Sorry, you need to have JavaScript enabled for this.

Actions

Work Header

a creature of grief and dust

Summary:

Thorin walked hand-in-hand with Dwalin down the steps towards Erebor's great gate. His heart was being rabbit-fast in his chest, but from grief or fear, he was not sure. Bilbo had been dear to Gandalf, they all knew that. Gandalf had been wroth with them when they would not tell the wizard of Bilbo's whereabouts after the Battle of Five Armies, though Thorin had no part in that. He had been confined to the healer's tents then, too injured to see anyone. By the time Thorin was able to have visitors once again Gandalf had quit the area to places unknown.

Notes:

Here's the next fic in the passing of mysteries series! *evil cackle*

(See the end of the work for more notes.)

Work Text:

 

        Thorin walked hand-in-hand with Dwalin down the steps towards Erebor's great gate. His heart was being rabbit-fast in his chest, but from grief or fear, he was not sure. Bilbo had been dear to Gandalf, they all knew that. Gandalf had been wroth with them when they would not tell the wizard of Bilbo's whereabouts after the Battle of Five Armies, though Thorin had no part in that. He had been confined to the healer's tents then, too injured to see anyone. By the time Thorin was able to have visitors once again Gandalf had quit the area to places unknown.

        Then had come the news that the Shire had fallen and all the world was upturned. More news had come out of Gondor, stating that Mordor's gates had fallen and that some great explosion had taken place in that black land. Some claimed that Orodruin had destroyed that entire land, causing a giant sinkhole to swallow all of that land whole. So far none had dared to brave those fallen gates, though word was that Steward Ecthelion II of Gondor was going to send parties there soon. But it was the news of the Shire's destruction that had caused the most concern. Many nations across Arda relied on the goods that came from that fertile land. The loss of such a breadbasket was sure to cause tensions across all the lands.

        The stairs that led up to the battlements were some of the few that were still sturdy enough to walk on in all of the upper levels. Thorin remembered that much from the gold-sickness, talking in depth with Bofur in the rooms about the treasury about the structural integrity of the Mountain and how much work would need to be done to make sure it did not come down about their ears with one misplaced hammer hit. It would be a decade before they would be able to access the upper halls as it was, for Bofur – after the gold-sickness and while Thorin had their people searching for Bilbo's body – had gone through what areas of the Mountain he could get into for a better, less impaired, look.

        The results of that study were rather grim.

        The dragon had done much damage to Erebor in its years there. At least two of the main support pillars were cracked all the way through. It was going to take years of work to repair that – if they even could. Bofur was hopeful that what remained of their artisan clans would come out of the hamlets in the Blue Mountains to lend their expertise in such work. As it was Bofur and the Ur clan were miners by trade – Bifur's toy making aside – and as such, construction of the interior of Erebor had never been theirs to study. Thorin's people had lost more than their home when the dragon came, clans being torn apart by the stress of their evacuation of the Mountain and their attempts at finding a new home, leaving huge gaps in their people's knowledge and apprenticeships.

        The stairs led to a wide hall beyond the gates, where once the King's Guard would have commanded. They were currently using those barracks to house Dáin and his people from the Iron Hills while their warriors healed from their wounds and returned home. Dáin himself had stayed while Thorin was recovering, not letting anyone question Thorin's claim on the crown. It was a kindness Thorin had not expected.

        Caravans of their people were starting to arrive as the fall days grew colder and colder. Thorin worried the most about how they were going to get through the winter with so many people under their roof. The dragon had destroyed the fields of the people of Lake-town and Thorin was not about to beg for help from Thranduil. Balin had broached the idea of sending some of their traders to Rohan or Gondor for foodstuffs. Thorin had agreed to it. Gold they had in plenty but gold would not feed their people.

        It was a pity he had not learned that lesson before...

       Thorin gave himself a shake and tried to focus on the here and now. He had cast off all the trappings of kingship that he had draped himself in during the madness of the gold-sickness, leaving just a small circlet to wear when he was out in public. Once he was in his rooms he refused to wear it at all. His people – and Dáin's – gave him short bows as they passed, all of them already full of tasks set out by either Balin or Bofur and hopefully Bombur soon, since Thorin had put that trusted dwarf in charge of the food and meals for all their people. Thorin and Dáin had had some short talks about perhaps relying on Dáin's own stores to get Thorin's people through the worst of winter but Thorin was reluctant to do so. Politics were a messy thing and Thorin had already heard from Nori and his growing herd of informants that there were grumblings about Thorin and his people putting strain on the Iron Hills folk as it was.

        The great gate of Erebor had changed much since Gandalf, Bard, and Thranduil had been there last. All of the rocks at the base of the gate had been cleared in the search for Bilbo's body, inadvertently speeding up the clean up from the dragon's damage in that area by weeks, if not months. The wide swaths of dying grass on either side of the road that led to their gates had been cleared of rubble. The damage done to the two Guardians of the Gate was being assessed. There were tents set up on those grassy areas, some for the workers that had already arrived, while their main kitchens were still set up outside since they were still unsure as to how sound the lower levels of the Mountain were.

        The work ran nonstop. They did not dare go any slower. Not with winter so close.

        At the entrance to the gates stood a tall horse with a lone rider just swinging down from the saddle. Gandalf's robes were stained with dust and his tall, pointed hat was bent at the tip but his eyes were as sharp and clear as ever. Thorin stepped forward, dropping Dwalin's hand. Bilbo's death was his alone to bear, though none of the Company agreed with him on that. They each blamed themselves for it, in different ways. The dwarrow in the surrounding tents had all stopped to see what was going on. Thorin saw all the members of his Company start to appear from all directions, gathering behind him in front of Erebor's great gate.

        “Thorin Oakenshield,” Gandalf was the first to speak. There was a murmur from the gathering crowd. Thorin saw Dáin push through them to stand to Thorin's right, his cousin glancing between Thorin and the wizard with a deep frown gathering on his face. “I am here to get answers from you at last.”

       Thorin swallowed, feeling a hard lump in his throat for a moment. Then, with shaking fingers he took the simple circlet from his head and knelt before Gandalf, placing it at his feet. There were shocked cries from all around him. Dáin started forward but two of Nori's people stopped him. All Thorin could do was stare up into that dark gaze. “Bilbo is gone,” Thorin said. His voice did not break at least. “After we turned you and the others from the gates in our madness Bilbo tried to reason with us. Tried to explain...” Thorin could not finish the sentence for all the breath had left his body. He sucked in a shaky breath. “Bilbo tried to explain that he had exchanged his part of the gold for your help. That he had a plan ,” this time his voice did break. Thorin closed his eyes for a moment, seeing Bilbo again on that battlement, pale and tired and so sad. Thorin opened his eyes. “I declared Bilbo Outcast then. A Betrayer. A Thief.” He shook his head. “And then in my madness I took him by the throat and dangled him over the gates. Then I let go.”

       “That halfling stole the Arkenstone, of course you –”

       “What stealing could Bilbo have done?” Thorin looked at a furious Dáin and shook his head. “The Arkenstone was trapped in solid gold . There was no way Bilbo could have stolen it. Bofur had to chip it out of that mess himself. Bilbo killed Smaug,” Thorin growled at his scowling cousin. “And I declared him Outcast for it. I have brought shame to my entire people, to my entire line. And now,” Thorin looked back to Gandalf who had not moved a muscle the entire time they were speaking. “Now the Shire is gone,” he whispered. “Gone in dragon fire. Destroyed. And I cannot think but that I am the cause of that as well.”

       Silence settled around them. Still Gandalf did not move. Those aged hands were curled tight about his staff, the joints and veins more pronounced than Thorin could ever remember them being. There was a light to the wizard's eyes that made the hairs on the back of Thorin's neck stand on end. One by one his Company knelt behind him, then dwarf after dwarf copied them, pulling the hats from their heads, still and silent as Gandalf's gaze did not leave Thorin for a second. Dáin was the very last to kneel.

        Then Gandalf sighed and it felt like the whole world sighed with him. “Get up, Thorin Oakenshield, King Under the Mountain.” The title should have felt like validation. It felt more like a slap in the face, instead. “There are things you and I must speak of. Get up, King Thorin. If you truly feel that you are beholden to Bilbo and his people then to make restitution you must be on your feet. Rise!”

        Thorin stumbled to his feet, feeling Dwalin surge to his side and take his arm. Thorin did not dare bend to pick up his simple crown, leaving it instead at Gandalf's feet. The wizard looked down at it, the end of his staff moving it over the gravel. Then the wizard bent and picked it up, holding it in one hand, careful and gentle, as he looked it over.

        “An interesting choice to wear, King Thorin. Perhaps there is hope for you, yet.” Then the wizard held it out for Thorin to take. He did so with shaking hands, curling his fingers about the cool metal, not willing to put it on in front of Gandalf or his people. Not yet. Not when it felt like he did not deserve it.

        “We can speak inside the gates,” Balin was the one to say with a quick look at Gandalf. “There are rooms and chairs there a plenty.”

       “Then lead us onward, good sir,” Gandalf said. The dwarrow gathered had not moved, aside from getting to their feet when Thorin did. He had little time to look at Dáin as he fell into step with Gandalf, heading for the gate. Thorin did not know why stories about Bilbo being a thief were circulating the Iron Hills tents. Bilbo was the Dragonslayer. Bilbo was the Savior of Erebor. That was how Bilbo should be remembered. Not as a thief.

        Balin led them to a large room they were using as a council chamber for the time being. It had seats enough for the entire Company and Gandalf too. The wizard took the seat closest to the fire, a sigh leaving him such that Thorin had never heard before. Gandalf set his staff to one side and pulled out his pipe but did not light it, choosing instead to stare into the fire. Thorin stood before him, not quite daring to sit.

       “You have done a grave harm, King Thorin, far more than you think you know,” Gandalf said as the silence went on for a moment too long. “Sit and tell me in detail all that you can remember from the moment you entered the Mountain.”

        Thorin sat and the tale he told was long. Long enough that food had to be brought and drink as well. Long enough that his voice cracked and Dwalin pulled a chair up to his side, not caring that the wizard saw them take hands as Thorin explained the descent into gold-sickness, the madness that they still could not understand, the paranoia and fury that possessed them all. All throughout the long tale Gandalf's expression barely wavered. But, at the end, when Thorin had laid all their sins bare, did the wizard finally sit back with a sigh and run a trembling hand over his eyes.

        “What a wretched mess,” Gandalf said. “What an awful, wretched mess.”

        “Yes,” Thorin agreed.

       Gandalf's hand dropped and Thorin was rewarded by a sharp glare. “You declared Bilbo Outcast,” he repeated. Thorin nodded, frowning when Gandalf's glare grew deeper. “Perhaps it was kinder that you dropped Bilbo from that gate, for if you had not every second Bilbo stayed in this Mountain would cause him agony.”

        “What?” Multiple voices choked the word out, Thorin's included.

        Gandalf sighed and finally reached out for a taper to light his pipe. “Hobbits,” he said after a few deep puffs, “abide by their own Rules. I'm sure you figured that much out on your own.”

       Thorin ducked his head and nodded. It had been so frustrating dealing with Bilbo at first. None of them knew why he acted so strangely. Not until Bilbo began to make offhand comments about his culture and the Shire. Then things had started to come into better focus but they were so deep into the Quest by then that there was nothing they could do about it except forge on. And then when they reached the Mountain...

        Well.

        “Once, long ago, hobbits lived a very different life,” the fire flickered light over Gandalf's face, making him seem...different for a moment. Younger. Thorin blinked and the illusion was gone. “They lived not far from here, in fact, all along these lands. They had Rules they had to live by and any straying from them, any crossing of those lines, was met with swift and permanent repercussions. To be declared Outcast...” Gandalf closed his eyes for a moment. “It would cause them to have physical injuries. Each step would open their feet, as if they were walking on broken glass. If they lingered too long they would start to have other physical injuries. Dislocated joints or even broken bones. They either had to leave the area they were Outcast from – a fate that was often a death sentence – or die by inches in agony until their bodies could not take any more pain.”

        Thorin pressed a hand to his mouth. “We searched,” he said when he had mastered his stomach. “I swear to you, we searched the rocks below the gate. We wanted...we wrote to the Shire. We wanted to give him a hero's funeral, to find out how his kind celebrated the dead. But the ravens...”

        “Yes,” Gandalf sighed again. “All was gone. I went there myself to see. Nothing remains. Not a single dwelling, not even their hidden stores. It was as if every hobbit in the Shire and all their possessions disappeared at the same time and something came in after to make sure they could never go back.”

        “But how?” Balin was the one to ask. All gazes shifted to him. “They did not even know of our dishonor to Bilbo. They wouldn't...they wouldn't blame the lad, would they?”

        Gandalf exhaled a long stream of smoke. For a moment it almost looked like Bilbo's round front door. “No,” he said after a moment. “And yes.”

        Thorin bowed his head.

        “But as I know these people, they would never have done something so drastic to their own homes and fields, not without a meeting of widows under the new moon. Then answers would have been gotten whether Bilbo liked it or not, had he really been worthy of being declared Outcast. But the physical punishment would have started immediately, with or without the widows' interrogation.” Gandalf's gaze went to the fire again, his pipe tapping at his lips. “But there was no body?”

        “None,” Thorin said. “We turned over every stone. There was nothing left of Bilbo there.”

        “Strange,” Gandalf murmured. The light from the fire reflected oddly in his eyes. “And when you lifted your pronouncement?”

        Thorin had to look away.

       “Thorin Oakenshield. You did lift that pronouncement.”

        “We were waiting,” he told the fire, unable to look Gandalf in the face as he spoke. “To know what we must do to honor him in the way of his people. We were waiting for you.”

       Thorin flinched back when Gandalf thrust the mouth of his pipe at him. “Then get up at once. You must lift the title of Outcast from Bilbo immediately. If he lingers...”

        Thorin felt a chill wash over him. “If he...lingers?”

        Gandalf's mouth opened. Closed. Then, “Sometimes, if a death is...painful enough, I have seen hobbits vanish from the face of the earth. Even I do not know where they go. But sometimes they come back and if they are suffering under any such judgments – rightfully so or not – they can become...tormented. Hobbits, you see, are made of far sterner stuff than even I,” Gandalf shook his head, his gaze going distant once more. “They had to be, coming from where they were. It is an awful sight to see a hobbit so tortured, Thorin Oakenshield. It will haunt you for the rest of your days. So get up, right now, and lift this judgment on Bilbo Baggins of Bag End. Perhaps that will allow him to rest, should he linger here.”

       “You think he's here?”

        “Where else would he be?” Gandalf said. “Up you get, King Thorin! Lift this false judgment at once!”

       “But how?” Thorin cried, already on his feet. “What do I do? Do I just say the words? I have said them hundreds of times!” Dwalin was at his side, hands curled into fists. So many times they had come together at night, whispering prayers to Bilbo's spirit, asking him for forgiveness.

        But, perhaps...perhaps they had never forgiven him. Perhaps they had never taken back those words in such explicit terms. Oh, they had mourned their words, Thorin had cursed himself for them so many times, but had they...had he...

        “You must go to the spot where the judgment was given,” Gandalf said. The fire surged in the grate, casting shadows over the wizard's face. “You must repent your words and deeds. You must ask him for forgiveness. And, if you are lucky, he will give it.”

        Thorin closed his eyes and bowed his head. “We will go immediately.”

        “Go. And only say what you truly believe. To lie...would only make things worse.”

        Thorin bowed low to the wizard and turned to leave. Balin and Bofur were already out the door, headed to the battlements, surely to clear the way. The path to the stairs had never felt so long. To think that they – that he – had damned Bilbo's spirit to agony for so many months. That he had hurt his One – their One – so badly with their madness.

        The stairs felt endless. Thorin could not even see them, only Bilbo's face in his mind's eye as he mounted each step. All he could hear was Bilbo's voice. Thorin had been the one to put off the Courting, when Dwalin had wanted to claim their one in Lake-town when they had the chance. Thorin had thought – by their Maker had he been gold-mad even then? – to cover Bilbo in gems, to drape their Burglar in luxuries so fine that he would never think to leave the Mountain ever again.

        Then, faintly, he heard Balin say, “Bilbo?”

        Thorin stumbled on the last step. It was only Dwalin's quick grab that kept him upright at all.

       Then, he heard a wavering voice said, “Don't. Please. I'm sorry. I'm sorry –,” and Thorin broke into a run. All of them did. They tore around the corner that led to the battlements just in time to see Bilbo – so pale and wan and thin it hurt to see – take one step up the rocks, then another, his ankle twisting when Thorin cried out his name along with Dwalin, reaching – reaching –

        Then Bilbo was falling, the silence all the louder for the lack of a scream. Thorin caught himself on the wall, choking on air as he saw Bilbo's body fall into darkness...

        And vanish like a specter.

       “Thorin,” Dwalin was at his side. “Thorin.”

       “What?” He turned to look at him. Then he saw that Dwalin was not looking at him but rather at Thorin's hands, where they rested on the wall. Where they rested in the blood on the wall, warm and wet as it coated Thorin's fingers and palms.

       Thorin stared down at his hands, mind terrifyingly blank. What had he done?

Notes:

you can find me at https://www.tumblr.com/blog/jezebel-rising