Chapter Text
“Pardon me, Your Majesty. Lords Balin and Fili are waiting for you in the Treasure Hall. It appears a dispute has arisen over some misplaced gold.”
Bilbo looks up from his and Thorin’s joined hands. It’s Thranduil, waltzing toward them. He may be addressing the King under the Mountain; but the elf has eyes only for him.
“Ah. Mister Baggins. I have been looking forward to spending elevenses with you.”
“I... Thank you. But I am not taking elevenses today. I’d much rather stay out here and enjoy the rain.”
“Oh. In that case, perhaps I can enjoy it with you?”
Bilbo looks at Thorin uncertainly, hoping against all odds that somehow he can forgo duties and remain outside with him. Thorin regards him fondly; says Thank you for this moment, and wishes Bilbo a pleasant day. Then, blast it, inclines his head politely to Thranduil, and leaves.
He looks happy, still.
Bilbo stares dejectedly at the Elvenking, forcing a smile. “All right.”
“Ha,” says Thranduil as soon as they are alone. “Still no tree for the poor dwarven king. It boggles the mind, how despite his professed nickname, an actual oak refuses to grow on his land.”
“Thorin wants to plant an oak tree?” It makes sense. Bilbo should have known.
“Many of us want. Few actually go for what they want,” says Thranduil, enveloping him in a seductive gaze, though Bilbo could be mistaken. It’s probably just part of the Elvenking’s “charming” act: theatrical and exaggerated, as always.
“What’s this.” Thranduil picks up a wet piece of paper from the ground and proceeds to read. “The tree will not be a means to an end. The tree will be a symbol of my love. Awww. In King Thorin’s handwriting, no less: who would have thought?”
“To me he said the tree stands for redemption,” Bilbo says.
Thranduil laughs. “He told that to you, of course. His heart’s secrets he obviously keeps for himself, and perhaps for the person he deigned worthy of them. Oh well. We can allow a nonexistent tree to hold multiple meanings, I suppose.”
He curls the paper into a ball and looks contemptuously around, expecting not to find what he’s looking for.
“Insufferable dwarves. They don’t even know how to recycle. I guess I’ll just leave this here, since they don’t mind littering their own ground.”
He discards the paper and extends his arm. “Shall we? I have missed our walks.”
Bilbo picks up and unfolds the paper. He needs to see for himself.
It turns out: those are Thorin’s words.
A symbol of his love.
Bilbo sees Thranduil’s point. Clearly the “love” part is not for me, or else Thorin would have indicated that much; would not have left things at “redemption”. No, Thorin wanted only forgiveness from him. Love must be reserved for someone else.
This is why Bilbo hates hope; why he tries to stay grounded and set realistic goals. There’s a soft, maddeningly attractive quality even to his dismay, Thranduil will observe, at a loss as to what could have caused it, but it renders this creature even more intriguing. Alas, the hobbit does not appear eager to take his arm; he just stands there looking down, caught between defeat and a just-in expression of surprise. It will take a while for Thranduil to interpret it: to notice that sometime between now and when Thorin left, a small oak shoot has sprouted at Bilbo’s feet.
* * *
Three days later, the Company are all in uproar. Not just because there is an actual sapling at the gates of Erebor that has been growing at lightning fast speed.
Nori finally found Beorn’s instruction sheet. It appears that, in an overzealous effort at safekeeping, he concealed the paper so well even he couldn’t remember its location. Until this morning, when Dori pointed out one of his braids looked a little off. It turns out Nori had folded Beorn’s sheet origami-style, turning it into a mini diamond shape, and smuggled it into his own hair.
“So what does it say??”
“In a nutshell? The acorn is magical. It can grow into a tree super fast. Just needs a crap ton of rain; seven straight days, to be precise.”
“How about that for a good omen,” says Gloin. “Since the seed sprouted, it’s been pouring non-stop, and the sapling grows bigger with each day. Fate seems to be with our Thorin Oakenshield.”
“But can anybody explain this rain? What say you, Master “prognosis negative” Oin?”
Oin has no theory on what could have caused this overflow. But a natural phenomenon, it is not.
Balin sighs. “Honestly, lads, does it even matter anymore? The elf king is taking things so fast with Bilbo lately, with no opposition from the hobbit’s end, I don’t see what difference a tree can make. Clearly asking Thranduil for soil backfired big time.”
“What are you saying? Bilbo and Thranduil are a couple now?” Bofur asks.
“Not quite. But the elf’s gallantries around our burglar have grown exponentially,” says Bombur. “Just this evening I spotted them having a candlelit dinner, complete with Thranduil taking Bilbo’s coat, pulling his chair out, pouring wine...”
“That’s nothing compared to what I have to witness each day,” groans Dwalin.
“You mean Thranduil’s flowers?” Bofur pats him on the back. “Surely Bilbo must have grown tired of violets and forget-me-nots by now.”
“It is not of violets that I speak. The elf’s treachery runs deeper than you think: he has crossed gardenias with daffodils into some wild mutant aphrodisiac. Planted these new flowers in a separate, more secluded spot that has nothing to do with “beautifying the oak’s surroundings”. Every time I walk by I’m treated to their pungent stench. It triggers my asthma, for Mahal’s sake!”
“You have asthma?” asks Balin. This is news to him.
“It’s probably just allergies,” says Oin. “I would advise you to stay away from that spot.”
“I can’t. I have to make the rounds every day: measuring Thorin’s tree, inspecting the surroundings and talking to “expert” elves. That’s my #$@#ing job. Thanks to which yesterday I saw Master Baggins and Thranduil having a picnic in said new flower spot.”
“Ugh. That is gross,” laments Kili. “But who has a picnic in this heavy rain? That reeks of desperation if you ask me.”
“Believe it or not, Thranduil had a huge umbrella installed. They looked quite comfortable.”
“You know, I wouldn’t be surprised if Thranduil himself caused this deluge,” Dori says. “Just so he could offer Master Baggins shelter in a romantic setting. Mark my words: tacky or not, the kiss under the umbrella is next.”
Fili shakes his head. “I just don’t see Bilbo falling for this crap. If this is how hobbits court, I feel doubly sorry for him.”
“We need not assume he’s into Thranduil,” puts in Ori. “I talked to Bilbo the other day. Asked him if he enjoys the Elvenking’s company. He’s a good conversationalist, he replied. Engaging with him keeps my mind occupied, which I badly need right now. But didn’t mention courting, and didn’t seem particularly enthused.”
“That doesn’t mean much. Bilbo can keep a lot to himself,” says Bofur.
“And Thorin? What does he say? Surely he’s happy the tree is growing?”
Balin looks resigned. “Alas, Thorin is not good at expressing himself these days. He’s been awfully quiet. Other than yes and no, I haven’t heard a word from him all week.”
The quiet before the storm, Oin thinks. Something serious must be happening with him. Thorin is not one to sit and take it. Perhaps seeing Thranduil put the moves on Bilbo finally got to him.
As soon as this thought crosses Oin’s mind, he has it. It’s not the quiet before the storm. The quiet is the storm.
* * *
Thorin should be happy, indeed.
Except he can now be in no doubt of what Thranduil is doing. He has heard Dwalin’s daily reports about the new patch of flowers that the elf planted just for Bilbo. There Thranduil takes him each day, and with great pleasure watches him bathe in their intoxicating fragrance.
There is not much Thorin can do. Dwarves are a private race. If someone is on the receiving end of courting overtures, you’re not supposed to figure out their feelings: that is between the pursuer and pursued. You can just assume, if such efforts are allowed to continue, that the courted one does not disapprove of them.
But to be Thorin is to act, however repressed or constrained.
Before the acorn sprouted, he boiled with jealousy inside.
Then, a short moment of peace arrived. Simply being in Bilbo’s presence at the tree site, so close to him as to feel forgiveness he’d never hoped for, was a beautiful thing. In wonder he watched the rain materialize out of a clear blue sky - it was a light, soft rain that induced a feeling of calm over the land. And great was Thorin’s delight when he returned, and saw that his little oak had emerged.
As the day went on, Thorin heard about the new flowers, the picnics, the dinners by candle light. His jealousy returned. And as the jealousy turned to rage, he watched the soft drizzle turn into a violent storm.
With each day, both storm and Thorin’s rage intensified.
Five days into it, he wonders at the sheer magnitude of this rage: it should not be able to be contained.
Then it occurs to him: it is possible it is not contained.
Your feelings can produce rain, confirms Oin. Your rage is literally overflowing; it's working miracles for the tree. Keep it up. Two more days, and the oak will be fully grown.
It does not feel right. Thorin preferred the peace that created the first rain. It is your rage, not peace, that produces the ideal weather conditions your tree needs, replies Oin. Let Thranduil keep up his stupid act; trust me, you will have the last laugh.
Thorin should be happy. The tree grows.
What’s more, per Dwalin’s latest report, the new weather has started to affect Thranduil’s new flowers. The brutal downpour must be more than they can withstand. Thorin can’t resist a surge of triumph: his rage, his rain. Perhaps he really has the weather under control. Yet control is an elusive thing.
Every day, Thorin takes time to visit his tree, hoping to avoid crossing paths with Bilbo and Thranduil. Today, however, he spots Bilbo standing alone in the “picnic” area, watching the delicate flowers getting crushed by the rain.
“Master Baggins.” Thorin approaches unthinkingly, forgetting about his tree. “Is something the matter?”
“These flowers. They are dying,” says Bilbo sadly. “I’ve grown very attached to them.”
Thorin takes a resentful look at the infamous daffodenias. Their sensual perfume must have died down; he can’t smell anything.
“I am sorry.”
“Well, it’s not your fault. It’s just... this rain. It’s too much for them.”
As it turns out, Thorin has some form of control. Not constant or reliable by any means, but volatile as he is; nevertheless, control. For as soon as he sensed Bilbo’s sadness his internal rage ceased. And Bilbo felt the change, turned his face to the sky, and saw the rain stop before his eyes.
* * *
“We need a word alone with you, my King.”
It’s Dwalin and Oin. They don't seem to care that Thorin is having a private moment. They whisk him away as the clouds lift, making way for the sun. Bilbo remains behind, struck with amazement at the sudden and utterly coincidental weather change.
“The rain has stopped,” begins Oin. “What in Durin’s name have you done?”
“It was killing the flowers.”
“Come again?”
“Bilbo likes those flowers. The rain was destroying them.”
“Are you out of your mind?”
“I don’t want to deprive him of his pleasure.”
“Just to be clear, we’re talking about the flowers Thranduil planted without your consent, for the purpose of seducing your One.”
Yes, Thorin knows. Mahal, there are times when subtlety would be a blessing to the dwarven race.
“Anyone in their right mind would want to halt the elf’s wretched attempt.”
“Then I must not be in my right mind.”
“So you’re going to let this tree-shagger steal Bilbo from you?”
“Bilbo is not mine.”
“At this rate, he’s not going to be.”
Thorin knows this too, just as he knows love is all-powerful; it cannot be stopped. If Bilbo has feelings for the elf, there is nothing anyone can do.
“I’m only going to point out,” says Dwalin severely, “that by stopping the rain, you’re neglecting your magical tree. Which you were, as I recall, supposed to care for like it’s your baby.”
“Bilbo likes the flowers,” Thorin repeats, and walks away from them before he will properly go mad, and then there’s no telling what the weather will be like. Also, Dwalin has a point: he’d better attend to the tree.
* * *
To his surprise, Bilbo joins him.
“I just wanted to say, your tree reminds me of something. That hasn’t happened yet, actually. It’s just how I imagined the oak I would plant in my garden, in Bag End. But watching a tree grow so unnaturally fast, in real time...” Bilbo laughs. “Didn’t expect that. Of all places, in Erebor.”
When are you going to tell Bilbo it’s for him, the dwarves’ voices stir in Thorin’s mind.
“The tree looks gorgeous, Thorin, by the way.”
At the right moment, I will.
“Thank you.”
“Still. You cheated,” says Bilbo with playful reproach in his voice. “No doubt for some honorable reason that shall not be disclosed.”
“I have a problem with time.”
Maybe Thorin can attempt to explain. Maybe this is the right moment to reveal what the tree is for.
“Time? I see. Oh, well. We all have our problems.”
“I have a problem with deadlines that are impossible to meet.”
“Surely there can be no deadline for redemption,” Bilbo says, looking suggestively at the tree. “Especially when you already have it.”
“No,” says Thorin. “But there can be a deadline for love.” Then he completely abandons the privacy rules of his race and plainly examines him, searching for a clue as to whether Bilbo is in love, or that Thranduil has taken the next step with him. Nothing stands out; Bilbo appears subdued, and careful not to move the conversation too far.
“I can’t imagine anyone imposing such a deadline on you,” he says, and then quickly changes the subject. “Thorin. I wanted to ask, about earlier. Do you not wonder how it is possible the rain stopped the very moment I complained about it?”
“I do not.”
“There is a saying, a sort of joke among Hobbits. That if you can stop rain with a comment, your next challenge should be to come up with a comment that will bring it back.”
“It’s not a comment. It’s a state of mind.”
“I felt it,” says Bilbo unexpectedly. “Five days ago, here, I... I could have sworn. The rain... it’s like it mirrored your state of mind.”
“Did you truly feel so?”
“Yes. But later, it turned into something obnoxious and loud, and...”
“And...?”
“I wondered if someone sabotaged that peaceful rain.”
“No,” Thorin says. “It’s possible somebody sabotaged my state of mind.”
Then Thorin regards him very seriously and says:
“It is the hardest thing you’ll ever learn, Bilbo. How not to let your internal state be swayed. By your own thoughts, by what happens around you. That stillness... it cannot be bought with a million diamonds. I wish I could learn it. But I am not known for such self-control.”
“Neither am I,” says Bilbo lightly. “But. I kind of like you lacking self-control.”
He makes to leave, with again that worriedly annoyed look as if he’s said too much but what the hell, and Thorin wonders at the carefree way Bilbo talks, despite appearing nervous and reserved; it’s the second time he complimented him.
“Master Baggins. Before you leave...”
Bilbo turns to him.
“I was thinking about taking the day off today.”
“Really? You can actually take a day off?”
Thorin smiles. “I guess I shall find out. My wish is to spend some time outside. And I would love to have your company.”
Bilbo hesitates. “Thranduil and I are about to go on a horse ride. After that’s done, if it’s not too late... yes, I would love to, Thorin.” Then Bilbo’s face changes rapidly to wow, what was that. A bolt of lightning just struck extraordinarily close, followed by the loudest thunder.
Thorin inspects the sky with a frown. He will remain calm.
“Very well. I will be here, Bilbo. Enjoy your ride.”
The tree will not be a means to an end.
The tree will be a symbol of my love.
And my gift to you, my other soul-part, my Heart. Two days from now, I will present it to you, no matter what.
“I promised to take care of you,” he whispers reassuringly to the tree. “I am going to find a way. You will continue to grow, rain or not.”
And Thorin can hear a deep humming sound ranging from middle tones to very low, coming from underground and rising slowly to the tree top. The young oak is talking, in a language no hobbit, elf or dwarf can discern. Long will the king remain by its side: the tree has responded to him.
