Work Text:
Darkness and solitude have a way of eating at the mind. The former wasn’t usually a challenge, as he was as well-acquainted as any dwarrow to dwelling in the dark. The latter however…Thorin had rarely spent any time alone in his entire life, and the cursed elves had isolated him, placed him in the lowest dungeon, where he could not hear his companions bickering or take comfort in their laughter… With each passing hour, and day, the walls seemed to press closer to him and weigh heavier than any physical pain. There was no sound to distract him, nothing but the drip of distant water. Twice a day the soft echo of elvish footsteps preceded the scrape of a food tray sliding beneath his door.
With solitude came rumination, and with it, guilt, and regret. Each member of his company had placed their faith in him, giving up their safety, their livelihoods, risking everything on his word alone, trusting him with their lives. And he had failed them all.
Was this to be his legacy: to rot in an elven dungeon while Erebor remained in the clutches of a dragon? While his companions suffered in their own cells, while Bilbo –brave, foolish Bilbo– was Mahal knew where.
He'd warned Gandalf, hadn't he? “I cannot guarantee his safety”. The words echoed in his mind, followed by that damning addition: “Nor will I be responsible for his fate”. What empty promises those had turned out to be. Somewhere between the Shire and this Valar-forsaken-forest, between scoffing at the hobbit's laments over handkerchiefs and watching him face down his greatest enemy, Thorin had found himself increasingly consumed by thoughts of Bilbo's wellbeing. Each danger and discomfort they faced brought a new knot of anxiety to the dwarrow’s king gut… not for himself, but for their burglar who should never have had to face such perils.
“Master Baggins”, he would murmur, the polite form of address slipping unbidden from his lips even in the privacy of his cell. “What has become of you?”
The question haunted him. Had the spiders taken him? Was he lost in the twisted paths of Mirkwood, starving, alone and afraid? Or had he abandoned the quest entirely, finally coming to his senses about the folly of joining a band of dispossessed dwarrow to defeat a dragon?
Thorin would not blame him if he had fled, nor would he curse him as he had done what seemed like so long ago, after the goblin tunnels. Yet the thought of him being safe and distant brought no comfort. Only a hollow ache that settled over his lungs and made breathing a painful task.
He tried not to think about it. About him. Yet he was constantly on his mind. Even with open eyes, he could envision the halfling's dear figure with startling clarity—the bright yet wry smile on his soft lips, that nimble body that had proven so fierce and resilient, that unexpected courage that had bloomed like a flower in stony ground.
“I should never have brought him”, he would growl, pacing his cell like a caged wolf. “A gentlehobbit of the Shire...a creature so soft that has never known war or privation… what madness possessed me to allow it?”
The guilt led him to ponder unthinkable acts of desperation. Perhaps he should humble himself before Thranduil, beg the Elvenking to send search parties for the hobbit, make sure he hadn’t fallen prey to the horrors lurking between the diseased trees.
Perhaps…. Perhaps that thrice cursed elf would agree… should he offer the very gems that had soured their relations… he would give them gladly to ensure Bilbo's safety.
He would give up anything.
Even his crown.
His crown, the crown he’d never actually worn, and yet sat so heavily on his weary brow. Since the day his father vanished and his grandfather fell, the invisible weight had been his constant companion. He'd carried it through years of wandering, through every indignity of manual labour amongst the Men folk, through every night he'd gone hungry to ensure his sister’s sons, his people as a whole, were fed and safe and clothed. Not once had he wavered or bent under its weight– he couldn't afford to. Too many looked to him, depended on him, even now.
The Durins endured. And so through it all, he had remained unbowed. Until now.
He’d bend now. Willingly so. He’d give up that burden if only…
The realization struck him with the strength of Mahal’s hammer. He, Thorin, son of Thrain, son of Thrór, King-in-Exile-Under-the-Mountain, would beg favours from the elf who had abandoned his people to dragonfire? And for what? For a halfling he had once dismissed as more grocer than burglar. Thorin realised now, Gandalf’s assertion that their quest would fail without Bilbo had been all too true.
“Find your way to us, burglar”, Thorin beckoned into the darkness, "or all is lost”.
All is lost without you.
His hope now rested not in his own strength or the loyalty of his kin, but in the clever yet so very small hands of a hobbit who should never have left his comfortable hole in the ground.
Sleep came fitfully, when it did come, and brought no rest, only painful memories transformed into painful nightmares. In his sleep, he saw Erebor as it once stood: halls deep underground gleaming with golden light, marvels of craft in every corner, hammers marking the heartbeat within the mountain. Then flames, the roar of wings, screams echoing through corridors turned to furnaces. The hideous faces of orcs, rendered more hideous by wrath and victory, fellow dwarrow by hundreds and thousands fallen under the vile metal of their blades. The stench of the battleground.
Oftentimes, something new haunted his slumber: Bilbo, alone in the vastness of Mirkwood, calling his name, his voice turned hoarse by strain, by thirst, by despair.
His sweet tenor, calling his name.
He woke with a gasp, sweat cooling on his brow from the dungeon's chill. A sound, so faint he thought he might have imagined it, had pulled him from the nightmare. Thorin stilled, hardly daring to breathe.
There it was again. A whisper of movement outside his cell door.
“Who goes there?” he growled, voice rough from disuse. Heturned on his pallet to peer between the cell’s bars.
Silence answered him. There was nothing to see outside.
Nothing?
He squinted in the dark.
The air seemed to shimmer, like heat rising above a forge.
“Thorin? Thorin, are you there?”
Suddenly, materialising from the very darkness, there stood Bilbo Baggins.
At first, Thorin thought his mind had finally cracked, conjuring the hobbit's presence from sheer loneliness, pulled from his dreams. But no. There he was, just a few paces away. The sight of his familiar curls, his bright eyes spying through the bars, made his heart surge painfully in his chest.
Thorin rose swiftly to his feet, crossing to the bars in two strides, like a magnet pulled to iron ore.
“Master Baggins”, he breathed, disbelief and elation mingling in his voice. “How…?”
“Shh!” Bilbo pressed a finger to his own lips, glancing nervously down the corridor. “The guards change soon. We haven't got much time”.
Thorin stared at him, drank from his strange, familiar, cherished features. The hobbit looked thinner, his face smudged with dirt, clothes tattered at the edges. But his eyes…they were the same. Yet different. Sharper, somehow. More certain.
“You're alive”, mumbled Thorin, as if he needed to say it out loud to believe it himself. "All this time, I thought…”
The distant light from the corridor’s torches caught in his hair, turning the curls to molten copper, with strands of pure gold, and Thorin's fingers ached with the need to reach through the bars, to touch, to verify this wasn't some cruel dream born of solitude.
“All this time, I’ve… I’ve been trying to find a way to free you all”, said Bilbo, fumbling with something inside the pocket of his open waistcoat, the buttons lost weeks ago in the goblin tunnels. “It hasn't been easy. I followed you inside the palace, and then down to these dungeons. The… the elves are terribly suspicious, light of feet and keen of eyes and ears, and they're… they’re everywhere”.
A question burned on Thorin's tongue, but the words that came out were not those he'd intended. “Have you seen the others? Are they… well?”
“Yes, all of them. Hungry and irritable, but unharmed”, Bilbo whispered, his hands wrapped around the iron bars. “Fíli and Kíli are together, a few levels above. The rest are not very far from them. Balin is with Dori, their cell is closest to the wine cellars, which might be useful, though they’re awfully pissy about being able to smell the vintage but not taste it. While I… well, I’ve kept myself busy, I've been mapping the guards' rotations, and I think…” He paused, brow furrowing, studying his perplexed, adoring expression, jaw dropped like a fool. “Thorin? Are you well? You've hardly said a word”.
Thorin dropped his face down, unwilling to let the hobbit see the emotions playing on his features, threatening to overcome him. “You should have left when you had your chance”, he managed to say, more gruffly than he intended. “Found your way back to the Shire while you could”.
A small sound of exasperation escaped Bilbo.
“What about my contract? What kind of burglar would I be if I left you all to rot?”
“A sensible one”.
A live one, provided the dry voice in his mind.
“Well…” Thorin hated that he could hear the smile in his voice, and yet he was not brave enough to look at him, to drink from its source. “I've never claimed to be sensible. Not since I ran out my door without a handkerchief. Not since…”
Bilbo stopped, as if he too had things to prevent from slipping through his lips.
As if…
The silence stretched between them, and Thorin dared to lift his face a little, not to look at him no… but he looked outside, fixating on those lovely, wretched, oversized bare feet on the corner of his sight.
“I… I have a plan”. Bilbo broke the silence, all business now. “It's not a particularly good one, I'm afraid, but it's the best I could manage with… the present situation”.
Thorin lifted his eyes then, studying the determined set of the hobbit's jaw—so soft, so vulnerable without the cover of any stubble.
When had the diminutive Master of Bag End become this resourceful, courageous figure before him?
“Whatever your plan…. I trust you”.
Bilbo's eyes widened slightly, as if surprised by the declaration, by the fervour in his tone.
“That's... well. That's good. Because you're not going to like this next part”.
And so Bilbo outlined his scheme —something involving barrels and the river— but Thorin was not really listening to the words. Instead, he watched the animated gestures of the hobbit's hands, how his brow furled and unfurled as he spoke, how his lips curled around the words, how he’d bite them, lick them, while he waited for Thorin’s response, bouncing on the heels of his toes, still fidgeting with the contents of his pockets.
No, Thorin had not been listening. He was too mesmerised. The mad idea of escaping through the Forest River should have given him pause, should have made him reconsider, object. The rushing currents, the jagged rocks that broke the surface like teeth, the icy spray that soaked through clothes and chilled to the bone—all of it should have been pondered. But Thorin had been too captivated by the hobbit's confidence, too eager to escape the Elvenking's halls to truly contemplate the implications of the escape plan, to calculate the risks.
A company of dwarves packed into barrels and launched into a river was one thing—they were stout and hardy folk. But what of Bilbo? What of this small creature who would have no barrel to protect his fragile form from the river's merciless currents?
Too late, he realised all the flagrant gaps in the plan. The dwarves were already committed to the plan, stuffed into the barrels and Bilbo was bouncing on his toes, a fake merry smile on his face, his hand already on the lever.
“What about you?” he’d muttered furiously, helplessly, from his undignified position inside the barrel.
“What of me? I'm coming too, of course!”
The hobbit had shrugged, and his smile wavered a little on the corner. It had been the tiniest of gestures, barely perceptible in the shadows, but it had stuck Thorin like a knife in his gut. Yet before he could utter a protest, the lever was pushed, the trapdoor was opened and out tumbled the barrels, one by one, into the rushing waters below.
The cold fury of the river didn’t surprise him, cognitively, inasmuch as it shocked him, bodily. Thorin had lived his life in the shadow of mountains, where even gentle streams could become deadly torrents after rainfall. This Green Wood river was no gentle stream. The water was deep and the current strong, making the barrels pitch and bob wildly, bounce off the walls of the tunnel, wood groaning with each impact.
And then down came the hobbit. His terrified shriek was cut short when the small body plunged like a stone in the water, narrowly avoiding the barrels. Up surged a high plume of water, followed by a ring of rippling waves that sent the closest barrels careening against each other.
Thorin waited, his eyes helplessly searching. For the longest moment, there were only bubbles. And finally, finally, the hobbit came back up, gasping for air, spitting water out, kicking with all the might his short limbs allowed.
Thorin strained to keep him in sight in the dim light of the tunnel, that small form bobbing between them, until he managed to cling precariously to Nori's barrel, his small body drenched and shivering, face contorted with determination.
"Hold him fast!" Thorin ordered the other dwarrow, trying to row with his hands to keep close. But the currents had a different idea. The company was soon scattered about, their makeshift fleet at the mercy of the river's whims, trying to steer the barrels as they could, rowing with their arms or broken branches.
Shortly after, they were pushed out of the tunnel under the elvenking’s palace. The sun had barely come out, but the sky was visible in between the tree branches, light blue and completely clear of clouds, and the air was fresh. It felt like a blessing, after the weeks they were lost in Mirkwood, and then however long they’d been in the dungeons. Thorin’s face split in a wide grin, and he looked back at the hobbit to share his joy. But Bilbo… Bilbo was not smiling. He was no longer safe by Nori’s barrel. On the contrary, he was visibly struggling to keep afloat, clinging to whatever piece of wood he could find, the barrels too slippery for him to grab securely with his small hands for more than a few seconds at a time, his head dipping below the surface with alarming frequency.
Thorin thrust his arm out as the current pulled him momentarily closer to Bilbo, trying to grab him, feeling the hobbit's sodden sleeve brush against his fingertips before being wrenched away by the current. The hobbit's wide, terrified eyes locked with his own before a wave crashed over him, dipping him again under the surface for a few seconds.
“I can't…” Bilbo managed to say when he came up again, spluttering and coughing, “…swim!”
Thorin’s heart stopped.
And it started again, more painful than ever.
“Help the hobbit!” Thorin commanded the other dwarves. “Grab him before he's lost!”
“We’re trying!” Dwalin shouted, his own attempt to seize Bilbo ending with grasping only empty air. With the movement, his barrel smashed against Thorin's, sending both spinning in opposite directions, against each bank of the river. “But the lad is more slippery than a river trout!”
The current pulled Bilbo tantalizingly close to Thorin again. This time, his fingers connected with the hobbit's wrist, clutching desperately. For one glorious moment, he had him, could feel Bilbo's pulse racing beneath his grip—only for the hobbit to slip away like a fish.
“No!” Thorin roared, slamming his fist against the wooden confines of his prison, which threatened with capsizing. He shouted again to his companions: “Use the barrels! Form a barrier!”
If they could create a pocket of calmer water, perhaps Bilbo could be shielded long enough to be pulled aboard one of the barrels.
His dwarrow responded with admirable coordination despite the chaos, each member fighting their own battle against the river’s force, pushing and pulling at each other's barrels, trying to create a formation that might catch their burglar.
But then, as if the river hadn't been bad enough, there came arrows, pelting them from the shore.
At first, Thorin had been so focused on trying to help the hobbit, that he wouldn’t have noticed them if it weren’t for a shout snapping Thorin's attention.
“Uncle Thorin!” Fili was gesturing wildly toward the shore. “We're under fire!”
Thorin squinted towards the green mass of the forest. Two slight figures moved through the trees with impossible grace, keeping pace with the barrels.
Elves?
There were too many arrows for even the best amongst elvish archers.
A black, twisted arrow whistled past, striking the water inches from his barrel. Then came the horns—not elvish, but deeper, more guttural.
Orcs.
“Orcs!” Thorin bellowed, warning those who hadn't yet seen them. “Protect yourselves! Protect the Burglar!”
The dwarves did what they could, weaponless, their barrels still spinning wildly in the current. Between dodging arrows and trying to keep his head above water, Thorin caught glimpses of Bilbo, who had managed to cling to the rim of Bofur's barrel, his knuckles white with the effort. The miner was muttering comfortingly to him, rubbing between his shoulder blades, as he tried to shelter him as much as he could, in between his own barrels and his cousins’. Seeing them curled together, an ugly feeling overtook the relief in Thorin’s stomach.
“Elves!” Balin called out. “They're helping with the orcs!”
Above the cacophony of battle cries and the deluge of arrows, Thorin could see the two swift figures darting between the trees on the opposite shore, leaping from rock to rock, firing arrows in rapid succession. Orc after orc fell with an elven arrow through their throat before they could properly aim at the dwarves.
Which was good. Not being saved by the elves. The dwarves were perfectly capable of saving themselves. But just for the hobbit’s sake, Thorin tried to feel thankful for their help.
The taller of the two elves, with long golden hair streaming behind him, dispatched three orcs in quick succession. His companion, a red-haired female warrior, spun with lethal precision, her daggers flashing in the morning light as she cut down any orc that came within reach.
“I don't care if they're helping us or not”, Dwalin grumbled as he used a broken branch to paddle away from an arrow's trajectory. “We need to keep moving, or we’ll end back in that cursed dungeon!”
The river narrowed ahead, funneling them toward what appeared to be an ancient stone structure spanning the waterway. As they drew closer, Thorin's heart sank. A wooden gate blocked their passage, and orcs were already gathering on the structure above it.
“We're trapped!” Gloin shouted.
The barrels collided against the gate with sickening thuds, clustering together in the churning water. Orcs leered down at them from the walkway, notching arrows and raising crude spears.
Thorin looked desperately for an escape. There was a lever on the far side of the gate—if pulled, it would release the mechanism holding the barrier closed.
Before Thorin could formulate a plan, he saw Kili's determined face as he scrambled from barrel to barrel and onto the stone platform, ducking under the first orc's swing.
“Kili, be careful!” Shouted his brother, while Thorin tasted blood on his tongue.
The two elves had reached the structure now, their arrows providing covering fire as Kili made his way toward the lever. The blond elf dispatched an orc that nearly caught Kili from behind, while the female warrior engaged three others on the opposite bank.
Kili reached the lever, his hands grasping the metal handle. With a powerful heave, he pulled it downward. The mechanism groaned and the gate began to rise, water rushing through the widening gap.
“The lad’s done it!” Bofur cried as the barrels began to shift forward with the current.
But then Thorin heard it—a sickening thud, followed by Kili's agonized cry. A black arrow protruded from his thigh, shot by a massive orc standing on the higher walkway. Kili staggered, falling to one knee, his face contorted in pain.
“KILI!” Fili screamed, trying desperately to maneuver his barrel back toward the gate, but the current was already pulling them through.
The injured dwarf prince gritted his teeth and, with a final surge of strength, pushed himself off the platform, falling awkwardly into an empty barrel that Dwalin managed to guide beneath him. The arrow snapped against the barrel's rim, leaving its barbed head embedded in Kili's flesh. His face had gone ashen, but he was with them.
“Keep going!” Thorin commanded, his eyes locked on his wounded nephew. “We must outrun them!”
Behind them, the elven warriors continued their deadly work. The female elf dispatched orc after orc with ruthless efficiency, while her companion used an orc's body as a shield before tossing it into the river. They showed no signs of following the dwarves further, content to defend their borders from the orcish incursion.
They had escaped the orcs, yes, but at what cost? The burglar – Bilbo – had no barrel to protect him. And he couldn’t swim.
To make matters worse, the river's character changed dramatically after the gate. The current accelerated, throwing them into a series of violent rapids. Barrels crashed against jagged rocks, spinning wildly in the whitewater. Thorin could hear the splintering of wood as some barrels took heavy damage.
“Hold fast!” he shouted above the river's roar, though the warning was hardly necessary. Each dwarf was fighting for their lives, clinging to their barrels as they were tossed like toys in the churning water.
Thorin managed to glimpse Bilbo, who had somehow maintained his precarious hold on Bofur's barrel despite the chaos. The hobbit's face was ashen, his soaked curls plastered to his forehead.
The river careened them around a sharp bend, and Thorin's barrel slammed against a jutting rock, sending pain shooting through his shoulder. Each time his barrel rotated in the churning water, Thorin searched desperately for a glimpse of that small figure. Sometimes he saw him, sometimes not, and each absence weighed Thorin's heart with dread.
The forest canopy thinned, allowing pale sunlight to dance across the foaming water. Ahead lay more treacherous rapids, and beyond that, if memory served, the Long Lake.
The sound of rushing water grew suddenly deafening in the narrow gorge they’d crashed into. Glóin and Óin disappeared from sight over the drop, followed by Dori and Nori. Thorin twisted desperately, trying to locate Bilbo in the churning froth, catching one last glimpse of the hobbit's pale face. Then the waterfall claimed him as well, his barrel plunging into the violently churning white water. The roar of falling water drowned all else, and Thorin lost sight of the hobbit in the spray and foam.
After the waterfall, the rapids grew even worse for a while. The world became a blur of foam and mist. His heart pounded against his ribs like a war drum. He called out, but the river swallowed his voice. The other barrels spun past – Fíli, Kíli, Dwalin – all of them counting on him to lead them to safety, to their homeland. All of them but Bilbo.
When the current finally released them, they dragged themselves onto a rocky shore, battered and bloodied but alive. Thorin's legs were unsteady, but he forced himself upright, counting heads, searching for that mop of honey-brown curls.
“Bilbo!” His voice broke on the name. “Where is the Burglar?”
“He was holding onto my barrel”, Bofur explained, his face pale with shock, his sodden moustache plastered to his face and neck. “But then we hit the waterfall, I… I felt his grip slip away”.
Something fractured inside Thorin then, like a foundation stone giving way beneath a mountain. His breath caught, and a pain so sharp and sudden tore through his chest that he nearly doubled over. This wasn't the dull ache of disappointment or even the heavy burden of leadership—this was a visceral, primal agony that reached into the very core of his being.
“BILBO!” The name ripped from his throat as he plunged back into the river, heedless of the exhaustion weighing down his limbs. The cold water shocked his system, but he barely noticed it through the burning panic in his veins.
The others joined the search, overturning barrels, calling out. Thorin waded back into the shallows, fighting the current, diving underwater, scanning every eddy and pool. The cold bit through his sodden clothes, but he barely felt it. There was only the growing void in his chest, the thundering silence where Bilbo's answer should be.
“We have to go back!” Thorin rasped, though he knew the current made such a return impossible.
Balin's weathered hand rested heavily on Thorin's shoulder. “He may yet live, Thorin. Master Baggins has surprised us before”.
But the impossible weight was settling in Thorin's chest. He had failed to protect the one member of his company who needed protection most. The one who had given everything while asking for so little in return.
“We must go back further”, he shouted, fighting desperately against Dwalin’s grip on his arm.
“The elves, Thorin… the orcs…”
“I care not for orcs!” The words tore from his throat. He wrenched free of his friend's hold, stumbling along the riverbank. Every shadow between the rocks mocked him with false hope. Every splash of water sounded like desperate gasps.
“Bilbo! BILBO!” He shouted until his voice grew hoarse, and then some more: “BILBOOOOO!”
The others watched him with heavy eyes. They knew what he could not accept – that the river had claimed him. That he had led another to their death in pursuit of his grandfather's crown and throne.
“BILBOOOOOO!”
Art by Marcel_theLobotomist
The pain in his chest was unbearable. Every breath ached and burned. This wasn't merely the guilt of leadership or even the deep loyalty companions had built over a journey.
The realization should have shaken him more. Instead, it settled into place like a perfectly cut gem finding its setting. Of course he had loved the Burglar. How could he not? Bilbo, who had faced down orcs for him. Who now risked everything to save them from their elven prison. Who had jumped into a river without knowing how to swim. Who was now lost before Thorin’s heart had found him.
The pain, the awe, the love…. All mixed in his heart.
This was the sort of feeling that inspired the great songs, the eternal tales of love that survived dragon-fire and doom.
The word came to his lips unbidden.
Âzyungel. The love of all loves.
His One.
“I should have never let him come”, Thorin muttered, more to himself than the others. “I should have realised it before…”
Bilbo was his One, the One he’d lost all hope of ever finding. The missing piece of his soul, split in two by Mahal at the time of the forging.
Durin himself, who had woken alone, had to wander Arda in search of his One, to prove himself to be worthy of their Love. Some legends said he had found themamongst the small beardless folk that lived in the vale of Anduin, who were protected by Yavanna and not Mahal. Of course a Halfling was the One of the last of the kings of Durin’s lineage.
Thorin sank to his knees beside the rushing water, his fingers digging into the mud. The invisible crown of Erebor sat like ice on his weary brow, and for the first time since they began this quest, he wished he could cast it away. Trade all the gold in the mountain for one small hobbit's safety. To at least cradle his motionless, lifeless body in his arms one time.
“Bilbo”, he whispered to the river that had claimed him. “Forgive me”.
The only answer was the now gentle lapping waters against his sodden knees.
He wondered if hobbits could find their final rest under water, or if the body would wash up ashore days or weeks later, to disintegrate into the soil that was so dear to Yavanna’s creatures.
He wondered if flowers would grow to mark the place.
If he would ever be able to find his resting place.
After some time Fili approached cautiously, laying a hand on his uncle's arm. “We need to move, Uncle. Kili needs help”.
Thorin looked at his sister-son's ashen face, the arrow wound festering already with unnatural speed. Another failure. Another he had not protected.
He nodded mechanically, but his eyes returned to the river, its rushing waters now the keeper of his heart. Among dwarves, there was no greater tragedy than to find their One only to lose them before the bond could be acknowledged. Such dwarves were said to carry an unbearable pain within them for the rest of their days—never whole, never complete.
He had dreamed of reclaiming Erebor his entire life, had sacrificed everything for this quest, trying to give back to his people what had been taken away from them. But now, with the hollow ache spreading through his chest where once beat a full heart, he wondered if getting the mountain back would do anything to fill the gaping void he felt now. His soulmate lost before he had properly found him, claimed him. There wasn’t a greater sorrow known to dwarrow.
“Thorin”, Balin said softly, his eyes filled with understanding that made Thorin look away. His oldest friend had seen it, had known perhaps before Thorin himself realized. “We cannot linger”.
“I know”, Thorin replied, his voice rough as stone. He cast one last desperate look at the river. “But how do I leave him, Balin? How do I go on when I have only just realized what he truly meant?”
“By honoring what he gave for this quest” Balin answered. “By ensuring his sacrifice was not in vain”.
Thorin closed his eyes against the burning there, and nodded once, sharply. He turned away from the river, away from the place where his heart had been lost, and faced the distant silhouette of the Lonely Mountain. It had never seemed more aptly named than in this moment, when loneliness had become the very air he breathed.
“Let’s go”, he commanded, his voice resonant, yet oddly hollow. “We make for Lake-town”.
Even as he led them forward, a part of him remained by the riverbank.
