Work Text:
“Dwalin!” A familiar voice, one Dwalin is certain belongs to Thorin, calls out. He quickly whips his head toward the sound, but sees no one. He blinks in confusion. Must be the exhaustion; maybe he’s hearing things. Dwalin sighs and turns away, but then hears it again. “Dwalin!”
“All right, I need to see Óin,” Dwalin mutters to himself.
Then, the voice, Thorin’s again, speaks near him, though he sees no one. “Bilbo, can you stop this magic?” There’s a soft, frightened whimper in response. “It’s all right. We’re safe here. Dwalin and I will protect you.”
Silence follows, and Dwalin begins to consider walking away to find a healer. But before he can move, both Thorin and Bilbo suddenly shimmer into view right in front of him. Bilbo looks pale and shaken, clinging tightly to Thorin, who stands tense and furious.
“Your Highness! Bilbo! What in the—how did you—what happ—?”
“No time to explain,” Thorin interrupts. “Einkil and his men are in the garden. Capture them all. Quickly. Let none escape. I’m taking Bilbo to Óin… or perhaps Bombur’s.”
It only takes a second for Dwalin to understand what Thorin means. The incident. The assassin.
Dwalin’s confusion vanishes, replaced by steely resolve. “Aye. I’ll get Nori and the others. They won’t escape.”
“Thorin…” Bilbo’s meek voice draws Thorin’s attention, and he gently guides the hobbit away from the garden while Dwalin marches off to rally the guards. There’s no need for Bilbo to see or hear what’s about to happen.
“Shh, ghivashel. Focus on me,” Thorin murmurs, holding Bilbo close as they walk. “Just take deep breaths. You were incredible back there, Bilbo. You saved us both…”
He tightens his hold protectively as they pass armed guards heading toward the garden.
“Would you like to see Óin,” he asks softly, “or should we get something to eat?”
Bilbo doesn’t answer at first. Then, in a small voice, he says, “I’d like something savory… but I don’t want to go out right now. Can we stay in your room?”
“Yes, we can stay in my room,” Thorin assures him. “I’ll send Roäc to ask Bombur if he can prepare something warm for us. I’m sure he’ll be happy to cook.”
With that, Thorin leads his hobbit away from danger, toward the safety and comfort of his room.
Once inside the room, Thorin cuddles Bilbo close, hoping to help his hobbit relax. Time passes and slowly, the tension eases from Bilbo’s body, but he stiffens again when there’s a sudden knock at the door. His panic subsides quickly, though, when Bofur’s cheerful voice calls out, “Bilbo! Thorin! You in there? I got a delivery for you two!”
Thorin rises from the bed and opens the door to find Bofur holding a tray with two large steaming bowls of venison and wild mushroom stew, simmered in lake trout stock and forest herbs.
“Heard what’s going on from Roäc. You two doing all right?” Bofur asks.
“Bilbo’s still a bit shaken, but he’s recovering. Thank you, Bofur, for the quick delivery,” Thorin says, accepting the tray. “Stay safe out there.”
“Will do!” Bofur replies brightly, then calls into the room, “Hey Bilbo! Wanna go out for dinner later with me, Bombur, and Bifur?”
“Huh? Oh, um, sure…” Bilbo answers, a little caught off guard by the sudden invitation.
“See you there! Thorin, you’re welcome to join us too,” Bofur adds.
Thorin nods with a small smile. He knows Bofur is doing this intentionally, giving Bilbo a distraction for the evening while Thorin questions Einkil and his men to make sure every conspirator is accounted for. It’s a thoughtful gesture, and one Thorin silently appreciates.
“Thank you. I’ll try to join you, but I might be late,” Thorin replies.
“No worries! I’ll pick you up soon, Bilbo. That all right?” Bofur grins.
Bilbo nods. “Oh, um, sure. Can I invite my parents?”
“Absolutely! The more, the merrier!” Bofur waves before heading off down the hall.
Thorin closes the door and returns to Bilbo with the tray. Together, they sit and eat. Thorin listens as Bilbo animatedly compliments Bombur’s cooking, speculates about the type of mushroom used in the stew, and chatters with familiar warmth. Asking for food, Thorin realizes, was the right decision to help ground him.
With a full stomach and Thorin’s steady presence beside him, Bilbo eventually curls up and drifts into peaceful sleep. Thorin holds him close, silently vowing to protect him no matter what.
His thoughts drift to Einkil and his men. What punishment is just? Should their families suffer for their treachery as well? He frowns, remembering Eldeth’s warning, the one he tragically dismissed. There are likely innocents caught in this web.
He sighs and presses a soft kiss to Bilbo’s forehead, whispering a quiet prayer that, with the conspirators captured, his hobbit is finally safe.
Thankfully, Dwalin and Nori manage to capture every last conspirator, including Einkil. Thorin takes charge of the questioning, but he does not do it alone, Thrór and Thráin join him, both to offer counsel and to keep him grounded in case his emotions spiral. It is well known among dwarrow that Durins are fiercely protective of their Ones, more so than most, and rage in defense of a beloved can burn hotter than dragonfire.
Though Bilbo has shown to lack fear for Thorin's willingness for violence, Thorin still does not want his hobbit to see the darker side of him, not if he can help it. So, to shield Bilbo from the interrogation, he sends him and his parents to Bofur’s home for the evening.
Bomfur and Genna, the lashshar of Bofur and Bombur, greet the hobbits warmly at the door.
“You must be Bilbo! And these must be your lashshar! Welcome!” Bomfur grins, ushering them inside with wide arms. He shares Bombur’s copper hair and beard but bears more of Bofur’s softer features, revealing the balance of both his dashat.
“Thank you for inviting us!” Bungo says with a kind smile as they step inside. “Your sons and nephew have been nothing but wonderful to us.”
“Oh, you have such a lovely home,” Belladonna adds, eyes scanning the space. It’s simple compared to the grandeur of Erebor’s castle, as expected from those not born to nobility, but it’s cozy, warm, and lived in. And to a hobbit, that’s more than enough for a house to feel like a true home.
“And dinner smells amazing!” Bilbo says with a delighted sniff, catching hints of roasting meat and rich herbs.
“Bombur was so excited for this. He outdid himself, truly, you’ll see!” Genna beams with pride. She has Bofur’s dark hair and gentle smile, with Bombur’s round frame. Together, both lashshar radiate the same jolly energy that clearly runs in the family. She leads them into the dining room, where Bofur, Bombur, and Bifur are already seated and waiting with eager smiles.
Dinner is a feast: grilled mountain goat seasoned with rosemary, golden potatoes roasted to perfection, and a tart spiced berry compote. On the side, there’s lakefish broth and fresh-baked wild mushroom bread. The flavors are earthy, savory, and hearty, just the kind of meal that warms both belly and heart. Conversation flows freely, laughter rings out, and the troubles of the day seem to fade into the background.
As the last bites disappear, the room begins to settle into a slower rhythm. Genna turns to Bilbo with gentle eyes. “I must thank you, Bilbo, for giving my dashat such joy. He and I always shared a love for cooking, but knitting was my Craft. I worried when he told us he wanted to pursue cooking, that others might mock him for it. But now, because of you, he proudly calls it his Craft.”
Bomfur nods, voice tinged with guilt. “I was the one who feared most for him. I tried to push him down other paths, not because I didn’t believe in him, but because I didn’t want him to be hurt. I forced him to try different Crafts, hoping to protect him… but in doing so, I realize now I only made him feel unwelcome in his own home.” He gently takes Bombur’s hand. “Thank you, Bilbo, for giving him the acceptance I failed to offer.”
For once, Bilbo finds himself speechless. He often brushes off compliments, but this quiet gratitude, this raw honesty, it lodges in his throat and refuses to be waved away.
Bombur blinks rapidly, his eyes misting. “Amad, thank you for never giving up on me. Adad, I know you were trying to protect me. I don’t blame you. I love you both. Thank you for raising me.”
Emotion swells around the table as Bombur’s family embraces, tears and laughter mingling in equal measure.
Then, suddenly, Bofur throws his arms wide and shouts, “Join in on the hug!” before grabbing the hobbits and pulling them into the embrace.
It is, to say the least, a wonderful dinner. Warm, heartfelt, healing. And for a little while, surrounded by food, laughter, and the love of good people, Bilbo forgets all about the shadows that linger back in the castle.
Meanwhile, back in the depths of Erebor’s dungeon, Thorin is once again held back—this time for what feels like the fifth time tonight, by his adad Thráin and sigin’adad Thrór. Each time one of the traitors dares to open their mouth, all that spills out is venom aimed at Bilbo. And with every slur, every insult, Thorin’s fury rises until it nearly boils over. Were it not for the strength of his father and grandfather anchoring him, he would have struck them down already.
“He’s a slut! A harlot!”
“He doesn’t belong in the mountain!”
“You’ve been seduced! Let us kill him!”
Their words are poison, and they repeat them like a chant, pushing all three Durins to the edge. Thrór’s jaw tightens, Thráin mutters prayers under his breath to Mahal, and Thorin, the one who is most affected, has his eyes blazing, is trembling with suppressed rage. But despite the endless torrent of bigotry and bile, they offer no actual information. Nothing of value. Even with Nori brought in to extract answers, progress is nonexistent.
“If you don’t talk,” Nori hisses, “your body will never be found.”
“Eat shit,” one dwarf spits back, grinning with bloodied teeth.
It’s a dead end, until Dwalin enters the room and quietly leans in to whisper something to Nori. The rogue’s eyes widen.
“Wait, seriously? Bungo said that?”
“Aye,” Dwalin replies, both impressed and vaguely unnerved. “Apparently, when he found out what was happening, he gave us some… creative threats. Said they might be more effective.”
Intrigued, Nori clears his throat and returns to the prisoner with a new approach.
“If you don’t start talking,” he begins calmly, “your family will never stop receiving pieces of you.”
The dwarf squints, confused. “... Pardon?”
Nori steps closer, voice dropping to a chilling whisper. “I mean it. We’ll keep you alive. But every week, every single week, we’ll send your kin a part of you. First, a lock of your beard. Once that’s gone, we move to your head hair. Then your fingernails. Your toenails. Your teeth. And when those are gone…” he leans in, smile thin and terrifying, “we’ll start on your eyes.”
The color drains from the traitor’s face. He goes pale, then green, and finally cracks.
“I’LL TALK!”
As the prisoner starts to babble out names, details, and meeting places, Nori straightens up and looks over at the Durin royals.
“We have to hire Bungo.”
The response is immediate and unanimous.
“No,” all three Durins reply in unison.
Even so, none of them can deny it, Bungo Baggins may be a gentle hobbit, but when it comes to protecting his son… he’s terrifying.
The new threats begin to break down the resolve of the captured conspirators, piece by terrifying piece. Bungo's creatively vicious warnings, delivered through Nori with theatrical glee, are disturbingly effective. One by one, the traitors start to confess. But when they get to the ringleader, Einkil himself, their momentum slams into a wall.
Einkil doesn't flinch. Doesn't break. His eyes burn with silent fury, fixed on the Durin royals and their interrogators. Not even the most gruesome of Bungo’s threats, which Nori now calls "the Took method," seem to move him.
That is, until Nori shifts tactics.
He remembers something crucial: Einkil, like Glóin, treasures his nadan, his nâtha, above all else. His love for Eldeth is well known, obsessive even. And Nori is more than willing to exploit it.
“He won’t talk,” Nori announces casually. “Go get his nâtha, Eldeth. Maybe she’ll be more cooperative.”
The reaction is immediate.
“DO NOT TOUCH HER!” Einkil’s voice thunders through the dungeon, his composure shattering like cracked stone.
Nori smirks, knowing he’s struck gold. “We won’t lay a finger on her… if you start talking.”
Einkil glares, jaw clenched tight. Silence stretches, then finally cracks. Words spill from his mouth, slow at first, then faster, as if he can’t stop them. Names, meeting places, codes, schemes. All of it. Nori documents every word.
But what surprises them most is what comes after the practical details, when Thorin demands to know why.
Einkil’s voice drops. It’s no longer defiant. It’s bitter, weary.
“I did it for my nâtha,” he mutters. “Ever since my yasthûna left us… I was broken. I loved her, but I was not her One. And when she found him, she left. Just like that. I never recovered.”
He looks up at them, pain twisting his face.
“I didn’t want that for Eldeth. I didn’t want her to be vulnerable. To be… soft. I wanted her to be strong. Independent. Better than me. So I gave her everything I could, education, weapons training, political guidance. I even arranged what I believed was the best match: Prince Thorin. A future queen.”
His gaze sharpens, hate bleeding back in.
“But when she was finally ready to take what she earned, that halfling came and stole everything from her. Everything she worked for!”
Silence follows. A heavy one.
Everyone in the chamber knows of Einkil’s downward spiral after his yasthûna left. Her departure, sudden and irreversible after finding her true One, had shattered something vital in him. Since then, he’s been a shadow of the noble he once was. Broken. Cold. And deeply bitter toward love and those bound by it.
They also know how fiercely he clings to Eldeth. She is the last living remnant of the dwarrowdam he lost. She is his pride, his obsession, his attempt at redemption, and the only thing keeping him sane.
Thrór and Thráin exchange glances. As bonded lashshar with naddan of their own, they understand, at least a little, the fear of losing something so deeply loved. Their expressions are grim, but not surprised.
But Thorin does not share their patience.
To Thorin, Einkil’s words are poison. He paints Bilbo as a thief, a usurper, when all Bilbo ever did was exist. Eldeth is still among the most respected nobles in Erebor. Yes, she had that embarrassing incident at the food eating competition, but so what? Every dwarven noble has had a scandal or two. Getting walloped in a public contest is practically a rite of passage.
To Thorin, this isn’t about Eldeth’s future.
It’s about hatred. Pride. Control.
And worst of all, it’s aimed at Bilbo.
Before anyone can stop him, Thorin lunges, only for Thrór and Thráin to intercept him again, pulling him back with practiced ease.
“Let me go!” Thorin growls, straining against them.
“No,” Thráin says firmly. “Not yet.”
“You’ll get your chance,” Thrór adds, voice low. “But not while you're blinded by rage.”
Thorin breathes hard, eyes burning. His fists tremble.
Because no matter what Einkil claims, his grief, his intentions, his broken heart, his love for Eldeth, none of it justifies the attempt on Bilbo’s life.
And Thorin Oakenshield will never forgive that.
By the time Bilbo and his parents return to the castle, the interrogations are over. The three Durin royals, Thorin, Thráin, and Thrór, have already given the orders to hunt down the remaining conspirators still at large. With the palace guards now quietly mobilized and the worst of the chaos behind them, the castle feels calm again, eerily normal, as if nothing ever happened.
“Do you want to wait for Thorin in our room tonight, Bilbo?” Belladonna asks gently, brushing imaginary dust from her son’s shoulder.
“I wonder if they used those lines…” Bungo murmurs beside her, half to himself, eyes gleaming with curiosity. “I should ask how they reacted…”
“Oh, I’ll be sleeping in Thorin’s room tonight, Mama,” Bilbo replies, then turns to his father, eyebrow raised. “And what lines?”
“Hmm? Oh, nothing important. Just playing with some dialogue ideas for my next piece,” Bungo says airily, waving a hand to dismiss the question.
Belladonna smiles and leans in to kiss Bilbo’s cheek. “If you need anything, don’t hesitate to wake us. Good night, sprout.”
“Good night, Mama. Good night, Papa,” Bilbo says, waving as his parents retreat into their chambers.
When Bilbo reaches Thorin’s room, he pauses at the door. The air feels… different, heavier somehow. As he steps inside, he nearly jumps. A dwarf sits on the edge of the bed, and though his back is turned, the sheer intensity of the energy radiating off him is unmistakable. It crackles like a thundercloud in a still sky, hostile, violent, bloodthirsty.
Thankfully, it’s only Thorin.
“Thorin?” Bilbo asks cautiously, stepping closer. “Is everything alright?”
The oppressive tension in the room dissolves instantly at the sound of his voice. Thorin’s shoulders drop, and he turns to look at Bilbo. In two swift strides, he crosses the room and wraps his arms tightly around him, as if anchoring himself. His embrace is firm, desperate, grounding.
“Just… stress,” Thorin murmurs against Bilbo’s curls. “From not being able to do something I really believed needed doing.”
Bilbo doesn’t need to ask what that something is. The violent aura, the lingering scent of metal and stone, the way Thorin still trembles slightly, all of it tells him the interrogation didn’t go smoothly.
“Do you want to talk about it?” Bilbo asks gently, letting Thorin lead them both to the bed where they settle into a comforting tangle of limbs, warmth, and shared breath.
“I can,” Thorin replies after a long pause. “But… I don’t want you to hear the words they used about you. Not tonight. Not ever.”
Bilbo frowns, tightening his grip around Thorin’s waist. “They insulted me?”
“They did more than insult you.” Thorin’s voice is low and dangerous again. “To hear them degrade you with such vile, ugly words, amrâlimê… it made me want to draw my sword and silence them. Permanently.”
“Oh, Thorin…” Bilbo sighs, half touched, half exasperated. “That’s romantic, and wildly dangerous. Please don’t go murdering anyone on my behalf.”
Thorin lets out a frustrated huff, pressing his forehead to Bilbo’s. “I’ll try to contain my anger. No promises.”
Bilbo chuckles softly and kisses the tip of Thorin’s nose. “Still… thank you. For being angry for me. For loving me enough to care that much.”
“Always,” Thorin replies, his voice soft now, the storm within him slowly quieting as he holds the one he nearly lost.
“Is that all that happened during the interrogation?” Bilbo asks quietly, burrowing deeper into Thorin’s arms as if trying to hide from the weight of the day.
Thorin exhales, his breath brushing against Bilbo’s hair. “No… not all. Most of the conspirators spewed the usual xenophobic nonsense. But Einkil… his reason struck a chord with my 'adad and sigin’adad, for reasons I can’t quite understand.”
Bilbo tilts his head, curiosity piqued. “What was his reason?”
“He claimed he did it all for his nâtha, Eldeth,” Thorin says, voice tightening with bitterness. “He believes all her hard work was wasted the moment you entered my life. That you stole what was rightfully hers, her future as my consort.”
Bilbo hums softly in thought. “I can see why he’d be angry, then. Any parent wants the best for their child. I know that feeling too well. Before I met you, and I was still back in the Shire, my cousins never stopped talking about their dreams and hopes for their children with me.”
Thorin’s expression darkens. “That may explain his frustration, but it doesn’t excuse what he tried to do. Poisoning public opinion, conspiring with others… he risked your life.”
“I never said his methods were justified,” Bilbo replies gently. “I just said I understand where the emotion came from. Love makes people desperate. It makes us foolish.” He sighs and hesitates before asking, “May I meet Eldeth?”
Thorin blinks. “Why do you want to meet her?”
“Because I want to know if she’s doing alright. You told me she was your friend, didn’t you? Wait… is she involved in the conspiracy?”
“No,” Thorin says firmly. “She knew about it, yes, but she refused to take part. She even warned me. I just… failed to listen. And yes, she was my friend. Before I met you, she was to be my consort in name, but there was never any love between us. We respected one another, nothing more.”
“Thorin, I know that,” Bilbo says with a soft smile. “You’ve told me this before. I trust you. You don’t need to keep reassuring me.”
Thorin lowers his gaze. “My apologies. I suppose some part of me still fears you’ll see her as a rival… because I still wish to be her friend.”
“And you still can be,” Bilbo says, gently brushing his fingers over Thorin’s knuckles. “Like I said last time, I trust you.”
Thorin leans forward, eyes filled with affection. “Oh, ghivashel…” he breathes, and presses a deep kiss to Bilbo’s lips. Bilbo sighs into it, his body relaxing completely as he melts into the embrace.
“I’m blessed to have you,” Thorin whispers.
“And I, you,” Bilbo replies, glowing under his lover’s gaze. “So… can I meet her?”
“I’ll ask Dís if she can invite her over for tea,” Thorin says after a moment. “They used to do that often anyway.”
“Thank you, honey,” Bilbo says, his voice warm and sleepy.
“Now let’s rest,” Thorin murmurs, pulling the hobbit close. “It’s been a long day.”
Bilbo nestles against him, tucking his head beneath Thorin’s chin. “Mmm… goodnight, cupcake…”
Thorin smiles softly, eyes slipping shut. Though somewhere in the back of his mind, a quiet voice reminds him: he should ask more about Bilbo’s fairy heritage. But not tonight. Tonight, they are both too weary. Tonight, there is only warmth, the quiet rhythm of shared breath, and the peace of knowing they are safe, for now.
They fall asleep wrapped in each other’s arms.
Caught off guard by the swift capture of their remaining allies, the last of the conspirators are quickly and cleanly apprehended. With no time to regroup or hide, they fall like dominos, ending the plot once and for all. But with their arrest, the conspiracy, long hidden in the shadows, finally becomes public knowledge.
Among the dwarrow population, the reaction is surprisingly measured. In their long lives, such conspiracies are rare but not unheard of. Most are relieved that the situation was contained before it could escalate into full-blown unrest. Rumors naturally begin to spread, speculation over who was involved, who was innocent, who might have secretly aided or known. But King Thrór swiftly addresses the public, issuing a formal statement to quash wild accusations and restore order. While his words settle most of the murmurs, not all tongues are so easily silenced.
The hobbits, however, react quite differently.
Unlike the dwarrow, the visiting Shirefolk are wholly unaccustomed to such political intrigue. As the news ripples through the guest quarters, panic spreads like wildfire. Some fear they’ll be blamed by association even though they are hardly related; others simply find the idea of a secret coup too much for their peaceful minds to comprehend.
Thankfully, Belladonna and Bungo are well-prepared. Having expected such a response, they had already spoken to the Durin family about a simple solution: food. More specifically, a grand celebratory feast. One meant to signal safety, peace, and normalcy.
And it works.
The moment platters of roast meats, cheeses, honeyed fruits, and dwarven spiced bread are served, the panic dissolves almost magically. Conversation returns to lighter topics, laughter resurfaces, and the hobbits begin to enjoy themselves. This confuses the dwarrow. How can such simple folk recover from a scandal so easily? Are they deeply resilient, or just incredibly naïve?
Still, the feast brings peace. Though gossip remains, more animated and absurd among the hobbits than even the dwarrow, it becomes harmless noise rather than dangerous rumor.
Yet not everyone finds it so easy to move on.
Eldeth, daughter of Einkil, the leader of the conspiracy, is terrified.
Though the royal family publicly clears the relatives of the conspirators, affirming their innocence, the court of public opinion is less forgiving. Whispers trail her through the market. Her family name is spoken behind hands and under breath. But Eldeth suffers most not because she’s guilty, she isn’t, but because her father’s betrayal overshadows everything she has worked for.
And then, one morning, a formal invitation arrives.
Tea… with Princess Dís.
Eldeth stares at the elegant handwriting as if it’s a death warrant. Her heart pounds. “This is it,” she mutters. “I’m going to be branded a traitor, have my beard shorn clean, and be executed for treachery. Quietly. Politely. Over tea.”
Still, she is a daughter of the Mountain. She will face her fate with dignity.
Taking a deep breath, Eldeth puts on her best formal dress, arranges her braids with care, and walks to the royal quarters with her head held high, prepared for judgment.
But instead of a tribunal or a cold welcome, she finds herself seated at a sunlit table across from Princess Dís… and Bilbo Baggins.
The hobbit is smiling, sipping tea with delicate grace. Princess Dís offers her a nod and a plate of pastries. They speak casually, like old friends, about the weather, the feast, and Bilbo’s apparent fondness for dwarven berry tarts. And Eldeth finds herself drawn into the conversation. They ask her questions, about her work, her interests, her thoughts on new mining routes. She answers stiffly at first, waiting for the trap.
Is this torture? she wonders. Are they trying to break me with kindness?
Are the pastries poisoned? Unlikely, Dís is an honorable dwarrowdam, not one to kill through deception. But what of the hobbit? Bilbo is unpredictable. He could be using this calm to mask a cruel intention. Yet… his eyes are kind. His laughter is genuine. And Dís treats him with real affection.
None of this makes sense.
Eldeth came prepared to face a blade. Instead, she’s being offered tea, trust… and a second chance. And it leaves her utterly, completely disarmed.
"How long are these pleasantries supposed to last?" Eldeth finally asks, voice steady but hollow. “Why don’t you both just drop the act and let me face my death with dignity?”
Bilbo looks absolutely horrified, while Dís tries, and fails, to suppress an amused smirk.
"Oh no, no, no! We're not doing any of that!" Bilbo exclaims, nearly dropping his teacup.
"You’re… not?" Eldeth blinks, genuinely confused.
Dís chuckles, setting her cup down with graceful poise. "Of course not, dear. We know you had no part in the attempt on Bilbo’s life. And the royal family does not execute innocents."
At that, Eldeth finally relaxes. Her shoulders lower just a little, the tension in her spine slowly beginning to ease. “I… see. Then why invite me here?”
“Well, for one,” Dís says with a smile, “Bilbo wanted to meet you. And, more selfishly, it’s been far too long since we last shared tea together.”
“You wanted to meet me?” Eldeth turns to Bilbo, cautious, unsure how to process his involvement. “Why?”
“Because,” Bilbo replies gently, “you’re a friend of Thorin’s. And his siblings'. My fiancé was terrified I’d resent your connection to him, simply because you were once considered a potential consort before I came along.”
Eldeth’s eyes widen slightly.
“I know there’s no romantic history between you and Thorin,” Bilbo continues. “But you do share a friendship. And I’d hate for him to throw that away just because he’s worried I’d be upset. That’s not the kind of partner I want to be.”
Eldeth is stunned. After everything, the rumors, her 'adad's downfall, she had assumed her connection to the royal family had ended the moment Thorin chose Bilbo. The idea that not only were they not pushing her away, but actively inviting her back in…
Dís raises a brow and sips her tea. “Did you truly believe our friendship was so fragile? So easily discarded?”
“I... I’m not sure,” Eldeth mumbles, feeling embarrassment creep up her cheeks. Her 'adad had always warned her that their ties to the royal family were transactional, nothing more than leverage until it stopped being useful. When her 'amad left, it broke him. He told Eldeth to always prepare for abandonment. And she had. Perhaps too well.
Looking down at her cup, Eldeth wonders just how much of her thinking has been shaped by her father’s pain, and her own.
Dís notices the flicker of shadow in her expression, the way her shoulders tense again. Her smile softens, but before she can say anything, Bilbo jumps in with a cheerful change of topic.
“Thorin’s told me stories about you,” he says brightly. “He says you’re very competitive. He told me all about the ridiculous games you and Frerin used to play.”
Eldeth blinks, then snorts. “I won every single one of those.”
The proud gleam in her eyes returns, and Dís smiles, relieved to see her rallying. There’s still healing to do, but for the first time in days, Eldeth feels like she might have a future again, and people who still want her in it.
Thanks to Bilbo’s warmth and Dís’s familiar presence, Eldeth slowly begins to relax and even enjoy the tea. She listens closely as Bilbo speaks about his people, hobbits, and finds herself fascinated. She had always assumed hobbits would be somewhat similar to dwarrow. After all, weren’t they both short in stature, lovers of underground homes, and if rumors are true, hobbits are the children of Yavanna, the beloved of Mahal himself.
But the more she learns, the more different they seem.
Where dwarrow are a warrior race, trained from childhood to defend themselves and their kin, hobbits have no standing army. What few defenders they do have are more ceremonial than combative. And while dwarrow dedicate themselves to mastering a single Craft, striving toward lifelong perfection, hobbits flit between many crafts. Some manage to become true masters in several, but most are content dabbling in baking, gardening, weaving, writing, without the relentless pursuit of mastery.
Eldeth tries to understand it. Why would anyone invest so much time in something and not aim for perfection? And yet, there’s a kind of freedom in that approach… one she never allowed herself to consider.
Still, a question burns in her chest. One she’s been too afraid to voice, until now.
“Um… may I ask…” She sets down her cup, eyes focused on her lap. “What will happen to my ‘adad?”
Dís’s expression sobers. She sets her teacup aside and answers gently, “Einkil and the others conspired to harm the One of a royal, Bilbo. In dwarven law, a One is considered the other half of a dwarf. An attack on them is the same as an attack on the royal themselves. The punishment… is death.”
Eldeth had known. Of course she had. But hearing it confirmed still knocks the air from her lungs. She nods slowly, her face tight with restrained grief. “I… I see. That is to be expected.”
Across from her, Bilbo presses his lips together, clearly uncomfortable. He gnaws the inside of his cheek. Death. It feels too heavy. Too final. Yes, they tried to kill him, but he doesn’t want to become the kind of person who wishes death on anyone. Not even them.
“Does it have to be death?” he finally asks, softly.
Dís tilts her head, surprised. “It does… traditionally. But you don’t seem pleased with that answer.”
“I’m not,” Bilbo admits. “I don’t like the idea of anyone dying because of me. Even if they hated me.”
Dís nods, understanding. “As the victim of the crime, your voice holds weight. If you wish for a different punishment, we can consider it. The king would listen.”
Eldeth’s heart leaps with hope, though she tries not to show it too much. Her fingers tremble slightly as she clasps them tightly together. “Bilbo… I know I have no right to ask, but please… my ‘adad wasn’t always like this. Before my ‘amad left, he was gentle. Loving. He loved her even though she wasn’t his One. And when she left, something in him… broke. It twisted him. That kind of grief… it ruins a soul.”
Her voice shakes, but her gaze is steady. “He lost himself to that pain. Please, I just… I don’t want to lose another lashar if it can be helped.”
Bilbo’s heart aches at her words. He thinks deeply, turning over what he’s learned about dwarrow customs, honor, identity, faith, and community. Death might be the law’s answer, but perhaps there’s something else, something just as meaningful in their culture. A punishment that might open the door to redemption.
“Well…” he says slowly, “what if instead of execution… they have all their hair shorn? Every strand, head, beard, all of it.”
Dís raises a brow but says nothing yet.
“And they can never return to any dwarven settlement,” Bilbo continues. “They’d be banished, forced to live among other races.”
Eldeth begins to pale.
“Oh! And…” Bilbo adds thoughtfully, “what if they were forbidden from speaking Khuzdul?”
Silence.
Disbelief.
Dís’s cup stops midair. Eldeth’s jaw drops. Both women stare at Bilbo as if he’s just cursed Mahal himself.
“Wh-what?” Eldeth croaks.
Bilbo blinks innocently. “I thought… since most of them are xenophobic, making them live among the other races would be a kind of poetic justice. If they must live, they should learn the value of the people they tried to harm. Maybe then they’ll change.”
Dís gives a nervous laugh, utterly stunned. “Bilbo… do you know what you just said?”
“To shave a dwarrow’s beard is already a deep humiliation,” Eldeth whispers. “But all of their hair? That’s a total stripping of identity. That alone is a sentence of soul-death.”
“And exile is one thing,” Dís adds gravely, “but to bar them from Khuzdul? That’s tantamount to declaring them no longer dwarrow. They’d be severed from our language, our prayers, our songs, our ancestors.”
Bilbo’s eyes widen. “Oh! I didn’t mean… I wasn’t trying to—!”
Eldeth breathes deeply, swaying slightly. “Still... he’ll live. That’s more than I hoped for.”
Bilbo looks helpless. “I was just trying to show mercy…”
Dís shakes her head with a dry chuckle. “You did, Bilbo. In the most terrifying way possible.”
Bilbo flushes. “Maybe we can just… scale it back a little?”
“No,” Eldeth whispers, trying to steady her nerves. “He’ll live. That’s enough.”
She manages a faint, fragile smile, though her hands still tremble in her lap.
Bilbo exchanges a glance with Dís, who sighs and pats his arm.
“Remind me never to get on your bad side,” she mutters. “You’re far too creative for your own good.”
After the tea party, Eldeth thanks Bilbo and Dís quietly but sincerely. Though the punishment is harsh, cruel, even, by dwarven standards, she is still grateful. Her ‘adad will live. And that is something she hadn’t dared hope for.
Bilbo nods, pleased with himself. He still doesn’t quite understand the full weight of what he proposed. In his hobbit mind, anything is better than death. Even exile. Even losing a language. After all, wouldn’t life, even under restriction, offer a chance at redemption?
But his confidence wavers when he presents the punishment idea to the rest of the Durin royal family later that evening.
Their reactions are… not what he expects.
“Ban them from Khuzdul!?” Thráin gasps, clutching his chest like he's been struck. “Mahal preserve us!”
“That is just…” Thrór breathes, staring wide-eyed. “That is just horrible.”
Frís looks like she might faint, her face ashen.
Hrera’s breath quickens in panic, short, fast gasps like she’s on the verge of a full breakdown.
“I… I suppose it’s fair…” Frerin mutters, his voice trembling. He doesn’t sound convinced.
“I think I’m gonna hurl,” Fíli groans, paling visibly.
“Same,” Kíli croaks, gripping the back of a chair for balance.
Víli clutches his dashshat close, the young dwarrow trembling as they hide their faces against their 'adad's shoulder.
“Oh, my poor boys…” Dís murmurs with a resigned sigh, wrapping her arms protectively around her dashshat. She expected this, but it still stings to watch.
Meanwhile, Thorin is beaming.
“Excellent!” he declares with a grin sharp enough to cut stone. “They do not deserve the gift of Mahal’s words!”
Bilbo blinks at him. “…Thorin?”
The prince-consort-to-be gives a nervous laugh, shrinking a little under the kingly glee radiating off Thorin like molten steel. At least he doesn’t want them executed anymore, Bilbo tells himself.
“Um… I think I want to reconsider the punishment now,” Bilbo mutters, glancing at the others’ horrified faces.
“No!” Thorin snaps, his eyes gleaming. “It is a perfect solution! Cruel, poetic, and just. We should use it!”
Bilbo gulps. The murderous aura Thorin once carried during the interrogation has clearly returned. “R-right. Yes. Very… poetic,” he mumbles.
But then he remembers something. “Wait, how would we even enforce something like that? How does one ban a person from speaking a language? Do we assign guards to follow them forever?”
Thorin’s manic glee pauses, only briefly, before he straightens with a thoughtful hum.
“Oh, I thought you knew this part already.” He tilts his head, regal and ominous. “You’ve been studying our history, haven’t you?”
Bilbo nods warily. “A bit, yes. About Mahal and… how dwarrow were shaped.”
“Good. Then you’ll remember that the Arkenstone is not just a symbol of kingship, it holds a spark of the original Flame, from Mahal’s own forge. A gift passed down through the line of Durin,” Thorin explains with solemn pride.
Bilbo nods again, slower this time, not liking where this is going.
Thorin continues, “Sigin’adad, the current King of Erebor, can use that spark to shape a dwarf, in a very limited sense. Not like Mahal, of course, but enough to alter certain gifts granted to us.”
“And… that includes…?”
“Yes,” Thorin confirms. “The gift of Khuzdul. It was given to us by our Maker. If a dwarf proves themselves unworthy, by misusing it, by staining it with betrayal, it can be taken away.”
Bilbo stares. “You can remove someone’s ability to speak their own language?”
Thorin nods once, firm and certain. “Through the Arkenstone’s flame, yes. It is rare. It has not been done in an age. But it is doable.”
Bilbo pales. “I just… I thought it was a symbolic punishment…”
“Oh no,” Dís murmurs, rubbing her temples. “It’s very real, my dear hobbit.”
Bilbo sits down heavily. “I think I’ve just invented cultural annihilation…”
Fíli and Kíli groan in unison. Víli whimpers. Dís pulls them all closer.
Thorin, still smiling darkly, leans toward Bilbo. “Don’t worry, ghivashel. It was a brilliant idea.”
Bilbo, increasingly distressed, stares blankly at the fire. “I was just trying to be merciful…”
Bilbo, with fairy blood in his veins, accepts the seemingly magical explanation with little hesitation. Thorin notices this ease, the lack of skepticism most adults show when faced with the unnatural, and something clicks in his mind.
“Bilbo,” he says, gently, “can we talk more about your… invisibility powers? Have you always known how to do that?”
Bilbo shakes his head. “No, not really. But when I asked my mama about it earlier, she said it wasn’t unusual. She suspected I probably used it as a child, especially during games of hide-and-seek. Said she always had trouble finding me.” He chuckles, then adds, “She also told me she thinks she used magic when she was young too; little things. But as she got older, she assumed it was just her imagination running wild.”
Thorin nods thoughtfully, listening closely.
“It seems us Tooks,” Bilbo continues, “can access our magic very easily when we’re children, because our minds are still so open and imaginative. But as we grow, we start to shape our thoughts to fit what’s ‘normal.’ We forget the magic. We dismiss what we did as make-believe. It fades, unless someone reminds us.”
Thorin hums. “That explains a lot… So it’s something innate? And fading is more about belief than ability?”
“Exactly,” Bilbo nods. “My papa fainted when I told them what happened with the invisibility, by the way.”
Thorin’s eyes widen. “Should I call for Óin?”
“Oh no,” Bilbo waves it off with a smile. “He came around a few minutes later. Muttered something about how it ‘explains so much’ about both my childhood and his. Apparently, my mama used to prank him using her magic when they were kids. He said he thought the furniture moving on its own was just her being clever with string.”
Thorin chuckles, both amused and fascinated. “So… can you control it now?”
“Not yet. But Mama already wrote to a family friend she thinks can help. He’s someone who might be able to help her reconnect with her own magic too. She says he should be arriving soon.”
Thorin pauses, considering what this might mean. Then, cautiously, he leans forward and asks something he’s been curious about since Bilbo's family told him about their fairy heritage. “Bilbo… I remember your ‘amad saying something about Took men carrying chil—”
“Wait!” Kíli interrupts, bouncing on his heels, eyes bright with sudden excitement. “Can the Arkenstone give me a beard!?”
Thrór groans deeply, dragging a hand down his face. “Yes, technically. But no, I will not be using the Arkenstone to help you grow a beard, Kíli. And neither will I do it for you, Fíli.”
“But—!” both Fíli and Kíli start, only for Thrór to cut them off with a stern shake of his head.
“The Arkenstone contains a spark of the original Flame of Mahal. It is a sacred relic, not some toy for vanity! It is not to be used to shape yourselves all willy-nilly!”
“Ugh, fine…” Kíli pouts, while Fíli sighs dramatically.
From the side, Víli chuckles and pats their heads fondly. “Don’t worry, you two. Your Ones both find you attractive, beards or not.”
The two princes brighten slightly at that, while Thorin leans back, still mulling over the implications of Bilbo’s heritage, and who this family friend might be.
It is said that hobbits are a peaceful folk, and indeed, they are. Because of this, many dwarrow, both those who accept Bilbo Baggins as Prince Thorin's One and those who do not, assume that the hobbit will be too soft for the harsh realities of royal life. In particular, they doubt his ability to carry the burden of judgment and punishment. They believe Thorin will shield him from such brutal necessities, keeping his gentle nature intact and far removed from the dark responsibilities that come with the crown.
So when word spreads of the punishment dealt to the traitors, those who conspired to assassinate Bilbo, they are stunned.
Not by Thorin’s response. No one would have been surprised if the prince had demanded death.
But this is worse.
Beards shorn clean, exiled from every dwarven settlement, denied the right to speak Khuzdul, their sacred tongue. It is a punishment that strikes not only at the body, but at the soul of a dwarrow. An execution of identity.
And to their shock, it comes not from Thorin, but from Bilbo.
The realization shifts how they view him entirely. No longer merely the soft-spoken, wide-eyed hobbit who wandered into their kingdom with kind manners and an odd accent, now they see someone capable of wielding power in a way even dwarrow find chilling. It plants a strange new seed: fear, yes, but also respect.
Meanwhile, Bilbo’s fellow hobbits are baffled by the reaction. To them, punishment without death is lenient. Exile? Living far from home isn’t ideal, but it’s still living. The idea that this could be worse than execution escapes them entirely. They don't understand that for dwarrow, what Bilbo has decreed is nothing less than the death of identity, of legacy, of everything that ties one to Mahal and their people.
Bilbo, however, now begins to understand. Slowly, painfully, the weight of what he has done settles on him. He may not feel regret, but he does feel responsibility. And with that, comes a quiet mercy.
He approaches King Thrór with a request.
“Can we… wait until spring to carry out the punishment?” he asks carefully. “Winter is harsh and unforgiving. I know they’ve done terrible things, but I don’t want to send them into the snow with nothing. At least let them face their exile when it’s warmer.”
Thrór regards him in silence for a moment, surprised again. This hobbit, who crafted a punishment to shake even dwarven hearts, now pleads for time.
“And if I may…” Bilbo hesitates, then continues, “Could we allow visitors during the winter? Family, friends… Let them say goodbye while they still can. They’ll lose everything soon—the least they deserve is a chance to part properly.”
Thrór sighs, his expression unreadable. “You are too kind, Bilbo. Especially for someone who’s just delivered a punishment more horrifying than death.”
Bilbo laughs softly, rubbing the back of his neck. “I didn’t mean it to be that bad…”
“But it was,” Thrór says plainly. Then he smiles, a genuine warmth in his eyes. “And yet you still have the heart to grant them a final grace. You’ll make a fine consort for Thorin.”
When Thorin hears of Bilbo’s request, his reaction is anything but warm.
He does not shout. He does not argue. But his scowl is thunderous.
They tried to murder Bilbo. And now they get time? Comfort? Goodbyes?
He grits his teeth, jaw clenched so tight it aches. But he says nothing. Because it is Bilbo’s right. Because Bilbo, the victim, is owed this voice in the matter.
Because Bilbo asked.
And for all Thorin’s fury, he cannot deny his One anything, not when his voice is calm and gentle, not when he asks for mercy with such hope in his eyes. Even if it hurts.
He says nothing.
But the dark gleam in his eyes, the tightness of his shoulders, and the stiff nod of reluctant approval say everything.
Thorin Oakenshield may accept the delay. But he does not forgive.
So Thorin oversees every visit personally.
Not out of kindness, but out of vigilance. These are traitors, conspirators who dared to harm his One. If he so much as hears a whisper of escape, a hint of subversion, he ends the visit on the spot. No exceptions.
He watches them all. The tears. The embraces through iron bars. The whispered goodbyes.
But none of it softens his heart.
His fury still burns. They had plotted to kill Bilbo. And even now, as they wait out their punishment, he wants them to stew in fear and silence. Let them dread what is to come. Let them feel the weight of their crimes.
But Bilbo, sweet, maddeningly kind Bilbo, asks for mercy. Not for their sake, but for their loved ones.
So Thorin relents. Barely.
Because he knows the limits of his own restraint, he asks Frerin to join him. His nadad 'ukham is the only one who can reliably talk him down from his darker thoughts.
“You know I could be doing my actual duties as a prince instead of standing here watching traitors cry?” Frerin remarks as they stand along the outer edge of the visiting area, arms crossed, eyes scanning the emotional scene before them.
Thorin doesn’t look at him as he answers. “Frerin, we both know you'd be doing anything but your duties, unless it’s a diplomatic mission that takes you far from Erebor.”
Frerin grins, not denying it. “That’s true. Though… I don’t think I’ll be taking any diplomatic missions anytime soon.”
“Because it’s winter?” Thorin asks, glancing sideways.
Frerin shakes his head slowly. “That too… but mostly because now, I think I might have a reason to stay.”
Thorin frowns, confused, until he follows Frerin’s gaze.
Across the room, a dwarrowdam kneels at the iron bars of the prison chamber, her shoulders trembling with sobs. On the other side of the bars, a middle-aged dwarf holds her hand through the gaps.
Eldeth and Einkil.
“Nâtha, forgive your foolish 'adad,” Einkil whispers, his voice hoarse with emotion. “If I had done things better... you could have become consort. You could have had everything.”
Eldeth shakes her head vehemently, tears spilling down her cheeks. “No! I don’t care about becoming consort anymore. I just— I’m terrified. Terrified of being left alone. When 'amad left us, you were all I had left. And now you’re being exiled…”
Einkil pales, grief and guilt washing over him. “Oh, Mahal… what have I done?”
He tightens his grip on her hands. “My sweet nâtha, I swear this: I will try to sneak in letters for you. Somehow. Even if I can’t be with you anymore, I’ll always be yours. You will always have me.”
The raw emotion in their goodbye tears at the hearts of those around them.
Thorin steps forward, about to cut the conversation short, too familiar, too dangerous. But Frerin stops him with a firm hand on his shoulder.
“Don’t,” he says quietly. “Bilbo wants them to change. Reform. Being able to stay connected with their loved ones… it helps.”
Thorin clenches his jaw, scowling. “They're supposed to be cut off.”
“They will be,” Frerin says. “Soon enough. Let them say goodbye while they still remember who they are.”
Thorin exhales sharply but relents. His anger simmers, but beneath it, he knows his nadad is right.
He watches as Einkil presses his forehead to the bars and Eldeth mirrors him, silent tears running down her cheeks.
And for the first time since the judgment was declared, a part of Thorin, buried deep beneath his fury, begins to understand what Bilbo meant. Not all punishment has to be cold steel or hard walls. Sometimes, the softest blade cuts the deepest.
Frerin nudges him gently, voice low. “He’s changing us, you know.”
Thorin doesn’t need to ask who he is.
Bilbo.
And maybe that’s not such a terrible thing.
Thorin spends most of the winter either overseeing the visits to the imprisoned conspirators or curling up with Bilbo in their shared chambers. The latter is a source of warmth and comfort for both of them. Bilbo enjoys the affection, truly, he does, but he begins to suspect that Thorin won't truly calm down until spring arrives and the last of the conspirators are exiled from the mountain for good.
Thankfully, time passes quickly, not because of the impending punishment, but because of something far more joyful to prepare for:
Their wedding.
Bilbo assumes from the start that he’ll be having a dwarven-style wedding, after all, he’s marrying into the royal family of Durin’s line. Dutiful as ever, he throws himself into research. He learns the ancient vows, studies the significance of various gemstones and metals, memorizes the ceremonial jewelry customs, and even practices dwarven etiquette during formal courtship rites.
However, there’s one tradition that makes him break out into a cold sweat: the traditional combat trial, where the non-royal partner must prove themselves worthy by facing off against a member of the royal family.
Even Kíli, the youngest and arguably the least intimidating, could flatten him with a sneeze.
Bilbo tries not to panic.
But to his surprise and relief, help arrives in the form of his parents.
Belladonna and Bungo Baggins, who have taken to their son’s courtship with impressive determination, start petitioning the Durin elders to include some hobbit traditions in the ceremony. After all, it’s not just a dwarf who is getting married, but a hobbit, too.
And under normal circumstances, the Durins might have refused.
But with the conspirators soon to be exiled, and Bilbo's terrifyingly effective punishment still fresh in everyone’s minds, the general dwarven population now sees him with a complex mixture of fear and respect. The idea of Bilbo being 'too soft' has thoroughly evaporated. He’s earned his place, and more importantly, earned deference.
And so, the Durins agree.
No combat trial. Hobbit traditions will be honored. Some dwarrow grumble, but few challenge the decision.
Winter, therefore, becomes a flurry of wedding preparations, led mostly by the families. Both the Durins and the Bagginses seem to believe it is their sacred duty to plan every aspect of the wedding. Thorin and Bilbo are mostly left out, aside from being consulted on essential decisions like the color scheme, food options, and music.
“I only have one request,” Bilbo pleads during one of the many chaotic planning sessions. “No bloodshed. Please.”
“I want to see Bilbo draped in Durin blue,” Thorin counters, voice firm but fond.
“I want a honeymoon,” Bilbo sighs, already overwhelmed by the never-ending discussions of seating arrangements and ceremonial song selections. “Please tell me we get a honeymoon after all this.”
Thorin hums, thoughtful. “We do. Though since we’re royalty, it’s usually postponed. There are rites, public ceremonies, and, unfortunately, paperwork after the wedding. My lashshar waited a few years before they could enjoy theirs properly.”
Bilbo groans. “Years?”
Thorin smiles and cups his cheek. “But yes, we will have one, amrâlimê. Even if I have to sneak us away from court myself.”
Bilbo melts at the promise. The delay might be frustrating, but in the end, they’ll be together, and that’s what matters most.
And with so much time consumed by endless fittings, dance rehearsals, political considerations, and deeply passionate arguments between both clans (usually about table settings), winter rushes past.
Before Bilbo knows it, spring arrives.
And with it, two great events: the exile of the conspirators… and a royal wedding unlike any Erebor has ever seen.
Once the last snow has melted and the first crocuses push through the thawing earth, the time for exile arrives.
A public ceremony is held in the great entrance hall of Erebor, with banners lowered to half-mast and guards flanking every wall. It is a grim occasion, meant not only to enforce the sentence but to mark the conspirators as traitors in the eyes of all dwarrow.
One by one, their names are listed aloud for all to hear, their crimes read in full before the punishment begins. Each name echoes through the halls like a hammer blow.
Einkil stands first among them, shackled and silent.
“Einkil, dashat of Eberk,” Balin announces with grim authority, his voice carrying through the solemn crowd. “Leader of the organization that attempted to murder the One of Prince Thorin, Bilbo Baggins. In doing so, he has sought harm upon the royal family of Erebor. For this crime, he shall be stripped of his honor, shorn of hair, exiled from dwarven lands, and severed from the sacred gift of Khuzdul.”
The audience murmurs but remains quiet. The air hangs heavy.
Dwalin and two other guards move forward with practiced precision. They grasp Einkil roughly, ignoring his struggling as they begin shearing off his beard, long, once-proud braids falling to the stone floor like blood on snow. Then they move to his scalp.
From a distance, Bilbo watches. He is hidden behind a latticework partition, out of sight from the traitors, nestled securely in Thorin’s arms. He didn’t want to be present, at least not fully, but curiosity about the legendary Arkenstone and the dwarven rite drove him here. Thorin, ever protective, holds him close, one hand resting over Bilbo’s heart as the ceremony proceeds.
At first, it unfolds exactly as Bilbo expected… until it doesn’t.
As the guards begin stripping Einkil of his clothes, Bilbo stiffens.
Then they begin shaving his entire body.
"W-Wait! I meant only his beard and head hair!" Bilbo exclaims in horror, poking his head from behind the partition. “Why are they shaving his everything?!”
No wonder the dwarrow had thought his punishment was too much! He’d only meant to remove their symbolic pride, not all their hair!
But it’s too late. He turns away quickly, face burning as the guards move lower. Even Thorin clears his throat awkwardly and shields Bilbo’s view with his cloak.
Eventually, they clothe Einkil again. Thorin gently murmurs, “It’s safe to look now.”
Bilbo peeks, his embarrassment forgotten as King Thrór steps forward, cradling a radiant jewel in both hands. The Arkenstone.
The gem gleams with a light all its own, shimmering with ever-shifting hues like moonlight on snow, sunlight on gold. It pulses softly as King Thrór chants in deep, resonant Khuzdul. The sacred words make the stone glow brighter until a tendril of multicolored light winds from its surface, spiraling around the king’s hand.
Then, solemnly, Thrór takes up a ceremonial hammer and kneels in reverence.
Bilbo holds his breath.
Without warning, Thrór rises and brings the hammer down in a ringing strike, straight onto Einkil’s head.
A loud bang echoes through the chamber.
Bilbo gasps, jaw dropping. “He’s dead! He’s dead! I said no executions!”
But Einkil grunts, staggering slightly before raising his head and glaring, more humiliated than harmed.
Thorin leans in and calmly explains, “Since we dwarrow were shaped by Mahal’s hands and forged with tools, it is only right we are reshaped the same way. A febble blow to the head seals the breaking of their name, it shatters their identity as dwarrow.”
“Feeble blow?!” Bilbo squeaks, still reeling. “You all have rocks for skulls!”
Thorin merely smiles.
The guards escort Einkil away in silence, a broken shadow of the dwarf he once was. He is now a nameless exile, stripped of the sacred language and kinship of his people. To the dwarrow, this is a fate worse than death.
One by one, the other conspirators follow. Hair is shorn. Names are declared. The hammer falls again and again. Bilbo watches the transformation, the unmaking, and with each strike, his heart grows heavier.
By the thirteenth exile, he can stomach no more.
He tugs on Thorin’s sleeve. “Please take me away. I don’t think I can handle any more naked dwarrow… or hammers.”
Thorin turns toward him with a sly smile and a wink. “I hope that doesn’t apply to me, ghivashel.”
Bilbo flushes a brilliant red. “Y-You perverted dwarf! … No, it doesn’t apply to you.”
Thorin chuckles warmly and presses a soft kiss to Bilbo’s brow, leading him gently out of the echoing hall, away from exile and into the soft, blooming promise of spring.
Once they return to their chambers, Bilbo collapses onto their shared bed with a weary groan, burying his face in the soft furs.
"Thorin…" he murmurs, muffled by the blankets. "Did I do the right thing? I wanted to keep them alive, but now I’m starting to think I sentenced them to a different kind of death."
Thorin closes the door behind them with a soft click and crosses the room. He sits beside Bilbo, running a hand gently down his back. “...While it does bring me some satisfaction to see them punished in such a cruel manner,” he begins, earning a half-hearted glare from Bilbo, “you did the right thing. Far more than I ever could have.”
Bilbo shifts to look up at him, eyes tired but searching.
“They still live,” Thorin continues, his voice calm but sincere. “And so they still have the chance to become better people. If Mahal sees that they truly regret their actions, if they turn from the path they walked, the gift of Khuzdul may return to them. It has happened before, though rarely.”
“You really think so?” Bilbo asks quietly, uncertain.
Thorin gives a small, sad smile. “Honestly, ghivashel, we dwarrow are a stubborn folk. Most of them will likely remain bitter, blaming you for their fall, never seeing the grace in what you gave them. But to those few who understand the gift of mercy you extended, they may yet change. For them, Bilbo, you didn’t just spare a life. You offered redemption. And that is a rare and powerful thing.”
Bilbo exhales slowly, still wrestling with the weight of it all. “I suppose so... Still, I didn’t expect them to shave them all the way. That part really caught me off guard. I just meant their head and beard! Not, everything.”
He shudders at the memory, curling in a little.
“What will you do with all the cut hair anyway?” he asks reluctantly, as if dreading the answer.
“Traditionally,” Thorin says, “it’s given to the victim as a symbol of restored honor. They can do what they like with it, craft it into a trophy, display it as a mark of justice served.”
Bilbo’s face twists into something between horror and disgust.
“But,” Thorin adds quickly, seeing that expression, “burning it is also a perfectly respectable alternative. Especially… under the circumstances.”
“Oh please burn it,” Bilbo pleads, shaking his head. “I don’t want to touch it, look at it, or even see a single strand of it. Especially if it came from, down there! Yavanna's grace!”
Thorin chuckles, the sound warm and low. He leans down and kisses the top of Bilbo’s curls, letting his fingers card gently through them.
“And what about my hair, hmm?” he teases with a smirk. “Do you not want to see them, too?”
Bilbo flushes a deep crimson. “Yours is exempt,” he mutters quickly. “Obviously. I am going to marry you.”
Thorin grins, clearly enjoying himself. “So once we’re wed… does that mean we finally get to do more than cuddle?”
He wraps his arms around the hobbit, pulling him close, and Bilbo hums as he leans into his warmth.
“Just a few more days,” Bilbo says with a small smile. “Then I’ll be your husband.”
Thorin nuzzles into his curls. “And I’ll get to call you yasthûn. My heart.”
They sit together in peaceful silence for a while, wrapped in each other’s arms, the darkness outside chased away by the golden glow of the hearth, the soft promises of spring, and the wedding to come.
