Sorry, you need to have JavaScript enabled for this.

Actions

Work Header

Pluck the Strings

Summary:

In Arda, music is a fundamental and powerful force, originating from the divine Music of the Ainur, which created the Universe. Elves, Dwarrows, and Wizards all harness music in unique ways—to heal, build, and shape fate. Among mortals, each person is born knowing how to play one instrument: the key to their heartsong, a melody that connects them to their destined other half. Some sing instead of playing—these rare individuals are said to be whole. Rarest of all are those whose heartsongs span multiple instruments, suggesting a soul resonating with many melodies.
Bilbo Baggins, however, avoids his own instrument, hidden in his basement. When he plays it, he feels conflicting emotions—sorrow, anger, and unsettling confidence—suggesting his other half is brash and difficult. Bilbo would rather not deal with that at all.

Notes:

Me and my partner FiannaRain are late! We know. We both did not join the discord server for this event cause we did not knew there was a discord server for it! Sorry! Anyway enjoy!

(See the end of the work for more notes.)

Work Text:

Before Time itself takes its first breath, there is the Music of the Ainur, the Great Song from which Eä, the material Universe, is born. From that divine harmony springs all that is, and in Arda, the echoes of that first melody linger still. Here, music is no mere art; it is a force, ancient and ineffable.

The Elves weave light and air into song, their melodies delicate as moonlight on water, crafting potions that mend the gravest wounds and cure the deepest maladies. The Dwarrows, with voices like the rumble of stone, sing in deep, resonant hymns that raise mountains, forge unbreakable steel, and shape halls of legend beneath the earth. The Wizards speak a tongue laced with melody, an arcane cadence that bends fate itself when the need is great.

From symphonies that stir the skies to weep, to lullabies that cradle children into dreams, music is the breath of magic in Arda. It does not merely accompany life, it shapes it.

There is no song more well-known to mortals than their own heartsongs . Every mortal is born with the intrinsic knowledge of how to play an instrument. This instrument allows them to perform their heartsong, a melody that lets them feel and understand their other half.

Of course, there are some who have no instrument and instead sing their heartsongs by voice alone. Those rare few are said to be whole requiring no other half. Rarer still are those who can play their heartsongs with multiple instruments, these individuals are said to have their souls resonate with not a single melody but a chorus.

This is why Bilbo Baggins of the Shire abhors the instrument hidden in his basement. Whenever he plays it, he feels a deep sadness, a burning anger, and a disorienting sense of confidence. Whoever owns the other half of his soul seems confrontational, and generally sour. And Bilbo doesn’t want that in his life, thank you very much.

He first discovered his instrument on a whim.

His mother, Belladonna, had invited him on a trip to Bree to see the world beyond the rolling hills of the Shire. Young as he was, Bilbo had been thrilled at the idea of adventure. Bungo, his father, had been less enthusiastic, but he had never learned to say no to his wife, and so he went with them.

It had been a beautiful day. The sun shone brightly, unchallenged by clouds, as young Bilbo wandered among wares unlike any he had seen back in Hobbiton. Spices with unfamiliar scents, trinkets whose purposes he could not guess, and even real weapons, none of the wooden playthings he was used to.

But most thrilling of all had been the people. Bilbo had never seen Men before, and their towering height had terrified the little fauntling. The Elves unsettled him too; their youthful faces contrasted sharply with the ancient wisdom in their eyes, which reminded him too much of his grandpa. And the Dwarrows were so strange in appearance that he had hidden behind his mother’s skirts.

Belladonna had only laughed, coaxing him out gently, “Come now, my child, there’s no need to be afraid. These are good folk, like you, your father, and me!”

“Just be polite and mind your manners, son,” Bungo had added. “They aren’t as scary as you think.”

Bilbo had pouted, but nodded, taking his parents’ hands as they walked deeper into the market. And that’s when his eyes had fallen on it , the instrument.

It had called to him. It is right there in the forefront of a stall, made with fine wood and draped with a beautiful white fabric. An Elvish lass was selling it. She noticed his gaze and asked, “Would you like to try it?”

Bilbo nods and gently lets go of his parents’ hands. He picks up the instrument without thinking, his small, untrained fingers caressing the polished wood, drawn to its shape and weight as though by instinct. And then, he begins to play.

He remembers their shocked expressions. He remembers the song, his heartsong. A sad, mournful lament. Halfway through, he had stopped playing and burst into tears, the emotions of his other half overwhelming his young heart.

They had rushed him home, where he cried and cried. It had been unsightly, nothing like the proper Baggins his father had hoped to raise, but neither parent had scolded him. They were too worried. They should have known better. For someone so young, sharing emotions with a soul’s other half was a bewildering experience. His parents had known what the instrument was, and what it could awaken. They should have waited until Bilbo was older before allowing him near it. But the way Bilbo reacted was a far cry from the typical way a fauntling does when playing their instrument for the first time.  Bilbo had shaken and gasped, struggling under the weight of feelings not entirely his own. It was so much that his parents had agreed that he must never touch that instrument again.

But they didn’t want him to grow up without music.

So they taught him their instruments. Bungo played the piccolo, a light, agile instrument with a high, bright tone. It reminded Bilbo of his mother’s laughter as they played tag. Belladonna played the clarinet, smooth and mellow, full of refinement and depth. It made Bilbo picture his father teaching him lessons, telling him stories.

When his parents played together, the harmony was stunning. The piccolo brought excitement, motion, and energy; the clarinet offered warmth, grounding, and soul. They were different emotional tones, yet instead of clashing, they enhanced each other, just like his parents: a Took and a Baggins, coming together in love to give Bilbo a joyful home.

Hearing their heartsong made something ache in Bilbo’s chest, something too big for words, too old for someone so young to name.

He had laughed happily whenever they played for him. Still, a quiet itch remained, the need to play along.

But he couldn’t use his instrument.

To remedy this, his parents bought him other instruments. They found him teachers. In Arda, learning more than one instrument was not uncommon, especially since musicians were held in high regard. Bilbo enjoyed every lesson and celebrated each time he mastered a new instrument.

But nothing ever felt quite right.

The instrument in the basement still called to him. And each time he tried to answer, it overwhelmed him again with those violent, tangled emotions.

So, the years passed. Bag End filled with instruments of every shape and size. And one, dusty and silent, remained untouched in the basement.

Until that fateful day when his father died. And in a way, so did his mother.

Without Bungo, Belladonna became lifeless, dulled, and mute. Gone were the kind words, the stern talks, and the grand stories from his father. Gone were the laughter, the playful teasing, and the grand adventures from his mother. All that remained was a shell.

Sometimes Belladonna returned to herself, but only rarely. It usually happened when Bilbo’s extensive family tried to take Bag End from them, believing that without Bungo, the smial should go to a larger family better suited to care for it. Most of the time, she stayed in her room, lost in  mourning.

Bilbo remembered the few times he tried coaxing her out by playing the piccolo, the clarinet, or any instrument he could, any except his own. He only wanted to bring life back into his mother’s eyes. But as he trotted out each of his technical masteries nothing worked. Belladonna continued slowly withering away.

Terrified and desperate, after years of trying and failing to bring some life back into his mother, Bilbo finally picked up his own instrument and played, hoping that his other half could somehow help him.As before, the song was filled with anger, despair, longing, and more, but this time, he was not overwhelmed. Now, he understood.

It was loss.

A grief his other half had never truly forgotten. One that still ate away at them every day.Bilbo sobbed as he played, and with the song came knowledge, an old, painful realization from his other half. And then, his mother emerged from her room.

She looked nothing like the woman she had been before Bungo’s death. Gone was the plump, happy hobbit. In her place stood someone pale and thin, a mere shadow of the mother he once knew.

“Bilbo... I am so sorry,” she said, her voice hoarse with regret.

Bilbo only shook his head. “It’s fine, Mama… I’m old enough now. You don’t have to stay…”

Because what he had learned from his other half was this: to let go.

His mother had remained in this world far too long, clinging on for him. And it was up to him to allow her to rest.

That night, when she went to sleep, she never woke again.

Bilbo was a wreck after that.

He believed he had killed her. Blamed his other half for telling him what it did. In a moment of grief, he nearly destroyed the instrument, until he remembered that his other half had endured something similar. So he collapsed, weeping once more.

“What a sad pair we make…” he muttered to himself, trying to pull himself together, to appear respectable for his mother’s funeral.

After that, time passed in a blur.

Bilbo did his best to be a respectable hobbit so no one would question his claim to his parents’ smial, the only thing he had left of them, aside from the instruments. But playing any of them was too painful; they reminded him too much of what he had lost. Still, sometimes he needed to hear something, anything , to disrupt the deafening quiet.

But it was never enough.

And yet, Bilbo didn’t want to follow in his mother’s footsteps and become a hollow shell. So he opened Bag End as a music school, teaching fauntlings to play instruments, not their own, but others. Or helping them discover which one called to them.

It helped, a little.

The ache never went away, but the children made it bearable. As time passed, the ache dulled, but it was always there.

And he never touched his own instrument again.

Thankfully, none of the fauntlings ever felt called to it, and Bilbo was more than happy to keep it locked away in the basement. From time to time, he considered selling it, but he always shook his head and let it rot there instead.

And so, Bilbo Baggins, bachelor of Bag End, lived by a steady routine.

He woke up, completed his morning rituals, and after breakfast, checked on his garden. After second breakfast, he prepared for the children. The fauntlings arrived before elevenses, and stayed until just before dinner. Once they left, he reviewed his notes and correspondence. Then he had supper and went to bed.

It was a fulfilling routine, familiar and comfortable. Even though the quiet was sometimes deafening, most nights he was too tired to notice, and sleep came quickly.

But one day, that routine would be broken, by a wizard and a group of very rude dwarrows.

And Bilbo would never again feel the quiet he had grown so used to.


He doesn’t know how he found himself in this situation. When he said no to that wizard earlier ago, he thought he would never see him again! And yet here he is, with twelve dwarrows just messing up his smial. And then they had the audacity to sing a song about how he tries to keep everything in order! The nerve of them! And the wizard that brought them here didn’t even try to help!

“Chip the glasses and crack the plates!
Blunt the knives and bend the forks!
That's what Bilbo Baggins hates,
Smash the bottles and burn the corks!”

“Cut the cloth and tread on the fat!
Pour the milk on the pantry floor!
Leave the bones on the bedroom mat!
Splash the wine on every door!”

“Dump the crocks in a boiling bowl;
Pound them up with a thumping pole;
And when you’ve finished if any are whole,
Send them down the hall to roll!”

“That's what Bilbo Baggins hates!
So, carefully! carefully with the plates!”

When they had time to compose such a insulting song he will never know! And they sang in perfect harmony and accompanied it with instruments as well! How!? True the song is catchy he must admit and as a music teacher he can appreciate a jolly song but how dare they!? And when the so called leader of the Company finally came the hands-infuriating dwarf calls him a grocer! Him! Master of Bag End! A grocer!? The nerve! And then the contract about a dragon!? Oh there is no way he is signing that!

And so Bilbo left and found a quiet place to be by himself. Honestly, what kind of idiot believes that he, Bilbo Baggins, Master of Bag End, teacher of instruments, has not stolen anything in his life (except for some window sill pies back in his childhood but many faunts did that too), would be able to steal from a dragon!? They are fools, and Gandalf is the biggest one out of all of them for he actually knows Bilbo! And so he stays in that little corner of his, hoping beyond hope that time moves fast and the dwarrows are no longer here, and go off on their foolish quest without him as soon as possible.

And then the leader of the Company begins singing, and Bilbo jolts up. And the rest of the Company sings as well. It wasn’t like the song from before where its magic was meant to spread a simple joy, this one was far more magical in nature. It is filled with longing, mourning, despair, and hope all at once, and the visions it shows to everyone who listens is traumatizing yet oddly beautiful. The way the dragon came, the mountain home, the joys of living, the horrors of surviving.

“Far over the misty mountains cold
To dungeons deep and caverns old
We must away ere break of day
To seek the pale enchanted gold.”

“The dwarves of yore made mighty spells,
While hammers fell like ringing bells
In places deep, where dark things sleep,
In hollow halls beneath the fells.”

“For ancient king and elvish lord
There many a gleaming golden hoard
They shaped and wrought, and light they caught
To hide in gems on hilt of sword.”

“On silver necklaces they strung
The flowering stars, on crowns they hung
The dragon-fire, in twisted wire
They meshed the light of moon and sun.”

“Far over the misty mountains cold
To dungeons deep and caverns old
We must away, ere break of day,
To claim our long-forgotten gold.”

“Goblets they carved there for themselves
And harps of gold; where no man delves
There lay they long, and many a song
Was sung unheard by men or elves.”

“The pines were roaring on the height,
The winds were moaning in the night.
The fire was red, it flaming spread;
The trees like torches blazed with light.”

“The bells were ringing in the dale
And men looked up with faces pale;
Then dragon’s ire more fierce than fire
Laid low their towers and houses frail.”

“The mountain smoked beneath the moon;
The dwarves, they heard the tramp of doom.
They fled their hall, to dying fall
Beneath his feet, beneath the moon.”

“Far over the misty mountains grim
To dungeons deep and caverns dim
We must away, ere break of day,
To win our harps and gold from him!”

By the end of the song, Bilbo found himself silently crying. Feeling foolish for feeling the way he is when it didn’t even happen to him, he ran to his room and hid. Trying to control his emotions. And then past the wall, in the room beside his own, he hears Thorin’s voice softly singing alone with so much longing and hope and yet with a familiar cadence to it that Bilbo couldn’t help but listen.

“Far over the misty mountains cold
To dungeons deep and caverns old
We must away, ere break of day,
To find our long-forgotten gold.”

In the future, Bilbo would curse the Company, especially Thorin for weaving such a spell that he made the foolish decision to join them the next day. But he did join them, and he would have adventure no other hobbit before him could ever imagine.


And what a whirlwind of an adventure it is now. First, there were the trolls, Bilbo had to rescue the entire Company by buying them time, claiming they were infested with worms. By the Valar, it was only thanks to Thorin that they finally understood what Bilbo was trying to do. The others had made such a fuss until Thorin gave them a look that shut them right up. And then they meet another wizard, Radagast was his name that solidified Bilbo’s impression that all wizards are odd for the brown wizard seemed… off for the lack of a better term. Though he must admit, without the wizard they would have been dead for orcs and their wargs suddenly started hunting them and Bilbo was not a natural sprinter unlike his dwarven companions. Thankfully Gandalf brought them to Rivendell where they can finally rest but the Company is so rude, and frankly the elves aren’t helping!

“O! What are you doing,
And where are you going?
Your ponies need shoeing!
The river is flowing!
  O! Tra-la-la-lally
  here down in the valley!”

“O! What are you seeking,
And where are you making?
The faggots are reeking,
The bannocks are baking!
O! Tril-lil-lil-lolly
    the valley is jolly,
        ha! ha!”

“O! Where are you going
With beards all a-wagging?
No knowing, no knowing
What brings Mister Baggins,
  And Balin and Dwalin
  down into the valley
        in June
        ha! ha!”

“O! Will you be staying,
Or will you be flying?
Your ponies are straying!
The daylight is dying!
To fly would be folly,
To stay would be jolly
And listen and hark
Till the end of the dark
    to our tune
    ha! ha!”

Elladan and Elrohir happily sing their song, and urges their soldiers to do the same as they escort the Company into Rivendell, much to the chagrin of their charge.

“If they keep singing, I swear I will cut down their tongues!”, Dwalin glares hard at the twins, as if trying to shut them up by his gaze alone and this only made the twins sing louder with huge grins on their face.

“Brother calm down”, Balin sighs as he holds his brother’s shoulder in a placating manner

“I say, they do have nice voices”, Nori grins, knowing he is getting under Dwalin’s skin

“Perhaps we should ask them to sing a song for us during this meal they invited us to?”, Bofur, always the dwarf to do pranks with, quickly joins in

“I will have both of your heads on a platter”, Dwalin glares at them both and sputters when Nori gives him a wink, making Bofur laugh and Balin rub his temple, questioning how in Arda did he get there.

“We’ll be having what for dinner?”, Óin asks loudly, with his horn on his ear

“Meat hopefully”, Glóin replies with a sad look

“Think they’ll have ham?”, Bombur asks with a grin

“Anything but leaves”, Glóin says with clear disgust

“Kíli… stop staring at the elves”, Fíli grimaces as he looks at Kíli looking awestruck by the tall folks

“Hmm? What was that?”, Kíli snaps out of his trance

When Bilbo spots the twins looking at each other with playful twinkles in their eyes, the hobbit groans knowing what is about to happen. And Thorin just sighs, knowing he will have to deal with both elves and dwarrows alike.


Thorin abhors elves in any form. How dare they play a prank on the Company!? And that bloody wizard, daring to tell that tree-shagger about the map!? He has no right! And then their burglar! Oh, how he looked at those leaf-eaters in wonder! It makes Thorin’s blood boil just thinking about it all... Wait. Why does it make his blood boil? That doesn’t make any sense. Thorin shakes his head to clear the thoughts as he searches for a quiet place to play his lap harp.

The harp is his instrument, the symbol of the other half of his soul. He remembers how one day, perhaps around fifty-one years ago, he suddenly felt a pull toward the stringed instrument. Odd, since he had been around harps before, yet never felt compelled to touch one. He remembered the first time he played it; it filled him with innocent joy, simple delight, and a warm, fuzzy feeling. It quickly became his only escape from the burdens of his life, giving him peace of mind to know his other half lived such a happy life. He could stop and forget about the hardships he had been facing, about the hunger he felt, about the coldness, the worry for his sister and nephews’ lives, about his father, his mother, his brother, his grandfather, about Erebor. When he plays the harp, he feels at home, and that feeling has never been with him ever since the dragon.

Until one day, around fifteen years ago, the joy disappeared. Playing the harp brought only fear, mourning, and despair. The feeling was all too familiar, loss. His other half had lost someone, and they never recovered. From that day on, Thorin kept playing the harp, hoping his other half would begin to heal. But they never did, and the strain added to Thorin’s already heavy burdens. Then, around seven years ago, playing the harp made him feel angry, broken, and wronged. The emotions came so suddenly and powerfully that it frightened him. But after a few months, the music changed, still classical, still beautiful, but now rehearsed. Hollow. His other half had buried their feelings behind a false smile, merely surviving through routine. The harp no longer gave Thorin joy or an escape. But still, he plays, for it gives him hope that, someday, he’ll find his other half, and maybe then… they can stop surviving and start living.

Once he finds a quiet place, he takes out his lap harp, eager to feel any trace of his other half. But he stops when he hears familiar laughter and music drifting from one of the rooms. Knowing just how much trouble his nephews can get into, and considering they’re in Elven territory, Thorin groans and quickly strides toward the noise.

He pauses when he sees why the two are laughing, and it is not just them. All of the Company are showing off their own instruments and skill to the hobbit who didn’t join them back in Bag Ends in their festivities. “I remember hearing beautiful music but I didn’t know who played what since I didn’t see you all perform and well, I was overwhelmed”, Bilbo explains sheepishly smiling, “I’d really love to know who played the viol though, they were amazing”

“Ah there was two of us who played the viol, laddie. Which one?”, Balin answers with a delighted smile on his face

“It’s me wasn’t it?”, Dwalin asks with a grin

“Oh how would Bilbo know if you guys don’t play something!”, Bofur joyfully grabs two elven viols from the racks and tosses them towards the brothers who both easily catch them, though it made the poor hobbit gasp in horror.

“May I take the lead, brother?”, Balin asks with a glint of mischief in his eyes that Bilbo has never seen before

Dwalin squints his eyes at his older brother before he bangs his head against Balin’s, however it’s Dwalin who stumbles back, “Agh! Alright!”

Bilbo blinks in surprise, wondering what he just witnessed before Balin starts to play the viol. Bilbo knows a viol can produce softer and more intimate tones, than it’s more famous counterpart the violin and Balin leans into that. He is mildly surprised to notice that Balin is playing his heartsong, and for him too! Normally heartsongs are played only for one’s own indulgence, or with close friends or family. Does Balin already see him as one? But then again, he remembers that half of the Company is Balin’s kin so perhaps to him it is normal that he plays his heartsong. The melody is rich, tasteful even, yet there’s an undercurrent fussiness to it but remains classy. Bilbo is reminded of the heartsongs of his relatives in Bag End. As Balin ends his song, he bows with a satisfied grin on his face, “Well? Do I get the win?”

“My word… Balin that was beautiful! I must admit I was surprised to hear you play your heartsong but it was amazing! Your other half sounds like a delight”, Bilbo replies with a huge smile

“Oh he is”, Balin says with a soft smile, his eyes looking at none other than Dori who flushes. Bilbo’s mind pauses at the sudden realization that Dori is Balin’s heartsong. “Dwalin, think you can beat that?”

“Aye! I could!”, Dwalin answers the challenge and he begins to play his own viol in a far more aggressive yet playful manner. The melody feels mischievous, challenging, and outright naughty. Whoever Dwalin’s heartsong is, they must be quite the rebel. However Bilbo does notice that there is some similarities between the melody between Dwalin’s heartsong and his brother’s. Perhaps their heartsong’s are related? Then that would mean… Bilbo turns to look at Nori who looks back at him and gives him a rather mischievous grin and a wink. “So what do you think, Bilbo? Did I win?”

“Oh I can’t say. You both performed your heartsongs and I can’t exactly judge that!”, Bilbo believes judging a heartsong is scandalous for it is the very essence of a person, not to mention the two dwarrows who are those heartsongs are right there.

“Ah well, that is true! It’ll be quite rude to pick one over the other”, Balin says diplomatically

“Though we all know mine is better”, Dwalin though eggs his older brother on, making Balin roll his eyes fondly

“Since we heard Dwalin and Balin’s heartsongs, can we hear everyone else’s?”, Kíli suggests with a huge excited smile, and Bilbo makes an odd noise at how rude that question is! But everyone cheers and laughs so he assumes it is fine.

“Oh! Let me! It’s been so long since I played my heartsongs! Unlike you all I can’t carry around my instrument!”, Glóin laughs as he quickly runs towards a large piano, “It ain’t good dwarvish make but it’ll do and let me feel my beautiful gem!”, Glóin cracks his knuckles before he begins to play the large piano and Bilbo feels his jaw drop. His heartsong is filled with passion, and fervor that Bilbo can tell Glóin’s wife is a very fiery woman, but the second melodic line, sounds peaceful yet loving, letting the hobbit know that Glóin’s wife is also compassionate. By the end of Glóin’s heartsong, the dwarf sighs in relief, “Ah! Mizim is doing well! I needed to know!”

“That was wonderful! Glóin your wife sounds like she’s a very passionate woman”, Bilbo smiles before yelping when Glóin suddenly grabs him.

“Aye you’re right about that! Why let me tell you about the time she—”, Glóin gets cut off by Óin who loudly yells, “My turn!”

Bilbo is confused when he sees Óin walk to the center of the room without an instrument, until he realizes that Óin is one of the rare few gifted with a voice for their heartsong.

Bilbo, when he was younger, had at first thought that those who sang their heartsongs without instruments must be lonely folk, for they had no other halves. His parents gently corrected him, pointing out that he was often alone during playtime and still enjoyed himself. They reminded him that love comes in many forms.

And now, Bilbo can clearly hear it. Óin sings a song in Khuzdul that Bilbo does not understand, but he can hear the mischief, the stubbornness, and the kindness layered beneath the melody of his beautiful bass voice.

And to his surprise... a harmony.

“How in the—”

“Oh yes! My brother can sing two pitches at once, it’s amazing really”, Glóin informs him with a huge grin.

Óin finishes his song with a powerful belt before bowing. “Beat that!”

“We’re not competing”, Glóin rolls his eyes fondly

“That’s cause you’ll all lose to me!”, Kíli laughs as replaces Óin at the center of the room, holding his own fiddle. When Kíli begins to play Bilbo is quickly reminded of the music the elves played for them earlier during the meal, a song with an airy yet freeing feeling, though instead of a slow and calm tune, Kíli’s melody is fast, exciting, and daring, but still has all the elements of an elvi—Oh! Thorin will not like this, Bilbo can tell. When Kíli finally finishes he bows with a flourish, “Tada!”

“My turn!”, Fíli practically pushes his younger brother to claim the center of the room causing Kíli to glare at his older brother before laughing as Fíli begins to play his own fiddle. Bilbo hears a very refined classical tune with an undercurrent of cautious excitement beneath the melody, yet to Bilbo’s surprise it also sounds oddly similar to Balin and Dwalin’s heartsongs… Wait, does that mean? Bilbo turns to look at Ori who is watching Fíli with wide surprised eyes. It is a well known fact that people instantly recognize when a heartsong is from them. After all a heartsong is supposed to be from their other half so it is only natural that said other half would recognize their own melody.

And it seems Ori recognizes that he is Fíli’s heartsong, for as soon as Fíli is done, Ori takes his own instrument which is a flute and begins to play a lovely tune. Bilbo listens to the calm rhythm that occasionally leaps playfully between notes. Bilbo knows it is because Fíli while being more mature, is still as mischievous as his brother Kíli. Bilbo watches Fíli look at Ori a dumbfounded expression, having recognized his own heartsong as well. When Ori finishes his own melody, Fíli rushes over to Ori, picks up the dwarf and immediately goes in for a kiss. Unfortunately both Dori and Thorin pull them apart before their lips meet.

“Hey! Get off of me! He’s my heartsong!”, Fíli yells out trying to break free from Thorin’s grip

“Dori! Please! Brother!”, cries out Ori as he reaches for Fíli

“Now Ori, I congratulate you for finding your heartsong but that doesn’t mean you should rush a courtship”, Dori chides him

“Remember, any craft hastily made can easily be broken, this includes the crafting of a bond”, Thorin adds

Ori pouts while Fíli outright glares but it seems to have calm them both down. Thorin sighs while Dori just looks amused, “Oh dear, what would our kin say back home. All three of us have royalty as heartsongs”

“They’ll call us hahdumral birizu I’m sure. Oh the eyes they both gave us when they found out we were dating the sons of Fundin! And now our baby brother is with the crown prince? Ha! It’ll be fun”, Nori grins mischievously as he begins to play his heartsong as if laying a claim to Dwalin. And indeed anyone who knows Dwalin can easily identify who Nori’s heartsong is. Bilbo has never heard a flute sound so violent or ruthless before, but due to the nature of the instrument there is a gentleness beneath it all. Giving Bilbo a glimpse on who Dwalin is, that he unfortunately hasn’t seen yet. Dwalin practically looks giddy when Nori finishes his song, and such a reaction is not what Bilbo expected from the dwarf but he has heard love makes people do things that is not the norm for them. Yavanna knows Bungo Baggins was a very respectable hobbit before he met Belladonna Took.

Before Bilbo can think too much on his beloved deceased parents and put him into a spiral of despair, Dori happily plays his own heartsongs. Like his brother Nori, and Ori his is also a flute and it plays as one would expect from a flute. Serene, gentle, and beautiful. A very classical melody. But to Bilbo’s surprise, there is the same rather aggressive melody that he heard before from Nori’s song. He supposes that it’s because Balin is a warrior much like younger brother Dwalin. But there is more… menacing feel to it? Bilbo finds himself gulping in fear at that glimpse in the gentle Balin.

“Well since we’re all playing heartsongs let me bless your ears with the music of my wife’s soul!”, Bombur happily demands as he takes out his drum and starts loudly playing to the point Bilbo is unsure if his ears will be alright. Despite the intensity of the volume, Bombur’s heartsong is a jolly one that makes Bilbo feel excited and just ready to dance, which almost makes him choke up for it is a familiar feeling for it is the same one he felt when Bungo plays his heartsong, symbolizing his wife. It seems like Belladonna, Bombur’s wife, is a life of any party. “Alrís still as jolly as ever I hear!”, laughs Bombur when he finishes his performance, happy to know his wife is doing alright while he is so far away.

Bifur loudly declares something in Khuzdul that Bilbo cannot understand, but when the dwarf pulls out his clarinet, Bilbo can only assume he yelled, “My turn!” Bifur begins to play his heartsong, and it is incredibly cheerful, reminding Bilbo a bit of his mother. But then, it suddenly turns sorrowful. Bilbo notices the dwarrows all look as miserable as the music sounds, and he can’t help but catch the similarities between Bifur’s melody and Far Over the Misty Mountains Cold. Bifur continues playing, and slowly, the playfulness returns, but never with the same intensity.

Bilbo comes to a horrible realization. Unlike other heartsongs, which reflect the current state of one’s other half, this one seems to tell the entire life of Bifur’s other half... which can only mean that they are already dead. He gets confirmation when the heartsong increases in tempo, signaling danger, anger, and fear. Bilbo sees Balin, Dwalin, Óin, Glóin, and Thorin looking more desolate than the rest. And when Bifur’s song abruptly ends, Thorin stands and walks out of the room. The other four dwarrows quickly follow him.

“Bifur… I… Are you alright?” Bilbo asks, not knowing what else to say but still wanting to comfort him. In truth, he wishes to comfort Thorin more, but knows he isn’t exactly well-liked by that dwarf, unlike Bifur, who is kinder to him. “I know playing your heartsong can be painful…” Bilbo says softly.

He knows the Valar intended mortals to be able to continue playing their heartsongs even after their other half is gone, as a way to remember them. The heartsong, once meant to reveal the state of one’s other half, becomes a theme, a story of how they were born, lived, and died. Some find comfort in this. Others feel nothing but pain, for the song no longer changes. It becomes repeatable, stagnant, a cruel reminder that their other half is no longer there. Bilbo knows many widows back in Hobbiton who refuse to play their heartsongs, unable to bear hearing the same song over and over again. But to his surprise, Bifur simply smiles and joyfully responds in Khuzdul.

Bofur translates for him. “My cousin says he loves playing Frerin’s heartsong. He cherishes the memories, even with the abrupt ending. He’ll always be happy to play in his memory,” Bofur says with a wide grin.

Bilbo is mildly surprised. Frerin, yes, he remembers now, is Thorin’s brother. That explains why Thorin walked out just now.

“Is Thorin going to be alright?” Bilbo asks, genuinely concerned for their leader.

“Thorin? Yeah, he’s alright. Just give him a minute or two,” Bofur replies casually. “While we wait, how about I play my heartsongs?”

Bilbo pauses. Heartsongs? Plural?

“You’re gifted with more than one instrument?” he asks, delighted. Back in Hobbiton, there are a few like that, though rare. Bofur nods cheerfully.

“Yes, I am! The clarinet and the flute!” Bofur replies proudly. “I’ll play one now!” he adds just as Thorin and the others return, seemingly recovered from the weight of memory.

Bilbo watches Thorin from the corner of his eye. He wants to approach, to say something comforting, but he knows it would be overstepping. They don’t know each other as well as he wishes they did. Any gesture might just make things awkward for them both.

Thankfully, Bilbo’s thoughts clear when Bofur begins to play. First, the dwarf lifts his clarinet, and a warm yet melancholy sound fills the room. An image forms in Bilbo’s mind, exhausted parents picking up faunts from their music lessons. There’s an undertone of fear woven into the melody as well. It sounds as if one of Bofur’s halves is a tired parent. Maybe his other halves have already met? But then comes another layer, a quiet grief that lingers beneath the notes. Is Bofur’s other half... a stagnant heartsong?

“That’s one of my halves!” Bofur exclaims cheerfully. “They sound like they need a break! But this one, this one totally needs to get out more!” He switches the clarinet for a flute and begins to play a light, airy melody.

It carries a different energy altogether. There's an ancient wisdom behind it, but it’s laced with deep, buried anger and an aching guilt. Grief floods the notes, so strong that Bilbo almost cries. The emotions are overwhelming, and he finds himself wondering how Bofur handles it so easily. After all, he knows too well how heartsongs can overpower you. But the dwarf plays on, smiling, unaffected. When the song ends, Bofur bows with a theatrical flourish.

“They both sound like they need a drink, don’t they?” he jokes brightly.

Bilbo blinks. “You’re not scared of them? That your other halves seem to carry so much baggage?” he blurts out before he can stop himself. His hands fly to his mouth in horror. Oh no. Father would roll in his grave for such disrespect.

He didn’t mean it like that. He too has a heartsong heavy with grief, one that has overwhelmed him so often that he stopped playing it. The last time he did... No. He didn’t kill her. He just let his mother go. Bilbo reminds himself again: His other half also lost someone. He shouldn’t blame them.

“I mean, I’ve got baggage too,” Bofur says with a shrug and a smile. “So I can’t exactly complain. And even if I didn’t, they’re still my heartsong. I want to lighten their burden. That’s why I try my best to always be happy, so they know I’m alright. Maybe, if they hear my cheerful melody, it’ll brighten their day.”

Bilbo feels a pang of guilt. He’s spent so long fearing his own heartsong, afraid of the intensity, the sorrow, the weight of someone else’s pain echoing through him.

“What about you, Bilbo?” Kíli pipes up, grinning. “Why don’t you play something for us?”

Bilbo hesitates, thankful for the distraction as Fíli continues shamelessly flirting with Ori using Iglishmêk. Bilbo can’t understand the hand signs, but judging by how red Ori turns, it’s either incredibly sappy or downright filthy. Judging by Dori’s gasp and how quickly he covers Ori’s eyes, definitely filthy. Nori nods in approval, which only confirms it.

“Oh, um… I can’t. My instrument isn’t here,” Bilbo lies weakly.

But every dwarf in the room catches the brief flick of his eyes toward a particular instrument.

“Oh, come on, Bilbo! Please?” Kíli pleads as he dashes over, picks up the large elven instrument, and practically shoves it into Bilbo’s hands.

Bilbo yelps and nearly topples under its size. The weight of it, physical and emotional, unsettles him.

“I mean, it’d be rude to hear all of our heartsongs, but not yours, right? And you’re all about manners, after all!” Kíli teases with a grin.

“Oh I really don’t know how to play this instrument”, Bilbo awkwardly laughs as he tries to right himself, feeling incredibly uncomfortable.

Balin notices his discomfort and quickly steps in, “Now laddie, we saw no such instrument back at Bag Ends which means Bilbo can’t play such a thing”

Bilbo sighs in relief, knowing he hid that blasted instrument inside the basement where none of the dwarrows went into. “I still don’t know my instrument! My apologies”, much to his luck, Bilbo’s stomach suddenly growls much to the dwarrows’ surprise since they are certain they just had a meal earlier, “A—Ah that is— um… I gotta go”, the hobbit takes the time to run away in embarrassment

“But he does know his instrument! We all saw his eyes shift to it!”, Kíli complains once the hobbit is far away

Balin is about to interject when Thorin speaks, “Kíli, perhaps the Burglar lost his other half and feels pain whenever he has to play his heartsong”, and then Kíli who quickly shuts up. He knows it all too well since back home, many of their people continue to lose their lives. From disease, accidents, or orc attacks. “Leave him alone, nephew.”, Thorin adds even though there’s something inside his chest that stirs at the image of Bilbo being with someone else. He shakes his head, thinking he is only tired and so his thoughts are drifting. “Everyone go and rest. As soon as we got the elf to read the runes we are out of here”


Bilbo wonders how this happened. Earlier he was enjoying his respite in beautiful Rivendell. Now here he is, following the dwarrow as the goblins lead them deeper into their tunnels. Bilbo tries his best to hide inside the group of larger bodies of the dwarrow, as they move and in doing so bumps into Thorin. Bilbo immediately steps back, Thorin’s hurtful words from earlier still lingering in his mind,  “M—my apologies, I didn’t mean t—”

Thorin shuts him up as he suddenly grabs Bilbo and hides him beneath his cloak, “Silence Burglar. If they find you, the smallest of our Company then you will be targeted.”

Bilbo frowns, feeling like a burden as they continue to move. As they do so the goblins continue to sing their horrible song.

“Clap! Snap! the black crack!
Grip, grab! Pinch, nab!
And down down to Goblin-town
    You go, my lad!”

“Clash, crash! Crush, smash!
Hammer and tongs! Knocker and gongs!
Pound, pound, far underground!
    Ho, ho! my lad!”

“Swish, smack! Whip crack!
Batter and beat! Yammer and bleat!
Work, work! Nor dare to shirk,
While Goblins quaff, and Goblins laugh,
Round and round far underground
    Below, my lad!”

Bilbo frowns as he covers his ears, the goblin voices, and horrible excuses of instruments sound more like screeches and screaming. They do not sound anything like harmony but instead sounds more like discord. And the very foothold they’re on always creaks with each step that Bilbo fears it’ll break and they’re all going die a horrible death. Bilbo’s body shakes in fear only to stop when he feels Thorin’s arms wrap around him, and the dwarf whispers into his ear, “We will be alright. Do not lose hope”, and there feeling the warmth of Thorin all around him, Bilbo feels oddly at peace.


Well, now he doesn’t! With Gandalf’s timely arrival, they manage to escape Goblin-town, only to be chased by wargs and their orc riders to the edge of a cliff, forcing them all to climb trees. And now here is Bilbo, clinging to a branch for dear life while the dwarrow hurl burning pinecones at their enemies.

Which should be a good idea… if the trees that they’re on weren’t also prone to catching fire! So much for the intelligence of wizards, giving them flaming ammunition as if their only lifeline can’t burn!

As if that weren’t enough the orcs starts to screeching, with the large pale orc as the lead, who Thorin is glaring bloody murder at.

“Fifteen birds in five fir-trees,
their feathers were fanned in a fiery breeze!
But, funny little birds, they had no wings!
O what shall we do with the funny little things?
Roast 'em alive, or stew them in a pot;
fry them, boil them and eat them hot?”

“Burn, burn tree and fern!
Shrivel and scorch! A fizzling torch
To light the night for our delight,
    Ya hey!”

“Bake and toast 'em, fry and roast ’em
till beards blaze, and eyes glaze;
till hair smells and skins crack,
fat melts, and bones black
    in cinders lie
    beneath the sky!”

      “So dwarves shall die,
and light the night for our delight,
    Ya hey!
    Ya-harri-hey!
    Ya hoy!”

The orcs cheer as the trees the Company clings to begin to topple over the cliff, and naturally, the dwarrows, and hobbit alike, add their screams to the ruckus. Well, at least if Bilbo dies from falling such a height, his death will be swift, unlike with goblins or orcs who would surely torture him first before granting him the relief of death.

As that grim thought crosses his mind, Bilbo watches in horror as Thorin suddenly pulls himself up and charges toward the large pale orc. He looks incredibly handsome as he does, like a living legend, only to be defeated almost instantly.

A surge of adrenaline floods Bilbo’s body as he sees an orc advance on Thorin, and in the very next instant, Bilbo does something very, very stupid.


“The wind was on the withered heath,
but in the forest stirred no leaf:
there shadows lay by night and day,
and dark things silent crept beneath.”

“The wind came down from mountains cold,
and like a tide it roared and rolled;
the branches groaned, the forest moaned,
and leaves were laid upon the mould.”

“The wind went on from West to East;
all movement in the forest ceased,
but shrill and harsh across the marsh
its whistling voices were released.”

“The grasses hissed, their tassels bent,
the reeds were rattling—on it went
o'er shaken pool under heavens cool
where racing clouds were torn and rent.”

“It passed the lonely Mountain bare
and swept above the dragon's lair:
there black and dark lay boulders stark
and flying smoke was in the air.”

“It left the world and took its flight
over the wide seas of the night.
The moon set sail upon the gale,
and stars were fanned to leaping light.”

Thorin listens to the voices of the Company as they offer their songs in thanks for Beorn’s hospitality. He still mistrusts the shapeshifter, and Gandalf’s announcement that he will not be joining them through Mirkwood only sours Thorin’s already foul mood, especially as he remains confined to bed with his injuries. He finds himself longing for his harp, to play his heartsong and check if his other half is faring any better than he is. It would bring him a measure of calm, as it always has. Alas, the goblins took his harp, and now all he can do is listen to the voices of his companions as they sing to entertain their host.

He tries to sit up when he hears someone enter the room and groan out, “Óin, any notable news?”, assuming it’s the Company healer checking on him.

But he stiffens when he hears Bilbo’s voice instead.

 “Oh, um… I don’t think so, other than the Company ransacking poor Beorn’s larder like they did with mine all those months ago,” Bilbo laughs nervously, and Thorin can see just how uncomfortable the hobbit is.
“I brought you some food. Óin said you should eat, but nothing too solid yet…”

“Master Baggins… I apologize for my words before…” Thorin says, knowing he already offered an apology back when he embraced the hobbit at the Carrock, but words, he’s learned, often mean little without action. Too many promises from other dwarven clans have gone unfulfilled when it matters most. For Bilbo, who has known little but coldness from him, his sudden kindness must be confusing.

 “You don’t have to force yourself to be near me, Master Baggins. I wouldn’t blame you.”

Bilbo shakes his head. “No, no. The others need their rest, and I was carried halfway through our journey. I can at least let them rest in peace by doing something as simple as bringing you food.”

“Then I’ll gladly eat,” Thorin replies with a soft smile, accepting the offering.

Bilbo lingers awkwardly, so Thorin asks about his home, knowing the hobbit enjoys speaking of it. Bilbo takes the bait and begins to talk about the rolling green hills, the bustling markets, and the incredible amounts of food one can find there. Thorin listens with quiet contentment, unaware that this would become a routine during their stay at Beorn’s. Bilbo always brings him food, and while Thorin eats, the hobbit shares news about the Company. When there’s none to give, he talks about his neighbors, his relatives, the Shire, so vividly that Thorin feels he could navigate Hobbiton’s winding roads as well as those of Ered Luin.

Over time, Thorin finds himself speaking too, of things he normally keeps guarded. He tells Bilbo about being raised a prince, how he used to complain about his lessons, the deep pain of losing his family, the crushing burden of being an exiled king. He even shares his frustration at broken alliances, and the bittersweet joy of raising Fíli and Kíli. He doesn’t know why it’s so easy to speak to Bilbo. There’s a peace the hobbit brings that he can’t ignore. Looking back, perhaps it was always there, he simply didn’t allow himself to feel it. His guard was always raised around the stranger who was Bilbo.

But now? Bilbo feels like kin.

The hobbit no longer looks nervous, his eyes no longer dart to the door, and his hands no longer fidget awkwardly behind his back. Thorin likes to believe that Bilbo feels the same, and that the tension, tension Thorin knows he caused, has finally lifted.

It feels… freeing.

Almost like how it felt to play his heartsong in those early days, when it was still an innocent joy, before grief hollowed it out. Before it became a carefully practiced performance, refined but hollow. When was the last time he poured his heart out to another? It must have been before Frerin died… before Dís was overwhelmed by loss and the burden of raising her children alone.

Maybe, when this is all over, he can introduce Bilbo to Dís. Maybe the hobbit will bring her the same calm he brings to Thorin.

When Óin finally allows him to escape bedrest, Thorin wants nothing more than to spar with Dwalin, to get his muscles back in shape and test his strength in a proper fight, much to Óin’s exasperation.

“I said to take it easy! Sparring is not taking it easy!” the healer snaps.

“Óin, I know my limits well. I—”

Thorin is cut off by Óin’s sudden laughter, and he glares at the older dwarf, about to scold him for such disrespect, even though he knows Óin would ignore it, when Bilbo enters and sees Thorin on his feet rather than in bed.

“Oh! Can you walk now?” Bilbo asks with delight.

“Aye, laddie, he can,” Óin answers before Thorin can. “But he has to take it easy. Or it’s back to bedrest!”
He practically points his hearing horn at Thorin like a weapon, and knowing Óin, he very well might use it that way.

“Can I take him for a walk around the garden then?” Bilbo asks hopefully. “It’s such a wonderful day, and some fresh air and sunshine would do him good. And perhaps he can thank the bees for making the honey he so loves to devour as well?”

“Master Baggins, I am right here,” Thorin says with a chuckle. “You could ask me instead of Óin.”

“I would,” Bilbo replies with a grin, “but I know how you like to torture yourself, injuring yourself for others’ sake. That’s why I’m asking your healer instead.”

Thorin can’t help but smile wider. Normally, such cheek would boil his blood, but Bilbo says it with such wit and charm that it only amuses him. It reminds him of the old days, when he and his siblings traded barbs without fear of crossing a line. But now, without Frerin to play peacekeeper, the tension between him and Dís can sometimes spiral too far.

“Yes, yes, Thorin can go enjoy the garden, if he can, ” Óin replies with a chuckle. “Most dwarrows aren’t exactly fond of plants.”

“Óin, your interest in plants is solely based on their herbal properties! Nothing of their beauty or scent!” Bilbo cries in mock dismay.

“Nah, laddie, I don’t need you to pay me a cent,” Óin says, putting his hearing horn back to his ear.

“Honestly!” Bilbo huffs. “Come, Thorin, let’s get you filled up with breakfast before I show you the garden.”

Bilbo happily leads Thorin out of the room and into the dining hall. The moment they step inside, the Company erupts in loud cheers.

“Uncle! So good to see you out and about!” Fíli says from where he sits, right next to Ori, who shyly looks away. Thorin also notices Ori is holding Fíli’s hand.

Thankfully, Dori and Dwalin sit close by, a silent wall of propriety to make sure the young couple behaves... at least while others are watching.

Thorin watches as Bilbo interacts with the others during mealtimes. Where once Bilbo had kept to himself, hiding in a small corner or sitting quietly beside Tharkûn, now he laughs with them all and even mothers the younger dwarrows. Thorin watches as Bilbo scolds Kíli for stealing a piece of bread from Fíli’s plate, passes cups of tea to Dori and Ori, tells Nori that no, he can’t have mead this early in the day, ensures Dwalin doesn’t sneak cookies from Balin’s bowl, somehow convinces Óin and Glóin to eat their vegetables, and tries to decipher what Bifur is saying, with the help of Bombur and Bofur.

It finally feels like Bilbo is part of the group.

And that makes Thorin feel guilty. He knows it is his own fault that Bilbo took so long to be included. So much so that he decides, then and there, to play Bilbo a song. He remembers snippets of conversation overheard between Bilbo and Tharkûn, and from observing Bag End with its many instruments, he knows Bilbo is a lover of music.

It’s true their relationship has grown warmer, and Thorin can now call the hobbit a friend. But still, he feels a deep need to please him. Thorin doesn’t fully understand why… though perhaps he has some inkling. He can’t seem to stop noticing how pleasing it is to see Bilbo smile, or how the hobbit’s laughter feels so familiar, so comforting, that it brings him joy.

He wonders, just wonders, if Bilbo might be his heartsong.

But no. That can't be. Based on Bilbo’s reaction to his instrument back in Rivendell, it's clear his heartsong has died. Playing music only brings him pain now. So yes, the thought that he could be Bilbo’s heartsong is a foolish notion. Still, Thorin wants to be dear to him, even if only as a friend.

After the meal, Thorin follows Bilbo into the garden, listening happily as the hobbit talks about plants and their uses, in a language unique to hobbits, one Thorin finds oddly similar to the dwarvish gem-language.

As they stroll, they come across Beorn standing by a patch of towering yellow flowers. Thorin is sure Bilbo told him their name earlier, but he had been too distracted by the hobbit’s smile. He had pretended interest to avoid being rude, but he still can’t recall the name.

“Ah, so the exiled king is awake,” rumbles Beorn.

“I must thank you again for allowing my Company respite in your lands, Master Beorn,” Thorin says, inclining his head in a respectful gesture, not a full bow, of course. His station won’t allow that. Beorn, however, seems mildly amused.

“No thanks necessary. Though perhaps now you can pay for your own stay?” Beorn says with a smirk. “I’ve heard each member of your Company play music, except you. The Grey Wizard and the little bunny are exempt. They entertained me with amusing stories instead. But you, King Thorin, have yet to give me anything.”

 He hands Thorin a harp, an Elvish lap harp, to Thorin’s displeasure. Still, a harp is a harp, and he has been meaning to play for Bilbo anyway. If he can fulfill both goals at once, all the better.

“Very well,” Thorin says. “I shall play for you both.”

He tentatively plucks the strings to test the tuning. Satisfied, he begins to play. He means to choose a common dwarvish drinking song. But when he looks at Bilbo, at those eyes that shift between emerald, sapphire, and moonstone, his fingers instead begin to play his heartsong.

He hasn’t played it since the beginning of their journey. Without that connection, he has worried for his other half’s wellbeing. But as the melody flows, he doesn’t hear the hollow, rehearsed sorrow he expected. Instead, the song is alive, with excitement, fear, hope, and wonder.

When he finishes, he looks to Bilbo and finds the hobbit frozen, wide-eyed.

“That was… beautiful, Thorin,” Bilbo says softly, dazed. Then, suddenly, he takes a step back, flustered. “I—I have to go help Ori. I’ll see you later, Thorin!”

 He turns and bolts, leaving Thorin standing alone and confused.

Out of sight, Bilbo curls into himself and lets out a quiet sob.

He had recognized the melody instantly.

It’s his melody. His song.

Now everything makes sense, all the intense emotions he’s felt whenever he played that bloody instrument: the grief, the anger, the bravery. They belong to Thorin Oakenshield.

And what is Bilbo to do with that knowledge?

He’s just a hobbit… and the Valar have fated him to a king.


Hobbit Bilbo might be, but he is a sneaky hobbit, the same one who once managed to slip past trolls and escape the notice of giant spiders. And now, here he is again, crouched in a bush with a daring plan to free his captured companions. He just hopes they all survive it.

The plan is simple: lure the spiders away, then cut the dwarrows down before anything else goes wrong. For this, he needs magic.

Bilbo has channeled magic through music before. Everyone in Arda does, though it’s usually simple magic, songs to spark joy, ease fear, entertain, or soothe. But today, he’s going to attempt something more difficult, a kind of mischief he hasn’t done since he was a faunt playing tricks on neighbors and kin. It’s been years. He’s not sure it will even work.

Still, he has to try. For the Company.

He begins to sing, softly at first, but the magic takes hold. His voice doesn’t emerge from his mouth but instead echoes from a distance away, exactly as he intends:

“Old fat spider spinning in a tree!
Old fat spider can’t see me!
    Attercop! Attercop!
      Won't you stop,
Stop your spinning and look for me?”

Bilbo slaps a hand over his mouth and waits, heart pounding.

It works.

The giant spiders twitch, then scuttle toward the sound of his projected voice. As soon as they’re out of sight, Bilbo sprints to the tree where the dwarrows hang suspended in their silken prisons. He climbs quickly, adrenaline fueling him as he begins slicing through the webs. He doesn't free them completely just yet, keeping the silk intact enough to cushion their fall.

Then he hears it.

Fighting. From the direction the spiders went.

Fear tightens in his chest. He doesn’t know who or what is battling the spiders, but he has no time to question it. He redoubles his efforts, nearly slipping in his rush to descend and begin tearing open the webbing on the ground.

“Please tell me you're all alive in there. I’d be so disappointed if you dwarrows couldn’t survive a fall wrapped in silk,” Bilbo tries to joke, but his voice trembles with worry as he slices into the first cocoon.

Kíli bursts out, gasping for breath.

“Bilbo! Thank you!” he cries with a smile.

“You’re welcome. Now help me get the others free before those things come back!” Bilbo says frantically.

Kíli nods and grabs a blade to cut down the others. One by one, the freed dwarrows join the effort, hastily releasing their companions. Fortunately, the spiders hadn’t thought to remove their weapons, too many legs and not enough brains, so the group works fast.

Still, Bilbo notices sluggish movements. The venom is still in their systems, dulling their reflexes and slowing them down.

When they finally free Bombur, a heavy silence settles over the forest.

The fighting has stopped.

Bilbo’s ears twitch. The absence of noise is worse than the chaos. Something isn’t right .

“They’re coming back,” he says urgently. “We have to go. Now.”

“I agree with our Burglar,” Thorin says. “Move swiftly. We must escape before they co—”

He stops abruptly.

An arrow is pointed at him.

An elf stands before him, golden hair gleaming, eyes narrowed in suspicion. All around them, bows are drawn, aimed at every dwarf. Bilbo lets out a startled, undignified noise as he turns to find an entire patrol of Elves surrounding them. Unlike the spiders, these captors are clever enough to take their weapons.

Bilbo groans inwardly.

And now he wonders, how in the Shire is he going to get them out of this one?


First of all, Bilbo apologizes, again , to both the Elves and his dwarrows for accidentally luring the spiders right to where the Elves were stationed. He only meant to draw the spiders away from his friends; he had no idea the Elves were even there. Nothing more, nothing less. Secondly, Thorin spitting on their king has absolutely nothing to do with him. And for the last time, no, he is not a child!

Bilbo sighs, rubbing his temples. It’s been, well, he doesn’t know how long they’ve been down here. There’s no sunlight underground to tell the time, but according to Balin, nearly two weeks have passed. At least they’ve been thrown into cells together. Misery loves company, after all, and it helps to have someone to talk to, and to huddle with for warmth when the nights get cold.

Thorin, naturally, is concerned that Fíli and Ori are in a cell together. He trusts his nephew, and Ori, but still… dwarrows are passionate by nature, and privacy is nonexistent in these cells. Much to Thorin’s dismay, and Dori’s fury , a suspicious noise had echoed from their cell a few nights ago.

“Fíli, you might be the first prince, but I will kill you if you dare touch my brother in a cell!” Dori hisses, eyes blazing.

“I—I was just giving Ori a massage!” Fíli yells, clearly flustered.

“M—My back was aching from sleeping on the floor!” Ori adds quickly, face redder than a ripe tomato.

“Should I bring you more blankets, then?” Tauriel, the captain of the Elven guard, asks with an amused smile.

“I believe we should ,” Legolas, son of King Thranduil, chuckles, much to the Company’s collective annoyance.

At first, Bilbo fears both Tauriel and Legolas. Their underlings are often rude, sometimes downright cruel, to the dwarrows, and Bilbo is only just beginning to understand why. According to Balin, Thror’s madness led him to hoard a piece of jewelry that Thranduil had commissioned for his ailing wife. When she died, Thranduil never forgave the dwarrows. So when Smaug descended upon Erebor, the Elvenking gave no aid, no quarter.

Bilbo sympathizes with Thranduil’s grief and understands why he might have despised Thror. But punishing the entire dwarven kingdom for the failings of one mad king? That’s something Bilbo can’t excuse.

Thankfully, both Tauriel and Legolas seem to have put that old grudge aside, or at least know not to direct it at the current Company. Bilbo suspects they understand that Thror alone earned their ire. Unfortunately, the Company doesn’t make it easy to maintain peace. Every day, more insults are hurled at their elven captors, and Bilbo groans every time it starts.

At least one of them seems to enjoy the company of the Elves.

“Perhaps you could sneak into my cell and warm me up instead?” Kíli calls out, his voice smooth and unmistakably flirtatious.

Bilbo doesn’t need to see him to know he’s waggling his eyebrows.

Tauriel giggles, giggles! , and Legolas groans in exasperation while the rest of the Company turns on Kíli instead, launching a fresh volley of insults for daring to flirt with an elf.

This is how most of their time in Thranduil’s dungeon passes: with banter, bickering, and Bilbo somehow trying to be the only adult in the room.

Despite everything, Bilbo must admit, he enjoys sleeping next to Thorin. Those large, powerful arms wrapped around him keep him warm, and Thorin’s scent is... comforting. Not that he’d ever admit that aloud. So, Bilbo always falls asleep easily in his arms, using the comfort to ignore the ache in his empty stomach.

What Bilbo doesn’t know is that his behavior worries Thorin, and the rest of the Company. They all know Bilbo eats more than a typical dwarf, and though they’ve tried offering him their shares, he always refuses, insisting they need the food just as much as he does and that he’ll be fine.

They could ask their elven captors for more, but... their pride won’t allow it. Even Kíli, despite his constant flirting, doesn’t ask, and Nori, who shares his cell, wouldn’t let him if he tried. Not that it stops Kíli from flirting; Nori, naturally, enjoys the chaos.

Now, as Thorin wraps his arms around the sleeping hobbit, he frowns. He can feel Bilbo’s ribs through his shirt. The hobbit has been sleeping more and more, and each day he seems thinner. Thorin fears what it means.

As the second week draws near, Thorin is startled when Bilbo suddenly stands, walks up to the cell bars... and slips through them.

“Ugh, finally,” Bilbo sighs, stretching his arms in relief.

The dwarrows gape at the sight, but before anyone can shout in joy or confusion, Thorin hushes them sharply.

“Master Baggins,” Thorin says, voice low and tense, “did you... starve yourself to fit through the bars?”

“Well... yes. I noticed the bars were designed for taller folks, not hobbits. So, I figured if I got small enough, I could slip through.” Bilbo dusts himself off. “Now I’m going to try to find a way to free you all before the guards come back—”

But before he can turn to leave, Thorin reaches through the bars and catches his arm, pulling him close.

“Bilbo,” Thorin says, voice soft and urgent, “please don’t do anything reckless. You are my— our only hope. Think of your safety first. If you find an opportunity to escape, take it . Don’t look back. Find Tharkûn. He’ll know what to do. Please, promise me.”

Bilbo stares at him, stunned. “O—Of course,” he says after a beat. “I don’t plan on getting recaptured. I’ll try my best, but I won’t leave this place without all of you.”

Then he runs off, disappearing into the elven stronghold, and the Company watches helplessly, their hearts heavy. His movements are sluggish from hunger, and they can only pray to Mahal to guide their smallest member.

Running through the elven realm proves easier said than done. Bilbo nearly gets caught more times than he can count, but his small, starved frame and natural hobbit stealth give him plenty of hiding spots. Unfortunately, he finds no obvious way out.

To his luck, some kind of festival seems to be taking place, he can hear music and laughter drifting through the halls, and the number of guards has noticeably thinned. Those who are still on duty seem to be in varying stages of drunkenness.

Still, escape eludes him.

Then, his eyes land on a musical instrument resting on a table.

A sudden memory strikes, of a dwarf playing his heartsong with an elven-like melody.

He has no idea why, maybe it's the hunger, maybe desperation, but his brain tells him this is a good idea. Without thinking twice, he grabs the instrument and races back toward the dungeons where his companions wait.

“Kíli, play your heartsong,” Bilbo says, thrusting the fiddle through the bars for Kíli to take.

The confused dwarf grabs it, eyes wide. “W—What?”

“Just trust me!”

“Bilbo! How is playing an instrument going to help us!? He’ll only attract guards!” Glóin snaps, clearly upset.

“Hobbit! They’ll question how Kíli even got it in the first place! This is not a good idea!” Dwalin growls, glaring.

“Just trust me! Kíli, play your heartsong. Now,” Bilbo urges, voice desperate. “I know your heartsong is someone here , and they’ll be able to help us. Trust me!”

Of course, the dwarrows immediately start yelling again, but Thorin silences them all with a commanding shout.

“Master Hobbit,” he says coolly, narrowing his eyes. “Are you saying my nephew has an... elf for a heartsong?” His voice drips with barely concealed disdain at the word elf .

“Yes. I’m certain. And they can help us escape,” Bilbo answers firmly.

“How? How are you certain ?” Thorin presses, fixing Bilbo with an intense stare that makes the hobbit fidget.

“I’m a music teacher, Thorin. I can read heartsongs better than most. Every race has a preferred musical style. And Kíli’s heartsong? It carries the style elves favor. Please, trust me. You said I was your hope…”

Thorin regards him for a long moment, expression unreadable, then nods.

“Kíli… play your heartsong. But first, Bilbo, come back in here.”

Bilbo slips through the bars again, but he’s so exhausted he barely manages a step before he collapses. Thorin catches him with a startled gasp, cradling the too-light hobbit in his arms.

Then Kíli begins to play.

As always, his heartsong has that airy, adventurous quality, but now it carries an undertone of confusion, curiosity, and uncertainty. It trembles a little at first but slowly finds its voice, growing steadier and stronger.

Just as the dwarrows predicted, an elf comes to investigate the sound from the cells. Tauriel appears in the doorway, silent as a shadow. She watches as Kíli continues to play. The song changes again, gaining clarity, purpose, recognition.

When he finally finishes, Tauriel walks to Kíli’s cell... and unlocks it.

The dwarrows immediately begin yelling, warning her not to touch him, but everyone falls silent when Tauriel leans in and kisses Kíli. Time seems to freeze.

Kíli moans into the kiss, whining softly when she pulls away.

“Follow me. Quickly,” Tauriel says, already unlocking the other cells. She leads them deeper into the stronghold, and though confusion ripples through the Company, they obey.

They stop when they reach the barrel room. Protests erupt immediately.

But Thorin, seeing the look on Tauriel’s face, and the stunned, overwhelmed expression on Kíli’s, raises his voice above the noise.

“She recognized his heartsong. That’s all I need to know. Everyone, get in the damn barrels.”

Grumbling, the dwarrows climb in. They’re stuck for what feels like an eternity before they hear the voices of elves singing a work song above them:

“Roll—roll—roll—roll,
roll—roll—rolling down the hole!
Heave ho! Splash plump!
Down they go, down they bump!”

Then they feel it, the sudden cold of the river as their barrels are released, the current carrying them away from Mirkwood. The elves’ song drifts over the water, hastening their escape.

But as the Company floats to freedom, Thorin can’t shake the dread settling in his chest.

How will their starved little hobbit survive this ?


Thorin should feel happy.

He is so close to the mountain he can practically smell the air of his homeland. The people of Lake-town sing for his favor, recognizing him as the rightful King of Erebor. He should be happy. Even now, he hears the voices of Men singing:

“The King beneath the mountains,
    The King of carven stone,
The lord of silver fountains
    Shall come into his own!

His crown shall be upholden,
    His harp shall be restrung,
His halls shall echo golden
    To songs of yore re-sung.

The woods shall wave on mountains
    And grass beneath the sun;
His wealth shall flow in fountains
    And the rivers golden run.

The streams shall run in gladness,
    The lakes shall shine and burn,
All sorrow fail and sadness
    At the Mountain-king's return! 

The King beneath the mountain!
His wealth is like the Sun,
His silver like a fountain,
His rivers golden run!"

But how can he be happy when one of his Company lies near death?

He watches as Óin gently wipes sweat from the trembling hobbit’s brow, Bilbo mewling softly in fevered distress. The healer’s expression is tight with worry, and Óin doesn’t usually fret, not even over the vilest wounds, unless the matter is truly grave.

“Thorin,” Óin says, voice low, “I’m so sorry. But I’m unsure if Bilbo will pull through this…”

“He will. He must .” Thorin’s voice is steel, but he feels it waver. “Our hobbit is not to be underestimated. I know he’ll get through this.”

He says it more to convince himself than Óin.

The old healer gives him a sad, knowing smile, then leaves, granting him a moment alone with Bilbo.

Thorin takes the hobbit’s small hand in his own, startled by the heat radiating from his skin. Bilbo is burning up. He whispers a prayer to Mahal, please, let him live . Let him be safe. He would give up Erebor, all its gold and glory, if it meant Bilbo could rise again and smile.

The sincerity of the thought startles him.

He falls still, realizing just how true it is. But when Bilbo whines softly in pain, the moment breaks, and Thorin quickly grabs a cup of water, bringing it to Bilbo’s lips.

He will do anything to ease his suffering.

But Thorin doesn’t know how to help, so he stays at Bilbo’s side, praying to Mahal to save his hobbit. He only leaves when absolutely necessary: to negotiate for supplies or to plan their approach to the mountain. Even then, he ensures Bilbo is never left alone. A member of the Company is always nearby, watching over him. At night, Thorin sleeps beside the ailing hobbit.

Sometimes, Bilbo wakes, but never fully lucid. During those moments, the Company learns more about Bilbo than he has ever willingly shared. For all his love of talking, Bilbo rarely speaks about himself. He tells stories of the Shire, of his sprawling family, but never of his own heart.

So they’re caught off guard when he cries out for his father, begging him not to leave him and his mother alone. When he pleads with his mother to eat. When he screams that no one will take Bag End from him. And when he curses his “other half” for making him kill his own mother.

The Company understands these are words never meant for them. Fevered confessions whispered in pain. They decide, together, to keep them secret. Thorin makes sure his nephews, especially, understand the importance of that silence.

When Bilbo finally wakes, fully coherent this time, he groans and clutches his head.

“Ugh… I feel sticky… Where am I? Thorin!? Fíli!? Kíli!? Anyone!?” he calls out, voice trembling in the dark.

Thorin knows hobbits cannot see in the dark like dwarrows. Waking from fever dreams into black silence must feel like waking into a nightmare.

“I’m here, Bilbo,” Thorin says quickly, trying to keep his voice calm. “Everyone is safe. It’s just night. I’ll light a candle.”

He strikes a match, and the soft flame fills the room. Bilbo’s frightened eyes meet his, then slowly relax.

“We’re in Lake-town. Far from Thranduil and his ilk. How are you feeling?”

Bilbo exhales in relief. “Well… I’m thirsty. And so hungry. I—I feel a bit lightheaded, too…” He trails off, flushing as his stomach growls loudly.

Thorin winces. They’ve done their best feeding Bilbo soup during his fever, trying to build up his strength, but they may have underestimated hobbitish hunger. It seems like every hour, Bilbo’s stomach protests, and Thorin begins to wonder if they’ve been starving their small companion throughout the journey without realizing it.

“I’ll go see if Bombur has anything ready in the kitchen,” Thorin says, starting to stand.

“Don’t go,” Bilbo blurts out, reaching for him, then hesitates and pulls his hand back. “I—I mean… no, it’s alright. I just…”

Thorin frowns and sits beside him again, gently taking his hand. “I will come back, Bilbo. I will always come back to you.”

He says it with quiet conviction. He remembers the fear in Bilbo’s voice during those fevered dreams, the fear of being alone. Bilbo flushes, then nods, letting him go.

Thorin leaves the room.

Dwalin stands guard at the entrance, and Bofur watches the hallway. Thorin informs them that Bilbo is awake and asks one of them to rouse Óin. Then he continues toward the kitchen.

Much to his relief, Bombur has left some soup warming, just in case Bilbo’s stomach growls again. Thorin fills a bowl and a pitcher of water, then makes his way back.

When he returns, he’s pleased to see Óin already there, crouched at Bilbo’s side, carefully checking on him.

“All right, laddie,” Óin says, examining Bilbo carefully. “A few more days of rest and plenty of food will do you well. And perhaps a bath. I’ll go and prepare one for you now so you don—”

“I’ll do it,” Thorin interrupts, his voice sharper than intended. “Thank you, Óin.”

He doesn’t know where the sudden surge of possessiveness comes from, but before he can stop himself, the words are out. Óin raises a brow, clearly amused, then chuckles and nods.

“All right then. I’ll let Thorin bathe you, Bilbo, while I take care of changing your linens.”

The hobbit flushes crimson. “Oh no, no, no—I can bathe myself, thank you very much,” Bilbo says quickly, laughing nervously.

“Nope,” Óin replies flatly, rolling his eyes. “You’re still too weak, and I’m not about to let a patient of mine drown in a tub.”

He gestures for Thorin to take Bilbo, and Thorin scoops him up before Bilbo can protest further.

“Thorin! Put me down! I am not so weak that I can’t walk,” Bilbo grumbles.

“Hush,” Thorin says, smirking. “You’re a patient, Master Baggins. Best do as the healer says.”

“Oh, you’re one to talk,” Bilbo huffs, rolling his eyes playfully, only to blush deeper when Thorin chuckles, that deep, warm laugh rumbling from his chest.

“Then perhaps you can show me how a model patient behaves?” Thorin teases, eyes glinting.

Bilbo groans. “Ugh, fine. But only to prove I’m not a brute like you ,” he says, trying not to think about the fact that Thorin will soon be undressing him.

“Very well, Master Hobbit,” Thorin murmurs, leaning closer. “I’ll be watching very closely.”

His voice, low and rich in Bilbo’s ear, sends an involuntary shiver down the hobbit’s spine.

Despite the teasing, nothing happens during the bath. Thorin is gentle, almost reverent, in the way he washes Bilbo. Every movement speaks of care, of quiet worry. Bilbo watches him, wondering, does he know? Does Thorin know he’s my heartsong?

But he’s never said anything. Bilbo hasn’t played his heartsong for Thorin either. Maybe he doesn’t feel it. Maybe he wouldn’t believe me if I told him…

“Thorin… I—” Bilbo begins, then hesitates. What can he say? That he’s Thorin’s heartsong? That would sound mad. So instead, he smiles softly and says, “I will never regret following you on this adventure. I’ll always look back on it fondly… even the bad parts. So thank you. For letting me join you.”

Thorin pauses, sponge in hand, and looks at him. A smile breaks through his solemn features.

“And I will never regret letting you join us,” he replies. He wants to say more, to confess that he wishes he could be Bilbo’s heartsong. That whoever had been his heartsong didn’t deserve him. What kind of monster makes someone kill their own mother?

No. Not yet. He is not worthy. But once he reclaims Erebor… once he is king, perhaps then he will be.

“I will never forget you, Master Baggins. I promise you that.”

They look at each other, hearts full of unspoken feelings, both quietly hoping that someday, they might be worthy of one another.


Bilbo takes a deep breath as he remembers that night back in Lake-town, one of the last times he truly feels safe. But ever since the ordeal with Smaug, that sense of safety has never returned. And now that the vile worm is dead, Thorin has been acting… strange.

He’s more aggressive. Restless. Unpleasant to be around. And that’s odd, because even in the early days of their journey, when Thorin is curt and mistrustful, he is never frightening. But now? Now Bilbo feels fear.

He recalls Smaug’s words, how the Arkenstone would corrupt Thorin, and he fears the dragon may be right. Thorin is no longer… Thorin.

Bilbo promises himself: if he finds the Arkenstone first, he’ll take it far away. He won’t let Thorin touch it. He’ll keep it hidden forever.

But to his dismay, Thorin finds it first. The dwarf’s laughter upon discovering it is not joyous, but monstrous, a roaring sound that sends a chill down Bilbo’s spine. It reminds him far too much of Smaug.

Bilbo shudders at the memory and hides himself during the celebration. He doesn’t understand what’s so special about the gem. Sure, it’s pretty, and it glows with its own light, which makes Bilbo think it’d make a fine reading lamp, but beyond that? It seems no different from any other jewel.

“Burglar! Where are you!? Show yourself!” Thorin’s voice cuts through the halls, low and edged with a growl far too close to the dragon’s.

Bilbo curls tighter into the small corner where he hides.

“Bofur! Where is my hobbit!?” Thorin roars.

“I—I don’t know! He was here earlier!” Bofur replies nervously.

“We have food and drink. He’ll turn up,” Bombur adds, though his voice is uneasy.

Bilbo hears Bifur say something sharp in Khuzdul, but whatever it is, it only fuels Thorin’s rage.

“You’re hiding him from me! How dare you hide my hobbit! He is mine! Mine alone! Now show me where he is or I’ll—”

The unmistakable sound of a sword being unsheathed makes Bilbo’s heart stop. He stumbles out from his hiding spot and runs toward the voices.

“Here I am! Sorry! I got lost, Erebor is huge ! Ha... ha…” Bilbo laughs nervously, eyes wide as he sees Thorin mid-swing, poised to strike one of his own kin. “Did you need me for something, Thorin?”

“Come here,” Thorin says, striding forward with an unnerving smile that makes Bilbo instinctively step back. Thorin scowls, grabs him roughly, and pulls him into his arms despite Bilbo’s protests. He marches to the head of the table and sits down with Bilbo on his lap like a prized possession.

“A toast,” Thorin declares. “To the reclamation of Erebor!”

The Company cheers, but none of them look celebratory.

Bilbo sees it all: Fíli and Kíli, unusually silent, their playful teasing absent. Óin and Glóin whispering to each other, worry etched deep in their faces. Bombur, Bofur, and Bifur sit close, visibly shaken. Dori and Nori subtly position themselves between Thorin and Ori, protective. Dwalin grips Balin’s trembling hand.

No one is truly celebrating.

And Bilbo… Bilbo hates the way Thorin holds him. It feels wrong. Possessive. Like he’s not a person, but a thing Thorin owns now.

And as if the day can't get any worse, Bard arrives, demanding reasonable compensation for the destruction of Lake-town. Thranduil follows soon after, seeking the white gems he once commissioned and Thror selfishly hoarded. Their requests are fair, but Thorin’s response is anything but. He refuses them with cold arrogance and barely concealed threats.

And what makes it worse? Thorin holds Bilbo in his arms the entire time, as if he’s some kind of accessory, something to display, not someone with a mind of his own.

That night, the Company begins to sing. A low, somber song echoing through the mountain as they prepare for war.

“Under the Mountain dark and tall
The King has come unto his hall!
His foe is dead, the Worm of Dread,
And ever so his foes shall fall.

The sword is sharp, the spear is long,
The arrow swift, the Gate is strong;
The heart is bold that looks on gold;
The dwarves no more shall suffer wrong.

The dwarves of yore made mighty spells,
While hammers fell like ringing bells
In places deep, where dark things sleep,
In hollow halls beneath the fells.

On silver necklaces they strung
The light of stars, on crowns they hung
The dragon-fire, from twisted wire
The melody of harps they wrung.

The mountain throne once more is freed!
O! wandering folk, the summons heed!
Come haste! Come haste! across the waste!
The king of friend and kin has need.

Now call we over mountains cold,
'Come back unto the caverns old'!
Here at the Gates the king awaits,
His hands are rich with gems and gold.

The king is come unto his hall
Under the Mountain dark and tall.
The Worm of Dread is slain and dead,
And ever so our foes shall fall!”

They’re going to die. He knows it, if he doesn’t act, they’re all going to die. But what can he do? He can’t fight. He can’t lead. All he can do is hide and cry for the loss of his dwarf.

Is Thorin still there? Or is he gone forever?

He has to know.

So while most of the Company sleeps and only a few remain on watch, Bilbo slips into the treasury, frantic and desperate. During the long, agonizing days spent searching for the cursed Arkenstone, he came across a number of instruments. There’s one in particular he remembers, large, impossible to miss if it’s still here.

If that Thorin, the thing wearing his Thorin’s face, finds him here, he’ll call him a thief. He might even kill him.

But Bilbo has to know.

He searches the golden heaps, dread gnawing at his stomach, until, at last, he finds it. The instrument he’s spent a lifetime avoiding. The one he swore he would never play again.

It stands tall and proud like a relic of royalty, its wooden body curved like a teardrop in motion. Rich mahogany gleams beneath a lacquered surface, now adorned with an obscene cascade of gemstones: sapphires tracing the edges, emeralds lining the ribs, and a frozen river of diamonds flowing down the fingerboard. The scroll is crowned in ruby, and the golden strings shimmer like sunlit thread.

It is hideously, painfully , beautiful. So ostentatious that Bilbo recoils from it, disturbed by the twisted splendor that mirrors everything wrong with Thorin now.

But it’s all he has. His only chance.

He takes a breath, heavy and trembling, and reaches for the instrument.

And he begins to play, hoping, praying , that he will hear Thorin he loves.


Thorin wakes to a sound.

It stumbles into the room like a newborn foal, wobbly, unsure, and painfully loud in its awkwardness. Notes clash against each other, some drawn out too long, others cut short mid-breath, as if the instrument itself protests the attempt. Each sound carries the raw, unfiltered effort of someone who doesn’t know how to play, fingers fumbling across strings, rhythms faltering, pitches wavering. A few screeches pierce the air like misfired alarms.

It’s annoying.

Thorin rises, irritated, and follows the discordant noise to its source, storming through the halls until he reaches the throne room. There, in the center of gold and ruin, stands Bilbo, dwarfed by a comically large cello.

“Bilbo, what are you doing?” Thorin demands, fury rising in his chest.

The hobbit flinches at the sound of his voice but doesn’t stop. “Playing my heartsong,” he says, voice trembling with fear.

This isn’t right. A heartsong is instinctive, something felt, not forced. But the way Bilbo grips the bow and presses the strings, it’s clumsy, calculated. The instrument is clearly unfamiliar.

At Bilbo’s reply, Thorin snarls, “Then stop it! Your other half doesn’t deserve you! They killed your mother, you said it yourself! I, however, will lavish you with gold and riches—”

“No!” Bilbo cuts him off, his voice shaking. “He didn’t kill my mother, and neither did I! I just didn’t want to let go. He helped me let her go. She’s in Yavanna’s Garden now… with my father. He does deserve me, just as much as I deserve him!”

Bilbo takes deep breaths, focusing. He reminds himself of what he knows, as a music teacher, he’s played violin and viola. A cello is just a larger version. He adjusts his bowing, his posture, refines his intonation, and slowly, the clumsy noise begins to shape itself into music.

“Stop that!” Thorin shouts. “You belong to me !”

He lunges, but Bilbo unleashes a note so powerful it stops him in his tracks. Thorin stumbles back, eyes wide, and pulls out the Arkenstone.

There’s a crack.

Bilbo keeps playing, stronger now, his melody growing confident, bold, defiant . It rises like a battle cry. It fights.

“You’re still in there! I know you are!” Bilbo cries. “You promised, you said you’d always come back to me!”

His fingers fly across the strings, the bow slicing through the air with purpose. The creature that wears Thorin’s face snarls, sword drawn.

“Stop playing!”

He charges, bringing his blade down, but Bilbo unleashes a shattering note that knocks him off his feet. The Arkenstone glows white-hot, and explodes into shards.

Bilbo gasps, stunned, and lets go of the instrument. His vision swims. Then he sees Thorin, collapsed on the ground, motionless.

“Thorin? Thorin!” Bilbo rushes to him, brushing away the glittering fragments and shaking him by the shoulders.

Thorin groans and opens his eyes, clear, sharp, and bright with awareness.

“Bilbo…” His voice is hoarse. “I’m sorry… I’m here. I came back… for you.” He reaches up and takes Bilbo’s hand, tears slipping down his cheeks.

Bilbo laughs through his own tears. “You’re here… You’re really back. I love you.”

And without hesitation, they lean into each other, and share their first kiss.


When the Company finally comes looking for the two, they find Bilbo and Thorin on the floor, nearly stripping each other.

Dori immediately throws his hands over Ori’s eyes and shouts, “ EXCUSE ME!? What in Mahal’s name are you doing!?”

They’ve never seen Bilbo move so fast. In a blink, he launches several feet away from Thorin, flustered and red-faced. “H—hello everyone! Good morning! How are you all?” he laughs nervously.

“I know we may die in the next few hours,” Dori scolds, arms crossed, “but at least lock the door! ”

“Ah, let them enjoy themselves, brother,” Nori chimes in with a grin. “Might as well let Ori bed Fíli before the big battle!”

Ori lets out a strangled noise and turns scarlet. “ Nori! ”

“Yes! Let him live a little before his end!” Bofur adds cheerfully.

“They haven’t even exchanged beads yet!” Dori cries, appalled.

“ Enough! ” Thorin’s voice booms across the room.

The Company freezes, suddenly tense, but then they see it: his eyes are clear. Free of the goldsickness.

“Balin,” Thorin says firmly, “help me mitigate the consequences of my madness. Request another meeting with Bard and Thranduil.”

“Of course, Your Majesty.” Balin bows and gestures for Dwalin to follow him as they leave to draft the letter.

“Glóin,” Thorin continues, “gather our kin. Search for the Gems of Lasgalen and assemble proper compensation for the people of Lake-town. I trust you to handle it well.”

“I’ll see to it swiftly, Your Majesty.” Glóin bows and leaves, rallying others behind him.

“Bombur,” Thorin calls, stopping the dwarf before he can follow, “prepare breakfast for everyone.”

Bombur lights up. “Gladly, Your Majesty!” He hurries off with a smile.

Thorin then turns to Bilbo and gently takes his hand. “And you, come with me.”

The hobbit follows, a bit dazed, as Thorin leads him down the corridor. When they’re alone, Thorin pauses. “I owe you an apology,” he says, voice soft. “For how I treated you while I was under the madness. And I owe you thanks, for bringing me back from the brink.”

Bilbo smiles, though his voice is still a bit shaky. “Well… I admit, you terrified me. But I knew that wasn’t you. I should also apologize. If it weren’t for me, the Arkenstone wouldn’t have shattered and I—”

Thorin hushes him with a gentle finger against his lips. Bilbo goes quiet, his cheeks burning.

“No jewel is more precious than our lives,” Thorin says. “I was willing to trade that stone for all of us. And yes, without it, it may be harder to prove my legitimacy to the other clans… but my people know the truth. It’s not every day a kingdom is reclaimed from a dragon’s maw.”

He chuckles, and Bilbo can’t help but smile.

“Bilbo, I must ask you something…” Thorin bites his lip, struggling to find the right words. But Bilbo already understands.

“You didn’t,” Bilbo says softly. “My mother… she died a long time ago, along with my father. But she stayed with me for far too long. She wanted to protect me—from certain relatives who only cared about the wealth my father left behind.”

“When I came of age… I felt your grief. Your loss. When I was younger, it overwhelmed me. But now that I’m older and wiser, I understand. I had to let my mother go. I told her to find Father that night… and she did.”

“I should have been happy for her—she was finally free, no longer suffering—but I wasn’t ready to be so alone. I should have thanked you, but instead… I abhorred you. So much that I refused to play my heartsong until earlier…”

Bilbo doesn’t notice the tears streaming down his cheeks until Thorin gently wipes them away.

“Bilbo…” Thorin murmurs, remembering how his heartsong changed over the years. Once joyful, then mournful, and eventually practiced and hollow—pain masked by habit. He should have realized that the last time it turned joyful again was when Bilbo became free of those greedy relatives.

“Erebor will welcome you,” Thorin says, voice thick with emotion. “So, Bilbo… stay with me here. Please.”

“Thorin, I… I would love to.” Bilbo smiles through his tears. “I’ll have to return to the Shire first, gather my belongings, make sure Bag End ends up in proper hands. But after that… yes. I’d love to stay.”

He thinks of his smial, how it stopped feeling like home the moment his father died. And now, far from the Shire, he's finally looking forward to making this mountain his true home.

Thorin grins and pulls him into another deep kiss. Bilbo eagerly returns it, until his stomach growls in protest, loud and demanding.

Thorin chuckles as he pulls back, amused by the flustered hobbit, who now looks like he wants to disappear into the stone floor.

“Go see if Bombur has anything ready, my hobbit,” Thorin says with a smirk. “I won’t mind.”

“I—I… this isn’t over!” Bilbo yelps before bolting down the hall, his face crimson.

Still chuckling, Thorin heads to the treasury, where the dwarves continue their search for the Gems of Lasgalen. He doesn’t find the jewelry, but he does find something else, something he can give to Bilbo. A token he can propose with. If negotiations fail and war comes… he wants to meet his end as Bilbo’s betrothed, if not his husband.

He sighs, mentally drafting a new letter for Dáin. Plans have changed. Roäc will have to deliver the message swiftly, and outfly any elven arrows.

When he hears Balin and Dwalin approaching, Thorin straightens, hopeful.

“Thranduil and Bard have agreed to the meeting,” Balin says, “on the condition it takes place in the open.”

“In the open, where their archers have clear sight,” Dwalin grumbles.

“Peace, Dwalin,” Thorin says. “I’ve shown them nothing but hostility until now. It’s only fair. We’ll have the meeting, and we’ll have peace.”

He believes it. He hopes it. With Bilbo at his side, peace finally feels within reach.


Thorin forgets how much he wants to punch Thranduil in the face—until the elf opens his mouth and speaks in that condescending tone.

“I believe,” Thranduil says smoothly, “that after the insult and blatant threat to my life yesterday, I should be compensated.”

“And what compensation do you seek?” Thorin asks through gritted teeth, doing his best to hold back his fury.

“I wish for the Arkenstone,” Thranduil replies, his smile as smug and serpentine as ever.

“I’m afraid I cannot give you the gem,” Thorin says. “It shattered earlier.”

“Shattered?” Thranduil scoffs. “Do you truly expect me to believe that you dwarrows would destroy such a prized heirloom?”

Thorin would usually agree, dwarrows do not shatter gems. But the truth is the truth, no matter how unbelievable.

“I also believe the amount of coin you’ve offered is far less than what was promised,” Bard chimes in, unhelpfully. “I will not allow my people to be swindled.”

“Lord Bard,” Thorin says, voice tight with restraint, “a sudden influx of gold would trigger inflation. That’s why the compensation is scheduled in installments. My advisor Balin already explained this to you.”

He resists the urge to rub his forehead. Bard is a good man, noble by blood, but raised as a commoner—he lacks the proper education for matters like this. To someone like him, the plan must seem like trickery.

“I do not believe you,” Bard says, his glare sharp and unwavering.

Thorin is just about to snap, ready to shout them all down, when Bilbo quietly takes the seat beside him—on his right, where a consort would sit.

The sight of his hobbit there, confident and composed, is enough to steal Thorin’s breath and calm his rage, if only for a moment.

“Pardon my delay, my lords,” Bilbo says pleasantly, “but I needed help with something. Now then, perhaps a bit of music might lighten this rather dour mood?”

“Do you honestly think we need music at this moment, half—” Thranduil begins, only to stop cold as a haunting, ancient melody floats into the chamber.

Bofur steps in, playing a delicate tune on his flute.

Thranduil’s eyes widen in stunned silence.

Thorin narrows his gaze in disbelief. No. No, it can’t be. One of Bofur’s heartsongs is… Thranduil?

As Bofur finishes, Bard opens his mouth. “That was lovely, but I believe we should—”

“I’m not done!” Bofur interrupts, cheerfully pulling out his clarinet. This time, a strong but weary tune fills the air. Bard's jaw drops.

Thorin lets out a long-suffering sigh.

Bofur’s heartsongs include both Bard and Thranduil. Of course they do.

He turns to Bilbo and murmurs, “How did you know?”

“I’m a music teacher, Thorin,” Bilbo replies with a proud smile. “I read heartsongs better than most.”

After that, the negotiations go far more smoothly. With Bilbo’s guidance and Bofur’s music, the tension thaws. For the first time in days, Thorin begins to believe that everything might actually turn out all right.

Then Gandalf bursts into the chamber.

“Prepare for war!” he shouts. “An army of orcs is coming!”


Bilbo watches in awe as the three races, Men, Elves, and Dwarrows, unite to strengthen the defenses. Thanks to Gandalf’s warning, they work together swiftly. Women, children and the elderly are ushered into the throne room, the most defensible space available, as the rest of the mountain remains unstable or blocked by rubble.

He stands amazed as Elves sing airy hymns, weaving magic into their bows and arrows. The Men hum working songs to keep their stamina up, while the Dwarrows chant in deep, resonant voices, moving stone as if it were clay. He knows they’ve done it before, but he had always been hiding. Now, he sees it: how the rocks break, shift, and reform under the dwarves’ will, shaping better defenses with ancient skill.

Even Gandalf is busy, humming to communicate with moths, gathering intelligence on the size and speed of the oncoming orc army. When Bilbo hears the number, he nearly faints.

“Bilbo! Come here,” Thorin calls, and Bilbo quickly rushes over.

“Thorin, I—I don’t mean to insult dwarvish architecture, but this place hasn’t seen proper repairs in years, and Gandalf said they have siege weapons. Are we certain we can’t just run?” Bilbo asks, fear creeping into his voice.

“Bilbo, I promise you, we won’t fall easily. And help is on the way. My cousin Dáin is marching here now. We’ll hit them with a pincer attack when they’re expecting only a siege. They won’t be prepared for it. We will win,” Thorin says gently, trying to calm him. “And here… I have something for you.”

Thorin reveals a beautiful, white silken shirt—at least, it seems like silk at first. But as Bilbo looks closer, he realizes it’s made of the tiniest, most delicate metal links he’s ever seen.

“Sanzigil,” Thorin says. “Or, as you might know it, mithril. I hope you’ll accept it as my proposal gift. Even if you don’t want to marry me, I want you to wear it, it will protect you, and I—”

Thorin is cut off as Bilbo grabs his cheeks and pulls him into a deep kiss.

“Yes! Yes, I’ll marry you!” Bilbo beams, nearly giggling with joy.

Thorin smiles and carefully helps Bilbo into the mithril shirt.

“NO FAIR!” both Fíli and Kíli cry out in unison. They had to go through the traditional, painstaking courtship rituals after finding their heartsongs, while their uncle skips straight to the proposal a day after discovering his.

“I’m old. I don’t have time for tradition,” Thorin jokes.

“Don’t joke about that!” Bilbo exclaims, playfully punching his stomach. “You and I are going to live long, happy lives after this. Promise me you’ll survive.”

“I will,” Thorin replies, smiling softly as he leans in for another kiss, one Bilbo happily returns.


Bilbo trembles with fear as he helps carry a wounded Elf away from the battlements toward the healers. A few of the women and elderly from Lake-town, trained in basic healing arts, assist Óin and the Elven healers in saving those struck by orc projectiles. Bilbo, with little skill in combat but sharp perception, is among the few who rush to find the injured and bring them back to the healing bay.

“Shoot them down! Don’t let their ladders reach the wall!” Bard yells, kicking one of the ladders off just as an orc nears the top.

“They’ve got a battering ram! Dwalin, prepare the oil!” Thorin shouts.

Bilbo watches as Dwalin and Dori lift a massive cauldron of boiling oil and pour it over the gate. He has no love for the orcs below, but even he winces at their screams of agony.

“Fire!” Thranduil commands, and the Elves loose flaming arrows. With the oil spread below, Bilbo can only imagine the horror it causes. The stench of burning flesh rises, making him gag. He nearly vomits but swallows it down, until he feels the ground tremble.

“Were-worms!” someone cries.

Bilbo turns in time to see a nearby wall collapse. A massive, grotesque head bursts through the rubble, one of the orcs’ living siege weapons. Acting on instinct, he plunges Sting into the creature’s eye. It rears back, shrieking, giving Elves and Men the chance to shower it with arrows, bringing it down.

Thankfully, Legolas, Thranduil’s son, had returned Orcrist and Sting to Thorin and Bilbo respectively. Without that blade, Bilbo knows he’d be dead.

“Bofur! Bifur! Bombur! Repair that wall, now!” Thorin shouts.

The three dwarrows break into deep, resonant song. Stone shards float and reattach, slowly reforming the damaged wall, but the orcs pour in faster than the song can hold them off.

Then the air itself shudders.

Gandalf chants in an ancient tongue, his voice like a hymn. His staff erupts with brilliant white light, forcing the orcs near the breach to flee just long enough for the dwarrows to complete the repairs.

It’s been hours. The battle rages on without pause, and Bilbo wonders if they’ll ever get to rest.

A Man crashes to the ground in front of him, an arrow in his chest.

Bilbo gasps, then drops to his knees. “Don’t pull it out! I’ve got you! You’ll be fine!” he assures, though his voice shakes. An Elf rushes over to help carry the injured man to the healers.

As soon as the Man is safe, Bilbo moves again, but then he sees it.

His voice breaks.

A belfry, a massive, mobile siege tower, rolls straight toward where Thorin and their friends are stationed. Thorin stands ready to intercept it.

“No, no, someone stop it!” Bilbo cries, heart pounding. He knows the archers are likely targeting the orcs operating the tower, but it’s not enough. More of them are appearing.

Too many. Far too many.

Bilbo watches as Nori hurls a wine bottle with a burning cloth stuffed in its neck. It hits one of the belfries and explodes into flames.

“Take that!” Nori shouts triumphantly.

Bilbo rushes over. “Nori! What are those?”

“Fire-flasks! Nifty little things! You can make them anywhere, just need alcohol!” Nori grins as he tosses another one at a siege tower. “I’d rather be drinking them, but, you know, I gotta stay alive first!”

“Hand me some! I want to help!”

Nori doesn’t hesitate. He passes a few to Bilbo and quickly explains how to make them, shockingly simple, and frankly a bit terrifying. Like he said, anyone with a bottle of booze and a rag can do it.

“Grab a bottle of alcohol, stuff a cloth in the top, but leave part of it hanging out. Light the end, and throw it!” Nori demonstrates.

It feels criminal to Bilbo to waste what is probably decent wine like this, but this is war, and if it’ll protect his friends, so be it. So now here he is, hurling flaming bottles down at siege engines, engulfing them in fire and rendering them useless to the orcs.

Thorin watches from the wall as Bilbo throws fire-flasks with surprising accuracy. His hobbit is full of surprises, and yet, he thinks, of course Bilbo would fight in his own clever, dangerous way.

“Balin, has Roäc returned yet?” Thorin asks, scanning the skies.

“Not yet, Thorin,” Balin replies, shaking his head grimly.

“Gah! We can win this without Dáin!” Glóin bellows, punching an orc in the face as it climbs the wall, then kicking the ladder back down.

“I’d rather Lord Dáin get here soon!” Ori squeaks, firing a crossbow bolt that drops another orc.

“Well, Uncle Dáin better hurry!” Kíli yells as he lets loose an arrow.

“I’m running out of throwing knives!” Fíli shouts, frustration mounting.

“There! Look!” Tauriel calls, pointing toward a pale orc standing beside a catapult, its features unmistakable.

It’s Bolg, Azog’s son. He sneers at them, and with a sharp command, fires the massive weapon.

Thanks to Tauriel’s warning, no one is hit, but the boulder crashes into the wall with a thunderous crack. The stone holds, but it’s weakened.

“Damn it!” Thorin curses, shielding his eyes from the dust. The impact leaves them dazed just long enough for one of the belfries to reach the wall, and the orcs start pouring in.

And leading the charge, Thorin’s heart drops, is Azog himself.

The Pale Orc snarls as his eyes lock onto Thorin. Without hesitation, he charges forward, arm-blade raised to strike.

Thorin rolls away just in time, narrowly avoiding Azog’s blade, and scrambles to his feet. Around him, his nephews and friends are doing their best to hold back the tide of orcs pouring from the siege tower, but Azog is his to face alone.

“Your line ends here,” Azog snarls with a cruel laugh, rushing Thorin with a flurry of heavy, brutal swings.

Thorin weaves and dodges, narrowly avoiding each strike. He retaliates with a slash across Azog’s arm, but it’s not deep enough, barely more than a scratch.

“No, your line ends here,” Thorin growls, slashing toward Azog’s neck. The orc blocks it with his arm-blade, then swings a fist that forces Thorin to leap back to avoid a blow that would break bone.

Thorin lunges forward, aiming to drive Orcrist into Azog’s gut, but the orc grabs the blade barehanded. Blood pours from his palm, but he doesn’t flinch. With a savage snarl, Azog raises his arm-blade and swings at Thorin’s neck.

Thorin is forced to release Orcrist and dive aside to dodge the strike, leaving him weaponless.

“I have you now, scum!” Azog grins, launching himself at the unarmed dwarf, only to scream in pain as a fire-flask slams into his face and explodes.

Thorin turns in shock to see where it came from, and there is Bilbo, charging forward with Sting in hand, eyes wild with determination.

With a cry, Bilbo launches himself at Azog, driving him back, and the two of them topple over the battlements together.

“ BILBO! ” Thorin screams, his voice ripping through the battlefield.

Time slows. Thorin watches helplessly as his beloved hobbit plummets alongside the pale orc. The sound of Bilbo’s body hitting the ground with a sickening crunch echoes louder than any war cry.

“ No...! ”

The orcs, seeing Bilbo broken and gasping, rush to finish him off, but a massive shadow passes over them, and a great eagle swoops down from the sky, scattering the orcs and scooping Bilbo’s fragile body into its talons.

Then the horn of Dáin sounds.

Thorin’s eyes snap toward the horizon. There, his cousin’s army charges forth, iron and fury in their wake. More giant eagles soar in from above, throwing the orc lines into chaos. And among the surge of reinforcements, Thorin catches a glimpse of a great bear, Beorn , tearing through the enemy like a storm.

But none of that matters.

Not now.

Not when the eagle bearing Bilbo is disappearing into the sky.

He frantically scans the battlefield until he sees the eagle land, beside Tharkûn. The wizard is already at Bilbo’s side, humming an ancient melody that fills the air with trembling magic. Wounds begin to knit, but Bilbo coughs blood, then goes still.

“I can’t save him,” Tharkûn says grimly. “Only Lord Elrond may have the skill now.”

“No! Please, Tharkûn!” Thorin pleads, dropping to his knees beside Bilbo and gripping his small hand tightly. “He is my heartsong, the melody to which my heart beats!”

“The Great Eagles fly fast, but even their swiftness is brutal on the healthiest of riders. For one already dying...” Tharkûn trails off, his voice low. “If I go with him, I can soften the toll. But it means I must leave this battle. Are you certain?”

Thorin meets the wizard’s eyes. He knows what losing an Istari could mean, but there is no hesitation.

“We dwarrows have won many wars without the help of the Istari. And we are not alone today. Go! Fly, save my hobbit. Please.”

Tharkûn nods solemnly and begins chanting again, his words older than the mountains. Magic flares softly as Bilbo’s limp form and the wizard are lifted onto the eagle’s back.

The great bird spreads its wings and launches into the sky. In the blink of an eye, they are a distant dot against the clouds.

Thorin watches until he can see no more, and all he can do now is pray that his hobbit lives.


Bilbo wakes to a dull ache radiating through his entire body. Where is he? What happened? Where’s Thorin?

He pauses when he hears Elves singing outside.

“The dragon is withered,
His bones are now crumbled;
His armour is shivered,
His splendour is humbled!
Though sword shall be rusted,
And throne and crown perish
With strength that men trusted
And wealth that they cherish,
Here grass is still growing,
And leaves are yet swinging,
The white water flowing,
And elves are yet singing
    Come! Tra-la-la-lally!
    Come back to the valley!

The stars are far brighter
Than gems without measure,
The moon is far whiter
Than silver in treasure:
The fire is more shining
On hearth in the gloaming
Than gold won by mining,
So why go a-roaming?
    O! Tra-la-la-lally
    Come back to the Valley.

“O! Where are you going,
So late in returning?
The river is flowing,
The stars are all burning!
O! Whither so laden,
So sad and so dreary?
Here elf and elf-maiden
Now welcome the weary
    With Tra-la-la-lally
    Come back to the Valley,
          Tra-la-la-lally
          Fa-la-la-lally
              Fa-la!”

The song, light and cheerful, stirs his memory. It all comes back, Azog taking Orcrist from Thorin, then a blinding surge of rage as Bilbo throws himself at the pale orc, sending them both tumbling from the rampart. He remembers looking up, seeing Thorin screaming his name, then darkness.

He wonders if everyone made it out alive.

“Bilbo, my dear boy, you’re awake!” Gandalf's voice rings out, heavy with relief.

Bilbo tries to speak, but winces.

“Stay still,” Gandalf instructs gently. “I shall fetch Lord Elrond.” The wizard disappears, and moments later returns with the Elven lord.

“Bilbo Baggins,” Elrond greets him, kneeling beside the bed. He presses a cup to Bilbo’s lips. “How are you feeling?”

Bilbo drinks eagerly, only to sputter and cough.

“Gently, Bilbo. Gently…” Elrond chides softly, and Bilbo obeys. Whatever is in the water, it eases his pain almost immediately.

“Is Thorin… is everyone all right?” he asks as the ache fades further.

“They are, Bilbo. They won,” Gandalf replies with a chuckle. “When Azog fell, thanks to your rather reckless intervention, his son Bolg took command. But a giant eagle snatched him up mid-charge, gave him a tour of the sky for five minutes, and dropped him. Without a commander, the orc army fell into disarray and was swiftly routed. Casualties were minimal.”

Bilbo shudders. As someone who also fell from great height, he can’t find the humor in it.

Elrond shoots Gandalf a stern look, then says, “If not for your mithril shirt, I’m afraid you would not have survived. In a way, Thorin’s love protected you, Bilbo. I’ll send him a letter informing him that you’ve awakened. Would you like me to include anything?”

“Yes,” Bilbo murmurs. “Tell him I love him, and not to blame himself for what I did. I know he will, he’s probably doing so right now. And… send a separate letter to the Company. Ask them to knock some sense into him if he keeps brooding.”

He offers a weak smile, then drifts off again, sleep reclaiming him before he hears a reply.

The next time he wakes, he groans. Laughter echoes nearby. Blinking through the haze, he sees two Elves, Elrohir and Elladan, Lord Elrond’s twin sons, and a young human boy, no more than ten years old if Bilbo judges human aging correctly.

The boy notices him stirring. “Oh! He’s awake! Elrohir! Elladan! We must get Lord Elrond quickly!” he cries and bolts out of the room.

“Good afternoon, Master Baggins,” Elladan says with a bright smile. “How are you feeling?”

“Do forgive Estel,” Elrohir adds with a chuckle. “He likes being responsible so much, he forgot to say hello.”

Bilbo smiles weakly. “He seems like a good lad… and I’m feeling rather starved.”

“How long was I out?”

“A month before your first awakening,” Elladan replies, “and a week since then.”

“Oh… no wonder I’m famished. I remember your father offering to send a letter. Any word yet?”

“Not yet,” Elrohir replies cheerfully, turning toward the doorway.

Elrond enters, carrying the young boy in his arms. Perched on his shoulder is a familiar raven, Roäc.

The raven flies from Elrond’s shoulder to Bilbo’s side and, to Estel’s surprise, speaks in a surprisingly clear and deep voice for a bird.

“Good afternoon, Master Baggins. I come bearing messages from the Company, as well as from King Thorin.”

“That is all well and good,” Lord Elrond says, setting Estel down gently, “but perhaps Bilbo can listen to these messages while he eats? Elrohir, Elladan, be good dears and fetch our guest some food. Nothing too solid for now.”

“Yes, Father,” the twins reply in unison before heading toward the kitchens.

“You talk…” Estel says, staring wide-eyed at the raven.

Roäc puffs up proudly. “But of course! I hail from a great lineage. And how are you, little one?”

“I’m bigger than you,” Estel pouts.

“Yes, but you are still quite tiny compared to others, are you not?” Roäc teases, earning another pout from the boy.

“My name is Arag— I mean, Estel. My name is Estel,” he mutters.

“A pleasure to meet you, Estel. Now, if you don’t mind, I would like to begin my message delivery while we wait for Bilbo’s meal, yes?”

Bilbo nods. “Yes, please. I would like to know how things fare at the mountain.”

Roäc inclines his head and takes a deep breath. When he opens his beak, Bilbo is thoroughly impressed—Roäc’s mimicry brings to life the unmistakable chaos of thirteen dwarrows shouting over one another, all attempting to describe their daily lives at once.

Then comes a commanding voice, Thorin’s, cutting through the noise: “QUIET!”

“Ahem… Roäc, please inform Bilbo that I love him as well,” Thorin’s voice says through the raven, calm and heartfelt. “And hearing that he is awake brings me great joy. I will endeavor to… not blame myself, as you said.”

The voice shifts seamlessly into Fíli’s: “He was mopey the entire month!”

Followed by Kíli’s: “Come back quickly, Uncle Bilbo!”

Then, back to Thorin: “ANYWAY, I wish to inform you, Bilbo, that I intend to journey there myself, for my heart cannot rest without seeing you—”

“Sap!” Dwalin interrupts.

“That’s not a good idea! We need you here to help rebuild Erebor!” Balin’s voice chimes in.

“Hey! We’re coming too!” Bofur adds, followed by Dori’s agreement: “No way you’re going alone!”

“We have to deliver Bilbo’s reward!” Glóin’s voice declares.

Roäc’s mimicry dissolves into another round of shouting, thirteen voices talking over one another in a chaotic, affectionate cacophony. Bilbo chuckles.

Roäc pauses and finally speaks in his own voice. “This goes on for another hour. Would you like me to continue or skip to the part where they actually reached a decision?”

Bilbo laughs softly. “As much as I’d love to hear their voices again, I think for poor Estel’s ears, it’s best we get to what they finally agreed upon.”

Roäc glances at the boy, who is now frowning in confusion, and nods.

“Very well. In the end, it was agreed that King Thorin, accompanied by his cousin Dáin as an escort, will journey to Rivendell. The rest of the Company will remain in Erebor to assist with rebuilding. Fíli and Kíli are technically in charge, though we all know it’s Balin who actually gets things done. Thorin also says he plans to return to Erebor with you, Bilbo, once Lady Dís and the rest of the Ereborian dwarrows begin their return.”

“Lord Elrond, how long will it take for me to heal enough for travel?” Bilbo asks.

“I believe, with the help of my magic, you’ll need another month or two,” Lord Elrond replies warmly. “You are quite resilient, my dear friend, and I truly believe you’ll be well enough in time to greet your husband-to-be on your own two feet.”

Bilbo blushes. “O-oh, I—Gandalf told you?”

“Was it meant to be a secret?” Lord Elrond chuckles.

“Oh no, it’s just… I’d rather have been the one to tell you, you know?” Bilbo replies, flustered.

“Understandable,” Elrond says with an amused smile. “Now, is there anything you need, aside from giving Roäc a reply?”

“Oh, um, yes. I’ll need to get my affairs in order back in the Shire. You see, I plan on permanently moving to Erebor once my fiancé picks me up,” Bilbo explains.

“I’ll have my daughter Arwen look into it,” Lord Elrond replies kindly. “She has the greatest skill in diplomacy among my children. Though,” he adds with a twinkle in his eye, “I do believe you should still visit the Shire yourself, my dear friend. After all, would you not wish for both a Shire wedding and a dwarvish one?”

Bilbo sputters at that, face flushing red, and is thankfully saved from answering when Elrohir and Elladan return with a large bowl of gruel.

“Sorry it took so long! It’s hard finding a bowl big enough for a hobbit!” Elrohir laughs as he places it on Bilbo’s lap.

Bilbo eagerly begins eating, and by the time he finishes, a heavy drowsiness overtakes him, his injured body demanding rest once more.

“Roäc,” Bilbo murmurs sleepily, “tell Thorin… I’ll be waiting… and um… two weddings… Deliver my love to him…”

Lord Elrond simply smiles as he and his sons begin to sing a soft, lilting melody to help lull Bilbo into peaceful sleep.

“Sing all ye joyful, now sing all together!
The wind’s in the tree-top, the wind's in the heather;
The stars are in blossom, the moon is in flower,
And bright are the windows of Night in her tower.

Dance all ye joyful, now dance all together!
Soft is the grass, and let foot be like feather!
The river is silver, the shadows are fleeting;
Merry is May-time, and merry our meeting.

Sing we now softly, and dreams let us weave him!
Wind him in slumber and there let us leave him!
The wanderer sleepeth. Now soft be his pillow!
Lullaby! Lullaby! Alder and Willow!

Sigh no more Pine, till the wind of the morn!
    Fall Moon! Dark be the land!
    Hush! Hush! Oak, Ash, and Thorn!
Hushed be all water, till dawn is at hand!”

Bilbo’s recovery in Rivendell continues for weeks, with Lord Elrond personally overseeing his healing. Elrohir and Elladan entertain him with their antics, and young Estel bombards him with questions, much to Bilbo’s delight. He grows particularly fond of the curious boy. He also meets Lady Arwen, who happily assists him in managing his affairs back in the Shire.

“I must admit, Bilbo,” Arwen says with a warm smile, “when I arrived, they were auctioning off your smial and belongings.”

“What!?” Bilbo gasps, eyes wide. “Oh, those—please tell me you recovered them!”

“Of course,” Arwen assures him, her smile turning amused. “It was not right of them to take advantage of your absence. I made sure your cousin Drogo is set to inherit Bag End, as you requested. And forgive me,” she adds with a twinkle in her eye, “but I took the liberty of beginning preparations for your Shire wedding as well.”

Bilbo turns crimson. “I—um—you didn’t have to—I mean—Thorin’s not even here yet—I—”

“Bilbo,” Arwen interrupts gently, still smiling, “I’m happy to say our scouts have reported two very loud dwarrows heading this way.”

Bilbo freezes for a heartbeat before racing out of bed, ignoring the dull ache in his legs. He hurries to the balcony, nearly tripping, and peers down toward the courtyard. There, riding behind the twins, are Thorin and his cousin Dáin.

“Thorin!” Bilbo cries out, joy bursting from his chest.

Thorin immediately looks up. “Bilbo!” he shouts back, his face lighting up as he leaps off Elladan’s horse and runs for him.

Bilbo doesn’t wait. He turns and races downstairs, stumbling in his haste, only to fall into Thorin’s arms. Thorin catches him effortlessly, pulling him into a tight embrace. He spins Bilbo around, laughing, before capturing him in a kiss that Bilbo returns without hesitation. They stay like that for who knows how long—long enough that Dáin eventually strolls over, grinning.

“So, I hear there’s going to be a Shire wedding?” he teases.

Bilbo and Thorin finally break their kiss. “You know, Fíli and Kíli are still very upset about you skipping steps, cousin,” Dáin adds.

“Well, they’ll just have to deal with it,” Thorin retorts with a playful roll of his eyes. “Unlike them, I’m a proper adult—and a king to boot.”

“Pleasure to finally meet you, Dáin,” Bilbo chuckles, still clinging to Thorin, who refuses to put him down.

“The pleasure is mine. It’s good to finally meet you too.” Dáin leans in conspiratorially. “Did you know, after the battle, they stopped calling him Thorin Oakenshield? Now it’s Thorin Bagginshield .”

Bilbo’s jaw drops. “It was Bofur. Or maybe Nori. Wasn’t it?” he frowns suspiciously.

“Nope! Your new nephew, Kíli,” Dáin says with a laugh.

Bilbo groans but smiles when Thorin kisses his cheek.

“And yes,” Thorin murmurs, “I would love a Shire wedding, Bilbo. You can show me off to your relatives before I whisk you away as my consort.”

“How humble of you, Thorin,” Bilbo laughs, burying his face into Thorin’s chest and listening to the steady rhythm of his heartbeat.

 “I would love that,” he murmurs just as Thorin leans in to kiss him.


Bilbo moans softly into the kiss as Thorin lifts him into his arms, deepening it. The world around them is no longer Rivendell, it’s the Shire, and they stand at the center of a grand celebration. Gandalf has just finished his pronouncement, and their guests erupt into cheers: hobbits and dwarrows alike, gathered under a garland-draped pavilion blooming with flowers.

The announcement of the Mad Baggins marrying a dwarf king had, of course, been met with skepticism at first. But that skepticism melted quickly when caravans of dwarrows from Ered Luin rolled into Hobbiton, declaring they had come to retrieve their future king and consort. No hobbit ever says no to a party.

Now, wedding rings gleam on their fingers, marriage beads braid their hair, and Bilbo relishes the joy of showing off Thorin, who is, at this very moment, kissing him senseless beneath a shower of petals.

“So what do you think of Shire weddings, love?” Bilbo asks breathlessly, grinning up at him, dressed in white and radiant with happiness.

“I enjoy the scent of these flowers,” Thorin replies, equally dressed in white, a faint blush on his cheeks. “And I fear I’ll never again taste desserts as sweet as these Shire confections. But what I truly long for—” he brushes a kiss along Bilbo’s jaw, “—is to see you dressed in Durin blue, adorned with proper gems.”

“Oh, I can cook those desserts for you, love,” Bilbo giggles. “And I’d wear Durin blue every day if it pleases you. Gems, however…” he winks, “those are only for special occasions, or the bedroom.”

Thorin lets out a delighted laugh and showers Bilbo with kisses as he carries him toward the waiting carriage.

“Careful, brother!” Dís calls out, laughing. She looks nearly a mirror of Thorin, save for her golden hair and gentler smile. “Don’t drop my new brother-in-law!”

“To Erebor! To home!” Dáin bellows, raising his arms as the dwarrows burst into song, an anthem both for their long-awaited return and for the love shared between their king and his consort.

“Roads go ever ever on,
Over rock and under tree,
By caves where never sun has shone,
By streams that never find the sea;
Over snow by winter sown,
And through the merry flowers of June,
Over grass and over stone,
And under mountains in the moon.

Roads go ever ever on
Under cloud and under star,
Yet feet that wandering have gone
Turn at last to home afar.
Eyes that fire and sword have seen
And horror in the halls of stone
Look at last on meadows green
And trees and hills they long have known”

Notes:

If you all want more art from my partner FiannaRain then head over to her tumblr Starsilversword's Art!