Actions

Work Header

We could have it all ~ who said we couldn’t

Chapter 2: This was your plan, then

Summary:

Bilbo persuades Bard to withdraw his men, allowing Thorin time to recover from dragon sickness.
He and Gandalf have a heated confrontation.

Notes:

Hi! Second chapter of this story!

I hope you'll like it!

Written for: First Steps (Gingerbread edition)

Chapter Text

Climbing down the wall was not Bilbo’s idea of fun, but it was something that had to be done.

 

Thranduil might have been a hopeless fool, but Bilbo knew Bard’s heart, and he knew the man wanted only peace.

 

He would understand that Thorin was not himself and would act accordingly.

 

“An army of Orcs, approaching.” Bilbo heard Gandalf’s voice, a wave of relief washing over him. Surely, Gandalf would know how to fix Thorin’s troubled mind.

 

“And where are these Orcs, Mithrandir?” Thranduil asked.

 

“Since when is my warning treated with such derision?” Gandalf huffed.

 

“Always, at least in the Shire,” Bilbo said, stepping confidently into the tent where the two kings and the wandering wizard were gathered. “Bard, it’s good to see you alive. Kili told me you killed Smaug. Congratulations.”

 

“Bilbo.” Bard smiled. “I don’t think I’ve ever been happier to see someone alive before.”

 

Bilbo felt embarrassed. “I know Thorin’s actions aren’t honourable right now, but he isn’t himself. He hasn’t been since he first laid eyes on the gold.”

 

“Like every dwarf,” Thranduil said scornfully. “They cannot be trusted.”

 

“And yet an elf who turns his back on a group of children and women—sick, injured, and seeking shelter, food, and care—can be?” Bilbo retorted, glaring at him. “I was shocked to hear you offered aid to Lake Town and its people. And then you brought an army to reclaim some blasted gems!”

 

“They belonged to my wife,” Thranduil said, his eyes flashing with irritation. “Heirlooms of my people are not easily surrendered.”

 

“Your wife also left you a son, if you recall.” Bilbo shot back, narrowing his eyes further. “What do you think she would consider more important?”

 

Thranduil flinched, as though the mere mention of his son was a painful memory.

 

Bilbo took a deep breath. “Thorin is afflicted by a sickness. Dragon sickness, as Balin called it.” Shaking his head, Bilbo turned to Bard. “He’s not himself. Otherwise, he’d never turn his back on anyone suffering as he and his people have.”

 

Bard remained silent. After a moment of hesitation, he asked, “When he recovers, if he does, will he honour his word?”

 

“Yes,” Bilbo answered confidently. “And Balin has said he should respect the contracts he signed before falling into the sickness. I’ll try to see if I can get him to yield what should be my share.”

 

Bard nodded. “Then I won’t lead my people to war over a bit of gold. It seems, instead, that an army of Orcs is on its way.”

 

Bard nodded toward Gandalf, who smiled at Bilbo, though there was something off in his eyes.

 

“Quite right. I’ve seen them with my own eyes. Orc armies, led by Azog himself,” Gandalf said gravely.

 

Bilbo frowned. “Did you see a large Orc with metal plates on him?”

 

The three of them turned curious, questioning gazes toward him.

 

“Fili and Kili told me about his presence in Lake Town,” Bilbo explained. “And I don’t think Tauriel and Legolas managed to kill him. If he’s not following Azog, despite hunting my dwarrows… where is he?”

 

“Perhaps my son and the captain of my guard will have news for us when they return,” Thranduil said, rising from the chair he’d had brought into his tent, like a kind of second throne. “In the meantime, I’ll ready my men.”

 

“And I mine,” Bard promised. “Bilbo, you’d best warn your dwarves—” Bilbo blushed as he realised how he’d referred to them aloud, “—about the approaching Orc army. Perhaps news of a real battle will shock Thorin’s mind enough to wake him from the stupor he’s fallen into.”

 

Bilbo smiled at Bard, bowing to him and Thranduil. “Thank you.” Then, looking at Thranduil, he asked, “Don’t you know how to help a dwarf overcome dragon sickness, King Thranduil?”

 

“No.” Thranduil shook his head, looking regretful. “I would have helped Thror back then. The only thing that might have saved Thorin would have been staying as far away as possible from the gold cursed by the dragon. I don’t know what drove him to reclaim that desolate land.”

 

Gandalf cleared his throat. “It doesn’t matter. We’ll find a way to help Thorin, Bilbo. Come, it’s nearly dawn.”

 

Bilbo followed Gandalf after offering another nod of thanks and farewell to the two kings in the tent.

 

“I’m surprised,” Gandalf murmured after they had walked for a while. “Thorin hasn’t found the Arkenstone, then?”

 

“Not yet,” Bilbo replied honestly. “But we’re all searching for it in the hoard.”

 

“Strange,” Gandalf murmured again.

 

“It’s a large hoard. Thorin said he saw it fall into the gold when Smaug arrived, but with all the movements Smaug made over time, who can say where it’s ended up?” Bilbo shivered. “I just hope Smaug didn’t decide to eat it.”

 

“I don’t think it ended up inside Smaug,” Gandalf shook his head. “Not when it was the thing that called to him in the first place.”

 

“What?” Bilbo blinked, staring at Gandalf in shock. “The Arkenstone triggers dragon sickness?”

 

“I’m afraid so,” Gandalf nodded. “It’s been linked to madness since it was discovered. Assuming it contributes to mental illness is no surprise, Bilbo.”

 

“But…” Bilbo blinked again. “You told Thorin to take the Arkenstone to unite the seven Dwarf kingdoms and rally them to war! If the Arkenstone is the root of all this… You’ve just driven Thorin into madness!”

 

“Now, Bilbo…” Gandalf began, but Bilbo interrupted him.

 

“No hedging. Why did you push Thorin to reclaim Erebor?” Bilbo demanded, recalling Gandalf’s argument with Elrond.

 

The Elven king hadn’t spoken out of disdain for dwarves. He’d been genuinely concerned for Thorin and his mind.

 

“Well, it was time for it to be reclaimed from Smaug’s clutches,” Gandalf replied.

 

“No, you wanted stronger defences in the East!” Bilbo retorted, his voice rising and drawing the attention of a few passing elves. “You admitted it to Lord Elrond in Rivendell! Don’t deny it—I heard the conversation! And so did Thorin!”

 

Gandalf paused, blinking. “Bilbo, I…”

 

“Why did you want a burglar who wasn’t a dwarf?” Bilbo pressed. “Thorin and Balin told me Nori was chosen for that very reason—to have a skilled and capable thief. So, why me?”

 

“Well, Smaug had never smelled a hobbit, so…” Gandalf began to explain.

 

“Curiosity wouldn’t have kept me alive,” Bilbo interrupted dryly. “I know because it didn’t keep Smaug occupied for long. He could sense dwarves nearby, and that was enough for him!”

 

“Well, you aren’t a dwarf,” Gandalf admitted at last. “And, as a hobbit, you don’t have a king. Hobbits don’t recognise kings.”

 

“You wanted someone in the Company who would find the Arkenstone but wouldn’t hand it over to Thorin just because he wore a crown?” Bilbo blinked. “Knowing the danger I’d face, given how obsessed Thorin is with that shiny stone?”

 

“Well, I thought you’d keep your distance once you realised the danger the dwarves were in,” Gandalf scratched his chin, looking somewhat guilty.

 

“You wanted me to betray him.” Bilbo realised. “Even now, you thought I’d give the Arkenstone to Thranduil?”

 

“And Bard, whom you trust and get along with,” Gandalf reminded him sternly.

 

Bilbo refused to take the bait. “Thranduil was there anyway, and whatever trust I may have in Bard is nothing compared to the trust I have in Thorin.” Then, shaking his head and glaring at Gandalf, he added, “You recruited me to Thorin’s company only to have me betray him in the end.”

 

“I thought you’d see reason, while all the dwarves were blinded by Durin’s line,” Gandalf sighed wearily.

 

“I am Thorin’s burglar, and I signed a contract to join Thorin’s Company—not Gandalf’s!” Bilbo exclaimed, wagging a finger accusingly in Gandalf’s face. “If you want a hobbit to play double agent for you, you picked the wrong hobbit! I am a Baggins of Bag End, and I gave my sacred word to see this through, and I will!” Bilbo narrowed his eyes. “Fortunately, Bard and Thranduil have better minds than yours. Otherwise, I don’t know where we’d all be. And now, I have preparations for war to begin.”

 

Bilbo stormed away from Gandalf, shaking his head.

 

“Don’t bother following me,” he added. “I know the way back to the Mountain just fine.”