Work Text:
They’d only invited him to have a good laugh at his expense. Bilbo knew this.
He had no delusions about his place in the Shire, or what it had become since he’d returned from his adventure. Eccentricity was tolerable only up to a point. Many did not forgive him his temerity, least of all the Sackville-Bagginses, who would have inherited Bag-End had he died out there in the Wild.
Things had changed. He had been respectable, once. Now the neighbours whispered, the vendors stared, the children made up rhymes about him. Bilbo knew all this, and he didn’t care.
Join us for Elevenses, Bilbo old boy, Otho had said with that sour smile of his. Really, I insist. Not traditionally a meal to be shared, but it was to make up for the mix-up with the silverware; or so Lobelia had assured him. He’d accepted the invitation.
Perhaps it was out of spite. They half-expected him not to show up, and he could already imagine the looks on their faces when he did. Perhaps it really was for the silverware—he could snatch his spoons and forks back as they served the oat pudding. Or perhaps, in some twisted way, he wanted their jeers and sneers. Anything but the silence of his empty rooms.
Whatever it was, Bilbo walked into the Sackville-Bagginses’ parlour that morning wearing his dwarven shawl wrapped around his shoulders, and pretended not to hear Lobelia’s gasp of disapprobation. There were other guests: Bruno Bracegirdle and his companion, as well as the Grubbs, making Bilbo the only bachelor. Otho and Lobelia smirked to each other. Sit, dear cousin, sit. He sat at the table with them, their son Lotho staring open-mouthed at the Durin family crest pinned to Bilbo’s shawl.
Autumn had swept over the Shire like a swarm of locusts, leaving bare tree branches and brown dead foliage in its wake. Bilbo stared out the window as honey cakes were placed on the table. His mind was perpetually distracted these days. He knew he was only partly back in the Shire—he’d left something of himself under the mountain.
The meal progressed. Mrs Grubb was talking about crochet and doilies. Apples were being served. “Lotho, darling, don’t stare,” Lobelia said. Tea, fresh baked bread, more apples. Bruno Bracegirdle complimented his brother-in-law on the excellent honey cakes. Lotho was still staring.
Then it started to rain, and someone complained about the gloom. Otho stood, clapping his hands once. “Let us have music!” he exclaimed. “That’ll brighten up the room!”
The Grubbs played their flutes, Bruno borrowed Lobelia’s mandolin, and she chose the fiddle. Young Lotho played the pipes as Otho clapped cheerfully to the familiar tune. Thunder rumbled in the distance.
Bilbo’s sorrow swelled monstrously in his chest, as if to swallow him whole. This was the way it always happened, every day since the Battle: suddenly, swiftly, without warning. He would be working at his desk or sitting on the bench in the garden; he would be washing dishes or mending clothes, reading or cooking—and then the weight of missing them would overwhelm him, all at once. It was like a chain of his own making, binding him to the pain. He carried it with him throughout his days, stumbling over it in the mornings, letting it rub and chafe his insides. He would see their faces behind his closed eyes, and he would keep them somewhere in his memory, safe and sound, it’s all over now, it’s all over.
The music did not stop—it would stop for nothing, for no one. Bruno struck a loud chord, Otho cheered, and Mr Grubb laughed through his flute. That was Bilbo’s life now; the agonising realisation that everything went on, on and on and on, even when his world had collapsed. That was the way of things. On and on and on.
What was it Thorin had said? He had said so much, he had said so little. The sound of his voice was still strong in Bilbo’s ears, but how long would that last? He’d bled right through his coat. There, on the snow, the red stains. Hush, Bilbo thought, comforting the image of Thorin, comforting himself, it’s over now, it’s all over.
He stood up, his body bursting with nervous energy. The taste of sorrow. Iron and earth, like blood on his tongue, blood on the snow. The music did not stop. Lifting his arms into the air, Bilbo took a step away from the table. Lotho stopped playing, but the others continued. Bilbo raised one leg and twirled, making his shawl float around him. Again, another twirl, and again. Otho Sackville-Baggins cheered some more, snickering and nudging his wife as they watched Bilbo dance. He didn’t care, he didn’t care. He closed his eyes. His pain drifted in the current of his dancing like a barrel upon a running river.
Somewhere under the mountain, the last of Durin’s sons were resting, still and cold. Bilbo recalled the sound their voices made from a distance, the deep rumble of anger or the bright clatter of joy. He recalled the color of their eyes, the warmth of their palms, the laughter lines. He knew the raw edges of their pain—now more than ever, he knew them.
He danced to the flutes and fiddle, to the wild plucking of the mandolin, to the clapping and the giggling. He bumped into a chair, sending the other hobbits into fits of laughter. Still he danced, chin tilted upwards, eyes squeezed shut.
Thorin’s ice-blue gaze, the shadow of eagles upon his face. His broken body, shivering under Bilbo’s palm. Red stains on the white snow. Thorin hadn’t fought it, he hadn’t even tried—and how could Bilbo forgive him for that? How could he ever forgive him? Too much to say, too little. The breath that rattled in Thorin’s chest. Bilbo hadn’t known how to tell him, how to let him know… there is an emptiness in me that holds your shape. It was all over now. How could he ever forgive himself?
It was raining outside. The Sackville-Bagginses would mock him, and the neighbours would whisper, and the vendors would stare, and the children would call him Mad Baggins.
But Bilbo would keep dancing with his eyes closed.
