gollum, Gollum!"
The creature's sibilant voice was a foul caress against their ears, and Thorin shuddered with revulsion. "Go after them, we need Sam!" he snapped to Frerin and Kíli, who took off running at once.
"Ah - they're the fastest, they've the best chance," Dáin said, staring at Gollum. "That…"
"Was once a Hobbit," Thorin finished. "Or something very like one."
"That is what the Ring can do," added Fíli, and true hate shone in his face.
"Easy," Thorin said to him. Fíli's eyes flicked up to his.
"I have now watched Frodo Baggins wrestle with that thing for weeks upon weeks, seen it eat him alive from the inside-out," he said, low and vicious. "I have never hated anything so much as that little circle of gold."
"It's nearly on him," said Nori sharply, bringing them back to the moment.
Gollum's hands moved, soft and strong and grasping, over the tortured stone as he crept ever closer to the fitfully-slumbering Frodo. All the while, his muttering never ceased. "They calls poor Sméagol sneak, they does, and then they go ssssneaking about in places they shouldn't be! O very nice, very fair, how very just, O yes Precious! Filthy hobbitses, they mustn't… they mustn't… and the fat one turns his nasssty eyes away, carries off the Elfs-sword and the Elfs-light and leaves the Masssster all alone! Now is the time, my precious, my love! Yesss, now!"
"Garn, get away!" came the shout of outrage, and Sam came trudging back with Sting glowing blue in his hands. "Get you gone, you slinker!"
Gollum gave a short cry of terror, and he was gone in a trice, web-toed feet disappearing over the ridge-line.
"Just in time," sighed Kíli, and he rubbed at his face. "He has to stop cutting it so fine."
"Well, luck did not let me down," said Sam, peering after the place where Gollum had vanished. "Isn't it enough to have orcs by the thousand without that stinking villain coming nosing round?" He fisted his hands and fairly stomped back to where Frodo lay, and sat down beside him with a pugnacious expression on his face.
"Did he find water?" Thorin asked Frerin, and he nodded.
"Brackish, smelly water, aye. But it's drinkable, he tried a bit. It's the best they're going to get around here, I'll wager."
Bilbo was wide-eyed and shaking with rage as he stared at the ridge-line. He seemed unable to find any words to put to his fury, and his breath was coming fast and rough through his nose.
"This Quest is not over," Thorin said, as quietly as he could. "Gandalf once said to Frodo that yours was the pity that may one day rule the fate of many. Do not repent of saving a life, Bilbo – even that one. He's a wretch and a monster, but you know that he was not always so."
Bilbo blinked, and then he shuddered. "Oh, blast it, tear it, curse it all," he moaned, and then his voice raised to nearly a shout. "Of course I know! I saw that when I spared him: he looked the spitting image of an old, withered Hobbit, sad and alone… and I have carried that evil thing for how long, Thorin Oakenshield, you cannot tell me a single dratted thing about what it does to a heart, what it does to a mind and body! Of course I pitied him! I still do! But he will kill Frodo, he means to kill my brave boy…" his hands fisted in his hair, and he began to weep. "How have you done this? Watched all this horror and sorrow and madness, unable to prevent it, for so long?"
Thorin let the storm of grief and horror and rage pass over him – had he not felt as much? Then he crossed to where Bilbo panted and shook, feeling the stares of the others upon his back. His hand lifted, fingers hovering over Bilbo's tawny hair. "I already told you that, Idùzhib," he said sombrely. "It was for you."
Bilbo gazed up at him with tear-wet cheeks, his mouth slack and open.
And then he vanished.
Frerin's little hand crept up to Thorin's shoulder and settled there. In the near distance came the sound of hundreds of booted feet, marching closer and closer.
...

It was for you, by fishfingersandscarves
TBC
