Sorry, you need to have JavaScript enabled for this.

Actions

Work Header

The Pony Paradox

Summary:

Bilbo, at the age of 105, is spending some time in the Prancing Pony, and is doing cooking work in exchange for his room. The Company – young, fresh-faced, as they were before the quest (before he even knew them) – walk in.

Notes:

Hey so uhhhh. About that fic I'm writing. Yeah, this isn't it. Saw a post and got inspired - it's one of those writing prompt ones. Here is the link: https://www.tumblr.com/writing-prompt-s/783355225778110464/you-are-a-retired-adventurer-running-a-quiet?source=share

This has not been proof-read and is fresh off the press, written all in one.
Enjoy!!

(See the end of the work for more notes.)

Work Text:

Soft gold light filters onto dark wood, reflected into the room thousands of times by large, heavy raindrops running down glass window panes. Darkness remains outside, unbothered by candlelight or the oven’s flame; he vaguely wonders if it’s cold out there, but turns back to his cooking, warmed by the fires of the kitchen. It wouldn’t do to burn some poor man’s meal because he was distracted – least of all because it would taste of charred meat; it would be disrespectful to both his cooking skills (both hobbitish and dwarvish in nature, thanks to Bombur’s influences) and disrespectful to Darla, who was letting him exchange his cooking for his room.

Soon enough, hot food was sitting on thirteen plates – a large group had obviously come in, he and Darla working together to provide their simple meal. Since it was only the two of them – as it was a Tuesday night, which wasn’t particularly popular – she had asked for his help with waiting, taking their food to the table. She said she’d handle the drinks or other requests, so he’d agreed; he’d never been a waiter at any official establishments, but he’d served food many a time, most often to gathered relatives on his own grounds – but once, a lifetime ago it seemed, he had helped the same dwarf who had so influenced his cooking to hand out warm meals to the rest of who would become his family.

Two sets of steady hands held burning plates with ease, both hobbit and human skin toughened by years of exposure to heat; they walk into a comfortably warm main room, too small to be called a food hall. Bilbo watches the floor – make sure to avoid that loose nail in the floor, yes, that’s it, I should probably tell Darla about that – and then looks up. He quickly wishes he hadn’t.

Thirteen sets of eyes peer in his direction, following the food he holds, none looking upon his face, but he knows – he knows immediately, because how couldn’t he? For, sat before him, are thirteen faces he knows well, far closer to him than his own blood; thirteen faces which were wrinkled and weary, last he saw them, but now sit, content, youthful, and rejuvenated.
A mohawk is what catches his eye first, trailing down into an impressively long skullet style, the dwarf’s skull marked by patterns and runes he knows he shouldn’t be able to read, but can, in part because their owner and his kin taught him. Their owner, who was unable to grow hair atop his head, last he heard, and who sat menacingly as he always did beside a significantly shorter dwarf – though wider he too was. A shock of white hair trailed around him, though within it were hints of tawny, a colour Bilbo had only ever associated with the clothing of Balin, who sat, alive, next to his brother. Breathing.
Only a week ago had Gandalf come by to tell him Balin had died in Moria.
Pale blue eyes squint at him as he meets their owner’s gaze, and Bilbo realises with a start he’s been standing in the doorway for what felt like years, so he moves with a squeak he learned to suppress while travelling with these dwarves over half a century ago.

They laugh, and joke, and breathe , and Bilbo is caught up in the moment, walking blankly back and forth between the kitchen and the table as he serves his unknowing family their food.
But they can’t be his family – they were too young. And that was ignoring that he’d counted thirteen figures, a baker’s dozen including three more childish silhouettes, from the kitchen when he’d started cooking; of those, six were dead.

“You alright, laddie?” Balin asks, voice crisp and clear of the slight rasp which had affected him following the Battle. “You look like you’ve seen a ghost.”
It takes Bilbo all of his willpower not to break down then and there, the dwarf’s words echoing his own from decades prior. He finds he can’t rip his gaze from Balin’s, both for fear he’d disappear, and for fear of meeting the eyes of the one he spoke such a sentence to, whose death launched him into a silent, screaming grief, for which the Shire had named him Mad Baggins.
Darla – wonderful, thoughtful Darla, to whom he’d recalled his whimsical, child-ified version of the Quest for Erebor on each occasion of his staying in Bree – placed a calloused, heavy hand on his shoulder, and said what he thought was quite possibly the worst possible thing she could have said.
“Because he has.”
They both wore red, and though he knew it to be a mere coincidence, he couldn’t help but draw parallels between Balin and his words, echoed by Darla years later, wearing a soft red tunic covered by a practical apron. He mentally thanks her for her interruption, for he knows his voice to be wobbly, swept entirely off its metaphorical feet by the exchange. She speaks with Balin in his stead.
“Whatever do you mean, lass?”
“He travelled, once – with a group just like yours,” she says, hand still resting on his right-hand side, voice low despite the absence of anyone else in the room.
“How so?”
“A baker’s dozen of dwarves, varying in age and fortune and background, as you sirs appear to. Only, you cannot be them, for some are no longer with us.”
Yes – they can’t be the Company. No use getting all worked up about it – maybe his age is finally catching up to him.
He fidgeted subconsciously, hand moving to caress the small, golden band he kept with him – it was soothing, in a painful sort of way, where it distorted his mind into emptiness; it was awful, should he want to experience anything other than absence, but absence was often better than grief or loss.
“Oh? Where did he go?” Balin asked kindly, though out of pity it sounded to be rather than any curiosity or recognition.
“Y’heard of Erebor?”
“Aye, a great kingdom – lost to a dragon, many years ago. But, pray tell, lad – why would you go there?”
“To get it back,” Bilbo heard himself speak, voice soft and barely-audible even in the still, quiet night. “With people much like yourselves.” He clears his throat, blinks, and locks onto not-Balin’s eyes, avoiding everyone else with undoubtedly obvious determination. “Apologies – enjoy your meal,” he says, turning to leave in what he knows he will later describe to himself as a sprint rather than a socially acceptable speed-walk. Darla, he hears, does not follow him.
“Wait,” another voice says, deep and gravelly and nearly so powerful as to send Bilbo back into his memories – memories of ice and sun and blood and love and a funeral’s votives, and all the red clothes stuffed into the back of his wardrobe that Frodo has learned to stop asking him about. Still, against his own mind’s warnings, he turns, slow but sure, keeping his eyes pinned to the floor. “Why do you speak of our kingdom as if it is reclaimed?”
Forget-me-not eyes burn into his own, furious curiosity keeping them aflame; solid black hair greets him, not a hint of grey at the temples or the braids he’d been buried with. He wears furs which Bilbo knows should be sitting at the end of his bed.
“Because it is,” he replies, his throat hardly catching thanks to his lack of breathing, air caught in his chest, almost like he was choking of his own volition. He exhales forcefully but slowly, measured in everything from depth to sound. Thick black eyebrows raise slightly, and barely two wrinkles form along his forehead, and Bilbo’s mind briefly wonders if it would feel different against his own compared to his well-worn memories.
“I think I would know if it was,” not-Thorin said, his mannerisms similar to the Thorin Bilbo had spoken to in his smial the first time they’d met. “For I am the heir of Durin, Th-”
“Thorin II, named Oakenshield, son of Thráin, son of Thrór, King Under the Mountain.” He had not meant to say it.
“...Aye.” Now fourteen sets of eyes squinted at him, though they were a mix of confusion and wariness (and worry, on Darla’s part). “Though named Oakenshield, I am not.”
“What about Azanulbizar?” Bilbo asks, because his mouth works faster than his mind, and he finds he is, for the first time since learning the language, scared as the dwarvish pronunciation slips out.
Any who were still eating no longer do, cutlery dropping onto plates and food dropping onto the wooden table as the not-Company stares once more, wariness abandoned in favour of pure shock.
“B-”
Cool golden metal finds its way onto his finger, his constant fiddling allowing for him to easily put it on; the world becomes muted, both in sound and sight, colour sapped from everything but their eyes, until it all goes dark and he can bear it no longer. He removes the ring, and finds himself staring at a wooden floor, lighter than that of the dark inn before; he looks up to see a long wooden table, at which sit thirteen dwarves, all looking at him strangely – but it is not this which catches his attention. Instead, he notices immediately the differences; he notices Dwalin no longer has hair atop his head, and Balin is fully white again, and Thorin – even from the back of his head, he can see the dwarf’s silver streaks which sit against his temples.
“Well? Are you?” Óin asks, ear-trumpet pressed excitedly against his head.
“Am I what?”
“He says he’s an expert!”
Uproarious celebration and laughter at Óin’s misfortune follow, and Bilbo realises his fate; it is confirmed with certainty, he thinks, when Gandalf furrows his brow at him as a contract he knows off by heart is passed his way, and he doesn’t even read it before he signs.

Notes:

Hey! Thank you for reading, I hope you enjoyed!! If you want, I'm taking asks/requests on Tumblr since I need some inspiration, so if you want to see something, don't hesitate to send an ask (or shoot me a message)! Much love <3