Chapter Text
"I have to go back to the Shire," Bilbo said. His voice, as usual, was quiet compared to the rambunctiousness of the dwarrow in the dining hall—yet it cut through the chaos like a blade. The entire Company froze, turning to stare at Bilbo, who continued eating as if nothing was amiss.
Almost as one their eyes shifted to Thorin, who looked more surprised than any of them. His face was pale and grim, his usually calm voice hitched slightly as he asked, "Why do you need to go?"
"Oh, well, if I'm gone from the Shire for much more than a year, a few of my less scrupulous relatives are likely to have me declared dead, and my smial and everything in it could be auctioned off!" Bilbo replied, his voice rising with agitation. "I have to go back and deal with my affairs before I can settle here."
"I’ll join you," Thorin said suddenly, and Bilbo stared at him, shocked.
"Thorin, I appreciate it, but Erebor is just being restored. They need their king here right now. You can—"
Thorin cut him off. "It’s alright. Fili is my heir; he can handle things until we return. And Balin will make sure of it."
"What? But I wanted to come wi—" Fili began, only to be silenced by Bofur, who clamped a hand on his arm and jerked his head towards the King, who was now standing with his hands clasped before him, facing Bilbo.
"It is the least that I can do for you." Thorin said, tilting his head down with an air of grave formality. With those words all the dwarves seemed to let go of any arguments and just nodded knowingly between themselves. Bilbo looked around suspiciously but knew they weren't likely to explain it to him.
"Well, if you’re certain, then yes, I would love to have you accompany me," Bilbo replied with a smile.
And the Company had heard it. Bilbo hadn’t said he was leaving for good. He said he was coming back—here, to Erebor. And he didn’t call Bag End his home. He said he'd come back to settle.
Bag End was no longer Bilbo’s home.
...
Thorin fought long and hard to persuade the others that he and Bilbo wouldn't need anyone else on the journey, despite their understanding of his obligations.
Since what was now being called the Battle of the Five Armies, Bilbo had improved his fighting skills, becoming good enough even to keep up with some of the dwarves in training drills with his speed and dexterity. Even before that he had proved his skill with Sting when he used it to ambush Azog on Ravenhill, which had given Thorin the opening he needed to finish him off. No one dared to call it a letter opener anymore. And what's more, Bilbo had proved himself to be a fairly good archer as well. They would be fine on their own.
"Are you sure the two of you will be enough, Thorin?" Balin asked, looking at his king's pack as he prepared for the journey.
"We are not going to fight another dragon, Balin." Thorin said, raising an eyebrow toward his friend. "Bilbo and I will be fine. It must be me, and me alone."
"Yes, yes," he agreed reluctantly. "Well, hearing Bilbo's descriptions of his cousin Lobelia, a dragon might be preferable." Balin muttered, making Thorin snort.
It was true, he mused, that Bilbo had no high opinions of his relatives back in the Shire. Even if Thorin felt sorry for the isolated life that his dear friend had before they met, he couldn't be completely sorry about those circumstances. After all, if Bilbo had been closer to his family in the Shire, he might not be choosing to make his life with them now.
Maybe, he would never have joined the quest.
Thorin gulped.
It wasn't important what could have happened.
Bilbo had asked for something for himself for once, and Thorin had leapt at the chance to be the one to help him. For all that Thorin had done to wrong the hobbit, from the moment of their first meeting to the terrible confrontation on the battlements, Thorin felt a deep and instinctual need to mend the rift that he had created. The weight of his debt sat heavy on his shoulders, but in this service he saw not only the path to offer a fitting altân (atonement), but also the secret hope that after their imbalances were settled, there might be the chance for more between them.
They just had to get through Mirkwood, across the Anduin, over the Misty Mountains, through the Trollshaws and the town of Men, and into the Shire. At least, he thought, this time there would be no orcs following them. How hard could it be?
...
It really shouldn't be that hard, Bilbo thought to himself. He was an experienced traveler now. He should know what provisions to pack and how many spare pairs of smalls he'd need.
But he just couldn't think about packing for this return journey without getting derailed by thoughts of sitting around a campfire with just Thorin and him under the stars…of scaling cliffs or fording rivers, firmly steadied by Thorin’s large hands…of walking for weeks on end at Thorin's side, not another soul in sight for miles upon miles. It could be either exhilarating, or excruciating, but he also knew that he wouldn’t give up this opportunity for anything, no matter what happened.
"Nugget for your thoughts," Bofur said as he bumped his elbow against Bilbo’s arm.
"Oh, just, uh, thinking…about packing, you know." He busied himself with shuffling the things he'd laid out on his bed into the leather rucksack that his friend had brought for him.
"If traveling with Thorin is making you uncomfortable, you know you only have to say the word and we'll be right there with you, right?" Bofur promised with an understanding smile. "After everything, well, I'm just saying no one would blame you for wanting to be careful."
"But Thorin is better now." Bilbo didn't sound very confident about that, even to his own ears.
"Aye, but what happened, happened. And Thorin’s the first dwarf ever to throw off the dragon sickness like this. It's okay if you're not sure, is all. You don't have to do anything you don't want to." Bofur reassured him with uncharacteristic gravity.
"Well, I have to go back, and quickly, now that the passes are clear. If I don't get back within a year and a day from when I left, I'm legally dead in the Shire and you would not believe the paperwork correcting that would require!" Bilbo’s face scrunched and he shuddered just thinking of the amount of letter writing and wheedling he already would have to do just to settle his affairs and ensure the proper care of Bag End in his absence. "Thorin and I can travel quickly just the two of us, and we'll be back before Durin’s Day, I'm sure. If we're lucky we'll meet up with the caravan from Ered Luin on the way back."
"If you're sure, then," Bofur said doubtfully, making it clear just how sure he really was. Bilbo wondered if he should be more concerned as well.
...
Meanwhile, in the confines of the somewhat repaired royal study, Thorin reviewed the paperwork required for his temporary leave and Fili’s regency.
Followed closely by the hulking form of his brother, Balin entered the room with a solemn expression. "Thorin, we need to talk."
"Balin, I already said it will be fine. Fili is responsible—as long as Kili doesn’t pull him into any sort of foolish—"
"Not about that," Dwalin cut in.
"It’s about Bilbo," Balin said gently. "Thorin, you heard him. He no longer sees Bag End as his home. He will come back. You don’t have to go. There will be other opportunities for your altân (atonement). There’s no need to fear." He said knowingly, cutting to the heart of the matter.
Thorin bit the inside of his cheek and sighed, looking at both of his old friends earnestly. "This is the way I must make amends. I can feel it in the stone." Balin’s eyebrows raised at this, and then his eyes closed in solemn understanding.
Thorin continued, "And Bilbo might not see this place as home now, but what if that changes once he is there? Erebor is still just a cold tomb to him, filled with bitter memories. It will be years before we restore her to her former glory. I just... have to make sure he comes back to m—here. He comes back here."
"Are you sure you don’t need a chaperone in case you get a little handsy?" Dwalin teased, and Thorin shot him a glare.
"I’m not some pebble who can’t keep his hands to himself! And after everything... I will not touch Bilbo unless he tells me to. My debt is too great."
He tried to shake the image of Bilbo’s terrified face—his own hands around the hobbit’s throat atop the ramparts. Two gentle hands patted his shoulders, and he looked up to see the brothers smiling kindly at him.
"Then, let's get this sorted," Balin said, sitting down on the other side of the desk to begin reviewing the plans with him.
"Have confidence, Thorin. You’re the first dwarf to ever break the sickness. Wooing a hobbit should be easier, no?" Dwalin chuckled.
"Maybe... but I’m not wooing just any hobbit," Thorin sighed, voice tight with both apprehension and affection. "I’m wooing Bilbo."
"Oh, that’ll definitely be harder," Balin laughed.
...
When they were finally ready to go, standing at the gates of Erebor, Thorin at his side and the rest of the Company there to send them off, Bilbo could finally admit to his own fears and failures. He may know how to shoot an arrow in the right direction and swing his sword a little better, but he was still a little hobbit, a head and a half shorter than Thorin and not even half as strong. A small part of his brain admitted he was worried. What if something out there could trigger the dragon sickness in Thorin again? What if the gangly thing from the goblin tunnels still looked for him? What if, what if, what if?
He let out an exasperated breath. There was no point thinking about the what-ifs. He was going back to the Shire with Thorin by his side. Thorin, Son of Thrain, Son of Thror. King of Erebor. King ... Bilbo reminded himself. He may be a well-to-do gentlehobbit, but he was just that, a hobbit, and whatever thoughts and dreams he had envisioned before everything went to pot over gold and a stupid stone were put firmly to the back of his mind.
This was a reasonably safe journey, especially with just the two of them, and they would be fine. Bilbo could simply enjoy the company of his friend, now that they no longer had the weight of the world on their shoulders. He could make it home in time to secure it from his grasping relatives. He could pack his most treasured possessions to bring back with him to Erebor, to make it a little more livable for a hobbit in a mountain.
And one never knew, if he was lucky it might be possible to someday establish trade that would bring his most coveted products from the Shire right to his mountain doorstep. After all, he was rather familiar with the Thain, his cousin Fortinbras. Then Bilbo could enjoy the short nights before winter set upon the mountain with a tankard of Holman’s brew and a nice pipe of Longbottom. A Hobbit couldn't ask for much more.
Ahh, but he had to get home, had to make it there in one piece, as well as make sure the most dramatic and trouble-prone dwarf he had ever met made it there in one piece too.
...
The first unavoidable stop on their journey would be the Greenwood. And since Bilbo absolutely did not want to meet giant spiders again, Thorin would have to manage not to offend their hosts.
"I never offend anyone." Thorin had the gall to reply.
Bilbo just looked at him, unimpressed. "You called me a grocer as soon as you walked into my house, then you sat in my chair and ate my food."
Thorin blushed. "I have not always been on my best behavior with you."
Bilbo waved his hand. "Look, I know you’ve had trouble with Thranduil, but he has helped us."
Thorin growled. "Trouble? Thranduil abandoned us, detained us, disrespected us!"
Bilbo adjusted the pack on his shoulder. He'd packed and repacked what he felt he'd actually need for the journey. It seemed much heavier than what he'd carried the first time.
"Well, he hasn't done anything offensive this time…yet." Bilbo said, cutting off what might have become quite a rant. "If he's disrespectful, of course it's fine to defend yourself…but just don't wish for him to die by fire."
Thorin’s mouth twitched. "I will behave," he promised solemnly.
Bilbo sighed. "That is all I can ask, I suppose."
Thorin laughed freely at that, and Bilbo was thrilled to hear it. Then the dwarf looked at Bilbo more intently, and frowned.
"Wh-what is it?"
"Is the pack too heavy?" he asked, glancing at Bilbo's bulging bag.
"I can carry it." Bilbo said quickly, not wanting to see Thorin do something chivalrous and give Bilbo's fool heart hope.
"Allow me." Thorin leaned in, moving closer to Bilbo.
With a start and an aborted movement, Bilbo stepped aside. Thorin's eyes filled with pain before he withdrew and Bilbo was quick to speak. "I can carry my own bag just fine, Thorin Oakenshield!"
"Of course." Thorin murmured, his voice growing soft. "I didn't mean to offend you, Master Baggins."
Bilbo swallowed.
In his rational mind, he didn't blame Thorin for his actions on the ramparts. It was the curse, not the dwarf. Thorin had not needed Bilbo's forgiveness because there had been nothing to forgive.
But what his brain understood easily and logically, his heart still struggled to comprehend.
Perhaps, Bilbo thought, during the journey his heart would learn what his mind already knew.
...
Notes:
By the way, a few of us have a stubborn little headcanon that "dwarrow" seems like it should be a plural noun. We know it's technically not, but we are dying on this hill, so apologies if it is not your thing! 🥰
Chapter Text
It would take three days by foot to reach Thranduil’s Halls, and they'd been assured that they would be met at the forest’s edge for safe escort on the second day. It had been decided, rather reluctantly, that war rams would not make good pack animals for their journey, and as no ponies were available, they would just have to travel under their own power.
Bilbo was intensely grateful when Thorin called a stop for their first night near a clear stream just off the road. He meant to carefully slide his pack off his back, but as he did his arms gave out and it crashed to the ground a bit rougher than he’d intended. "Oh, bother." He rubbed at his sore arms and flexed his shoulders, groaning gratefully. "That's definitely going to take some getting used to again!"
"A fair portion of our journey was done either with mounts, or with little to no supplies. It's not surprising that you'd not be accustomed to carrying a full pack." Thorin said while clearing a space for their fire.
"I suppose. That's a good point." Bilbo set to pulling out foodstuffs and setting up a prep space. The two of them worked silently at each of their tasks, moving around one another and anticipating the other’s needs without having to say a word. When their meal was ready, Bilbo took a moment to appreciate how well they worked in tandem, and how natural it felt for just the two of them to be here together. With a little sigh, he shoved that wistful thought back down and brought a plate of food over to Thorin where he was just laying out the last blanket on his bedroll. Bilbo noted that his own bedroll was set up a bit more than a respectable arms length away, slightly closer to the fire.
Again, Bilbo nipped his disappointment in the bud, chiding himself for wishing they were so at ease in all things. You have to shell your peas one pod at a time, after all, he scolded himself.
Thorin was quiet after their meal was cleaned up, but that was not uncommon for him at all. What surprised Bilbo was that he felt no compelling need to fill the silence. Not only was he exhausted from the unfamiliar strain of the day, he just…didn't feel the need to talk. It was rather refreshing.
Once he had washed his face and teeth and wiped off his feet, Bilbo tucked into his bedroll. He took a moment to confirm that Thorin would wake him to take a watch in a few hours, and murmured a gentle goodnight. He assumed he would be deeply asleep as soon as he laid down his head.
...
Thorin sat so he could have as wide a view of the world around him as possible, but also so that Bilbo was always in his line of vision, no matter which way he turned his head.
He was once again amazed at how lovely Bilbo looked at all times. Be it in moonlight, sunlight or the darkness that pressed around the edges of Erebor, no matter how many torches were lit, Bilbo shone. Thorin was sure it was because of the sheer beauty that radiated from inside of the hobbit, having to find some way to escape his form. He had accidentally mentioned that theory to Dwalin once when they were both deep in their tankards, and he would never make the mistake of uttering it again to anyone, least of all to Bilbo.
He purposefully turned his eyes to scan the wilderness around them. He knew he shouldn’t stare, knew it was improper. After all, he was here as Bilbo's friend and guide, here for the hobbit’s protection, not for anything more, no matter how much his old stone heart wished for everything from and with Bilbo.
Thorin let out a morose sigh and wondered if he would ever feel worthy of being Bilbo’s friend again. After everything he had done, everything he had almost caused, all the death and destruction, the broken oaths, and most importantly, the rabid possessiveness poor Bilbo had had to weather when he was out of his mind.
Thorin had sworn all his life that he would never succumb like his grandfather and, to a lesser degree, his father. He had sworn he would be above that, better than that, for he knew he needed to be. And yet, at the first sign of all that gold, he had lost his Mahal-damned mind.
He wasn’t sure if Bilbo remembered, what with how fraught everything had become, but Thorin remembered the first time he had wanted to hurt Bilbo. That first moment when he had come running out of the treasury, Smaug close on his heels, Thorin had held his sword up to the hobbit, ready to run him through.
Thorin knew the scars of those moments and many others were his fault alone, and his burden to atone for.
...
"Are you all right, Thorin?" Bilbo's voice snapped Thorin out of the painful memory. "You seem... well, more brooding than usual." The hobbit was sitting up in his bedroll, not at all as asleep as Thorin had assumed.
Thorin felt a smile spread across his lips. "More than usual?"
"Yes, well, you are often off somewhere alone brooding,." Bilbo said earnestly, tilting his head and looking thoughtful. "You seem to get lost in your own world, blaming yourself for everything that's ever happened, past or future. I'm pretty sure you're even blaming yourself for anything that may or may not be happening in the Shire with Bag End, too."
"If I hadn't dragged you out of your home, you wouldn't have to worry about defending it from your greedy cousins." Thorin murmured.
"There, I knew it." Bilbo gestured sharply, shaking his head. "It wasn't your fault, Thorin. And you didn't drag me. If you don't remember, I ran after you. And my greedy cousins were greedy long before we met."
"Why?" Thorin asked. "I know why you came back after Goblin Town, but why did you follow us in the first place?"
"The song you sang." Bilbo admitted softly, his gaze growing distant. "It was a beautiful song. I mean, before I heard it, your quest just seemed like a very dangerous but pointless adventure. I didn't understand all that you'd lost. Hearing your voice, so melancholy and sorrowful... It added meaning and value to Gandalf's words."
"Did you like it?" Thorin asked, feeling a blush creep up his cheeks. "The song."
"I liked hearing your voice when you sang it." Bilbo confessed.
Thorin sat with that revelation for a moment. "Would you like to hear another song?" he offered.
"I'd love to." Bilbo said, smiling. "You have a very beautiful voice."
Thorin bowed his head, gracefully accepting the praise and the charge of his task. It was easy to do the things that brought Bilbo cheer. And, after everything Bilbo had done for him, it was the very least Thorin could do.
...
"This song is not translated, but I can sing it in Khuzdul for you." Thorin offered before he began to sing in his growling language that always reminded Bilbo of rolling, rumbling boulders.
Bilbo listened to Thorin's beautiful voice —the voice that had touched him so deeply, back there in his cosy smial, and had inspired him to commit to such a perilous journey. It seemed laughable, truly, that such a rich, almost seductive voice was what pushed him into an adventure.
But back then, he had felt it…heard it. The sorrow, the longing, the misery, the mourning, and the quiet desperation that had been laced through every note. His parents had raised him to be a kind hobbit, to help anyone in need. And, well... he had been trapped between obligation and desire by Thorin’s beautiful voice and his desperate message.
Now, though, the quality he heard in Thorin’s voice was different from the song of fire and loss that he had sung that first night. There was a gentler ache to it. The melody was joyful, but there was an undercurrent of sadness and deep longing, like something precious was just out of reach.
~~~<>~~~
Thorin knew that Bilbo wouldn’t understand the words he was singing, but he sang them with all the meaning he could infuse in his voice. It was a love song written by a dwarf whose heart belonged to someone far away—someone from a different mountain home. The song spoke of a vow that resonated with the passion that burned in Thorin’s own heart: to climb every mountain to be at their side, and to build a home wherever they wished, so long as they could be together.
If the Company were with them Thorin knew he would be teased mercilessly for singing such a sentimental song. But here, with just the two of them, he let himself feel. He allowed himself to serenade his hobbit with a love song.
Hold me close and hold me dear
The words you whisper clear:
"You are my hearth and home."
When you are near, the mountain sighs
And when I close my eyes
I see my hearth and home.
When you press me to your heart,
I'm in a world apart
A world where mountains sing
And gems glow all around.
Words turn into love songs
Give your heart and soul to me.
For you will always be
My hearth and home
...
The last notes of Thorin’s heartfelt song faded away into the night.
Bilbo sat in contented silence for a time, not knowing what the song had meant, but captivated by its haunting melody and the beauty of Thorin's voice all the same. Eventually Bilbo encouraged Thorin to seek his own rest, knowing that sleep would not be coming for him any time soon. He put his foot down firmly at taking over the watch, and was most satisfied to see the dwarf king comply without a fuss.
Bilbo remembered what Thorin had been like on the quest. He had often been the first and the last to stand watch, and many times he took longer than he should to wake the others. Bilbo was sure that given a chance, Thorin would take watch all night and carry on through the day, never saying he needed a rest.
It was one of Thorin's most endearing and irritating traits, in Bilbo's opinion. The desire to take care of those one loved before oneself was a very Hobbitish trait that Bilbo could respect, but unlike Hobbits (who were much more sensible about not running themselves into the ground), Thorin had never quite managed to find the balance between too much and not enough. He always presumed he should be doing more, working harder, providing more. And even now, when he had provided his people with an entire mountain full of treasure, even then, he still pushed himself.
It hurt Bilbo's heart to see such a fine dwarf brought low by his own need for redemption. It was his hope that the respite of this little journey would be enough to help Thorin let go of a little of that guilt and pain.
Bilbo also hoped he would have time to let go of some of the hurt and anger that had been festering inside him since they had first entered Erebor. For now, all he could do was look at Thorin softly as he started humming an old Shire lullaby, one that spoke of green trees, open fields, and peaceful days. If anyone deserved peaceful days and peaceful dreams, it was Thorin.
...
The brisk and peaceful morning had given way to a sunny afternoon when the elven delegation stood before them, silently guiding them to the palace where Thranduil greeted his guests.
"Welcome, King Thorin, son of Thrain, and Bilbo Baggins of the Shire." Thranduil’s voice was soft, but clear and commanding. "I hope you will find rest in the halls of my house, and peace among my kin."
Thorin breathed deeply. Bilbo could practically feel the dwarf’s pent-up frustration in his very bones. So, regardless of the impropriety, fearing Thorin was about to insult their host, Bilbo spoke up.
"We thank you, King Thranduil, for your gracious hospitality." Bilbo bowed his head slightly in respect. He was quite surprised when the stern Elven King returned the gesture, as equals.
This wasn't the first time, Bilbo thought, that he had been treated with such high respect by the ancient elf. At least something good had come out of the ‘Arkenstone fiasco’: Bard and Thranduil had begun to respect him.
The biggest surprise of the day, though, wasn't Thranduil, but Thorin. He had allowed Bilbo to speak for him without protest or argument, and now he was following placidly as they were led to their rooms.
"Is everything all right?" Bilbo murmured, reaching out to touch the hem of Thorin's cloak.
"Of course." Thorin replied in a tight voice. "Perfectly fine."
Bilbo could see that something was certainly not perfectly fine, but he supposed the animosity between Elves and Dwarves, and especially between Thranduil and Thorin, couldn't be done away with so easily.
Understandably, Thorin had not forgiven Thranduil for his inaction toward the needs of his people after the dragon attack, nor for the callous treatment his Company experienced at his hands much more recently. In fact, Thorin's behavior, for a brooding dwarf with such a deep grudge, was incredibly polite, though he must have been absolutely seething inside. It hurt Bilbo to think how good Thorin had become at pretending to be civil; masking hurts and injustices for the sake of his people.
A chilling thought struck him: How much of Thorin's behavior toward Bilbo was pretense, How much was true? What did it say about Bilbo that he didn't want to know the answer to that question at all?
...
After he’d refreshed himself, Bilbo wandered out to the sitting room that connected the guest suites. It was rather surreal being back in these Halls, rested and fed and not invisible nor haunted by the whispers and bleakness of the world through his little ring. He patted his waistcoat pocket absently, reassured that it was safe, and grateful that he didn't need to put it on.
"Do you think Thranduil will expect us to dine with him?" he asked Thorin, who was sitting near the unlit hearth, smoking his pipe. That sounded like just the thing to Bilbo, and he longed once again for the mellow pipeweed of his homeland. With a happy zing he realised that in a matter of weeks he'd have all the Longbottom Leaf that gold could buy.
"If he has any sense at all, he will not," Thorin said around the pipe stem in his mouth.
Bilbo snorted at that, quite agreeing. Distance and time were what was needed to rebuild the long-burnt bridges between the kingdoms. "Shall we plan to head out early then?"
Thorin just grunted, taking another long pull. Bilbo sorted out his own pipe and soon the two were sitting in quiet comfort. A dinner tray was delivered, confirming that the Elf King did have some sense of tact after all, and the two passed a pleasant evening in the comfort of Thranduil’s Halls.
Their early start the next day was met by Captain Tauriel, who had been restored to her position not long after Bilbo had made it clear what a service she had been in saving the lives of the Line of Durin.
"Hello, my dear, how fares the Greenwood?" Bilbo greeted her warmly.
Her graceful face was grave, but her eyes were warm. "Gi suilannon, felagon" (I give greetings to you, fair-minded Lord.)
"Oh none of that," Bilbo exclaimed, patting her on the arm kindly. "I'm no Lord and you’re not to be so formal with me! Are we not friends?"
Her eyes crinkled with a fond smile. "Indeed, my friend. I am to escort you both safely to the western border. Are you ready to depart?"
...
With Tauriel guiding them they made swift progress through the forest. She took them on paths that only Elves knew, and they encountered no spiders or foul corruption. It was as if they were traveling through an entirely different forest.
Though Thorin was grateful for her help, he couldn’t help but feel a sting of resentment. This journey was supposed to be just Bilbo and him. He tried not to glare at her, and instead kept things cordial—he knew that if he let his temper show, Bilbo would not look at him kindly. Still, it irked him that over the days of their journey Tauriel and Bilbo would occasionally slip into Sindarin, as if sharing a secret that they kept from him.
Too bad for them because Thorin, son of Thrain, son of Thror had been raised a Prince of Erebor, neighbor to the realm of Mirkwood. Of course he spoke Sindarin; diplomacy demanded it.
Their conversation drifted between teasing remarks about how loud and brash dwarrows can be, light chatter about flowers, and practical advice on herbs. Kingsfoil, in particular, caught Thorin’s attention—he tucked that bit of knowledge away in case he ever had use for it in the future.
But when the tone of their conversation shifted, Thorin found himself pausing to listen to them more intently.
"Do dwarrow marry outside their race?" Bilbo asked softly.
Tauriel gave him a sad smile. "I wish they did..."
"Oh... oh, sweet Tauriel..." Bilbo gently took her hand, trying to soothe her. "You must know that he misses you dearly."
"And I miss him as well," Tauriel replies, her voice heavy with longing. "But alas, it is not meant to be. Dwarrow are carved from stone, whereas Elves are born of starlight. They were not crafted to find love with someone outside of their race, no matter how much that knowledge may hurt us." Her expression was one of quiet resignation. Bilbo's, by contrast, was unreadable.
Thorin wasn’t blind to the affection Kili had for Tauriel. He had always dismissed it as fleeting—a passing fancy—given she was not a dwarf. Yet it felt hypocritical of him to think that way now, especially when he himself was walking beside a hobbit whose heart he was secretly hoping to win.
Thorin took a deep breath, then spoke in clear, steady Sindarin. "It is rare, but not unprecedented. In days long past, when Elves and Dwarrow were allies, some did find love between the two races. Many more found love among Men. If you wish to court Kili, Lady Tauriel, then you must do so by our customs—not yours. Consummation is not considered a form of marriage among my people."
Tauriel and Bilbo’s heads whipped around to him, shock written plainly on their faces. Then Tauriel broke into a small smile and replied, "Thank you for your blessing, King Thorin."
She turned, gesturing to the clearing ahead. "We’ve reached the forest’s edge. I cannot escort you beyond this point. I wish you both well on your journey."
"Namárië, (Farewell)" she added with a deep bow of respect. With a final nod, she departed, disappearing among the trees.
"You can speak Sindarin?!" Bilbo exclaimed, his face flushed a brilliant red.
Thorin smirked. "I am a king with an Elven kingdom as our close neighbors. It would be a diplomatic error not to have learned it, don’t you agree?"
For once, Bilbo—witty as he was—had no clever retort. He only turned even redder.
...
Chapter Text
The last time they'd traveled the grasslands from Beorn's house to the edge of Mirkwood, it had taken the Company four days riding the fat, gentle ponies the skinchanger had lent them. Walking the same way back on foot was no less idyllic, though a bit slower. Thorin and Bilbo were seasoned travelers by this point though, and well accustomed to the routine they’d developed on the road. They went about most of their days with a comfortable, companionable silence that was a balm to Bilbo’s worried mind. If Thorin had thoughts or questions about the things he and Tauriel had spoken about, they did not seem to weigh heavily on his mind, or strain their camaraderie.
When they were still days out from the hedge wall of Beorn’s homestead, they began to catch glimpses of a huge, hulking shape on the horizon, mostly at dawn or dusk. Beorn was tracking their progress, but seemed to be in no hurry to greet them. Which is why, on the third morning of their trek across the valley, it was a surprise for them to wake up to the soft whicker of ponies.
Evidently, Beorn had sent two of his dear children to assist them, or perhaps he was just impatient with their pace, Bilbo thought with a chuckle as he scratched under the chin of a sweet bay pony with soulful eyes and luxurious lashes that made her look quite elegant. "I think I’ll call you Dahlia." Bilbo said. "It’s a fine name for a dignified lady such as yourself. Do you find that agreeable?"
Dahlia just whuffled and nosed at his pocket, which contained the last of the dried apples he’d packed.
"Yes, yes of course my dear! I'll share," he offered up the chewy slices on his flattened palm and chuckled indulgently when her velvety muzzle nipped them up daintily.
Thorin watched them fondly, marveling at how Bilbo charmed everyone he met, even ponies. He was abruptly nudged in the small of his back by the stout piebald pony who had also come to their camp. "No, I don't have apples in my pocket," he said gruffly, to which the pony snorted mightily all over his back.
Their new friends provided a much faster pace, but riding also gave Bilbo more time to fret. He couldn't stop thinking about the way Thorin had said that Tauriel should court Kili by Dwarrow customs. Bilbo realised he had no idea what those customs were, and his only source of that information was the one person he did not want to have to ask.
...
Before Bilbo found the courage to ask Thorin about anything, Beorn’s cabin was coming into view, and with it, their friends’ large, smiling form.
Bilbo had not seen Beorn since just after the battle. As soon as the skinchanger's wounds had been tended enough for him to make the trek home, he had bid a fond farewell to Bilbo, and Bilbo alone.
He hoped that both Beorn and Thorin behaved this time around. Now that Bilbo was as far from stressed as he could possibly be, he realised that almost the entire time they had stayed here before the two had been scowling at each other constantly, not that Bilbo understood why. He had hoped that part of it had been Thorin’s injuries, and things would be better now that he was well-rested and hale. As handsome as Thorin looked with a scowl (which was decidedly unfair in Bilbo’s not-so-humble opinion), they were in a place of peace, with flowers more splendid than Bilbo had ever seen, even in Rivendell and the Shire. He wanted to teach Thorin how to make a flower crown and how to sit amongst the grass and savour the scent as one enjoyed a good pipe and a half a pint of Beorn’s honey mead as the sun set over the land.
Bilbo knew Thorin had had little softness and stillness in his life, and this place of Beorns was a wonderful start to showing him how idyllic life could be, if one allowed oneself to feel it.
It was one of Bilbo’s dearest wishes that while this trip was to fetch his belongings and secure his home, it would also be a way for him to help Thorin learn how to live again, to learn how to enjoy the things so many others, including himself at one point, had taken for granted.
If part of that hope was that if Thorin softened towards other peaceful things, he may soften his own heart towards Bilbo as more than just a member of his Company and a dear friend…well, wishes spoken aloud were foolish things, and so, Bilbo would keep that wish, that hope, close to his own heart, just in case.
...
When they finally passed through the high hedge and into the settlement, Beorn seemed glad to see them. Or rather, he was glad to see Bilbo. He seemed to accept Thorin's presence as if it was a burden to bear.
"I haven't seen Bunny since the battle!" Beorn said jovially, scooping up Bilbo and moving toward the house. "Are you well? Have your dwarves fed you enough?" He poked at Bilbo’s growing waistline with a thick finger.
Bilbo swatted the finger away. "I am not a bunny, and you can put me down now, thank you very much!" He prodded Beorn several times. Since there was no way Bilbo could have hurt or annoyed the giant in any way, Beorn’s gentle compliance was just a sign of the skinchanger's respect and affection for the hobbit.
As soon as Bilbo was back on the ground, Thorin was at his side, glaring darkly up at the tall man. So much for a soft and peaceful rapport between the two. Or, Bilbo mused, that could just have been Thorin’s default look. He was pretty sure the dwarf had his brows furrowed even when he was sleeping.
"Thank you, Beorn, for taking us in." Bilbo smiled. "We don't have a deadline as we did before, but we'll probably get away quickly anyway, and we’ll likely be back this way before winter."
"Don't worry, little bunny." Beorn laughed. "You and your mate are always welcome."
Bilbo felt himself blush, though surely Beorn didn't mean mate in the way Bilbo had assumed it.
"Of course, uh... thank you, again." Bilbo stammered at last, hoping neither of them would notice his discomfort.
Judging by the flash in Thorin’s blue eyes, he had indeed noticed.
Of course he did, Bilbo thought ruefully. For a dwarf who had managed to get lost on his way to Bag End, notably placed at the top of a well-marked road, he was oddly observant at the most inconvenient of times, such as when Bilbo was blushing and stammering. But then, that was just Bilbo's luck, wasn't it?
After Beorn left them alone, Bilbo began unpacking the few things they would need during their short stay. He was also shoring up his courage to ask Thorin a question that had been burning in his mind for some time.
"You know, when you said that Tauriel would have to woo Kili in the Dwarrow way..." Bilbo started as he focused on digging through their packs. He hoped he simply sounded curious about a friend, rather than something much more personal. "I wondered, how would an Elf know the proper way to woo a Dwarf? It's not as if you have a book to explain that, do you?"
...
When no answer was forthcoming, Bilbo looked up to see that he was alone in the room that had been granted them for their stay. He felt his cheeks heat furiously and finished tidying their gear rather aggressively. The cosy little room was complete with two cots, already made up. That was a nice change. They certainly hadn't had any cots or private rooms their first time here.
"Your dwarf has gone to tend the ponies, little bunny. Perhaps I underestimated him." Beorn said from the doorway.
"There’s a lot more to him than a sword or a crown," Bilbo replied after recovering from the startle that came from Beorn of all people moving so quietly. "And really, Beorn, it’s quite unseemly for you to keep calling me a bunny," he sniffed.
"When you stop twitching like a bunny, perhaps I shall stop," he guffawed. "Come little one, I have made the honey cakes you so liked during your last stay. You can tell me stories of your dwarves, and perhaps explain why you and your king are not yet bonded?" Beorn’s bushy eyebrow raised knowingly.
Bilbo’s blush clearly had no chance of receding any time soon. He scurried past the skinchanger into the main room where a sheep was sliding another plate of cakes onto a table already laden with dishes. Bilbo helped himself eagerly, hoping that Beorn might tire of watching him stuff his face, but no, he remembered from their last visit how delighted Beorn had seemed to have an appreciative audience for his baking. "Your honey cakes are as delicious as always, Beorn, thank you." Bilbo said warmly as he tidied up with a napkin. "How did you fare this winter?"
"We did well enough here, even after having my stores depleted with unexpected guests last summer," the large man said rather directly.
"Oh! I never considered how our stay might have tapped your reserves. I am sorry we never thought to send recompense!" Bilbo was mortified that he’d so neglected the responsibilities of a guest. His Hobbitish manners really had taken quite a hit since he ran off with a pack of Dwarrow.
But Beorn just waved it off. "I said we did well, did I not? This land gives freely, and we live well. Your visit was no burden." He leaned his hulking form down closer to Bilbo, and lowered his voice, "I had time to do some ranging in the hills during the cold months, though. The land gave more than bounty this winter," he said cryptically as he dragged a covered bundle out from under the table. "Look," was all he said.
Bilbo’s curiosity overrode any sense of propriety he may have had, and he quickly tugged open the bundle, then gasped. Inside, lay Thorin’s singed, but intact, shield of oak.
...
"Oh!" Bilbo gasped. "I never thought it would... Thorin will be so pleased to see it again!"
Beorn smirked. "I thought the same. Would you like to give it to your dwarf?"
Bilbo felt himself blushing. Now he had no excuses to explain Beorn’s earlier use of the word ‘mate’. It was the third time the skinchanger had referred to Thorin as Bilbo's, as if he could ever claim anyone as grand as Thorin as his own, no matter how he longed to do so.
"Thorin isn't my dwarf." Bilbo stated. "He is a king, and I live in his kingdom. That's our relationship."
"I recall that he valued your opinion quite well, the first time you were here." Beorn murmured. "And I don't think that he would follow another on such a long journey."
"And I am sure that he would do that for any of his subjects. He is that kind of king."
"He must be very special, if he makes everyone feel as you do." Beorn seemed amused.
Bilbo scoffed. "I am not the only one who feels that way."
"I am sure of that." Beorn conceded, before nodding towards the shield. "Are you going to give it to your dwarf then, or should I do it?"
Bilbo huffed, his hands covering the shield possessively as though Beorn would snatch it back. Hadn't he just explained that Thorin wasn't his dwarf? And yet Beorn had completely ignored him—unbelievable!
"I will do it, just to be sure you won't shame me or him!" Bilbo announced. "And he is not my dwarf!"
"Well, he must be someone's dwarf, and certainly he isn't mine." Beorn said gruffly.
Bilbo just shook his head, picking up the shield and stomping off in the direction that Beorn had indicated. The sooner the shield got back into Thorin's hands, the better.
Especially for Bilbo, since he didn't want to hear any other comment on that topic.
...
Bilbo easily found Thorin in a dark corner of Beorn's garden, brooding as usual, with a fierce scowl. What he didn't know was that Thorin was wondering exactly how Hobbit courtships worked. Thorin knew Dis had often had more interactions with hobbits back in Ered Luin—she was the more social of them, and used that skill for the good of Thorin's Halls—so perhaps he could ask her someday. But without Roac at his side, he could not send a raven to ask for her council.
Still, he remembered that flowers were important to hobbits, though he also knew it was an entire language of its own with complex rules about combinations of flowers, what color ribbon to tie a posy with, and how to present it. He had no hope of understanding it fully, and he didn't want to make the mistake of giving Bilbo the wrong message when he meant to show affection. It would be like handing him a spinel instead of a ruby—the latter meant tender affection, while the former would call him a liar!
...
Bilbo saw the thunderous frown on Thorin's face and all of his determination to set the oaken shield in Thorin’s hands and see the light of love spark in his eyes just drained away. He turned right around and walked quietly back to the main house, the shield clutched tightly in his hands.
He stopped, suddenly aware of the fact that he had no idea how Thorin would react, no idea if he would be as pleased or angry, grateful or dismissive…no idea if he would accept it as the olive branch that Bilbo hoped it would be. No matter how much courage Bilbo had gained over his time with Thorin and the other dwarves, he suddenly didn't think he could bear another of Thorin’s rejections.
In fact, Bilbo was so worried about it that he scurried back inside Beorn’s home and right to his and Thorin’s packs. He hoped Beorn wouldn’t mind him borrowing the soft cloth that the shield had been stored in as he wrapped it reverently before placing it safely in the bottom of his pack, out of sight until he could be sure he would be able to present it to Thorin the way he deserved.
Bilbo wasn’t hoping for much, perhaps just a vow of undying love, as a start, he thought with a sardonic twist to his mouth. Still, Bilbo was sharp enough to know that by Dwarven standards, his position in the Shire made him the equivalent of a Dwarven Lord, after Balin had (with what Bilbo seemed to feel was much hopefulness) discreetly encouraged him to research protocol and the hierarchy of the nobility. He had learned that as a Lord of lesser standing, his hope for a courtship with Thorin would get him laughed out of Erebor and running back to the Shire with his tail between his legs.
Unbeknownst to Bilbo, Thorin was sitting in the same position he had left him in, looking at the vastness of the sky overhead, viciously cycling through hope and doubt, praying to Mahal that by some miracle Bilbo would accept his overtures towards courtship, once the unfinished business between them was resolved and he had figured out what suitable courting would even be. He wondered if there were some way he could lay the stone of that foundation now, skirting around the strictures of his atonement.
Thorin hoped that, even after everything, Bilbo would look on him kindly, even though he was sure he did not deserve such a thing from the hobbit he had so cruelly wronged. He knew all too well that hobbits had no love for power, hierarchies, or kings. His position would be no help. All Thorin could do was prostrate himself before the hobbit who owned his entire heart, and hope he was dwarf enough to accept the inevitable when Bilbo found him lacking.
...
Bilbo awoke the next morning to an empty room. Curious and vaguely concerned, he ventured out to see where his companion was.
Beorn was nowhere to be seen, but Thorin was there, facing away from him and holding something.
"What are you doing?" Bilbo asked, confused and forgetting the Baggins’ manners he had always prided himself on.
Thorin started, looking at Bilbo with a nervous expression. Bilbo's eyes narrowed. He recognized that expression. It was the same one Thorin wore after he had offended an elven envoy with his rough, undiplomatic tongue.
"I picked these for you." Thorin said, offering Bilbo something. "To show how I feel about you."
Bilbo smiled automatically as the King lifted an offering of flowers. And then, the smile froze on his face as he took note of which flower it was.
Calla lily.
In the Shire, they called it the flower of undying friendship. It was a beautiful flower, with deep meaning.
Offered as a token of renewed friendship.
Deep, unbreakable, pure friendship.
But merely friendship.
"Do you like them?" Thorin asked, with a strange tone.
Bilbo smiled, grateful for his experience in feigning pleasure when receiving his many relatives at his door all his life. Now it was serving him well in not showing his broken heart to the King.
"I will always treasure them." Bilbo promised. Perhaps, after all that had happened between them, Bilbo could consider himself lucky to still be worthy of Thorin's friendship.
...
Thorin smiled brightly, pleased by how happy Bilbo sounded as he accepted the flower. He knew it was a good choice — most pleasing to look at. As joy filled his heart, Thorin noticed Bilbo’s eyes.
Despite being an exiled prince, Thorin had still been trained to read people in subtle ways. The best method he knew was to study their eyes. He had heard Men say that the eyes were the windows of the soul, and that saying had served him well in spotting cheats and liars who would extort him and tarnish his hard work.
Now, he watched as the once-bright, cautious gleam in Bilbo’s eyes darkened into deep sadness.
Before Thorin could ask what was wrong, Bilbo turned away and escaped into the kitchen to prepare breakfast.
...
Chapter Text
Despite being one of only three beings capable of speech in the cabin, Bilbo somehow successfully avoided talking with Thorin the rest of the morning. He busied himself with the final tasks needed before they departed, surrounded by the sleek dogs and docile sheep that Beorn so loved. They, like everyone Bilbo met it seemed, adored him. He had a little troop of devoted four-legged helpers who followed him about, packing provisions and fetching all they would need.
Beorn met them at the gate. "My ponies and I will see you across the River, and set you on the path for the lower pass," he said.
"The lower pass has not been safe to travel for a decade," Thorin protested.
"Yes," Beorn acknowledged the King, then looked at Bilbo with a broad grin, "but someone slew the Great Goblin last year, and emptied the mountain of orcs and wargs for a great war. The low pass has been quiet, and it will see you home much faster."
"But how will we find our way off the Great East-West Road?" Thorin asked, trying not to show his trepidation at taking an unfamiliar route.
"Oh I think he's quite right," Bilbo pulled out the previously blank journal that Ori had given him before their journey. He had been writing in and consulting it all along their journey. He turned to a page near the beginning and showed Thorin the expertly-detailed map of the lands West of the Misty Mountains that he had sketched out there.
"You see, if we strike out due west from the pass here we should reach the Loudwater, which we can follow south to Tharbad and then take the Greenway practically right to my home! It will be much faster, and we do need to make good time, I'm afraid." His brow wrinkled with worry.
And so Beorn led them and his ponies much farther south of the Carrock, down to where the Gladden River joined the Anduin, then west along the Gladden as it trickled down to its source where it met the opening of the pass. The path before them through the mountains was completely clear of snow, broad and level.
At the least, Thorin was grateful that they would not have any more encounters with Elves since this route would take them far south of the leaf eaters who had so mocked his Company, even while offering them aid. He hadn't been looking forward to facing Lord Elrond again, now that he'd succumbed once to the madness the Elf had predicted. How bad could their luck be that they might encounter a stray Elf in a deserted pass, after all?
...
Bilbo, meanwhile, was thinking of much more unpleasant beings—or one unpleasant being in particular. Taking the lower pass was a great relief to him as well, since he'd fretted about somehow running into that strange creature from the depths. Now that Beorn had left them, surrounded by towering peaks on all sides as they were, he couldn't help but feel that they were being watched by menacing eyes, after all.
On their first day, nothing much happened. Bilbo and Thorin made good progress, and then set their small camp under an overhang. Thorin decided not to risk a fire as it was a mild night, and their bedrolls, blankets, and cloaks would be enough to keep them warm as they alternated shifts on watch.
With no fire in the night and thick clouds covering the moon, the darkness enveloped Bilbo, far more unrelenting than he had anticipated. As he settled into his bedroll his thoughts spiraled back to the memory, vivid and raw, of that encounter under a distant peak of these very mountains, months ago. The creature that had skulked in the darkness had brought to mind the terrible fairytales of mewlips who would snatch at travelers from their murky homes and collect their bones in a sack. That this creature could speak, and even knew Shire riddles, and yet ate goblins alive—it haunted Bilbo's nightmares. He dreamed that it would keep him trapped down there in the damp dark, feeding on him until there was nothing left of Bilbo but an empty husk that joined in its monstrous appetites, always with the sallow glint of gold on his withered hand.
Thorin shook him awake not much later, worry written all over the dwarf’s faces. "Are you alright, Bilbo?" Thorin asked the hobbit, concerned.
"Of course, of course." Bilbo answered groggily. He hadn't realized, but he must have been having a nightmare, and now he was feeling shaken and wrung out. He’d not be sleeping again any time soon. "But, seeing as how I am awake, you may as well settle down now," Bilbo said, a faux smile plastered on his face as he all but bullied Thorin into lying down.
Like any good soldier, Thorin soon found his sleep now that it was offered to him, regardless of how much he wanted to stay awake and console Bilbo. His companion’s demeanour made it clear that he did not wish to talk about whatever had plagued his sleeping thoughts.
And Thorin was correct in his assumption.
Bilbo found himself sitting on a rock a few feet away from Thorin and the overhang they were resting under, unwilling to have stone at his back considering his sleeping mind had conjured disturbing thoughts of... it … scaling down the wall like a misshapen spider. He shivered and pulled his cloak tighter, and his blade closer.
...
The night passed.
Bilbo was sure he could feel Gollum ready to pounce from within every shadow, by turns expecting a murderous attack or a bizarre continuation of their riddle game.
"Are you rested enough?" Thorin asked, glancing at Bilbo worriedly when he woke with the rising sun. "If you are too tired, we can get a later start."
Bilbo wrinkled his nose. "I am well, thank you," he said shortly.
The dwarf scowled at him darkly and turned to pack their bedrolls with a huff. Thorin must have been annoyed with him. For all Thorin’s gifts of friendship, the mithril shirt, and the calla lily, and especially his presence here by Bilbo’s side on this journey, Thorin would always be put off by Bilbo’s…hobbitishness.
How could Bilbo have even thought that Thorin would ever care about him? They were from two completely separate worlds: Bilbo a mere Hobbit, nothing special, and Thorin the majestic Dwarf King who had forged a way for his people to return to their home. Bilbo chided himself once again for his delusions of something more.
Perhaps, he mused, he could still return the shield, but as a token of friendship. If armor could be a token of friendship, then returning the shield would simply be the same. But how to go about it?
"Have you been there before?" Thorin asked suddenly, as if continuing a conversation.
Bilbo gasped, snapping out of his musings as he looked at Thorin. "Excuse me, what?"
"Have you been to Tharbad before?" Thorin asked again slowly, frowning at Bilbo again.
"Not personally, no, but I have heard of it." Bilbo nodded, keeping his gaze averted. "The Men there rebuilt the town after it was destroyed in the floods that followed the Fell Winter more than twenty-five years ago. They do some small trade with the Hobbits of the Southfarthing. We may not find generous hospitality, but there will surely be an inn where we can restock."
...
Despite Bilbo's foreboding, their journey through the pass continued in the next days to be as unremarkable as Beorn had promised. When the jagged peaks started wearing down into foothills three days later it seemed that all was well. Bilbo took a deep breath and could swear to himself that even the air on this side of the Misties smelled differently, fresher somehow.
To celebrate, they stopped early that night and Thorin set snares, hoping to net them one or two lean rabbits for their dinner. When he returned from their camp he found Bilbo just returning himself, his hands full of fleshy green leaves with small white bulbs attached. "I found ramps!" he said excitedly. "Can you get the pocket knife from the front of my pack?"
"It's not exactly a pocket knife if you don't keep it in your pocket, burglar." Thorin chided gently. Bilbo’s pack was face down near their bedrolls, and when Thorin turned it over he was surprised at how heavy it was. "Have you been carrying this weight all this time?"
"Oh! Oh, no…no I’ve…Beorn gave me…well, he wanted to…" Bilbo stammered uncharacteristically, then trailed off. Thorin thought he might know what the Hobbit was up to.
He reached out his hand and clasped Bilbo's shoulder gently. "It's alright," he said softly.
"It…it is?" Bilbo looked up at him with wary confusion.
"Beorn is a good friend. If he wanted to make sure you had extra provisions, I would not judge you for it, Bilbo." He smiled indulgently. "You know, I admire your appetite."
"You…you do?" Bilbo seemed a bit shocked at that.
"When we return to your homeland and you can once again enjoy the plenty of your pantry, perhaps you can make a proper Hobbit meal for us?"
"My pantry! Don't you go on about my pantries, Thorin!" he shook his handful of greens at the dwarf, then seemed to realize why he'd asked for the pocket knife to begin with, and snatched it from his hand. Thorin just laughed as he walked away to check his snares.
Later, neither could quite say whether it was the merry crackling fire or the slowly-roasting coneys stuffed with fragrant ramps that drew attention to their little camp, but regardless, not long after the sun had set, the goblins struck.
...
Bilbo heard them before he saw them, and he instinctively reached for Sting. Thorin was already up with Orcrist in hand, prepared for the moment the goblins arrived.
What he wasn’t prepared for was Bilbo suddenly disappearing beside him. Panic seized his heart for a moment as the ragged pack of goblins charged, and Thorin had to focus on the fight before him for now. He quickly retreated several steps from their camp and into the trees where trunks, branches, and roots made it harder for the goblins to aim.
Thorin weaved left and right, causing the goblins to bury their weapons into the surrounding trees. Before they could pull them free, Thorin ended them with swift, tight slashes. He noticed that, despite their usual aggression, these goblins seemed slower than normal. Judging by their unusually gaunt appearance, he assumed they must be starving. It seemed Beorn's news about the goblins scattering throughout the mountains was accurate.
He also saw some enemies fall before they could even reach him, flashes of a glowing blue blade appearing before blinking out again. Thorin exhaled in relief—proof that his burglar was out there, somehow, fighting and doing well at it. The battle was going in their favor when he heard a sharp whistle and Bilbo’s panicked shout: "Thorin! Look out!"
Thorin turned just in time to see an arrow flying straight at his head. It stopped mid-air—blocked by a familiar oak branch. Bilbo had reappeared, holding the very branch that had saved him yet again.
"Is that my—?"
...
"No time. Fight now. Ask questions later," Bilbo panted as he pushed the Oakenshield into Thorin’s arms, a goblin’s crude arrow still sticking out of it.
Thorin would never be able to explain how he felt at that moment. Not only had Bilbo once again saved his life, but he had returned his precious shield to him. Fitting it to his arm, he felt more complete than he had in months.
Before Thorin could contemplate the fluttery feeling in his stomach, a goblin that had raced forward towards him fell, gasping for breath. That was what pulled Thorin’s attention back to his surroundings once more. Bilbo was right. Fight first, and everything else can be dealt with later.
Thorin waded forward, his trusted shield placed firmly on his arm where it belonged. He now understood how Azog had almost defeated him on Ravenhill, now that he had his shield back. He relied on it not only as a shield but also as a weapon, and he had been fighting handicapped, even though he had not realised it.
He made a mental note to train more with Dwalin without his shield, so he never ran that risk again. How could he defend his people, his family if he was not doing so with his full potential? How could he defend his newly reclaimed kingdom and ask Bilbo to stand at his side?
He took a moment when there was a lull in the fighting to run his hand over the Oakenshield, to feel it beneath his finger tips before engaging once more with all of the protection and added attack power his shield gave him. Thorin wasn't sure how long they fought, or how many enemies they defeated between them. When the last goblin finally fell at his feet he rested against Orcrist breathlessly.
So much for a peaceful journey, he thought. He also thought he was getting too old for all these battles. He swore that the next time Bilbo wanted to come back to the Shire, since they would no longer be bound by Thorin's obligation of service, they would bring most of the Company and possibly an entire troop with them.
By the time they made it back to Erebor Dwalin, Fili, and Balin should have at least a small army, and as king, he was definitely going to take advantage of that.
...
Even after nearly being overwhelmed by goblins, Thorin was grateful that his comrades had granted him this chance alone. Any dwarrow who returned to Erebor and wondered where their king was would instantly understand when it was explained that he was on a journey of ’ultânul, atonement for the most grievous of wrongs.
They had passed the uneasy night after the battle in a new camp set well away from the carnage that would surely be drawing predators shortly. The next day was cloudy and gray. Fitting, Thorin thought as he grimly pondered his situation.
Now that Bilbo had restored such a personal artifact to Thorin, he felt in his heart that his altân was nearing completion, and all that remained was a final airing of all their grievances. They had needed this time; to find moments of quiet as well as time to speak, just the two of them, to do the work of bringing their hearts and minds back in alignment.
Of course, fool that he was, Thorin had only managed minimal progress on that yet. His plan had evolved over their journey, but now he knew that he would need to wait until they were back in the Shire before he could resolve their distance and then let his sânazyungel know his intentions. He had to make sure Bilbo really was returning to Erebor once they'd secured his home just as Bilbo had restored Erebor to Thorin, but also, Thorin really just needed some Hobbitish advice.
He had spent many hours considering the rite, and especially the fact that Hobbits surely would not have nor possibly even understand the stone deep, spiritual need to right their wrongs in such a way. He had tried to find a more Hobbitish way to express his desire for resolution between them, so they might move forward in life together, but it had become crystal clear over the last few days that he’d failed quite thoroughly on that endeavor.
What Thorin needed was an expert, on both Hobbits and on flowers and their mystifying language. Perhaps once they reached Bilbo's home, Thorin might be able to speak with this gardener, Holman Greenhand, who Bilbo put such faith in to watch over his home in his absence.
The land shifted slowly from jagged hills and thick evergreens to sparser copses of some still-leafless trees over sloping hills. Below them in the near distance, a smudge of vegetation marked the location of the Loudwater river, but the land before it was strangely barren.
Towards the end of the day, just as the promising rain finally delivered, it became clear why. The rain came down in sheets over ground that had grown spongy and fetid. In addition to the deluge, he could feel water squish up from under his boots as he walked.
A swamp. Perfect.
Notes:
altân - absolution (forgiveness)
'ultan - greater / greatest absolution (forgiveness)
'ultanul - of or belonging to the greatest absolution
From the DS-Nkh Sentence Maker and this Tumblr post.
Chapter Text
As they continued through the swamp lands, Thorin noticed something odd about Bilbo. The hobbit was moving slowly, his face pale, and breathing labored. He was sweating more than what seemed normal for the cool day and their modest trek. Then there was the way he held his arm—it looked like he was trying not to move it much. Without a word, Thorin stopped and approached him.
"Thorin, what’s wrong? Is there something you nee—THORIN!" Bilbo cried out as he swiftly tore the top half of the ragged sleeve of his coat, revealing an angry, red swelling wound on his bicep—infected from a foul goblin arrow.
"Bilbo, why didn’t you tell me?" Thorin asked, his voice thick with worry.
"I just… I was going to take care of it once we stopped," Bilbo muttered, looking away.
"Well, we’re stopping now," Thorin said, his tone sharp with concern. But when Bilbo flinched, he softened. "I worry for you, Bilbo. You don’t have to hide these things from me."
"I just…" Bilbo chewed the inside of his cheek, but yelped when the dwarf suddenly lifted him into his arms. "Thorin!"
"I’m not letting you exert yourself more than you need to," Thorin said firmly.
Bilbo turned bright red. He should protest, tell Thorin to put him down, and insist that he can walk. But… Thorin’s arms around him… the sound of his heartbeat… the scent of him… Bilbo’s tired, wounded body gave in, and sleep took him in the safety of dwarven arms.
...
"Bilbo!"
When he realised that Bilbo had lost consciousness, Thorin feared for the worst. He couldn't help but remember the effect that infection from an orc arrow had on Kili’s health and spirit, bringing him just one step from the Halls. Thorin had less supplies and even less expertise than they'd had available to them then.
Thorin placed his small body gently on the driest ground he could find and checked his pulse. To his great relief, it was still there, though clearly strained from the infection and the energy he'd expended already.
"Everything will be fine." Thorin soothed, to calm himself as much as anything, trying to clear his mind. He had seen war with countless deaths and injuries, yet seeing Bilbo wounded once again affected him far more than Thorin could have ever imagined.
He set to pitching the small oilcloth tent that he'd carried but rarely had need to use thus far. Well, they needed it now. A fire would be out of the question in this rain, but he could get Bilbo dry at least.
He opened Bilbo's pack and searched inside. "Athelas." Thorin murmured, remembering Tauriel speaking with Bilbo just a couple of weeks ago of how she had cured Kili of the poison. Thorin had no elven magic on his side, but Oin had insisted that all of the Company receive additional medical training. Thorin supposed that Bilbo must have had a hand in that. He was always looking after their practical needs, preparing for anything.
Following Tauriel's directions, Thorin made a sort of poultice with the stems and flowers, before rubbing it into Bilbo's wound. The hobbit thrashed in his fevered sleep, but did not wake. Thorin knew that Tauriel had sung in Sindarin, using her elven magic to speed the healing process.
Thorin had no magic, but he could ask for mercy from his Valar, the mighty Mahal, to make Bilbo strong again, as he had been before the goblin attack. And he could sing his own songs of comfort to his beloved.
...
The night stretched out before him. Thorin could not rest, fearing that Bilbo would no longer be in the land of the living when he woke. He refused sleep as if it would counter that possibility, and continued to tend to Bilbo through his low fever. Thorin occasionally prodded gently at the arrow wound, grateful it wasn’t deeper, observing the angry swelling and streaks of red slowly receding through the night.
He was once again thankful for Bilbo's preparedness in packing the herb that Thorin knew as injamu-azâbad and the Elves called athelas. Thorin was sure Bilbo wouldn’t be faring half as well as he was without it, and he wasn’t exactly in the best shape as it was. The idea of losing Bilbo on a trek back to his homeland, a trek on which Thorin had said he would protect him, a trek where Thorin was trying with all of his might to complete his ’ultânul, didn’t even bear thinking about.
"What would I do if you were no longer in this world with me, Master Baggins?" Thorin asked the restlessly sleeping Bilbo beside him. "Food would lose all taste, light would lose all its brightness, and all of Arda would slip into madness if you were not here. At least, it would for me," he continued, pouring out his glum but heartfelt thoughts to an incapacitated Bilbo.
Thorin wasn’t sure what time it was when Bilbo’s fever finally broke, but the sun was just beginning to rise when the hobbit opened his fever-dimmed eyes and attempted a weak smile before falling asleep again, this time into a healing sleep and not a fever-induced one.
injamu-azâbad - leaf of kings (kingsfoil, athelas)
...
Thorin was sitting outside their oilcloth tent, minding the coals of a small cookfire that was keeping pots of tea and porridge warm, when he heard rustling. Suddenly, Bilbo threw back the flap, squinting at the weak light.
"You shouldn’t be up!" Thorin scolded, jumping up and steadying the hobbit as he shakily stood. "Come now, rest and I will bring you breakfast."
Bilbo just waved him off, but leaned on the offered arm regardless, and quickly sank to a mossy log. "How long have we been here?" he croaked, before clearing his throat and gratefully accepting the offered cup of tea.
"This is the third day," Thorin answered, and Bilbo sputtered and coughed through his tea.
"Three days?! We can't afford to lose that much time!" Bilbo pinched his nose against the headache his outburst caused. "We're so close now, Thorin," he whined. "We can't be more than a week away from Hobbiton."
"A week or a year would matter little if you died on the journey, burglar." Thorin replied darkly.
"Well, I'm hardly at Mandos’ gate now, and I have you to thank for that." He pressed his hand to Thorin's arm and looked up at him earnestly. "In fact, other than being intensely hungry, I rather think I'm feeling alright."
Thorin picked up on Bilbo's cue and handed over the bowl of porridge that he'd been preparing with nuts and honey. Bilbo quickly devoured it, and three more like it.
"We should be able to make it to Tharbad by the end of the day, if we push. I am in dire need of a bath." Bilbo said between servings.
Thorin seemed skeptical of Bilbo's ability to travel today, but did concede that they were both rather rank. "But we will rest, if you need it," he said menacingly.
Bilbo just laughed, "I've never before been threatened with such kindness." He smiled fondly at his dwarf, "Yes, dear, I promise."
Bilbo grinned to see the shine that rose under Thorin's beard at his teasing.
...
Later Bilbo was second-guessing himself, feeling perhaps that he should apologise for being so forward and familiar with Thorin, maybe using his fever as an excuse. If he remembered correctly, Kili had said some rather embarrassing things to Tauriel while he was recovering from the poison. The endearment had been a lapse, and, despite his own secret pleasure at having finally used the term that sat in his heart constantly, he felt he must apologize to his friend.
The King’s friendship - Bilbo still felt the sting of Thorin's gift burn, even though the flower was long gone - was better than not having him in his life. The soft voice that he had heard whispering sweet vows while he was recovering had to have been simply another dream, a foolish hope for a foolish hobbit.
Bilbo's troubled thoughts continued to weigh on his mood as the town grew closer. He couldn't seem to stop the spinning worries and fears that dragged him down and made him feel irritable and out of sorts. The sun was low in the sky and his thoughts were dark and unsettled as they crossed the great Bridge of Tharbad, repaired now since the floods and busy with commerce even this late in the day.
...
As they walked through the busy streets of Tharbad, Bilbo heard the familiar sounds of life all around him—the clatter of hooves, the chatter of voices, the comforting sight of people moving about without a care. It was different from Hobbiton, of course—this crowd included many races, including a few Hobbits—but still, something about it felt a little like home and it soothed his worries, just a bit.
That’s when Bilbo spotted an inn. His eyes lit with anticipation for a warm meal, a clean bed, and, most of all, a bath.
"Let’s get a room for the night. After that, we can see if there’s a caravan heading toward Hobbiton. I know some of my Took cousins have come here for trade," Bilbo said.
Thorin nodded his agreement.
Inside, they found a handsome young hobbit with thick blond sideburns stationed at the front desk. Bilbo was delighted to greet the first hobbit he'd spoken to in nearly a year. He walked up to the low counter with a cheerful step.
"Good day to you, sir. Might I ask if you have any rooms available?"
"We do indeed! Will you be staying for the one night?" the hobbit asked brightly.
"Yes, we are," Bilbo replied.
"And how many are in your party?"
"Just the two of us." Bilbo gestured between himself and Thorin, who was standing just behind his shoulder.
The hobbit glanced between them, then smiled broadly. "I see. There’s a room with a lovely view of the sunset—perfect for a romantic evening with your husband."
"A-Ah, we aren’t—I mean—I—" Bilbo stammered, feeling flustered. In Tharbad, where many races mingle, a dwarf-hobbit couple must not seem unusual.
Thorin stepped in smoothly. "We are not a couple, simply companions. But we do require one room—with two beds—for security."
"Ah! My apologies," the hobbit said with an easy laugh. "I do have rooms like that. I’ll gladly book one for you."
"Thank you," Thorin replied.
Bilbo blinked. Thank you? From Thorin? It is basic courtesy, but Bilbo had rarely heard Thorin say it—even to him. Why now? He wondered sourly if it was because of something about this hobbit. He was rather handsome. Would Thorin favor him because he has a bit of facial hair? But then, Bard and other Men had facial hair too, and Thorin was always rather rude to them, no matter all they’d done for the dwarves. Maybe I’m overthinking this, Bilbo told himself. It has been a long journey.
Lost in thought, Bilbo barely noticed that Thorin had already paid, absently following him upstairs.
"Bilbo, are you well?" He asked worriedly. "They should be bringing you a bath shortly. I would like to resupply and look for a caravan while I still can tonight. You stay here and rest, alright?"
Bilbo nodded quickly. "Oh, of course. I do need to rest a bit, after all."
Thorin scrutinized him for a moment, then nodded with a small smile and headed out.
As he watched Thorin leave, Bilbo frowned. Suddenly, he was deeply concerned that Thorin might speak to the Men here with the same gruff suspicion that he usually did, and he might ruffle some feathers. On impulse, Bilbo quickly locked their room and followed him, slipping on his Ring for stealth.
Since wearing the Ring in battle a few days ago, Bilbo had been thinking of it often, and found the muted colors and whispering wind that came when he wore it somehow more comfortable than ever.
What he saw as he followed the dwarf surprised him. Thorin was speaking with people—mostly Hobbits—with respect, warmth, and... manners. He even made a few of them laugh.
Bilbo watched, stunned. Why is he being so friendly? Thorin used to glare at every stranger—including Bilbo himself.
And then Bilbo heard a hobbit flirt with Thorin.
Something inside him twisted.
Ah. That’s why. Thorin must find them attractive after all…
Bilbo hurried back to the inn, doing his best not to lose his composure, pressing his palms against his smooth cheeks. Most Hobbits in Tharbad were of Stoorish descent and the males all had some small amount of facial hair. To a Dwarf, they must seem far more appealing than Bilbo's bare face.
When Thorin returned, he found Bilbo sitting silently, uncharacteristically still.
"Bilbo? Are you all right?"
Bilbo forced a bright smile, hurriedly wiping his hand over his face. "Hmm? Yeah. I’m fine. Just... homesick. The bath hasn't arrived yet."
"I see. Seeing one of your kind after so long tends to do that." Thorin set the supplies he'd gathered on the table and walked over, placing a warm hand on his uninjured shoulder. "You must be tired of dealing with us Dwarrow all this time," he added with an awkward smile.
Bilbo stared at him, caught off guard.
"You know, back then... I disliked Hobbits," Thorin continued, voice low. "I used to call them halflings—even though I knew it was derogatory. I truly believed Hobbits were less than other races. Small, weak, and entirely unable to handle a journey such as ours."
Bilbo glared at him, but Thorin smiled earnestly and opened his mouth to continue.
...
"Well, I'm happy that you stopped calling us halflings," Bilbo interrupted him, rising suddenly as he remembered Thorin and that other hobbit. "After all, it's one of the greatest insults someone could make to a Hobbit."
Thorin blinked, "What do you mean? I thought it was..."
"You just admitted that you knew it was denigratory, Thorin." Bilbo reminded him sharply, feeling his irrational anger swell. "You know who started calling Hobbits that? Elves."
Thorin stood silent, having the sense to let Bilbo keep talking until he'd said his piece.
"’Halfling’ is how we are regarded amongst Elves. Half of a Man, not worth as much as an Elf, certainly. When someone calls a hobbit ‘halfling’ it is implying that the hobbit's life is worth less than his own." Bilbo shrugged. "We are used to insults from other races. Gandalf, Lord Elrond, and his people... They are the only ones that treat Hobbits with respect."
"I..." Thorin muttered. "You know that I didn't mean it like that, right? Your life is worthy."
Bilbo smiled tightly. "You say that now." He couldn't seem to stop the bitterness from pouring out now that he'd unstoppered it.
"What does that mean?" Thorin asked, his voice crackling.
"Hobbit hearing works quite well, Thorin, better than most, in fact." Bilbo’s smile sharpened into something hard and distant. "I heard you, speaking with Gandalf, that first night. Not responsible for my fate." Bilbo stopped Thorin from answering with a raised finger. "I didn't judge you for it. You had a purpose in mind and knew that I would be a burden." Bilbo shrugged. "We are accustomed to hearing that kind of contempt from other races. Very few give much credit to Hobbits."
Bilbo blinked, feeling suddenly uneasy in such close quarters. The words Thorin had growled at him when he was in the throes of gold sickness sounded in his mind.
Miserable rat.
Thief.
"Well, I feel like sleeping now." Bilbo’s anger seemed to leave him all in a rush, and he felt cold and tired in its wake. "If you didn't find a transport for the Shire, I'm sure we'll find something tomorrow."
"Bilbo, I-" Thorin began to speak.
"Goodnight, Thorin." Bilbo interrupted him. "I'm sorry, but now that I see a bed, I suddenly feel quite tired."
"Of course." Thorin sighed. "Goodnight, Master Baggins."
...
Chapter Text
The room was empty when Bilbo woke. So, that's that, then, he thought to himself bitterly, and had to bite his lip hard to keep from breaking down there on his pillow. He rolled over and wrapped the blanket tighter, feeling thoroughly sorry for himself and increasingly confused as to why he had even been angry with Thorin last night in the first place. Once he'd let his anger slip, it had seemed to rage like a brushfire, out of control and with no logic whatsoever. What a fool he was.
It could have been three minutes or thirty that he lay there feeling sorry for himself when a key rattled in the door. He quickly flipped over and feigned sleep as the lock turned and he heard Thorin shuffle into the room. What, had he spent the whole night in the common room drinking??
He heard shuffling and clinking, and then a heavy sigh, before his bed dipped under the weight of a solid dwarf king, sitting on the edge. A gentle hand rested on his shoulder and squeezed lightly. "I've brought you breakfast, amr—hmm" Thorin whispered, seeming to cut himself off. Oh Bilbo really had made a fine mess of things, hadn't he?
He took an exaggerated breath, humming and shifting as if he were just waking up. "Wha’ssat?" He mumbled.
"Come. Eat " Thorin said simply, and stood again, lifting the covers off of the plates he'd brought up. Bilbo groaned in earnest this time. It smelled divine. The table was crowded with a whole platter of fried sausages and scrambled eggs, a stack of toast with a pot of jam, even a steaming teapot and a lovely saute of mushrooms and wild greens on the side. Truly, it was good to be so close to home again!
Bilbo forestalled the inevitably disappointing conversation by diving into the wonderful breakfast before him. He hadn't lost all of his manners, of course, and made sure Thorin’s plate was full as well before he filled and emptied his own twice over.
Once he'd slowed down a bit, Thorin reached out and stilled his hand over his teacup. "It is long past time that I should have come to a reckoning with you, Bilbo," he said suddenly, his voice quiet and steady. How can he just come right out and say something like that? Bilbo despaired.
"I…I'm sure that's not necessary, Thorin," Bilbo began weakly.
"No, it is. There can be no 'ultânul without mining out the faults between us." Thorin replied.
"You'll need to speak a language I'm allowed to understand for that to happen," Bilbo snapped, then winced. He just couldn't seem to keep himself from stepping right in it every time he opened his mouth for anything other than food, it seemed.
Thorin's mouth twisted, but his voice remained even. "Bitterness has been allowed to fester between us. To step into our future with a clean slate requires an airing of all grievances…for both of us."
...
Bilbo instinctively recoiled. Airing grievances so openly went against everything he had been taught—it was rude, vulgar. Worse, anything he said ran the risk of fracturing the fragile bond they shared. But then, Thorin reached over and gently took his hand.
"Bilbo," he said, voice low and steady, "I promise you—our bond is not so delicate that a few words could shatter it. Don’t think of it as pointing out faults in our relationship. Think of it, in Hobbit terms, as weeds we need to pluck from our garden."
Bilbo nearly snorted at the metaphor. It was a clumsy attempt to soften the blow, but it did help, in its own way. He drew a deep breath, and nodded.
"Alright... Yesterday... I, um, followed you. I’m sorry."
Thorin raised an eyebrow. "I’ll admit, I’m disappointed, but I’m more impressed that you did it without my noticing." He paused. "Still... it’s not alright, is it?"
Running a hand over his beard, Thorin exhaled and continued in a voice thick with sincerity. "Last night, my words hurt you. I was offensive towards you and your fellow Hobbits, even unintentionally, and that is still an offense—and for that, I apologize. I offer you my altân, atonement in my vow to do better by you from now on."
"That’s just it!" Bilbo blurted out, frustration with himself overflowing. "You knew when you were being rude—using the word halfling—but you’ve changed! You’ve become better! And yet... something in me still felt vindictive. I don’t know why! I’m not the sort to hold grudges, but I was angry. At you. At those hobbits. Like—like you only said those things to justify forgetting that you were mine!" His words ended in a snarl, and both hobbit and dwarf jerked back, startled by the outburst. A tense silence fell between them. Thorin’s gaze dropped to Bilbo’s hand—and he realized that he’d been clutching something in his pocket this entire time.
When Bilbo noticed too, he pulled his hand away as if burned. "I... I never thought of you like that," he said weakly. "Not until... well, not until I last wore this..."
With trembling fingers, Bilbo reached into his pocket and drew out a simple gold ring. He set it on the table. The act seemed to pain him, like parting with something far heavier than it appeared.
...
Thorin looked at the deceivingly simple-looking gold band and felt his throat close. The gold seemed to shine with a lustre that was at odds with the weak morning sunlight. What was it, and why did Bilbo have a gold ring upon him?
Thorin’s first thought was that Bilbo was betrothed and had hidden it from him, from them all. After all, they had talked about their cultural practices on the quest, and Thorin had learned that Hobbits used simple rings to signify their bonds in the same way dwarves used marriage beads and braids. So, who did Bilbo receive this ring from?
It was only when Thorin saw Bilbo’s grimacing trepidation and the trembling of his hand as he seemed to hold himself back from snatching the ring up again that Thorin realised, this wasn’t something Bilbo had received in a happy circumstance; this was something that had ensnared him, and Thorin more than most, understood the weight of such things. "Bilbo ... what is it?" he asked, refusing to take his eyes off the deceptively innocent-looking band of gold.
"Wrong. It’s wrong, Thorin, but I can’t explain why," Bilbo admitted with a whisper.
"What do you mean wrong?" Thorin asked when he could finally lift his gaze from the ring.
"It ... it makes me invisible, but it turns the world into shadow and darkness. I used it to hear the spiders, and I could understand what the orcs were saying, and ... it makes me want to forget about all the things I love," he said with a shudder. "All the things I want. It makes me think I’m taller than Beorn and ready to take over the world. I don’t want to take over the world, Thorin. Why would I want to take over the bloody world? I’m a Hobbit, for Yavanna’s sake," Bilbo declared hotly as he pushed himself away from the table and the ring.
Before Thorin could say anything else, Bilbo whirled back around and leaned into his face to confide in a desperate voice, "It whispers. And do you know what it whispers, Thorin?" His voice cracked with sorrow. "That I should run you through. That you will never see me as more than a Shire rat. That you will once again hold your sword against my chest even as I do the job you entrusted to me. It tells me that you are biding your time until you kill me and take it, and how can I deny it when you nearly did the same once over a bloody rock?!"
Thorin looked deeply shaken as he watched Bilbo’s eyes widen with fear. He seemed shocked at his own words, yet unable to stop the bile from spewing forth. "And you! You wanted to throw me over the battlements!" Bilbo all but wailed, tears now falling down his face. "I thought ... I thought we were becoming more, but you never cared, did you? Not really." He wrapped his arms around himself desperately. "I’m sure you’re only helping me because you feel guilty, and then you will march right back to Erebor, leaving the Shire rat behind once again. I suppose being unwanted and left behind is better than being murdered for a stone," Bilbo spat out as he snatched up the ring and backed away from the placating hand Thorin had reached out to him.
A part of Bilbo remembered all the times those large, strong hands had held him gently, all the times they had cared for him or aided him, but superimposed over those times were the remembered images of Thorin holding a sword to Bilbo’s chest as a dragon roared behind them…of those hands gripping him greedily as if he were just another mathom in the hoard…cruelly holding him out over the abyss.
And those hadn’t been the only times, the darkness whispered from within him. All of the unkind words Thorin had thrown at Bilbo throughout their journey, all of the cruel things he said…Thorin hadn’t been kind even when rescuing Bilbo from the cliffs with the stone giants. He had been rude and cruel, and once they were on firm ground he had pushed Bilbo out of the way so hard he had all but bounced off the wall as the Company trudged into the cave where they had become separated. And this was all long before the dratted Arkenstone business, when Thorin had become cruel and possessive, leaving bruises on Bilbo’s arms as he roughly kept the hobbit close while the Company searched for the very stone that had been weighing a hole in Bilbo’s pocket.
Bilbo had been terrified for too long, and now, even with the odd golden ring screaming at him, something inside him screamed back that he would never hold those things against Thorin again.
...
All of the fear and hurt had come crashing back at once, and was slow to recede. Bilbo gasped like he was drowning again in the Forest River, struggling to break free from the tumultuous thoughts that tried to drag him under. The hands he so loved and feared in turn were softly stroking his hair, the heart he treasured above all things, especially treacherous rings, was pounding in his ear as Thorin gently rocked them.
How did they get on the floor? Bilbo wondered numbly. He was sat in Thorin’s lap, where the dwarf king was wrapped around him protectively.
He realized that Thorin was speaking to him, pleading and crying in a mix of languages. "Bilbo amrâlime come back to me. Don't let it take you. You are so strong, markhel, ghivashel, you are belegoth, lukhelime...Avo dhavo am môr I know you can do this. I am here, I will never leave you. My place is by your side, but do not go where I cannot follow, please."
Bilbo had never, in all their distressing adventures together, heard this depth of desperation in Thorin’s voice. He sounded terrified, and that more than anything shook Bilbo right out of his haze. He stiffened, and Thorin stopped his stroking and pleading, just waiting to see how Bilbo would react.
He could feel the fingers of his right hand cramp and pinch with how hard he had squeezed them around the Ring that was still clutched in his hand. Suddenly he wanted nothing more than for it to be as far away from him as possible. He threw it as hard as he could into the grate of the low fire that warmed their little room, even as his other hand came up to grasp his own wrist, warring from within even still.
Bilbo sobbed and collapsed against his dwarf, bereft and terrified at the strange darkness that had eclipsed his reason.
- amrâlime - love of mine (Khuzdul)
- markhel - shield of all shields (Khuzdul)
- ghivashel - treasure of all treasure, beloved (Khuzdul)
- belegoth - great light (Sindarin)
- lukhelime - my supreme light (Khuzdul)
- Avo dhavo am môr - don't yield to darkness (Sindarin)
...
It broke Thorin's heart, seeing the way his hobbit, his brave hobbit, who had riddled a dragon and yelled at kings and steadfastly helped his people reclaim their heritage, shook as tears rolled over his cheeks.
Thorin felt bereft. When he had been lost to the gold, Bilbo's words had been enough to call him back from the darkness, even if Bilbo may not have realised it then. But, now, Thorin could only whisper comfort words, words of love, mixing all the languages he knew—Sindarin and Khudzul and Westron—hoping that it would be enough for his hobbit to hear from within whatever darkness had him in its grip.
The words Bilbo had spoken just now, a bitter but honest and so heavy accounting of all the wrongs he had committed against the hobbit, had pained Thorin to hear. They were horrible, not only because of Thorin's shame, but because they had shown him the way his beloved hobbit thought that Thorin saw him.
"You are right for blaming me." Thorin whispered in Bilbo's hair. "You are right at wanting to defend yourself from me. And, if I ever laid my hand again on you like I did once... I'd accept death gratefully, knowing that you would be safe from me."
Bilbo tried to protest, but Thorin spoke again. "But never think I want to get rid of you, that I would leave you in the Shire, in a place that doesn't deserve someone as incredible as you are. I don't deserve you either. I don't think anyone or anything exists that deserves you, Bilbo Baggins. You are something unique. Something I have never met before in my long life, and that now I feel blessed to have met and known. You... you have helped me, even when I was nothing but cruel towards you. Bilbo, you are not a miserable rat, as I called you in my sickness. You are..." Thorin shook his head. "There are no words in any language that I can use to describe how incredible you are."
Bilbo blinked, sniffling and looking up at Thorin, tears in his eyes. "You really think so?"
"Yes." Thorin promised. "And we will solve this. I will help you, just as your voice called me out of darkness when I needed it." Thorin paused, before muttering. "When I needed you."
...
He squeezed Bilbo's arms and gently set him aside, rising to fish the cursed ring out of the fire, which, while not hot enough to melt it, could still cause damage, when he exclaimed, "Behkazu Mahal tamrakhe!"
"What?! What is it?" Bilbo exclaimed, jumping to his feet.
Thorin pulled the heated ring out of the coals, pinching it gingerly between his forefinger and thumb and holding it as far from his body as he could, watching in horror as the glow of the fiery letters along the plain gold band slowly faded away.
He dropped the ring onto the table and the ringing thud it made implied an object of much greater weight. Everything about this foul object was wrong.
"What language was that?" Bilbo cried. "I'm familiar with the Tengwar, but those words mean nothing to me." He rubbed his upper arms, unsettled nonetheless.
"I do not know," Thorin sounded deeply shaken, reaching out again to offer comfort and take it in kind. "By Mahal, I do not know."
- Behkazu Mahal tamrakhe! - Mahal’s hammer shields me!
...
"What do we do with it?" Bilbo asked from where he had pressed his head against Thorin’s chest, trying to hide away from his troubles, even for a moment. He just wanted all the anger and pain he was feeling to leave him. He was sure that, just as Thorin, in his sound mind, wouldn’t have hurt him without the influence of the Arkenstone, the ring was feeding his darker emotions. He wanted nothing more to do with it.
"I do not know," Thorin answered again, truthfully. "When we get to your home, can you send a message to Tharkûn?"
"Not really. He sort of comes as he pleases, and when you least expect him to, honestly," Bilbo said, his voice hoarse.
"Then we will go to Rivendell, after the Shire. We will take the time and seek Elrond’s advice," Thorin said decisively.
"You would do that?"
"Indeed. After all, Elrond has shown his wisdom. It may be that he will know what we do not," Thorin said, fighting to hide his grimace. As elves went, Elrond was decent, but well, he was still an Elf.
But this ring was evil. Thorin could feel the power it held even from where Bilbo had thrown it across the room. He did not want his burglar carrying this burden any longer, nor did he particularly want it anywhere near himself, for that matter.
"But what do we do until then?" Bilbo asked as he lifted his head and caught Thorin’s gaze with his tear-filled eyes. "I can't wear it again, when it makes me feel such terrible things. I don't even want to hold it again!"
"I ... have an idea," Thorin said suddenly as he slowly removed his arms from Bilbo and stood.
"Which is?" Bilbo replied as he, too, stood, looking up at Thorin from where they stood close together.
"This is ... That’s to say ..."
Bilbo was sure he had never seen Thorin speechless, and to see such a regal dwarf lost for words and his cheeks and ears pinking, well, Bilbo was charmed. He was terribly confused, but charmed nonetheless. "What is it, Thorin?"
Thorin took a deep breath before removing something from around his neck and fiddling with it before holding his hand out to Bilbo.
"What are you ... oh ..." Bilbo exclaimed. His eyes were riveted to what Thorin had shook out of a small velvet pouch and into his hand.
Thorin took a deep breath before he unthreaded the leather thong that had kept the old but well-loved pouch around his neck. He then threaded that thong through the stunning beads he held safely in the palm of his hand before presenting the makeshift necklace to Bilbo.
"These were my Amad’s beads. They are all I have left of her, after her passing during the Long Migration. It is too early for some of what we must speak of. We must see the process through, and this is most assuredly not the place for such conversations. But I would be honoured if you would hold these and protect them for me, Bilbo," Thorin whispered, his eyes burning with ardent emotion.
"Thorin, I can’t..."
"Please, do not say you can not…unless you truly mean it." Thorin winced at the idea. "I am not asking you to court me, not yet. I am asking you to keep these safe for me so I can use this," Thorn explained as he nodded down at the pouch in his other hand.
"Not yet?!" Bilbo exclaimed, his eyebrows raised in shock. "And what are you using that for?"
Thorin gently thumbed at the opening of the pouch and showed Bilbo that the inside was lined with the same fine mesh of unmistakable silver steel that was currently adorning his own body. "Mithril?" Bilbo asked in wonder.
"Yes, some of the last. We could not bear to sell it. We sold all of my Amad’s jewellery and her other beads, but we could not bear to part with this pouch and these beads." Bilbo soaked up these rare details of Thorin’s past and his family, as the dwarf continued, "I hope you will protect her beads for me until we can discuss what I wish to do with them. Mithril is known to have protective properties, so I hope that the mithril inside of this pouch will help guard us against the evils of that ring."
Thorin’s intent gaze bored into Bilbo’s as he continued, "No matter what, understand this, Bilbo Baggins, son of Bungo: I will not let this evil consume you, as the Arkenstone and the dragon’s curse attempted to consume me," Thorin declared as he gently raised Bilbo’s hand and pressed a soft kiss to the back of it, revelling in the way Bilbo’s ears had pinked and now matched his own.
"It would be my honour to protect this for you," Bilbo whispered as he gently held his hand out for the bead necklace.
To Bilbo, the smile on Thorin’s face was worth every trial that they had faced.
...
While Thorin gingerly used a knife to slide the ring into the pouch without touching it, Bilbo inspected the mithril beads on the leather cord with wonder. Before he could talk himself out of it, he spoke, "Thorin, can you...would you braid these into my hair?"
Thorin’s breath caught, nearly fumbling the pouch as he tied it securely. "Bilbo, I told you—you don't have to accept them that way. If you do, my people will assume things, and... if I braid them into your hair, it means... something very intimate."
"I know... it's just... I don’t know how to braid my own hair, and I figured..." Bilbo rolled the lightweight beads in his hand. "Well, the ring nearly slipped out of my pocket so many times, I’m afraid the beads could slip off as well. Maybe wearing them as intended is safer than just keeping them on a leather cord. And, well, hair isn’t so intimate for Hobbits, but... You don’t have to, if you don’t want to—"
"I do!" Thorin cut in. "Oh, I do, Bilbo."
They stared at each other in silence for a long moment before Bilbo gave a shy nod. Thorin stowed the pouch away at the bottom of Bilbo’s pack, then retrieved the fine wooden comb from his own. He tentatively sat beside Bilbo and, with trembling hands, gently smoothed the comb through his unruly curls. It felt so soft—just as he imagined. Like silk. He wanted to run his fingers through it forever.
But this... this was scandalous enough for Dwarrow as it was, given the lack of resolution to his ’ultânul, and the strange circumstances that defined, well, their entire relationship. He felt the need to rush, and yet, if he rushed and hurt Bilbo...so Thorin took his time, smoothing each tangle, then gently taking up a section behind his ear and weaving the beads into Bilbo’s hair with slow, careful reverence, as if he was performing a sacred act. In truth, for Thorin it was more like worship.
And Bilbo... he had never imagined having someone braid his hair could feel so intimate. But the way Thorin’s fingers moved—gentle, deliberate—set his cheeks aflame. He had never felt closer to Thorin than he did at that moment. Maybe it was because he understood what this act meant to Dwarrow. Or maybe it’s just because it was Thorin.
Either way, Bilbo knew he would never forget the feeling of Thorin’s hands in his hair.
...
Chapter Text
The next morning the exhausted travelers ran into a spot of good luck, as Thorin encountered the foreman of a caravan of dwarrow that had been camped on the outskirts of the town, and was planning to leave for Hobbiton that very day.
"Aye, we've had word there's some festival of some sort goin’ on in Hobbiton next week, and there's to be a market that should be good profit," the foreman explained.
Thorin handled the negotiations for their travel, and quickly returned to Bilbo with the good news. The hobbit was perplexed though. "There's no festival this time of year," he said, scratching his bare chin. "Mid-summer’s not for weeks. Perhaps someone is getting married, but that's not generally call to hold a big market." He shrugged, and set about packing their gear with his usual efficiency.
They introduced themselves to the dwarrow traders with no mention of titles or lineage, wanting to keep things as simple as possible. It came naturally for Thorin to tie his braids back and hide his identity when encountering new people, even dwarrow, unfortunately. Bilbo received some raised eyebrows when they got a look at his braids, and especially when the mithril beads sparkled in the sun, but thankfully it wasn't in dwarrow nature to pry, and no one asked about them directly.
It was in dwarrow nature to gossip, however, and they were both the subject of much whispered speculation that first day. They seemed to have assumed that Bilbo was as good as any dwarrow in their eyes, as they did not hide their language and customs from him. When they all sat down to the first of what would be four nights on the road before they reached Hobbiton, a dwarf with a long blue-black beard that was tucked into his belt in a most practical manner sat down next to Thorin and struck up a conversation, introducing himself as Nar, son of Annar.
"Eh, didja hear the news about Azsâlul'abad?" (The Lonely Mountain) he asked with a broad grin.
Thorin tensed at that, "We have been traveling through the wilds for some weeks. What news have you?"
"They did it!" The dwarf crowed. "King Thorin has reclaimed the mountain and the dragon is slain!"
Thorin let the tension drain from him at that. "Ah, yes. We had heard that," he said with a relieved grin.
"Are ye headed that way?" The eager trader continued. "My brother Lofar and the boys are hoping this market pays off enough so we can stock up for the journey and head out ‘afore mid-summer."
"Can you tell me more about this festival you're headed to?" Bilbo piped in.
Nar scratched his beard and shrugged. "‘S not much to tell, from what I know. Just got word of some big sale or market or something’s going on and half the Shire’s supposed to show up, or somesuch."
Bilbo paled at that.
...
Thorin looked worriedly at his companion, realising that something was wrong.
"Bilbo...?" He asked, not wanting to startle him but concerned by his silence.
After another moment of frowning silence Bilbo exploded, "That goblin!" Jumping up from the campfire suddenly, he stalked away on his short, sturdy legs. He continued his complaints, now muttering under his breath. "I knew Lobelia was just waiting for…oh my things, my parent's things... Oh, I will make her pay for every single piece! I cannot believe Fortinbras allowed this!!" Bilbo walked faster, and Thorin followed him. "I wrote a will! It explained exactly what should happen in case of my death! And it is definitely too early to declare me dead!"
Thorin frowned. "What does that have to do with the sale?"
"The sale! Half of the Shire will be there…to buy my things! And I suppose Lobelia will want to snatch up Bag End as soon as she can! That…that she-goblin without the sense Yavanna gave a pea! I cannot believe I have to bear her abusing the Baggins name on top of this kind of behaviour! But she will see!"
Thorin had seen Bilbo worried, scared, and angry. And because he knew Bilbo Baggins, a part of him felt a shred of pity for this Lobelia woman. After all, the last being that angered Bilbo that much ended up dead. Thorin comforted himself with the fact that Bilbo would never actually treat a hobbit as he would an orc…probably.
"She's always been trying to steal my mother's silverware..." Bilbo then muttered something that sounded like, "I should ask Bard to shoot her, as he did with Smaug. He's already slain one dragon, after all."
Nevermind. Thorin sighed. If he stopped Bilbo from killing this relative of his, Bilbo would probably be very angry with him.
It may be best to just let Bilbo handle these things.
...
Bilbo was still muttering invectives as Thorin guided him gently back to their bedrolls, laid out side by side—but a respectable distance apart— near one of the wagons. He avoided making eye contact with the other dwarrow, sure that they'd still be looking askance at his hobbit.
Thorin felt confident that this would all be easily sorted out in a few days when they reached Hobbiton. He had no familiarity with the laws of the Shire, but his many years of experience in mediating property conflicts should give them some degree of advantage, especially if Bilbo had official documentation, like a will, supporting his claim.
Thorin kept watch over Bilbo as he tossed and turned before settling into an uneasy sleep. Only then did the dwarf king seek his own rest.
The road from Tharbad to Sarnford was blessedly flat and well-maintained, so they made excellent time. The little Hobbit village marked the borders of the Shire, being just on the other side of the Brandywine River from the town of Men called East Sarnford.
Their dwarrow hosts remained somewhat reserved around Bilbo and Thorin both, which honestly suited them just fine. They seemed like decent, honest dwarrow and Thorin made a mental note to have Balin keep an eye out for them once they'd returned to the mountain. There was not much he could do to aid them at this point, beyond slipping a few of the gold coins that he'd sewn into his traveling coat into the foreman’s wagon with a note that it was to help them in their journey home.
Bilbo had been in an anxious mood since he'd learned of the possible sale of Bag End, but a noticeable weight was lifted from his shoulders as soon as they stepped off the wide bridge that marked the borders of his homeland. When the caravan foreman said that he intended to push on past Sarnford through lunchtime, Bilbo applied his significant but long-unused charm in convincing him that the lamb and pea pie at the Garden Gate in Sarnford was not to be missed.
Thorin did not miss the fact that Bilbo did not bother to eat more than one serving of said pie, which was actually quite delicious, before he nipped out of the pub and returned triumphantly with two bulging pouches and a small cask of Longbottom Leaf.
"You can't pass through the Southfarthing and not stock up on their finest leaf!" he insisted when Thorin arched an eyebrow at him, his mouth twisted with fond amusement.
"Here, I got one for you too, so hush up with that look," he chided gently, bumping into Thorin’s side companionably as he handed over the fragrant pouch.
Thorin sighed at the sweet smell, suddenly recalling the first weeks of their journey when Bilbo still had his supply of pipeweed from home, which he never failed to share generously with his traveling companions. Not that Thorin ever dared accept, not in those days when he had his head so firmly up his arse. He offered another of his daily thanks to his Maker, that he was here now to make up for those, and many other, mistakes.
...
Their caravan continued to make good time that day, though they were forced to walk behind the wagons on the narrow winding paths of the Shire. Thorin was happy to be walking comfortably beside Bilbo, laughing at the hobbit’s quick wit and sharp mind. There was a lightness in him that made him shine under the spring sunshine. Thorin was unsure if it was only being so close to home that was lightening Bilbo’s spirit, or if also his mithril pouch was working as intended to shield his love from the foul magic that had burdened him.
"What do Hobbits take in trade?" Thorin asked as they walked.
"Hmm ... what for?" Bilbo asked.
"If we were to trade for your precious pipe tobacco, for example, or maybe seeds or dried goods, what would the Shire ask in return?"
"Protection," Bilbo answered quickly and honestly.
"Protection?"
"Yes. We are not fighters, as you know. You know how wolves ravaged our lands when I was all but a faunt. You know how useless I was with a sword, and now imagine a society that doesn’t even want to pick up a weapon. We don’t desire gold, or gems or the jewellery you dwarves seem to adore. We need protection, and if you can provide it, as the Thain’s cousin I can convince Fortinbras to send shipments of Old Toby and whatever else we want back to Erebor in exchange. But you will need to find your own people to get it there," Bilbo advised. Thorin said nothing, just thoughtfully absorbed the information.
Later, as they made what would be their last night’s camp with the caravan, Thorin also savored their remaining time sitting apart from the other dwarves, sharing Bilbo’s pipeweed. He was not going to admit it, but Bilbo was correct. It was the best pipeweed he had ever tasted, and he mentally kicked himself again for having kept himself apart and not sharing it at the start of their quest all that time ago.
As he sat beside Bilbo in front of the flickering firelight, Thorin was pointedly ignoring how the flames only enhanced Bilbo’s beauty because, as he had told Bilbo now was not the time. That didn’t mean he was blind, however. The firelight flashed on the subtle braid tucked behind the hobbit’s curving ear, and Thorin had to swallow the urge to reach out again. He turned his thoughts back to their conversation that afternoon.
"No other hobbits would travel to Erebor for trade, even with you in attendance?" Thorin asked. He knew Bilbo had said that he was an outlier for a Hobbit; that they were lucky Gandalf had picked him because every other hobbit would have either cowered behind their door or laughed in their face before shoving some fresh baked goods into their hands and slamming the door closed. As amazing as Thorin found Bilbo, it struck him as odd that he would be so very atypical.
Bilbo nodded. "You must understand how uncommon my situation was. The reality of it is…well, I was lonely, if you must know. Though I hadn’t realised how alone I truly felt. My parents are long gone. We have discussed how I am too Baggins for the Tooks and too Took for the Baggins and how my closest friend is my gardener. I am a rather solitary person by nature, though I never consciously chose to be alone. Once my grandfather, the Old Took, died, well…I had distant cousins, but no siblings, no spouse. That was just my lot in the Shire."
He turned to the dwarf and placed his smaller hand on his broad forearm, looking up at him earnestly. "I have gained so much by leaving with you, and I do not regret it, even if I have regretted some of the circumstances. You regained your homeland, a place of peace for your people. I gained a family, friends, and a new home not haunted by my parent’s memories. And hopefully, well ..." Bilbo trailed off with a gentle squeeze to Thorin’s arm before leaning back on the log behind him.
"Then I am glad that you became our hobbit, Bilbo Baggins," Thorin admitted in a gruff voice.
They sat side by side until the fire burned low.
...
Thorin smiled as he sat, imagining Bilbo living in Erebor with him, ruling by his side. As his thoughts warmed him, after some time he heard a soft, shaky exhale of distress from his companion.
Gently, he reached over and placed his hand on Bilbo’s, voice soft with concern. "Bilbo?"
"I’m sorry," Bilbo murmured, his breath unsteady. "My apologies. It seems my emotions got the better of me..." He was clearly trying to bottle them back now that Thorin has caught him in a vulnerable moment.
"Bilbo... tell me, please. I care for you." Thorin tugged on his hand, pulling him close to press his forehead gently against the hobbit’s. Bilbo exhaled shakily.
"It’s just..." Bilbo began, his voice low and raw. "The reason hobbits never leave the Shire, the reason we stay so close, is because the Shire is home for us," he pulled back, wiping his face with a handkerchief and clearing his throat. "But I haven’t thought of Bag End as my home for such a long time—long before the journey, not since my parents passed, really. But still... Sometimes I don’t know if I can let it go. Not anymore. I thought I could protect that smial. Bag End was the only thing I had left of them. I thought I could leave it in safe hands. And now I hear that it’s being sold off like it’s nothing. My father’s books. My mother’s silver. Everything. I just—!" His voice cracked and Thorin waited patiently, giving space for his words.
"It’s no longer my home, but it’s still important to me. And if my leaving caused it to be in jeopardy... should I have stayed? Maybe I should stay now. I know it sounds foolish—especially compared to all of you, who literally lost your home to a dragon—but I—"
Thorin hushed him gently by laying his broad hand over Bilbo’s where they were his twisting handkerchief in knots.
"Bilbo," he said softly, "I know how hard it is to lose both a home and those you love. Your loss may not seem as dramatic, but grief isn’t a competition. What you are feeling is real. And it matters. We will get there before the auction and protect the smial your parents left you."
He hesitated, breath caught in his throat. "And if you do decide to stay, to guard it for the rest of your life... I will miss you, Bilbo." He reached out to tentatively brush his hand over Bilbo’s cheek, wiping away the last trace of tears.
Because you are my home now, Thorin wanted to say—but the words wouldn’t come. Not yet.
Instead, he said, "But if you choose to come back to Erebor, even after all this... I will do everything in my power to ensure that you are happy there."
...
It took all of Thorin’s will not to pour out the well of desperate longing that rose within him. Bilbo deserved better. He deserved everything. The old rites of atonement and forgiveness existed so that they could move forward on equal footing, leaving their many conflicts and transgressions behind confidently, and Thorin resolved again to see them completed properly.
Just a few more days, he told himself, knowing that the issue of Bilbo’s childhood home had to be settled before he could approach with his final ’ultân, and then finally, finally present his suit with all the proper Hobbitish tradition that he could muster.
Chapter Text
Their final morning on the road dawned bright and crisp. The caravan reached Bywater just before lunchtime, and they parted from their hosts on good terms, with offers to travel together in the future, should their paths cross again.
As soon as the pleasantries were done, Bilbo made a bee-line for the Green Dragon, bursting in through the door and pausing dramatically. Chatter in the busy tap room was instantly silenced as hobbits all around the room gaped at him as if they were seeing a ghost.
"Mister Bilbo!" a voice cried from behind the counter. Out bustled a very round hobbit, who would have been as wide as Bombur, if he'd been anywhere near as tall.
"Hullo Toby," Bilbo said warmly, leading Thorin over to where the stout innkeeper was wringing a dishtowel fiercely in his thick fingers.
"Oh Mister Bilbo, it’s mighty good to see you! We’d near given you up for dead, we had!"
"Well, as you can see, I’m most certainly not dead," Bilbo replied, ending in a much louder tone that was clearly meant for the room at large. At those words, conversation in the taproom picked up again, tables buzzing with fiercely whispered gossip.
"Can we get a spot of luncheon, Toby? And a couple of half-pints. My travel companion and I haven't stopped since first breakfast and I could eat a horse!" Bilbo said, eyes comically wide.
"Oh of course Mister Bilbo, of co—eep!" Toby cut off with a little yelp when he turned to Thorin and looked up, and up at the tall dwarf, who tilted his head in polite greeting.
"Toby, this is Thorin Oakenshield, my dear friend and travel companion. He was kind enough to see me all the way here from his home in the East once my business there was complete. Thorin, this is Toby Toppletoast, proprietor of the Green Dragon." Bilbo conducted his introductions in a still slightly louder than normal tone while the whispers continued to swirl around them.
Toby bobbed again and bustled himself back behind the counter to call the order back to the kitchen. Bilbo turned away and scanned the room, his eyes lighting when he spotted a gray-haired figure dressed in the fine green velvet coat of a gentlehobbit sitting in the back corner, looking at him expectantly.
"Well, Bilbo Baggins, in the flesh! This is quite a pickle, my boy, quite a pickle indeed!" the hobbit declared when they'd approached his table. "Come! We have much to discuss!"
"I don't doubt it, Bert." Bilbo said dryly, deftly handling introductions again, naming the older gentleman as Filibert Noakes, his solicitor. Again he named Thorin as an Important Dwarf from the East, and his Travel Companion, with that curious emphasis that Hobbits seemed to put on certain words and phrases that had some hidden meaning. The older gentleman rose to greet them, then ushered them into a private room off the main taproom so they could speak freely.
...
Thorin just sat back as the hobbits spoke, attentive but mostly watching Bilbo's solicitor with sharp eyes. In truth, he was trying to find what things Bilbo and this gentlehobbit had in common.
Their manner of speaking was only slightly different, with Bilbo’s speech being more direct and slightly sarcastic, although Thorin couldn't remember if Bilbo had always spoken that way, or if that had changed during their travels together. Otherwise they both seemed to have a more eloquent and precise manner to their speech that the innkeeper, for example, didn't have.
Their style of dress set them apart from other Hobbits, but in this too Bilbo had just a little more flair, with the solicitor’s dark, simple coat in contrast to the bright colors Bilbo wore. Bilbo had allowed his hair to grow longer than any other male Hobbit that Thorin had seen, and it thrilled him again to see his braid and bead peeking out of his tangled locks. He wondered if the other Hobbits had noticed, or what they thought of his more exotic look now. They didn't give any indication, but it seemed that was mostly their way.
Toby arrived with their meals and drinks, smiling kindly at him, a huge difference between his behaviour when he first saw Thorin. Although that initial reaction had proved to him that protection was likely the only thing Dwarrow could offer Hobbits that wouldn't be rejected.
"It’ll take some doing to reverse things now, but we’ll manage." Bert said to Bilbo, then turned to Thorin. "Mister Bilbo here has quite a way with contracts, don’t you know?"
Thorin nodded, smiling fondly at the memory of Bilbo ruining the sham of a contract Thranduil had tried to offer them. "I wasn't aware that contracts were often used in the Shire," Thorin murmured, "Mister Baggins seemed surprised when we gave him a contract for our journey."
"Well, no one expected a Baggins to go off on an adventure!" Bert coughed a little awkwardly behind his hand. "And Mister Bilbo had always been the perfect Baggins, with an impeccable reputation as the Head of such a fine family!"
"Bilbo seemed to think he was alone here." Thorin muttered, forgetting for a moment the proper respect Bilbo's title clearly deserved.
Toby, who had lingered near the table clearly hoping to listen in on the proceedings, blurted out, "Oh but there’s still plenty what support the good Baggins name! Not those uppity Sackville-Bagginses. We’ll all be goin’ to the sale, o’ course, as most would like to keep a memory of dear Mister Bilbo." He smiled fondly at Bilbo, who looked a little uncomfortable.
...
"But it is a blessing that you're back, Bilbo," Bert rushed to add. "I’ve had a bramble of a time trying to find new homes for all of your tenants, you see."
"My tenants? What about them?" Bilbo suddenly straightened up.
"Well, you are by now aware that Lobelia has been trying to take possession of Bag End, and with Bag End, ownership of Bagshot Row and the lands on The Hill—and she's already been stirring things up," the solicitor said sourly, lowering his voice. "It’s nothing but blatant extortion, Mister Bilbo. I've been trying to help them move, but it seems not many are as kind as you or your father ever were." Bert shook his head ruefully. He didn’t even seem disturbed by Bilbo’s sudden anger, knowing it wasn’t directed at him.
"That parasite! She has enough wealth already! Those families are good people—all of them! How dare she—I just—" Bilbo began muttering in colorful Sindarin, an old habit he'd developed since no one in the Shire, except his parents, spoke the language fluently. It allowed him to curse freely in public. Of course, Thorin’s eyes widened—he had never heard Bilbo use such language. It was clear he was deeply protective of his tenants.
"Bert! Please, tell me where they are! I left them defenseless against that harpy. It’s only right that I help them now."
"I believe a number of them have plans to disturb the auction tomorrow, actually. None of them wanted to believe that you were dead. They're still in their homes on Bagshot Row for now, and they'll be delighted to hear of your return to be their kind landlord once more," Bert replied with a kindly smile.
Bilbo suddenly fell silent. The burden of his plans to return to Erebor with Thorin seemed heavier by the moment. Sensing the shift, Thorin reached for his hand and gave it a gentle squeeze to let him know he was there to support him.
The gesture was not lost on the other hobbits, and Toby actually jumped a bit from where he had been making a show of wiping the same table for the last few minutes. Bilbo just looked at him with a raised eyebrow and the round little innkeeper gave a squeak and scurried away.
...
Bilbo waited until Toby had left the room before he allowed his anger to melt away and a small amount of despair to fill him as he thought of the ties that bound him in the Shire, that could very well keep him away from Thorin and all of his dwarves for the rest of his life. "What do I do?" he asked himself, quiet enough for only Thorin to hear.
"I am sure that between us," Thorin nodded to Bert, "we can devise an ironclad contract that will withstand all assaults. You would just need to appoint an executor that you would leave in charge of your estate. Can you think of anyone?" Thorin replied quietly, not wanting to exclude Bilbo’s lawyer. Thorin felt he was being very gracious in not elaborating on the ways that a Dwarrow contract was surely superior to something Hobbits could come up with, when he truly looked like a decent enough chap.
Relief washed over Bilbo’ face, and hope once again filled his eyes. To cause that look in Bilbo’s eyes, and for it to once again be directed at himself, Thorin felt as if he could take on Azog, Bolg, Smaug, and the entire contents of the Misty Mountains and still have time to write the documents Bilbo needed.
Bilbo covered Thorin's hand with his own and gave it another gentle squeeze. He only let go again when Toby appeared back at their table with another round of drinks. "Here you are, Mister Bilbo. Finest ale we have for you and your, erm, uh, dwarf," he said as he dropped it off before scurrying back out of the room and closing the door quietly.
Bert stood from the table, patting his ample belly as he stretched. "Well, I had better get on with calling off the auction tomorrow, then. Bilbo, you surely do know how to cause a stir! The only thing I can imagine would have made a bigger fuss would be for you to show up right in the middle of all the bidding!" He chortled at the image and dipped his head in farewell. "I will call at Bag End, likely sometime after tea, to debrief you and discuss further strategy. Thorin, a pleasure." He tipped his hat to the dwarf with a wink as he left.
"Thank you, Bert. It's a comfort to know that you are representing my interests," Bilbo said graciously, turning back to the table and dismissing him as regally as any king. Thorin marvelled at how naturally a noble bearing seemed to rest on his hobbit.
"Eat, Thorin." Bilbo admonished when Thorin just sat staring. "Good ideas don't come on an empty stomach. The disaster when we first took Erebor should have told you that," he said with a happy smile as he tucked into the real Shire fare he'd been much too long without. It was a far cry from those days of near starvation. He made a mental note to grab a few of his cookbooks before they returned to Erebor, to share with Bombur. It wasn’t like a Dwarf would know the precise importance to a Hobbit of sharing family recipes, and the idea of having Shire fare made for him by Bombur’s expert hand was too tempting a thought for him to change his mind.
Bilbo was so busy considering how well potatoes might grow in some of the open caverns in Erebor that he didn’t notice the stricken look that had passed on Thorin’s face.
Thorin, for his part, held his tongue, letting the hurt and guilt become again a part of his atonement. With it, he renewed the vow to himself that once they'd sorted this mess with Bilbo's home, he would finish the ’ultânul ceremony, where he would prostrate himself at Bilbo’s beautifully overlarge feet and resolve all that stood between them. And then…hopefully then he would be worthy of asking Bilbo for his hand in marriage.
With settled thoughts Thorin allowed himself to tuck into the heaping plate of simple but rich and filling food. He had finally stopped being surprised at Hobbit portions. After all, it wouldn’t be a meal fit for a Hobbit if it didn’t leave a Dwarf all but bursting at the seams.
He allowed the relaxed atmosphere of the pub and the friendly company to settle over him. Bilbo’s presence filled his heart as full as his stomach.
...
As he ate, Bilbo's thoughts revolved around family, and tradition, and the ties that bound it all together. With all they'd been through, and the way Thorin had consistently offered his support by escorting Bilbo and coming to his aid time and again, well, could be the kind of thing that was comparable to sharing family recipes here in the Shire.
As soon as they'd entered the inn’s taproom together and saw all of those gaping hobbits, Bilbo had realised that in running off as he had and then returning with a single companion, everyone here would assume he had run away to get married in the old-fashioned way of the Shire, the way some couples had done long before the Fell Winter, and before they were so harshly reminded of the dangers outside the Shire.
Looking at Thorin, Bilbo sighed. It was too bad he hadn't run off to get married to that particular dwarf, pigheaded and brooding as he was. He wouldn't have complained in the least.
But with Thorin’s position, and after everything that had come between them, Bilbo considered himself lucky just to be his friend again. But then, there was that pesky “Not yet” that Thorin had let slip…
Bilbo sighed.
"Everything alright, my burglar?" Thorin asked.
Bilbo bit his lower lip. "I'm just thinking about who could be a good candidate to act in my place." He deflected, "Being a Baggins is important, in the Shire."
"I’ve noticed." Thorin chuckled. "I don't know if you knew, Master Baggins, but you put a lot of emphasis on your last name."
"Well, it is important! A lot of hobbits rely on the Baggins estate, and there's a certain degree of tradition that comes with that responsibility." Bilbo nodded. "It's downright shocking that Lobelia would dare think she could parcel off my and my parents' things and threaten my tenants. She should definitely know better."
Thorin looked at him seriously. "I would fight her, if it is what you needed me to do."
"Oh, you would fight anyone for fun," Bilbo raised an eyebrow, "but fighting any hobbit is not even a challenge, and Lobelia will likely crumple like wet paper the moment she sees me, if she knows what's good for her."
...
"Speaking of traditions …" Bilbo said with uncharacteristic hesitance. He took a deep breath and plunged on, "Um, Thorin, there is something you should know."
Thorin arched a brow, curiosity piqued. What could possibly make Bilbo—usually so composed—blush such a deep and fetching shade of red?
"Um... there might be, uh…it's a possibility that…well, that the other hobbits here may…think you’re my husband…" Bilbo mumbled, eyes flicking up to meet Thorin’s before darting away.
Thorin’s brain stalled. He stared. Did he hear that correctly?
Bilbo shifted awkwardly and continued, "You see, there’s an old tradition among Hobbits—especially the Brandybucks and Tooks—where if two hobbits go off on an ramble together, vanish to who knows where, and return side by side…well, it’s assumed that they’re then married. It’s considered something of an elopement…very romantic. And, well… I am a Took on my mother’s side, so it’s quite likely the others will just assume you and I… tied the knot, so to speak."
He paused, chewing his lip. "Thorin? Are you alright?"
Thorin blinked, then slowly smiled—a rare, unguarded smile that lit up his face. He felt like he was caught in a dream. A warm, golden dream he never wanted to wake from. If he looked like a lovesick fool, so be it. His heart beat loudly in his chest, drowning out reason. A happy chuckle bubbled up from his chest.
Married, it echoed. To Bilbo.
He rather liked the sound of that.
...
Thorin continued to chuckle happily as he savored the moment. A wisp of doubt drifted into his reverie when he looked again at Bilbo and saw how unhappily distressed he appeared. Wait, was it not a good thing in Bilbo’s mind that other hobbits think they are married? The wisp was a full-blown thundercloud in moments. Bilbo looked miserable.
"Would this…" Thorin cleared his throat against the squeezing despair, "would this pose a problem for recovering your estate?"
"Oh! No, no not at all, actually." Bilbo’s eyes were wide, but his mouth still down-turned, "if anything, it adds quite a bit of legitimacy to my disappearance. Much more acceptable than haring off on an adventure to reclaim a mountain from a dragon." He chuckled weakly.
"But, Thorin," the hobbit leaned forward and placed his hand on Thorin's forearm again, where it burned like a brand, "we don't need to pretend for the sake of my legal troubles, if it's uncomfortable for you, or you find it silly."
"It is no burden." He rumbled lowly. "It would be my greatest honor, even under false pretenses, to be called your…husband." He could barely whisper the word, so great was the longing that rose up within him. Thorin found himself completely unable to pull on the stoic mask he usually wore—he was sure his desperate hope was evident for Bilbo to read clearly.
Bilbo’s eyes were still blown wide, but his mouth slack with shock now as he drifted closer. Thorin sat, feeling as trapped as a fly in honey, unable to tear his gaze from Bilbo’s face, from his parted, pink lips that glistened when his tongue darted out to wet them.
"It would? You would?" Bilbo asked weakly. "You…want that?"
Thorin tore his gaze away and rose so quickly from the table that he rattled the plates and mugs. "It is not time yet." He said harshly, as much to himself as anything. "I would not dishonor you so."
"Me? How would being married to you dishonor me?" Bilbo demanded.
"We are mabinjalanattân; it cannot be," Thorin growled, clenching his fists fiercely as he paced.
"Thorin!" Bilbo said sharply, causing the distressed dwarf to jump and whip back to him so quickly that his long hair flew across his chest. "I will thank you to use one of the several languages that I do speak when discussing matters that involve me!" When he had Thorin’s full attention he continued with a wave of his hand, "Now, what precisely does it mean to be malbinjallatan?"
Thorin would have smiled at Bilbo's attempted Khuzdul, if he weren't kicking himself so fiercely for breaching the strictures of the altân rites. "It is not spoken of," he began gruffly, "but, perhaps it would be appropriate to explain."
"Considering I am not a dwarf, yes, most appropriate."
Thorin froze, looking at Bilbo, really looking at him. His One was not a Dwarf. This really shouldn't have been a new idea but the fact kept blindsiding him at the most random, and important, moments. Would he have any idea what was required of them?
Bilbo started to look uncertain. "That is, if you can, if it is allowed. I know I'm not supposed to–"
"You have every right to our culture and language." Thorin said softly, taking Bilbo’s small hands in his. "But I must ask yet again that you have patience with me, with us. It is not something we are accustomed to, sharing ourselves with those who are not dwarrow."
"I'll do my best to be patient." Bilbo promised, giving Thorin's fingers a squeeze. "I've never been very good at it, but I'm quite motivated." He smiled crookedly.
Thorin took a deep, bracing breath, and began, "When one Hobbit has wronged another, what do you do to make amends?"
"Well, if something of value was damaged they may offer to replace it, as they are able. If it's a personal matter, they may expect to have a heartfelt conversation to clear the air. Either way, they typically just apologize, and that's that."
"You just…apologize?" Thorin asked, bemused.
"Well, that is, only if you want to remain in that person’s good graces, I suppose. Plenty of Hobbits have given offense and continued on as if nothing had happened!" he grumbled a little sourly, "But if you truly want to set things right, you own up to it and apologize, often with a gift of appropriate flowers or food to show one’s intent and sincerity."
"Ah, and, is there a form or standard for how one presents this gift?"
"What? No, nothing like that!" Bilbo reared back a little, but did not relinquish his hold on Thorin’s hands, "You don't want to draw more attention to the incident than is necessary, really. Sometimes you don't even say it outright. Simply offering the right combination of flowers is enough to let them know you’d like to regain their good will."
Thorin knew there was a lot more to "offering the right combination of flowers" than he understood, but he didn't want to get sidetracked. "Dwarrow handle these things in a very different manner," he began.
"I gathered as much," Bilbo said wryly, tugging Thorin down so they could sit at the table again, their chairs pulled close together since he still wouldn't let go of Thorin's hands, a matter which Thorin found quite comforting.
"When one dwarrow has wronged another, he must offer altân. It may be as small as repairing or replacing a damaged item, as you said, but in cases of less material damage, a gift of gold or of service may be offered." Bilbo’s brow furrowed as he absorbed this information, but he did not interrupt.
"There are certain expectations for the delivery of such a gift," Thorin continued. "Unless very personal in nature, it must be presented before at least one other dwarrow. It must be fitting to the wrong that has been committed. One does not discuss the offense or nature of the gift explicitly, especially while the service is being carried out. You may not enter into contracts or other agreements with the dwarrow you have wronged until your altân has been accepted. It's all a very instinctive thing for us. When the appropriate amends have been performed or delivered, the…one who has wronged, I suppose you could say, requests formal forgiveness. If sufficient, the wronged party accepts and the matter is resolved. Both parties are released and there’s no need to speak of the matter again after that."
Bilbo looked a little dazed, "That all sounds…dreadfully complicated."
Thorin chuckled, "It is very straightforward to a dwarf, I suppose. We know when altân is required, and to what degree." He grew somber again, "And when one’s offenses have reached the highest level, ‘ultânul: the most supreme atonement, is required." He withdrew one hand to pinch at the bridge of his nose, sighing when Bilbo’s thumb traced over the back of his hand comfortingly.
"I have not yet completed my ’ultânul to you, Bilbo," he said lowly, gaze fixed on their clasped hands.
"Why, whatever for, dear?" Bilbo asked.
"Until you have regained your ancestral home, my service in amends for the wrongs I have committed against you will not be complete." Thorin said, meeting Bilbo’s soft gaze resolutely.
"Well, that's easily done then!" The hobbit said cheerily. "Let’s go home now, Thorin, and be done with this." His fingers squeezed Thorin's again, and the dwarf felt as if his small hands had reached in and squeezed his very heart, filling it with comfort and love.
...
Notes:
mabinjalanattân - “Those who continue to be unfinished.” (constructed with the graceful assistance of The Dwarrow Scholar in this Tumblr post.
Chapter Text
Bilbo all but rushed Thorin out the door and down the street in the direction of Bag End. The walk would have gone much quicker if Bilbo hadn’t had to stop and greet many of those who saw him bustling away from the pub. They stopped at several market stalls along the main road to purchase a few fresh provisions to bring back to the smial, and each vendor seemed to gawk and stutter more than the last.
Of course, no one said anything directly about the implications of Bilbo showing up nearly a year later with a dwarf on his arm—one whom he had left the Shire with so suddenly—and Bilbo certainly wasn’t going to confirm or deny anything to any of them, especially with Thorin’s confession not even ten minutes ago.
Instead, he politely diverted their subtle inquiries and declined their invitations, explaining that he had such a lot to do considering he had been away for so long, and yes, it is lovely to see you.
Thorin couldn’t help but marvel at how easily Bilbo lied to those who knew him. He assumed it was a Hobbitish habit to dissemble so freely about being happy to see someone. After all, dwarrow would quickly tell someone to Îmi! (Scram!), if they did not wish to converse with them. It seemed that, as with so many things, that was very different in the Shire.
It wasn’t until they were only a few doors down the Hill from Bag End that Thorin saw an actual, genuine smile for a fellow hobbit cross Bilbo’s face.
"Holman," Bilbo said delightedly as he finally released Thorin’s arm and marched over to his gardener and old family friend.
"Oh, Master Bilbo! It’s so good to see you well," Holman Greenhand replied, a smile covering his weathered face as he grasped Bilbo’s hand in both of his and squeezed it gently, reassuring himself that Bilbo was here and looking mighty fine, if not a little thin. "Hmm ..." Holman said, turning his assessing gaze on the regal-looking dwarf who had been on Bilbo’s arm. His opinion seemed to diminish as he took in the weary state of Bungo’s boy.
Bilbo, long used to Holman’s protective attitude towards him since his father had died, raised an eyebrow before shaking his head discreetly at the other hobbit. "It’s a long way to Erebor and back again, Holman. Please meet Thorin. He’s the King of the Dwarves and one of the finest hunters I’ve ever met; one who would never allow me to go hungry," Bilbo said, stretching the truth a little, not that Holman needed to know, of course.
For all his protectiveness and loyalty, Holman was a Greenhand, and they were worse gossips than a Sackville-Baggins (though certainly not malicious in any way). Whatever Holman learned about Thorin would be all over the Shire by tea time tomorrow. Bilbo would be damned before he let any hobbit say a bad word against Thorin; he had already said enough bad things about himself, the daft dwarf.
"Why would I allow you to be hungry?" Thorin asked, even more confused when Bilbo beamed up at him, and at this Holman’s glare turned a little softer towards him.
"Why indeed?" Bilbo said happily.
"You'll be wanting your key then?" Holman dug into the pocket of his rough jacket and handed the brass key to Bilbo. "Poppy ain't been ta cleaning yet this week, but we've kept it up right proper for you."
"I never doubted that you would, my friend," Bilbo said earnestly. "It was always a comfort to me, on the road, to know that my home was in your care. Thank you." He bowed his head gratefully, which caused his gardener to bluster and blush.
"Oh, now! Get on with you, Master Bilbo. You let me know if there's anything you need to get settled back in."
Bilbo assured him that he would, before wishing Holman goodbye and whisking Thorin the rest of the short way to his own door.
"Oh ..." Bilbo said as he stood before the door to his smial. The same round green door, the same door knob he had helped his father fit many years ago, the same rune burnt into the door that Gandalf had used to signal the Company all those many months ago.
Unlocking the door, Bilbo took a deep breath before grabbing Thorin’s hand and pulling him forward. "Welcome back to my home, Thorin," Bilbo said giddily as they crossed the threshold of Bag End.
...
Thorin smiled as he watched Bilbo gaze around Bag End with a look of quiet relief. He seemed at peace, a tension that he'd carried for nearly a year lifted from his frame. He looked right, here in this cosy hobbit hole—far more fitting than he'd ever looked in the grand spaces of Erebor. Thorin felt a pang at the thought of how very much he would be asking Bilbo to give up.
"You know," Bilbo said suddenly, "after we’re old and gray, do you think it’d be alright if we retired here?"
Thorin blinked, startled by the question, but instantly heartened that Bilbo was so eager for their future. He wondered how long that might be. He didn't know how long Hobbits typically lived, but Thorin likely had another fifty or so years, a hundred if he was as long-lived as many of the Line of Durin had been. But none of that mattered. Thorin was certain he would be with Bilbo until the very end, however long that was.
"It’d make a wonderful retirement home," Bilbo added, smiling.
Thorin chuckled, but Bilbo’s smile faded as he spotted something outside the window. A small group of hobbits could be seen proceeding far down the road, coming towards the Hill and Bag End. A distinctively oversized hat with a huge green feather in it bobbed over the flouncy dress of the one marching firmly in the lead.
"Lobelia," Bilbo hissed with such venom that Thorin prayed he’d never hear Bilbo say his name like that. Suddenly, Bilbo’s frown morphed into a mischievous grin.
"I have an idea," he said.
Before Thorin could question him, Bilbo grabbed his arm and pulled him out the back door of the smial. Holman had come up to tend the flower beds behind the smial, and he blinked in confusion when Bilbo suddenly threw himself onto the dirt and began rolling around.
"Bilbo, what are you doing?" Thorin asked, baffled.
"Lobelia thinks I’m dead," Bilbo replied with a grin only a Took could manage. "So I’m going to give her a grand hello. Holman, can you ask the Gamgees for some ketchup?"
Holman laughed and nodded. "I’ll be quick," he said before hurrying off toward his cousin’s smial.
"I don’t understand," Thorin muttered.
"Thorin, once Lobelia and the others are inside, I want you to go through to the front door and very solemnly announce that I am dead," Bilbo said, sounding positively delighted.
Thorin blinked again, then shook his head with a low chuckle and a smile. "Very well. I shall endeavor to be as mournful as possible when delivering the tragic news."
Holman returned, breathless but triumphant, carrying a bottle of ketchup, with a gangly young Hamfast at his heels.
"The Gaffer* here wanted to watch," Holman explained with a grin for the blushing boy.
"Aw, well I wanted to see Master Bilbo again, too!" Hamfast said, beaming. "But it don't hurt to see that sorry excuse for a hobbit get what she deserves."
Bilbo laughed, letting the teen help dab strategic splotches of ketchup across his clothes and face. A sharp rap at the door echoed from within Bag End. Everyone froze.
Thorin gave them a meaningful look before quietly slipping around to the front door.
(* - While "gaffer" often means an old man, it's also another word for a foreman or boss. Hamfast is just 16 at this point and hasn't taken over the business from Holman, his second cousin once removed, but his cousin likes to tease the boy about being in charge already. It's a nickname that will stick with Hamfast the rest of his life.)
...
Lobelia Sackville-Baggins burst into the smial as soon as the door was opened. Panting and running up behind her were a harried-looking Bert, and another hobbit huffing and puffing up the Hill.
"Who are you?! You're trespassing!" she squawked.
The stout hobbit had caught up behind Bert and was wringing his hat in his hands, careful not to damage the long red feather in the band. Thorin realised this fellow must be a Bounder, based on Bilbo's explanations of law enforcement in the Shire. He seemed quite uncertain about attempting to assert any kind of authority over Thorin, and rightly so as he only had a little billy club at his waist and Thorin was still fully armed and armored from the road.
"Now, Lobelia, if you'll allow me—" Bert began, only to have her cut him off.
"I'll not allow you to let this ruffian stay a moment longer in my smial!" she snapped. "Out, dwarf!" She pointed out the door as if Thorin could be shooed out like an errant puppy.
Thorin simply turned to Bert, doing his best to adopt a grave expression and appropriately solemn tone. "I'm afraid there's been…an accident."
"Whatever could you mean?" Bert asked breathlessly. Thorin felt a twinge of regret for any distress they might cause the kind old hobbit.
"Bilbo he…well, you should see for yourself," he intoned, sweeping his hand towards the garden door. They could see from the foyer that it stood wide open.
Lobelia bustled straight to the back door, muttering about damages and savages. When she reached the threshold she let out a blood-curdling scream. "Murder! He's been murdered!" She wailed.
...
"We need justice!" Lobelia said. "Once I'll have Bag End, I will..."
"You have Bag End?" Bilbo asked, raising up to sit on the ground. "I'm sorry, Lobelia, but not even dead would I stand for that."
Thorin snorted, amused by his hobbit.
Lobelia screamed again, "You were dead!" She pointed a shaking finger at the fake blood on Bilbo. "We all saw it!"
"Well, death is just a social construct, if you think about it." Bilbo shrugged. "Now, you are right that we need some justice here. Wouldn't you agree, Fortinbras?"
Bilbo stood up, smiling at the hobbit who was just entering at the garden gate with another young gentlehobbit in tow.
"Hello, my dears!" Bilbo beamed. "Drogo lad it is good to see you. Most sorry that I missed your coming of age party. I did have to leave so suddenly, but there were some very specific instructions right on my desk here, so everything should have been cleared for the following year." Bilbo wiped the ketchup from his face with a handkerchief, pointedly not looking at the hobbits gaping at him all around.
"Ah, I had wondered about that, cousin," Fortinbras answered, frowning and looking at Lobelia. "Holman here tells me he ran into you coming out of Bag End the day Bilbo left. You wouldn't have happened to misplace any documents now, would you Mrs. Sackville-Baggins?"
"He was dead!" Lobelia muttered, still visibly shaken from their prank.
"I suppose it is my fault, thinking that everyone would respect others' property." Bilbo sighed dramatically. "Well, now I'm here and I am able to repeat every single word that I wrote on those papers!"
"There is no need." Bert assured him. "We’ll draft up some new documents and have them witnessed, so there's no further confusion."
"But, my dear cousin, you didn't tell anyone you were going off."
"Ah, Fortinbras," Bilbo turned, and Thorin's eyes were caught on that charming smile, "you know how wizards are. Grandpa’s old friend Gandalf called one morning at Bag End, and before I knew it I had dwarves in my smial and a whole new life ahead of me! I followed them to help them regain their ancestral home, and now I'm back to settle my estate."
"You followed dwarves?" Fortinbras asked, looking at Thorin with wide eyes. "You ran away with them? With him?"
Ah, Bilbo was right, Thorin realised, they did seem to be making assumptions about them.
"Yes, well, I think it's past time we all talk about it over some tea!" Bilbo nodded. "You'll have to excuse the state of my smial. We haven't had much chance to get settled in yet, but I'm sure we can fix up some tea."
Bilbo smiled. "There are a few matters of trade I would like to discuss, my dear cousin."
Bert picked up on Bilbo's cue, "Ah, well, we should leave them to their family business and be getting on with it, then?" He said, pointedly guiding a sour-faced Lobelia to the gate, followed by the still stunned-looking Bounder. "See you later Mister Baggins, Thain. And so good to see you again as well, Your Majesty." He nodded to Thorin with a wink.
After dropping that bomb, the solicitor sailed out of the garden with a knowing smile, ushering the other hobbits away and leaving Fortinbras and Drogo gaping at the two travelers.
…
"Well, that was nice, wasn’t it?" Bilbo asked as he bustled around, cleaning up after the impromptu afternoon tea he had just hosted. "And we will have to thank the Gamgees for the cake. It was so thoughtful of Hamfast to run and fetch it for us," Bilbo refilled Thorin’s cup of tea one more time and put the last slice of cake on his plate before heading to the sink to wash the dishes.
Thorin was once again in awe of how much Hobbits could eat in a single setting. This was his third slice of cake in two hours, and he was stuffed to the gills, what with the size of the servings. He was also in awe of how well Bilbo had handled the gossip, fending off personal inquiries and sorting out what was going to happen to his smial, all with one tea-time conversation with his relatives. He was amazing.
Fortinbras had been quite interested in the trade agreement Bilbo had all but dangled in front of his cousin’s face, especially when Bilbo had explained that Thorin was now king of a very wealthy mountain that was in urgent need of supplies. As they had passed back into the smial Bilbo had whispered to Thorin, "Stay quiet, look regal, and don’t put your foot in your mouth," which had made sense, considering how Fortinbras and Drogo had both been trying to get all sorts of information from him with their subtle questions.
Speaking of Drogo, he looked like a good lad. According to Bilbo, he had just reached his majority at 33, and as such, it would do the boy good to get out of his parent’s smial sooner rather than later, especially as Bilbo was more than aware of how stuffy most of their Baggins relatives were. He still had hopes for the boy.
Bilbo had assured Drogo that they had a few weeks before they'd be heading back East; plenty of time to get him up to scratch to take over the estate. Bilbo had been adamant that he would be returning to Erebor, seeming to have come to a resolution on that sometime amidst the drama of the afternoon. No amount of his cousins’ fears or arguments would dissuade him.
Drogo’s "Well, I suppose if your husband has to return, you have to as well," had put a stop to the arguments, causing Bilbo’s ears to go bright red and Thorin all but held his breath, wondering if Bilbo would finally inform those closest to him about their marriage, considering it was, sadly, a huge lie. But he'd just gone on to refill everyone's cups and turned the conversation to what goods could be shipped to Erebor this summer.
That brought Thorin’s thoughts full circle once more. Bilbo’s home was returned to him, the auction having been successfully called off. He had made an appointment to meet with Bert on the morrow to make sure his new will was filed correctly so that nobody (Lobelia) could ever try snatching it again. Considering he was making Drogo his successor, that would be that.
This led to Thorin wondering how to go about the last step of the ritual and finally clear the way to courting Bilbo properly. And Thorin knew he needed to do this properly. He had done many things wrong in his relationship with Bilbo, but this would not be one of them.
So, as Bilbo pottered around the kitchen, Thorin allowed his mind to slip into the future, maybe a year or two out, when Bilbo could become his husband in truth. He dreamed of Bilbo becoming his Consort and standing beside him until they were called back to their creators at the end of their days. Listening to how Bilbo prattled on as he did his chores, Thorin couldn’t imagine a happier future for himself than the one he was envisioning now.
…
Bilbo was considering what to pull from their few options to make into a proper supper when Thorin picked up the cleaned plate that Hamfast had brought the cake on.
"I'll just return this to the Gamgees. Their smial is just down the hill, correct?"
"Oh, that's very kind. Yes, their smial is the second on the row just down the lane, Number Three, with the yellow door. You might not find Hamfast or Hobson around, but Lily’s likely there with little Halfred." Bilbo gestured in the general direction down the hill, and didn't give much thought to it as Thorin left.
When he returned nearly an hour later, Bilbo was up to his elbows in flour, working a fiddly pie crust that wouldn't hold together, and again didn't give much thought to the fact that Thorin went directly down the hall after entering the smial.
Bilbo could hear the taps running and idly thought it was good the bathroom was still in working order, considering it's state the last time it was used, and good also that Thorin was getting the dirt of the road off before supper.
The sausage and mushroom pot pies turned out perfectly, with a flaky, if a little wonky, crust and a tangy mustard gravy that Bilbo was quite proud of having pulled together with what they grabbed at the market and what little was left in his pantry.
After supper Thorin mysteriously disappeared again, returning with a vase filled with a massive spray of flowers. The bouquet was as lovely as it was meaningful: white alyssum and forget-me-nots peeked out among a huge mass of lush blue hydrangeas, pale pink roses broke up the large swaths of blue with their tender petals, sage and ivy were artfully interspersed, and Bilbo's breath caught when he saw the pale white bleeding hearts hanging delicately down from the edges.
In the language of flowers it spoke, clear as day. It said: "I am truly sorry. You are precious to me. Please don't reject my love, but accept my offer of a wedded life filled with love, respect, and joy."
He looked up and was shocked again to see that Thorin stood before him, his gleaming hair unbound and hands unadorned with his usual rings. The expression in his sky-blue eyes was so achingly tender. The noble dwarf king then dropped to his knees before Bilbo and bowed his head, still holding out the beautiful mass of flowers.
"Ai-latunsuwê," he spoke the words slowly, with much gravity. "I request your forgiveness." He translated, just as slow and serious.
"Thorin," Bilbo breathed, struggling to find his voice in the face of such an outpouring. It was clear from the gravity of the moment that Bilbo needed to meet it with the same depth of emotion, throwing aside all doubts. He reached out and accepted the stunning bouquet, setting it on the table beside him. "You have it, my love. And yes, I will marry you."
Thorin’s eyes widened almost comically, his mouth hanging open for a beat before his face lit with the most luminous, joyful smile. He let out a whoop of joy and sprang up, scooping Bilbo in his arms and spinning them, his happiness spilling out in his booming laughter.
…
Thorin’s heart was filled to overflowing. His One was finally in his arms; no more confusion, no more burdens or unspoken hurts between them. They had conquered so many obstacles to get to this point. He felt rather justified in celebrating like a gleeful youth.
His spinning slowed as he looked up at Bilbo, smiling down at him with such open love. His cheeks were flushed with high spots of color and his eyes crinkled with joy. Thorin had dreamed of putting such a look on Bilbo’s face someday.
Bilbo slowly slid down, their chests pressed together, until Thorin's arms were tucked under his, and his broad feet were perched tip-toed on top of Thorin's boots. Thorin felt more lightheaded from the intensity of Bilbo's gaze than from all the spinning.
Their eyes stayed fixed on each other through this dizzying slide until Bilbo's gaze flicked down to Thorin's lips and then back up. The Hobbit licked his lips as if he were staring at his favorite meal, and suddenly Thorin’s only desire was to be devoured.
Thorin never knew which of them leaned forward first, but soon their lips met in a gentle press that shook him deeply. He held forth in his heart all his love and wonder for this remarkable hobbit, and poured it into their kiss. Soon Bilbo was trembling in his arms as well.
Here in Bilbo’s reclaimed home, with their past laid to rest and their future shining before them, Thorin felt peace like he had never known settle over him.
…
Notes:
- White Alyssum (Worth beyond beauty)
- Forget-me-nots (True love)
- Blue Hydrangea (Apology)
- Light pink roses (Desire, passion, joy of life)
- Ivy (Faithfulness, wedded love)
- Sage (Respect, esteem, domesticity)
- White bleeding hearts (Unconditional love, rejected love (in this case fear of))
ai-latunsuwê - I request that you forgive me (when addressing a male) - formal (archaic)) from this Tumblr post
Chapter 10
Notes:
(See the end of the chapter for notes.)
Chapter Text
Dís sighed as she once again read through the letters her sons had sent over the months. In between the (clearly exaggerated) tales of their own heroics, they had written of how her brother—of all people—had fallen in love with the Company’s Hobbit. They described the quarrel over the Arkenstone, the heartbreak that followed, and how Thorin was offering 'ultân to redeem himself in the eyes of the very hobbit he once wronged.
Normally, Dís would disapprove. A hobbit as a lover? That alone was enough to make her bristle. And not just any hobbit—the one who stole the Arkenstone and handed it over to the Elves. The audacity. The insult! But despite herself, she could not deny the facts. That same hobbit had also saved Thorin’s life—more than once. He shielded her sons in battle, soothed the madness of the gold-sickness that no dwarf had ever broken through, and played a quiet, steady hand in restoring Erebor.
And now, Thorin offers ‘ultân—for him. For the hobbit.
This was no passing fancy.
She needed to understand just who this hobbit was, and if he posed a threat to her family. Dís sighed again and read the last letter a second time, then a third. Her fingers lingered on the parchment, hesitant. What if the hobbit refused to forgive Thorin? She knew her brother far too well. Thorin took every burden upon himself, carrying guilt like armor, and would rather burn than reach for joy he thought he didn't deserve. The fact that he left Erebor, left the throne, to chase this halfling across Middle-earth—it spoke volumes. It terrified her.
She rubbed her forehead, trying to quell the dull ache rising behind her eyes, when the sharp sound of wings drew her gaze to the window. A raven landed heavily on the sill, feathers ruffled from a long journey. With a raised brow and a flicker of unease, Dís unfastened the scroll from its leg and unrolled it quickly.
She read it once. Blinked. Read it again. A third time, just to be sure.
Then she shouted, loud enough to rattle the stone halls of Ered Luin:
"THEY’RE GETTING MARRIED ALREADY!? IT’S BARELY BEEN A FULL YEAR SINCE THEY MET!"
…
The light fell perfectly on the grass, making it look almost golden. The stage under the Party Tree had been decorated for the ceremony with many different kinds of climbing flowers and vines, adorning the curving arch over the center in ways Thorin could never try to understand.
It had all been so simple. Fortinbras had brought them together, calling Thorin his cousin by choice and an honorary Baggins - Thorin supposed it was only fair, since the dwarves would adopt Bilbo as their own similarly - and wrapped a long satin ribbon around their clasped hands. Bilbo kissed him, and then the food was served.
"You look sulky, my husband." Bilbo dropped down beside him on the bench he'd retreated to, trying to wrap his head around the events of the day.
Thorin smiled at his beautiful hobbit, resplendent in a shimmering pale blue waistcoat and dark blue cravat over a fine linen shirt. Bilbo had the same shimmering fabric made into a tunic in the Dwarven style for Thorin, and he was still admiring the skills of the tailor who had produced them in just a couple of weeks.
When Dis had arrived in Hobbiton a week ago, rolling in like a thundercloud, Thorin feared that all of their hasty plans would be ruined. Yet again, he underestimated the considerable charm of his…well, his husband. Thorin thrilled at the thought that they were wed in truth now, with the full blessings of both their families. In fact, when Dis had learned of Bilbo’s preliminary trade negotiations, she had scooped him up and pressed her forehead to his, and called him brother.
"How could I be sulky, my hobbit, when I've just married my One?"
"Well, you’ll find just about any excuse to sulk, I've learned," Bilbo shrugged. "Is Hobbit effusiveness too much for your Dwarf sensibilities?"
Thorin chuckled, "You'll have to excuse me, ghivashel, if it takes some time for me to catch up with the pace of all this." He gestured to the beautiful stage, the lantern-lit dance floor, and all their happy guests. "When I thought we should be wed, I imagined it taking place years in the future, not weeks."
"I think we'd wasted quite enough time, thank you," Bilbo replied, wrinkling his nose adorably. He seemed distracted, his gaze focused on the table across the floor where Fortinbras and Dis were engaged in deep discussion.
"You look thoughtful too, my Bilbo." Thorin murmured, pulling him close and reveling in the ability to do so freely, and in public. "What is on your clever mind?"
"Ah, nothing, it's just..." Bilbo stopped talking, his attention drawn by the sudden cheers of the hobbits around them, before the revelry was cut by a crackling boom. Thorin's hand went to his sword, which not even Bilbo had persuaded him to leave aside—and more than one matron had tutted over—but there was no danger. A splash of sparkling color appeared above them, followed quickly by another firework, and then another.
"Gandalf!" Bilbo smiled, his eyes huge as they fixed on the glittering show in the sky.
Thorin had never seen anything like it, and he had never seen Gandalf so cheerful. He seemed to be quite enjoying himself.
"Bilbo, my dear hobbit!" Gandalf smiled, waving from across the field. "Did you really think I would let my dear friends get married without being here to celebrate it?" He bellowed, turning to light yet another rocket.
Thorin basked in his husband’s child-like joy at the spectacle.
"Oh!" Bilbo smiled. "The party just didn't seem complete without Gandalf's fireworks!"
"Ask and I'll give you anything your heart desires, amrâlime." Thorin promised.
"All my heart wants is you, Thorin."
…
"And you say it’s buried here now, in the mithril pouch, under the seedling?" Gandalf was staring at the tiny seedling that had sprouted quite a bit in a very short time.
"Yes, and that was, what," Bilbo looked to Thorin, "three weeks ago? I've never seen an acorn sprout that quickly."
"Hmmm." Gandalf pursed his lips and stroked his beard contemplatively. "Hmmm."
Thorin just crossed his arms and waited, familiar with the wizard's way of saying what he needed to say only when he was good and ready. Bilbo leaned against his side and Thorin decided he had no problem waiting a bit longer as he wrapped an arm around his husband’s shoulders.
Gandalf reached down, his hand hovering over the little tree but not touching it. "I sense nothing, at least not now," he muttered. "Show me this sketch you made of the lettering, as you remember it."
Bilbo pulled out the sketch of the fiery letters that had appeared on the ring. He'd made it that same night in Tharbad. He felt a little tug of sadness at the memory of the harsh words and strange emotions of that day, and was again grateful that they'd moved past it so effortlessly.
Gandalf peered at the sketch for a bit, then tucked it away. "It seems you've found a safe place to keep it for the time being. Be sure to let your gardener and your cousin know that it's not to be disturbed under any circumstance." He glanced down fondly at the little tree again. "I have a feeling you've given it a stout protector."
"Beorn did have the most remarkable garden, after all." Bilbo replied. "Now, you must come try the leaf I picked up on our way through the South Farthing. This must be one of the best years for pipeweed since the bumper crop of Old Toby in 1324!"
As Bilbo and the wizard walked back to the smial, Thorin took one last look at the seedling. He could have sworn he saw the leaves stretch and grow before his very eyes, but perhaps it was just the breeze…
…
"So, you both followed traditions of your cultures to court the other?" Balin asked, frowning at the paper in front of him.
After a lovely long honeymoon and a few weeks to pack his belongings and make sure that Drogo was ready to take care of everything, Bilbo and Thorin had met Dis and the caravan from Ered Luin. The journey back to Erebor had been filled with song and laughter, with many chilly nights spent cuddling by an open fire. It had been a deeply emotional moment when they’d rounded the spur of the mountain and brother and sister rode side by side to approach the great gates, where an enthusiastic Company had been waiting for their return.
Apparently, and Bilbo was tired of being surprised by his dwarves' actions at this point, the very first order of business had been settling the Company's betting pool on their unfortunate relationship.
"Hold on a moment, but we can't really say there was a rejection of the mithril, if Bilbo didn't know it was a courtship gift!" Fili protested.
"Is the fact that they got married so soon a scandal, or not?" Kili asked, tilting his head.
"We are dwarrow!" Dori said. "Of course it is a scandal!"
"Bilbo's a hobbit." Nori pointed out. "The scandal was already there."
Dwalin growled. "I had to watch my king pining after a hobbit, and they had the nerve to get married the moment they got out of my sight."
“It’s not fair! We wanted to be there for the wedding too!” Kíli cried out, smacking the back of his hand against Fili’s chest, who nodded vigorously.
“I should have officiated!” Balin complained.
Bifur shouted something in Khuzdul that Thorin was glad Bilbo couldn’t understand yet.
“What’s going on?” Óin asked, holding up his ear trumpet.
“How could you do this? I thought we were family!” Glóin exclaimed in outrage.
The cries of protest continued until Gimli, Glóin’s surprisingly diplomatic son, suddenly shouted, “Well, since they had a Hobbit wedding, they should also have a Dwarrow wedding—right here in Erebor!”
Bilbo rolled his eyes, thinking they couldn’t possibly be serious. But then he saw Thorin’s expression. The king was nodding contemplatively, as if he were already planning another ceremony. Well, Bilbo had to admit, it would be good for morale—and, truthfully, it had been a bit unfair to only have a Hobbit wedding when his husband is a Dwarf.
“Amrâlime? Can we?” Thorin asked.
Bilbo sighed. “Yes, we can have another.”
Thorin smiled, already picturing how handsome Bilbo would look in Dwarrow wedding attire—covered in gems, wearing Durin blue, and perhaps even clad in mithril armor.
"Well," Dis said, somehow cutting through all the shouting while casually sipping the tea that Bilbo had offered her, "I didn't see my brother pining, but I did see their wedding. Hobbits have a unique way of celebrating marriage, if I can say. What a pity, I'll be the only one to attend both weddings,” she added with a vicious little smile behind her teacup.
There was a moment of silence, and then their friends began to yell and protest all over again.
Bilbo sighed. "We left the Shire for this...you know Drogo would let us stay with him?"
"You love our enthusiasm, my hobbit," Thorin chuckled, kissing Bilbo's hair. "And I am happy that our friends find comfort in our happiness."
"They’re still arguing over the bet." Bilbo pointed out.
"And yet, I am the one that truly won." Thorin whispered.
"We both did." Bilbo sighed, “I love our family."
Gandalf was right. The world wasn't found in books or maps; it was right here.
It was home.
…
Notes:
Uff-da, that was a beast! Three months of back and forth and all around, including many, many, many hours of editing to make it all work together. It was marvelously fun!! What we make together is greater than the sum of its parts, indeed!
Our next project is even more ambitious! An Erebor Never Fell AU that dives deep into the Tolkien Legendarium and comes up with something completely new! We would love to have your help bringing it to life. Please join us on the Bagginshield Book Club Discord Server and check out our Story Relay Chat channel for more info!
