Actions

Work Header

Old Friends

Chapter 13: Time will tell

Notes:

Fun fact—this is more or less the first scene I ever wrote for this story. It was one of two very clear ideas I had, and while it has been updated slightly, large portions remain as it was before I had a clear arc. Hope you enjoy it ... and don't hate me too much.

Chapter Text

To no one’s surprise, spring came late that year. The warming sun made the roads through the Shire slushy, and people often spoke in low, grumbling voices beyond the kitchen windows. The first buds peeked out from the hedgerows, and a few brave crocuses colored the garden in soft violet and gold. A chill that had nothing to do with the weather had settled over Bag End by the time the snow receded. Spring was near, but Bilbo felt no warmth in it.

Though he spent almost every moment in Thorin’s company, the chasm between what they ought to say to one another and what they did say seemed to grow each day. Bilbo often caught Thorin observing him. A strange, pensive stare that Bilbo did not dare to meet, even though he felt the weight of those eyes burning his skin. Perhaps Thorin too could feel the shadow that seemed to loom before them.

The letter arrived in the early hours of a chilly morning. The lad handed it over with a grin as he rambled about it coming by way of Bree for Hobbiton’s resident dwarf. He departed as quickly as he had arrived, seemingly not noticing the way Bilbo had gone stiff and still.

Thorin opened it by the fire, his expression unreadable. Bilbo watched the kitchen counter, his hands stilling on the loaf of bread he had been slicing.

When Thorin finally spoke, his voice was low. “It’s from Dis.”

Bilbo nodded slowly. “Bad news?”

“She asks me to return. There’s unrest. The miners clashed over claims, and council tensions are rising. Dwalin cannot settle them on his own, and she…” Thorin trailed off, his mouth tightening. “She needs me.”

The words hung between them like smoke.

Bilbo set down the knife, wiping his hands on his apron. “When will you leave?”

“Tomorrow,” Thorin said. “At first light.”

A long silence followed.

Bilbo busied himself with preparing supper, though he doubted either of them would eat much. Thorin remained by the fire, silent and still. Neither reached for the other.

That night, they did not speak of partings. They sat quietly, as they had for so many evenings before, drinking tea that had long gone cold. When the fire burned low, Bilbo walked Thorin to the guest room, pausing outside the door.

“I’ll pack you a parcel for the road,” Bilbo said. “There’s still some of that blackberry jam you liked.”

“Thank you.” Thorin hesitated. “Bilbo…”

Bilbo shook his head and reached out and laid a hand over Thorin’s heart, just briefly. “Goodnight, Thorin.” 

He had almost reached his own bedroom door when the heavy fall of Thorin’s approaching steps made Bilbo turn in surprise.

“Thorin, what?” Bilbo began, even as Thorin gripped his arm tightly, forcing the hobbit to face him fully.

“No,” Thorin growled as he crowded Bilbo back against his bedroom door.

The words struck like a hammer blow. Bilbo’s breath caught; his hand went instinctively to the knob at his back, as if he could retreat into the safety of solitude. Yet Thorin’s presence loomed, solid and immovable, his hand still wrapped firmly around Bilbo’s arm.

“Thorin—”

“Do not say goodnight to me as though we are strangers in a hall,” Thorin said, voice rough with anger, or perhaps grief. “Do not look through me as though I have become naught but a guest at your table. We are not—" He broke off, jaw tight, searching Bilbo’s face. “We are not nothing .”

Bilbo’s throat worked. His heart thundered so loudly he thought it must surely echo through the hole. “I never said we were nothing.”

“You act as if we are.” Thorin’s hand slid down Bilbo’s arm until their fingers brushed, desperate, almost pleading. “Day after day you draw away. You smile and speak of gardens and weather and jam, and all the while I feel you slipping. I will not go into exile from you, Bilbo Baggins, not while I yet live.”

Bilbo closed his eyes against the rawness in Thorin’s tone. His resolve, so carefully tended these past weeks, trembled. This is what you feared. This is what must end.

“You are a king,” Bilbo whispered. “A king cannot tie himself to a hobbit’s hearth. You belong to your people. To your sister. To Erebor. Not here. Not with me.”

“ I belong to you ,” Thorin said fiercely. His forehead lowered until it nearly touched Bilbo’s, his breath warm against Bilbo’s lips. “Do you not see it? You are in my every thought. I would weather every storm, every crown, every burden if it meant you were at my side.”

The door was cool against Bilbo’s back; Thorin’s heat pressed against his front. He could not escape either way. He wished desperately that he wanted to.

“It would break us both,” Bilbo managed. His voice wavered. “You cannot belong to me, Thorin. You belong to them—to your people, your family. You said as much yourself. Better to end it here, while there is still—”

“Still what?” Thorin’s eyes burned. “Still some pretense of indifference? Still the lie that we are merely friends? Tell me to my face, Bilbo, that you do not love me, and I will go from this room and never trouble you again.”

The silence that followed was agony. Bilbo’s lips parted, but no words came. His hands, traitorous things, fisted in the wool of Thorin’s tunic. His chest ached with all the things he could not speak.

Thorin’s gaze softened, though his grip did not. “I cannot leave with this chasm between us. If you would cast me from your heart, say so now.” His voice dropped, rough and tender all at once. 

For one wild heartbeat, Bilbo let himself imagine it: the warmth of Thorin’s lips, the weight of him pressed close, a night stolen against all reason. His fingers clenched tighter in Thorin’s tunic, betraying him. But then the vision cracked, replaced by the truth he could not outrun: Thorin would go, and Bilbo would be left behind, clutching only the memory.

He forced his hands to fall away.

“You are not mine to claim,” Bilbo said softly. His voice trembled, but he did not falter. “Not now. Not ever.”

Thorin flinched as though struck. His grip slackened, and he stepped back a pace, the distance between them a chasm that yawned wider with every heartbeat. His chest rose and fell unevenly, his gaze searching Bilbo’s face as if he might find some crack, some mercy, in those steady eyes.

“You lie,” Thorin whispered. “You lie, and it wounds us both.”

Bilbo’s hands twisted in the fabric of his nightshirt. He dared not look up. “Perhaps it does. But better one clean wound now than a thousand slow ones later.”

For a long moment, the only sound was the low crackle of the dying fire. Thorin’s shadow fell across Bilbo’s door, great and dark and trembling.

At last, Thorin drew himself up, shoulders rigid. The longing still burned in his face, but it was caged now, locked behind the iron bars of his pride. “So be it,” he said, his voice hollow. “If that is the choice you make.”

He turned, his cloak swirling behind him, and walked back down the passage. His footfalls were heavy at first, then faded into silence.

Bilbo remained at his door, fingers still pressed white against the wood where Thorin had pinned him. Only when the last echo of steps was gone did he let himself sink against it, chest shuddering, throat thick with unshed tears.


The closer they drew to the Lonely Mountain, the more Thorin seemed to disappear.

At first, Bilbo thought it was exhaustion. They had left Lake-town just after sunrise, the cold biting at their cloaks and the wind howling in from the lake like a living thing. The company rode in silence more often than not, the anticipation pressing on them like a stone. But soon, Bilbo noticed it wasn’t just weariness. The desolation of Smaug lay like a thick mist all about the lands. The earth beneath the hobbit's feet was still. It was unlike the sickness of Mirkwood; there it had tasted of spoiled fruit and poisoned herbs. This place tasted of nothing but ash. Even so, it was obvious that Thorin, more than any other, felt it.

Thorin rode ahead more often than with the others. He no longer spoke unless spoken to. His eyes, once bright with purpose, had gone hard and distant, fixed always on the looming peak ahead as though it might vanish if he dared to look away.

He barely looked at Bilbo at all.

The mountain had first appeared as a dark smudge on the horizon—an indistinct shape that might have been a cloud or a cliff. Now, it loomed over everything. Each morning, it seemed closer, more solid, and more terrible. The others felt it too. Even Dwalin had grown quiet, his usual gruffness tempered with wariness.

One evening, as they made camp among the broken stones of an old watchtower, Bilbo approached Thorin where he stood apart, gazing toward the mountain with his back to the fire. He’d done this each night since leaving Lake-town—alone in the cold, as if keeping vigil. The companies' evening watches had resumed as soon as they left the city, and yet Thorin stood each night separate and still.

“Thorin,” Bilbo said quietly.

The dwarf didn’t move.

“Thorin,” he repeated, stepping closer. “You haven’t eaten. There’s still stew, if you’d—”

“I am not hungry,” came the curt reply.

Bilbo hesitated. “You’ve barely spoken since we left. I know this must be weighing on you, but—”

"I do not trust this stillness. The men may think the beast dead; some even of the company hope it to be so, but I do not believe it. I will not believe it till I see his corpse."

"We will see him dead, Thorin. If time has not taken him, we will find a way."

"If—" Thorin muttered bitterly.

"Thorin," Bilbo began, unsure what comfort he could possibly offer in the face of so much hope and grief.

"Take your rest, Master Baggins," Thorin continued. His attention was back on the mountain looming before them. Searching ceaselessly for some spark that might indicate the dragon was alive within.

"You need not watch alone," Bilbo told him softly. "I will stay beside you."

Thorin’s jaw tensed. His eyes, in the moonlight, looked almost silver. "You made it clear long ago that is not something you wished from me."

The sharp intake of Bilbo's breath was too loud in the quiet of the night. Thorin's eyes were still on the distance, but the dwarf had gone stiff.

"I didn't mean…Thorin," Bilbo said weakly.

"I would prefer solitude," Thorin continued in the same voice he had often used with the Master in Lake Town. "Good night."

“If you say so, your majesty,” he whispered.

He turned and walked back toward the fire, the warmth of it doing little to thaw the cold now rooted in his bones.

Behind him, Thorin did not follow.