Actions

Work Header

Prayers For Rain

Chapter Text

Bilbo interacts with dwarves regularly; just not with the one he has set his heart on. And that’s fine, it’s not like his affections stood a chance to be returned, though Bilbo still remembers the Carrock, when he watched Thorin change from a fearsome look that could pierce dragon’s scales to I’ve never been so wrong in my life. He gets it, Thorin is passionate in everything, that hug was just his way of saying I approve of you now; no need to read more into it. But when Bilbo vouched for him in Laketown, Thorin’s eyes enveloped him with the warmest gaze; and when he found the answer in Thrór’s map at the Hidden Door, Thorin’s eyes seemed to ask more than loyalty, honor, a willing heart. Bilbo may be inexperienced in romance, and severely unqualified to date a king, but he is not a fool. What they had was the start of something real, that did not seem like a passing fling.

And yet, pass it did, as soon as Thorin entered the Mountain and shattered those great expectations Bilbo had foolishly formed - yes, he imagined a confession of feelings, possibly a night together, or hey, at least spending an evening as friends. Instead of that, gold beyond measure was all Bilbo got, from one who’d rarely cast a look in his direction.

What went on after... let’s just say he never believed they would get close again; yet they did when Thorin almost died, and by the way, since he did almost die, who could complain he doesn’t have romance in mind? Who could expect him to, when it should be enough he survived?

Such it is Bilbo meditates by candle light in his lonely room, on that blasted wall, or walking on Erebor’s barren land. If he and Thorin could talk, would he find the words to say what his mind tried to block? That chance may never come. The only way to get Thorin alone is by appointment, which so many urgently schedule each day: it would feel like cheating if Bilbo attempted it. Yet maybe he should, before calling “a lost cause” something that could have been love.

* * *

“We did not expect to see you in person, my Lord,” Balin says as he watches the Elvenking dismount his majestic elk, followed by a dozen caravans that appear to be carrying a heavy load.

“I heard His Majesty needed aid,” Thranduil says. “Trees are a treasured hobby of mine; I thought I’d lend him my own hand.”

There’s something shady about the elf coming all this way, Thorin thinks, but decides not to dwell on it. He shows him the intended planting site, and offers him chests of gold. Thranduil accepts, but has a further request: he’d like to stay in Erebor for a few days.

“To oversee the digging and replacing of soil,” he clarifies. “To offer advice, if needed.”

Right. The elf doesn’t trust dwarves know how to handle his soil. “You are welcome, of course,” Thorin magically produces instead of Why should I trust your advice. Then he is called to a court meeting, leaving the Company to attend to their guest.

The dig begins, old soil replaced by new, and soon it becomes clear Thranduil brought more than necessary for planting a single tree. The elves encourage the dwarves to use all of it. After all, there is plenty of land. Why not have a wide-stretching patch of fresh soil?

“Yeah, whatever,” Dwalin shrugs. In his absence Thorin left him in charge.

 

After dinner, Thranduil excuses himself from the king’s table and draws towards the Company’s, where the hobbit sits with his friends. He waits for Bilbo to finish eating and asks, “Would you like to go for a walk?”

Bilbo regards him in confusion. “Me?”

“I have something to show you,” Thranduil quickly adds. Bilbo has no choice but to join him.

Outside the gates of Erebor, the land breathes with fresh soil spreading in all directions.

“So that’s what the commotion was about,” Bilbo says. “I’m not sure what they’re planning to do with this land.”

“Oh, nothing of significance. It’s just, as I understand, the dwarf king wants to plant a tree out here.”

Bilbo’s eyes widen in shock. “He does?”

“Indeed. Something to reflect how great His Majesty is. He has a power complex, you see; and very little besides. I mean, come on. It’s not like he vanquished the beast that inhabited these halls.”

Thranduil doesn’t need to say it: Bilbo can hear the silent All Thorin did was lose his mind as soon as he walked in here.

“I’ve wondered why you still linger here. After how he treated you.”

Bilbo hesitates. Could he open up to Thranduil, of all people, to tell him Thorin’s madness only managed to change his hope, not his heart.

“You said you had something to show me.”

“In my kingdom, there are many things I could show you,” Thranduil replies dreamily. “Here, there is nothing. Which is why I thought I’d impart some of the splendor of my Realm onto this place.”

He takes a notebook out of his coat and flips through its delicate pages, revealing elaborate sketches of flowers. Bilbo can almost breathe their fragrance, so beautifully they are drawn and colored.

“I was thinking of a mix of perennials and Spring flowers. What do you think?”

“For what? What do you mean?”

“I think flowers would compliment the dwarf’s upcoming tree.” Thranduil gestures casually to his superb drawings. “Which ones do you like best, by the way? Lily of the valley? Hyacinth? Anemone?”

“I... my favorites are violets and forget-me-nots,” Bilbo says, unable to take his eyes off the notebook’s bewitching pages. “I am sure anything in here would look gorgeous. But... does Thorin like this idea?”

“The question is, rather, do you like it. Would you take pleasure in such a sight?”

“Of course I would. But surely they are not for me, are they?”

“I thought they should be.”

Is it possible the Elvenking has a thing for me? Bilbo wonders in disbelief. In the Shire this would be considered courting. But they’re not in the Shire. He probably doesn’t mean anything by it.

Perhaps he shouldn’t confide in Thranduil after all; yet Bilbo does need to make one thing clear.

“What you saw on the wall that day... that is not the Thorin I know.”

“If you say so. I certainly hope he has made it up to you.” Thranduil gives a slight bow and departs with an easy smile.

 

Bilbo never thought about it this way.

He almost shouts Thranduil’s name, urging him to stop and listen because no one else will, because he never has the guts to talk about it: how Bilbo wishes he’d done one thing differently that night when he visited the Elven camp. After giving the Arkenstone to Bard, he could have come back and told Thorin what he’d done, in private, not in view of a foreign army at the gates. Or, if Bilbo had been too scared to face him, he could have left Thorin a note before going to see Bard and Thranduil, and not come back to Erebor at all. You are changed, Thorin, he could have written there, and I’m leaving because I want to save what can be saved. Thus Thorin would have had a chance to be prepared; would have been spared the tearful shock at the sight of foreign hands holding the Arkenstone.

Either would have been better than Bilbo standing beside his friend the next morning, part of the Company still but not really because he betrayed him, witnessing Thorin’s humiliation when he knew it was going to come.

When he caused it.

When Bilbo thinks of it now, this part deems him more cowardly than if he’d run away; although, he supposes, the threat of war blurred the edges of right and wrong that day.

Only after Ravenhill, only after Thorin apologized did Bilbo see there was something missing on his end, too heavy to mention when he thought they would part forever and too difficult, too in-the-past to bring up now to this person who in the meantime broke free of madness and acts like a true king, who doesn’t seem to care about gold anymore.

No. Thorin doesn’t need to make it up to him.

* * *

Back at the Company’s table, Bofur has rapidly nailed the situation.

“They’ve been gone for a while.”

“Who?” Ori asks.

“The elf and the hobbit,” Balin answers. “He was pretty smooth, that cunning sly fox. He just slipped in here and before we knew it, snatched Master Baggins away.”

“If Bilbo likes his company, that is not our concern,” Thorin grumbles, beginning to regret he joined his friends. The conversation is cut short, though: Thranduil returns alone.

“King Thorin. If I may be allowed to offer a small suggestion. Concerning your... botanical project.”

Did he walk Bilbo to his door, Thorin wonders as he tries to remember his manners, and not jump out of his seat to go after Bilbo at once. He invites his guest to sit and does his best to appear at ease.

“I wonder if I might suggest the addition of flowers in proximity to your tree,” says the elf. “I understand the halfling would like that.”

“He does? Master Baggins said that?”

“He did. He said they would bring him much pleasure.”

“Then by all means,” says Thorin, briefly forgetting he has no clue where to get flowers or how to plant them.

“As it happens, I have some flowers with me in seed form. If your Highness allows, I’ll be happy to plant them.”

“I will allow it. Thank you,” Thorin says, in his hope flowers will soften Bilbo’s image of Erebor totally missing the I in I’ll plant them. Then he excuses himself and dashes out of the dining hall.

 

Bilbo is not in his room. And that is not good, because now Thorin actually has time; as in, time to think he has no right to be anywhere near him. He wanders around the halls, not looking for anyone, of course not, in fact perfectly meaning to go back to...

He spots Bilbo on the ramparts, at the scene of Thorin’s crime; his heart sinks.

“Master Baggins. Is everything all right?”

Bilbo turns to him. He doesn’t look affected or sad, just deep in thought.

“Thorin. It’s good to see you.” There is relief and apprehension in Bilbo’s voice.

“You should not be here.”

Bilbo doesn’t move; it’s clear he intends to be here.

“The Arkenstone... we never really talked about it.”

Perhaps he means to let Thorin have it.

“We can, if you wish.”

Then Bilbo is silent for a long time, and Thorin doesn’t know if it’s just him composing his thoughts, overwhelmed by anger or fear of having this conversation.

Perhaps all can be made easier if he started it.

“I am so sorry about what happened here that day. The things I did...”

“I won’t hear it.”

Thorin stops. Bilbo is right to silence him: I am sorry will not solve anything.

Then Bilbo speaks. “I am the one who should apologize.”

“No.”

“Yet I never got a chance to speak my mind. Let me do so now. I would give anything to be able to go back in time and change some of the things I’ve done. I shouldn’t have stolen from you in the first place.”

“You have not stolen anything from me,” Thorin says, realizing he’s distorting what counts as real; but he has come to feel like that for a long time.

“I betrayed you. And I went about telling you the truth in the worst possible way. At the worst possible time.”

It’s true, Thorin was hurt; the only way to make it hurt less was to weigh it against what he did. Bilbo’s betrayal was nothing compared to what he did.

“I know you did not mean to hurt me.” And you did not know how it could hurt me.

“You trusted me. And now you can’t... you can’t do so anymore. It’s something I cannot stand.”

“Bilbo. When it comes to trust, I would not put anyone above you,” Thorin says, wishing he could do something, a small gesture, clear and tender, that won’t cross the boundary of friendship but show Bilbo he still holds him in the highest regard.

Bilbo appears appeased by his words alone. “So that means we can still be friends?”

“Always.” Though Thorin knows he needs to apologize too, more properly than he did before. But not today. Let this moment be Bilbo’s alone, forgiveness and trust regained; and anyway, until Thorin can find the right words what he did is unspeakable.

“King Thranduil mentioned a tree. Are you really...”

“It’s nothing,” Thorin waves it off, because all things considered the alternative would be cheesy, to pull out the acorn from his coat and present it.

“It’s a great idea. I think it would suit you. And your kingdom.”

Then Bilbo says good night and leaves, though appears to regret doing so. And Thorin wonders why; he cannot know Bilbo is afraid to stay longer, for if he did he would say it, everything that can make this renewed friendship go down in flames again. Friends is good for today: it will hold until Bilbo can find a way to say more, to ask Thorin to be more.

 

...For what it’s worth: if he knew Thorin is kneeling outside the gates right now, mysterious and majestic in the torches’ gleaming light, his hands burying an acorn in the elven soil, praying this perfect little moment will endure, Bilbo would find the courage to talk to him again.