Actions

Work Header

Rating:
Archive Warning:
Categories:
Fandom:
Relationships:
Characters:
Additional Tags:
Language:
English
Series:
Part 2 of Monkeyshines
Stats:
Published:
2025-02-08
Completed:
2025-05-23
Words:
129,496
Chapters:
17/17
Kudos:
358
Hits:
0

A Fool's Errand

Chapter 13: Upon the Snow

Summary:

Everyone (or, almost everyone) actually communicates, some grieve for others needlessly, and one determined little creature starts making his way South.

Notes:

A bit of a shorter one, this time. It was really quite difficult to write, being so communication- and dialogue-heavy. It's fresh out of the metaphorical oven (and physical heater) which is my poor old laptop, so if you spot any mistakes, lemme know!

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

Blood covered the snow as a thrush flitted through the bitter air, fleeing for its life. Below, tents were set up upon the fields between Erebor and Dale, and minute figures flowed from white to blue to yellow to green, rushing from tent to tent as though the cloth itself was trying to eat them. Upon the battlefield were hundreds, thousands of bodies, blood both black and brick in colour, innumerable and still and terrible.
The bird had first stopped upon a river long iced-over, kneeling over a body he never thought he’d see. He’d taken his time to mourn, but it had been cut short, a tall figure arriving just barely after he got away. All he had to show for it was a knife from his mother’s glory-box. How it got there, he knew not – but he would not take it for granted, and was thankful for its presence, despite his confusion.
Now, the thrush flew against the wind, rising and falling at its whims. He flew, for fear and for love, having lost all in the tides of war. A family left behind, either dead or alive, though he knew not which, nor did he know which would be worse: them being dead, or very much alive, and quite possibly after his head.
It was all or nothing now, and a whisper filtered into his mind, despite his efforts to keep it silenced.

 

–x–x–x–

 

Meneldor’s large wings flapped once again, though this one was jittery where they were normally smooth, shaking with trepidation or another emotion. The motion stirred Elrond from his half-sleep – not that it had done him any good, anyway, for Elves need to be fully tranquil to experience rest in the way Mortals do. Elrond was everything but relaxed. His sons were headed to their deaths, his daughter was walking a thin line, and his vision haunted him more with each and every wingbeat, bringing him ever closer to the truth. Was it precautionary? Or was it solidified, set in stone by actions already put into motion?

A solitary peak arose upon the horizon; on the grasses below were hundreds of tents, small shadows moving between them like a kicked anthill, each one busy and speeding to their destinations. Among the clouds, several shapes came into view, circling around them and trilling – the Eagles were joined once again. Elrond would see at least one happy reunion today, though he felt it would be the only completion anyone this side of the Misty Mountains would feel until the sun set and rose again.
“Take me down?” he asked Meneldor, who chirped calmly, and began a twirling descent. Eagles are, by no means, silent; in fact, they’re quite loud birds, as evidenced by the upturn of hundreds of faces towards them while Meneldor continued the descent. He landed softly in dewy grass which crunched unhealthily beneath his talons – watered by something not so pure, much more thick and viscous. They were within walking distance of the tents, but far enough that none would be disrupted by the power such a large wingspan could create – and far enough to keep Meneldor safe. Giant birds are not common in these parts, and for good reason.

Elrond thanked Meneldor, patting the Eagle’s side before he launched himself back into the air, ready to land again if he was needed, but far away enough that no one could bother him or be bothered by him. Cool mist formed before his face as he breathed, and it was with a start that Elrond realised just how cold it was; white smoke steamed seamlessly from everyone’s lips, releasing into the air as it devoured their heat like it was trying to warm itself. Many were wrapped in thick clothing, and those who weren’t were bundled up in layers upon layers of thinner fabrics, stacking them up to increase their insulation. Few walked about with anything but their faces and hands showing, and even fewer walked around with un-rosied cheeks or stiffened limbs. The few who cared to watch the Elf who had arrived by Eagle stared, jaws agape and eyebrows raised, as if expecting some sort of mythical god to appear. Most carried on with their tasks, rushing about to assist the wounded and accompany the dying. There were many of those here; people who had seen many things, and been through too much – those who died on the battlefield hadn’t yet been grieved, and still people were dying. Wounds, infections, blood loss – people too damaged to continue on with life, pushed even further into the pit by frigid temperatures and a lack of medical professionals. Healing fingers itched to assist, but he had a job to do; he knew not why, but Elrond found his mind steeling himself for whatever was to come. He knew it was important – it was the why that eluded him.

 

–x–x–x–

 

Flat white plains stretched on leagues beyond vision or comprehension, decorated only with vague shapes in its geometry, lumps indistinguishable from the invisible horizon. Every direction was nothing, and no direction existed. It smelled of nothing. No scents, no sounds, no textures or feelings or forces. Just a blank expanse. Nothingness, with a hint of white.

Despite the lack of direction, lack of sense, he kept walking, and turning, and looking around. Then, a voice infiltrated the silence, eradicating it from its unnatural existence.
“You’re not supposed to be here yet.”
A blond dwarf stared at him, face blank in both expression and features; slowly, as the world around them changed and formed a bubble around them, and the dwarf’s previously unadorned face came into view. It was unremarkable. He had thick eyebrows, which connected into a long, straight nose, either side of which were strong blue eyes, like the summer’s sky. His jaw was coated in a short, light beard – not unrespectable by any means, but definitively youthful in its lack of content. Only two beads adorned his hair, which was loose; both hung like windchimes from a braid behind his left ear, unmoving with the stale air, even within their bubble.
“No,” he responded, because he wasn’t.
“You don’t even know who I am.”
“Yes, I do.” He was sure he did.
“Who am I, then?”
“Frerin.”
Now, that’s a name he hadn’t heard in… how long had it been? At least a year. Maybe more. Frerin , here, in front of him, which meant-
Ah.
A slight smile crept up on his younger brother’s features, which turned into a smirk as he spoke.
“You’ve not a clue, brother, of Amad’s thoughts on your Quest. Amad wants to meet your Consort, so you’d better start praying Mahal will let him in, otherwise you’ll get your ears boxed when you do finally get here.” Frerin had, at some indeterminable point, started walking, and he’d started following. The words only caught up to him minutes – minutes? – later.
“Consort? I have taken no such relation.” He’d missed the way Frerin’s eyebrows rose above his hairline whenever he was shocked. Now it was happening, he wasn’t so sure.
“He saved your life. You gifted him Mithril, and spoke your inner name to him. That seems to me to be a marriage of Dwarven legend.”
He needed to sit down.
He could not feel his legs – hadn’t, since he’d been here – but he knew he needed to leave. He needed to run, he needed to find his Consort, to- his Consort .
“Brother, I have fallen in love.”
Frerin laughed as he booted his fool of a brother through a previously unnoticed door, summoned from the milky white around them.

 

Cold greys and browns filtered into view as his eyes roved around the room. The last thing he could remember was an Orc, pale in both colour and epithet, with a knife stabbed through his arm and his face contorted into a pain full of frothing anger rather than fear or an overwhelm of the physical sensation. No , his mind recalled. His vision was fuzzy, and he felt warm; in the depths of his memories was a blank slate, scrawled with cries from a horribly recognisable voice. What did he do? What had he done to create a sound so vile?
Grey shapes came into focus across from him slowly, unmoving as they were – the rest of the world swirled, but Tharkûn stood before him, still as mountains on the horizon. He was leaning heavily on his staff, and looked old, too old – wrinkles of worry and wrath lined his face like deep crevices in a long-droughted desert.
“You’d better have a good explanation for this,” he bit, venom dripping from his voice as the rage became cold, full of wretched misery.
Hidden by his blankets, Thorin only cried in anguish, a lament for a body he thought he’d never see.

 

–x–x–x–

 

Pain.
Pain unlike anything she’d ever experienced.
Pain like she was walking with her legs cut off.
Pain like she was drowning.

Emotions do not travel well in air. This is a well-known fact of the world. It is why so many Soulspeakers enjoyed open lands. It is also why many of them hated the sea.

Many times, growing up, Arwen was told, along with her brothers, of those who loathed the sea, and yet crossed it, only to end up in a place of amplified life, a place which existed to emulate the purity of it all. It suffocated them. They were in too deep, buried beneath mounds of healing and light, millenia of troubles both big and small. Arwen had never been told to forfeit Valinor, but she’d not exactly been incentivised to it – those of her kind who approached the gods got a quick and quipped ‘sorry, can’t do much about that’ and were sent on their way. Perhaps learning to heal wasn’t such a bad thing, if her heart kept tugging at her.
It felt heavy, as though it were made of wood rather than flesh, rotted and dead – except, it kept beating.

From a young age, she’d get rogue feelings; a bit of joy found in a food she didn’t recognise, a joke in a language she didn’t know, a laugh she’d never heard. A graze on the knee, a tear rolling down a child’s cheek, the loss of a loved one not loved by her. The list goes on and on; she learned how to listen, how to respond in kind. But that did not mean she liked it.

Pain was never fun, least of all when you didn’t know why.

 

–x–x–x–

 

Blankets, food, water – all necessary items for a wounded army, and all in short supply. Bard handed out what he could, but being one of only a few Humans – all either uninjured or dead – meant little for both Elves and Dwarves; they kept to themselves, usually, but in this mad frenzy of a war, had begun helping one another. He was pushed and pulled between groups of the two peoples, who avoided talking to each other like the plague, despite fighting back-to-back in battle as brethren. He didn’t understand it, but then again, he didn’t think they did, either.

“Thank you,” a Dwarf said gruffly, shuffling away to a group of the injured, spreading the blanket out among them. They piled together below it, sharing what heat they could retain. A sigh released itself from his mouth; it was tiring work, and would be until the cold receded, its invite rescinded by warmer months. Those warmer months were many moons away.

A flash of red hair whipping around tents caught his attention, and he suddenly wondered how his children were.
“‘Lo!” he called, his voice cracking with disuse. He hadn’t spoken much since the battle commenced, finding it pointless first amongst the shouts of warriors, then among their screams upon their victory. Despite his internal conflicts about how shouting was a less than impressive idea, the red-haired Elf turned around, and he knew she was the one he had been looking out for. She wore green, with an intricate-looking dagger attached to her back. As he walked over to her, he realised that her leather armour had twisting vine patterns embedded into it, made more obvious by the blood coagulated in the divots.
“You are the one who led the peoples of Laketown to safety, yes?”
“Yes,” she replied, surprise filtering onto her face for a second before it became entirely neutral again. It was almost uncanny how quickly Elves could contort their features. “Me and some of my Guard.”
“Thank you,” Bard sighed. “Are they safe?”
“Yes, they are safe, and they are well-fed,” the Elf answered, seemingly judging his questions before he asked them. “They will remain so until Laketown can get to its feet.”
Bard thanked her almost embarrassingly profusely; he was relieved beyond belief – his children were okay. They were going to be okay.

 

Another Elf arrived from the sky not too long afterwards. Elves today, it seemed, were quite large fans of dramatic entrances.

He walked to the edge of the camp before breathing deeply and visibly preparing himself – something the Mirkwood Elves did not often do. This one didn’t look like them; where the residents of Mirkwood were all blond hair and cold looks, this one had long hair of ebony, more tanned skin, and wore elegant armour above practically-cut robes. It was impressive how put-together he looked from the neck down – especially compared to his face, which was pale, wan, and weary, much like the rest of the camp.
His eyes drove over the tents, and caught Bard’s gaze, and the Elf’s face flickered for a moment into a strange, detached smile before returning to its morbid expression, recognition dawning on his face. Bard knew not what for, since he’d never met the Elf in his life.
Today was a day for the improbable, though, as the Elf drew towards him slowly, and stood silently with him for a few seconds. Then, he spoke.
“Could you take me to Mithrandir?”
His voice was like old family velvet, and he spoke words Bard did not understand. “Who?”
“Gandalf, the Grey Wizard,” the Elf corrected, shooting him an apologetic glance.
“And who are you?” Bard asked – yes, the Elf looked fancy, but that meant nothing in the face of a wizard.
“Forgive me my manners,” he said tiredly, “for it has been a long few days. My name is Elrond, Lord of Imladris, otherwise known better in Westron as Rivendell, the Last Homely House East of the Sea.”
Bard started to wish he hadn’t asked. The Elf appeared to be a lovely person, really, but there are some things which are too far beyond him. His life has started to feel like an exponentially-growing side quest in one of those poorly-written novels Sigrid was fond of.

He walked alongside the Elf towards one of the blue tents; there was no organisation in their layout, so they had to weave between tents of all colours and small clearings between large groups where the uninjured laid themselves down whenever they found the time to sleep. It had been no secret within the mish-mash camp that Gandalf – the Grey Pilgrim, as some further South call him – could almost always be found within the Dwarfking’s tent, staring at him like he was daring the King to wake up, and very much prepared to punt him back into sleep when he did.
As he and the Elf-Lord entered the tent, Gandalf barely moved, his eyes not leaving their sole target. Two younger-looking Dwarves were also in the tent, but were visited by doctors constantly as they slept, while the third – the King – was visited only by one, with the wizard… looking after the rest of his care, whatever that meant for him. The less Bard knew, the better.

Soon, the Lord Elrond nudged Gandalf, and Bard thought he was about to witness a murder; instead, the wizard launched himself at the Elf, holding his shoulders and speaking in hushed Elvish, like any within the room actually knew it. The Elf replied in equally as hushed tones, before recalling Bard’s presence and turning to thank the man. Probably to bid him his leave, as well, but before Bard could escape, the King awoke.

Blood still covered his hair, and the dirt was only superficially wiped from his face; Bard almost desperately hoped the rest of him wasn’t nearly so unclean. The Dwarfking muttered in Dwarvish, before blearily opening his eyes, staring Gandalf down for several seconds before another Dwarf burst into the tent, white hair sticking out in all directions like a child standing upright in a thunderstorm.
“Balin,” the Dwarfking choked, and the dwarf – Balin – nearly leapt over to him, after calling something in Dwarvish behind his back to the tent’s flap-door. Bard thought he could recall Balin being one of the more responsible ones.
“Thorin! Don’t try to speak, Óin would kill you if he-”
“You must bury me while I still yet breathe.”
…Okay, Bard could admit he’d heard some pretty odd things about Dwarves, but that was not one of them.
Balin seemed to think so too, since his reply was a one-worded, gobsmacked question.
“What?”
“I have killed my Consort, and so must be buried alive, as per Durin’s tradition. I heard him calling.”
“Consort?” Balin asked, and everyone within the tent was still; it was a very good question, indeed. Gandalf must have thought so, for he was the one to break the silence.
“You took a Consort ? Upon the Quest?” the wizard asked, a delicate balance between curious and enraged. In all honesty, Bard felt a little bit bad; while the Company had been staying at his house and travelling on his barge, the Hobbit had been the only one to talk to him properly, and had seemed quite enamoured with the King. Bard supposed he most likely didn’t retain those feelings now, after everything, but it did strike him as odd that, between then and now, the King had managed to both find and kill a Consort.
The black-haired dwarf turned his attention slowly back to Gandalf, and a look so pathetic it reminded Bard of a newborn kitten appeared on the King’s face.
“One of your very own suggestion.”
Gandalf looked as confused as Bard felt for all of a millisecond before whatever the Dwarf said seemed to click, and understanding dawned on his face. It was followed by rage.
“You killed my burglar?!”
“Master Baggins is dead?” Lord Elrond asked quietly, sounding far more fragile than Bard would expect of an Elf. His previously lightly-concerned expression dropped, a fragile upset lingering over his features, which appeared to grow older as the seconds passed by.
It was Balin’s and Bard’s turn to be confused.
“Bilbo’s not dead,” Balin stated, squinting between Dwarf, Wizard, and Elf. Bard found himself wanting to support the tired Dwarf. He had been fairly nice, after all.
“He’s right. Bilbo fought in the battle too, everyone saw.”
“There was no place for a creature so gentle on a field so bloody,” the King said softly, gazing at his hands as though they still carried the remnants of those he’s slain upon them.
“Try telling that to the poor bastards who have to clean up charred Orc,” Bard muttered; the downside of having made himself known is that he had, in fact, made himself known, and was reaping the consequences. Everyone turned to him, confusion highlighting their features.
“He was the dragon?” Balin asked, piecing it together quite easily. Bard wondered who Balin thought the dragon had been, if not Bilbo.
“Aye, of course.”
Lord Elrond very suddenly looked sick.
“Where is Bilbo now?” he asked, urgent and wide-eyed, a stark contrast to the tiredness with which he’d arrived just minutes before.
“I don’t know,” Bard answered honestly. He liked the little Hobbit, yes, but that did not make him his keeper.
“We must find him,” the Dwarfking stated, attempting to sit up; Balin pushed him back downwards easily, speaking firmly to him.
“When did you engage?”
“We did not court traditionally, but I spoke my inner name to him.”
Whatever that meant, Balin was taken aback, physically recoiling backwards and removing his hands from holding the Dwarf in a lying position. Gandalf and Lord Elrond seemed equally as flabbergasted, with the latter pushing his head forwards, and the former donning a smile that, had Bard been any braver of a Man, he would have called soppy.
“When?” Balin asked incredulously.
“He asked me my full name. It was when I gave him the Mithril coat.”
“You gave him what ?”
Bard had a very bad feeling about this. He didn’t know the intricacies of the Dwarven stock market, nor did he know much about forging, but he knew for a fact that Mithril – silver steel of the Dwarves – was a highly sought-after material, and incredibly valuable for its rarity.
The Dwarves continued in their back-and-forth, a painfully slow way of drawing information from the King.
“I’m afraid,” Balin sighed, holding his head in his hand and pinching the bridge of his nose, “that your marriage is completely valid, and that Bilbo is indeed your Consort… and, therefore, responsible for all of Erebor until you can lead again.”
“Sorry to interrupt,” Bard said, not really very sorry for interrupting. “But does Bilbo actually know you’re married?” Balin’s face dropped again, Gandalf and Lord Elrond sighed wearily, and Thorin short-circuited, a deep furrow appearing between his brow.
“I explained the intricacies of inner names to him.”
“Aye, that’s well and good, but does he know?”
“The lad’s right,” Balin heaved, inhaling and exhaling deeply to calm himself. Bard wondered how many international incidents the old Dwarf had dealt with or prevented due to the stupidity of those above him. “We’ve no way of knowing if Bilbo is aware of your marriage at all, but either way, he’s officially the King Consort of Erebor, and has been for… about a week or so, by my reckoning.”
“It might possibly be two,” Bard commented, trying to think back to when the Dwarves hired his barge. It had been a long week, if it truly was only one; everything was muddy, and thinking about it more only gave him a headache.

 

–x–x–x–

 

Once, many moons ago, a young Hobbit, not yet of age, left for home, six months older than when he’d arrived and much less enthusiastic. He’d gained something, but lost more, and Elrond could not begrudge him for leaving as soon as the healers allowed. Even then, he’d left two months before any of them had expected he’d have been able to.

Now, that same Hobbit had gained something, but lost more, and the Elf-Lord knew exactly what Bilbo Baggins did when he lost things.

 

“I don’t see it that way,” Bilbo said, looking down to where his feet dangled off of the bench, barely touching the grass below.
“Well, how do you see it, then?”
“I don’t, really.” What an odd thing to say.
“You see no point in attempting to preserve the quality of life in one’s final moments, and yet, you have offered it to Arathorn?”
Bilbo nodded.
“Why?” It was something Elrond couldn’t wrap his head around – why would the Hobbit, a child, stick his neck out, endangering his social reputation and clearly electing to do something he did not enjoy, for a stranger?
“Because he is nice,” came the simple answer, and maybe things were as simple as that. “He has a sharp mind, despite the- his injury, and he doesn’t frown upon it. He doesn’t see it as the people of the Shire do.”
“How does he see it, then?”
“He doesn’t. But he’s seen how others suffer with it, and- well, I think he knows a bit more about me than what I’ve told him,” Bilbo said, looking slyly up at Elrond before returning his vision to the flowers. A child the Hobbit may be, but Elrond would be wise to remind himself of the craftiness of Belladonna Took.
It was with Bilbo’s next utterance that Elrond remembered he really was just a child, even one on the cusp of adulthood.
“He reminds me of dad.”

When Arathorn died, he offered something to Bilbo. Elrond knew not what, but it wasn’t his business, and never would be; the two had grown close within a very short period of time, and Elrond thought they reminded one another of their own father and son, respectively. Despite the best efforts of the Elves, through both direct and indirect means, Bilbo Baggins left almost immediately after Arathorn’s death. He’d spent many moons with little to no sleep, and had a rather nasty habit of bursting into fits of panic, often ending up spending the evenings alone, curled up somewhere he thought no one could find him – only to wake up hours later, starving and embarrassed, avoidant of all except the one Man he’d known. Arathorn died, and it was like Bungo all over again.
Bilbo slipped away quietly, and Elrond didn’t see or hear from him again for a fair few years.

 

“We need to find the Hobbit,” Elrond stated, bringing the hushed conversation within the tent to a standstill. He’d been lost in memories, but one glared at him, clawing at the back of his mind as it begged to be seen, examined, understood.
“That much has been established,” Mithrandir said slowly, though he tilted his chin up like he knew Elrond had something to say. He probably did. “What envelops your mind so, Elrond?”
“Bilbo Baggins has experienced much loss before,” Elrond started, unsure of his words as they stumbled their way out of his mouth. He didn’t want to divulge sensitive information, but a life was very possibly at stake here. “If he is not here, then he believes something has happened – and, when he does, he becomes somewhat… self-destructive.”
“How so?” Balin, the older Dwarf, asked, as Thorin whipped his head back up to ask the very same thing.
“He is careless of his own needs should he believe there is a greater one.”
Both Dwarves became uneasily quiet, looking between one another like they weren’t allowed to talk.
As always, nothing is ever easy for Lord Elrond, because just at that moment, another Dwarf and an Elf stormed into the tent, the former following the latter as he ranted and raved.
“Thorin Oakenshield!” Thranduil screeched, throwing his hands into the air in a dramatic reenactment of a mother whose vase had been found broken. “Where have you put the Arkenstone?!”
“...What?” Thorin asked, somewhat dumbly – Elrond almost felt bad for him, confused as he was.
“You’ve taken it! You greedy little-” Thranduil advanced as he spat the words out of his mouth, and Elrond moved to hold the Elvenking while Mithrandir stepped between him and the Dwarves. Thranduil sneered, looking nearly surprised at Elrond’s presence, and purely annoyed at the wizard’s.
“Thranduil, this is madness! Whatever do you mean, the Arkenstone is gone ?” Mithrandir asked, conjuring a gravitas only a truly disappointed parent could. Elrond briefly wondered if the wizard had ever adopted any children.
“I mean,” Thranduil replied, leering at the Dwarves behind Mithrandir’s back, “that it’s gone, and one of these Dwarves has stolen it.”
“I told you, it weren’t one of us, it was- someone else,” a voice sounded from near the entrance, and Elrond peered over Thranduil’s shoulder to see another Dwarf – the one who had entered with him – who looked completely and entirely done with the situation already. He appeared to be exasperated by Thranduil, like he’d been saying the same thing over and over again for hours. He probably had.
“And who was that ‘someone else’? I need names , Dwarf!”
The Dwarf remained silent, though he stared directly at the Elvenking, fuming.
“Nori?” Balin asked, and the Dwarf – who, Elrond was just realising, had the most ridiculous star-shaped hairstyle he’d ever seen – breathed a sigh of relief, switching to rushed Khuzdûl. Elladan and Elrohir would probably compare his verve to that of an auctioneer. Instead of listening, he instead watched for the other Dwarves’ reactions, and they did not disappoint; Balin’s jaw progressively dropped lower and lower, while Thorin stared, silent and unchanging, before releasing a wordless shout which Elrond suspected was some sort of curse. The tent remained silent for a tense few minutes before Balin finally spoke.
“I… believe we may know where Bilbo is, Lord Elrond.”

 

They were all in a circle, some sitting and some standing, as the star-haired Dwarf found his words. They’d let the healers come in to change the boys’ bandages, and Mithrandir pronounced some sort of ritual before everyone settled back to business.
“None of us have the Arkenstone,” Nori started, and Thranduil immediately interrupted, his Silvertongue ability cutting across Nori’s words.
“Lies, if you ask me-”
“We did not,” Balin said, dispelling Thranduil’s hold over everyone. Elrond was very much aware of the dangers of Thranduil being a Silvertongue – he’d witnessed the outrage within Mirkwood when he rose to the throne – and became infinitely appreciative of Balin, and incredibly glad for his ability. “Let Nori speak.”
“...Thank you, Balin. Anyway , as I was saying – none of us have the Arkenstone, because none of us stole it. Someone else did – not a Dwarf, Man, or Elf, but a Hobbit by the name of Bilbo Baggins.”
“That sly-”
“What use would Bilbo have for such an artifact?” Elrond nearly shouted in his attempt to cut Thranduil off.
“Well, he’s the one who gave it to me, so I suppose he wanted it back, the little thief,” Thranduil said rather snottily.
“Thranduil,” the Man in the corner said, speaking again for the first time in a while. “That’s not exactly true, is it? He gave the Arkenstone to us – me, you, and Gandalf – to help the Dwarves. It was no gift to you.”
Thranduil huffed, but he at least had the decency to look properly chastised.
“So, Bilbo stole the Arkenstone from the Dwarves to give to you three as some sort of peace offering, and has stolen it back, only to disappear?”
“That’s about the sum of it,” Nori shrugged, before he turned to stare into the wall behind Elrond, expression carefully blank as ever, like he’d been trained for it. “‘Cept, he’s got a good reason.”
“How so?” Mithrandir asked.
“There is… somethin’ else, he hadn’t told you lot,” Nori started again, directing it mostly towards the Dwarves and wizard. “When he was in the goblin tunnels, he picked up a little ring. It whispered to him all the time, and did my bloody head in. We borrowed one of Óin’s lead-lined pouches to drown out the noise.”
Last Elrond had heard of a ring that whispered to people, he’d tried telling a Man to put it into the fires of Mordor. It had not worked, and caused quite a lot of strife.
“What does this ring look like?” Mithrandir questioned, already running along the same thoughtlines as Elrond.
“It’s a little gold band, he told me, though he didn’t let me see it. Wouldn’t shut up aside from with lead. I don’t think he liked wearing it, and he got quite upset when I told him I felt like it was watching me. Told me to look out for an Eye , whatever that means, and it means something, ‘cause it’s Bilbo.”
“Did he seem protective of it at all?” Mithrandir asked, but another question plagued Elrond’s mind.
“When he told you about the Eye , did he say he’d heard that before?” Nori opened his mouth to answer Mithrandir, but stopped as Elrond’s question slipped from his lips, and gave him an almost analytically evaluative look before responding, leaning in and speaking in hushed tones despite the privacy of the tent.
“He never said anything – not to me, anyway, and not directly. But he made me promise my little finger that if it got worse, or I saw some sort of eye, I’d tell him. He looked a bit upset at the time.”
“Yes, I suppose he would be,” Elrond murmured, staring into the middle-distance as memories of the news of Belladonna’s and Bungo’s deaths swirled in his mind.
“Wossat supposed to mean?”
“We all know Bilbo’s ability, yes?”
“No,” said Bard, and Thranduil scoffed at him.
“In these situations, Bargeman , we stay quiet, so we may learn more.”
“That’s quite dishonest, Elvenking.”
Elrond decided he didn’t want to get involved, so he moved on.
“Whatever we say in this tent does not leave it,” he prefaced, making sure to catch Thranduil’s eye as he looked around. “Whose ability did Bilbo take?”
“Thrór’s,” Thorin said, after a minute of silence from the Dwarves.
“ Take? ” Thranduil gasped, and everyone elected to ignore him.
“He was a Deathshifter. Apparently, Bilbo absorbed all his previous… capabilities, along with his Re- ability,” Nori amended.
“Which is how he appeared in Smaug’s body,” Balin added. The picture was not yet full, but gained definition with each sentence from the Dwarves.
“Self-destructive in the face of a goal, you said?” Mithrandir asked softly, and a horrified understanding dawned over the wizard. Elrond himself had thought it several minutes ago, but now, it was practically confirmed.
“What’s the likelihood he worked it out?”
“He’s a smart Hobbit, Bilbo, but he can’t know the intricacies of the Ring-”
“He may not know its origin, but its nature is easy to figure out for someone such as himself. He’s experienced enough of the stages before death to understand.”
“Can someone please inform the room of what we speak?!” Thranduil demanded more than asked, and had Elrond been in any lighter a mood, he would have laughed and asked why the Elf didn’t stamp his foot. However, his spirits were not so high as that. He exchanged a nod with Mithrandir, and sighed wearily before starting the arduous task of detailing everything in as compact a manner as he could manage.
“One Bilbo Baggins is in possession of the One Ring of Power. He may not know its true history, but he certainly knows it’s evil, from what Master Nori here has said. Presumably, he’s stolen the Arkenstone so he can destroy the two together. Where he is now is the only question.”
“Why doesn’t he turn into a dragon and destroy them?” Bard asked.
“It’s likely he tried that,” Elrond replied tiredly. “There are no dragons powerful enough to create that kind of firepower left, not on this side of the world.” Bilbo Baggins was nothing if not thorough. It was part of why he was so dangerous.

“Your Eagles are talkin’ to each other,” Nori spoke into the thoughtful silence, looking between Elrond and Mithrandir, who was standing next to him.
“And what do they say?” Mithrandir asked.
“Well, I don’t speak Eagle, do I?”

Two Eagles materialised from the skies, landing once again far enough from the camp that it wouldn’t blow the tents over, but close enough to reach quickly. Golden feathers appeared dim beneath the overcast skies, despite Thorondor having looked quite fine before they’d plunged below the clouds. Another stood beside him, moving himself from foot to foot in his impatience.
“What ails your mind, Thorondor?” Elrond called out as he walked, followed by Mithrandir and Nori. Balin had elected to stay with Thorin, and Bard decided it would be better for one of the larger folk to be there should Thranduil decide to display his lack of emotional maturity yet again.

“It is not mine, but Gwaihir’s which itches.” Gwaihir trilled in agreement, tongue flicking outward to the scar on his face as he closed his mouth. “He believes he may have useful information to you.”
“And you have come to translate for us – I thank you greatly for your presence, Thorondor, Lord of the Eagles.” Thorondor dipped his head in thanks, which still hung greatly above Elrond’s, and he remained taller than Gwaihir while doing so. His sheer size was intimidating when he was up close. Gwaihir, however, was more reasonably-sized, like Landroval – though he was still bigger than the rest.
“Gwaihir has learned from Meneldor who you may be looking for.” Elrond nodded, but he didn’t remember telling the Eagle about Bilbo at all. This was top-secret stuff – one doesn’t talk about a Valar’s servant’s magic ring in anything other than a secured room. “There is a Halfling, is there not?”
“Hobbit,” Elrond found himself saying, and was surprised to find Nori and Mithrandir had both had the same knee-jerk reaction. The three shared a look, and knew immediately that the others had been kicked or punched at least thrice for their misstep.
“Yes, he said much the same thing.”
“You’ve spoken to a hobbit?” Mithrandir asked, looking up hopefully to Thorondor. Elrond wondered whyever the wizard had brought Bilbo along in the first place, considering he seemed not to even know of Bilbo’s Burglar title during their discussion in Imladris those months ago – in fact, he’d never delved into the possibility of Bilbo’s ability being abused.
“Yes, by the name Bilbo Baggins, though he was a thrush when we met him.”

 

–x–x–x–

 

Lead. Lead. Lead thicker than skin, older than trees, contaminating the Bearer’s skin as it protected the miserable creature from its lulling whispers. Not for long, not for long – broken minds were far easier to get through to than whole ones, that much it had learned in the five-century-long bout with… whatever it had become. Maybe this one would be like it; they started out the same, after all.
“Come to me,” it whispered through the air, watching as the atoms of its containment crumbled, imbuing themselves into thick flesh. “Tell me what you know.” The creature knew something . “We’ll always be here, to listen to you. Not like that King of yours.”
If a thrush could huff, then he did – an odd motion to create while held aloft in the air, morphed into the flesh of a Deathshifter as he flew.

Breaking this one was going to be fun.

Notes:

Did I make up some of that Dwarf culture lore? Absolutely. Is Thorin a dramatic bitch, and needed something to fuel his moping? Most definitely. Am I a sucker for social differences across different cultures and fantasy races? Unequivocally, yes.

Also, I learned how big Thorondor was, and I really want to see him beat the shit out of a dragon like he does in the Silmarillion. He’s huge, guys. 55 metre wingspan. That’s unreasonably large. I would LOVE to be his friend.