Actions

Work Header

Back and There Again

Chapter 8

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

Their final morning on the road dawned bright and crisp. The caravan reached Bywater just before lunchtime, and they parted from their hosts on good terms, with offers to travel together in the future, should their paths cross again.

As soon as the pleasantries were done, Bilbo made a bee-line for the Green Dragon, bursting in through the door and pausing dramatically. Chatter in the busy tap room was instantly silenced as hobbits all around the room gaped at him as if they were seeing a ghost.

"Mister Bilbo!" a voice cried from behind the counter. Out bustled a very round hobbit, who would have been as wide as Bombur, if he'd been anywhere near as tall.

"Hullo Toby," Bilbo said warmly, leading Thorin over to where the stout innkeeper was wringing a dishtowel fiercely in his thick fingers.

"Oh Mister Bilbo, it’s mighty good to see you! We’d near given you up for dead, we had!"

"Well, as you can see, I’m most certainly not dead," Bilbo replied, ending in a much louder tone that was clearly meant for the room at large. At those words, conversation in the taproom picked up again, tables buzzing with fiercely whispered gossip.

"Can we get a spot of luncheon, Toby? And a couple of half-pints. My travel companion and I haven't stopped since first breakfast and I could eat a horse!" Bilbo said, eyes comically wide.

"Oh of course Mister Bilbo, of co—eep!" Toby cut off with a little yelp when he turned to Thorin and looked up, and up at the tall dwarf, who tilted his head in polite greeting.

"Toby, this is Thorin Oakenshield, my dear friend and travel companion. He was kind enough to see me all the way here from his home in the East once my business there was complete. Thorin, this is Toby Toppletoast, proprietor of the Green Dragon." Bilbo conducted his introductions in a still slightly louder than normal tone while the whispers continued to swirl around them.

Toby bobbed again and bustled himself back behind the counter to call the order back to the kitchen. Bilbo turned away and scanned the room, his eyes lighting when he spotted a gray-haired figure dressed in the fine green velvet coat of a gentlehobbit sitting in the back corner, looking at him expectantly.

"Well, Bilbo Baggins, in the flesh! This is quite a pickle, my boy, quite a pickle indeed!" the hobbit declared when they'd approached his table. "Come! We have much to discuss!"

"I don't doubt it, Bert." Bilbo said dryly, deftly handling introductions again, naming the older gentleman as Filibert Noakes, his solicitor. Again he named Thorin as an Important Dwarf from the East, and his Travel Companion, with that curious emphasis that Hobbits seemed to put on certain words and phrases that had some hidden meaning. The older gentleman rose to greet them, then ushered them into a private room off the main taproom so they could speak freely.

...

Thorin just sat back as the hobbits spoke, attentive but mostly watching Bilbo's solicitor with sharp eyes. In truth, he was trying to find what things Bilbo and this gentlehobbit had in common.

Their manner of speaking was only slightly different, with Bilbo’s speech being more direct and slightly sarcastic, although Thorin couldn't remember if Bilbo had always spoken that way, or if that had changed during their travels together. Otherwise they both seemed to have a more eloquent and precise manner to their speech that the innkeeper, for example, didn't have.

Their style of dress set them apart from other Hobbits, but in this too Bilbo had just a little more flair, with the solicitor’s dark, simple coat in contrast to the bright colors Bilbo wore. Bilbo had allowed his hair to grow longer than any other male Hobbit that Thorin had seen, and it thrilled him again to see his braid and bead peeking out of his tangled locks. He wondered if the other Hobbits had noticed, or what they thought of his more exotic look now. They didn't give any indication, but it seemed that was mostly their way.

Toby arrived with their meals and drinks, smiling kindly at him, a huge difference between his behaviour when he first saw Thorin. Although that initial reaction had proved to him that protection was likely the only thing Dwarrow could offer Hobbits that wouldn't be rejected.

"It’ll take some doing to reverse things now, but we’ll manage." Bert said to Bilbo, then turned to Thorin. "Mister Bilbo here has quite a way with contracts, don’t you know?"

Thorin nodded, smiling fondly at the memory of Bilbo ruining the sham of a contract Thranduil had tried to offer them. "I wasn't aware that contracts were often used in the Shire," Thorin murmured, "Mister Baggins seemed surprised when we gave him a contract for our journey."

"Well, no one expected a Baggins to go off on an adventure!" Bert coughed a little awkwardly behind his hand. "And Mister Bilbo had always been the perfect Baggins, with an impeccable reputation as the Head of such a fine family!"

"Bilbo seemed to think he was alone here." Thorin muttered, forgetting for a moment the proper respect Bilbo's title clearly deserved.

Toby, who had lingered near the table clearly hoping to listen in on the proceedings, blurted out, "Oh but there’s still plenty what support the good Baggins name! Not those uppity Sackville-Bagginses. We’ll all be goin’ to the sale, o’ course, as most would like to keep a memory of dear Mister Bilbo." He smiled fondly at Bilbo, who looked a little uncomfortable.

...

"But it is a blessing that you're back, Bilbo," Bert rushed to add. "I’ve had a bramble of a time trying to find new homes for all of your tenants, you see."

"My tenants? What about them?" Bilbo suddenly straightened up.

"Well, you are by now aware that Lobelia has been trying to take possession of Bag End, and with Bag End, ownership of Bagshot Row and the lands on The Hill—and she's already been stirring things up," the solicitor said sourly, lowering his voice. "It’s nothing but blatant extortion, Mister Bilbo. I've been trying to help them move, but it seems not many are as kind as you or your father ever were." Bert shook his head ruefully. He didn’t even seem disturbed by Bilbo’s sudden anger, knowing it wasn’t directed at him.

"That parasite! She has enough wealth already! Those families are good people—all of them! How dare she—I just—" Bilbo began muttering in colorful Sindarin, an old habit he'd developed since no one in the Shire, except his parents, spoke the language fluently. It allowed him to curse freely in public. Of course, Thorin’s eyes widened—he had never heard Bilbo use such language. It was clear he was deeply protective of his tenants.

"Bert! Please, tell me where they are! I left them defenseless against that harpy. It’s only right that I help them now."

"I believe a number of them have plans to disturb the auction tomorrow, actually. None of them wanted to believe that you were dead. They're still in their homes on Bagshot Row for now, and they'll be delighted to hear of your return to be their kind landlord once more," Bert replied with a kindly smile.

Bilbo suddenly fell silent. The burden of his plans to return to Erebor with Thorin seemed heavier by the moment. Sensing the shift, Thorin reached for his hand and gave it a gentle squeeze to let him know he was there to support him.

The gesture was not lost on the other hobbits, and Toby actually jumped a bit from where he had been making a show of wiping the same table for the last few minutes. Bilbo just looked at him with a raised eyebrow and the round little innkeeper gave a squeak and scurried away.

...

Bilbo waited until Toby had left the room before he allowed his anger to melt away and a small amount of despair to fill him as he thought of the ties that bound him in the Shire, that could very well keep him away from Thorin and all of his dwarves for the rest of his life. "What do I do?" he asked himself, quiet enough for only Thorin to hear.

"I am sure that between us," Thorin nodded to Bert, "we can devise an ironclad contract that will withstand all assaults. You would just need to appoint an executor that you would leave in charge of your estate. Can you think of anyone?" Thorin replied quietly, not wanting to exclude Bilbo’s lawyer. Thorin felt he was being very gracious in not elaborating on the ways that a Dwarrow contract was surely superior to something Hobbits could come up with, when he truly looked like a decent enough chap.

Relief washed over Bilbo’ face, and hope once again filled his eyes. To cause that look in Bilbo’s eyes, and for it to once again be directed at himself, Thorin felt as if he could take on Azog, Bolg, Smaug, and the entire contents of the Misty Mountains and still have time to write the documents Bilbo needed.

Bilbo covered Thorin's hand with his own and gave it another gentle squeeze. He only let go again when Toby appeared back at their table with another round of drinks. "Here you are, Mister Bilbo. Finest ale we have for you and your, erm, uh, dwarf," he said as he dropped it off before scurrying back out of the room and closing the door quietly.

Bert stood from the table, patting his ample belly as he stretched. "Well, I had better get on with calling off the auction tomorrow, then. Bilbo, you surely do know how to cause a stir! The only thing I can imagine would have made a bigger fuss would be for you to show up right in the middle of all the bidding!" He chortled at the image and dipped his head in farewell. "I will call at Bag End, likely sometime after tea, to debrief you and discuss further strategy. Thorin, a pleasure." He tipped his hat to the dwarf with a wink as he left.

"Thank you, Bert. It's a comfort to know that you are representing my interests," Bilbo said graciously, turning back to the table and dismissing him as regally as any king. Thorin marvelled at how naturally a noble bearing seemed to rest on his hobbit.

"Eat, Thorin." Bilbo admonished when Thorin just sat staring. "Good ideas don't come on an empty stomach. The disaster when we first took Erebor should have told you that," he said with a happy smile as he tucked into the real Shire fare he'd been much too long without. It was a far cry from those days of near starvation. He made a mental note to grab a few of his cookbooks before they returned to Erebor, to share with Bombur. It wasn’t like a Dwarf would know the precise importance to a Hobbit of sharing family recipes, and the idea of having Shire fare made for him by Bombur’s expert hand was too tempting a thought for him to change his mind.

Bilbo was so busy considering how well potatoes might grow in some of the open caverns in Erebor that he didn’t notice the stricken look that had passed on Thorin’s face.

Thorin, for his part, held his tongue, letting the hurt and guilt become again a part of his atonement. With it, he renewed the vow to himself that once they'd sorted this mess with Bilbo's home, he would finish the ’ultânul ceremony, where he would prostrate himself at Bilbo’s beautifully overlarge feet and resolve all that stood between them. And then…hopefully then he would be worthy of asking Bilbo for his hand in marriage.

With settled thoughts Thorin allowed himself to tuck into the heaping plate of simple but rich and filling food. He had finally stopped being surprised at Hobbit portions. After all, it wouldn’t be a meal fit for a Hobbit if it didn’t leave a Dwarf all but bursting at the seams.

He allowed the relaxed atmosphere of the pub and the friendly company to settle over him. Bilbo’s presence filled his heart as full as his stomach.

...

As he ate, Bilbo's thoughts revolved around family, and tradition, and the ties that bound it all together. With all they'd been through, and the way Thorin had consistently offered his support by escorting Bilbo and coming to his aid time and again, well, could be the kind of thing that was comparable to sharing family recipes here in the Shire.

As soon as they'd entered the inn’s taproom together and saw all of those gaping hobbits, Bilbo had realised that in running off as he had and then returning with a single companion, everyone here would assume he had run away to get married in the old-fashioned way of the Shire, the way some couples had done long before the Fell Winter, and before they were so harshly reminded of the dangers outside the Shire.

Looking at Thorin, Bilbo sighed. It was too bad he hadn't run off to get married to that particular dwarf, pigheaded and brooding as he was. He wouldn't have complained in the least.

But with Thorin’s position, and after everything that had come between them, Bilbo considered himself lucky just to be his friend again. But then, there was that pesky “Not yet” that Thorin had let slip…

Bilbo sighed.

"Everything alright, my burglar?" Thorin asked.

Bilbo bit his lower lip. "I'm just thinking about who could be a good candidate to act in my place." He deflected, "Being a Baggins is important, in the Shire."

"I’ve noticed." Thorin chuckled. "I don't know if you knew, Master Baggins, but you put a lot of emphasis on your last name."

"Well, it is important! A lot of hobbits rely on the Baggins estate, and there's a certain degree of tradition that comes with that responsibility." Bilbo nodded. "It's downright shocking that Lobelia would dare think she could parcel off my and my parents' things and threaten my tenants. She should definitely know better."

Thorin looked at him seriously. "I would fight her, if it is what you needed me to do."

"Oh, you would fight anyone for fun," Bilbo raised an eyebrow, "but fighting any hobbit is not even a challenge, and Lobelia will likely crumple like wet paper the moment she sees me, if she knows what's good for her."

...

"Speaking of traditions …" Bilbo said with uncharacteristic hesitance. He took a deep breath and plunged on, "Um, Thorin, there is something you should know."

Thorin arched a brow, curiosity piqued. What could possibly make Bilbo—usually so composed—blush such a deep and fetching shade of red?

"Um... there might be, uh…it's a possibility that…well, that the other hobbits here may…think you’re my husband…" Bilbo mumbled, eyes flicking up to meet Thorin’s before darting away.

Thorin’s brain stalled. He stared. Did he hear that correctly?

Bilbo shifted awkwardly and continued, "You see, there’s an old tradition among Hobbits—especially the Brandybucks and Tooks—where if two hobbits go off on an ramble together, vanish to who knows where, and return side by side…well, it’s assumed that they’re then married. It’s considered something of an elopement…very romantic. And, well… I am a Took on my mother’s side, so it’s quite likely the others will just assume you and I… tied the knot, so to speak."

He paused, chewing his lip. "Thorin? Are you alright?"

Thorin blinked, then slowly smiled—a rare, unguarded smile that lit up his face. He felt like he was caught in a dream. A warm, golden dream he never wanted to wake from. If he looked like a lovesick fool, so be it. His heart beat loudly in his chest, drowning out reason. A happy chuckle bubbled up from his chest.

Married, it echoed. To Bilbo.

He rather liked the sound of that.

...

Thorin continued to chuckle happily as he savored the moment. A wisp of doubt drifted into his reverie when he looked again at Bilbo and saw how unhappily distressed he appeared. Wait, was it not a good thing in Bilbo’s mind that other hobbits think they are married? The wisp was a full-blown thundercloud in moments. Bilbo looked miserable.

"Would this…" Thorin cleared his throat against the squeezing despair, "would this pose a problem for recovering your estate?"

"Oh! No, no not at all, actually." Bilbo’s eyes were wide, but his mouth still down-turned, "if anything, it adds quite a bit of legitimacy to my disappearance. Much more acceptable than haring off on an adventure to reclaim a mountain from a dragon." He chuckled weakly.

"But, Thorin," the hobbit leaned forward and placed his hand on Thorin's forearm again, where it burned like a brand, "we don't need to pretend for the sake of my legal troubles, if it's uncomfortable for you, or you find it silly."

"It is no burden." He rumbled lowly. "It would be my greatest honor, even under false pretenses, to be called your…husband." He could barely whisper the word, so great was the longing that rose up within him. Thorin found himself completely unable to pull on the stoic mask he usually wore—he was sure his desperate hope was evident for Bilbo to read clearly.

Bilbo’s eyes were still blown wide, but his mouth slack with shock now as he drifted closer. Thorin sat, feeling as trapped as a fly in honey, unable to tear his gaze from Bilbo’s face, from his parted, pink lips that glistened when his tongue darted out to wet them.

"It would? You would?" Bilbo asked weakly. "You…want that?"

Thorin tore his gaze away and rose so quickly from the table that he rattled the plates and mugs. "It is not time yet." He said harshly, as much to himself as anything. "I would not dishonor you so."

"Me? How would being married to you dishonor me?" Bilbo demanded.

"We are mabinjalanattân; it cannot be," Thorin growled, clenching his fists fiercely as he paced.

"Thorin!" Bilbo said sharply, causing the distressed dwarf to jump and whip back to him so quickly that his long hair flew across his chest. "I will thank you to use one of the several languages that I do speak when discussing matters that involve me!" When he had Thorin’s full attention he continued with a wave of his hand, "Now, what precisely does it mean to be malbinjallatan?"

Thorin would have smiled at Bilbo's attempted Khuzdul, if he weren't kicking himself so fiercely for breaching the strictures of the altân rites. "It is not spoken of," he began gruffly, "but, perhaps it would be appropriate to explain."

"Considering I am not a dwarf, yes, most appropriate."

Thorin froze, looking at Bilbo, really looking at him. His One was not a Dwarf. This really shouldn't have been a new idea but the fact kept blindsiding him at the most random, and important, moments. Would he have any idea what was required of them?

Bilbo started to look uncertain. "That is, if you can, if it is allowed. I know I'm not supposed to–"

"You have every right to our culture and language." Thorin said softly, taking Bilbo’s small hands in his. "But I must ask yet again that you have patience with me, with us. It is not something we are accustomed to, sharing ourselves with those who are not dwarrow."

"I'll do my best to be patient." Bilbo promised, giving Thorin's fingers a squeeze. "I've never been very good at it, but I'm quite motivated." He smiled crookedly.

Thorin took a deep, bracing breath, and began, "When one Hobbit has wronged another, what do you do to make amends?"

"Well, if something of value was damaged they may offer to replace it, as they are able. If it's a personal matter, they may expect to have a heartfelt conversation to clear the air. Either way, they typically just apologize, and that's that."

"You just…apologize?" Thorin asked, bemused.

"Well, that is, only if you want to remain in that person’s good graces, I suppose. Plenty of Hobbits have given offense and continued on as if nothing had happened!" he grumbled a little sourly, "But if you truly want to set things right, you own up to it and apologize, often with a gift of appropriate flowers or food to show one’s intent and sincerity."

"Ah, and, is there a form or standard for how one presents this gift?"

"What? No, nothing like that!" Bilbo reared back a little, but did not relinquish his hold on Thorin’s hands, "You don't want to draw more attention to the incident than is necessary, really. Sometimes you don't even say it outright. Simply offering the right combination of flowers is enough to let them know you’d like to regain their good will."

Thorin knew there was a lot more to "offering the right combination of flowers" than he understood, but he didn't want to get sidetracked. "Dwarrow handle these things in a very different manner," he began.

"I gathered as much," Bilbo said wryly, tugging Thorin down so they could sit at the table again, their chairs pulled close together since he still wouldn't let go of Thorin's hands, a matter which Thorin found quite comforting.

"When one dwarrow has wronged another, he must offer altân. It may be as small as repairing or replacing a damaged item, as you said, but in cases of less material damage, a gift of gold or of service may be offered." Bilbo’s brow furrowed as he absorbed this information, but he did not interrupt.

"There are certain expectations for the delivery of such a gift," Thorin continued. "Unless very personal in nature, it must be presented before at least one other dwarrow. It must be fitting to the wrong that has been committed. One does not discuss the offense or nature of the gift explicitly, especially while the service is being carried out. You may not enter into contracts or other agreements with the dwarrow you have wronged until your altân has been accepted. It's all a very instinctive thing for us. When the appropriate amends have been performed or delivered, the…one who has wronged, I suppose you could say, requests formal forgiveness. If sufficient, the wronged party accepts and the matter is resolved. Both parties are released and there’s no need to speak of the matter again after that."

Bilbo looked a little dazed, "That all sounds…dreadfully complicated."

Thorin chuckled, "It is very straightforward to a dwarf, I suppose. We know when altân is required, and to what degree." He grew somber again, "And when one’s offenses have reached the highest level, ‘ultânul: the most supreme atonement, is required." He withdrew one hand to pinch at the bridge of his nose, sighing when Bilbo’s thumb traced over the back of his hand comfortingly.

"I have not yet completed my ’ultânul to you, Bilbo," he said lowly, gaze fixed on their clasped hands.

"Why, whatever for, dear?" Bilbo asked.

"Until you have regained your ancestral home, my service in amends for the wrongs I have committed against you will not be complete." Thorin said, meeting Bilbo’s soft gaze resolutely.

"Well, that's easily done then!" The hobbit said cheerily. "Let’s go home now, Thorin, and be done with this." His fingers squeezed Thorin's again, and the dwarf felt as if his small hands had reached in and squeezed his very heart, filling it with comfort and love.

...

Notes:

mabinjalanattân - “Those who continue to be unfinished.” (constructed with the graceful assistance of The Dwarrow Scholar in this Tumblr post.