Sorry, you need to have JavaScript enabled for this.

Actions

Work Header

Possessions

Summary:

Thorin catches Bilbo cooking and seems awkward and embarrassed. The explanation as to why is a real eye-opener. Some mysteries hide in plain sight.

Work Text:

Bilbo moved around the elaborate food preparation area in the consort's quarters while humming softly to himself. "You are lovely," he told the leeks in his hand before picking up his favorite knife to chop them. They were notoriously fiddly, leeks, hiding grains of dirt and grit deep within their creases, so he talked to them as he worked, telling them in no uncertain terms that no grit would be permitted. He appreciated this kitchen; it was one of the first gifts Thorin had arranged for him once they were properly courting. He would have objected to the diversion of dwarvish craftsmen when there was still so much to be done around the mountain if he'd thought it would do any good. Even so, though the weeks since had been a flood of gold and jewels and fripperies, as his mother would have called them, it was still by far his favorite of the lot. He broke off humming his tune as he finished the task and nodded once, decisively; a job well done. "Now, let's see about this butter, shall we? The mountain butter won't do at all, but we've got that lovely Dale stuff..." he murmured to the chopped leeks - which looked perfectly grit-free - as he bent to fetch the right butter from the cold well. He turned to the heating surface over the fire box... and almost fell over in surprise at the sight of Thorin hovering in the door. "Thorin! Good heavens, you startled me!"

The King Under the Mountain resembled nothing so much at this moment as an embarrassed tween. "My apologies, Master Baggins," came the rumbling response. "It was not my intention to spy on the mysteries of your craft." The mysteries...? Bilbo thought in puzzlement.

"What on earth? No, you simply surprised me... wasn't expecting you to be looming there," Bilbo said a bit sharply before pausing, eyebrows creasing. "Craft mysteries?"

Thorin's expression became, if possible, even more hang-dog. "As you know, I am not... gifted at cooking," Thorin mumbled. Bilbo loved Thorin dearly but he also considered the king's words to be a truly Shire-level understatement. Biting his tongue, he simply nodded. "I had not realized there was more to the process. Now I understand how your food is made to taste so exceptionally good. As I said, it was not my intention to pry." With that, the king withdrew, leaving a very puzzled hobbit indeed standing in the kitchen. Shrugging, he turned back to the stove. These leeks wouldn't braise themselves.

Later, after a meal of quite tasty stewed leeks and a fish pie that Bilbo was rather proud of given the limited ingredients available in Erebor, he brought Thorin a glass of wine and sat down with him. "Now then," the hobbit said as he sipped at a matching glass of wine, "if you'd be so kind, explain what you were talking about earlier. 'Craft mysteries?'" He snickered a bit as Thorin scowled. "I was just cooking, as I do all the time. Not sure I'd describe any of it as mysterious, just a series of things to be done."

Thorin sighed, shifting a bit in his chair and adjusting his (quite lovely, Bilbo thought) court coat. "It is the same," the king replied, leaving Bilbo no closer to understanding. "I saw you speaking and singing to the ingredients as you cooked, and you made them more of themselves. No smith would find this process unfamiliar." Thorin glanced away, glaring briefly at the elven sculpture Bilbo had set in pride-of-place on the mantel. A gift from Thranduil, Bilbo thought it quite the loveliest thing he'd seen, all sweeping ivory-white swirls and unexpected shapes erupting from a smooth bole below. "No dwarven smith, at any rate." Bilbo sighed; he didn't want to get sidetracked into Thorin's Very Clear Opinions about elves if he could help it. Even so, this was a view into something he'd been curious about so the hobbit leaned forward.

"Made them... more of themselves?" Bilbo asked. "Kind of you to say about the cooking, and I appreciate the compliment, but that's an odd way to put it. I just..." he paused, thinking. "It's nothing special. Just ingredients, Thorin, and knowing what goes with what."

"Is that all?" Thorin glanced over, one brow arched and a half-smile on his face. Bilbo thought him unfairly handsome most of the time, but this expression in particular was absurdly unfair during a conversation! He fought to focus again on what Thorin's mouth was saying rather than how it looked. "And what else would it be? If it would truly not violate your guild mysteries, then tell me... how did you prepare the laukr for dinner?" Bilbo had been confused the first time he heard dwarves call leeks this, but now he knew.

"Well, they're not the simplest thing to fix, but not the hardest by far," the hobbit replied, sitting back with a smile. "I chopped them and rinsed them to make sure there was no lingering grit, as they are more prone to it than anything else other than maybe some greens. These were a bit bitter, so I added a pinch of sugar to the water that I seethed them in, along with the right amount of salt. Too little and they're bland, too much and... well, too much and they're just salt, aren't they? I did have to use some of the butter I got from Bard for them, because the mountain butter is too greasy, but..." he broke off because Thorin was nodding and grinning as though more was being said than Bilbo thought. "What? Thorin, that's just how you cook leeks!"

Thorin nodded. "Aye, likely it is, I'd not know. But you knew exactly what ingredients made the laukr more of themselves, as I said. You knew what to use, and how much, and you ended with a dish that was the perfect expression of them while being more than they were alone. That is the essence of what dwarven craft is, Bilbo... you must know this by now, you've lived here for months." The hobbit was floored. Truly, this was nothing he'd ever heard before, but before he could say so Thorin was already shaking his head. "No, no-one would have said a word, because you're not a dwarf. Sometimes I forget." He set his wine glass down and leaned over, taking Bilbo's hand. "Tell me, though... are there foods in the Shire that you know as soon as you eat them who cooked them? They taste of the cook who made them, so that you could even pick them out of a line of dishes made with roughly the same ingredients?" Bilbo was nodding immediately. What a silly question!

"Of course," he chuckled. "Many of them, so many I can't list them all. Any cook worth the name has a signature dish or two, and anyone in the Shire who ate it would know immediately who had prepared it. Why..." At that moment, the penny dropped. "Wait," Bilbo said, interrupting himself and clutching at Thorin's oversized dwarven hand in his as he sat forward, "so you're telling me dwarves can tell who made something just by, what, by looking at it?" Thorin's laugh was clear and loud.

"Easily," the king responded, still chuckling. "Look and touch. If they'd ever seen or met the dwarf's work before, they'd know it like the sight of a face. Did you not wonder why we would leave our comfortable delvings in the Blue Mountains for Erebor? This place isn't just a source of gold and treasure, it's our memory." Thorin's face drew down. "The gold is..." he shrugged awkwardly and Bilbo cringed a bit at the memories the topic produced in them both, but Thorin soldiered on bravely. "A side issue," he continued with a brief headshake. "But each carving, each stone, each item, is the voice of our kin speaking from the past to the present and the future. They are like our children in a way. Each item made by a dwarf, be it for ever so common a purpose, is a message, a moment of beauty sent forward to all who use it." He shrugged. "If you are to be married to a dwarf," he gave a brief bashful grin that rendered Bilbo momentarily speechless, "this is a thing you must know. You are dwarf-friend, khuzdbaha, so it is permitted to tell you these things." Bilbo wasn't often what he would call 'flabbergasted', but he definitely felt so now.

"So..." he paused, mind whirling. "So when the Company went into the treasure hall..." He stopped, remembering. He had watched as they had all clambered over the piles of treasure and coins, pulling items from the pile. Always items, he remembered in retrospect, never gems or coins, and always to show to each other. They might have been made of gold or worked with gold, but always it was things of complicated make and, he had thought even at the time, surprising beauty. At the time he'd dismissed it as the legendary greed of dwarves, a memory which brought a flush of shame to his cheeks as he sat here in front of the fire.

Thorin nodded. "Aye, seeing all that..." He paused, eyes staring into the distance. "It was as though..." he paused, clearly fighting to think of something comparable. "As though you were served again the foods of your childhood, or even things you had never been served but only heard of in your youth, legendary meals, brought out all at once and set before you in a feast. We dwarves just taste with our eyes and hands, not our tongues." He grinned at Bilbo, who scowled in return.

"Thorin Oakenshield, I already love you dearly as you well know," the hobbit grumped. "If you become a poet in addition to all your other many skills, it shan't be safe for anyone." Despite this firm admonition he leaned forward to press a kiss to the dwarf before sitting back. He glanced around the room, seeing the carved walls and stonework in a new light. The mantel in particular, directly beneath the elvish confection, had an unusual blank bezel on it that Bilbo had only seen one other place in the mountain. He'd noticed them both because they were so plain and so unusual in such a heavily-decorated realm. "So this mantel..." he said slowly as Thorin smirked and nodded. "It is made by... the same dwarf that made the one in the council rooms?"

"Yes, though there's more to it," the king replied, sitting back himself. "This mantel was carved for the first Queen of Erebor, Kûris, wife of Thrain I, by her brother Kurn. He was a Stonelord and accounted a master craftsman even among the folk of Khazad-Dûm. He was young too, at the height of his skills when Durin's Bane came. He survived the trip to the mountain - barely - but he had been terribly burned by the creature's fire before the flight. He did not live through the first year here. If you look at the mantels..." Thorin stood and gestured to a spot just below the unusual bezel where the stone was a bit rough, "the polish is still imperfect. He was unable to carve the seal of Durin here as he wished," he motioned at the bezel,"and no other would touch his work from the respect they bore him. His hands were rough and unsteady by the time these were made, but for love of him both mantels were given pride of place. They were the last things he made. He sleeps in the stone below." Thorin gave a small, bittersweet smile. "My mother told me that story, and now she too is gone. I mean it when I say these halls are our memory, azyungel."

"I..." Bilbo wasn't sure what to say. He thought of his own mother, of the chance to taste her blackberry crumble again, or her persimmon pies, and his mouth watered at the same time his heart ached for knowing he'd never taste them again in this life. "I had no idea." He felt like an idiot, suddenly. Here he'd been tramping around through all the work of all these hands, some of whom had died for it, without even a thought! "I feel a bit of a fool," he admitted grimly. "I hope I haven't disrespected anyone's..." Thorin cut him off.

"No," the king retorted, eyes fixed on Bilbo's. "No, never think that, for none of us would. You not only helped us take it back, you've carried half the mine yourself helping us reclaim it," Thorin said firmly, eyes glowing with pride. "You've done more for Durin's folk than any non-dwarf - or most of the other clans, if I'm honest - since the fall of Khazad-Dûm itself. Never feel anything but pride for your actions, my love. We know they were done with kindness and care, and in kindness and care there can be no disrespect." Thorin smiled warmly. "It is only that now you have better eyes to see what is around you, that's all."

Bilbo was nodding, so many things now falling into place. "So all the stories of the dwarves' greed for things and treasure..." Thorin snorted and scowled at Bilbo.

"Well, those stories are elvish, no doubt. They see everything twisted and sideways, always making themselves look good and all others seem at fault," Thorin scoffed, making Bilbo fight the urge to roll his eyes. "But yes, they do not understand. They have a different idea of everything and crafting is no different, if you can call what they do crafting at all." He paused, a fey light coming into his eyes. "Do you have your elvish dagger about? Go fetch it. I will show you what I mean." Bilbo looked at him a bit nervously, but rose and went to his chamber, returning with Sting. Thorin pulled it from its sheath and laid it on the low table between them. He then pulled his own belt knife out, a lovely piece of work in dwarvish steel, and laid it beside the other. "What do you see?"

"Two knives?" Bilbo replied with a shrug. "What am I supposed to see?" Thorin simply gestured at the knives. Sighing, the hobbit glanced at the pair. Sting was leaf-shaped, blade curving out and back in the swooping lines that the elves loved so dearly. The blade seemed to be almost a single piece of metal and now that he examined it closely, he didn't see any forge marks or patterns in the metal at all. There wasn't even a grinding line, it was just... sharp. He also wasn't sure what metal it was made of, since it didn't look like steel or iron, not really once you examined it. The hilt was minimal and undecorated, a piece of unidentifiable dark wood with the same spare, swirling lines as the blade. Thorin's dagger, on the other hand, was a traditional blade shape, elongated and triangular, with two sharpened edges tapering abruptly to a point at the end. There were rippling patterns damascening the steel from where it had been folded and hammered over and over, or so Bilbo had been told; he knew little of the forge, but he had asked once. The hilt was a piece of darkened oak, patterned with a tight diamond pattern burnt into it for a better grip. Blue cabochon gems were set into it flush with the wood, and the finial was a larger rondel of the same gem. "Yours is certainly more complicated," Bilbo finally said. "But it's..." he paused, trying to wrap words around the idea he was forming. "It's not quite... the same."

Thorin smirked as Bilbo continued to peer at the pair of daggers. "Exactly. Well spotted. Mine is a knife, and made to be so. That..." he gestured at Sting, "is a device to kill orcs, if it's anything, that just happens to be knife-sized."

"What do you mean?" Bilbo said crossly, glancing at Sting. "You lot have always made fun of Sting, but I'll have you know..." Thorin shook his head, holding up his hands in apology.

"This isn't to mock," he said. "But to make a point. Would you use Sting to cut meat?" Bilbo paused but had to shake his head. "Alright. Would you use it to sculpt? Whittle? Carve a message? Trim rope?" He snickered at Bilbo's dumbfounded expression. "It's not a knife. A knife can be used for all of those things. This," he motioned at the elvish dagger, "is not. Look at it. Its shape is suited for nothing but fighting. It is made of some sort of bizarre alloy, more magic than metal. It glows when it's near an enemy of the old elves who made it; knives don't do that. It helps you fight; knives don't do that, either. I've never seen you sharpen it, because it doesn't need to be sharpened any more than my elvish sword does. That's not how blades work." He paused, clearly choosing his words with care. "Every craft of the dwarves takes a thing - just like your cooking does - and makes it a better expression of itself. Do you see? This knife, any knife made by a dwarf, is an attempt to express the most of the idea of what a knife is with the ingredients we have to work with. Each item is bound by ingredients, just as your dishes are; you couldn't make a mutton pie with no mutton, could you? No more could a dwarf make a good knife with weak iron. But the elves don't see it like that. They take whatever they've got and just make what they want to make out of it, so you end up with this," he waved again at the knife, "a knife made out of songs and moonbeams like a mutton pie made out of sand and blueberries. There's nothing of the ingredients in their things, it's all... them." Thorin paused. "What would you think of a cook that brought you a beef roast that turned into apples in your mouth? Or onions that tasted like plums?" Bilbo made a face in spite of himself. The idea was horrid but he saw Thorin's point. "Aye, but that's what they do with metal and wood." Thorin nodded as though he'd made a strong case and Bilbo was forced to concede that perhaps he had.

"I... see," the hobbit finally said, though he wasn't entirely sure that was true. "Let me think on it." Thorin nodded, and they passed to other things. The rest of the night was spent in conversations about more casual topics, politics and gossip and the struggles of Erebor's trickle of returning dwarves. At the end of the evening Thorin returned to his own rooms as dwarven propriety demanded that he must, though Bilbo longed for the day when they could just retire together. Still, he thought, that night he had plenty to think about. Every fixture and feature of his suite now appeared subtly different and pregnant with meanings he couldn't quite fathom.

Bilbo soon found that his new perspective accompanied him everywhere he went. The carvings that he had previously disregarded as simply meaningless dwarven decorations drew his attention, and the dwarves who noticed him looking smiled and moved around him as he stood instead of pushing rudely past. Even more interesting, he noticed other dwarves doing the same now, though he'd always assumed them lost in thought when (if) he'd noticed them blocking the paths before. Bilbo also noticed how everything, even the ladle in a water bucket, was made with care and craft to serve its purpose, and how broken things were treated with respect even when being discarded. Eavesdropping in spite of himself, he heard dwarves murmuring to each other about the history, real or speculated, of things all over the mountain. It certainly cast a different light on their reclamation efforts to the hobbit; it also made clear a lot of the things that seemed puzzling to him only weeks before, like the emphasis on preserving as much of the structures as possible instead of just building anew. Each thing the dragon had truly destroyed - and there were many - was a deep loss that could not be regained, no matter how long they labored, and that was a bitter pill to swallow.

On the third afternoon after his conversation with Thorin, Bilbo's errands brought him to what had been the grand market. It was hardly grand now; barely a half-dozen merchants were there, selling scraps of food and gear for exorbitant prices, but he stepped aside out of the door and looked at it again. Shafts cut high in the mountain allowed sunlight in, and luckily the dragon hadn't done anything to harm or block them. The lamps that had supplemented the natural light once upon a time lay in tangled masses against a side wall, all fallen chains and broken crystals; they had been carefully set aside against the day when an artifex might come who could repair them. The ruins of the shops and stalls stretched out in three stepped tiers, the outermost being against the rough exterior wall of the mountain itself. Thorin had explained at one point that it had been left rough to conserve heat and keep the cold from the outside at bay. Even as he watched, a reclamation crew was picking along the second tier, calling out to each other at some discovered item or another. The sadness and struggle of it all made him tear up for a moment, though he'd not have noticed a week ago he realized.

"We'll survive, lord," came a gruff voice from beside him. He glanced over to see a grim old dwarf who looked to be Balin's age. Despite the scowl lines in his face, the elder's dark eyes shone with a moment of sympathy. "Looks rough now, but we'll get it back. Hard part was gettin' that worm out," the old dwarf spat to one side, "but now? Mahal made us strong, you'll see." With a friendly nod, the old dwarf moved off leaving Bilbo shocked. Were his emotions that visible, he wondered, before nodding and heading to the merchants. Survive indeed. There was work to be done.

Thorin never mentioned the topic again directly, though he grinned broadly every time Bilbo did or said something to reveal his new understanding. Most pleasing to him of all was when the elvish sculpture quietly moved from the mantel to the receiving room for foreign guests, but he never commented on that, either. Bilbo wasn't the only one learning new things, it would seem.