Work Text:
Bilbo gingerly climbed up his hill to the very top. While he looked well preserved, as many of his neighbours had taken to calling him, he was still old. And the weariness of all these years were starting to gain on him. Below his feet, under the crest of the hill his smial was burrowed in, the cosy warm and welcoming smial that all hobbits had. Though of course, he felt, and he was not alone in that feeling (for example, Lobilia Sackville-Baggins happened to agree), that his smial was by far the most superior smial there was in all of Hobbiton.
While the inside was nice and curved in shape, the furniture was of excellent quality and taste, and the garden was also excellent. There was a wonderful selection of flowers, roses, of course, but also poppies and honeysuckles. In the back there was a vegetable garden that fed him. Not the largest but enough to be suitable for a bachelor. Of course that garden also had his prize winning tomatoes. He still won most years in his category, and that still gave him a lot of pride. And also irked Lobilia, another passion of his.
While many of the hobbits would have sighed in longing at the showy flowers or the bountiful vegetable patch, Bilbo himself felt that the best part of his garden was a large oak tree planted right at the top of the highest crest of his hill.
About sixty years previous, just after Bilbo had gotten home from his adventure, but before he had gone around all the Shire trying to get his auctioned off items back, Bilbo had made the same climb up the hill (but with younger bones) and planted an acorn. He had thought about building a bench when the tree got a little bigger, but he didn’t want to encourage anyone else to sit there.
It was his spot.
That being said, these old bones were a lot harder to move now, and he sometimes regretted not getting a nice stone bench. He sat on the ground beneath the tree and closed his eyes. It’s tall branches were giving shade and protecting him from the heat that sometimes creeped in during the summer, or the worst of the rain in the fall. Thinking back on the quest was not painful any more, it was a balm to comfort him now, on lonely nights and calm days. Remembering Thorin and company, the only place he really felt at home, despite the dangers and strangeness and adventuring.
Even to this day, he remembered what Thorin looked like, his bright blue eyes that always seemed to see right through Bilbo and all his hobbit-y proprietary.
His long hair that Bilbo always wanted to tangle his fingers through.
His blue coat with wolf fur collar, that he let Bilbo borrow when he was cold. He remembered sniffing that collar and getting Thorin’s scent stuck in his nose.
His cold metal armour biting against Bilbo’s naked chest.
When he was younger he worried that Thorin’s face would be lost to his memory, but it never faded, as though kept in his mind by magic.
One time, Bilbo had tried to put charcoal to paper and draw Thorin’s likeness to prevent it from fading from his mind. But after several failed attempts he decided that words were his strength when it came to describing. He could always paint a picture with his mind using a description.
That was how There and Back Again: A Hobbit’s Tale , started. He did not want to forget any of his family or their adventure. But especially, he wanted to remember Thorin.
On cool evenings like this, Bilbo could almost imagine Thorin sitting with him under the tree, his arm wrapped protectively around him to keep the worst of the chill off, both of them smoking a pipe together.
Perhaps Thorin would open up his own smith, and come back warm and sweaty, after a day of hard work. After he washed himself they could walk together up the hill. Bilbo would listen avidly as Thorin retold all he had done in the day. Thorin probably would have been annoyed at how hobbits conduct business but eventually gotten used to it. Bilbo would have loved to hear him complain about it. He would laugh at his silly dwarf and then Bilbo would tell him about the progress on his novel or how it was with the tenant farmers. Thorin would probably laugh at Bilbo and call him too kind if he gave a tenant an extension on rent. But he knew that Thorin would have done the same in his place. Then they would have gone in together and had supper.
A simple life that they could share.
Bilbo took his pipe out then, and started to prepare it, taking out his knife to ream his pipe. He let the scrapes of ash float away in the breeze before he took out his new leaf and filled it carefully. The motions were practiced and careful. The leaf Bilbo had taken with him was special, a much harsher strain from the Erid Luin. It reminded him of Thorin. On the adventure, the surly dwarf king had shared some of his own personal stash when Bilbo had run out, not having packed enough in his haste to catch the party before the left the borders of the Shire.
Thorin had laughed at him when he coughed on his first taste of it. Bilbo’s ears had turned red in embarrassment as though he was some youngling who had never smoked before. The dwarf had apologized for laughing at him before planting a kiss right on his lips in apology.
When Thorin had first let Bilbo borrow the wolf fur mantle, the smell had caught Bilbo off guard, but it just smelt so Thorin . Sword oil, something like smoke or burning (as though Thorin could not quite wash off the hard work from the smith), harsh pipe weed and then something softer. His beard oil scented with something light, like jasmine or sandals wood and his soap was citrus. Subtle enough that you could only smell it by shoving your nose into it. Not that Bilbo would ever admit to doing that.
The leaf was the only scent Bilbo had left.
The hobbit had not particularly enjoyed the leaf, but it always reminded him of Thorin. Bilbo took the first drag and then leaned back his head resting against the rough bark of the tree.
“Do you know what day it is my dear?” he asked as though to no one in particular, “the day before my one hundredth and eleventh birthday. Why would you know though. When we were together I forgot to mention it entirely. We were in the dungeon in Mirkwood. We were so miserable.” Bilbo laughed at that last comment. Truly they were so miserable stuck in that dungeon, not knowing if they would ever get out. But in some ways Bilbo wished for those crazy and chaotic days.
For those who knew, it was apparent that the person Bilbo was speaking to was his lost lover, Thorin Oakenshield, second of his name, son of Thráin son of Thrór, leader of the Longbeard Clan, Descendant of Durin the Deathless and Ruler of Erebor for about one miserable week. In the break between his thoughts, Bilbo took another drag on his pipe. Sitting on the hill talking to Thorin had become a sort of tradition. About once a month, he would come up the hill and update Thorin about his life. One time he even brought Frodo up the hill.
He told the young tweenager all about his adventure and Thorin. He even explained how he got the acorn that grew the tree. In some ways he felt like it was a good way to introduce Thorin to Frodo. Though he never ‘spoke’ to Thorin in front of anyone. It was really just a silly fancy of his to speak to his lost lover. His neighbours already thought him mad, and there was no harm in adding to their speculation.
“Now let me think, we were in the dungeon during August and September, but when did we leave? You know I think it was before my birthday. Yes, that's right. We had just reached Laketown and I didn’t mention it as I was struck with quite the bad cold. I was worried you were going to leave me behind, even after everything. Well the feast the Men planned for us was just as good as a birthday party, though I suppose I was not able to give any gifts. I would have liked to have given you at least one flower crown.”
He took another drag on his pipe and closed his eyes and let his mind wander for a second. The plans for his party were starting to take a toll on him.
“I have quite the surprise planned for tomorrow you know,” Bilbo took another drag before continuing, “Everyone is going to be there, I even got gifts from Erebor to mark the occasion. Bofur and Bifur are still making those wonderful mechanical toys. I ordered some of his birds. The faunts love them. He even made a flower with petals that move! Quite remarkable. If I didn’t know it was wood, I would think it was real.”
You know, I plan to disappear. Leave the Shire that night. My bag will be all packed up, but don’t worry I planned it this time. I have Sting and the mail you gave me. I know what to pack. I am quite the adventuring hobbit now.”
He paused then, not quite ready to reveal all his plans, even to Thorin.
“I’m going to go to Rivendell first. I know, I know. You do not approve. But I would like to see Elrond and the valley once more. For, you see, I don’t think I will be able to make the journey back. And it will be a good place to rest. After that I will try to join a caravan south to the gap of Rohan. And yes, I know that will add more to my journey. But these old bones can barely make it up this hill. I don’t want to imagine how they will fare in the Misty Mountains. And I did not fare so well the first time, if you remember.”
He took another puff on his pipe and twirled it between his fingers distracting himself from saying the next part.
“I just- I want to see you one more time. You know Bofur wrote to me once, and explained the plans for your and the boys’ tomb. You were to be buried with that blasted stone, and yes I know it was very important to your people and I am not trying to belittle that but Balin did warn me. Anyway, there were also supposed to be statues depicting your life. Bofur said the company managed to convince them to add me to one. Apparently we are together on it. I like that. That in at least one place we are together forever.” He stopped then, realizing how melodeon his thoughts got. “Very grand tomb, but you were very grand. It’s fitting. I just want to see you one more time, my dear, just once more.”
He kept explaining to Thorin all his plans for the party and the journey and smoking his pipe. Bilbo had time to finish up his discussion, and Frodo knew not to bother him when he was under his tree.

Thorin felt as though he woke from a long deep sleep. He always felt that way here. As though it was his first time waking in the afterlife.
Here of course, was Mando’s Halls; specifically, the area Mahal had negotiation with Mando for the dwarves. It was a pleasant place to spend the afterlife. There were sections for each family, large, grand and cavernous to house all the descendants. Private rooms liked the walls all the way up, and as new people joined new doors formed and the cavern just got higher and higher. At the center there was a meeting hall, to sit and talk to whoever was there. In other parts there were guild halls for every profession a dwarf could have. Thorin was partial to spending time in the blacksmith’s guild. There were other spaces too. Caves with minerals whose natural beauty anyone could enjoy, or dining rooms so large you could not see one end.
At this point, there were very few of Thorin’s companions that had joined him. His sister had joined several years ago, Ori and Balin were just starting to make themselves at home. They only waited for Dwalin now.
And they were certainly happy to still be waiting for him.
Loved ones joining you in the afterlife was always bitter sweet. On the one hand you wish them no suffering and want them to have a long and happy life. On the other hand you are finally united.
Ones uniting was also always beautiful to see. Thorin remembered when his sister joined them and she was finally together again with Víli. There were tears, but mostly there were hugs and laughter. Her husband embraced her and Thorin and the boys watched with smiles as they embraced. Then the house of Durin organized a large feast to celebrate.
It was only later at night that Thorin had finally let his own grief take over, in the privacy of his room. The reuniting of Ones was especially hard for him. There were few like him in Mando’s Halls, those whose One was not a dwarf. They knew how to recognize each other after a little while. Those who never seemed to have more people join them but always looked wistful when Ones reunited.
You must understand, while many of the free races of Middle Earth ended up in Mando’s Halls, dwarves were kept separate. While you might have a One from the other races, you would only have your life together. You would never be able to share an afterlife.
Thorin was one such poor soul, forever doomed to be alone in the afterlife, his heart no longer beating but still longing for his One.
His One was a simple hobbit, while he might look like a simple grocer, there was steel under the surface and kindness and beauty.
Unlike the others here, whose Ones were of the other races, Thorin was not even able to share a life with Bilbo. Only a few short cold months.
He knew he would never be able to see his hobbit again, his Bilbo.
And at the same time he knew that hobbits were not like dwarves.
They did not have Ones, they . . . . remarried.
Thorin both wished Bilbo would never find another and yet at the same time, hoped that he would not be alone.
Some days he cursed Bilbo and himself for never being able to be together, knowing that Bilbo might have betrayed his love and found another. Other days he hoped that Bilbo found some comfort with another and was never alone. And still on other days, Thorin wondered if Bilbo was in a similar situation to Thorin. Forever waiting to be with his love but never able to reunite.
True to Thorin’s memory.
Did Bilbo remember the way Thorin held Bilbo as they fell asleep?
Did he remember the feeling of Thorin’s lips?
Did he remember the feeling of being close to the one you love.
Thorin knew he still did. That the memory would never fade.
And so Thorin woke from a deep sleep, the sleep of the dead.
He readied himself for the day and went about his normal morning routine. When he entered the main hall and sat to eat breakfast, a dwarf approached him.
Thorin recognized him as one of the others whose soul was destined for another part of the Halls.
“Good morning, Hanar,” Thorin greeted him, “How are you today.”
Hanar was a very nervous type. In life he was a potter making very delicate fine china. His fingers were able to sculpt delicate shapes and paint intricate patterns. They looked immeasurably fragile but were strong as steel. Thorin always wondered if that is why he was so nervous: waiting for someone to knock over his art.
“H- Hello, Thorin,” he responded softly, “I am well. A- and you?”
“Also well . . . . Can I help you with something?”
“I was asked- that is, it was my turn to speak to you, the next one. What I mean is-” Thorin watched as he struggled to find the words.
“Why do you not sit down for a second and take a breath, start over and speak again,” Thorin suggested.
Hanar took Thorin’s advice and sat again.
“I am sorry, Thorin. I just, this is very important.”
“Of course my friend, what can I help you with?”
“It is not so much that I need your help, but that I want to help you. Or we want to help you,” he finished, which only left Thorin with more questions.”
“Who is we?”
Hanar looked a little surprised for a second, “We, you know others like us!”
Thorin didn’t want to imagine it was about his One, he couldn’t, so Hanar continued, “Dwarves whose One is not a dwarf.”
All at once, anything that he imagined was at the forefront of his mind, but at the same time he felt defensive. Other dwarves, even his sister, had not been so supportive when he had told her that his One was not a dwarf. What if Thorin had been wrong about this dwarf.
“What do you mean?” his voice was devoid of emotion, not wanting to hope, and not wanting the worse to happen.
“After some time, if it becomes clear that a dwarf will not have their one join them, we try to help. Since we will never be united with our Ones we are allowed to see them one more time, to say goodbye. If they are still living, you can see them but they cannot see you. If they are already in the falls then you can speak to them,” Hanar explained.
Thorin nodded, he was still cautious but he could feel hope blooming that he could not stop, “And who allows us this generous offer?"
“The maker’s wife, Yavannah, Kaminzabdûna! When the first dwarf came here, she saw his distress and in her mercy granted him one last visit. he had loved a man and was unable to say goodbye before he passed. He had been away working as a merchant and when he came home his one had already passed.”
Thorin was stunned silent. The hope he had been trying to squash down suddenly came to full force. He would do anything to see his love one more time to hear about his day and what he did when he came home, back to the Shire after his adventure.
“How? What price must I pay . . . .” Thorin started, knowing he would pay any price to see him again, to see his Bilbo.
“Price? No, Yavannah asks no price, she only wishes you peace once you have passed on.”
“When may I see him again?” Thorin asked.
“Tonight, when you sleep, you will dream of him, but it will not be a dream, you will be with him. But remember if he has not passed, he will be able to hear you.”
“Yes yes of course,” Thorin said, almost too excited to respond before whispering to himself, “tonight,” with reverence.
Hanar patted him on the shoulder and then left Thorin to contemplate the gift he had been given.
He went through the rest of the day as if in a haze.
Would Bilbo be in Mando’s halls, would they be able to speak? Thorin tried to do the math and wondered how long hobbits lived. He thought, if time had passed the way he thought it did, that Bilbo would be over 100 years old, which seemed to be rather a lot for a hobbit. Though it was possible he was still alive, Thorin remembered a story about Bilbo’s grandfather being well into his hundreds before he died.
In some ways, Thorin hoped Bilbo was still alive.
What would he say, I am sorry for trying to kill you and not being as careful as I could have been?
I should have cherished you more, noticed your strengths from the beginning?
If Bilbo was still alive, he could see the Smial again, Baggend. A place where Bilbo truly belonged. Thorin still had fond memories from the one night he was there. The room was a true home, as if just being a visitor he could sense the happy memories the flooded the halls and rooms.
In the evening, having shooed off his sister's concert, “Brother you are behaving more erratically than necessary, what is it with you,” Thorin made his way to his room and bed. He sat heavily on the feather bed for a second thinking about his time with Bilbo with a heavy heart.
Would Bilbo still welcome him or would he never want to see him again after all he had done.
Thorin could not blame Bilbo if the latter was true.
He closed his eyes and could feel the excitement, he wondered how he would ever fall asleep. . . .
. . . . And then suddenly, he was at Baggend. Thorin recognized the hill, it was some time in the afternoon he thought.
Bilbo was still alive then.
Thorin looked around hoping to see his hobbit, when he noticed his hands. They looked like a painting leached of all its colour, there was a slight halo around him. He was a ghost!
Reaching for the gate his hand just went through. How fascinating , he thought.
The door opened and a familiar, if slightly older looking Bilbo was suddenly there.
He looked much distinguished in his old age, a fine waist coat and jacket on, and of course shoeless as he had ever been on their journey. Bilbo’s hair had greyed in the intervening years and he had wrinkles but it was the same green eyes Thorin remembered.
“Bilbo!” Thorin tried to greet him, but Bilbo did not seem to hear and just kept walking.
And that is when Haran’s words came back to him.
If they are still living, you can see them but they cannot see you
Thorin would not be able to communicate with Thorin at all. He would just be able to see and hear his beloved.
His eyes tracked as Bilbo started to climb up the hill and Thorin decided to follow him. He could not resist being so close to his beloved.
He watched as Bilbo carefully sat under the tree, an oak tree he realized. Thorin wondered if it was planted from the acorn Bilbo had stolen from Beorn.
Bilbo started to prepare his pipe. He watched as Bilbo’s delicate hands cleaned the pipe and prepared it for smoking. Then he lit the pipe, and the aroma wafted toward Thorin.
The scent was so familiar!
Thorin was taken right back to one of the nights at Beorn’s, when they first arrived and his paranoia from being around the overly tall baer man was taking off.
Bilbo had started to complain about not having and pipe weed left and then of course wondering if Beorn might have some to share. All the dwarves had looked around wondering if he was seriously going to ask a bear man for pipe weed, when Thorin finally had given him some.
The hobbit had coughed when he first tried it. Thorin thought he had been adorable but tried to tamper it down, his ears had even turned red, right to their point.
Now it seemed Bilbo was much more familiar with it, he did not cough and sputter, instead he closed his eyes and sighed like he was enjoying it.
Then he spoke.
“Do you know what day it is my dear?” Bilbo’s voice, like his face, had aged, and at those words, Thorin looked around wondering if Bilbo was speaking to someone else. But there was no one, just Thorin.
“The day before my one hundredth and eleventh birthday. Why would you know though. When we were together I forgot to mention it entirely. We were in the dungeon in Mirkwood. We were so miserable.” Bilbo laughed at the end, as though their misery was funny, but at the same time he looked so wistful.
Thorin realized, hearing those works, that Bilbo had never forgotten him and was talking to him.
His unbeaten heart felt so full of joy in that moment. Bilbo still held him in his memory, even telling him about his life. A smile broke across his face without warning.
“Now let me think, we were in the dungeon during August and September, but when did we leave? You know I think it was before my birthday. Yes, that's right. We had just reached Laketown and I didn’t mention it as I was struck with quite the bad cold. I was worried you were going to leave me behind, even after everything. Well the feast the Men planned for us was just as good as a birthday party, though I suppose I was not able to give any gifts. I would have liked to have given you at least one flower crown.”
Thorin listened, sitting on the ground next to Bilbo, wondering, hoping and wishing, if the hobbit could sense him somehow but knowing that was not possible. He had always loved how Bilbo lit up when telling a story, and if anything the years had only added to that.
“I have quite the surprise planned for tomorrow you know,” Throin watched him take a drag from the pipe before continuing and he wondered how often Bilbo came to speak to the dead king, “Everyone is going to be there, I even got gifts from Erebor to mark the occasion. Bofur and Bifur are still making those wonderful mechanical toys. I ordered some of his birds. The faunts love them. He even made a flower with petals that move! Quite remarkable. If I didn’t know it was wood, I would think it was real.”
He listened as Bilbo explained about the party and what went into the planning. He was a little surprised to hear that the host would be providing the gifts, but then, the most shocking thing of all happened.
“You know, I plan to disappear. Leave the Shire that night. My bag will be all packed up, but don’t worry I planned it this time. I have Sting and the mail you gave me. I know what to pack. I am quite the adventuring hobbit now.”
Bilbo was leaving the Shire, away from this place he seemed to belong to. But that was not all. He kept the courting gift Thorin had given him in his madness. It was . . . . romantic. But even that did not seem to be a strong enough word to describe what Thorin was feeling. Even in his madness, Bilbo knew how much he meant to Thorin and now Thorin knew how much Thorin meant to Bilbo. Why else would one keep a courting gift despite the events that happened after.
“I’m going to go to Rivendell first,” the dwarf scowled at that, but started laughing as Bilbo correctly predicted his response, “I know, I know. You do not approve. But I would like to see Elrond and the valley once more. For, you see, I don’t think I will be able to make the journey back. And it will be a good place to rest. After that I will try to join a caravan south to the gap of Rohan. And yes, I know that will add more to my journey. But these old bones can barely make it up this hill. I don’t want to imagine how they will fare in the Misty Mountains. And I did not fare so well the first time, if you remember.”
Thorin did remember and nodded with him. Not taking the Misty Mountain at his age was a smart idea. He was not prepared for the turn in the conversation.
“I just- I want to see you one more time. You know Bofur wrote to me once, and explained the plans for your and the boys’ tomb. You were to be buried with that blasted stone, and yes I know it was very important to your people and I am not trying to belittle that but Balin did warn me. Anyway, there were also supposed to be statues depicting your life. Bofur said the company managed to convince them to add me to one. Apparently we are together on it. I like that. That in at least one place we are together forever.” He stopped then, realizing how melodeon his thoughts got. “Very grand tomb, but you were very grand. It’s fitting. I just want to see you one more time, my dear, just once more.”
Thorin finally spoke, not that Bilbo could hear but he still wanted to answer, “I would have you buried with me, so at least here we could be together forever. If there was any way for my wish to become truth I would do it, madtubirzulê (my golden heart).”
He gently moved onto his knees and reached out a hand to touch Bilbo’s face. It felt a little wet to him as if Bilbo was crying. He tried to wipe them away only to realize, that like the fence he was unable to move material things.
“Madtubirzulê (my golden heart), I still love you so. Forever. I hope you know that. I will never forget you in the afterlife.”
Once he finished, Thorin sat back down and listened to Bilbo speak, about his plans to leave and the party. Who he thought would be the most upset and who would not be.
Thorin laughed with him, and cried with him.
When it was time to go back he woke as he always did, as if from a long deep sleep.
