Sorry, you need to have JavaScript enabled for this.

Actions

Work Header

The Injury of Knowing You

Summary:

Bilbo Baggins comes to terms with his grief, several years after Thorin’s death while visiting his memorial and pontificates on the injury of being known while never being fully understood.

I was listening to Hozier and got sad. I’ve never written a full-on angst, so ya’ll… bear with me. This is just a short little fic because I needed an outlet.

Notes:

(See the end of the work for notes.)

Work Text:

Erebor was oddly bustling as Bilbo made his way through its arching doorways. Gandalf was his ever silent companion, and after so many weeks of travel, he realized that they’d hardly spoken a word to each other. Frodo was safely stowed in his arms, the fauntling’s gentle snores calming him slightly. He gazed down at the boy, struck as he usually was with how much the bairn looked like the very man he was here to see. It brought a stinging to his eyes. He was quickly found by Balin, the old dwarf gathering him like wheat in a gentle hug before springing back at Frodo’s sounds of protest. The fauntling glared at him, clutching Bilbo’s shirt in his tiny hands. Bilbo smiled a little before handing Frodo off to Gandalf, who promised to find them room and board. The wizard knew that Bilbo needed to go the rest of this journey alone, as he often knew most things. Frodo was ever jealous of Bilbo’s time, but he was content enough to bother the wizard into showing off. Balin laid a gentle hand on his shoulder, his own eyes shining with grief. It had been so long since they’d seen each other, so long since they’d seen…

Bilbo swallowed his grief and his tears. There would be plenty of time to wallow where he was going. They were soon joined by the remaining members of the company, some seemed pleased to see him, others seemed overtaken by their own sadness. Bilbo didn’t pay them much heed. He would worry about reuniting and catching up later. Balin led them all to the burial chamber, and for hours they sat and talked. They reminisced about the journey, about the aftermath, and then fell silent. Bilbo said nothing. His own eyes were captivated by the memorial in front of him. Orcrist laid in dead stillness, perfectly sharpened and shined. It seemed to glint dully in the firelight. It reminded him of the way that the light had faded from Thorin’s eyes, his breath feeling choked in his chest as a lump rose in his throat. Balin spoke a few more respectful words before the dwarves departed, leaving him alone in the burial chamber. Bilbo listened for the loud thud of the door before allowing himself to look at Thorin’s grave again. 

You know the distance never made a difference to me. 

I swam a lake of fire, I’d have walked across the floor of any sea…

Ignored the vastness between all that can be seen,

And all that we believe.

When Gandalf had knocked on his door, bringing chaos and an overabundance of dwarves into his life, Bilbo had staunchly refused. But with the morning sun rising, so had his sense of adventure. He’d travelled miles and miles, following after Thorin like a lost puppy. The dwarven king had such an aura about him, such a passion, that Bilbo had felt helpless but to join their cause. 

So I thought you were like an angel to me!

Thorin… With his dark hair and light eyes. With his growling voice and his gentle hands. 

Funny how the colours shine in the darkness and in secrecy. 

If there were scarlet flags, they washed out in the mind of me. 

Where a blindin’ light shone on you every night,

And either side of my sleep. 

Thorin’s eyes had darkened along with his mind when they’d finally reached Erebor. Bilbo shuddered as he remembered the way that Thorin’s hands had caressed his chest as they gripped his shirt and hoisted him over the wall. In that moment, he’d felt no fear. Though Thorin was threatening to kill him, Bilbo could only focus on the biting caress of Thorin’s hands over his skin. The beautiful pain that bloomed along his back as Thorin dangled him over the terrifying drop, and the magnetic nearness of their lips. He’d wanted to kiss Thorin so badly, even then. 

Where you were held frozen like an angel to me!

Thorin… with his terrifying snarl and his careful grip. With his darting eyes and his untamed mane. 

It ain’t the being alone. (Sha-la-la.)

It ain’t the empty home, baby. (Sha-la-la.)

Over the past years, Bilbo had returned to his hobbit hole and grieved. But it seemed that each day he woke, the pain was fresher than the last. He was drowning in regret and in pain, but even in that darkness, he had been given a light: Frodo. It was Frodo who dragged him from the pits of his misery, forced him to rejoin the waking world again. He had someone else to care for. Life had to go on. For Frodo. But at night, alone in his bed, Bilbo still desperately prayed. 

You know I’m good on my own. (Sha-la-la.)

Sha-la-la, baby, you know, it’s more the being unknown.

So much of the livin’, love, is the being unknown. 

And however much Bilbo loved Frodo, he could not fill the gaping hole inside of his heart and soul. The fissure was ravenous and insatiable, wanting for what Bilbo could not have. For what he could never have. No one had ever known him as Thorin had known him. And Bilbo was now scared of letting Frodo know him. He didn’t talk about the journey, nor the dwarves. In fact, Frodo had been incredibly confused when Bilbo explained their own pilgrimage to Erebor. He was distrustful, and anxious. It was Bilbo’s fault. But he couldn’t turn down the offer to rip his carefully stitched heart open again, not if it was to see Thorin. Pain was always bearable for Thorin. 

You called me “angel” for the first time, my heart leapt from me. 

You smile now, I can see its pieces still stuck in your teeth. 

And what’s left of it, I listen to it tick,

Every tedious beat. 

From the very moment Thorin had called him by name, Bilbo knew he was lost. And every ‘Master Baggins’, every ‘Burglar’ after had felt like daggers in his heart. Thorin knew him. And yet he refused to. On the surface, he’d been cold. Distrustful. But nights on the journey, by the light of the fire, he had seen the deepness of Thorin’s eyes. The hope. The wonder. The longing. Bilbo just didn’t know if it was longing for him or for Erebor. The Mountain would always be Thorin’s first love. Perhaps his only love. His unanswered question set his stomach fluttering, not with anything so romantic as butterflies, but with angry hornets that buzzed and stung.

Going unknown as any angel to me.

Thorin, with his mystery. Thorin, with his thousand-league walls constructed carefully around his heart. The heart that Bilbo would have done anything to make a home within. Bilbo let out a renewed gasp, clutching at his stomach as he heaved. 

Do you know I could break beneath the weight?

Of the goodness, love, I still carry for you? 

That I’d walk so far just to take,

The injury of finally knowing you?

Bilbo’s shoulders wracked with the force of his sobs. Finally allowing the tears to fall. Finally coming to terms with death and the vicious emptiness it left behind. Thorin had kept him at a distance, a distance that felt leagues further than any he’d ever crossed—though he’d followed the king from the Shire to the halls of Erebor. He would have done anything for Thorin, and he had. But despite the pain, he couldn’t let go. He couldn’t shake the weight of his love for the king. It felt heavy around his heart, dragging it down until he feared that it would never beat steady again. His grief felt carved onto his heart, a branding from Thorin, though the king had not done the branding himself. It had all been Bilbo, and now the pain was all his to bear. 

It ain’t the being alone. (Sha-la-la.)

It ain’t the empty home, baby. (Sha-la-la.)

You know I’m good on my own. (Sha-la-la.)

Bilbo had been a happily confirmed bachelor before the quest. He had been fine. He had not felt the sting of loneliness until he’d learned what he was missing. And now it was all that he could think about. 

Bilbo wiped away his tears, standing and taking shaky steps toward the memorial. He dug through his pocket until he found what he was looking for. A single acorn, born from the tree he’d promised Thorin that he’d grow, so many years ago. It was a meager offering, compared to the finely forged and meticulous gifts surrounding it, but Bilbo felt a little lighter as he placed it inside a wreath of metal leaves. A little life amongst all the death that threatened to drag him back down. He leaned over Thorin’s grave, tears falling freely. Deep in the Lonely Mountain, Bilbo grappled with his own feelings of abandonment. Thorin had never truly known the depth of his attachment. Would it have turned out differently if he had? Bilbo doubted it. But the regret choked at his throat all the same. He kissed his fingers, pressing them against the carven portrait of Thorin and staring at the peaceful likeness. They hadn’t gotten his nose quite right. He laughed despite himself. Thorin would have been properly broody at that. 

He heard the door to the burial chamber as it opened, the sound echoing throughout the silent room. He glanced up to see Gandalf carrying his nephew, eyes red with tears. Bilbo wrinkled his brow in concern and turned away from the grave. 

“Poppet, what’s wrong?”

“What is this place? Why are we here?” Frodo demanded, childlike indignation shaking with his frightened tears. 

Bilbo gulped hard and looked back at the memorial where his heart lay shattered. 

“I think it’s time I tell you a story.” His voice cracked, but the words were out and it was a start. A start to healing, and a start to opening his heart back up again. 

“It isn’t bedtime yet!” Frodo exclaimed, wriggling out of Gandalf’s arms and plopping onto the floor, intent on escape. The wizard watched him with careful eyes, a sad set to his brow. An understanding. A grief for Bilbo’s grief.

“I know it isn’t. This isn’t a bedtime story.” Bilbo placated the young lad. 

“Then what sort of story is it?” Frodo asked, curiosity overtaking his determination to stay awake. 

“It’s the story of how I first left the Shire to fight off goblins, trolls, and a dragon.” Bilbo told him, tears stinging at his eyes again and voice theatrical despite it all.

“It sounds exciting.” Frodo breathed, hurrying to wriggle his way into Bilbo’s arms, and in doing so, wriggle his way into Bilbo’s very heart. “Is it a true story?” He asked, wonder in his eyes. 

“Truer than any.” Gandalf spoke, voice cracked.

So they sat beside Thorin’s grave, Frodo in his lap and tearful words upon his lips. Gandalf excused himself, a gentle sorrow on his face. It was clear that Frodo longed for a parent. He longed for the trust and gentleness. And so perhaps Bilbo could survive being known, just one more time.

Sha-la-la, baby, you know, it’s more the being unknown. 

And there are some people, love, who are better unknown. 

 

Notes:

Ouch

Series this work belongs to: