Sorry, you need to have JavaScript enabled for this.

Actions

Work Header

hardest hue to hold

Summary:

Blue were the flowers Belladonna stitched onto the corners of his jacket — one on the left pocket, three on the right — before taking him to the fireworks. The jacket itself had been red, naturally, because red was a proper Baggins colour: sensible, yet quite enjoyable, evoking autumn leaves, ripe apples, and — purely in Bilbo’s mind — ladybugs.

He tore it apart an hour later, chasing after one.

***

A concept fic based on my obsession with Thorin and Bilbo exchanging colours (the Laketown matching cloaks being the prime example), except I've pushed it a bit further.

Notes:

I mix the book and the films, so any inconsistencies you might spot are most likely due to that! Still, feel free to reach out if it looks like something needs to be corrected.

(See the end of the work for more notes.)

Work Text:

Blue

Blue were the flowers Belladonna stitched onto the corners of his jacket — one on the left pocket, three on the right — before taking him to the fireworks. The jacket itself had been red, naturally, because red was a proper Baggins colour: sensible, yet quite enjoyable, evoking autumn leaves, ripe apples, and — purely in Bilbo’s mind — ladybugs.

He tore it apart an hour later, chasing after one.

Red

was Bungo’s sweater, far too large for Bilbo unless three extra layers filled the space beneath.He kept it on the night when the Horn-call of Buckland rang out[0]. He pleaded with Bungo to let him go with him, but his father made sure they stayed home, he and Belladonna — together. That night Bilbo curled into the wool, eyes squeezed shut, hands over ears, desperately trying to smoother the howls that reached the hill. Bungo returned home with the dawn. Many didn't. 

Even after the winter bared its teeth one last time and retreated, Bilbo refused to let go of the sweater, wearing it faithfully until it slowly unravelled, thread by thread.

Red

and blue

were the anemones he brought to the funeral. Roses, of course, had already arrived in armfuls: the Gamgees came first, followed by many others. But Bilbo went into the woods alone that evening, wandering half-forgotten trails until he lost his way entirely. He returned home at dawn, with hands scratched by blackberry thorns, two lost buttons, and a bunch of greenery. The anemones were his adventure trophy, wild and beautiful.

They were also what Belladonna Took would have picked to weave a wreath that Bungo Baggins would have worn proudly.

Blue

was the mark Gandalf the Grey scrawled on his freshly painted door, shattering Bilbo's most ordinary morning and Bilbo's most ordinary life. 

The dwarf who missed it twice had a bright blue cloak and eyes to match. There were many things to blame for awakening the Took in Bilbo that evening: the insistent wizard, the map, and the song, of course. But he himself knew it was that colour, restless and daring, that finally pried his feet off the doorstep.

Red 

was the berry wine of Rivendell — light, sweet and much stronger than it seemed. It must have had some enchantment in it, because Bilbo was enchanted, and could not in his right mind bring himself to retire while the songs still flowed through the evening air. They had long since faded by the time he woke in an armchair, the fire had burned low, and for a brief moment he thought he was home.

Elrond Peredhel had eyes of salt-washed grey, as though the first sight he had ever glimpsed was the cold sea before the gale[1]. He sat with Bilbo through the quiet grey hours before dawn, speaking gently, as if small Shirefolk deeds mattered greatly, which was a welcome change after the past few weeks. Somehow the valley became Bilbo’s to stay in, and he promised himself he would, someday. But that day he pulled up the hood of his cloak and walked on along the narrow mountain path.

Blue 

flickered across the blade of a letter-opener Bilbo found in the trolls’ cave. It was the first thing he saw when he woke in a dark tunnel after falling from Dori’s shoulders, and it was deeply unsettling, to say the least. Its absence was sorely felt, though, when he riddled with a slick, unpleasant creature which called itself Gollum. Scrambling up the hillside, overjoyed to leave the dark passages of the Misty Mountains behind, Bilbo thought about naming his sword — yes, sword — but didn't. The right name came many days later. 

Red 

was fire. Bilbo was terrified of it, of course he was. But when the howls pierced the night, the word fell short, for this time nothing stood between him and the teeth in the dark. Had he been able to loosen his grip on the pine branch, he would have covered his ears and pretended none of it was real.

But then came the orc. 

And Thorin Oakenshield rose to face him. Red became snarling, wet jaws closing around Thorin’s throat, and Bilbo had no time to think, no chance to feel, no right to hesitate. He let go of the branch; his hand found his sword, and the world went very quiet.

Blue 

was the colour of Durin’s folk.

Bilbo first learned that by the fire at the foot of Carrock. He learned other things too —of Azanulbizar, of old mountain halls and long years in the Ered Luin, and of days longer before, when the Blue Mountains were yet unbroken. There was more still he had not heard, but what he had was more than Thorin had shared in all the weeks before. It was an unexpected discovery — though hardly an unwelcome one — that, with the tension between them gone, Thorin Oakenshield did not seem to mind long conversations that lasted well into the night and kept them by the fire long after everyone else had gone to sleep.

Red 

was the warmest of Beorn’s blankets, drawn close about Thorin’s shoulders. Gandalf had warned them that hasty healing could have consequences, but none foresaw a fever so fierce it nearly felled Thorin upon entering Beorn’s hall.

The first night passed in fragments. When Thorin woke, Bilbo Baggins pressed a cup of linden brew or thin broth into his hands; when he drifted again, Bilbo kept watch, stirring honey into a huge teapot and dozing only at dawn. Morning at first promised better fortune — Thorin rose unaided and managed a few bites of flatbread — but by the afternoon the fever returned, swift and sharper than before. Thorin, of course, would not utter a word of complaint, but it was obvious he could not even lie still, tossing and turning as though trying to outrun his own skin. The cloth on his forehead soon turned warm in a matter of minutes. Bilbo dipped it into the basin of cold water and laid it gently back in place and then — surprising them both — began to speak softly, reciting the first lines of an old Shire tale about a water-spirit living in the mill pond[2]. Thorin did not bid him cease. Bit by bit, his breathing steadied.

The next time Thorin woke, there were a few moments of expectant silence before he asked, with feigned indifference, what became of the miller’s daughter. Bilbo smiled and traded the ending for another cup of honeyed tea, and so it went. Whenever the fever rose, Bilbo was at his bedside, spinning every tale he had ever heard as a child — from Yuletide fright-tales to short poems Belladonna Took would make up whenever the mood took her — until, just before the third dawn, Thorin slipped into a deep, steady sleep, and the blanket lay cool against his skin.

Blue 

cloak among prisoners’ belongings was Bilbo’s only proof Thorin had been taken, too. 

Red

was the ivy curled over the gates of the Elvenking’s halls. And the leaves in his crown. It was only a matter of time, finding Thorin and getting them all out of Mirkwood for good, only a matter of time.

The autumn deepened. Bilbo learned every corridor of Thranduil’s realm, memorised the guards by name and face, and spent hours in the dungeons speaking with every member of the Company — no one knew what became of Thorin. 

Autumn deepened, turning the ivy darker. Hope began to thin.

Blue 

was the first true colour Bilbo had seen in weeks. He had not even noticed the ring’s strange bleaching effect, not until he took it off and the world rushed back at him, sharp and near.

Or perhaps it wasn’t the ring at all. Perhaps it was simply seeing Thorin again, alive and unharmed. And the look on his face when Bilbo stepped out of the shadows into the dark cellar, stumbling to the bars and reaching through them, made every grim moment before that worth enduring.

Red 

cinders smouldered in the hearth. The last day in Esgaroth held no peace: from his place in the common room, Bilbo had already watched Dwalin lecture Kili on his excessive flair with a sword, Oin mutter to himself a list of burn remedies, and Fili lace and unlace his bracers no fewer than five times. Then Balin appeared and, for reasons Bilbo had no intention of guessing, suggested he review the contract and put his affairs in order.

Bilbo could recall the word incineration perfectly well without revisiting anything, thank you very much. And while he wasn’t in danger of fainting this time, he had just enough to firmly order everyone out and off to their rooms for the night.

So when Thorin returned from his meeting with the Master of Lake-town long past midnight and, without so much as a greeting, blurted out, “I am not certain I’ll see another night, so I would rather say this now,” Bilbo only let out a groan and buried his face in a pillow.

Thorin’s plan wasn’t going to work anyway — Bilbo’s hair still wasn’t long enough for a braid. So they spent the better part of an hour going back and forth over every possible custom that might suffice, Shire and Erebor alike. But there were no flowers here in Winterfilth, no ribbons in the Mountains, and no one could find a gift worth giving, especially with half of their belongings lost in Mirkwood. It was not, by any measure, going well.

That was, until Bilbo remembered Thorin speaking once of family colours. The suggestion, unfortunately, made something shift in Thorin’s face in a way quite opposite to what Bilbo had hoped to see. The royal blue, he said, was not yet his to offer, not until the Mountain was reclaimed and the crown was his by right. Bilbo kept his thoughts on that to himself, though there were many. Instead, he let out a breath and sent a slow ring of smoke curling toward the ceiling, then rolled over to meet Thorin’s gaze, storm-dark and brooding.

“Well. In that case, you might like to know that Baggins is a very respectable name. And we’ve a few traditions of our own.”

He paused, watching Thorin across the narrow distance between them. 

“How do you feel about red?”

Blue 

shadows spilled across the rock face beneath the crescent moon. Speckled shards of a snail shell glinted on the stone, and in that moment Bilbo knew — a heartbeat before the keyhole revealed itself in the moonlight, he knew. He wasn’t making much sense when he called out, barely able to form a thought, but thankfully Thorin didn’t need much. He stepped back at the sound of Bilbo’s voice, and with that everything sprang into motion; the next thing Bilbo knew, they were standing before the black hollow of the door. 

The quest was nearing its end. The last threshold stood before him, and he was about to cross it.

Alone.

Red

was absent in only one place. In an elusive, hidden, single patch to the left of Smaug’s chest. Bilbo prayed to Yavanna with everything he had that somehow, against all odds, that would be enough.

Blue 

was the colour of Durin’s folk. 

Which Bilbo would have never guessed now, standing before the King Under the Mountain, draped in gilded armour, crowned in gold, cloaked in cloth threaded through with fire-bright strands. Even the beads in Thorin’s hair had changed, silver traded for gold and rubies. Nausea rose in Bilbo’s throat at the thousand mirrored gleams, the weightless glare of it all. Thorin was swallowed whole by splendour, and Bilbo, once brave enough to steal from a dragon, could not bring himself to meet his eyes. 

Red 

was the tip of Bofur’s pipe, a lone ember against the watchtower dark. Somewhere beyond the valley, fires burned in the camps of elves and men. Bilbo had never lived through a siege before, but this feeling — the strained hush of a moonless night, breath fogging in the air, the slow weight of snow burying stone and field alike — this he knew.

When Bofur left him alone, Bilbo cinched his jacket tighter, checked every knot twice, and let the rope slip over the edge. Five hours remained until the next watch — five hours to make his way down the slope, cross the Celduin, and find Bard among the tents, if luck was with him.

The wind keened low through the stones, and for a moment, Bilbo shut his eyes. Then he stepped forward — feet slipping for a heartbeat on the rimed ledge, rope biting into his palm — and the snowfall drowned him, like it once drowned the hills and burrows.

Blue 

were Thorin Oakenshield’s eyes, and Bilbo had never learned to fear them.

Not even now, when his back struck stone, weightless mail shifting against his ribs. The world around him — the commotion of the Company, the rumble of armies at the gates — faded, narrowed to Thorin’s face and the sharp air atop the ramparts. The wind caught in his hair. Bilbo wasn’t afraid. How absurd would it be to survive goblins, outwit spiders, and outlive a dragon, only to die here, looking up at the face he could barely recognise, twisted with pain and disgust. Bilbo had to bite down on the laughter rising in his throat.

Had he ever told anyone how funerals were held in the Shire? Would they bury him with his sword, as in the old tales? That was probably a moment for his last words. He would prefer Sting to not rot in the soil. He would prefer many things. Was he to say something to Thorin now, to try and stop his hands? Find the right word? He tried words. He tried all of them, he tried pleas and promises, and none had reached Thorin. 

Perhaps none could. Perhaps it would take something else. And if so, Bilbo could make his peace with it. The only thing left to do was to allow himself to laugh, after all, just so that the last thing Thorin remembered would be something kind, something to soften the inevitable weight of realisation. 

His plan was ruined by Gandalf, like many other plans did. The next moment Bofur’s hands were on Bilbo’s shoulders, the familiar rope was shoved into his grasp, hooves echoed down the stone, and—

and the battle Bilbo had been ready to die to prevent had begun.

Red 

cloaks from Lake-town lay scattered across the ruins of Dale, covering the faces,

and Blue 

was the sky above them.

Red 

was the sweep of Tauriel’s hair as she ran past him,

and Blue 

were Thorin’s eyes when Bilbo found him at the Ravenhill. In time. Alive, unharmed, familiar, in time, thank Valar, in time.

Red

was the flash when the stone struck his temple, just before the world turned dark,

then Blue 

was ice,

and Red

was blood. A lot of it. So much of it, too much of it, spilling hot and fast through his fingers no matter how tightly he pressed, no matter how steady his voice was when he begged — ordered — Thorin to hold on. 

Blue

Blue was eldritch lamplight, shivering against canvas walls, a weak barrier against the night’s restless sounds. Footsteps rushed past, voices whispered urgent and low, punctuated by muted cries of pain. The scent of boiled willow-bark filled the air. A dull ache had settled deep between Bilbo’s shoulder blades, and he could barely move his neck without a wave of pain. Wax dripped to the edge of the table, melting the minutes away — excruciatingly long, endless minutes. Eight candles were gone. His eyelids kept drifting shut, but each time they sagged he jerked upright, fingers tightening around Thorin’s wrist. He could not let himself miss anything, because what if—

What if he missed something last?

Red 

crept through fresh bandages. Someone dropped the basin; hands gently pushed Bilbo back, and hurried orders snapped through the air in Khuzdûl and Sindarin alike. Bilbo staggered outside and coughed, choking on cold air. When another healer rushed in and closed the heavy tent-flaps behind him, Bilbo took a few unsteady steps away from it and collapsed entirely. Snow stung his palms as he knelt and let the tears spill down his face.

For the first and only time.

Blue

were gentiana's petals steeping in a copper pot. Steam curled upward, sharp with root-bitterness and the sting of crushed pine resin. Bilbo’s knuckles ached from hours spent cutting and grinding, the scent soaked permanently into his sleeves.

The healers called the third night the first threshold, deciding whether things would get better or worse. That had passed. So had the seventh. Today was the tenth day: the last of the turning-point nights was now gone.

Thorin did not wake.

Red 

was the setting sun. Bilbo had ceased his whispered pleas days ago; and now found himself wishing for nothing but certainty, even if it meant any certainty. Because he could not possibly face another night of not knowing. Yet, when a tired healer approached, finding him midway to the tent with an armful of clean linens, Bilbo froze, ice-sharp dread slicing through his chest.

Not yet.

Please, not yet.

The elf, with lines etched softly around her eyes — lines Bilbo had never seen on her kin — paused at a respectful distance, as if afraid to come closer. Everybody seemed to be walking on eggshells around him lately. 

Bilbo shut his eyes, counted — five — six — seven — and forced himself to straighten his spine. 

“Tell me.”

Blue

and red 

were the anemones in Bilbo’s wreath. It was a beautiful day, warm and gentle, and he was rather pleased with himself for slipping away from the unending stream of congratulations before they could dull the lightness in his chest. He hadn’t, however, accounted for the fact that Kings under the Mountain do not get to do the same, so he now lay on his back in the meadow alone, biting the end off a green stem and basking, watching the clouds drift by.

“You were harder to find than I expected.”

Bilbo opened one eye. Thorin stood over him, the ceremonial robe still draped across his shoulders, its corners newly stitched with tiny blue flowers where golden patterns had once been.

“Well, it’s something of a gift,” Bilbo murmured. “Helped me survive many family gatherings. And some other occasions.”

“Indeed. You will have to teach me your mastery.” Thorin dropped to the ground beside him, exhaling as though something long held tight had finally been released.

Bilbo hummed, not bothering to look this time. “Maybe I w—”

Before he could finish, the ground vanished beneath him. Bilbo’s eyes flew open, and he let out a startled yelp as his world flipped — sky replaced by a face, close and bright and far too amused.

“You ruined my wreath,” Bilbo informed him, fingers settling more securely on Thorin’s wrist, right where the red ribbon encircled it.

Thorin laughed. 

“I’ll make you a new one,” he said. “These flowers grow wild here come spring. Look.”

He reached past Bilbo’s shoulder, plucked one, and tucked it behind his ear. The breeze stirred the grass; sunlight caught in Thorin’s hair and lit the edge of his smile.

Far beyond the green slopes, the bells of Dale began to ring, steady in the wind.

 

Notes:

0This refers to the Fell Winter (T.A. 2911–2912), when the Hobbits were attacked by white wolves that crossed the frozen Brandywine River. Bilbo was around 22 at the time. [return to text]

1If you want to nerd out: Bilbo might be right here, because Elrond was, in fact, born in the Havens of Sirion, being one of the two sons of Elwing the White and Eärendil the Mariner (more commonly known as a bird and a star). [return to text]

2See "The Little Water Sprite" by Otfried Preußler :) [return to text]