Chapter Text
“So. You have answered my summons at last, daughter of the forest.”
Hröa. New hröa. She had died, she had stormed the dark fortress, and…
“And far sooner than I had anticipated.”
She blinked her eyes, feeling the breath rush in and out of her lungs, the expansion and contraction of her ribs, as she had never noticed it before. Her toes scraped against the ground as she slowly stood up. Her skin felt unbearably sensitive, as though rough cloth were being pressed against it, though it was no more than the whisper of air around her limbs.
It was too bright, but she could just make out that her hands were as she remembered them. This flesh was identical to the old, just as all the tales had promised.
Then she took in the gigantic figure stooping over her, and her newly-beating heart nearly stopped yet again. “My Lord… Mandos?”
“Námo, if you please. Mandos is the name of my realm.” The Vala was neither young, nor old. His skin was deep bronze, and the piercing glow of the moon came from his eyes, etching the edges of the room in stark white and grey. His hair and body were swathed in scarves of many colours, covered in fantastical designs so intricate and dizzying that they defied the eye. They wafted around him, blurring his silhouette, drifting about like ghostly tendrils.
art by fishfingersandscarves
She shrank back.
“I did not expect to see you for several centuries yet,” he continued, and straightened up. The scarves floated in the air about him, as though an unseen wind were toying with them. Half-hidden in this cloud of complexity, he moved back politely to allow her some space in which to recover. “Those who refuse my summons and my halls do not tend to change their minds as readily as you have.”
“I did not change my mind,” she said, bravely lifting her face to that moonglow. “I do not know why I have come, nor why I have been given this new form. I would have stayed in my trees, entombed beneath the stones. There is nothing for me here.”
“Hmm.” The Vala waved a hand (or was it a scarf?) at a table which had suddenly appeared. “You are the daughter of that wood indeed: stubborn, thorny and hard. There are clothes for you here, at least. Choose which pleases you best.”
“It is my home,” she said, and as hurriedly as she was able she dragged on a pair of green hose and a brown tunic. Her colours. “It is where I would have my body remain.”
“You are an Elf, child,” said Námo patiently. “You cannot be elsewhere. Your very essence is tied to the world. You may refuse the summons, but it only prolongs the inevitable: this was always meant to happen. Your re-embodiment is the fate of all Elves. Most find it a relief.”
“Elves are not a monolith; I do not need to react as others do,” she growled, shoving her feet into a sturdy pair of boots. “I want to go back.”
“Why?”
That stopped her for a moment, but she firmed her jaw nevertheless. “I left great evil behind me, roosting in the branches of my home,” she said. “I will return and destroy it, now that I am whole once more.”
“Ah! Rejoice, then, daughter of the trees! For the evil has been destroyed as you drifted beyond all hope of news.” Námo smiled, and she was momentarily dazzled by the flash of his teeth. “The enemy has been thrown down and can never be reborn, for his greatest and chiefest weapon was in the end, the instrument of his destruction. No shadows will crawl from Dol Guldur in the days and decades to come. It is destroyed, and not a stone remains.”
She stared up at him, overwhelmed by the glow and the myriad patterns of his scarves and scarcely believing it. “Dead? Sauron is dead?”
“He is. I have turned him away, and he shall lie trapped in the void until the Sun and the Moon both perish. This I swear to you.”
“And is that prophecy?” She sat down heavily, and stared at her fingers. The lines and creases of her palms were exactly as before – the stark harsh light painted them in black and grey upon her skin.
“It is truth. It is what must and shall happen.”
“How did this happen?” She looked up again. It was difficult to say whether the movement was scarves or arms as the Vala drew closer once more.
“Through trial and terror, bravery and fellowship,” he said, and his smile pierced her again. “And love, of course. It is a tale long in the telling. Therefore we must find a time long enough, and begin. As for you, I may hazard a guess. Though the mightiest of the Elves yet in Middle-Earth were the ones responsible for the fall of Dol Guldur, it was Aiwendil that sowed the earth in the aftermath. He was a pupil of Yavanna before his journey, and it was his task to protect the Olvar and Kelvar of Middle Earth. He has fulfilled his task.”
“I do not understand.”
He considered her. “You stayed to protect your forest, did you not? You gave the last of your strength, even unto your last breath, to rid it of evil.”
She nodded dumbly.
“Thanks to the Brown Wizard, it is no longer in need of protection. It is cleansed. It is free.”
She blinked. The knowledge sank heavily into her, as though it was a stone and she a still woodland pool.
Then she said, “what do I do now? Where shall I go?”
The Vala’s expression was shrewd. “I, famously, have little in the way of pity. I suggest you seek out a new purpose, Elfling.”
She sat motionless for another moment. Then her head whipped up, an impossible hope flaring in her breast. “You see all those who die, do you not?”
“That is my purpose.” He sounded stern now, as though he anticipated her next question. “I see them, yes. They are my charge. But only those of Elven blood may pass through my borders. The Men and Hobbits and Orcs go on, to a place even I cannot see. Only Eru Illuvatar knows their destination.”
She took a huge breath. “And Dwarves?”
He drew back, his scarves flaring in shock. “What?”
She scrambled to her feet. “What of the Dwarves? Where do they go? Do they also move beyond, to a place you cannot see? Or do they stay as the Elves do?”
Stiffly, he answered, “They stay. But not under my care.”
Her heart began pounding with a new challenge. “Where? Under whose care?”
But Námo was silent.
She spun on her heel, and all at once there was a door where there had been none before. “Is that the way out? To Aman and beyond?”
“It is.”
“I will find where the Dwarves go,” she promised him, and raced for the door. “I will!”
“Unusual girl,” he murmured as she disappeared into the fields. “Perhaps I should warn Aulë… or then again, perhaps not.”
After all, he was owed a surprise after that nonsense with Irmo, the Dwarf, the Hobbit, and the Olórë Mallë.
…
“So, let’s get a plan together,” Jeri said, sitting back comfortably. They had lit a small fire, and all around them the great red desert stretched as far as the eye could see. Small scrubby bushes dotted the parched earth, and giant monoliths of red rock were interspersed with swathes of fibrous grasses, tough and dry. The night sky reached into infinity above them, and new constellations could be made out on the Eastern horizon. “What do we have?”
“The element of surprise,” answered Kara moodily. “And nothing else.”
Laindawar frowned at her. “That is not true. That is useless talk.”
“Well, I don’t see what else we have,” she snapped back. “I’ve lived in the Ghomal my whole life: I know it as you never can. And I tell you, we are hopelessly overmatched… I have no idea how to begin.”
“We begin by pooling our assets,” Jeri said, as Laindawar drew himself up to retort. “No, shut up. Really, shut up. All right. Laindawar, you won’t be able to pass unnoticed in the Orocarni. I have no idea if there are Elves in the East at all… so you will stand out like a big blond boil on someone’s nose.”
Laindawar’s lip curled. Kara sniggered.
“So we make use of that. You’re new, you’re unusual, you’re going to draw attention. Folks will want to know all about you: what you can do, your people, all of that. You’re a crown prince, too. We can make you a big shiny Elven distraction while Kara here gets people whispering.”
“Are you suggesting that I should be a figurehead?” Laindawar asked incredulously. Jeri looked faintly amused.
“Not at all, Highness. You’re trained as a warrior, but you’ve no doubt had a few millennia of polite and princely niceties shoved down your throat, yes?”
Laindawar gave a curt nod, lips pressed together.
“Then you know how to lay a word or two in the right ear. You know how to use a phrase to get people thinking. You know how to grease the right palm. And you know how to act as though everything you see belongs to you. Your status will give us access to dignitaries we otherwise might not have been able to reach, the very highest offices of the land.” Jeri clasped their hands on their stomach and tapped them in thought. “Kara, who do we really need to get to? The folks most in need of sanctuary?”
“It depends,” she said, glancing up at Laindawar. “There will be political dissenters and prisoners: they will be under intense scrutiny if still free, and if captured they will be guarded day and night. There are many who simply live quietly and fearfully. Snitching on your neighbours is not only encouraged, it is highly praised. There are few places in which to think or talk freely. The Cult of Sauron is paranoid, and it makes them ever-vigilant. We will be watched intently.”
“What of your mother?” Jeri asked gently. “Does she not need to escape?”
Kara clammed up immediately, her eyes blazing.
“Perhaps leave that enquiry for another day, mellon,” Laindawar murmured.
“And yourself,” Jeri said, adroitly side-stepping the awkward silence. “You were a political exile, no? Will you be arrested on sight?”
Kara frowned. “Maybe. Or maybe not. Exile yes, but I am still Crown Princess, and there will be some who see my return as the reestablishment of stability and continuity. We will need to gain the ear of the Treasurer, Korvir. She holds the purse-strings of the kingdom, and thus a great deal of power and influence. She is no friend to the Cult, but they cannot oust her while she controls the coin of the realm.”
“A concealment, perhaps?” Laindawar wondered.
“No-one is going to believe you are a Dwarf, no matter how short you are for Elvenkind,” Kara snorted.
Jeri coughed, and Laindawar growled beneath his breath. “That wasn’t what was intended,” Jeri said, and laid a calming hand on Laindawar’s arm. “Easy there, friend. No, I think you were suggesting that we disguise Kara herself, aye?”
Laindawar gave another short nod. Kara nearly shot to her feet in outrage.
“I will do no such thing! Lies and deceit are the way of the enemy! I will return to my halls as myself and with my own name, or not at all!”
“Peace! Peace,” Laindawar said, and he shook his head. His hair was rusty gold in the firelight. “I did not suggest that you pretend to be someone you are not. Only that you wear your veils, as Ashkar does, and give no name until we are sure of the lay of the land. Then we may reveal you.”
“Oh.” She chewed her lip. “I suppose that may work. If you can dazzle them with your Elven snobbishness, then get them wondering… yes, then it may be safe enough to come forth, or at least too awkward and public to attack me without reprisal or question. What about you, though?” she turned to Jeri, “you’re never going to pass for a Blacklock Dwarf.”
“Nope,” Jeri said cheerfully. “I’m Jeri child of Beri, aide and guard to the great Prince Laindawar, Elven adventurer and explorer, etcetera and so forth. If he and I are noisy, showy and flashy and new, then we may conceal you as a guide and interpreter before we make our big reveal.”
“Great Prince Laindawar,” repeated Laindawar, flatly.
“Etcetera and so forth,” Kara said, eyes dancing.
“I’ve never been this far from home before,” Laindawar said. “I’ve never even left the Greenwood before this year. My youngest brother had the wanderlust, not I!”
“Yes, I know, but we have to get folks interested. That way, we can begin our campaign of whispers.” Jeri squared their shoulders. “All right, so what else have we got? Skills, I’ll start. I’m a warrior, I favour the axe and the sword, I’ve an excellent head for planning but a terrible grasp on numbers sadly. I will be of little help there – they turn inside out when I try. I’m good at spotting a problem, and at getting out of a tight spot. I can mine and sing, I’m a fair cook, and I can talk friendly-like to anyone.”
“That last is useful, for I cannot,” Laindawar said. “I am also a warrior, and have been solitary for much of my life. I cannot make small chatter. It is not in my nature.”
“So you stand and look impressive and enigmatic, and I’ll do all the talking,” Jeri laughed. “You should be good at that.”
“Droll,” Laindawar said, dry as the dust all around them. “My weapons are the sword and bow. I have knowledge of statecraft and history and healing herbs. I am a woodsman and tracker, and I can settle beasts and birds of the sky.”
“Is it true that Elves don’t really need to sleep?” Kara said, leaning in with a sort of fascinated worry.
“We are creatures of flesh, just as you are,” Laindawar said. “But we need little sleep in comparison to you.”
“Good thing, for we’ll need Elven vigilance where we’re going,” Jeri said. “Kara?”
She sighed. “I can fight, but not to any great mastery. I only gained my journeyship in the art of dual swords, and I was removed from my place before I could finish. I was taught to be a quiet, obedient ornament, when I was taught anything at all.”
“But you have skills and passions, do you not?” Laindawar prompted her. A strange sympathy was rising in his heart.
She looked up at him, and her huge dark eyes were imploring. “Ashkar was the one who cared… my mother, she. But yes. Ashkar taught me to debate and to speak to the truth in other people. They taught me how to be an orator. I don’t think they meant to,” she added, laughing a little self-deprecatingly. “Not at first. But they did anyway. Couldn’t help it. Ashkar saw all the words trapped inside me and encouraged me to string them together: to turn them into arguments and reason and rhetoric. Ashkar is a historian, a lecturer, as well as a politician, but in their heart of hearts, they’re an academic first and foremost. A teacher. And that was their undoing. All the thinkers have been silenced, just as I was expected to be silent.”
“Well now!” Jeri said, and nudged her gently. “An orator? THAT is a gift worth having. D’you know how rare it is to find a charismatic leader? Believe me. We can get the people interested, sure. But you, Kara – you’re the one who is going to capture their hearts and minds. You’re going to lead them to freedom.”
“All those thinkers,” Laindawar said, “they will have stopped speaking, certainly, for it is not safe. But they will not have stopped thinking. Yours will be the first voice, and others will follow.”
She looked rather lost. “I…I… just want them to be safe. I want us all to be safe, as it once was, as it used to be when grandmother was alive. I want-”
“Looks like you’re the chosen one, sweetheart,” Jeri told her, and gave her forehead a smacking kiss. “Now sleep, you’re gonna need it. I’ll start teaching you some more swordplay in the morning, and the prissy twig here can quiz you some more about being royalty in the Ghomali court, and all that stuff. We’ve got the bare bones of a plan, so let’s not waste the night with more talk.”
“I will sing to the stars,” Laindawar announced abruptly, and at Kara’s torn face he added, “I will not go far. Whatever we must do, Kara, we will help them find safety. I promise you.”
She sighed, and lay down at a safe distance from the fire. “I don’t know if I want to be a Chosen one,” she mumbled as she tugged her blanket up over her shoulders.
“Just a fancy way of saying, ‘here is a dirty, difficult job with lots of pain involved, and a faint glimmer of glory at the end of it’,” Jeri said, yawning. “That’s if you get to the end of it. In my experience, things don’t really end so much as change. Night, all. Nice to be co-conspirators with you. Here’s to another day of trudging through a desert full of bugger-all in the morning.”
Laindawar stood, watching the two Dwarves curl up for a long moment, motionless and patient as only Elves can be. Kara looked astonishingly young as her face relaxed into rest, and Jeri seemed oddly unfinished without their usual glib humour shining in deep brown eyes.
The stars felt very distant as he stepped away, out upon the endless plains of the North. Perhaps forty leagues back West, the Iron Hills dreamed their Iron dreams. Even further West lay Erebor, and south of that, his home. Green and still and ancient, cloaking all in warmth and in the slow soft voices of trees. He could taste the homesickness upon his tongue as clearly as the hardtack and waybread of their evening meal.
No place had ever seemed as unlike his home as this. Red and sparse and parched, it was as different from Eryn Lasgalen as day from night. He missed his home with an ache that he could feel in his teeth. He missed the sounds of his own tongue, the whispers of his beloved trees.
Yet he could not turn away, could not return. Evil still lay plotting in the world, and Sauron had taken too many homes already. Glancing back at the small, stout form of Kara, his resolve hardened.
They were much alike, though he could never have understood that only a handful of months ago. Indeed, he would have poured scorn upon the notion. But there it was: they shared an intense love of homeland and people, a fierce protectiveness, a willingness - nay, an eagerness - to fight. Laindawar’s home was free of shadow now. But hers had been stripped from her, all in one cruel blow.
Yes, a strange sympathy indeed. But he could acknowledge it now.
(Even if she bickered and snapped and grumbled upon every second word.)
Change is the way of the world. We change, or we are left behind. Jeri had been right. Jeri was often right, he was learning. The cheerful, chatty Dwarf might just be one of the most intelligent people he had ever met.
“A young hopeful Queen, and her tactician,” he murmured. “And what does that make you, Laindawar of the Greenwood?”
“A deadly secret weapon in a crown and silly silk robes,” Jeri mumbled. “Shut up and sleep, Highness. We’ve got a long way to go.”
…
It was Nori who shook him awake. “Oi, you lump, wake up,” he hissed. “You gotta come to the Shire. Things are coming to a head.”
Thorin struggled out of the pile of blankets before the fire. All around him, his family slept on. Dís was wrapped in Víli’s arms, and Kíli was sprawled with his head upon her lap. Her hand was laid upon his hair even in sleep.
Even Hrera was bundled in a chair with a rug over her knees, her beard for once not woven intricately and studded with beads, but simply and loosely braided for sleep. None of them had wished to leave now that they were, at long last, all reunited.
“Fili?” he mumbled, his mind still rattling loose in his head. “Is he…”
“Yeah, he snuck out earlier. Said he needed to watch over Frodo, at the very least. Dead on his feet, he is, so I made the call to come get you.” Nori’s eyes were a suggestion of white in the gloom, flicking from side to side. “The Men are beginning to gather now. They’re getting a clue faster than I’d like, frankly.”
“Damn.” Thorin managed to free one arm – Frerin was clinging to him like a limpet – and extricated himself from the warm huddle of Dwarves surrounding his sister. “All right, give me a moment to find my boots. I don’t want to be stumbling over the place in bare feet.”
“Afraid all the Hobbits’ll laugh at ‘em?” Nori said, grinning.
“No, they’re harder, and so all the better for kicking your arse,” Thorin retorted, and he nudged the thief. “Get on with you now, you rascal, and thank you. Go to bed; it’s late.”
“Cheerio, boss.” Nori stood up, silent and quick as a thought, and glanced around at the family sprawled together, a knot of love and safety. “There’s a look. The great and noble line o’ Durin, curled up like a litter of kittens in a basket.”
“Well, we missed her,” Thorin said, feeling mulish.
Nori paused as he reached the door, and his hand rested upon the jamb for a second. “Oh, I get it,” he said softly. “Didn’t used to hope much, but Fíli made me reconsider. What we’ve seen, well, it worked.”
Eyeing him curiously, Thorin wondered where the thief was going with this. “Aye. By the narrowest hair and the very skin of our teeth. But it worked.”
“By the narrowest hope,” Nori corrected, and then grimaced a bit at his own earnestness. “Ugh. Anyway. It made me think, after everything that’s happened... Praps there could a bit more left in the corners of me. So I hope – I hope that you’re happy, my king. Hope you all are. And I hope that my brother is happy with Bifur, an’ that the Hobbits see these bastards off… and that the world is a bit less hungry and frightened now. And I hope that Dori an’ Ori and I might one day er, borrow some of those blankets. Did Hrera make ‘em? That looks bloody cosy, don’t mind saying.”
Thorin’s face softened. “Of course. As long as you don’t steal them.”
Nori nodded, and his wicked grin tugged at his lips. “Me? Would I do that?”
Then he disappeared without another word.
Dori was two hundred and thirty, or thereabouts, Thorin remembered. It would be some time yet before Nori could pinch the blankets.
“That was nice,” murmured Dis, her words blurring together. “When did you make friends with him?”
“Eighty years ago,” Thorin said, and kissed her brow. “Sleep. I’m off to see what is keeping Fíli.”
“Mmm. Good. Bring him back here please,” she said, and turned in Víli’s arms. Between one breath and the next, she fell back into her slumber.
Thorin finally found his boots, one tucked beneath Dáin’s head and one underneath his grandmother’s chair, and pulled them on. Walking through the Halls in the middle of the night seemed to be a habit now, and he barely paid any attention as someone fell in beside him.
“Got a pressing errand?” Bilbo asked, thumbs tucked into his jacket pockets. He looked for all the world as though he were on a casual afternoon stroll.
“Going to the Shire,” Thorin said, yawning. “Your people are about to win a war, I believe.”
“Splendid, I’ll join you,” Bilbo said, and his sharp little chin firmed in anger and determination. “Blasted scoundrels. I want them out of my father’s house, so I do. It’s a million times worse than the blessed auction.”
“You’ll be all right, seeing such things?” Thorin blinked his bleary eyes down at the Hobbit. “It’s your home, after all.”
Bilbo’s eyes grew soft and warm as he returned Thorin’s gaze. “No it isn’t. Not anymore.”
Then he coughed, as though he’d said a little more than he’d meant to. Pasting a businesslike look on his face, his head snapped forward and he began to walk briskly towards the Chamber of Sansukhûl. “Besides,” he said, “I doubt there’s anything in the whole of the Shire that those four cannot deal with. No, I will be fine, Thorin, though it’s good of you to ask.”
“If you’re sure,” Thorin said, and pushed open the great pearl-studded doors.
Only one Dwarf was seated at the poolside: Fíli, his head bobbing to one shoulder and his eyelids pressed and bruised. “Oh, namadul,” Thorin sighed, and he caught the lad’s shoulders before he keeled over. “Come back now. Come on.”
“What in the name of my second-best walking-stick has he been doing to himself?” said Bilbo, worried.
“I should have guessed,” Thorin said to himself, before he looked up at Bilbo, his mouth drawn down. “His mother died tonight. He has been awake too long, and sore and heartsick besides. He should be with the others, with the rest of the family. But Fíli has always been loyal before all, oftentimes to the ruin of his own health. I should have guessed that he would not leave Frodo and his friends, even with Dís finally here at last. He has become very protective of him. Nori did well to come and find me.”
“Doesn’t remind you of anyone at all, does he,” remarked Bilbo.
“He knows better than to be emulating my mistakes,” Thorin said, frustrated, and gently shook Fíli’s shoulders again. “Come along, nidoyel. Come out of the waters now: you need real sleep, and your mother is waiting.”
“Not a peep.” Bilbo crouched down, peering into Fíli’s face. “It’s quite disturbing, the way he doesn’t blink at all as he stares at the water. Do you look like that?”
“I expect we all look like wax statues,” Thorin answered absently. “Fíli? Fíli?”
“Terribly unsettling. Perhaps you have to go in after him,” Bilbo said, pulling at the lobe of one ear and scrunching up his face.
“No time like the present,” Thorin said, and sat down beside Fíli. His nephew’s hand was cold as he took it. “I will see you in the Shire, ghivashel.”
“Race you,” Bilbo said, and vanished.
The starlight took its time to rise in the water upon this occasion, as though the Pool itself could feel the challenge left hanging in the air all around them (and it wanted Thorin to come second). He let out a huff and redoubled his stare, willing the light to swirl faster… faster….
…and he was falling, gathered up as though by a hurricane and flung into the world. He landed on his belly with a grunt, his hands pressed against the ground and his cheek resting upon a hard cobblestone.
“Elegant,” Bilbo commented.
“Impertinent Hobbit,” Thorin managed, pushing himself up onto hands and knees. His hair was scattered all over his vision, but he could make out the blur of torches in the distance. “Ah.”
“Uncle?” Fíli was there, hovering at Sam’s side. “Uncle, it’s the middle of the night!”
“Aye, and I’m here to relieve you,” Thorin said, hoisting himself up onto one knee. “Where are all the Hobbits?”
“They’re setting a trap,” said Fíli, and he pointed to where a grizzled old farmer-Hobbit stood alone, warming his hands over a cheery little fire. “There’s the bait.”
“That’s young Tom Cotton,” Bilbo said, stepping forward. “And this is Bywater, and– my word, I hardly recognise it! It’s all gone!”
“I know, Bilbo, I see it,” said Thorin under his breath. “Fíli, you are exhausted. Go to your family.”
“They’re yours too, you should be there still,” Fíli said, lifting his head and folding his arms. The way he swayed slightly upon his feet took away any power in his words.
“I have at least had some sleep, nidoyel,” said Thorin dryly. “Go. Your mother is missing you.”
Fíli grumbled a bit, his eyes rebellious. “I need to be here. I need to make sure they…”
“I’ll look after them for you,” Thorin said, taking Fíli’s shoulder and squeezing it gently. “You have my word. Fíli, part of being the leader is knowing when to delegate, and your time to do so is now.”
Fíli looked up again, and then sighed. “All right,” he said, and he was yawning even as the light lined his frame and swallowed him up.
“He’s more like me than Kíli,” Thorin said to the air, and let out a sigh of his own. “Even though Kíli resembles me more closely.”
“That’s not such a terrible thing,” murmured Bilbo. “Come along. I want to see the trap close.”
Farmer Cotton was idly picking at a loose thread on one of his gloves when the torches finally neared. A large group of about twenty Men was swaggering into the empty square, and they chuckled as they came. A single Hobbit alone seemed a perfect target for their brand of bullying.
“Cowards,” Thorin grunted. “Where are Merry and Pippin? Where is Frodo?”
“Not sure, but there’s Hobbits closing in behind this lot,” said Bilbo, peering behind the group.
Thorin hadn’t heard a thing. “How many?”
“At least fifty. Some are armed. Oh! There’s Merry!” Bilbo grabbed for Thorin’s arm – as usual, his hands passed straight through. “Blast!”
The sharp pang in his heart was swiftly muffled, and Thorin refocused upon the events unfolding before them. “Merry has been acting as general,” he said, crouching to see behind the ruffians. “He will be the one to watch.”
“I want to see my Frodo-lad,” Bilbo grumbled, his expression still put-out at forgetting their mutual inability to touch.
“Who’re you, and what d’you think you’re doing?” said the leader, a pinch-faced man with a self-important tilt in his chin.
Farmer Cotton gave him a long, level look. “I was just going to ask you that,” he said. “This isn't your country, and you're not wanted.”
“Well, you're wanted anyhow,” said the leader. “We want you. Take him lads! Lockholes for him, and give him something to keep him quiet!”
“Oh, bugger,” said Bilbo.
The Men took one step forward towards the firelight, but then the roar of voices rose all around them. Farmer Cotton watched with a grim little smile on his face as the Men slowly realised that they were completely surrounded.
“At least two hundred!” Thorin said, turning on the spot. “I see billhooks and hoes and saws…”
“There’ll be a weapon in every hand, mark my words,” Bilbo said, pride ringing in his tone. “We’re a staid and sensible people, true enough – but we’re rather good in a pinch.”
“Truer words,” Thorin agreed, and folded his arms in satisfaction as Merry came forward with his sword bright in his hand.
“We have met before,” Merry said to the leader, softly, “and I warned you not to come back here. I warn you again: you are standing in the light and you are covered by archers. If you lay a finger on this farmer, or on anyone else, you will be shot at once. Lay down any weapons that you have!”
“Beautifully done!” Thorin cheered. Bilbo was shaking his head.
“No! No, they won’t back down, you silly sod! Give him the old heave-ho, kick him in the shins! Oh… Oh you Brandybuck whelp, run him out of town right this instant, don’t give him a choice in the matter!”
“You would have spared him too,” Thorin said, without turning around.
“Well… yes. But I wouldn’t have made it into his decision!” Bilbo groaned. “Oh you see? There you are, now it’s all gone to the dogs.”
For the leader did not seem to understand his peril – or at least, he did not understand Hobbits well enough to know his danger. “At 'em lads!” he cried. “Let 'em have it!”
And with these words he made a rush for the circle that enclosed them, striking out with a long knife and a heavy club. He made directly for Merry, aiming a savage blow straight at him.
Merry didn’t move an inch as the leader fell dead with four arrows in him.
That took all the fight from the others. They allowed themselves to be roped together and led away, and all their weapons were taken from them at once.
“Where’ll we put them?” shouted Farmer Cotton, giving the rope a shake.
“Into one of their huts, I say,” came a grumble, and Sam trudged into the firelight. Sting was in his hand, but it was clean of blood. “Now that all that business is cleared up, anybody know where my Gaffer’s got himself?”
“They dug up Bagshot Row, and that was a blow to him. He’s in one of them horrid new houses that the Chief’s Men used to build – back when they was building anything at all,” Cotton said. “Rosie sees to it that he’s fed better than some of the poor old bodies on that Row.”
“Bless her!” Sam said. “That’s a kindness I’ll never forget. But I don’t like the thought of him up there, so close to Bag End and all. There’ll be business with that Sharkey and that Boss before long, and they might do a mischief before the morning.”
“Choose a lad or two and fetch him to my house,” said Cotton. “The other old folks too. That should keep them out of the way of harm.”
“What now?” wondered Bilbo.
“They must press forward while the advantage is theirs,” Thorin said. “They haven’t time to spend standing here in the light!”
“There’s Frodo!” Bilbo said, and he fair danced on his furry feet. “Oh, he looks far better! He’s been eating properly. That’ll be Sam at work again, no doubt.”
“No doubt,” Thorin agreed.
“We’ll camp at Cotton’s,” said Merry, “while we wait for the Tooks. When Pip gets here we will have to make for Bag End at once. I dare say our little trick has already been noticed.”
It had. Even as the small army dispersed, the sound of the horns rising up from Waymeet could be heard ringing over the little hills. “They’ll be here soon,” Merry said, and he gripped the Horn of Rohan in his fist. “Hurry UP, Pippin…”
Frodo settled comfortably enough into Tom Cotton’s battered kitchen, and Merry and Farmer Cotton began talking of how Lotho had brought such a terrible fate upon the Shire. He added little to the conversation, but listened intently as they spoke of Sandyman’s mill, of the exports, and of the Shirriffs.
A moment later, there was a cup of tea sitting by his elbow.
“No milk, I’m afraid, and no lemon,” said Rosie, giving a little bob of her head. “It’s all gone to be ‘shared’ nowadays. But the tea’s hot.”
“Rosie,” Frodo said, his eyes lighting in recognition. “How have you managed through all this? Has Sam seen you?”
“There’s a pair of loaded questions,” she said, and gave him her sweet, shy little smile. “Drink it up now, no good letting it go cold. Yes, Sam came by, and he asked about us too. We’ve been keeping as nicely as we can, thank you.”
“If you can call putting herself in danger twice every day ‘keeping nicely’,” growled Farmer Cotton, his muttonchops bristling to put shame to one of Gloin’s displays. “No matter how I argued or how her mother begged, th’lass kept going back to the Lockholes with her basket on her arm.”
“Hush, Pa,” Rosie said, and she ducked her head at Frodo’s piercing, worried gaze. “No, don’t you look at me like that, Mister Frodo sir. Don’t, please.”
“How are they?” Frodo said, after wetting his lips with his tongue and clearing his throat. “Are they…”
“None killed, though not through any sort of responsible care,” Rosie said, and her eyes were pinned to the tablecloth as though she could scorch it through force of will alone. “Old Lobelia is in a poorly way, bein’ over one hundred in the tale of years… and she’s hurtin’ inside, for that ol’ Pimple’s her son and all. Still, she’s down, but she’s not out. She’ll give any guard a tongue-lashing if they come near. Will Whitfoot’s down to skin and bone now, and he’s gone quiet and grey. Barely talks anymore; you wouldn’t think he was dull old Flourdumpling who could drone on and on for hours. Freddie Bolger’s got some spark left in him, I think, but then he’s younger. He keeps asking about the outside, anyway, which is more than many others do.”
“Rosie,” Frodo said, sad and shocked.
“But you, sir,” she said, and she laid a quick hand over his. “Whatever has happened to you?”
Frodo drew in a quick breath, and looked down at their hands. His four fingers tensed underneath her five. “A lot,” he said at last. “Too much.”
“Oh sir,” she whispered, her expression drawn down into worried, unhappy lines.
“But it’s not yours to concern yourself over,” Frodo said, looking up and giving her a tight-lipped smile. “I hope to be more like Freddie than Whil Whitfoot, but we’ll see.”
“You’re not like either, sir. You’re not like anyone,” she said, low, and gave his hand a quick, firm squeeze before letting it go as fast as hot coals. “Drink that up now, Mister Frodo. It’ll only do you good.”
“As if Rosie would ever stop concerning herself with anything,” muttered Old Cotton, tugging at his whiskers. “As I was saying, Master Merry, there’s naught but Shirriffs between Bywater and Hobbiton nowadays - and we’d not be counting on any cover either, for they’ve torn all the trees out between here and the Mill. We’ve no place to set an ambush, and they’ll be ready for the bait-and-trap trick next time.” Their heads bent together, they began discussing the whys and wherefores of the situation all over again.
Bilbo was quivering slightly at Thorin’s side. “Are you certain you are all right?” Thorin asked him. He’d learned his lesson too well with Frerin: he’d probably drive everyone mad asking after their health, but he’d never assume that his family was unaffected ever again. Best to ask and be annoying.
“Yes,” Bilbo said, though his throat was working quickly. “I’m perfectly all right. But Frodo… he’s better, surely? He is getting better. She could see something, just by looking at him. But I thought he seemed better?”
“He is, as far as it goes,” said Thorin. “Âzyungelê, I fear to say it, but… I think we must face the possibility that he is as healed as he may ever be.”
Bilbo’s face spasmed, before it smoothed out. Then he gave a single, short nod.
“He’s well-loved,” Thorin said, “he has Sam, Merry and Pippin, and as you can see there are others like Rosie who care for him.”
“Quite right,” Bilbo said, though he was wringing his hands. “And he has that Baggins constitution. Yes, he’ll be all right. He’ll be quite all right.”
Thorin forebore to comment.
They were interrupted by Sam, bursting in with his gaffer. The old fellow did not look much older, but he was a little deafer.
“Mr. Baggins!” he said loudly. “Glad indeed I am to see you safe back. But I've a bone to pick with you, in a manner o' speaking, if I may make so bold. You didn't never ought to have a'sold Bag End, as I always said. That's what started all the mischief. And while you're been trapessing in foreign parts, chasing Black Men up mountains from what my Sam says, though what for he don't make clear, they've been and dug up Bagshot Row and ruined my taters!”
Thorin carefully looked away from Bilbo, training his eyes upon the ceiling.
“Oh go on. Laugh, you know you want to,” said Bilbo, resigned.
“I am very sorry, Mr. Gamgee,” said Frodo, carefully polite. “But now I've come back, I'll do my best to make amends.”
“Well, you can't say fairer than that,” said Gaffer Gamgee. “Mr. Frodo Baggins is a real gentlehobbit, I always have said, whatever you may think of some others of the name, begging your pardon.”
“I rather feel I should be taking offense at that,” Bilbo remarked.
“He means Lotho, dearest,” said Thorin.
“I know that, but the family’s going to be taking its lumps from two directions from here in. First Bilbo the mad old baggage, and now greedy, foolish Lotho! No, the respectable Baggins name shall never recover, I think.”
“Twas a Baggins that saved the world,” Thorin reminded him.
Bilbo shrugged. “That’s of less interest to them than the gaffer’s taters, believe you me. They’ll pay attention to that later, I’m sure. But now-”
“And I hope my Sam's behaved hisself and given satisfaction?” the Gaffer was saying, holding his cap in his hands.
“Perfect satisfaction, Mr. Gamgee,” said Frodo. “Indeed, if you will believe it, he's now one of the most famous people in all the lands, and they are making songs about his deeds from here to the Sea and beyond the Great River.”
Sam went purple, but the look he gave Frodo was full of thanks and love. “Look at Rosie!” Bilbo whispered, and Thorin craned to see the lass in the doorway, her eyes shining and her lips parted in a soft, wondering smile.
“It takes a lot o' believing,” said the Gaffer, gruffly, “though I can see he's been mixing in strange company. What's come of his weskit? I don't hold with wearing ironmongery, whether it wears well or no.”
“Not a word about soft silly Hobbits now,” Bilbo said. “Not. one. word.”
“I have nothing but admiration for your people,” said Thorin, perfectly honest. “They needn’t know the workings of war or weaponry to have all my respect.”
Bilbo’s head whipped about and he stared at Thorin. “Well,” he said, and then he let out a shaky little laugh. “You do manage to steal my breath on a regular basis, don’t you?”
Thorin smiled. “As you do for me, Bilbo.”
The night passed, inching along. “Come on, Pippin,” Merry muttered to himself. “Come on, come on, come on…”
Eventually Merry could stand no more, and he grabbed his pack and sword and left into the night. Frodo began to nod into his cup.
“Come along now, Mr Frodo,” whispered Sam, “let’s put our heads down. No good staying awake to worry, and it’ll be a sight better than some of the places we’ve kipped.”
“There’s the sitting room, or you can take my room,” said Rosie, also speaking low. “Jolly might share, too…”
“No, we won’t put you out of your bed,” said Sam, “we’ll bundle up in the sitting room. The old folks can have the beds: they need ‘em more.”
“Oh!” Rosie’s hand flew up before her mouth. “Yes, of course! Your gaffer, Sam, he can have my bed. The others can take Jolly and Nibs’ rooms… I hope we have enough towels.”
“We’ll make do, love, there’s no need to play hostess in times like these,” said Cotton. “Go see that everyone’s got a place, and then we’ll turn in. Where’s Merry put himself?”
“He won’t be back before sunrise,” Frodo said. “He’ll be watching for the ruffians.”
“Come on, Mister Frodo,” said Sam, and he led the other towards the corridor. Thorin and Bilbo followed him, watching as the pair curled up before the fire in their Lothlorien cloaks.
“Do we stay?” Bilbo asked.
Thorin made himself comfortable before the fire, crossing his legs and leaning against a wall. “We stay. Or at least I do. I promised Fíli, and he needs the respite far more than I.”
“I suppose I should too.” Bilbo sat down, and heaved a massive sigh. “It beggars belief, after everything else… that this should be the last of it, and in our soft, peaceful little country too!”
“The last of it to plague the West, at any rate,” said Thorin. “We have learned that the East is sorely troubled by the Cult of Sauron. Gimli and his friends have a rough plan to de-fang them.”
Bilbo smiled up at him. “You don’t even attempt to hide how proud you are anymore.”
“Pointless endeavour,” he said, and snorted, half in amusement at himself and half at the memory of Hrera berating him for trying to deny how much he loved his brave, bold star. “My grandmother is a tyrant, but she is often right – as galling as that is!”
“Oh?” Bilbo leaned his chin upon his hand. “Tell me about her, to pass the time.”
“Not so enamoured of the sounds of Hobbits sleeping?”
“It’s a lot less noisome than the sound of Dwarves sleeping, I’ll thank you.”
The fire was pleasant, and Thorin could almost imagine that they were tucked together in Bag-End-as-it-was, speaking comfortably together after a good meal and a pipe. “There’s a fact. Well then, to my grandmother, Hrera of the Line of Telphor. She is a Broadbeam princess,” he began, folding his hands on his stomach, “her clan have no Halls anymore, not for an Age and more, but they maintained their lines and records in their exile as best they could….”
He spoke on and on, and Bilbo listened eagerly, even as Rosie crept into the sitting room with her blanket upon her arm. She looked between Sam and Frodo, nestled together tightly, and then lay herself down quite close – not touching, but nearby. Her little curly head looked like a dropped dandelion as her hair spilled over the floor.
“That’s a good lass,” Thorin broke off his tale to say. “A kind one.”
“Hmm? Oh, the youngest Cotton. A good family, if a poor one,” Bilbo said, blinking at the abrupt change of topic. “I taught many of the young ones their letters. She has always been a kind lass, if not very learned.”
“We can’t all be scholars and poets, Bilbo,” said Thorin, amused.
“No, some of us have to be preposterously noble Dwarf Kings,” Bilbo said, tossing his head.
“Not such a terrible thing,” Thorin teased back, feeling warmth bloom in his stomach at delivering Bilbo’s own words back to him so neatly.
“Cheeky ones at that,” Bilbo added, sniffing. His nose twitched in that so-familiar way, and Thorin laughed.
“I admit it, and proudly too, for I must confess to pranking my cousins over and again when we were children. Frerin was my right hand, but I was most definitely the ringleader.”
“Really? You?” Bilbo sat up sharply. “Good gracious, that seems unlikely; you’ve always been so dour. But then, I suppose many terrible things had happened to you by the time I met you.”
Thorin braced himself for the old sour surge of sorrow, guilt and anger – and it arrived, right on cue. He had been doing so well, came the disappointed thought, he had been… His hand rose, fingers gripping at the bead twined in the new point of his beard.
“Oh, I am sorry,” Bilbo said then, a soft exhalation. “Thorin, dear one, I am sorry. I should not have said that.”
“It’s all right,” Thorin said, and he shouldered the feeling and the thought away as best he could. There was a tired hollow left in its absence. It was not real: the howling dogs were neglected and angry, that was all. “As I have told you before, Bilbo, I am better than I have been. But like Frodo, I may be as healed as I am ever going to be.”
“And I love you,” Bilbo said, as fierce and huffish as always. “I love you, and I will love you even when you are sad and angry. You have loved me through it all, haven’t you? Well, Master Oakenshield, I may not be stone but I’m as stubborn as you any day of the week.”
“I love you too,” Thorin said, quietly. The dogs lowered their howling to a whine.
Perhaps one day they would be silent forever, but he very much doubted it.
“Tell me more about your family,” Bilbo said, and he scooted closer. “If you want to. Just to while away the hours, not as penance or because I demand it or any silly nonsense like that.”
Thorin blinked, looking up at the homely little ceiling above his head, with its exposed beams and baskets hanging from them. “All right then; it’s a long ways til morning yet. Have I ever spoken of Dís’ husband, Víli?”
“Not to my recollection, I don’t think so.”
“Did you never wonder why she did not come to the throne after me? It is a long tale, and it begins in Ered Luin, in the years of hunger…”
As he spoke, Rosie rolled closer to Frodo and Sam, her hands inching towards them in her sleep.
At last the morning dawned crisp and grey, fog rolling in from the Old Forest and burning away in the sunlight. Thorin blinked and licked his lips, which were rubbery from speaking. Bilbo was nodding slightly at his side.
“Wake up, dearest, it’s day,” he murmured.
“Already? But you were going to tell me about the prank you and Frerin and Dáin pulled on old Fundin back when you were eighteen,” Bilbo mumbled. His hair was flattened upon the side of his head, and the skin of his cheek was folded and marked from the press of his own hand. He looked thoroughly charming to Thorin’s biased eyes, but he restrained the urge to tell him so. “Oh, would you look at that?”
For Rosie had tucked herself neatly beside Frodo, even as she slept, so that she and Sam bracketed him against the chill of the night air.
“She’d be mortified to know she’d done that,” Bilbo remarked. “It’s not the done thing; not mannerly, you understand. Could you do the girl a kindness and rouse her before the others get up? So she can escape and compose herself a little.”
“As you wish.” Thorin stretched his stiff arms and legs, and then walked (rather creakily) over to Rosie and crouched down by her head. “Rosie Cotton, wake! The day is here!”
Her eyelids fluttered, but it was Frodo’s voice that answered with a groan. Perhaps he had grown used to hearing Thorin’s suggestions, much as Gimli had in the beginning, thought Thorin in dismay. “Sam?” Frodo said, the word blurred with sleep. “What time is it?”
“Too early,” grumbled Sam. “Too early to get up an’ fight, anyrates.”
Rosie’s eyes snapped open, and she stiffened in shock and realisation. Then she bolted to her feet, gathering up her blankets in clumsy arms, and tore from the room with her face burning scarlet.
Thorin turned to Bilbo, holding out his hands helplessly, at a complete loss.
“No, that didn’t go so well, did it,” said Bilbo, wincing. He was slapping at his legs to wake them. “Oh dear. I wanted to avoid that.”
It appeared that Thorin had woken them at an opportune moment, however, as Merry came charging back into the house with a great huffing and clatter. “The Tooks are as mad as a beehive knocked off a branch,” he announced. “I’ve just taken a message. They’ve raised all their country, and the word is spreading like wildfire. The ruffians that were watching on Tuckborough have fled off south, those that escaped alive. The Thain has gone after them, to hold off the big gang down that way; he's sending Pippin back here with all the other folk he can spare. They’ll be here any minute.”
“What’s the bad news?” said Frodo, his gaze even and piercing.
Merry grimaced. “There’s a big mob about four miles away. It’s the Waymeet gang, just as we thought, but a great many stray scoundrels have joined up with them. There must be close on a hundred of them now, and they’re torching everything as they come. Curse them!”
“Ugly-minded folks always scorn and destroy those things they can’t take,” said Sam. “We’ll rebuild what’s burned, and better too.”
“But a hundred!” Merry’s jaw clenched. “This lot won’t stop to talk, not even in a trap. They’ll kill if they can.”
“I don’t want any killing,” Frodo said, lifting his eyes. “Not even of the ruffians, if it can be helped.”
“If Tooks don't come sooner, we'd best get behind cover and shoot without arguing,” said Cotton from the door. “There's got to be some fighting before this is settled, Mr. Frodo.”
“My dear Frodo, we shan’t win anything by being sad and shocked,” said Merry, as gently as he could.
Frodo let out a heavy sigh, and nodded as Sam helped him up.
“Knock, knock!” came a cheery voice from the window. “Up and at them, slug-a-beds, we’ve been marching long before dawn! Incidentally, is there anything to eat?”
“Pippin!” Merry cried, and he whirled to see his cousin grinning broadly at him, his arms folded on the window-sill.
“With a hundred Tooks after me,” Pippin said, “we won’t all fit in Farmer Cotton’s house, nor his barn for that matter!”
“You’re not going to try, there’s enough bodies in this house as it is,” said Cotton.
“And you’re not putting my Bill out of the barn!” Sam said firmly.
Merry deflated in relief, his thoughts obviously moving very fast. “A hundred, plus our own,” he said. “That gives me enough sturdy hobbitry to deal with these thugs. No, don’t come in, Pip – we’ll come out.”
“I’m serious about that something to eat,” Pippin said, as Merry bolted out the door. “It’s been a long time since breakfast.”
“Not second breakfast?” said Sam, throwing him a winter apple. Pippin caught it easily in one hand and took a bite.
“Not these days, Sam m’lad! Did you find your Gaffer?”
“That I did, and he’s none too the worse for wear, thankee Mister Pippin. But it’s a hard blow to see our little garden all turned to ugly brick and mortar.”
“It gets worse,” Pippin said, and a dangerous light filled his eyes. He looked entirely a veteran soldier of Gondor in that moment. “The Southfarthing is even more wrecked than we first saw on our way in. It’s not just trees and buildings, either. We’ve been going over-field, and there’s farms lying fallow everywhere. Those that are being sown are done too close; the soil won’t be decent in another two seasons, mark me. I’ll wager that’s what has happened to the rest of the fields. They’re trying to force as much as they can, as fast as they can.”
“Disgusting,” Sam muttered.
“I didn’t understand a word of that,” Thorin said in an aside to Bilbo.
“I’ll be furious for us both, then,” said Bilbo, his ears hot and red. “Over-sowing the fields means that the earth loses too much of its vigour, too quickly. Do it enough times, and it won’t support a crop at all. It means taking too much away, and not giving anything back. It’s a ruinous, greedy way of farming.”
“There’s more and more of those hideous little huts scattered everywhere too,” Pippin said, and he bit into his apple with a little more force. “We flushed a few of those villains out, but more escaped and ran to find their fellows. No doubt they will have all joined with the big group.”
“Come on, I think I have a plan!” Merry shouted to them. “Pippin, I need you! These ruffians are big, but there won’t be a single one that understands warfare at all. We have to work quickly!”
“Come on, Mister Frodo,” said Sam, and he shook out their Elven cloaks. “Back to work!”
“Did you see Rosie just before?” Frodo whispered. “Why did she run off like that?”
“Embarrassed, I suppose,” Sam said after a beat. “Got to say, I am a bit too. I didn’t want her to know that I snore so dreadful loud.”
Frodo smiled. “Oh Sam, you don’t snore at all.”
“Kind of you to say, Mister Frodo, but Gandalf himself told me so, and a Wizard wouldn’t lie to spare my feelings on the matter.”
Merry’s voice could easily be heard from outside. “We need to get to the Bywater Road, as quick as winking,” he was saying. “Where all the hedges are. We’ll line the high banks, and lie low. Sam and Farmer Cotton can get some carts together: we need a barricade to pin them in one place. Let’s go!”
The Tooks let out a great cheer, and Frodo shared a look with Sam.
“Here’s to the end of it, Mister Frodo,” said Sam.
“And here you are again with me,” Frodo half-sighed, and together they left Cotton’s house.
Rosie’s bright head could be seen from the hallway, peering around a doorjamb. Her eyes were wide and huge and worried.
“She’s fond of Sam, isn’t she,” Bilbo said, following Thorin’s gaze to the young hobbit lass. “That’s a fine match, as my father would have said.”
“And you? What do you say?” Thorin raised an eyebrow down at Bilbo, who scrunched his nose.
“Sam most certainly fancies her, but he’s also thoroughly devoted to Frodo. And Rosie herself seems to care for my lad too, but it’s hard to know. Tcch, no, I’ve no idea how it might play out. If I were them, I’d happily set up house all together and let the tongues wag as they might. But there’s a fight to be had first, and so any scandals will have to wait.”
“After all this, I suspect that any scandal will be small indeed,” Thorin said, leaving to follow Sam and Frodo. Bilbo snorted.
“Not to Hobbits, my dear. Gossip is worth more than coin in the Northfarthing, as the old saying goes!”
Merry’s trap worked beautifully. The Waymeet Men stomped into the field, roaring and swearing and threatening as they went, until they were funnelled onto the Bywater Road. There they were met by a barricade of waggons, behind which stood a line of Hobbits all with bows drawn and arrows nocked.
It was at that point that the Men realised that the high bank by the road was also lined with Hobbits, and that three more wagons were being pushed behind them, effectively corralling them together and cutting off any retreat.
“Garn, what’s this!” shouted one, and he kicked at the waggon that blocked his path to escape. “You little rat-folk, what d’you think this is? The Boss is getting angry, you hear me?”
“Oh, we hear you,” came Pippin’s grumble from somewhere above. “Wish we didn’t.”
“Shh.”
“This is a trap,” said Merry, standing up so that his helm and armour could be spied over the hedge – though he made sure that all they could see were his head and shoulders. “Your fellows from Hobbiton walked into one too, and now one is dead and the rest are prisoners. Lay down your weapons! Then go back twenty paces and sit down. Any who try to break out will be shot.”
But these ruffians, more numerous and more desperate, could not now be so easily cowed. Some handful of them obeyed, but the rest let out a roar and set upon them for betrayal at once. Then a score or so charged the wagons, where arrows were loosed upon them. The air was filled with shrieking, and Thorin whirled to see another group pushing at the other end of the road, tipping the waggon there onto its side and clambering over it to freedom.
“Two Hobbits killed!” shouted Sam, and Sting flashed and glittered as fiercely on this gentle soil as it had ever done in Mordor.
“They’re scattering across country!” yelled Pippin. “They won’t get far if they’re going towards Woody End: all that land is alive with our hunters now! There’s nowhere for them to go!”
Merry lowered his dripping sword, and blew a horn-call, and there was an answer from the forest to the south. “There, now they’ve a warning,” he said, satisfied.
“Merry, the bank!” Thorin said sharply.
For some of the Men in their desperation were trying to climb it, trampling Hobbits and their own comrades in their rush. The Hobbits laid about with axes, and the air hissed with their arrows, but some were pulled down. Many of the strongest and most desperate ruffians got out upon the west side, and were more bent upon killing than escape. The line was wavering.
“Pippin!” Merry barked, and he flicked his sword in his hand, blood spattering a line upon the ground. “With me!”
“Gondor and the King!” Pippin cried, and he ran ahead, his own blade held above his head in a mighty two-handed swing. He took out two Men with the first blow, then turned and delivered another swing that sent another Man yelping and scrambling away, clutching at his arm.
“And STAY out!” he shouted after the ruffian, before he sprang after yet another.
“Bullroarer!” Thorin cheered, throwing his fists into the air. “Yes! Now to your right, Pippin. Feint here – yes, now left! Got him!”
“Take that! And that! You beastly vandals, you cowardly vultures, you- you auctioneers, you!” Bilbo shouted, hopping from foot to foot in his excitement.
A hobbit cried out and was down: Bilbo spun on his heel in shock. Then another screamed and lay still. There were renewed shouts of anger amongst the Shirefolk, and then their blows redoubled in savagery.
“I surrender!” hollered one Man, as a sturdy Hobbitwoman came close to splitting him in half in her wrath. “I surrender, please!”
“Goodwife, stay your blade!” Frodo cried, and he stepped in with his hands raised. “I know their crimes are deserving of all your fury, but he has surrendered! We cannot meet surrender with death!”
“Folco is dead!” she wept, and Frodo gathered her up into a fierce embrace, tucking her ravaged face against his shoulder. “He’s dead! These monsters killed him!”
“Oh Goodwife, I am so sorry,” Frodo said, and there were tears in his own eyes. “I am so sorry – but killing this Man will not bring Folco back.”
“Watch Merry,” Bilbo shouted, “he’s fighting the leader!”
Thorin twirled on the spot, searching for the plumed horse-helm. There was Merry, hard-pressed by a great brute of a Man whose weapon was a heavy broad-bladed greatsword. He had the higher ground and was pushing Merry back down the slope, making every use of his longer reach that he could.
“Oh damn,” Thorin whispered, and began to race for the battling pair.
“He’s getting close to the edge of the bank, he’ll fall,” Bilbo said, puffing. “Where are all the archers?”
“This is chaos, it would be too easy for an archer to hit a Hobbit in the confusion,” Thorin replied, ducking through a Man as he was wrestled to the ground by six furious Hobbits. “Merry must have ordered them to cover the edges of his trap…”
“Well, I could hope that they’d show a bit of initiative,” Bilbo fretted.
“Ah!” Thorin made it to where Merry was at last, “Mahal watch over him, he’s losing ground too fast. He needs to get around this lout. Merry, you’ve nothing behind you but air! Get forward!”
Merry was evidently too preoccupied on not being stabbed to really listen, but something must have gotten through, for he rounded to the left and swung his sword around towards the ruffian’s weak side. The Man leaped back to avoid the swing, before he snarled and stabbed down for Merry’s feet.
But Merry knew that trick, and his sword was there to meet the attack. “Yes!” Thorin hissed, and then turned to Bilbo. “Gimli taught him that, in Rohan.”
“Not the time, dear!” Bilbo said, biting at his fingers. “Merry, get away from there, you madcap young rascal, you’re going to…! You’re… going to kick him in the berries and stab him through the neck as he falls… ? Right. Jolly good.” He cleared his throat. “Capital job, well done.”
Merry kicked the body from the ledge and shouted out, “Pippin! Draw back, all! Archers, cover the centre!”
And as quickly and quietly as only Hobbits can contrive, abruptly only the Men were standing where there had been a melee a bare ten seconds earlier. The fighters melted back behind the bristling ring of arrowheads, all nocked and aimed at the remnants of the ruffians.
“There’s a lot of these Men, all dead,” said Bilbo, looking around. “And there’s Hobbits not moving either.”
“More Men than Hobbits,” answered Thorin, and once again the familiar, horrible post-battle silence fell. He breathed it, shouldered it, and forged ahead. “We should find out how the rest have fared.”
Merry dragged off his helm and wiped his forehead. “Let’s lock these idiots up,” he said, and he sounded terribly weary. “Now we need to see to the wounded.”
“My sister,” someone was sobbing, and there were more cries of sadness and fear arising. Bilbo squeezed his eyes shut.
“It’s all right if you need to go,” said Thorin, as softly as he was able.
“I’m staying,” Bilbo said, and he opened his eyes and stared up at Thorin with a touch of defiance. “Just bad memories. The last time I stood at the aftermath of a battle, it was me doing all the weeping.”
Thorin lowered his gaze.
“I’m not weeping now,” Bilbo added, with a little shrug. Then he smiled rather sadly at Thorin’s startled look and began to make his way over to where Cotton and his son Jolly were laying injured Hobbits (and even one or two of the ruffians) onto the waggons. “Keep up, Thorin!” he called behind him.
There were more screams at the edges of the clearing, and a Man was fighting still, eyes wild and mouth open and red with fear and delirium. There was a groaning Hobbit rolling at their feet as they passed. “Nevertheless, I doubt I will ever be ready for this bit,” Bilbo said, watching with a torn and helpless expression.
Thorin sighed and nodded. “It’s never easy,” he said, as the uninjured Men were chained up and led away. “No matter how many battlefields you see. There’s a strange, transparent, faded sort of feeling to it – Dáin is better at describing it than I am – but you never do forget.”
Bilbo squared his shoulders. “Well, no doubt this lot’ll be cleared away in no time,” he said, his chin jutting forward. “That is to say, it had better be, or you’ll be able to hear the complaining in Minas Tirith.”
“Nineteen Hobbits dead,” Cotton was saying in a hushed voice as they neared.
“I had hoped to lose nobody,” Merry said, bitterly. “How many of these scoundrels did we take out?”
“Seventy or so,” Cotton said. “By my best guess. Nothing left now but Bag-End.”
“I’m not going up there until I’ve had more than an apple,” said Pippin. “I’m going to need all my strength, I can feel it. And some of our fellows have been marching through the night only to fight a battle on this end, and they’re not used to it.”
“We should take care of them first,” Frodo said, and he looked up at the churned bank-side and at the hill rising over it. “We should lay them together and write down their names. I don’t want to leave them here, tossed upon a waggon like a bunch of marrows for market.”
“True, and that’s sound thinking,” Cotton said, tugging his chin. “And these ruffians?”
“Sandpit’s not far,” piped up Jolly.
“Perfect,” said Merry, with a savage little grin.
A late midday meal was brought out from the nearby holes, and a meagre spread it was too. Then a hush fell over the gathering. Frodo stood up slowly, and his face spoke of sadness and steely resolve.
“Well, I suppose it is time now that we dealt with the ‘Chief’.”
They organised swiftly, and with few words. An escort of two dozen Hobbits was organised: the strongest and fiercest of the lot. The rest were put to the grisly business of cleaning up after the battle. Thorin watched for a moment as bare little chins set hard in determination, small shoulders stiff and unyielding in their soft cotton shirts, as they bent to the task at hand.
Then, on foot, the four adventurers, Farmer Cotton and their escort, made their way over Bywater and towards the village itself, along the well-beloved, well-known old paths that led to The Hill.
“I feel I might cry, or shout, or do anything at all,” said Pippin, looking about. “It’s all turned to foulness and ugliness and filth!”
“I was wrong. It’s worse, so much worse than I saw in the Lady’s mirror,” Sam whispered, and he gripped Sting’s hilt at his hip. “That mill, now. It looms over you like any tower o’ Mordor.”
“And the River stinks to high heaven,” added Merry.
“All the trees in Bywater are gone,” Bilbo said in a distant tone. “Every last one.”
"Burushruka igbulul e," said Thorin, and wished he could hug the Hobbit close, if only to make him feel less alone.
As they came over the Bridge, Farmer Cotton said, “Now I feel I ought to warn ‘ee, we’re not to the worst of it yet. Bywater wasn’t hit nearly so hard as Hobbiton Town. Brace yourself for the sight, lads, for it’s a terrible one.”
From the height of Bywater Bridge they could see all the way to the old Grange – except it was utterly gone. Not a chestnut remained, no banks or hedgerows, nothing but bogged-down waggons in empty fields churned to mud, surrounded by tarred and tatty sheds. Bagshot Row was a quarry. Bag End could hardly be made out beneath the terrible chimney, belching black fumes into the air.
A suspicion began to dawn in Thorin’s mind. “Were you there at Isengard, my love?” he asked, frowning. “I cannot remember now… but if you were, then this is…”
“Isengard in miniature,” finished Bilbo. His throat bobbed.
As the four travellers stood in utter horror at the sight, there came the sound of a low laugh. By the awful new mill, a grubby hobbit was lounging upon the fence. “Don’t like it, Sam?” he sneered. “'But you always was soft. I thought you'd gone off in one o' them ships you used to prattle about, sailing, sailing. What d'you want to come back for? We've work to do in the Shire now.”
“So I see,” said Sam. “No time for washing, but time for wall-propping. But see here, Ted Sandyman, I've a score to pay in this village, and don't you make it any longer with your jeering, or you'll foot a bill too big for your purse.”
Sandyman spat over the wall: “Pshawww!” he said. “You can't touch me. I'm a friend o' the Boss's. But he'll touch you all right, if I have any more of your mouth.”
“What a charming specimen,” said Pippin, his lip curling.
“Don't waste any more words on the fool, Sam!” said Frodo. “I hope there are not many more hobbits that have become like this. It would be a worse trouble than all the damage the Men have done.”
“You are dirty and insolent, Sandyman,' said Merry. 'And also very much out of your reckoning. We are just going up the Hill to remove your precious Boss. We have dealt with his Men.”
The grimy Hobbit gaped at the dozen strong Hobbits behind Merry, as though he were only now noticing them there. Then he fumbled at his belt for a horn, sounding it with a shaky and unmusical squawk.
“Save your breath!” laughed Merry. “I've a better.”
The silver horn glinted in the light as he raised it, and once more the cry sang out over the hills: Awake! Fear! Fire! Foes! Awake!
Sandyman scrabbled back as Hobbits emerged in a trickle, then a flood, from the dingy little sheds and cramped new houses, all shouting with relief and happiness. The party moved on as a much grander procession, and he stood and stared as they passed, all the while with his mouth gaping foolishly open.
“My garden!” Bilbo said in absolute outrage as they neared Bag End at last. It was covered in piles of refuse, and there were crooked huts and sheds crammed into every last square yard. “Would you just look at my garden!”
“I’m so sorry, dear,” sighed Thorin.
Bilbo fumed, his fists balled at his side. “My tomatoes won prizes, damn it all!”
Pippin looked at his companions, and then he shrugged, before leaning forward and tugging firmly on the bell-pull. No bell sounded inside the hole, and Bilbo’s ears and neck went scarlet with rage.
“My father built this hobbit-hole,” he gritted through his teeth. “For my mother.”
“Try knocking,” suggested Merry, and they all fell to bashing at the door. No answer was forthcoming.
“Either they’ve terrible manners, or nobody is at home,” said Pippin. “Let’s force the door and find out which it is!”
“And I used to get it fresh-painted every spring too, lovely and shiny,” Bilbo mourned. “Now look at it!”
Thorin said nothing. It was, after all, a dreadful thing to walk into your home after it had been made the haunt of monsters.
At length, after some pushing and shoving, they managed to get the door open. A reek blew out of the corridor at them, and more piles of rubbish were stacked in the entrance-hall.
“Right,” said Sam, beetling his brows and rolling up his sleeves. “Let’s find ‘em. They’ve explanations to give.”
But a search turned up no Lotho, nor anybody else inside Bag End – just more rubbish and squalor, as well as plans upon plans for more smoke-belching machines such as Sandyman’s mill. “Where is that miserable Lotho hiding? said Merry in confusion.
“Nothing here but rats and mice,” said Sam. “We’ve been through every room, and the place is as empty as grudging charity.”
“Does the smell count at all?” said Pippin. “It’s certainly got enough body.”
“This is worse than Mordor!” burst Sam, smacking his fist against the wall in frustration. “Much worse in a way. It comes home to you, as they say; because it is home, and you remember it before it was all ruined.”
“Yes, this is Mordor,” said Frodo, thoughtfully, looking up at the cobwebs that smothered the beams above them. Then he cast his too-old eyes over the wreck that had become of his home - the home in which he had been raised from the age of nineteen onwards. His shoulders fell. “Just another one of its works. Saruman was doing its work all the time, even when he thought he was working for himself. And the same with those that Saruman tricked, like Lotho.”
Bilbo shared a quick look with Thorin. “We’re not alone in our suspicions,” he said low.
Merry looked around in disgust and dismay. “Let's get out!” he said. “If I had known all the mischief he had caused, I should have done far more than pilfer his pipeweed and drink his wine.”
“No doubt, no doubt! But you did not, and so I am able to welcome you home,” came a voice from the door. There standing upon the stoop was Saruman himself, looking sleek, clean and self-satisfied. His eyes shone with health and malice.
“Well, there you have it,” said Bilbo, resigned.
Frodo turned to face the Wizard fully, his own eyes flashing. “Sharkey,” he said, grim and flat.
Saruman laughed. “So you have heard the name, have you? All my people used to call me that in Isengard, I believe. A sign of affection, possibly. But evidently you did not expect to see me here.”
“I did not,' said Frodo. 'But I might have guessed.”
“You made me laugh, you hobbit-lordlings, riding along with all those great people so secure and so pleased with your little selves,” Saruman said, sneering. The cruel tilt of his lips had become even more pronounced: all faint resemblance to Gandalf had been burned away. “You thought you had done very well out of it all, and could now just amble back and have a nice quiet time in the country. Saruman's home could be all wrecked, and he could be turned out, but no one could touch yours. Oh no! Gandalf would look after your affairs.”
“And yet, Gandalf is not here, and we have settled matters ourselves and without his aid,” said Frodo calmly. “Instead you must deal with us.”
Saruman laughed again. “O yes, when his tools have done their task he drops them. What trusting, naïve fools you are! Such idiots deserve setting-to-rights, and so I came ahead even as you talked and dawdled and bumbled along. Call my actions your wake-up call, if you will, or perhaps an instruction into how the world truly operates. It would have been a sharper lesson, if only you had given me a little more time and more Men. Still I have already done much that you will find it hard to mend or undo in your lives. And it will be pleasant to think of that and set it against my injuries.”
“Well, if that is what you find pleasure in,” said Frodo, “I pity you. It will be a pleasure of memory only, I fear. Go at once and never return!”
“He’s letting him go?” Bilbo cried, and he was echoed by the Hobbits of the village who had come crowding up to the door of Bag End.
“He can’t be let go!” they muttered angrily, “he’s a villain and a murderer, the worst of the lot! Kill him!”
Thorin tipped his head and regarded Saruman, who appeared perfectly at ease as he flipped a hand at their hostile faces. “Kill him!” he mocked. “Oh, you think there are enough of you, do you? You think that when I lost my goods I lost my powers? Whoever strikes me shall be accursed. And if my blood stains the Shire, it shall wither and never again be healed!”
The crowd recoiled, and even the sturdy Hobbits of Cotton’s Bywater escort quailed somewhat.
“Saruman,” said Thorin, and though he had pitched his voice soft and low, he sounded quite loud in the sudden fearful hush of the village.
The black eyes met his.
“Saruman,” Thorin repeated quietly, “you are a liar. Your staff is broken. I was there and I saw it break. I watched it happen. You have no colour, and were thrown from the Order.”
It was so tightly controlled as to be nearly imperceptible… and yet, the Wizard flinched as though receiving a hidden blow to the core of him.
Frodo drew himself up, and his voice was clear and strong when he spoke: “Do not believe him! He has lost all power, save his voice that can still daunt you and deceive you, if you let it. But I will not have him slain. It is useless to meet revenge with revenge: it will heal nothing. Go, Saruman, by the speediest way!”
“Frodo heard you,” said Bilbo in relief.
“Apparently so,” Thorin said, still holding Saruman’s gaze. “And Frodo was not the only one. Do as the Ringbearer bade you and go, Wizard. You and your lies are not welcome here. Go hence and find a better life than vengeance and bitterness.”
Saruman snarled wordlessly, but nevertheless he raised his voice. “Worm! Worm!”
Out of a nearby hut came Wormtongue, crawling upon his belly like a frightened and cowed dog. He was lank and thin, and his eyes were dreadful to see.
“To the road again, Worm!” spat Saruman. “These fine princes and lordlings are turning us adrift again. Come along!”
“He just about made the word princes sound like profanity,” said Bilbo. “I rather think that was aimed at you, dear.”
Thorin smiled. “I sincerely hope it was.”
The wretched pair turned away, and the village began to breathe easier. But as Saruman passed close to Frodo, a blade shone in his hand and he stabbed down swiftly. It was turned aside on the mithril coat with a skittering sound.
“Oh glory,” gasped Bilbo. “Is he all right, is he all right? Thorin, I swear on the hair on my toes, that coat is the greatest gift I ever received, for it has saved his life over and again. Oh, that scoundrel, that murderous scoundrel! He can’t even leave with a pinch of grace and dignity; he has to try even fouler methods of vengeance?”
“Some folk have veins in them that prove too treacherous to mine,” murmured Thorin, even as Pippin propped Frodo back up and Merry drew his sword with fury in his face. Sam was faster and had thrown Saruman to the ground, Sting bright in his hand and his breath heaving.
“No, Sam!” Frodo croaked, rubbing his chest and gulping for breath. “Do not kill him even now. For he has not hurt me. And in any case I do not wish him to be slain in this evil mood. He was great once, of a noble kind that we should not dare to raise our hands against. He is fallen, and his cure is beyond us; but I would still spare him, in the hope that he may find it.”
Saruman rose to his feet slowly, all the while staring at Frodo. The look in his black eyes was terrible to behold: understanding, and hatred, and wonder all intermingled. “You have grown, Halfling,” he grated. “Yes, you have grown very much. You are wise, and cruel. You have robbed my revenge of sweetness, and now I must go hence in bitterness, in debt to your mercy. I hate it and you! Well, I go and I will trouble you no more. But do not expect me to wish you health and long life. You will have neither. But that is not my doing. I merely foretell.”
“Did you foretell this, you disgusting, wicked old-” and Bilbo made an obscene gesture at the Wizard’s back.
As Saruman passed, all the assembled Hobbits tightened their hands around their weapons. They said nothing, but their expressions spoke volumes. Behind Saruman, Wormtongue hesitated for a moment, his face torn. Then he scampered after his master with a whimper.
“Wormtongue!” called Frodo. “You need not follow him. I know of no evil you have done to me. You can have rest and food here for a while, until you are stronger and can go your own ways.”
Merry looked politely incredulous at this. “Um, Frodo, I know you didn’t spend all that much time in Rohan… but…”
“I must try,” Frodo muttered. “Wormtongue, your answer?”
The Man, thin and lank and desperate, halted. A wild hope appeared in his eyes, and he leaned a little towards them as though towards the possibility of escape.
Then Saruman laughed, and all at once Wormtongue’s shoulders curled in on themselves like a beaten cur. “No evil?” jeered Saruman. “Oh no! Even when he sneaks out at night it is only to look at the stars. But did I hear someone ask where poor Lotho is hiding? You know, don't you, Worm? Will you tell them?”
Wormtongue cringed and cowered beneath his uplifted arms, the very image of abject hopelessness. “No, no!”
“Then I will,” said Saruman. “Worm killed your Chief, poor little fellow, your nice little Boss. Didn't you, Worm? Stabbed him in his sleep, I believe. Buried him, I hope; though Worm has been very hungry lately. No, Worm is not really nice. You had better leave him to me.”
Wormtongue’s head jerked up. His eyes were red and deranged. “You told me to; you made me do it!”
Saruman laughed again, low and cruel. “You do what Sharkey says, always, don't you, Worm? Well, now he says: follow!”
He gave a final contemptuous sneer, and kicked Wormtongue in the face as he grovelled, sending the Man sprawling. Then Saruman spun on his heel, robes casting out, and made to leave. But at that instant something in the air changed; Wormtongue growled, standing sharply with his back hunched. Something glittered with deadly intent in his hand. Snarling like a dog, he sprang onto Saruman’s back, and with a fistful of white hair he jerked his head back to expose the long, pale throat and slit it with his dagger.
With a yell he let the corpse fall and ran, stumbling and sobbing and snarling, down the lane, lurching between two legs and all fours. The Hobbits shouted in shock; bows twanged. Before Frodo could shout or Thorin could even think to speak, Wormtongue fell dead with four arrows in him.
“Mahal have mercy,” Thorin said, stunned. It had happened in the blink of an eye, from the kick to messy, gruesome death. “That. That did not…”
“He reminded me a bit of Gollum there,” managed Bilbo through a tight throat. He was blotch-faced and trembling. “Wormtongue, I mean.”
“Probably why Frodo wished to save him,” agreed Thorin, and closed his eyes. A base and wretched end to a despicable and twisted little Man. “I think you must be a good influence upon me, dearest one. For even knowing as I do the wickedness he has wrought and the sorrows he has brought upon Eowyn and Theoden, I do feel pity for him.”
“Mm.” Bilbo nodded at Saruman’s body where it lay. “However, that one I have no pity for in the slightest.”
“A Wizard should know better,” said Pippin, softly to himself.
“Barum,” Merry added, and folded his arms.
As they watched in the shocked aftermath, a grey mist gathered over the corpse of Saruman, rising into a column like smoke from a fire. It soon appeared as a pale shrouded figure many times larger than the great chimney, and loomed over the Hill. For a moment it wavered, looking to the West; but out of the West came a cold wind, and it bent away, and with a sigh dissolved into nothing.
“Oh, that is not righ’ at all!” exclaimed Cotton, and Thorin turned back to see the body shrivelling as though the work of thousands of years of desiccation were revealed in seconds. It shrank and the skin became nothing more than rags upon a hideous skull. Frodo picked up a corner of the cloak and threw it over the face, and the crowd appeared to start breathing again at last.
“And that's the end of that,” said Sam. “A nasty end, and I wish I needn't have seen it; but it's a good riddance.”
“Bless you Sam, and may the hair on your toes never fall out,” muttered Thorin, still rather shaken.
“And the very last end of the War, I hope,” said Merry.
“I hope so,” said Frodo and sighed. “The very last stroke. But to think that it should fall here, at the very door of Bag End! Among all my hopes and fears at least I never expected that.”
“I shan't call it the end, till we've cleared up the mess,” said Sam gloomily. 'And that'll take a lot of time and work.”
“If I weren’t incorporeal,” Bilbo announced to all and nobody, “I’d be investigating just how much of my cellar is left. I think we could all use a stiff drink.”
Thorin scrubbed at his eyes and tried to erase the dreadful sight of Saruman’s corpse from his memory. “You did always have the best ideas,” he muttered. “A drink, and then I’m going back to bed. That was… not pleasant, and I am glad it is finally done and that I have seen it through. Durin’s beard, but I am relieved that Fíli missed it!”
“Shoo, sleepy head,” Bilbo said. “I’ll see you in the morning.”
“I’ll drink your share and be sure to snore extra loud,” Thorin promised him, and pressed a kiss to the air over Bilbo’s cheek. “In the morning, then.”
...
TBC
