Sorry, you need to have JavaScript enabled for this.

Actions

Work Header

A Neutral Braid

Summary:

Bilbo waited until most of the Dwarves were asleep before singling out Bofur. If this was some sort of faux pas, he wanted as few Dwarves to bear witness to it as possible. He walked across the campsite with purpose, ignoring the sudden rush of nervousness.
“Bofur?” he asked in half a whisper.
The Dwarf looked up at him with a cheery expression. “What is it, Master Baggins?”
Bilbo exhaled shortly, collecting whatever courage he had left. “I uh. My hair has been…” He paused a moment. “Getting in my face of late and I certainly don’t have the tools to cut it,” he added almost as an aside to himself. “And I was just wondering if you could braid it for me.”

~*~

Or: In which Thorin is an idiot, Bilbo is culturally unaware, and Bofur causes problems on purpose.

Notes:

hello!! this is my first fic in this fandom (idk how, i've been in love with these idiots for months now) so if the characterization feels off that's why lol. i tried my best with it and had a fabulous time.
shout out to @humancorn for the wonderful prompt and for participating in fandom trumps hate 2025!! it was so much fun to write for you!
hope you all enjoy the fic!!

(See the end of the work for more notes.)

Work Text:

It had been nearly two months since they left the Shire, if Bilbo’s count of the days was correct. (He was rather unsure how many days they’d spent in Mirkwood, but that couldn’t be helped. It could have been as many as seven or as few as two. Keeping track of the days in that frightful place had been difficult.) But regardless of specifics, it was around this point in the journey that Bilbo began to notice it.

Generally, a Hobbit’s hair grew rather quickly. If one wanted it short, one had to get it cut often. Bilbo had always cut his own hair, with no small amount of care and tools designed expressly for that purpose. But he had been on this adventure for some time now, and he had not had the foresight to pack the necessary effects for the upkeep of his hair. Bilbo knew well that nothing the Dwarves had would be of use; he doubted the concept of cutting ones hair was something they were overly familiar with, nor did he trust any of them not to make him look a fool with the instruments they had to offer.

However the Dwarves did have a way of keeping their hair away from their face, and quite a lovely way at that. Their braids were intricate and unique, gorgeous works of art that bore messages of kinship and skill and self-expression. Balin had described the practice to him once, and Bilbo admired it greatly. Perhaps if he asked politely, one of them would be willing to braid his hair, just to keep it out of his face.

Bilbo waited until most of the Dwarves were asleep before singling out Bofur. If this was some sort of faux pas, he wanted as few Dwarves to bear witness to it as possible. He walked across the campsite with purpose, ignoring the sudden rush of nervousness.

“Bofur?” he asked in half a whisper.

The Dwarf looked up at him with a cheery expression. “What is it, Master Baggins?”

Bilbo exhaled shortly, collecting whatever courage he had left. “I uh. My hair has been…” He paused a moment. “Getting in my face of late and I certainly don’t have the tools to cut it,” he added almost as an aside to himself. “And I was just wondering if you could braid it for me.”

Bofur’s expression went slack, and Bilbo’s heart sank.

“I mean no offence at all,” he added hastily, trying to remedy the situation before Bofur died of shock. “I know that braids are very important to you, and I don’t mean to intrude on something I have no right to. I’m not looking for anything, uh, significant,” he clarified, hoping he’d stumble upon the right words that would make Bofur stop staring at him like he’d started speaking Elvish. “Just something to keep it up. Just a…uh a neutral braid,” he stammered. Is there such thing? he thought suddenly. Are all dwarf braids significant in some way?

Bofur’s expression was shifting from utter shock to a wary confusion, as though he was searching for meaning in Bilbo’s words that Bilbo himself had not put there. “Oh bother,” Bilbo muttered. “Just forget I said anything, I didn’t know it would—”

“No, no!” said Bofur suddenly, seeming to snap out of his shock. “It’s quite alright, Master Baggins, you haven’t offended me.” He smiled cordially, a twinkle in his eyes. “I think you’ve spent long enough among us to get a braid of your own.”

Now it was Bilbo’s turn to look skeptical. He was overwhelmingly relieved that he hadn’t offended his friend, but there was a glint of mischief in Bofur’s eyes that made him slightly wary. “I don’t want anything that will cause a stir,” he clarified again. “Not to signify something or other, just a braid.”

“Aye, just a braid,” Bofur agreed, nodding.

“Thank you so much, my dear Bofur,” said Bilbo, feeling the last traces of worry leave him. “I can’t tell you how grateful I am.”

Bofur grinned. “Come over here and sit down.”

 

***

 

“You saw it too, right?”

Fíli huffed a laugh. “Kind of impossible to miss.”

“When did it happen?” Nori asked conspiratorially.

“Sometime last night,” Kíli replied. “It wasn’t there when I went to sleep.”

“Who do you think did it?” asked Fíli, almost scared. “He can’t have done it himself.”

This was met with a hushed chorus of agreement, and then a tense quiet.

“Could it have been Thorin?”

Everyone shushed Ori in unison.

“No, you fool,” Nori muttered. “We all know Thorin would rather face a rampaging warg than admit his feelings for our burglar.”

“But maybe he’s changed,” said Ori, ever the romantic.

Fíli shook his head. “I know my uncle. He’d never do something as forward as that.”

“As forward as what?”

The four of them turned in shocked unison. Bilbo stood at the edge of camp, eyebrows raised in innocent curiosity.

“Asking the men of Laketown for help,” Kíli effortlessly lied. “We all think he ought to, but…” He looked around at the other three Dwarves who shrugged and looked down, trying their best to play along. “He’s rather stubborn sometimes.”

“Oh,” said Bilbo with a short laugh. “Eru knows that’s true.”

“You mustn’t tell him though,” Kíli added, a conspiratorial tone to his voice. “You know how he is when he’s angry.”

Bilbo laughed, albeit slightly nervously. “Yes, yes of course,” he acquiesced. He took a little breath. “Good morning,” he said briskly.

And as he walked away, the four Dwarves watched in shock as he absentmindedly reached up to touch the end of the courtship braid that trailed along his brow and around his ear.

 

***

 

Thorin’s instinctual feeling when he saw the braid was shock. But anger and vicious distaste followed close at its heels, like wolves chasing a rabbit. How could anyone have turned against him like this? They all knew that the quest was paramount, that openly courting the burglar in such a way would only add a layer of complications to an already complex quest.

But beneath the layers of anger, something else lurked, something bitter and unnamed. Thorin fought the feeling as valiantly as he would any other enemy, but it was not to be vanquished. He was in a sour mood all day, snapping at the other members of the company and all but ignoring Bilbo.

That evening found Thorin lurking off by himself, away from the laughter and cheery songs of the campfire. All he could think of was Bilbo, walking along beside them, so carefree, the courtship braid curled around his ear like a caress. A caress of another, a traitorous voice in Thorin’s head whispered. He cursed himself and sighed sharply through set teeth.

“I suppose congratulations are in order?”

Thorin nearly jumped back. Collecting himself he glanced briefly over his shoulder at Balin. “Aye.”

“Oh don’t look so dour,” Balin admonished, good natured as always. “You of all people should be happy for him.”

Thorin nearly laughed. “Why?”

“Oh, come now,” Balin scolded. Then after a small pause he said, softly. “I’m proud of you, laddie.”

Something sharp and twisting tightened in Thorin’s chest. “What,” he asked sarcastically, “for not making a fool of myself?”

Balin huffed a laugh. “You know what I mean.” The night air sat between them for a moment before Balin continued in that same gentle tone that made Thorin want to yell and cry all at once. “I think this will be good for you.”

Thorin felt suddenly faint. “Good for me,” he echoed, his voice hollow.

“Aye,” said Balin slowly, confusion taking root in his voice. “I mean we’ve all seen the way you pine after him, I think we’ll all be grateful to see an end to it.”

“Enough!” The word flew from Thorin’s lips, fueled by the sudden rising rage and devastation that could no longer be contained within him. “Do not speak to me of what is good for me, Balin son of Fundin,” he spat. “You know nothing.”

Balin was staring at him with utter shock, as though he did not understand the admonishment. “I did not mean to offend,” he said softly. “I’m not sure what you’re talking about, but I truly thought you’d be happy.”

Thorin scoffed. “What in Mahal’s name is there to be happy about?” he nearly snarled.

“Your engagement?” Balin said warily. “To Bilbo?”

Thorin felt as though he’d been slapped. He stared, openmouthed at Balin for a moment before he could even find words. “My what?”

 

***

 

“Bilbo.”

The Hobbit turned around expectantly and Thorin ignored the way his heart clenched at the sight of the braid.

Taking a deep yet unsteady breath, he gathered his courage. “I’ve been informed that there’s been a misunderstanding,” he began carefully.

“A misunderstanding?” Bilbo asked, brow furrowed.

Thorin nodded. “You received a braid yesterday, and you were not told the full meaning of it.”

Bilbo huffed a sigh. “Oh Eru Ilúvatar above, I knew Bofur was up to something,” he muttered to himself. “What didn’t he tell me?” he asked Thorin, a note of his usual cheerfulness in his voice.

“The braid he gave you is…” Thorin paused, feeling the warmth rise to his cheeks and only making it worse by attempting to will it away. “It’s a braid of betrothal,” he said finally.

Bilbo went pale.

“It is the first step of entering into a courtship,” he added. “If all goes well, it will eventually be replaced with a braid of marriage.”

Bilbo stared at him, mouth agape. Then he burst out laughing and Thorin’s stoic expression only made him laugh the more. “That cheeky rascal!” he said at last when he’d caught his breath. “Here I was asking him specially for a neutral braid and he gave me an incredibly significant one.” He sighed merrily, staring over at where the rest of the Dwarves were packing. “I must find a way to get him back for it,” he muttered to himself. “But in the meanwhile,” he said turning back to Thorin, “how does one exit a courtship? Is it possible?”

Thorin nodded. “Aye. Taking the braid out is sufficient. While it normally would be considered rather harsh, I doubt that Bofur will take it in such a way.” Or even if he does, he deserves it, thought Thorin with a derision that surprised him.

Bilbo chuckled. “Oh, he meant nothing by it,” he assured Thorin, his fingers already at work undoing the braid. “Only to make a fool of me, I’m sure.”

Thorin made a noise of agreement. All this panic and heartache over a simple prank. He nearly wanted to ring Bofur’s neck, just for the whiplash he’d caused. He watched Bilbo’s hair come free from the braid, the knot in his chest unspooling with relief.

“I’m sorry for the confusion,” Thorin said lamely, trying to find a way to end the conversation that wouldn’t incriminate himself.

“Well it’s not your fault,” Bilbo laughed, shaking his hair free. “Bofur only meant for a bit of fun and I didn’t know better. It’s not your fault.”

Thorin reluctantly nodded. “Even so.”

It was silent for a moment. Bilbo glanced up at him, a small smile on his face and just as quickly looked away, his face flushed. He opened his mouth to say something but shut it again, and Thorin could practically see the internal battle in the Hobbit’s mind.

“What is it?” he prompted.

“Well I was just thinking that perhaps, um…since I still need my hair out of my face if you could—and I don’t mean to impose,” he added hastily, his face growing redder by the second, “but I was wondering if you could, uh, rebraid it? For me?”

There was a long silence. Thorin didn’t know what to say. Had nothing he had just told Bilbo registered at all? Bilbo couldn’t possibly be asking what Thorin thought he was. Could he? “What?” he asked softly when he finally found his voice.

Bilbo looked suddenly a bit doubtful, his hopeful expression dimming. “You’re really going to make me say it?” he muttered almost to himself. “I, um,” he paused and cleared his throat. “Since I know what it means now, could you braid my hair for me?”

Thorin felt as though he were in a dream. For how else could Bilbo Baggins be asking such a thing of him? “Bilbo,” he said softly, still unsure if he could believe this. “What are you asking me?”

Stepping closer to him, Bilbo took both of Thorin’s hands in his own. “Thorin Oakenshield,” he began, his eyes earnest and gentle, “will you give me a courtship braid?”

Something in Thorin’s heart gave way and he drew a shaking breath, failing at last to keep his composure. “Aye,” he breathed. “If you want me to.”

Bilbo was beaming at him, his eyes alight with something Thorin had hardly dared to dream of. “You foolish Dwarf,” Bilbo murmured, and kissed him.

Thorin nearly stepped back from shock, but it only lasted a moment. Drawing a gasped breath, he wrapped his arms around the Hobbit’s small frame and kissed him back. Bilbo laughed into the kiss, his hands framing Thorin’s face with a tenderness that he had never felt before. Bilbo pulled back after a moment, and Thorin kept his eyes closed, savoring the soft breaths and fragile space between them, worried that if he opened his eyes it would have all been a dream.

“I’m sorry,” Bilbo breathed. “Was I not supposed to do that? Is there some law against not kissing someone unless you’re betrothed?”

Thorin laughed softly. “It is not custom, but I am willing to make an exception.”

“How generous of you, King Under the Mountain,” Bilbo mocked with nothing but mirth. “How will I ever repay you?”

“I can think of several ways,” Thorin teased and watched as Bilbo’s face flushed.

“Alright but first you should braid my hair,” said the Hobbit, beckoning him over to sit. “So we are official and all that.”

As if in a dream, Thorin approached and sat down beside him, his hands threading through the golden waves of Bilbo’s hair. Then, with a steady breath, he began.

Thorin had not done this braid in years but he knew the steps by heart. Every young Dwarf learned how to do a courtship braid from the time they came of age, and process was familiar and new all at once. He deftly wove the strands in and around each other, trying to keep his shaking hands steady. Slowly but surely the braid wound across Bilbo’s brow, and down around his ear. Thorin had never thought of a future for himself beyond regaining the mountain. Of course there was the vague future of the Dwarves returning to their ancestral homeland, but he had never considered a future for himself beyond merely leading his people. But as he watched the courting braid form, Thorin began to wonder if this could be his future. Not the weight of a crown and a kingdom, a life that did not belong to him, but a soft and precious love that was his, that could not be tarnished by war, or dragons, or gold. Could he deserve such gentleness after all he had done? He could hardly believe it. But as he tied the end of the braid with a small strip of cloth, he indulged the fantasy.

“There,” he murmured. “All done.”

Bilbo reached up, his fingers tracing the neat braid. “It’s beautiful,” he said, staring up at Thorin with so much love in his eyes that Thorin didn’t know what to do with it all.

There was a kingdom to be won, a dragon to kill, and a fate that he could not foresee. But for a moment, Thorin looked into that dark and unknown future and saw a sparkle of light.

***

Notes:

thank you so much for reading!
kudos and comments are much appreciated if you feel so inclined :)