Chapter Text
Bilbo was tossed from one end of the barrel to the other, sometimes elbowing and squishing the Bilbo clone in the process as they traveled down the swift currents of the river. He was very thankful that he wasn’t on the outside of the barrels as he would have been if he didn’t have the other Bilbos to help him. Even still, the spray was like needles against his skin and the edge of the barrel cut against Bilbo’s hands.
They had just gone over their first waterfall, drowning them in ice cold water when they heard the sound of an Elvish horn. There was a gate up ahead with a lever at the top that one of the elven guards was using to close their path.
“NO!” Thorin cried out, trying to make the barrel move faster.
It was all for naught. The gate was shut and they were trapped on the other side. Bilbo looked over at the other two Bilbos who nodded their heads as they pushed each other out of the barrel and onto the riverbank. The first Bilbo had barely taken a step when an arrow protruded straight out of the end of the elven guard’s chest and the orc that shot it appeared over his shoulder, snarling at them. Bilbo gawked as the monsters came from nowhere, crawling over the wall and killing any elf in its path. It was a good thing Bilbo remembered to pack their weapons as the orcs threw themselves at the company trapped in their barrels.
Bilbo stabbed one of the orcs that landed nearby before looking over at his clones, nodding his head towards the lever. The first one gave him a determined look as he scrambled for the stairs only to be stabbed straight through the middle. Bilbo grunted against the pain as the second clone took his chance only to be cut down as well. Bilbo and the one clone left, too filled with adrenaline to be incapacitated from the pain, shared a look. The clone grabbed Sting, cutting down any orc that got in his way as he ran for the stairs.
Some of the other dwarves were trying to crawl out of their barrels as well, but Bilbo’s clone urged them back. As soon as he got that door open, the river would pull them through too fast for the dwarves to get back in. The clone reached the top of the gate where he stabbed the first orc, Kili’s arrow flew through the next one, and the third was shoved off by the dead orcs body for the company to kill him. The Bilbo clone was right there, reaching for the lever when a large arrow pierced his knee. Bilbo cried out as the clone gave him a sorry look before disappearing.
Bilbo looked over at the orcish archer, a real ugly bugger, which was saying something for orcs. The archer’s eyebrows pulled together at seeing Bilbo’s clone disappear in front of him, but before he could pull back another arrow, there were the elven reinforcements. The orcs became distracted as the elves tore through their ranks and Bilbo took his chance. He scrambled back up the stairs and pulled the lever to free them, picking up Sting from where his clone lay.
The gate opened, releasing the barrels back down the river. He eyed the other side, noticing his barrel moving through the gate and wondering how he was going to get back in it. Ori and Nori stopped themselves from passing through by holding onto the gate and holding out his barrel for him.
“Jump, Bilbo!” Ori hollered.
Bilbo hesitated, noting it was a long way down, before making his jump. He mistimed it and ended up on the outside of the barrel, gripping the edge with all that he had as they went back to bouncing through the rapids.
“Bilbo!”
“Hang on Bilbo!”
He was trying, but between the way the barrel was tipping and the water pushing and pulling, Bilbo dipped below the surface and let go in his panic. He clutched to his sword with all that he had even as he realized this was it. This was going to be how he died. He didn’t dare allow his mind to wander too far as the sheer idea of creating multiples of himself to drown over and over again was too gruesome. He flailed trying his hardest to get back to the surface when a warm feeling overcame him.
It was the transformation magic again, and Bilbo mentally whimpered in dread at what this transformation could be. His lungs were burning with his desperation for air when it felt like his legs suddenly snapped together. Bilbo gasped out at the feeling, water pouring down his throat, and he knew this would be the moment when he drowned. He waited for the pain…but it never came. He took another deep breath just to make sure, but the water entering into his lungs wasn’t suffocating for some reason.
Bilbo looked down, figuring it was somehow related to his transformation, and sure enough there was a large red fish tail sprouting out from where his legs used to be. Well that was fairly useful. Did the magic just have some sort of ironic sense of justice? He couldn’t imagine having grown a fish tail while he was still inside the elven halls after all. He shivered at the thought. No, definitely not. Of course now he just had to figure out how to steer this thing.
Bilbo thought of it like kicking his legs, and sure enough he propelled himself forward. This was going to be easier than flying. He aimed himself up at the surface, popping out of the water near Ori. The young dwarf cried out in surprise before reaching as far as he could for him.
“Quick Bilbo, take my hand!”
Bilbo shook his head. “No, Ori, it’s alright. It’s…a transformation.”
Bilbo could tell that had grabbed Ori’s interest, but before they could say anymore an orc jumped onto his barrel. Bilbo didn’t even think about it as he took his sword and stabbed it straight through its middle. The orc began to fall backwards into the water, tipping Ori down with it.
Bilbo held his breath as he dived down underneath, remembering that he could breathe underwater only after the fact. Bilbo tried to find the dwarf through the foam and the orc bodies when he saw Ori’s flailing limbs up ahead. He swam towards the dwarf who stopped to stare at Bilbo in awe. Wrapping his arms around Ori, he pushed towards the surface. It was after they breached, that Ori suddenly became much heavier in Bilbo’s arms. He looked around for someone to help when he found Dori.
He called out for the other dwarf, forgetting for a moment how overprotective the older brother was. As soon as he saw them, he looked ready to dive in and save them.
“I can’t hold him.” Bilbo stated through gritted teeth.
Dori immediately latched onto Ori’s sleeves, holding him to the edge of the barrel. Bilbo ducked below the surface in relief, only to feel someone yank him up by the back of his jacket.
“Hey!” He complained.
“Give me your hand!” Dori commanded.
Bilbo realized he didn’t know about his transformation.
“No, Dori, really it’s oka-”
Something grabbed onto the back of Bilbo pulling him below the waves again. He turned around to see an orc clinging to his shredded pants. Bilbo stabbed the orc, getting him to let go only to almost run into another. Turns out, orcs don’t drown easily. Bilbo took it upon himself to swim out ahead, stabbing orcs that entered the water and making sure they stayed dead. It was a pain when his sword fought against the current every time, but eventually, the number of orcs slowed down along with the current.
For the first time it felt like since entering Mirkwood, Bilbo finally felt like he could relax. He floated there below the waves before realizing he couldn’t see the barrels anymore. He poked his head out, looking around only to hear Thorin’s desperate shout.
“BILBO!”
Bilbo spun around. The barrels had all run aground in the shallower water. Most of the dwarves had made it onto the shoreline with their gear. Thorin, on the other hand, was throwing himself from barrel to barrel as if looking for something. And from the way he continued to scream Bilbo’s name, he had a pretty good idea as to what that could be.
“Thorin! Thorin, I’m okay!” He called.
Thorin’s head snapped to the side so quickly that his beads hit him in the face. Not that it slowed him down in the slightest as he dove in where Bilbo was, swimming until he was able to reach him. Bilbo felt himself pulled into a hug, actually humming at the warmth the dwarf was somehow still able to put off.
“I thought I had lost you. When Dori said you had been dragged under…”
“I’m fine, Thorin. I promise.” Bilbo murmured against his chest.
Thorin slowly pulled away, a small smile gracing his face.
“Come on, sanâzyung (perfect love/One).” He stated, pulling Bilbo along as he swam back over to the company.
“No, Thorin. I won’t be able to…you don’t understand…”
They had just reached the shallow part of the river, Thorin moving to stand and pull Bilbo up in one go. Bilbo’s fins scraped against the river stones causing him to hiss as Thorin spun around to see what the problem was. His eyes widened as Bilbo’s red tailfin crested the water, shining in the sunlight.
“So I had a transformation.” He explained.
Thorin opened his mouth and closed it and opened it again, unable to form words as he stood there staring down at Bilbo.
“Well that seems incredibly lucky.” Kili finally called out.
Someone made an attempt to shush him.
“What?” The younger prince complained. “Could you honestly imagine Bilbo being half-fish when we were stuck in the forest?”
“That wasn’t why we were shushing you.” Fili explained, shaking his head in exasperation.
Bilbo could imagine from the smirks and eyebrow waggles he was receiving that he had a pretty good idea what they were thinking. He supposed he and Thorin hadn’t made any sort of formal announcement about it. Of course they would speculate.
“What’s not lucky is we need to take the old paths to get to Laketown and stay ahead of the orcs, and we can’t drag him along looking like that.” Dwalin grunted.
“So we leave him behind?” Ori cried aghast.
“We have to cross the lake eventually.” Nori pointed out. “We’d meet up with him before too long.”
“No one is leaving anyone behind!” Thorin interrupted the conversation with a growl.
“Lad,” Balin sighed. “You know as well as I do that we’re not going to be able to swim across the Long Lake. We’re going to have to leave the riverside in order to find the path into Esgaroth.”
Thorin looked torn, and Bilbo hated the fact that he put him in this position. However, he didn’t feel confident in splitting up from the group. What if something happened to them and Bilbo wasn’t there? What if they were captured by the elves again? What if Bilbo had another transformation and drowned by himself with none of them knowing what happened to him? He said none of this though as he stared at Thorin’s conflicted expression. Dwalin was right. He couldn’t let them stay and get hunted down by the orcs that were surely following them as they tried to argue over his fate.
“Thorin.” He brought the dwarf’s attention back to him. “If…if splitting up is going to be easy on you all…”
“No!” Thorin snapped. “I won’t hear anymore of it.”
“I bet we can find some way to make a litter and carry the hobbit.” Gloin pointed out. “Wouldn’t be any different than when we carried Bombur!”
There were several opinions on that. Some in favor, and some opposed.
“Um?” Ori tried to catch their attention.
Thorin and Dwalin, in particular, were having a rather heated discussion over whether they could find their way into Laketown by sticking close to the river or not when Ori tried to interrupt again.
“Excuse me…”
Bilbo turned his head to Ori, his eyes caught watching something over the ridge. Bilbo followed his gaze in that direction as well only to see a man appear with his bow drawn.
“Thorin!” Bilbo shouted.
“What?” The dwarf demanded.
Bilbo pointed the man out. Thorin turned, immediately taking a step to put himself between the man and Bilbo. All the company noticed at this point, and slowly touched their weapons.
“Draw your blades, and you’re dead.” The man threatened, loosing an arrow that hit the cup Kili had pulled over his head as if to throw.
Everyone remained on guard after that, respecting the accuracy of the mysterious archer. Balin was the first to break the tension as he approached cautiously, his hands held up to show he meant no harm.
“Pardon me, but that barge there. It wouldn’t be for hire, would it?”
The man smirked. “So you can kill me and dump my body overboard at your earliest convenience? I’ll pass.”
“You misunderstand.” Balin insisted. “We are simple merchants from the Blue Mountains, journeying to see our kin in the Iron Hills.”
The man slowly lowered his bow, looking over at the barrels with a raised eyebrow.
“Simple merchants, you say? Yet I can see that you had an unfortunate run-in with the King of the Woodland Realm.”
“What of it?” Thorin demanded.
“All of the Master of Laketown’s wealth comes from trade with King Thranduil. He won’t risk that for thirteen dwarves.”
The man frowned, trying to peek over Thorin’s shoulder at Bilbo, but he ducked down as far as he could in the water.
“I’ll wager there are ways to enter the town unseen.” Balin remarked.
The man smirked and shrugged. “Aye, and for that you would need a smuggler.”
“For which we would pay. Double.” Balin insisted.
He finally looked like he was at least starting to take them seriously. The dwarves helped load up the barrels on the barge as Balin and the man haggled over the details. He wanted confiscation of their weapons, at least until they entered Laketown. The dwarves were very off put by this but eventually loaded their things into the barrels as a show of good faith. Thorin remained next to Bilbo with his arms crossed.
“You’ll be able to keep up with us?” He asked.
Bilbo nodded. “I think so. Unless of course, I transform again.”
“If that’s the case, I will come in after you.” Thorin promised with a smirk.
Bilbo felt himself flush and he ducked down a little further in the water to hide his pleased grin.
“What do you think of our smuggler?” Thorin asked him, following the man with his eyes.
Bilbo turned his gaze onto him as well. “I think we can trust him, but I also think we don’t have much of a choice.”
Thorin sighed. “So it seems.”
“Master Dwarf!” The man called over to Thorin. “Are you ready to shove off?”
Bilbo saw his eyes widen, and Bilbo quickly ducked down below the waves. He couldn’t be sure if he saw him or not, but he thought it would be a good idea to remain hidden in case he was needed again. Thorin gave him a long look that Bilbo couldn’t make out from below the surface before he stomped towards the barge.
Now that he wasn’t swimming for his life, it really wasn’t that bad being half-fish. He was aware it was cold, but it wasn’t biting in the same way he would imagine if he were still in his hobbit form. He passed other fish, some big and some small, that seemed to pay him no mind. He attempted to talk to them just to see if he could, but it turned out he did not gain that ability as well.
Following the barge was relatively easy, and every once in a while, a hand would appear off the side that Bilbo just knew was Thorin checking in on him. He grasped the hand tightly before letting go, and it seemed to satisfy Thorin as the hand would disappear moments later.
The one time he actually poked his head up was due to hearing Bofur shout. The bargeman’s head spun around to him, and Bilbo quickly ducked back down again. He made sure he was out ahead of the barge away from the man’s sight when he slowly poked his head up to listen.
“You were paid to get us safely to Laketown, not hunt down some fisherman’s myth.” Thorin growled.
“I’m telling you what I saw.” The bargeman shot back. “I’ve been born and bred on these waters, and I’ve never seen anything like that! It could be dangerous.”
“It could be friendly.” Ori argued.
“That’s not a risk I’m willing to take.”
Bilbo realized the bargeman was gearing up to grab his arrows and start shooting as soon as he got through these rocks, so Bilbo decided it would be in their best interest to beat him to the punch. As soon as they were in the clear, he pulled himself up to hang against the side of the barge, holding his hand out for the surprised man.
“Uh, how do you do? My name is Bilbo Baggins.”
The man stared at Bilbo skeptically before turning to the dwarves and noting their tense positions as he turned back to Bilbo. He slowly shook Bilbo’s hand.
“Bard. I take it you are with these dwarves?”
“Yes, I’m a member of the company.”
“And what manner of beast are you exactly?”
“Well I must say that’s quite a rude question. I am a hobbit of course.”
Bard snorted in spite of himself and Bilbo grinned in victory.
“Can’t say I’ve ever heard of a hobbit. My people call yours ‘mermaids’.”
“Oh! Well, I must confess I don’t normally look like this. In fact, the fishtail is rather new.”
“Really?” Bard asked, raising an eyebrow.
Bilbo opened his mouth to explain the situation when Thorin cut him off.
“That’s enough, Bilbo.”
Bilbo tried not to shoot him a glare. He was just being friendly. It wasn’t like he was about to tell Bard of their quest.
“In any case, I will be following along. Please don’t shoot me.”
With that, Bilbo disappeared back below the waves. It seemed not a moment too soon, as the massive rock structures of fallen kingdoms long ago gave way to wooden man-made docks. Bilbo had to duck completely under the barge in order to avoid the hooks and lines dotting the water. That’s all he needed, to be strung up as someone’s latest ‘big fish’ story.
The barge pulled up against the dock and rocked just slightly as if someone were getting off. Bilbo saw boots walking along the dock and followed, curious as to what was going on. He poked his head out when the boots stopped only to gag at the smell. Rotten fish permeated the air and it made Bilbo want to dive back down where his nose was more ineffective. For his dwarves’ sake, he needed to hear what was happening, though.
It was some sort of transaction. Bard was talking about fish and pointing towards his barge. Bilbo suddenly had a horrifying idea of how Bard was about to smuggle his dwarves into town, and couldn’t find them to be too enthused about it. Sure enough, he watched Bard give the man some coin and shake his hand as he then called out to the rest of the dock. For fish.
Bilbo quickly swam back towards the barge to warn the company, only for his jacket to get caught on a hook. He struggled to get untangled as the man who had caught him shouted above. There was no helping it. Bilbo slipped his arms out of the jacket only remembering at the last moment, his ring was in the pocket. The jacket was jerked up and into the boat before Bilbo could do anything about it. He cursed under his breath. There was only one thing for it.
Bilbo popped out of the water, snatching the jacket out of the stunned man’s hands.
“Do you mind?” He snapped before disappearing back below the waves.
The screams and shouts that followed him were actually a little humorous, more so after he checked his pocket to find the ring was, in fact, still there. The relief coursed through him like a visible, tangible thing as he ran his finger over the smooth metal. He was not about to lose that, clever and useful as it was. The barge was starting to pull away and Bilbo quickly swam up to its side. Bard was smirking when he poked his head up.
“They’re going to be telling stories of mermen for the next three generations. At least.”
“Well, they wouldn’t exactly be wrong.”
Bard gave a small chuckle. “Now comes the hard part.”
Bilbo looked ahead, aghast at the city of wood built right there upon the lake. Didn’t men have better sense than to live on a lake?! He could see they were coming to a gate though, and ducked back down to hide from view. The barge was stopped, sitting still in the water as Bard talked to the man on the dock in charge of opening the gate. It was rather boring, if Bilbo were being perfectly honest. Sitting down here under the water. He wanted to know what was going on. ‘Tookish curiosity’ his Baggins’ relatives would call it. However, it did intune him to the best gossip that they were happy to listen to so he wasn’t quite sure what they were complaining about. Deciding he couldn’t handle another minute hiding down here, he carefully peeked up over the edge of the boat only to gasp at what he saw.
There were guards headed towards his dwarves in the barrels as probably the ugliest man Bilbo had ever seen was explaining to Bard how it was illegal for Bard to bring fish in for some reason. Bilbo felt like he had to do something. He dove back down under the boat and pushed against it as hard as he could. The first shove did nothing. The second shove, he really rammed his shoulder into it, crying out as the boat began to rock. Gingerly holding his shoulder, he surfaced again to see if it worked. Indeed, the guards were tripping over themselves to remain standing.
“What’s this now?” The ugly man demanded, his gaze accusing as he glared at Bard.
“And what could I have possibly done?” Bard complained. “Perhaps the fish object to you tossing the dead ones back in. I know the people will.”
“Not my problem.” The man growled.
“And when the rioting starts?” Bard pressed. “Will it be your problem then?”
That seemed to stop the man as he glared coldly at Bard.
“Ever the people’s champion, eh Bard? You would do well to remember, we know where you live!”
Bilbo had simply had enough of this man. He dove to the other side of the boat towards the dock. He raised his big fin above the water and slapped it back down causing a spray to coat the ugly man. Bilbo popped back up on the other side near Bard who looked down at him with a smirk.
“I told you the fish objected!” He called out to the man who was still sputtering and complaining over his impromptu bath.
Bilbo felt quite pleased with himself even as Bard felt the need to warn him once they were far enough away.
“You’re going to draw some unwanted attention to yourself if you keep that up.”
Bilbo scolded. “He absolutely deserved it. I couldn’t stand listening to him for another moment.”
“You and me both.”
Bilbo did have to dive back down once they were in the town proper due to all the people walking the docks or fishing from boats in the middle of the water. When Bard finally stopped, he watched as the boat rocked and assumed he was getting the dwarves free. A hand in the water confirmed his suspicions and Bilbo quickly swam forward to give it a quick squeeze. Rather than releasing him, Thorin went ahead and pulled on his hand indicating he wanted him to surface.
“Bard is going to get us to his house.” Thorin explained, “But I don’t know how you are meant to follow.”
“I’ll watch your boots from under the docks.” Bilbo decided.
“Hurry!” Bard hissed at Thorin. “We’ll have to be quick if we want to avoid the guards.”
Thorin gave Bilbo a long look before nodding.
“Go. And be safe.”
Bilbo dove back under the water, becoming rather at home down below the waves. It smelt better at least as he watched the dock making sure he counted thirteen pairs of dwarven boots before he followed after them. There were a lot of pauses, quickened steps, and then pausing again. Bilbo couldn’t imagine how they were managing. Dwarves weren’t exactly known for being sneaky after all. It wasn’t until they came to a large structure that Bilbo lost them.
The structure was blocking out the light, and it became harder to watch their boots. But there wasn’t any movement coming or going…except for a large group of humans walking towards the structure. Bilbo hated not knowing. It wasn’t like he could just flip himself up on the deck though. He pushed himself up as far as he could trying to hear through the floorboards, but couldn’t get anything more than vague thumps. Bilbo flicked his tail as he swam up ahead. He would just take a peak and…suddenly they were on the move again and Bilbo could feel himself sink in relief.
Actually, he was sinking from more than just relief. Bilbo looked down at his hands just catching the start of the golden sparkles. Bilbo felt the cold crashing down on him. It was too soon, wasn’t it?! It was becoming hard to wiggle his fin, and breathing suddenly became a challenge. He started swimming as fast as he could to the surface. He launched himself up on top of the nearest dock even as his fish end trying to drag him back into the water. Bilbo clawed at the boards, as the fin gave way to hobbit legs once more.
“THORIN!”
Whatever this new transformation was, it made Bilbo’s body grow heavier and heavier as more of him dipped back into the water. He was clutching the edge of the plank at this point when he knew he couldn’t hold on for another moment. He had just enough time to take a deep breath before he was pulled back under the water. Only this time, he wasn’t able to breathe, he wasn’t able to swim, and no amount of flailing was keeping him afloat. He saw a dark shape dive into the water, trying to get to him. Bilbo held out his hand towards the shape, and Thorin grabbed onto him.
Thorin got his hands under Bilbo’s armpits and tried pulling him up only for both of them to keep traveling down. Bilbo felt his eyes go wide as his lungs began to burn. What if he was the opposite of weightless? What if he was impossibly heavy?
Thorin wasn’t giving up, kicking and fighting, he was doing everything in his power to pull them away from the inky darkness below. Bilbo could feel the burn in his lungs at the desperate need for air, and knew Thorin mst be feeling the same. He wasn’t about to let Thorin drown for his sake. He allowed himself one last touch as his hand cupped Thorin’s cheek and he gave him a grim smile. Thorin’s gaze was horrified as he shook his head, but Bilbo’s mind was made up.
He started trying to pull himself from Thorin’s grasp even as the dwarf tried to tighten his hold. Bilbo managed to pull most of himself away. Thorin held tight to his hand, still shaking his head as Bilbo opened his mouth to tell him goodbye. Right before he could let go though, four other shapes suddenly jumped into the water above them. Dwalin, Bifur, Gloin, and Dori grabbed onto them both, and between the dwarves combined strength were able to pull them back to the surface.
So eager to take a breath, Bilbo hadn’t quite breached the water before he sucked in a lungful. Water and air filled his mouth in equal measure as he coughed and hacked, choking on the water he tried to dispel from his body. He felt more than watched the dwarves up on the walkway reach down to help pull him up. His vision dancing in little sparks of light over the near death experience of almost drowning. They were pretty. Like looking through a gem. He was set down on all fours on the dock, his elbows bracing him as Oin pat his back in an attempt to help him breathe quicker. Bilbo noticed the sparks of light were still there. What were they exactly?
He drew in great lungfuls of air, panting and wheezing in equal measure, but finally feeling like he wasn’t about to die anymore. He pulled himself to his knees and looked up only to be greeted with thirteen dwarven stares and one mannish one. All in various degrees of awe and shock. Bilbo groaned as he shook his head.
“Whatever it is, I don’t want to know.”
