Actions

Work Header

Westward

Chapter 4: ⛰︎ Restless Covet

Notes:

for you lore nerds:
i stated previously that this story will mainly be based on the book, however this chapter bases some backstory details on the movies because i think it serves this story better. nothing major though.

Chapter Text

⛰︎

The forge Thorin chose stood far below the grander smithies of Erebor.

 

It was not abandoned, nor neglected, but old in the manner of places that had outlived all need of splendour. The walls bore centuries of darkening from smoke above the mouths of furnaces, and the stone beneath the anvils had worn smooth beneath generations of hammer-blows long before Smaug's shadow ever fell across the Mountain. Even after years of restoration, no one had polished away the forge's age. No silver inlay gleamed along the walls. No carved kings watched from high pillars. It was a place built to endure heat, labour, and silence.

 

The hour had long since passed when most smiths laid aside their tools. Elsewhere beneath Erebor, the kingdom had softened into evening. The last traces of the second day of anniversary celebrations still lingered through the higher halls in the form of distant song and the occasional burst of laughter, muffled by stone and distance until they seemed less like living voices than echoes left behind by the previous night. Here, however, there was only the furnace, the anvil, and the steady work of his hands.

 

The metal before him had no great importance. It was a narrow length of reinforced ironwork meant for one of the lower supports beneath the monument chamber. A piece useful enough to justify the hour if anyone cared to ask, but not so urgent that it required the King under the Mountain to shape it himself deep into the night. No one had asked, yet Thorin worked it anyway.

 

The hammer rose and fell in measured strokes. Sparks leapt briefly from the iron and vanished into shadow like fireflies swallowed by deep forest. Heat curled against his forearms beneath rolled sleeves, and the heavier braids of his hair had loosened enough that several grey strands clung faintly against the sweat near his temples. Stone dust from the monument chamber still lingered upon his boots and cuffs, pale against soot-dark cloth. 

 

The rhythm steadied him. Metal did not flatter. It did not argue from wounded pride, nor hide weakness beneath courtesy. If struck poorly, it bent poorly. If heated too little, it resisted. If overworked, it cracked. There was honesty in such things, and after the council chamber's polished words and sharpened silences, Thorin found the plain answer of iron beneath his hammer almost merciful.

 

The meeting had ended well.

 

That fact should have been enough. Agreements had been reached. Trade remained secured. The Iron Hills would send smaller labour groups and fittings more frequently rather than risk heavier transports through unstable mountain roads before the stone shelves had properly settled after winter. Dáin had grumbled, as Dáin often did, but had accepted the solution readily once Fíli shaped it into sense.

 

Thorin struck the iron harder than intended, and the piece shifted slightly across the anvil. He stilled at once. For several breaths only the furnace spoke, its low orange mouth breathing heat against the stone. Thorin adjusted the iron back into place and lowered the hammer, though his hand remained wrapped around its grip.

 

A softer sound interrupted the forge. Footsteps - light but not uncertain.

 

The door at the far end of the chamber opened with a low creak before closing again against the cooler passage beyond. Fíli stood briefly in the entrance while his eyes adjusted to the light in the forge. He had changed from his council garments into plainer dark clothing, though some trace of the day remained upon him still: a faint charcoal mark near one cuff, hair loosened from its formal braids, weariness carried quietly across the shoulders.

 

"There you are." he said at last.

 

Thorin looked down at the iron.

 

"So it would seem."

 

Fíli crossed the chamber slowly, not with the caution of one entering forbidden ground, but with the care of someone who understood that silence too could be a kind of work. He glanced over the shelves, the tools, the cooling trough, then finally toward the piece of metal upon the anvil.

 

"You have improved that beyond all reason."

 

"It required adjusting."

 

"It required adjusting two hours ago. Not it requires rescue."

 

A faint laughter left Thorin despite himself.

 

Fíli leaned on one hip against the nearby worktable and folded his arms. For a while he said nothing. The light from the furnace caught his hair, turning it almost copper-red where it fell loose near his temples. In such light he looked younger than he had in the council chamber, but still older than Thorin remembered him being on the road to Erebor. The thought unsettled him in a manner he could not entirely name.

 

"Balin sent you?" Thorin asked.

 

"Balin suggested I might find you here."

 

"That is not the same thing."

 

"No." Fíli agreed. "He only raised his brows at me until I went."

 

"That is much the same thing."

 

Fíli smiled faintly, though it faded soon enough. For a time they stood in the heat without speaking. Thorin lifted the iron once more into place, though he did not strike it. Fíli watched him, then watched the metal, then looked toward the furnace as though choosing his words with more care than came naturally to him.

 

The younger dwarf possessed a patience that had not existed in him during childhood. Thorin remembered too clearly a boy who once attacked every task with the singular conviction that force and speed together could solve nearly any problem placed before him. Both Fíli and Kíli had been forces of nature no dwarf could contain, yet so many times Dís, Thorin, and the company had to come to their rescue. Kíli still harbored a lot of that recklessness, yet somewhere across the years since Erebor's reclamation, Fílis sharp restless energy had settled into something steadier. Not diminished, simply tempered. Rather like steel.

 

"The council troubled you." Fíli spoke at last - not as an accusation or a challenge, but as a mere observation.

 

"The council resolved successfully."

 

"That was not my question."


Thorin finally lowered the hammer. The metal upon the anvil glowed faintly red along its edges while heat shimmered softly upward between them.

 

"You handled the matter well." Thorin stated with a slight smile.

 

Fíli's expression shifted slightly at the deflection, though he allowed it momentarily.

 

"So I am told."

 

"You disagreed."

 

"I thought you were trying very hard to quarrel with Dáin."

 

The honesty of it nearly drew another smile from Thorin.

 

"And did I succeed?"

 

"Oh, magnificently." Fíli folded his arms lightly. "Another few remarks and I suspect Dáin would have challenged you to wrestle him atop the council table for rights to the eastern roads."

 

"That would at least have shortened the meeting."

 

A brief laugh escaped Fíli then before the warmth faded gradually from his expression. The younger dwarf studied him quietly for several moments afterward while the forge-light shifted across the old stone around them. Thorin had the uncomfortable impression that he was being observed rather more closely than he would prefer.

 

"Dáins remark was unnecessary." Fíli finally spoke again.

 

The warmth vanished from the room. Not literally - the furnace still burned and the coals still glowed. Yet something in Thorin stiffened all the same.

 

'We all know what that gold did to you when the dragon was first slain.'

 

The words returned with uncomfortable clarity. Not only because Dáin had spoken them particularly harshly, but because they had landed.

 

"He should not have said it." Fíli stated, turning his gaze toward the furnace.

 

"He was not wrong."

 

"No."

 

The answer came quietly.

 

Thorin lowered his gaze briefly, scuffing one boot against the soot-darkened stone, before his nephew spoke up once more.

 

"When we first returned to Erebor," Fíli said, "I thought it would be different."

 

Thorin looked toward him then. Fíli did not immediately continue. His face changed, though not into sadness exactly. Memory sat upon him like dust disturbed from a long-covered work.

 

"I do not mean easier." he continued. "I knew it would not be easy. Kíli and I used to speak of it on the road whenever we were too tired to sleep. We thought of halls full of music, forges lit again, feasts where no one counted how much bread remained. We imagined treasure too, of course. We were fools enough for that."

 

"You were young." Thorin stated.

 

"We were Dwarves." Fíli replied, and there was enough dry honesty in it that Thorin could not argue. "I remembered the first time I entered the treasure halls after recovering from the battle. Not during..."

 

He paused, choosing not to name those first terrible days after Smaug's death, when gold had seemed to coil about Thorin's thoughts like smoke from dragon-fire. Fíli instead took a moment to gather his thoughts before continuing.

 

"After. Before you woke up from your injuries. Óin had just concluded that you were going to make it. When the dead had been named and most of the wounded moved and someone finally decided we ought to know what remained beneath our own feet."

 

The furnace breathed between them.

 

"I thought I would feel wonder." Fíli said. "Or pride. Perhaps even temptation, if I am being honest. I had heard all my life of Erebor's wealth. But when I stood there, all I could think was that none of it looked like ours."

 

Thorin's brow drew faintly. Fíli noticed.

 

"I do not mean it belonged elsewhere." he said. "Only that it did not feel as treasure feels in tales. It looked like work. Like generations of hands. Miners, smiths, gem-cutters, traders, masons. Every coin and cup and carved thing had passed through someone's labour before it ever lay in those halls. Smaug slept upon it as though gold becomes his simply because he covers enough of it with his body."

 

The words settled quietly into the forge. Thorin looked back toward the iron upon the anvil, though he no longer truly saw it.

 

"And you?" he asked after a while. "Do you never feel it?"

 

This time Fíli did not answer quickly. He turned the question over in silence, which made the answer when it came seem more truthful.

 

"Not as you mean." he replied at last. "I have wanted many things in those vaults. Any dwarf who claims otherwise is lying or has never seen them properly. But covet them?"

 

He shook his head slowly before continuing.

 

"No. I think I would feel foolish coveting what is already entrusted to us. The gold belongs to Erebor before it belongs to any one of us. Perhaps that is easier for me because I never had to dream of it while sleeping under hedges and broken stone. Or because I am not tasked with managing our riches. Either way, I do not believe I have ever admired it for its own sake."

 

There was no accusation in the words. That made them even harder to bear.

 

"When I first woke up after the battle, you had already managed to relocate every single coin and gem into our treasuries deeper within the mountain." Thorin said after a moment of silence. "I wanted to be angry, but I struggled to blame anyone but myself. It was not hard to see why you did it."

 

"That wasn't the only reason, and you know it. We needed the space for other things. We didn't exactly hide the treasure from you."

 

Thorin took a deep breath, staring at the dust covering his feet for a moment. Then, he let out a deep sigh before looking up at his nephew.

 

"I haven't once entered those vaults."

 

The words hung strangely in the air.

 

Fíli blinked.

 

"Not once?"

 

"No."

 

A long silence followed. The younger dwarf seemed neither shocked nor judgmental, merely surprised. 

 

"Five years?" He asked.

 

Thorin only nodded in response as the furnace crackled softly between them.

 

"Why?" Fíli questioned with a look of genuine bewilderment.

 

The answer arrived before Thorin could stop it, like his tongue had decided the answer for him before he had even made up his mind, though it did not make it any less true.

 

"Because I want to."

 

The younger dwarf frowned, and Thorin rested both hands against the workbench. The words had escaped too quickly. Too easily. Too honestly. For several moments he considered retreating from them, but the longer he contemplated, the less convincing his retraction would appear. Looking up once more and meeting the gaze of his nephew, Thorin found that he wanted to continue.

 

The confession sounded absurd spoken aloud. Yet now that it had begun, stopping felt harder somehow.

 

"I know exactly which corridors lead there." he spoke softly. "There are mornings I find myself walking in that direction before I realize where my feet have taken me. I have allowed my fingers to trace the carved patterns of the doors more than once."

 

Fíli listened without interrupting, only speaking up once more once his uncle had caught his breath and the room had fallen silent once more.

 

"And you walk away every time?"

 

"Every time."

 

The older dwarf exhaled slowly and carefully, returning his gaze to the glowing forge.

 

"I remember Bilbo."

 

The forge seemed to grow still. Even the embers of the fire seemed to freeze for a moment. Fíli lowered his gaze, and Thorin knew immediately that his nephew understood which memory he meant. How could he not?

 

All of them remembered - the company had been there and seen it for themselves. The battlements. The Arkenstone. The rage. 

 

"I remember putting my hand around his throat." Thorin's words came low and measured, as though each needing forcing through cracked stone.

 

The furnace breathed again, but both dwarves still appeared frozen in place.

 

"I remember looking at him and seeing a traitor." Thorin's jaw tightened. "And I remembered him looking at me with the same terror in his eyes as when I was nearly killed, right after the goblin tunnels, before the eagles arrived."

 

A pause. The forge seemed smaller suddenly. More enclosed, with the heat pressing even closer.

 

"I think of that every time I near those halls."

 

The confession settled heavily between them. For a while, neither dwarf said anything. Then, Fíli broke the silence in the softest voice he could muster.

 

"You apologized."

 

"I did."

 

"You made things right."

 

"I tried."

 

Silence fell over them once more, only disturbed by the crackling flames and a quiet, humourless laughter from Thorin.

 

"We sent each other a few letters in the first year after I woke up from my injuries. He did not seem to hold much hostility, yet words written on paper can only convey so much."

 

"I hear him and Balin still write each other quite often."

 

"I heard that too. It gives me some relief."

 

Fíli considered him for a long moment.

 

"Perhaps you should write him again."

 

Thorin looked sharply towards him, but Fíli had already turned his attention to the anvil, as though the thought had been no more than a practical comment regarding an unfinished seam.

 

"I doubt Master Baggins would thank me for disturbing his peace after all these years."

 

Fíli's mouth twitched.

 

"Considering what he endured during the Quest, I suspect ta letter would seem a mild intrusion."

 

The thought did not settle fully in Thorin's mind. Not then. It merely passed through like a glimmer glimpsed within deep water, gone before one could say whether it had been light or memory.

 

"He returned to his home." Thorin said.

 

"As he should have."

 

"Yes."

 

"And you returned to yours."

 

Thorin looked toward him then. Fíli's expression remained open, almost too open. He did not seem to know what he had touched upon. Or perhaps he did, in the manner he often knew things without yet knowing what they meant.

 

"Did I?" Thorin asked.

 

Fíli stilled.

 

The words had escaped more quietly than Thorin intended. Too quietly, perhaps. For a long moment they remained between them like an unfinished thing left cooling upon the anvil.

 

Fíli did not answer at once. He instead swallowed faintly and looked down at his hands, flexing them once as though remembering work from earlier in the day.

 

"The Mountain is yours." he said again.

 

It was the same comfort Dís had offered. The same truth spoken with love and certainty. Yet from Fíli it sounded different somehow, less like expectation and more like a plea to understand. Thorin could not tell if that made it better or worse, only that he felt the old unease stir once more.

 

"Is that what you see when you look upon her?" he asked. "Something that is mine?"

 

Fíli frowned faintly.

 

"No." he said after a moment. "Not quite."

 

Thorin waited for the younger dwarf to continue.

 

Fíli glanced toward the forge walls, blackened by ages of labour, then toward the iron cooling upon the anvil.

 

"I see something we were trusted to return." he said slowly. "And to keep alive. I see my mother's people. Our people. The children who run where there used to be ashes. The smiths who argue over copper costs as if we did not once count scraps. Bori cursing at apprentices. Balin pretending not to worry. Dwalin frightening guards into standing straighter than stone."

 

A faint smile touched him.

 

"I see you too, of course. But not only you."

 

Thorin listened without moving.

 

Fíli seemed almost embarrassed by how much he had said, but continued before he could lose the courage.

 

"The gold is part of that. The halls are part of that. The throne too, I suppose. But none of them matter alone. If I thought they belonged to you before they belonged to Erebor, I think I would be no better than the dragon."

 

Thorin stayed silent for a moment.

 

Fíli grimaced faintly.

 

"That sounded wiser in my head."

 

"No." Thorin said quietly. "It sounded true."

 

Fíli looked at him then, surprised.

 

For reasons Thorin could not have named, the sight of him there - young still in some ways, yet steady, with soot on his sleeve and an instinctive certainty that Thorin himself had spent years failing to grasp - stirred something in him more painful than pride and more gentle than grief.

 

"You handled the council well." Thorin said.

 

Fíli blinked at the change in subject, then smiled slightly.

 

"You did more than settle tempers." Thorin continued. "You heard the shape of the room before the rest of us did."

 

Fíli's smile faded into something less easy.

 

"I heard you and Dáin preparing to bring the ceiling down."

 

"That too."

 

"Someone had to hold up the pillars."

 

The words were spoken lightly, almost carelessly, but Thorin felt them strike somewhere deep.

 

Fíli did not seem to notice. He simply pushed himself away from the worktable and reached for the poker beside the furnace, turning one coal inward until sparks rose and died.

 

"The monument will be ready tomorrow." he said. "Bori has sworn at six workers, three tools, one scaffold, and the concept of dust itself. Which means all progresses as expected."

 

"A reassuring report." Thorin allowed himself to smile.

 

"I thought so."

 

For a while they stood together beside the forge, the conversation easing back into safer ground. Fíli spoke of the lower seams, the cloth coverings, the workers who had been forbidden from peeking and were therefore more determined than ever to do so. Thorin listened, grateful in ways he did not know how to express. The anticipation for the unveiling returned faintly, though now tangled with other thoughts less easily shaped. Gold. Vaults. Bilbo. Home. Fíli's voice saying the Mountain was not his alone.

 

At last Fíli moved toward the door.

 

"You should sleep before tomorrow."

 

"An excellent suggestion."

 

"You have no intention of following it, have you?"

 

"Very perceptive."

 

"That too I learned from you."

 

Thorin shook his head faintly. At the threshold, Fíli paused and looked back.

 

"Uncle."

 

Thorin lifted his gaze. Fíli seemed for a moment as though he might say something more, something heavier, but in the end he only smiled faintly.

 

"Do not improve that piece a fourth time. It has suffered enough."

 

Then he was gone.

 

The forge fell quiet once more and his footsteps faded. Only the furnace remained, breathing steadily against the old stone walls while the iron cooled slowly upon the anvil. Thorin stood beside it for a long while, one hand resting near the hammer, his thoughts drawn not toward the council chamber nor even the monument waiting veiled beneath scaffold, but toward a small figure upon a battlement years ago and the look in his eyes before everything broke.

 

'Perhaps you should write him again.', Fíli had said.

 

Thorin did not take up pen that night.

 

But long after the forge-fire dimmed and the Mountain sank deeper into sleep, the thought remained.

⛰︎