Sorry, you need to have JavaScript enabled for this.

 

Actions

Work Header

We could have it all ~ who said we couldn’t

Summary:

Thorin hasn't been himself for a while. Bilbo gets his confirmation when he sees how Thorin reacts to the arrival of the survivors from Lake Town and how he goes back on his word and honour.

Notes:

Hi! We all love a proper fix-it of the BoTFA right?

Well, I do, so here's one of the possible way it could have gone! (I could write more of this what ifs with Happy Ending, cause I don't hate you)

Anyway, this is written for: Prompt: A Heart of Ice (Gingerbread edition - Fandom Free Bingo)

Chapter 1: Something’s odd, something’s cold

Chapter Text

There was something wrong.

Bilbo knew things had been different since the Mountain had been reclaimed.

And since the Arkenstone had gone missing.

Balin had confided in him, during a moment when Thorin had allowed the Company some rest—interrupting their frantic search just long enough to let everyone eat something—that Thorin had seen the gem fall into the treasure with his own eyes and that nothing could make him forget that exact moment.

The Arkenstone was not only in the Mountain, but Thorin had also seen it fall, tumbling straight into the vortex created by Smaug as the dragon coiled into Erebor's gold.

Bilbo sighed, running a hand over his face.

He could understand the desperate need to rally the dwarrows and reclaim Erebor before Smaug was killed.

But weeks had passed, and Thorin was still determined to find a single luminous stone amidst an entire treasure —mountains of gold that reached the ceiling. Quite a high ceiling, at that.

Bilbo sighed again, casting a glance towards the dwarf in question.

Thorin's search for the Arkenstone had grown more frenzied recently. As soon as word of the survivors from Lake-town had reached him, Thorin had become… more intense in his resolve to protect the treasure from any potential thieves .

It unnerved Bilbo slightly, as he wondered when—and how long—it would take for Thorin to decide that Bilbo could not be trusted either.

Would he kill him? Throw him to the enemies?

Bilbo sighed once more, feeling weary.

He was playing a dangerous game, and he knew it—keeping the stone tucked into one of the pockets of his coat.

All it would take was one unplanned movement, and Thorin would notice the sinister and far-too-bright glow, and then…

Well, Thorin had said he would have his revenge if anyone dared to conceal from him his rightful claim—the King's jewel.

"Master Baggins," Thorin had found him in his private corner of reflection, far from the crowd. "I was beginning to wonder if you had vanished."

"Vanished? To where?" Bilbo huffed, then shrugged. "I missed the sunlight," he admitted, neither lying nor telling the whole truth.

"The sunlight?" Thorin frowned, a glimmer of his old self showing through.

Perhaps Bilbo simply needed to be his irritatingly honest self, and the gold's hold on Thorin would fade out of sheer surprise and confusion .

"There isn't much sunlight after Durin's Day, I'm afraid," Thorin informed him, sounding strangely guilty for an event entirely beyond his control.

It was a peculiar thing, if Bilbo was honest.

Thorin ought to feel guilty for calling Bilbo a grocer , considering all Bilbo had done was save the lives of those ungrateful dwarrows.

"I know, but the rays still get through, past the incoming clouds." Bilbo pointed to a brighter spot, slightly less overcast and allowing a bit more sunlight through. "It's not the Shire, but it still feels like home."

"I see," Thorin murmured, though Bilbo would wager he'd said it only to avoid admitting he hadn't understood a word.

Dwarrows and their foolish pride.

"I suppose winter in Erebor won't be to your liking, then," Thorin said, speaking almost casually.

" Perhaps I really should return to the Shire, then," Bilbo replied. "Just to avoid the freezing cold you seem so confident about."

Thorin's expression darkened suddenly. "You cannot."

" Excuse me ?" Bilbo raised an eyebrow, both irritated and surprised. He hadn't been serious, of course, but for Thorin to presume he could keep him there against his will… "As far as I know, my contract has been fulfilled! I was to get past Smaug."

"And retrieve the Arkenstone, which has yet to be found," Thorin muttered.

"The contract doesn't mention the stone at all, to be honest," Bilbo said, frowning as he stared at Thorin. "I suppose Balin didn't think to include that clause. Quite the oversight on his part."

"Well, the contract certainly mentions it," Thorin said, looking embarrassed, and Bilbo grinned in response.

"Balin didn't write the contract, did he?" Bilbo asked, already knowing the answer.

"It was a very important contract, and I decided it was the king 's responsibility to handle the details when it came to an outsider ," Thorin grumbled, looking incredibly insulted by Bilbo’s words.

"Well," Bilbo coughed, trying to stifle the laugh bubbling up his throat, "I suppose you should have left it to Balin , then. He seems far better suited to that sort of thing."

"This is not amusing, Master Baggins," Thorin glared at him. "I will not let those usurpers take anything that is mine . Ever ."

"Er… what ?" Bilbo blinked, confused by the sudden ice in Thorin's voice.

The king's hand closed around Bilbo's arm—firm, yet still gentle. "Come now," Thorin said, decisively steering Bilbo back towards the Mountain's interior. "We've lingered outside long enough."

Bilbo allowed himself to be led by the king, knowing deep down that something was not right.

That something was terribly wrong .