Chapter Text
“All right, lads,” says Bofur after his friends finished an epic battle board game and a round of drinks, their usual pastime on a Friday night. “It’s been a week since Thorin planted Beorn’s seed. Nothing has come out of the ground. Shall we take bets on how much longer it will take?”
Ori and Gloin are in.
“I say the acorn sprouts tomorrow morning!”
“My money is on three days from now!”
“How about never,” Dwalin interjects. “Obviously it should have happened already. So you guys might as well turn out your pockets now.”
Balin is of a different mind. “I say when in doubt, consult Beorn’s instructions. They should spell out every step of this mysterious process.”
“Yes, they should,” says Kili. “Only, there’s a slight problem: we lost them.”
Balin is outraged. “Well, what happened? Who had the paper last?”
Eyes turn straight to Dori, who says: “Don’t look at me. I thought it was with Nori.”
“Somebody must have taken it from my desk,” says Nori.
“I have a feeling whatever it is we’ve missed is on that paper,” mutters Fili, hit by a realization.
The dwarves become seriously agitated. Has nothing been done to recover it? Are they supposed to just sit here while a thief roams freely in Erebor?
“Let’s not lose hope. We know Beorn’s letter to Thorin mentions two simple things: sun and rain. Now, sun we’ve had plenty, but...” Bofur’s eyes turn to the meteorologist under the Mountain. “Oin, what say you?”
“This place hasn’t seen rain for a while. If you ask me, when we drew Smaug out of Erebor, he used his hurricane wings to blow a high-pressure system over it. That system stays parked there with no change in sight. So, prognosis for precipitation is negative, I’m afraid.”
“Then how come Thranduil’s flowers emerged? Surely violets and forget-me-nots need rain too?”
“Oh, I don’t know,” Dwalin sighs, tired of waiting for this point in the conversation. “Maybe it’s because he has heard of... irrigation?”
Irrigation, the dwarves repeat, thoroughly fascinated. You can actually manually water land to help stuff grow? Aye, you can, Dwalin condescends. Being project manager of tree planting has taught him a thing or two, in large part thanks to the presence of elves.
“And why has nobody brought this concept to Thorin’s attention?”
“Because Thorin, once known as a go-getter, is quickly turning into the most passive bloke I’ve ever seen. He spends hours just standing near the planting site, as if his stare alone could make that blasted tree come out. Which, by the way, at this early stage would be called a sapling,” Dwalin says authoritatively, scrutinizing the inquisitive eyes and beards before him.
“You’d think he would have made a move by now,” Dori says. “If not on the tree, then on the... other object of his affections.”
“Meanwhile the elvenking seeks Bilbo’s company at every turn. They walk every morning after breakfast: Thranduil inspecting his flowers, Bilbo admiring them.”
“And I’ve seen them take afternoon tea together,” puts in Bombur. “Every time Bilbo stops by my kitchens in search of a snack, Thranduil is with him.”
“Could the elf be courting him, then?”
“Nah. He’s probably just amusing himself. Must have guessed Thorin wants to court him, and is trying to nip that in the bud,” muses Kili. “Probably gets a sick, twisted pleasure out of it.”
“I suppose that’s possible,” Fili says. “But if the elf is actually interested in Bilbo, I’d say Thorin has some serious competition.”
“Would Thranduil court someone on foreign land, though? I would think he’d try to lure Bilbo into Mirkwood first, then sink his claws into him.”
Balin has got it. “I’ll wager that’s why he brought his own soil. He wants to court Bilbo on elvish ground. By my beard, that sneaky fox thought of everything.”
“I’ll drink to that.” Dwalin spits with disgust. “Maybe noticing what’s going on under his very nose will induce Thorin to actually make a move.”
* * *
Thorin has noticed. On the day he arrived with the soil, Thranduil figured out something the hobbit likes, gave it to him, and has spent no shortage of time in Bilbo’s company ever since. He has noticed the glow on Bilbo’s face, sometimes when accompanied by the elf king; who, by the way, is unusually relaxed and at ease these days. If Thorin has never understood the appeal of flowers, he does now: it’s clear how happy Bilbo is around them. Yes, Thranduil is likely courting him.
If Bilbo would allow such a thing... Thorin’s mind stops here, lest he slip into madness again. He’s painfully aware of how thin the line is, how easy it would be to cross it if he wondered who is more right for Bilbo: between himself and Thranduil, it is not Thorin who deserves him.
Thus his focus remains the tree, which is not growing yet, but Thorin is determined to be patient. The skinchanger’s instructions were lost soon after they arrived; he turned the Mountain upside down looking for them, then asked Erebor’s librarian for help. But the library doesn’t hold any information on planting trees or making it rain. The best Ori could find was that a king’s prayer, when said with a contrite heart, can do much for the good of his land. So Thorin composed one and offered it to Mahal. Mahal responded: I don’t do trees, my child. Seek my wife.
So Thorin wrote to Yavanna next, trying to explain the reason behind the tree, how he wronged Bilbo and nothing can make up for it, you can’t court somebody you tried to kill, but a tree could at least show Bilbo Thorin listened, and match something that matters to him.
He could have expressed himself more clearly, Thorin thinks as he reads the prayer: it’s all over the place. He offers it anyway. The paper burns on the altar deep beneath the Mountain. Thorin’s eyes close, and a vision takes him.
...Many years have passed. The tree has grown. Bilbo saw it, or maybe he didn’t, a long time ago, before he left Erebor never to return. Thorin remained to fulfill his duty as king, though his heart is fading without his love; the tree, once tall and vigorous and filled with hope, is fading with him.
“Why do you want to plant this tree?” a snappy voice transports him back to the present day. But the vision remains, a once majestic, glorious tree subject to Thorin’s horrible neglect. “Do you truly wish to grow it, cherish and care for it until the end of your days?”
“Lady Yavanna.” It must be her, putting him on the spot. Thorin has no idea what to say. His friends suggested the tree; he just went with it.
“Growing a tree begins with a commitment, much like when one wants to have a child: to raise it, cherish it, bond with it. Can you make that commitment, Thorin Oakenshield?”
“I can.”
Every time I’ll look at it, I’ll remember. Remember everything that happened. The good, the bad... and how lucky I am that I made it home.
This could be me, Thorin thinks. I can do this. I will live by these words.
“A tree will not be a means to an end,” says the voice firmly; it will not be fooled. “And it will most certainly not be subject to your fickle moods. Are we clear?”
“Yes, my Lady.”
“Promise you will care for it no matter what. Even if things don’t work out with your hobbit.”
“I promise.”
“Even if he shows no interest, no appreciation for that tree, you will.”
“I will.”
“By the way, your prayer is missing something. And it’s not the amount of guilt you’re feeling.” The voice fades before Thorin can get an answer to how in the world can anyone grow said tree.
You need to learn to articulate your feelings, Balin had told him some time between Laketown and Dale; that was when Thorin still had hope, before the ramparts occurred.
Now he can’t separate his feelings from his guilt.
Maybe the tree is not growing because he feels too much guilt.
A high-pressure system is parked over the Mountain, Oin said. I have seen no clouds, measured no wind. I’m afraid there’s no chance for rain...
Not a prayer. Something that will cement the link between his feelings and the tree. So Thorin writes again, and tries to perform what he has never been good at, putting his feelings into words. He manages, sort of; then goes to the planting site and speaks to Beorn’s acorn in the ground, while clutching the new piece of paper in his hand.
“You will not be a means to an end. You will be a symbol of my love. If my love is endless and strong, so you shall be. Which is to say: you shall be. And I will grow you, cherish you, and take care of you. I will not let you fade, no matter the weather conditions or the state of my heart.” Even if Thranduil steals my heart from me, and I remain here alone like a fool, with these cursed flowers for a daily reminder, a nasty thought quips in his mind, with zero good intentions. Thorin will ignore it: this is not about him.
* * *
Ever since he and Thorin talked on the ramparts, Bilbo has contemplated his next step. Thorin forgave him: is there anything that can stop him from confessing his feelings now? Nothing, except his own apprehension, and that he’s not used to making the first move on a king. But he just ran into Bifur today, who remarked casually he’s seen Thorin outside and Thorin didn’t look busy with anything, in fact, he’s more of a dreamer nowadays, and somewhat lonely, too, Bifur said; does Bilbo have anything planned right now? Yes, he does, but he’ll gladly skip elevenses if that means there’s a chance.
By Yavanna, there is. Thorin is kneeling at the planting site, where his tree is supposed to sprout, his face lifted toward the sky.
“Any news about your planting project? Kili mentioned the tree is supposed to come out these days.”
“It will,” Thorin says, a bit forcefully, like he’s willing himself to believe it. And then Thorin looks him fiercely in the eye, takes a warrior-like stance, and something urgent and entirely unexpected ensues.
“I need to speak with you. About what happened that day. Bilbo... All the time, during our quest, I knew what awaited me here. I didn’t need Gandalf or Elrond to express their concern when I had seen my grandfather succumb to madness before my eyes.”
“What?...”
“I could feel the change as soon as we entered the Mountain. I knew exactly what was happening to me. I just couldn’t stop it.”
“I’m... not sure where you’re going with this.”
“It was an inner fight, from the moment I ran in to when I emerged on the battlefield. I wrestled constantly with the madness, knowing it was about to take me. And it would have, if it hadn’t been for two things. One was the fact that I was needed in the battle. The other was you.”
“I don’t see how...”
“You saw the madness for what it was, and were not afraid. You made me see what I stood to lose because of it. To feel you turn against me... that was the ultimate sign that something was very wrong.”
Bilbo raises his hand in protest: that’s not how he would put it, though he does understand how Thorin felt this way.
“I do not think I can properly show you how much I regret my actions that day. But one thing I can promise you: I will never be like that again.”
Why are you telling me this? You think I do not see that you are healed, really, more than healed, you are majestic, and glorious, and ever so reliable now, to the point where I almost resent it because it probably means you don’t need me anymore
“Bilbo... what I did was unforgivable. I am sorry, more than I can say.”
“Thank you. I was not holding anything against you, but it’s... good to know,” Bilbo says, the forgiveness part already resolved in his mind, yet afraid to switch the subject too soon.
“So... I hear things. About what this coming tree is supposed to represent. A symbol of your power, your greatness, or your success in retaking Erebor?”
Thorin looks at him, positively afraid, as if he doesn’t have the courage to answer. “Redemption,” he says after some hesitation.
Thorin is more of a dreamer nowadays... No kidding, Bilbo thinks; redemption doesn’t exactly spell action.
“Thorin,” he says, timidly reaching for the dwarf king’s hands. They are shaking, and Thorin drops something, a piece of paper he must have forgotten he was holding. Their hands join over the earth where the acorn lies, and Bilbo thinks of something to say, but you’re being too harsh on yourself sounds too plain, and I forgave you long time ago is too much about the past. “Do you ever think of happiness?” he asks, suddenly struck by the heat of Thorin’s hands. Through them he feels the release of pressure, energy long held, somewhat akin to what Bilbo felt at the Carrock. Thorin had apologized then... Bilbo had been overwhelmed, because to get close to Thorin was to feel that passion, given in equal measure to retaking the Mountain and to something as small as a hug. Unlike then, Thorin is holding back now, but Bilbo can feel the same passion, a searing heat encircling his wrists. If they could put a name to it... but how to get from redemption to love is not something Bilbo thought of, even as he took all morning to work up the courage to talk to Thorin again.
“I do not think of happiness,” Thorin says. “But I can still feel it, from time to time.” Bilbo’s eyes look to the sky, suddenly darkened by a gathering of clouds. A sound of thunder is heard in the distance; a fierce, strong wind is felt in the air. Could it be?... A few drops drizzle his fingers tentatively, as if asking for permission, and Bilbo is overcome with the feeling of the first Spring rain. Can you feel it too? He searches Thorin’s eyes. Thorin looks really happy; by Iluvatar, there’s a smile, and it’s as if that smile is enough to let the rain come down. It comes as a blessing, a promise that the past is now over and done, and Bilbo feels the heat and pressure dissipate, and happiness take their place. It’s quiet now, this unnamed feeling between them, save for the sound of rain falling on the elven soil.
He doesn’t need anything more than this moment. It’s perfect: it gave Bilbo more than he hoped for. He doesn’t need to wonder how this rain feels, whether they read into it the same thing. To Thorin, it may feel like redemption; to Bilbo, it feels like love.
