Actions

Work Header

Westward

Summary:

"Strange, how one may wander half the world before realizing he has been following his own footsteps."

Five years after barely surviving the Battle of Five Armies, Thorin finds himself unfulfilled by the throne he vowed his life to reclaiming. When he finally steps out of the mountain once more, his journey reframes an old friendship and forces him to evaluate the true purpose of legacy and meaning.

a story told in three parts
| ⛰︎ | ✉︎ | ❦ |

Notes:

hey so this is my first story i post on here. this story is basically where i think thorin’s character arc would have continued if botfa had been a near death experience for him.

this will mainly be based on the book and not necessarily the movies unless i feel like something from the movies would benefit this story.

hope you enjoy :)

Chapter 1: ⛰︎ The Aftermath of Prophecy

Chapter Text

⛰︎ 

The halls of Erebor remained restless even when most were asleep.

 

Despite the late hour, the great feast having long since dwindled down, the familiar hum of forges could still be heard from deep within the mountain. The echoes of hammers ringing against metal only reached these halls as a faint whisper - soft enough that one could doubt if they told of current work or were simply audible trails hammered into the mountains permanently. Because as much as the dragon had taken from them, Erebor was nothing if not a display of permanence. Time may change most other things, but what is carved into would remain through the ages. 

 

Thorin stood as the embodiment of that legacy.

 

The heavy doors had long since closed behind him, though the memory of the feast still pressed against him like walls drawn too close. Just like a hammer against metal, the warmth and noise of celebration still echoed through the hall. A golden glow cast by lanterns woven by silver and iron lingered across the polished rock beneath each step he took. Spilt ale and mead painted the tables and occasionally overshadowed the reflected light of the cold stone floor. Bones from poultry and whole boars, bread and a few cracked plates were scattered across the tables. 

 

Five years.

 

Five years since the Battle of Five Armies.

 

Five years since the prophesied King under the Mountain became the ruler of Erebor.

 

The anniversary feast had been grand even by dwarven standards.

 

The great halls had brimmed with laughter and song from dawn until deep into the night. Entire boars had been roasted above mighty fires. Casks from allied cities and kingdoms had been emptied at a near alarmingly rapid pace. All had celebrated regardless of title or status - miners, craftsmen, nobles, merchants, royals, smiths. Residents and guests alike had wanted to take part in filling the Lonely Mountain with enough noise to wake the dead beneath its roots.

 

And through it all Thorin had been the center of attention. The steadfast king and ruler of a nation destined to once more become the mightiest and most prosperous of all the dwarven kingdom. Songs had been sung in his honor. Poetry recited about his accomplishments. Praises and blessings all in his honor. King under the Mountain. Restorer of Erebor. The rightful heir of Durin. A hero amongst his kin.

 

None of these titles startled him the way they once did, instead settling upon his shoulders like the familiar weight of armour long worn. Despite it all, with each passing year Thorin found himself listening to the songs as though from an increasingly great distance. Not with bitterness, nor grief. 

 

That, perhaps, would have been easier to understand.

 

No - what unsettled him most was the absence of feeling altogether.

 

The songs had risen around him rich with triumph and memory. Voices had echoed through the hall recounting their victory against Smaug, though the burglar was often left out of the anthems. They sang of the reclamation of Erebor, the rebuilding of the kingdom, the prosperity now flowing once more through the Mountain and into Dale below.

 

The king had listened. He had looked upon the halls restored to splendor beyond even his memory of the time before the dragon. He had looked upon his people thriving.

 

Yet he felt nothing. Not truly.

 

The realization had settled quietly within him over the years, so gradually he had scarcely had time to notice when or where it began. At first he had thought it to be exhaustion. Then he had attributed it to the lingering wounds of grief. After that he had considered that it may be that strange numbness which often follows the fulfillment of a long pursued goal. Or perhaps it was the aftermath of gold sickness that was slowly seeping out of his veins.

 

Yet the feeling had only deepened. 

 

Like standing beneath stone worn slowly hollow by dripping water - a refusal from even rock itself to remain permanent.

 

Thorin slowed near one of the great archways overlooking the lower halls. Below him Erebor stretched vast and golden beneath the light from a thousand lanterns. Bridges crossing immense chasms carved deep into the heart of the Mountain. Forges burning in distant chambers cast a warm glow on the otherwise cold lower floors of the kingdom. Endless stairways wound downward into the shadows and glowing embers.

 

Beautiful. That word still came easily. It still rang true, perhaps even more now than when he was a child. 

 

A kingdom revived. Alive. Healed.

 

And somehow, somewhere along the way, Thorin had begun feeling as though he alone remained unchanged. That his permanence went deeper than the rocks.

 

He rested one hand against the stone railing, focusing deeply on the cool beneath his palm.

 

Behind him footsteps approached softly. Not cautious enough to belong to a servant. Not heavy enough for a guard. Not drunk enough for the Company. 

 

“Though the celebration was one for the history books, I fear the feast is over, dear brother.” Dís spoke gently. 

 

Her voice carried the same warmth it always had, even back when they were young children - rich and steady as the fire of a hearth. 

 

At last, Thorin glanced back. 

 

She approached him wrapped in deep blue and silver, the jewels woven into her dark braids catching the lantern-light as she walked. Time had marked her more gently than it had him, though grief had left its traces upon the both of them long ago.

 

There were few people within the Lonely Mountain and beyond who still looked upon Thorin first as a brother rather than a king. Dís had never stopped.

 

She came to stand beside him at the railing, following his gaze as it returned out across the halls below.

 

For a while neither of them spoke, before Dís sighed softly.

 

”Something troubles you.” she spoke, more as a matter of fact than a question.

 

Thorin exhaled through his nose and let out a slight chuckle, though the smile never quite reached his eyes.

 

”You say that every year.”

 

”That is precisely what concerns me.” 

 

Thorin looked at her briefly, but upon meeting with concerned eyes and worry lines, he promptly turned his gaze back to watch over the mountain.

 

Far below, a burst of laughter rose from one of the lower bridges before fading once more into the vastness of the Mountain.

 

Dís studied him quietly.

 

”The halls sing your praises tonight,” she said at last. “Even now they likely still sing them.”

 

”The halls have also had enough ale to sing the praises of a cracked anvil if it stood still long enough.”

 

That earned him a quieter laugh, contagious enough for a slight smile to form upon his worn and worried face.

 

”You rebuilt a kingdom from ruin, Thorin. You speak of it as though that were some small feat.”

 

”The mountain rebuilt herself. I merely survived long enough to witness it.”

 

”And you guided it there.”

 

Her tone was not corrective, nor was it argumentative. She merely remained gentle. Certain of her words in a way Thorin used to find comforting.

 

”Look at her,” Dís spoke softly, gesturing toward the halls below. “When was the last time Erebor stood so full of life? The halls are thriving. Dale prospers beside us. Our people no longer wander the world as mercenaries in exile. Children born beneath this mountain have never known dragon-fire, nor hunger, nor sleeping beneath snow and rubble.”

 

Thorin listened in silence.

 

Because none of it was untrue.

 

That perhaps was the worst part.

 

”I know.” he said at length.

 

Dís turned toward him fully at that.

 

”Do you?”

 

The question carried no accusation. Only concern, and Thorin frowned faintly.

 

”You think me ungrateful?” he questioned her.

 

”No.” she shook her head immediately. “Never that.”

 

She rested her arms lightly upon the railing beside him.

 

”But you still carry yourself as if you are waiting for something.”

 

Thorin’s jaw tightened as his sister spoke.

 

Below them, the Mountain glowed warm and alive. Everything he had once dreamed of stood before him. And still that strange emptiness remained.

 

Another moment of silence passed between them before Thorin spoke up.

 

”Perhaps,” he said at last, still avoiding eye contact, “I simply grew too accustomed to wandering.”

 

Dís turned slightly at that, studying him with the same expression she had worn when they were young and she suspected him of concealing some injury from their father.

 

”I think perhaps you no longer know what to do now that the ground stands secure beneath you.”

 

Again that strange discomfort stirred within him. It was subtle yet immediate.

 

”Secure?” he replied with a slight frown.

 

”Of course secure.” Dís sounded almost surprised by the question. “How many times do I have to remind you, dear brother - Erebor is restored. The line of Durin sits once more upon the throne beneath the Mountain. Our people flourish.”

 

She smiled faintly, hoping to see the same from her brother next to her.

 

”And for the first time in years, there is finally room again for thoughts beyond mere survival.” she continued.

 

Thorin kept avoiding her gaze. Any semblance of warmth and familiarity from her care for him was squashed out by the cold feeling that surged throughout his veins at the prospect of where he thought this conversation seemed to be quietly drifting.

 

“You are not merely a king now, Thorin. You are the future of the line of Durin.” Dís continued carefully.

 

Thorin froze at that. He noticed how his sister did not speak it heavily, nor as obligation. She spoke with hope. Hope he knew he should share.

 

Which somehow made it worse.

 

“Dís-“ 

 

“I do not say this to burden you,” she spoke even more gently upon taking notice of his reaction. “Quite the opposite.”

 

“I know.” he responded plainly.

 

”Most noble families of the dwarves kingdoms have spent the evening attempting to place their daughters somewhere within your line of sight.”

 

Thorin was unable to stop himself from letting out a low and exhasperated sound halfway between a sigh and a laugh.

 

”Then I best send their daughters my condolences.”

 

The two shared a smile, but Dís noticed how quickly it faded from her brother.

 

”You laugh,” she said softly, “but I truly mean every word I have spoken. You have done what many believed impossible. There is no shame in allowing yourself happiness now.”

 

Happiness. That word settled strangely within him. Distant in some way. Not that he felt unhappy either. Just like the word belonged to someone else.

 

He thought of the feast hall behind them. Of songs rising proudly through chambers framed by gold. Of voices praising his name. Of nobles and common folk alike smiling across long tables. Of himself seated at the end of the table feeling as though he observed the evening from somewhere far outside his own body.

 

And beneath that numbness lingered a thought that, despite his best effort to silence, grew louder with each passing day:

 

‘If this is not enough for you, what is?’

 

That this - his kingdom awakened, these thriving halls, a future secured - ought to have made him feel complete by now. Yet the sensation of emptiness remained within him, sharpening with each passing year. Like a hunger becoming clearer the longer one ignored it.

 

On days like these he found himself worried there may be a hollow running clean through him that everyone could see. 

 

Dís mistook his silence for uncertainty of another kind.

 

”You need not decide anything quickly,” she said gently. “But you have spent so many years carrying duty on your own. Perhaps it is time you allow someone to lessen the weight from your shoulders. You deserve something that is truly yours.”

 

Thorin frowned faintly. ‘something that is truly yours’. The words unsettled him further in ways he could not explain. Because Erebor belonged to him. The throne belonged to him. The line of Durin rested in his hands. Yet standing there beneath the Mountain he suddenly felt strangely absent from his own life. 

 

Dís spoke with love and care, yet every word she spoke chipped further pieces of him into that vast sense of detachment.

 

“You are a great king, Thorin.” she said quietly, resting a hand lightly against his arm.

 

He almost recoiled from the words. Not visibly, but somewhere deeper. Because the praise no longer reached him in the way it once had. All it did was strike stone and fall away.

 

And worse still - he could not grasp why.

 

Dís seemed to notice the discomfort. Or perhaps she simply mistook it for modesty.

 

“Father would have been proud of you,” she added softly.

 

Again that heaviness settled within the silence. Not quite grief, but something more difficult.

 

Thorin looked out once more across the halls of Erebor. Smithies still glowed deep within the mountain. Voices echoed in the distance through restored halls once thought lost forever. Everything endured. Everything flourished. And still that peculiar restlessness remained lodged somewhere deep beneath his ribs like an unanswered question. 

 

“You should sleep.” Dís spoke as she slowly withdrew her hand.

 

”Perhaps.”

 

Neither of them truly believed he would.

 

She lingered beside him another moment before turning toward the corridor behind them. After several steps she paused.

 

”Do not spend so long wandering these halls tonight that you forget they are yours.” 

 

With those words of concern, she departed, her footsteps fading slowly into the Mountain.

 

Thorin remained standing alone at the railing long after she disappeared. Below him Erebor glowed warm and endless beneath lantern-light and carved stone. Beautiful. Enduring. Whole. 

 

And for reasons he could neither name nor understand, Thorin Oakenshield had never in his life felt further from peace.

 

Far beneath the Mountain, the forges burned on into the night.

⛰︎ 

Chapter 2: ⛰︎ A Hammer and a Tribute

Notes:

btw english is not my first language, and even though i have watched the movies in english i have only read the book in my native language, where characters and places have differently translated names.

i will do my best to double check everything so it is consistent with the english version of the book but feel free to correct me if i do any major mistakes.

Chapter Text

⛰︎

Morning hesitated to reach the Mountain after the night of the feast.

 

In truth the sun had risen over Dale hours before, casting its pale gold across the broken ridges beyond the Lonely Mountain. But deep within Erebor, where light travelled by lantern and flame and polished stone, the day began not with dawn but with sound. First woke the hammers. After that, the chisels. Finally, the long groan of chains drawn through iron pulleys and the scrape of sledges against stone. By these signs, the Mountain announced to all her residents that morning had finally dawned on them.

 

Thorin had been awake before them all. He had not slept long, though it was about what he had expected. Despite the lack of sleep, the weariness that sat upon him in the feast hall had loosened somewhat with the coming of work. It had not vanished, not entirely; such things seldom did merely because a night had passed. But here, in the great open chamber where the nearly finished monument rested beneath veils of cloth and scaffold, the feeling became less sharp.

 

There was stone to be cut. Stone to be lifted. Metal fastenings to be set properly before the final pieces could be fixed into place. Such things required no answer from him beyond the strength of his arms and the steadiness of his hands. Some workers hacked into rock, some carefully shaped molten metal. As for Thorin, he was able to find his place by a hammer and stead.

 

The chamber chosen for the monument stood low within Erebor, not fare above where the roots of the Mountain met the earth itself. The outside wall of the room gave way for streaks of sunlight and cold mountain air to enter through carefully carved arches. Though most warves preferred working deep under the mountain, far below any direct source of sunlight, Thorin had always favored this working chamber. In fact, the construction of this room was one of the first things he had commissioned once he had recovered from his injuries in what was now referred to as the Battle of Five Armies. Before the dragon, this space had been part of an older hall. A hall that then was devastated by dragon-fire to a degree that could not be salvaged and restored into its former glory. Instead of allowing it to be a testament to the desolation of Smaug, the chamber now rang with voices and labour, with dust rising silver-grey through shafts of daylight.

 

No covering had yet been removed from the centre of the chamber. Heavy cloth, tied securely with rope and weighted along the floor, concealed the greater portion of the unfinished monument. Around it stood scaffolds of dark timber, platforms, carts of tools, and slabs waiting to be raised.

 

Thorin had commissioned it for the fifth anniversary of Erebor's reclamation. Not wanting to lead the project himself, he had instructed Fíli to oversee the construction - a job Fíli had taken to with pride as he did most responsibilities these days. 

 

What Thorin had not foreseen, however, was that the indefinable shape covered by cloth would be all he would be allowed to witness until the unveiling. King or not, it had taken a great deal of effort for Thorin to convince his nephew to let him help out in the first place. As much as Fíli had come into his own amongst their people these past few years, he still sought the approval of his uncle and was adamant that his uncle may not witness the monument until it was fully complete. For these reasons, Thorin was grateful he was allowed to work on constructing the metal anchors for the monument.

 

If there was one rule even the King under the Mountain would not challenge any dwarf on it was the wish for unfinished work to remain a private matter. Even now, with half the Mountain whispering about it and the other half pretending not to, Fíli had kept the work carefully guarded. Not from distrust, but from a stubborn wish that the thing should be beheld hold before it was judged. It was for the most part an unspoken understanding amongst all Dwarves to respect such wishes - even when the work belonged to all.

 

Thorin stood behind the workers with his sleeves rolled up to his elbow, thick and wiry hair tied back from his face, watching the construction unfold before him. He watched his nephew with one hand braced against a carved block while two others guided it into place. As much as Thorin wanted to help them out, he knew his best option so as to not be shunned from the construction completely, was to remain by his stead. As much as he knew nobody could stop him from stepping in, it would by default undermine his nephew, and so Thorin simply watched.

 

"Lower it by half an inch!" Fíli called.

 

Stone dust marked the young dwarf's tunic and had gathered in the lines of his hands. A smear of it crossed one cheek where he had wiped sweat away without thinking.

 

"Half?" one of the workers questioned from above him on the scaffold.

 

"If you would prefer the whole piece to sit crooked until the end of days, lower it by a quarter."

 

A few nearby Dwarves laughed, and he could not help but let out a chuckle. Thorin struggled to remember the last time laughter had risen so easily around him. When people had bowed to him, not because it was necessarily mandatory, but because they saw in him a leader amongst his people.

 

The block shifted slowly downward, chains creaking as the weight settled. Fíli leaned close, judging the seam by eye before setting his shoulder against the stone.

 

"There," he said. "Hold."

 

Thorin scrambled forward with wedges and a hammer. The sound of iron striking wood echoed across the chamber. For only a moment, there was no king beneath the Mountain. There was only Thorin, slowly being more and more covered with stone dust, with stone beneath his hands and the familiar strain of labour settling peacefully through his body. 

 

It was a simple peace, if peace was the right word for it. Not the peace of victory, the kind sung of in halls or spoken of between kin at night. Nothing grand enough for song. Merely the narrowing of the world into weight, measurement, balance and breath. Here, if something was wrong, one could see it. If a joint failed to hold, it could be fitted anew. If a line wandered, it would be corrected beneath a chisel. 

 

Stone did not praise him, nor did it look to him for meaning. Stone only yielded when properly understood. And for one brief hour that morning, Thorin did understand exactly what was required of him.

 

Across the chamber, Fíli's voice rose above the noise.

 

"Not that crate - the other one. Those fastenings are for the upper frame. If you use them there, Bori will spend the rest of the day cursing your name loudly enough for the Iron Hills to hear."

 

"I would not need to curse if folk learned to read their markings." Bori replied from somewhere beneath the scaffold.

 

"Aye, but we will not be so cruel as to deprive you of your chief pleasure." said Fíli.

 

Another ripple of laughter moved through the workers, and Thorin turned to witness his nephew once more.

 

Fíli stood upon the lower platform of the scaffold, bright hair bound back, sleeves rolled in much the same manner as Thorin's. He held a slate tablet in one hand and a charcoal marker in the other, though judging by the new streak across his brow he had already used the charcoal somewhere other than the slate. To say the least, Thorin was impressed by the ease with which his nephew moved through the work. Though he had progressively taken on more and more responsibilities in the Mountain these past five years, this was the first time Thorin actually worked beneath his direction upon a project of this scale. It was clear to see that the younger dwarf felt at ease among the bustle.

 

Never idle, but Fíli never had been. Ever since he was little, the young dwarf had little patience for standing merely to be seen. But today, Thorin witnessed a manner to him that made the work around him flow more smoothly. Fíli knew which crews had finished early, which had fallen behind, which mason disliked working beside which metalworker, and which tasks needed pride soothed before hands would move properly again. He did not command the chamber as Thorin usually would. He moved through it, and the chamber moved with him.

 

"Uncle," Fíli called out. "If you wish to pretend to lift that stone you have now so carefully secured, at least wait until someone important is watching."

 

"I was under the impression you had declared yourself important sometime last winter."

 

"I did. No one listened."

 

"That is because you made your announcement during supper."

 

Fíli descended a few steps of the scaffold with a grin. "A poor choice of moment, I admit. Bombur had just brought out the pies."

 

"Then you were doomed from the start, dear nephew."

 

The workers nearby laughed again, and Thorin felt something in his chest ease - not greatly, not permanently, but enough.

 

"The eastern fittings are ready, but the lower supports still need checking before the cloth is set for tomorrow." Fíli spoke as he reached the floor and handed the slate to a passing mason.

 

"I saw the supports."

 

"You looked at them."

 

Thorin raised an eyebrow.

 

Fíli smiled with infuriating cheer. "There is a difference."

 

"Careful." 

 

"I learned it from you."

 

"That does not make it wise."

 

"No, but that does make it difficult to argue with."

 

Thorin let out a low sound that was on the verge of being a laughter before he turned back toward the block to anchor the last wedge into place. He ran one hand along the seam, feeling for the smallest shift beneath the dust. Good, not perfect, but close enough that the next piece would answer it in the way it should.

 

"Well?" Fíli asked.

 

Thorin let the pause stretch longer than necessary - just long enough for him to see Fíli's face tighten as the young dwarf did his absolute best to hide how anxiously he wished for his uncle's approval.

 

Thorin nodded once.

 

"It will hold."

 

The younger dwarf released a breath and immediately attempted to appear as though he had not been worried.

 

"Of course it will hold," he muttered. "I set the lower line myself."

 

"So you did," Thorin said gravely. "Which is why I checked it twice."

 

Fíli barked a laugh. 

 

For a while after that, Thorin continued working without speaking much. The chamber warmed as the morning deepened, filling the room with the scent of stone and oil and hot iron. More workers came and went. Tools changed hands. Measurements were shouted and corrected. Somewhere upon the scaffold, an argument concerning the proper angle of a fastening became so passionately technical that Fíli had to climb up himself and settle it before either party began citing ancestors.

 

Thorin watched him do it. Not openly, and not for long. But enough to see how naturally Fíli placed himself between irritation and insult. He did not silence either dwarf, instead letting both speak until each had spent the sharpest edge of pride. Then, he pointed to the line, adjusted the measure by a fraction, and somehow left both convinced that they had been largely correct.

 

He turned back to his own work before Fíli could catch him watching. A length of carved metalwork lay ready upon a nearby bench, wrapped in oiled cloth. The piece would not be visible once the monument was completed, at least not to most eyes. It was a fastening, nothing more, though carefully made. Strong enough to bear weight and fine enough that no careless hand should be trusted with it. 

 

Thorin lifted it and tested the balance across his palm.

 

"Too heavy?" asked Bori, appearing at his side.

 

"For what it must bear? No." Thorin responded.

 

"For what it cost us in copper? Yes." Bori responded, entirely unrepentant.

 

"It is the fifth anniversary of the Mountain's reclamation." Thorin stated plainly.

 

"Aye, and apparently the first anniversary of every smith in Erebor forgetting the value of restraint."

 

"There are many virtues in restraint."

 

"Then perhaps Your Majesty might demonstrate one and let someone else carry that."

 

Thorin's mouth twitched.

 

"You grow bold with age."

 

"I grow bold with sore knees. Age merely receives the blame."

 

Bori reached for the fastening, but Thorin shifted it away before he could take the full weight.

 

"I have it." He spoke plainly.

 

"I do not doubt it." Bori responded before softening his voice just enough for Thorin to notice. "And that is not the point."

 

For a moment the work noise seemed to settle strangely around them. Thorin was well aware that Bori meant nothing beyond care. There was no rebuke in the words, nor any hidden meaning. Only the plain concern of a craftsman who had watched his king work since before dawn and saw little sense in letting him strain himself for pride.

 

Still, something in the words touched the edge of the feeling from the night prior. Thorin said nothing.

 

Then Fíli's voice cut across the chamber.

 

"Bori, if you are trying to make my uncle surrender a piece of metal before he has decided the matter himself, I commend your courage and mourn your chances."

 

Bori snorted. "Then come take it from him yourself."

 

"I enjoy living."

 

That seemed to break the moment cleanly. Thorin simply shook his head and carried the fastening to the lower frame himself, though he allowed two younger workers to take the weight when it came time to raise it into place. They did so with care, not because he commanded them, but because their hands knew the work. That pleased him. More than any praise sung in the late hours of the night before.

 

The fastening slid into position with a satisfying finality. The bolts followed one by one. Iron turned. Stone settled. Weight found its proper path downwards through structure on the floor, and Thorin stepped back to look at it. For several breaths he only looked. The others looked with him. Not at the monument itself, still veiled and unfinished, but at the line of work. At the hidden strength now secured beneath it. A thing made properly as its own kind of truth.

 

"Well," Bori spoke at last, grudgingly pleased. "That will hold."

 

Thorin inclined his head. "So I have heard."

 

This time the laughter came freely.

 

It was into that sound that Balin entered.

 

He stood for a moment beneath the archway leading into the chamber, hands tucked before him, white beard with a near blue tint arranged neatly and tucked into a golden belt over robes far too clean for the worksite. He looked around at the scaffolds, the dust, the workers, and finally at Thorin who wore dust and chipped stone upon his sleeves and hair slightly loosened from its tie.

 

"Ah," Balin said. "I see I have arrived just in time to prevent the King under the Mountain from becoming part of its foundations."

 

"Too late," Fíli called from above. "He has been attempting it all morning."

 

"I am assisting." Thorin said.

 

"With great dedication I can see." Balin replied mildly. "And with apparently no memory whatsoever of the meeting awaiting you."

 

He had known, of course. The meeting had been set days ago. Dáin and several other Dwarves of the Iron Hills had remained after the anniversary feast, and certain matters of trade, road security and iron shipments required proper discussion before they departed eastward once more. Necessary matters of royal importance.

 

Thorin looked down at his hands, calloused and gray with dust.

 

"I need only finish one thing."

 

A sound moved through the nearest workers, this time not with laughter. Something gentler.

 

"No, my lord." Bori spoke, folding his arms. "You need not."

 

Thorin turned toward him, ready to call out disobedience but instead finding a room of caring eyes gazing upon him.

 

"We have got it from here." Bori continued, nodding toward the scaffold.

 

Another worker, younger and less bold, added quickly, "It will be ready by tomorrow. You need not worry."

 

Then, as though fearing he had spoken too plainly, he bowed his head slightly.

 

"My lord."

 

Thorin became aware of the dust upon his sleeves, the ache in his hands, the warmth still lingering from labour. For one brief, foolish instant he wished to refuse. To reschedhule the meeting. To remain until the last fastening was set and the last cloth secured. But he knew better. He was a servant to his people, their king. And kings did not belong only where they wished to stand.

 

Balin watched him with an expression too knowing to be wholly innocent.

 

"Your presence is requested aswell, young master Fíli."

 

Fíli had already climbed down from the scaffold. He crossed the floor quickly, returning the charcoal-marked slate to one of the foremen.

 

"Rani, keep the western supports covered until the dust settles. If anyone removes a single piece of cloth before tomorrow, tell them I shall personally assign them to polishing lower stair rails until Durin's Day."

 

Rani grinned. "A cruel fate."

 

"A deserved one." Fili responded before turning to another worker. "The upper frame can wait until midday. Check the lower seams again first. Bori will pretend to complain, but he will want to see them himself."

 

"I heard that." Bori said.

 

"I was counting on it."

 

The foremen nodded. THe workers answered him easily, already moving as he directed. No hesitation. No confusion. Thorin watched without meaning to. He saw how Fíli gave instructions as though he had always stood there, and the work continued. That should have pleased Thorin.

 

It did please him.

 

Yet alongside the pride came another feeling, small and quiet enough that he might have ignored it had he not already grown so tired of ignoring it. It kept festering, yet he still could not hold it long enough to name it.

 

"Uncle?" Fíli said, stepping beside him. "Balin will begin lecturing us both if we delay much longer."

 

"I do not lecture." Balin stated. "I merely offer necessary wisdom at appropriate length."

 

Thorin looked between them. Both Fíli and Balin were now both watching him with pride and eagerness, and despite himself he felt warmth rise briefly through the lingering unease.

 

"Go," Bori said, shooting him with one dusty hand as though Thorin were an apprentice lingering underfoot. "Before Dáin begins without you and declares the Iron Hills independent out of boredom."

 

"The Iron Hills are not dependent upon Erebor." Balin said automatically.

 

Bori shrugged. "Then he will declare something else. He is inventive when impatient."

 

That earned a laughter from half the chamber, even the king himself letting up a smile as he surrendered the last tool in his hand to Rani after glancing once more toward the covered center of the chamber.

 

The monument remained hidden beneath cloth and scaffold, unfinished yet close enough now that the shape of it could nearly be sensed without being seen. Tomorrow the covers would fall. Tomorrow the Mountain would look upon the completed work. Tomorrow song and memory and stone would meet before all who had lived to see Erebor restored. Thorin felt, then, something close to anticipation. Something adjacent to expectation. A quiet hope that once that veil fell, some part of him might answer it properly.

 

He held to that hope more than he cared to admit.

 

"You may wish to change before speaking with Dáin." Fíli spoke, lightly clapping Thorin on the shoulder and leaving a handprint of dust upon his tunic.

 

Thorin looked down upon the stone dust that covered him from sleeve to belt.

 

"I have attended councils in worse condition."

 

"You have." Balin said. "And I have vowed my life to convincing you to do better."

 

Fíli let out a slight chuckle. "Come now, uncle. If we hurry, you may still arrive looking only partially like part of the masonry."

 

Thorin cast one final glance back.

 

Behind him the workers had already returned to motion. Chains creaked. Hammers rang. Bori was indeed inspecting the lower seam while pretending he had not been asked to. Rani had gathered three others near the western supports. The chamber breathed with labour.

 

For a moment Thorin stood very still.

 

Then, finally, he turned from the worksite and followed Balin and Fíli toward the waiting halls beyond. 

 

Behind him, unseen beneath its covering, the monument neared completion. 

⛰︎

Chapter 3: ⛰︎ In Bearing Pillars

Chapter Text

⛰︎

The council chamber of Erebor possessed a peculiar talent for making even prosperity feel severe.

 

Though great braziers burned steadily along the walls and their heat settled richly upon the dark stone, warmth itself seemed unwelcome there, smoothed flat beneath centuries of order and restraint. Every line within the chamber had been carved with purpose. Thick pillars rose upward like unmoving sentinels toward vaulted shadows high above. The long stone table at the center of the chamber stood crowded with ledgers, maps, iron seals and carved figures of ancient kings beneath the Mountain, each placed with such precise intention that even disorder itself seemed reluctant to linger there long. Even sound carried strangely within the room. Voices did not soften beneath tapestry and timber as they might have in lesser halls, but travelled cleanly from wall to wall like hammer-strikes through bare caverns.

 

Nothing in the chamber existed merely because someone had wished it pleasant. That was something Thorin ordinarily appreciated.

 

Yet as he stood beside the great table listening to the discussion unfolding before him, he found the chamber pressing faintly against the senses like armour worn too long beneath summer heat. Not suffocating. Merely present in a way difficult to ignore. The same sensation had crept increasingly often upon him these past years during matters of court and governance. A subtle tightening of the spirit beneath ceremony and obligation, as though some inward part of himself had slowly begun resisting the shape of the life built around him.

 

Dáin sat opposite him at the far end of the table, broad as an old gatehouse and scarcely less intimidating. Age had thickened the old dwarf rather than diminished him. Gathered iron rings in his long grey beard had darkened nearly black with time, though his shoulders remained sculpted for battlefields more than council chambers. On one side of him sat his most trusted soldier, and on the other sat a noble of the Iron Hills, whom seemed to be acting in the role of advisor, both of them equally weathered by time. On each of their sides sat yet another set of nobles of the Iron Hills. Their garments bore fewer ornaments than Erebor's nobility had grown accustomed to, their belts heavier with practical iron than ceremonial gold. Even seated within the grandeur of the Mountain, they carried themselves like creatures more habituated to harsh ridges and cold roads than polished halls.

 

Balin stood somewhat apart from the table with several ledgers tucked beneath one arm, listening quietly while the eastern dwarves reviewed transport figures. Unlike the others, he seemed in no hurry to shape the discussion himself unless necessity demanded it. Thorin found himself grateful for that much at least. Balin's wisdom often proved invaluable, though subtle mediation between proud dwarves was not always among his gifts.

 

Fíli sat at Thorin's right hand listening quietly while the eastern nobles reviewed transport figures spread across the maps before them. Though stillness rarely suited the younger dwarf as naturally as movement and labour did, there remained within Fíli a curious ease all the same. His attention moved fluidly between speaker, map and ledger without appearing to strain toward any of them. Thorin had begun noticing such things more often these past years, though he rarely allowed himself to linger on the observation for long.

 

"...which leaves the northern roads unsuitable for heavier labour transports until autumn." concluded one of the nobles from the Iron Hills, pressing a thick finger against the eastern passes marked across the map.

 

The dwarf spoke respectfully enough, though not timidly. Dwarves of the Iron Hills rarely softened their speech where practical matters were concerned.

 

"The roads supported larger movements five winters ago." Thorin stated, his gaze fixed upon the maps spread before him.

 

"Aye. Before the western shelf collapsed." Another one of the Iron Hills nobles stated.

 

"We repaired the western shelf."

 

"We repaired enough for trade."

 

"Trade," Thorin replied evenly, "is not the matter at hand."

 

A small shift passed through the room. Not silence as much as the subtle tightening of posture that precedes it. Dáin leaned back slightly in his chair. Fíli's gaze flickered briefly toward Thorin before returning to the maps. Even Balin's eyes rose from the ledgers for a moment before settling once more upon the pages.

 

Dáin folded both his hands atop the head of his axe.

 

"The matter under discussion," his voice rang firm through the hall, "is whether Erebor expects the Iron Hills to drag half its workforce through spring mud merely because your lower halls grow impatient."

 

Ordinarily Thorin might have accepted the bluntness. He might even have appreciated it. Dáin had never been one to wrap his thoughts in layers of polished diplomacy before offering them. There had always been something reassuring in that. Today, however, the resistance itself seemed to catch strangely against Thorin's thoughts, like sparks striking dry timber.

 

"The lower halls are not impatient." he replied. "They are a necessary expansion."

 

"For Erebor."

 

"For both kingdoms."

 

One of the nobles gave a low grunt.

 

"With respect, your majesty, the Iron Hills already profit well enough from present arrangements. Additional labour demands were never part of the original arrangement."

 

"No." Thorin agreed calmly. "Nor did the original arrangement anticipate Erebor's reconstruction proceeding this successfully."

 

There it was - small enough to pass beneath the surface of diplomacy if one chose not to look directly at it. Yet the implication settled plainly enough all the same. Erebor had exceeded all expectations while the Iron Hills had merely kept pace.

 

Dáins eyes narrowed almost immediately.

 

"Aye." he said slowly. "Your rebuilding has proceeded quickly."

 

"Remarkably so," Thorin replied, "considering the state in which the Mountain was found."

 

Again that subtle tightening passed through the chamber. This time Balin looked up fully from the ledgers. Thorin knew precisely what he was doing now. And worse still - some part of him no longer wished to stop.

 

The sensation unsettled him even as it steadied him. The room no longer felt distant in the way the feast hall had the night before. Every answer struck solidly. Every resistance demanded shape from him in return. The pressure of disagreement narrowed the world into something simple and comprehensible. Not unlike labour beneath the monument scaffolds. Not unlike a hammer striking metal.

 

Across the table, Dáin now leaned back fully and heavily in his chair.

 

"The Iron Hills have not exactly remained idle these past five years."

 

"Of course not." Thorin said smoothly. "Your merchants have benefited greatly from Erebor's renewed ore production."

 

At that point, even Fíli's attention sharpened. The jab had been carefully wrapped, though only barely.

 

One of Dáin's advisors let out a short humourless sound.

 

"And Erebor has benefited from eastern labour besides."

 

"Mutually." Thorin agreed.

 

"Mutually." repeated the advisor, sounding unconvinced.

 

The chamber had begun to resemble a forge nearing dangerous heat. Nothing openly hostile had yet been spokened, but despite that, pressure kept building steadily beneath every exchange. It was the kind of pressure Dwarves understood instinctively. Like flaws hidden within metal before the first visible fracture revealed itself beneath the strike of a hammer.

 

Dáin's temper had never been famous for patience. Thorin watched it beginning to rise now the same way one watched smoke gathering beneath a forge hood before flame.

 

"You speak often of what Erebor provides," Dáin said, voice flattening, "for a king whose halls would still stand half empty without eastern hands helping raise them."

 

"And yet they would still stand." Thorin replied.

 

Silence struck the chamber immediately - sharp and heavy.

 

One of Dáin's advisors stiffened outright. Balin slowly lowered the ledger in his hands,. Even the braziers seemed louder in the stillness, their flames crackling softly against iron.

 

Dáin stared down Thorin for several long moments before one broad hand struck the table hard enough to rattle the iron map-weights.

 

"Careful, lad."

 

The words came rough as falling stone. Not diplomatic, nor measured. Pure dwarven warning. Somewhere beneath the heat rising through the chamber, Thorin felt the strange unsettling realization that some part of him welcomed it. The resistance steadied him.

 

For one brief and deeply absurd moment, another thought crossed his mind entirely unbidden: Bilbo Baggins seated somewhere near the edge of the table, listening to the argument with growing bewilderment before quietly asking whether anyone involved had considered waiting until the roads stopped collapsing beneath wagons. The image arrived so suddenly that Thorin nearly felt himself recoil from it.

 

He could picture it with irritating clarity too - the faint crease between Bilbo's brows whenever dwarves transformed practical matters into contests of pride; the particular tone of mild exasperation he employed when speaking to creatures behaving far more dramatically than circumstances truly required. The memory vanished almost immediately, this was no supper-table dispute to be softened with practicality and tea.

 

Dáin leaned further across the table now.

 

"The Iron Hills did not march to Ravenhill merely to spend the next five years being spoken to like sluggish merchants too lazy to fulfill quotas."

 

"No one accuses the Iron Hills of laziness."

 

"Then stop speaking as though we owe Erebor our backs every time your masons grow ambitious."

 

The chamber had abandoned diplomacy almost entirely now, though it had not yet erupted into chaos. Dwarves argued like the mountains shifted: slowly at first, then all at once. Like the shelf of a mountain pass finally collapsing under weight and wear.

 

"And Erebor owes gratitude endlessly in return?" Thorin asked. "Must every disagreement now be measured against Ravenhill?"

 

Across the table, one of the eastern nobles barked a sharp laugh devoid of humour.

 

"Aye, perhaps it should, considering half the Mountain still draws breath because we answered your call - you among them."

 

The words landed hard, not because they were false, but because they rang completely true. That was perhaps the worst part. Because Dáin and his folk had answered. They had bled for Erebor. They had lost for Erebor. They had helped rebuild the kingdom now rising proudly around them.

 

Yet even knowing that plainly, Thorin found himself pressing further into the argument almost instinctively, like a creature testing bruised flesh simply to feel something answer back.

 

"The Iron Hills have profited richly from Erebor's return," he said, "as Erebor has from its alliances."

 

"There!" Dáin thundered suddenly, rising half from his chair. "That tone again."

 

His voice rang through the chamber like the strike of a hammer against steel.

 

"You speak of alliance as though you handed prosperity down from your throne like coins tossed to beggars."

 

"And you speak of assistance as though Erebor alone benefited from it." Thorin answered bluntly, feeling the subtle straightening of his spine.

 

"Aye!" Dáin snapped. "Because you keep speaking like every disagreement thrown before you is some challenge to your pride. We all know what that gold did to you when the dragon was first slain."

 

The words struck harder than Thorin expected. Somewhere unpleasantly deep beneath the argument itself, he suspected Dáin was not entirely wrong. That dragon sickness had left scars on his person that the mountain could not heal. Yet the realization brought no clarity. Only the sharp awareness that once the conflict ended, the strange hollowness waiting beyond it would return as well.

 

He hated that thought immediately. 

 

Before the silence could sharpen further, another voice entered the chamber with enough steadiness to cut cleanly through the heat gathering around the table.

 

"No one here doubts what the Iron Hills sacrificed for Erebor."

 

Fíli had not raised his voice. He simply sounded like the only dwarf in the room who still believed the discussion solvable. The chamber shifted toward him immediately - not because he demanded it, but because he had offered the first words in several minutes that did not feel sharpened for battle.

 

He rested one hand lightly against the maps spread before them.

 

"And no one here doubts what Erebor's restoration has returned to the Iron Hills in turn." he continued evenly. "That is precisely why neither kingdom wishes to weaken the other now.

 

Dáin grunted but did not interrupt. That alone felt significant, and Fíli took it as a sign to continue before anyone else could reclaim the sharp edge of the argument.

 

"The issue is not whether the Iron Hills contribute enough labour. The issue is whether the roads can support larger transports before summer without creating greater delays later."

 

"That was already said." one of the eastern nobles stated with a thoughtful frown.

 

"Aye." Fíli replied calmly. "But not properly listened to."

 

To Thorin's surprise, that nearly drew a smile from Dáin as Fíli leaned slightly across the maps.

 

"The lower western halls do not require full labour increases immediately. Only the reinforced supports and bracket-work must arrive before summer if construction is to continue uninterrupted. Smaller crews travelling more frequently through late spring would place less strain upon the roads while still allowing work beneath the Mountain to continue."

 

Balin finally stepped forward again then, opening one of the ledgers.

 

"The figures would support staggered shipments," he said after a moment, "and the southern patrol routes already overlap the trade roads sufficiently to support additional escorts without heavily increasing labour demands."

 

The chamber quieted again, though this time it was different. A silence of ponder rather than tension. Dáin slowly lowered himself fully back into his chair with a grunt. For several moments he studied the maps in silence before exhaling sharply through his nose.

 

"That," he muttered at last, "sounds considerably more sensible than most of what I have heard this morning."

 

One of the other nobles barked a low laugh.

 

"A poor achievement considering the competition."

 

The tension broke then like thaw-water cracking winter ice. Low chuckles moved around the table. Even Balin's beard twitched faintly with restrained amusement. 

 

Only then did Thorin fully realize how tightly his hand still gripped the edge of the stone table. Slowly he loosened it, and almost immediately that strange hollowness began creeping quietly back into the place where the conflict had briefly held him steady.

⛰︎

Chapter 4: ⛰︎ Restless Covet

Notes:

for you lore nerds:
i stated previously that this story will mainly be based on the book, however this chapter bases some backstory details on the movies because i think it serves this story better. nothing major though.

Chapter Text

⛰︎

The forge Thorin chose stood far below the grander smithies of Erebor.

 

It was not abandoned, nor neglected, but old in the manner of places that had outlived all need of splendour. The walls bore centuries of darkening from smoke above the mouths of furnaces, and the stone beneath the anvils had worn smooth beneath generations of hammer-blows long before Smaug's shadow ever fell across the Mountain. Even after years of restoration, no one had polished away the forge's age. No silver inlay gleamed along the walls. No carved kings watched from high pillars. It was a place built to endure heat, labour, and silence.

 

The hour had long since passed when most smiths laid aside their tools. Elsewhere beneath Erebor, the kingdom had softened into evening. The last traces of the second day of anniversary celebrations still lingered through the higher halls in the form of distant song and the occasional burst of laughter, muffled by stone and distance until they seemed less like living voices than echoes left behind by the previous night. Here, however, there was only the furnace, the anvil, and the steady work of his hands.

 

The metal before him had no great importance. It was a narrow length of reinforced ironwork meant for one of the lower supports beneath the monument chamber. A piece useful enough to justify the hour if anyone cared to ask, but not so urgent that it required the King under the Mountain to shape it himself deep into the night. No one had asked, yet Thorin worked it anyway.

 

The hammer rose and fell in measured strokes. Sparks leapt briefly from the iron and vanished into shadow like fireflies swallowed by deep forest. Heat curled against his forearms beneath rolled sleeves, and the heavier braids of his hair had loosened enough that several grey strands clung faintly against the sweat near his temples. Stone dust from the monument chamber still lingered upon his boots and cuffs, pale against soot-dark cloth. 

 

The rhythm steadied him. Metal did not flatter. It did not argue from wounded pride, nor hide weakness beneath courtesy. If struck poorly, it bent poorly. If heated too little, it resisted. If overworked, it cracked. There was honesty in such things, and after the council chamber's polished words and sharpened silences, Thorin found the plain answer of iron beneath his hammer almost merciful.

 

The meeting had ended well.

 

That fact should have been enough. Agreements had been reached. Trade remained secured. The Iron Hills would send smaller labour groups and fittings more frequently rather than risk heavier transports through unstable mountain roads before the stone shelves had properly settled after winter. Dáin had grumbled, as Dáin often did, but had accepted the solution readily once Fíli shaped it into sense.

 

Thorin struck the iron harder than intended, and the piece shifted slightly across the anvil. He stilled at once. For several breaths only the furnace spoke, its low orange mouth breathing heat against the stone. Thorin adjusted the iron back into place and lowered the hammer, though his hand remained wrapped around its grip.

 

A softer sound interrupted the forge. Footsteps - light but not uncertain.

 

The door at the far end of the chamber opened with a low creak before closing again against the cooler passage beyond. Fíli stood briefly in the entrance while his eyes adjusted to the light in the forge. He had changed from his council garments into plainer dark clothing, though some trace of the day remained upon him still: a faint charcoal mark near one cuff, hair loosened from its formal braids, weariness carried quietly across the shoulders.

 

"There you are." he said at last.

 

Thorin looked down at the iron.

 

"So it would seem."

 

Fíli crossed the chamber slowly, not with the caution of one entering forbidden ground, but with the care of someone who understood that silence too could be a kind of work. He glanced over the shelves, the tools, the cooling trough, then finally toward the piece of metal upon the anvil.

 

"You have improved that beyond all reason."

 

"It required adjusting."

 

"It required adjusting two hours ago. Not it requires rescue."

 

A faint laughter left Thorin despite himself.

 

Fíli leaned on one hip against the nearby worktable and folded his arms. For a while he said nothing. The light from the furnace caught his hair, turning it almost copper-red where it fell loose near his temples. In such light he looked younger than he had in the council chamber, but still older than Thorin remembered him being on the road to Erebor. The thought unsettled him in a manner he could not entirely name.

 

"Balin sent you?" Thorin asked.

 

"Balin suggested I might find you here."

 

"That is not the same thing."

 

"No." Fíli agreed. "He only raised his brows at me until I went."

 

"That is much the same thing."

 

Fíli smiled faintly, though it faded soon enough. For a time they stood in the heat without speaking. Thorin lifted the iron once more into place, though he did not strike it. Fíli watched him, then watched the metal, then looked toward the furnace as though choosing his words with more care than came naturally to him.

 

The younger dwarf possessed a patience that had not existed in him during childhood. Thorin remembered too clearly a boy who once attacked every task with the singular conviction that force and speed together could solve nearly any problem placed before him. Both Fíli and Kíli had been forces of nature no dwarf could contain, yet so many times Dís, Thorin, and the company had to come to their rescue. Kíli still harbored a lot of that recklessness, yet somewhere across the years since Erebor's reclamation, Fílis sharp restless energy had settled into something steadier. Not diminished, simply tempered. Rather like steel.

 

"The council troubled you." Fíli spoke at last - not as an accusation or a challenge, but as a mere observation.

 

"The council resolved successfully."

 

"That was not my question."


Thorin finally lowered the hammer. The metal upon the anvil glowed faintly red along its edges while heat shimmered softly upward between them.

 

"You handled the matter well." Thorin stated with a slight smile.

 

Fíli's expression shifted slightly at the deflection, though he allowed it momentarily.

 

"So I am told."

 

"You disagreed."

 

"I thought you were trying very hard to quarrel with Dáin."

 

The honesty of it nearly drew another smile from Thorin.

 

"And did I succeed?"

 

"Oh, magnificently." Fíli folded his arms lightly. "Another few remarks and I suspect Dáin would have challenged you to wrestle him atop the council table for rights to the eastern roads."

 

"That would at least have shortened the meeting."

 

A brief laugh escaped Fíli then before the warmth faded gradually from his expression. The younger dwarf studied him quietly for several moments afterward while the forge-light shifted across the old stone around them. Thorin had the uncomfortable impression that he was being observed rather more closely than he would prefer.

 

"Dáins remark was unnecessary." Fíli finally spoke again.

 

The warmth vanished from the room. Not literally - the furnace still burned and the coals still glowed. Yet something in Thorin stiffened all the same.

 

'We all know what that gold did to you when the dragon was first slain.'

 

The words returned with uncomfortable clarity. Not only because Dáin had spoken them particularly harshly, but because they had landed.

 

"He should not have said it." Fíli stated, turning his gaze toward the furnace.

 

"He was not wrong."

 

"No."

 

The answer came quietly.

 

Thorin lowered his gaze briefly, scuffing one boot against the soot-darkened stone, before his nephew spoke up once more.

 

"When we first returned to Erebor," Fíli said, "I thought it would be different."

 

Thorin looked toward him then. Fíli did not immediately continue. His face changed, though not into sadness exactly. Memory sat upon him like dust disturbed from a long-covered work.

 

"I do not mean easier." he continued. "I knew it would not be easy. Kíli and I used to speak of it on the road whenever we were too tired to sleep. We thought of halls full of music, forges lit again, feasts where no one counted how much bread remained. We imagined treasure too, of course. We were fools enough for that."

 

"You were young." Thorin stated.

 

"We were Dwarves." Fíli replied, and there was enough dry honesty in it that Thorin could not argue. "I remembered the first time I entered the treasure halls after recovering from the battle. Not during..."

 

He paused, choosing not to name those first terrible days after Smaug's death, when gold had seemed to coil about Thorin's thoughts like smoke from dragon-fire. Fíli instead took a moment to gather his thoughts before continuing.

 

"After. Before you woke up from your injuries. Óin had just concluded that you were going to make it. When the dead had been named and most of the wounded moved and someone finally decided we ought to know what remained beneath our own feet."

 

The furnace breathed between them.

 

"I thought I would feel wonder." Fíli said. "Or pride. Perhaps even temptation, if I am being honest. I had heard all my life of Erebor's wealth. But when I stood there, all I could think was that none of it looked like ours."

 

Thorin's brow drew faintly. Fíli noticed.

 

"I do not mean it belonged elsewhere." he said. "Only that it did not feel as treasure feels in tales. It looked like work. Like generations of hands. Miners, smiths, gem-cutters, traders, masons. Every coin and cup and carved thing had passed through someone's labour before it ever lay in those halls. Smaug slept upon it as though gold becomes his simply because he covers enough of it with his body."

 

The words settled quietly into the forge. Thorin looked back toward the iron upon the anvil, though he no longer truly saw it.

 

"And you?" he asked after a while. "Do you never feel it?"

 

This time Fíli did not answer quickly. He turned the question over in silence, which made the answer when it came seem more truthful.

 

"Not as you mean." he replied at last. "I have wanted many things in those vaults. Any dwarf who claims otherwise is lying or has never seen them properly. But covet them?"

 

He shook his head slowly before continuing.

 

"No. I think I would feel foolish coveting what is already entrusted to us. The gold belongs to Erebor before it belongs to any one of us. Perhaps that is easier for me because I never had to dream of it while sleeping under hedges and broken stone. Or because I am not tasked with managing our riches. Either way, I do not believe I have ever admired it for its own sake."

 

There was no accusation in the words. That made them even harder to bear.

 

"When I first woke up after the battle, you had already managed to relocate every single coin and gem into our treasuries deeper within the mountain." Thorin said after a moment of silence. "I wanted to be angry, but I struggled to blame anyone but myself. It was not hard to see why you did it."

 

"That wasn't the only reason, and you know it. We needed the space for other things. We didn't exactly hide the treasure from you."

 

Thorin took a deep breath, staring at the dust covering his feet for a moment. Then, he let out a deep sigh before looking up at his nephew.

 

"I haven't once entered those vaults."

 

The words hung strangely in the air.

 

Fíli blinked.

 

"Not once?"

 

"No."

 

A long silence followed. The younger dwarf seemed neither shocked nor judgmental, merely surprised. 

 

"Five years?" He asked.

 

Thorin only nodded in response as the furnace crackled softly between them.

 

"Why?" Fíli questioned with a look of genuine bewilderment.

 

The answer arrived before Thorin could stop it, like his tongue had decided the answer for him before he had even made up his mind, though it did not make it any less true.

 

"Because I want to."

 

The younger dwarf frowned, and Thorin rested both hands against the workbench. The words had escaped too quickly. Too easily. Too honestly. For several moments he considered retreating from them, but the longer he contemplated, the less convincing his retraction would appear. Looking up once more and meeting the gaze of his nephew, Thorin found that he wanted to continue.

 

The confession sounded absurd spoken aloud. Yet now that it had begun, stopping felt harder somehow.

 

"I know exactly which corridors lead there." he spoke softly. "There are mornings I find myself walking in that direction before I realize where my feet have taken me. I have allowed my fingers to trace the carved patterns of the doors more than once."

 

Fíli listened without interrupting, only speaking up once more once his uncle had caught his breath and the room had fallen silent once more.

 

"And you walk away every time?"

 

"Every time."

 

The older dwarf exhaled slowly and carefully, returning his gaze to the glowing forge.

 

"I remember Bilbo."

 

The forge seemed to grow still. Even the embers of the fire seemed to freeze for a moment. Fíli lowered his gaze, and Thorin knew immediately that his nephew understood which memory he meant. How could he not?

 

All of them remembered - the company had been there and seen it for themselves. The battlements. The Arkenstone. The rage. 

 

"I remember putting my hand around his throat." Thorin's words came low and measured, as though each needing forcing through cracked stone.

 

The furnace breathed again, but both dwarves still appeared frozen in place.

 

"I remember looking at him and seeing a traitor." Thorin's jaw tightened. "And I remembered him looking at me with the same terror in his eyes as when I was nearly killed, right after the goblin tunnels, before the eagles arrived."

 

A pause. The forge seemed smaller suddenly. More enclosed, with the heat pressing even closer.

 

"I think of that every time I near those halls."

 

The confession settled heavily between them. For a while, neither dwarf said anything. Then, Fíli broke the silence in the softest voice he could muster.

 

"You apologized."

 

"I did."

 

"You made things right."

 

"I tried."

 

Silence fell over them once more, only disturbed by the crackling flames and a quiet, humourless laughter from Thorin.

 

"We sent each other a few letters in the first year after I woke up from my injuries. He did not seem to hold much hostility, yet words written on paper can only convey so much."

 

"I hear him and Balin still write each other quite often."

 

"I heard that too. It gives me some relief."

 

Fíli considered him for a long moment.

 

"Perhaps you should write him again."

 

Thorin looked sharply towards him, but Fíli had already turned his attention to the anvil, as though the thought had been no more than a practical comment regarding an unfinished seam.

 

"I doubt Master Baggins would thank me for disturbing his peace after all these years."

 

Fíli's mouth twitched.

 

"Considering what he endured during the Quest, I suspect ta letter would seem a mild intrusion."

 

The thought did not settle fully in Thorin's mind. Not then. It merely passed through like a glimmer glimpsed within deep water, gone before one could say whether it had been light or memory.

 

"He returned to his home." Thorin said.

 

"As he should have."

 

"Yes."

 

"And you returned to yours."

 

Thorin looked toward him then. Fíli's expression remained open, almost too open. He did not seem to know what he had touched upon. Or perhaps he did, in the manner he often knew things without yet knowing what they meant.

 

"Did I?" Thorin asked.

 

Fíli stilled.

 

The words had escaped more quietly than Thorin intended. Too quietly, perhaps. For a long moment they remained between them like an unfinished thing left cooling upon the anvil.

 

Fíli did not answer at once. He instead swallowed faintly and looked down at his hands, flexing them once as though remembering work from earlier in the day.

 

"The Mountain is yours." he said again.

 

It was the same comfort Dís had offered. The same truth spoken with love and certainty. Yet from Fíli it sounded different somehow, less like expectation and more like a plea to understand. Thorin could not tell if that made it better or worse, only that he felt the old unease stir once more.

 

"Is that what you see when you look upon her?" he asked. "Something that is mine?"

 

Fíli frowned faintly.

 

"No." he said after a moment. "Not quite."

 

Thorin waited for the younger dwarf to continue.

 

Fíli glanced toward the forge walls, blackened by ages of labour, then toward the iron cooling upon the anvil.

 

"I see something we were trusted to return." he said slowly. "And to keep alive. I see my mother's people. Our people. The children who run where there used to be ashes. The smiths who argue over copper costs as if we did not once count scraps. Bori cursing at apprentices. Balin pretending not to worry. Dwalin frightening guards into standing straighter than stone."

 

A faint smile touched him.

 

"I see you too, of course. But not only you."

 

Thorin listened without moving.

 

Fíli seemed almost embarrassed by how much he had said, but continued before he could lose the courage.

 

"The gold is part of that. The halls are part of that. The throne too, I suppose. But none of them matter alone. If I thought they belonged to you before they belonged to Erebor, I think I would be no better than the dragon."

 

Thorin stayed silent for a moment.

 

Fíli grimaced faintly.

 

"That sounded wiser in my head."

 

"No." Thorin said quietly. "It sounded true."

 

Fíli looked at him then, surprised.

 

For reasons Thorin could not have named, the sight of him there - young still in some ways, yet steady, with soot on his sleeve and an instinctive certainty that Thorin himself had spent years failing to grasp - stirred something in him more painful than pride and more gentle than grief.

 

"You handled the council well." Thorin said.

 

Fíli blinked at the change in subject, then smiled slightly.

 

"You did more than settle tempers." Thorin continued. "You heard the shape of the room before the rest of us did."

 

Fíli's smile faded into something less easy.

 

"I heard you and Dáin preparing to bring the ceiling down."

 

"That too."

 

"Someone had to hold up the pillars."

 

The words were spoken lightly, almost carelessly, but Thorin felt them strike somewhere deep.

 

Fíli did not seem to notice. He simply pushed himself away from the worktable and reached for the poker beside the furnace, turning one coal inward until sparks rose and died.

 

"The monument will be ready tomorrow." he said. "Bori has sworn at six workers, three tools, one scaffold, and the concept of dust itself. Which means all progresses as expected."

 

"A reassuring report." Thorin allowed himself to smile.

 

"I thought so."

 

For a while they stood together beside the forge, the conversation easing back into safer ground. Fíli spoke of the lower seams, the cloth coverings, the workers who had been forbidden from peeking and were therefore more determined than ever to do so. Thorin listened, grateful in ways he did not know how to express. The anticipation for the unveiling returned faintly, though now tangled with other thoughts less easily shaped. Gold. Vaults. Bilbo. Home. Fíli's voice saying the Mountain was not his alone.

 

At last Fíli moved toward the door.

 

"You should sleep before tomorrow."

 

"An excellent suggestion."

 

"You have no intention of following it, have you?"

 

"Very perceptive."

 

"That too I learned from you."

 

Thorin shook his head faintly. At the threshold, Fíli paused and looked back.

 

"Uncle."

 

Thorin lifted his gaze. Fíli seemed for a moment as though he might say something more, something heavier, but in the end he only smiled faintly.

 

"Do not improve that piece a fourth time. It has suffered enough."

 

Then he was gone.

 

The forge fell quiet once more and his footsteps faded. Only the furnace remained, breathing steadily against the old stone walls while the iron cooled slowly upon the anvil. Thorin stood beside it for a long while, one hand resting near the hammer, his thoughts drawn not toward the council chamber nor even the monument waiting veiled beneath scaffold, but toward a small figure upon a battlement years ago and the look in his eyes before everything broke.

 

'Perhaps you should write him again.', Fíli had said.

 

Thorin did not take up pen that night.

 

But long after the forge-fire dimmed and the Mountain sank deeper into sleep, the thought remained.

⛰︎

Chapter 5: ⛰︎ Unveiled

Chapter Text

⛰︎

The third and final evening of celebrations came with gold upon the sky.

 

Beyond the carved arches of Erebor, the sun lowered itself behind the far ridges and cast its light across Dale, setting roof and river aflame in colours that seemed wrought more than born. Within the Lonely Mountain, lanterns had already been lit in long rows along the walls, and their flames caught upon stone, bronze, polished iron and the bright edges of jewels worn for the unveiling ceremony. Everywhere beneath the upper halls there moved the sound of gathering feet.

 

Dwarves came first from Erebor itself: miners still broad with the strength of the lower tunnels, smiths smelling faintly of coal and hot metal despite their finer clothes, merchants whose belts rang softly with tokens of trade, children half-pulled into order by exasperated elders, and workers whose hands had helped raise the very monument now hidden at the chamber's heart. After them came guests from the Iron Hills, from Ered Luin, from lesser halls and scattered clans, from Dale, and from those kin who had travelled far simply to stand within the Mountain on the fifth anniversary of her reclamation. Some wore gold openly. Some wore plain travelling wool. Some still looked up at the vaults of Erebor as though expecting the stone itself to speak.

 

The chamber had now been cleared of scaffold, dust and workbenches, though the air still held a trace of stone-cutting beneath the perfume of oil-lanterns and ceremonial incense - as if no sweeping could wholly remove the memory of labour from a place where so many hands had recently worked. Along the outer wall, great arches opened toward the evening. Through them entered a breath of cold mountain air, moving gently through the gathered crowd and stirring the hanging cloth that still concealed the monument.

 

The covering Fíli had chosen was deep blue and heavy enough that it gave little hint of the shape beneath. Silver runes bordered its edge, stitched by Dwarven hands with such care that even the concealment seemed ceremonial. Ropes of braided black and gold held the fabric in place. It gathered above and around the monument so that, at the appointed moment, one pull would free it all at once. 

 

Thorin stood near the raised stone platform at the front of the chamber, listening to the gathering murmur rise around him.

 

He had dressed as was expected of him. Dark ceremonial garments beneath a regal blue mantle edged in silver. Gold at his belt. Braids set carefully with rings belonging to the line of Durin. The crown rested upon his head with a weight long since familiar enough to be ignored by those parts of him carved for endurance.

 

Across the chamber, Fíli stood near the monument with several others, speaking in low tones with Bori who was still fussing over the fall of the cloth. Though the younger dwarf had changed from work clothes into formal blue and gold, there remained upon him some stubborn trace of the past weeks' labour. Perhaps it was only in the way he stood too near the craftsmen and not near enough the nobles, or the way his gaze kept travelling anxiously over the bindings as though expecting the entire monument to collapse out of spite the moment a crowd gathered.

 

Kíli approached Thorin from the side.

 

"My brother tells me all is prepared." he said.

 

"So I see."

 

"He has also checked the ropes five times."

 

"Only five?"

 

"Six, if one counts the argument with Bori as inspection."

 

"Then the monument is likely the safest thing in Erebor tonight." Thorin said, allowing the faintest smile to take form on his lips.

 

"Possibly in all the North." A voice behind them spoke up.

 

Both Thorin and Kíli turned to see Balin approaching them, leaning on his staff in a way he did increasingly with each passing year.

 

Balin's eyes traced the covered monument before moving back to Thorin's face, and for one brief moment something quieter entered his expression. The look was not questioning precisely, nor was it pity. Balin had always possessed the troublesome gift of seeing too much and saying little until the weight of silence became intolerable.

 

"I will speak first." Thorin said at last. "Then the honour is mine to give."

 

Kíli inclined his head.

 

"And after?"

 

"After," Balin replied before Thorin had the opportunity, glancing toward the crowd with a hint of a smile beneath his beard, "we allow Dwarves and our visitors from Dale alike to admire fine work, which means no one will leave this chamber before midnight unless hunger or injury compels them."

 

"That seems likely."

 

"Dáin has already wagered that the Iron Hills could have built it in half the time."

 

Kíli let out a slight chuckle, but Thorin's brows furrowed.

 

"Dáin wagered that before seeing it, knowing full well that a third of the workers on this project are from the Iron Hills."

 

"He did not seem to consider that relevant to his argument."

 

This time Thorin did smile, though the expression faded as his gaze returned to the covered shape at the centre of the chamber.

 

'It should matter.', he thought. 'All of it.'

 

The words did not come sharply to him, nor even with distress. They passed through him like a cold current beneath still water. This should matter.

 

For weeks he had wondered what lay beneath those cloths, having only commissioned Fíli to lead the construction of a grand monument for the Erebor's anniversary. He had watched the younger dwarf guard the secret with increasing stubbornness. He had felt the low anticipation of a craftsman denied sight of a work being fitted together almost within reach. He had helped shape pieces he had not been allowed to understand fully. He had seen pride in the eyes of every worker who knew what waited beneath the covering.

 

All day, as the hour approached, some part of him had waited for feeling to gather. It had not, not yet.

 

A herald struck the base of his staff against the floor twice. The sound carried through the chamber and returned from the vaults above in diminishing echoes until even the children quieted. The gathered assembly turned toward the platform, voices lowering into silence as ripples lower upon a deep pool. Lantern-light moved across countless faces: expectant, solemn, eager, proud.

 

Thorin stepped forward, and the chamber received him as it always did.

 

His people watched. His kin watched. Guests and allies watched. Dáin stood near the front with arms folded across his broad chest, gruff face half-lit by flame. Dís stood not far from Fíli, her gaze fixed upon Thorin with quiet warmth and anticipation. Dwalin had placed himself slightly to one side of the platform where he could see too many entrances at once and pretend he was not moved by anything at all. 

 

Thorin rested his hand upon the carved edge of the platform railing.

 

"My kin." he began, and his voice carried cleanly through the chamber. "Friends of Erebor. Guests from halls near and far. We gather tonight beneath the Mountain not only in celebration, but in remembrance."

 

The first words settled well. He felt it in the room, though not within himself. That too had become a skill of his these last five years: knowing when words struck true by the breath of those listening, by the smallest change of posture, by the manner in which silence deepened not from boredom but attention.

 

"Five years have passed since dragon-fire was driven from these halls, since enemies were defeated at our gates, and since Durin's Folk stood once more where our fathers stood before us. Five years may seem a short span in the memory of stone. To Dwarves, it is scarcely the blink of an eye beside the ages through which our people have endured. Yet there are years that weigh more than centuries, and there are days upon which the course of many lives turned."

 

He let his gaze move across the chamber.

 

"Many here remember exile. Many remember halls lost, names scattered, labour sold beneath foreign roofs and children born beneath skies that were not their own. Many of us remember the long road between what was taken and what was restored."

 

The silence in the chamber deepened, though the words came easy for Thorin. This was not hard to say - that was what made it strange.

 

These words belonged to him. They had been carved into him by years of hunger, grief, stubbornness and hope. They were not false, nor were they borrowed. If truth alone were enough to summon feeling, surely it would have risen then. Yet nothing rose, so he continued.

 

"We remember also those who did not live to stand beneath this roof tonight. Those who fell before these gates. Those who fell far from them. Those who guarded memory when no stone hall remained to shelter it. We do not speak all their names, for they are many, and each heart here carries some among them already."

 

A low murmur moved through the crowd then, not disruptive but more solemn, like wind passing through pine trees far away. Near the front, Dáin lowered his head. Dís closed one hand around the beadwork at her wrist. Somewhere among the workers, an older dwarf wiped roughly at his eyes and glared at no one in particular, as though daring anyone to observe it.

 

"Yet tonight," Thorin said, "we do not honour sorrow alone. Were this monument raised only to grief, it would stand incomplete. For Erebor was not restored by mourning what had been lost. She was restored by hands set again to work in honour of those who fell."

 

At that, something stirred in the crowd. The workers standing closest to the monument seemed to straighten almost without realizing it.

 

"By miners who returned to dark passages and opened them once more. By smiths who kindled dead forges. By stoneworkers who raised broken halls from ruin. By merchants who brought trade through roads long silent. By mothers and fathers who taught children than exile was not the only inheritance left for them. By our allies who stood beside us when standing beside us meant blood upon the ground."

 

Thorin's gaze found Dáin briefly, whose expression shifted - rough and unreadable as always, though the nod he gave was firm.

 

"Erebor stands because many hands lifted her. She prospers because many hands continue the labour. No king beneath the Mountain, whether of old or of days yet to come, may claim otherwise and speak truth."

 

The words moved through the chamber with greater force than Thorin had intended. Not because they were too loud, but because something in the room answered them at once. A murmur of approval rose and fell. Fíli looked toward his uncle sharply, then smiled before quickly looking away. Balin's gaze softened.

 

Thorin felt none of it reach him. He heard himself speaking still.

 

"And so this work, raised in honour of five years restored, is given not to the glory of one name, nor one hand, nor one crown. It is given to the making of Erebor. To those who struck the first hammer-blow after ruin. To those who will strike last long after we are gone. To the fallen. To the living. To the children who shall one day look upon these halls and know not the dragon, nor the battle of five armies, but only the home their people built anew."

 

He then turned toward Fíli.

 

"My nephew, Fíli, son of Dís of the line of Durin, has overseen this work from its beginning. It is only fitting that it should be revealed by his hand."

 

A ripple passed through the crowd. Surprise in some places, approval in many more. Fíli's face changed at once, pride and sudden alarm warring so plainly upon it that a quieter laughter stirred among those near enough to see him.

 

Thorin stepped down from the platform, and for several moments the chamber seemed to hold its breath as Fíli approached the cord.

 

He paused there, hand wrapped around the braided rope, and glanced toward Thorin. There was formality in the moment, certainly. Ceremony demanded it. But beneath that formality, Fíli's expression remained almost painfully familiar: hope barely restrained behind composure, the wish for approval still sitting somewhere beneath the authority he had grown into.

 

Thorin nodded once.

 

Fíli drew the cord.

 

For an instant, nothing happened. Then the bindings released, and the cloth fell in a great blue sweep. The chamber fell silent. Not because the monument disappointed, but rather the opposite. Because no one yet hade voice enough for it.

 

At the centre of the hall rose an anvil carved from black stone, vast and solemn, its sides veined with silver and patterned in runes so fine they seemed almost woven rather than cut. It did not resemble the common tools of a smithy except in essence. Rather, it stood like the memory of all anvils: weight, purpose and endurance given form.

 

Above it descended the hammer. It was not held by any carved figure. No smith loomed over the work. No king guided the blow. The hammer itself emerged from the monument's upper structure, meticulously balanced to stand firm and secure yet appear as though falling from some unseen hand beyond the moment captured there. Its head was wrought from dark stone banded with iron and gold, frozen at the breath before and the breath after impact all at once.

 

Where hammer met anvil, the monument became wondrous.

 

Metal burst outward from the strike in sweeping arcs of bronze, iron, silver and gold. Some pieces were slender as threads, others broad as ribbons of flame. They did not merely imitate sparks; they transformed them. Each arc had been shaped and anchored into stone so precisely that the whole seemed to move despite its stillness, as though one had entered the forge at the very instant creation leapt from impact.

 

Within those frozen sparks lay carvings too intricate to comprehend at first glance. A miner lifting the first lamp in a dark passage. A smith bent over white-hot metal. A mason setting stone into an archway. A merchant leading a pack of animals beneath mountain roads. A mother fastening the cloak of a young child. A young apprentice watching an elder's hands. Bridges rising. Forges kindling. Wheels turning. Halls filling. Small scenes folder into greater lines, each one part of the burst, each one carried outward from the central strike until the entire life of Erebor seemed to unfold from hammer meeting anvil.

 

At the base, rough unworked stone gave way gradually to carved pillars, polished walls, inlaid patterns and shining metalwork. The higher one looked, the more the monument changed from raw matter into craft. It did not show a battle. It did not show a dragon. It did not show Thorin. It showed making.

 

For another breath the hall remained still.

 

Then the sound came, not applause first. A deep murmur rising from many throats all at once. Wonder. Recognition. Pride so sudden and so collective it seemed almost to pass through the stone beneath their feet. Then voices followed, and laughter, and exclamations as Dwarves surged forward by instinct before remembering themselves and stopping short of the ceremonial boundary.

 

Dáin was the first to break into open approval.

 

"Now that," his voice thundered, "is a proper piece of work!"

 

The chamber erupted.

 

Laughter burst out. Workers began speaking all at once, some pointing toward sections they had helped carve, others toward details they had clearly not known would sit beside their own. Bori stood with arms crossed and face rigid in a heroic attempt not to appear moved, though his eyes had gone bright and he was blinking too often for dignity. Balin removed his spectacles, polished them carefully, then placed them back upon his nose only to remove them again almost immediately.

 

Fíli stood near the fallen cloth, smiling more proudly than anyone had ever seen him.

 

Dís reached him first. She took his face briefly between both hands as she had not done in public since he was young. She pressed her brow to his and said something Thorin could not hear over the swelling voices. Whatever it was, Fíli laughed and looked away at once, though not quickly enough to hide the shine in his eyes before he was tackled into a deep hug by Kíli.

 

The workers gathered around him next. Then Dáin, who clasped his shoulder hard enough to stagger a lesser dwarf, and immediately began demanding to know which fool had managed to shape the hammer-head without collapsing the entire structure. Half the chamber answered at once. The other half began arguing over whether the true mastery lay in the stonework, the metalwork, or the hidden supports that allowed the monument to appear almost alive.

 

Thorin remained where he was.

 

He looked upon the monument and understood at once why the hall had fallen silent.

 

The workmanship was extraordinary.

 

Not merely skilled, though it was precisely that beyond question. The monument possessed the rare quality found only in the finest craft: it revealed more of itself the longer one studied it. The eye travelled from the hammer to the anvil, from the strike to the sparks, from the sparks to the countless scenes hidden within them. One moment he found himself studying a mason shaping an arch. The next, a smith bent over a forge. Then a miner carrying a lamp through darkness. Then merchants upon a road. Then children learning trade from weathered hands.

 

The whole kingdom seemed to emerge from the single strike of a hammer. Not treasure. Not kings. Not victory. Instead work. Creation. Making. A monument worthy of Erebor. A monument worthy of remembrance.

 

A monument that should have moved him like it did everyone else around him.

 

The workers who had helped raise it stood a little taller. Craftsmen pointed eagerly toward details only they would ever fully appreciate. Arguments had already begun regarding technique and proportion, which was perhaps the highest praise a gathering of Dwarves could offer any work. Even those who possessed no knowledge of stone or metal seemed drawn towards it instinctively, as though some part of them recognized themselves in the monument's purpose.

 

Thorin watched one of the masons involved in the project tracing one section of carved stone with his fingertips. The old craftsman wore an expression Thorin had seen countless times throughout his life: pride. Not pride in himself, not even pride in the monument. Pride in the work - that distinction mattered.

 

Nearby, several younger smiths were debating the metalwork with such intensity that one might have mistaken the monument for a matter of national survival. Dáin had already inserted himself into the dispute and was making it considerably louder. Balin stood studying the stonework with a faint smile hidden beneath his long beard.

 

No one seemed aware of being observed - they belonged entirely to the moment.

 

That, more than anything, was what struck Thorin.

 

Not the monument, but the people. The monument merely gave shape to something already living within them. They understood this, not all of them intellectually, but naturally. As though the same spark that leapt eternally from hammer to anvil had always existed within them.

 

His gaze drifted toward Fíli. 

 

The younger dwarf had disappeared into the crowd entirely. Or rather, the crowd had entirely absorbed him.

 

Workers pulled him toward different sections of the monument. Nobles sought his attention. Craftsmen interrupted one another attempting to explain details he already knew. Dís had been drawn into the centre of it as well, laughing at something one of the stoneworkers had said. Even Dáin had ceased treating Fíli as a prince and begun treating him as something far more dangerous: a fellow dwarf with authority and opinions.

 

The thought almost made Thorin smile.

 

Almost.

 

Instead he found himself watching.

 

A strange memory surfaced then, brief as the flicker of a lantern. Among the countless figures hidden within the flowing metalwork, one small carving depicted a traveller walking a winding road. The figure was so minor most would likely overlook it entirely.

 

For reasons Thorin could not have explained, it brought Bilbo briefly to mind.

 

He found himself the hobbit would have admired the monument or immediately begun criticizing practical matters no Dwarf had considered. The thought felt oddly familiar, like a letter rediscovered between the pages of an old book.

 

Then it passed, yet the monument remained. The crowd remained. As did the feeling.

 

Or rather, the absence of feeling.

 

Thorin looked upon the crowd of people gathered around the masterpiece at the centre of the hall and waited for something to stir within him. Pride. Gratitude. Wonder. Even grief would have sufficed. Instead there was only distance. Not because the monument lacked meaning or because the celebration felt hollow. In fact, it was the complete opposite. Everything possessed meaning. Meaning woven into stone and metal. Meaning alive in every voice around him. Meaning shining openly upon faces he had known for decades and faces of strangers alike. The fault did not lie in Erebor, nor did it lie in the monument.

 

A cold clarity began gathering slowly within him, not sudden as lightning but steady as frost spreading across iron. He had let himself believe, without admitting it to himself, that this might answer something. The anniversary. The speeches. The honouring of both dead and living. The finished work revealed at last. Something within him should have stepped forward to meet it.

 

Instead he stood at the heart of his restored kingdom and felt as though the hall belonged to another life.

 

A king should have been moved by this.

 

Thorin, who had crossed wilderness and war for Erebor, who had dreamed of the Lonely Mountain through years of exile, who had once believed no treasure beneath earth or sky could rival the restoration of these halls, should have been moved by this. Yet, for some reason, he was not.

 

For the first time, the absence itself frightened him. Not because it was new, but because it was undeniable.

 

The thought came then with the impact of a hammer against anvil.

 

'I cannot remain king'

 

It did not arrive as a decision. It was too vast for that. It instead came as clarity. As knowledge glimpsed through a crack in the foundations: a dark seam running beneath all things, present long before one notices it, shaping a whole structure from below.

 

Thorin looked toward Fíli.

 

The younger dwarf stood among workers and nobles alike, laughing at something Dís had said while still glancing every few moments toward the monument as though scarcely believing it had finally been seen. Kíli stood nearby. Balin too. Dáin's loud approval shook the air. The people of Erebor crowded close, not toward the platform or toward Thorin, but toward the work itself and the many hands that had made it.

 

The Mountain lived.

 

The Mountain needed no convincing.

 

The Mountain rejoiced without him.

 

For a moment, Thorin felt very still, as though any movement might reveal the fracture opening quietly within.

 

Then Dwalin looked toward him from across the chamber. Only briefly, yet long enough for Thorin to straighten by instinct. The king's face returned before the dwarf beneath it could be seen.

 

He stepped forward as the celebration swelled. He accepted the praise directed toward him, clasped hands, listened to voices, spoke words of approval where they were required. None of it was false. That, perhaps, was the strangest cruelty. He meant every word he spoke. The work was a masterpiece deserving of the highest honour. Fíli deserved pride. The craftsmen deserved remembrance. But meaning somehow moved around him now rather than through him.

 

Above them all, frozen sparks of gold, bronze, silver and iron leapt eternally from hammer-strike into stone. 

 

The chamber was filled with joy.

 

And Thorin Oakenshield stood among his people, smiling as a king should, while somewhere deep beneath crown and mantle the last certainty of his reign began quietly to give away.

⛰︎

Chapter 6: ⛰︎ Heavy Lies the Crown

Chapter Text

⛰︎

Morning lingered pale upon the eastern slopes when the Dwarves of the Iron Hills began their departure from Erebor.

 

The celebrations had not ended so much as loosened their grip upon the Mountain. Though the halls still carried the remnants of wine, song, and ceremony, guests had begun gathering their cloaks, tightening their belts, searching for misplaced possessions, and extending farewells far beyond what any other departure would have required. Messengers moved between chambers with final copies of agreements, sealed letters, and invitations offered too late to be useful but too warmly meant to refuse. Beneath it all the Mountain had already resumed its ordinary rhythm: carts rolling, hammers waking, voices calling across corridors, fires being fed in kitchens and forges alike. Erebor had celebrated her restoration; now she had returned, steadily and without ceremony, to the labour of remaining.

 

Thorin and Fíli stood together upon one of the outer balconies overlooking the eastern road. They had come there intentionally, as was fitting. Dáin was kin as much as ally, and though the meeting two days prior had frayed tempers more than honour demanded, no bitterness had remained since the unveiling of the monument. Dwarves were rarely gentle in anger, but neither were they always inclined to preserve it once it had spent its force. Dáin had embraced half the household before breakfast, insulted the ale of Erebor while requesting another cask for the road, and loudly praised the monument.

 

Far below the balcony, the departing company arranged itself into something that aspired toward order and achieved instead the familiar controlled disorder of Dwarves preparing for travel. Pack animals stamped upon stone. Wagons creaked beneath secured loads. Guards shouted to one another across the road while younger dwarves hurried back and forth carrying bundles that should have been loaded the night before. Dark banners of the Iron Hills stirred heavily in the cold morning air, and beyond them the road wound eastward through the lower slopes before disappearing among ridges still pale with the early morning light.

 

Fíli leaned both forearms upon the stone railing and watched Dáin stride through the confusion below with all the subtlety of a boulder deciding to roll downhill.

 

“I give it another moment before he turns the entire procession around because someone forgot something important.” he said.

 

“The hard part of getting him out of the Mountain is over. Once Dáin is on the road there is no turning back unless lives are at stake.” Thorin replied.

 

“You have greater faith in him than I do.”

 

“I have greater knowledge of him.”

 

Below, several dwarves broke away from the line and hurried back toward the gate carrying empty crates between them. Fíli pointed without attempting to hide his satisfaction at being right.

 

”There.”

 

”They may be carrying farewell gifts.”

 

”They are running.”

 

”Then the gifts must be urgent.”

 

Fíli laughed, and the sound passed out over the road with the morning wind. For a time the two of them stood in companionable silence while the first wagons began to move. Thor in watched the wheels settle into the road’s old grooves and felt, by habit, the familiar count begin within him: riders, guards, provisions, distance, weather, the state of the eastern shelves after winter. Such calculations had shaped him for too many years to leave him merely because one decision had formed in the dark of the night before. 

 

Yet beneath those thoughts lay another, broader and stranger. The road itself seemed clearer to him that morning than it had in years. Not as a route requiring repair or negotiation, nor as a line upon a map tied to trade, alliance or defence, but simply as a road - stone giving way to distance and distance giving way to lands unseen from the Mountain’s gates. The sight did not call to him, not exactly. It was too soon for that. It merely existed before him without asking anything of his crown.

 

“The Iron Hills seemed satisfied enough.” Fíli said after a while. “I heard Dáin praising the metalwork to Glóin, even though Glóin was not even involved in the construction.”

 

“Dáin told Glóin that the hammer-head could use more iron.”

 

”That is high praise from the Iron Hills.”

 

”That is hunger from the Iron Hills.”

 

”Glóin looked ready to strike him with one of the ceremonial lanterns.”

 

”I would have allowed it.”

 

”Balin would not.”

 

”Balin ruins many fine moments in the name of diplomacy.”

 

Fíli smiled, though the expression turned thoughtful almost at once. He had been tired when they came out, but it was the clean tiredness of work completed and well received, not the grey heaviness Thorin had come to recognize in himself. Formal blue still marked him as prince of Erebor, yet the wind had loosened several strands of hair from his braids, and there remained, stubbornly, a faint dark line near one cuff where charcoal or soot had survived every attempt at ceremony.

 

”You did well with them.” Thor in said.

 

Fíli glanced sideways.

 

”With the Iron Hills?”

 

”With all of it.”

 

The younger dwarf’s expression shifted, wariness stirring beneath the morning ease. 

 

“That is broad enough to mean nothing.”

 

”It means what I said.”

 

”I oversaw a monument and survived one meeting.”

 

”You speak as though either were small.”

 

”I speak as though you are beginning a conversation from the wrong end, uncle.”

 

Thorin allowed himself a faint smile at that, but it faded as his hands settled upon the railing. The stone was cold beneath his palms, worn smooth by weather and the hands of those who had stood there before him. Far below, the first line of Dáin‘s company rounded slowly towards the north-east. The rest followed in staggered motion - shouting, adjusting, correcting one another and arguing about loads that were by now already tied down.

 

”When you look at Erebor,” Thorin said slowly. “what do you see?”

 

”I see Erebor.” Fíli said as he turned fully to face his uncle.

 

”That is not an answer.”

 

”It is the only answer your question deserves.”

 

”You know what I ask.”

 

”No,” Fíli said, though without sharpness. “I suspect that you know what you ask, which is not always the same thing.”

 

Thorin looked at him then, and for a moment something like amusement passed between them. Fíli had grown increasingly difficult to corner in conversation these past years. Once he would have answered too quickly and defended the answer too stubbornly. Now he circled questions when he sensed hidden edges in them, and that was perhaps something he had learned more from Balin than from Thorin.

 

Still, he considered it. His gaze moved across the Mountain below them, over the lower roads leading toward Dale, the outer workshops already needing more room, the gates through which carts entered and departed, and the visible ridge lines where new watch-posts had been discussed but not yet built. What began as caution gradually softened into attention.

 

”I see what it might become.” he answered the question at last, and seemed almost surprised by the plainness of his own answer.

 

Thorin remained still. “Tell me.”

 

Fíli frowned, then gave a small shrug as though to diminish the answer before fully offering it.

 

”The southern workshops are crowding each other already. If trade continues as it has, we will need new storage halls before the decade passes, and proper space for visiting merchants before they overrun every lower corridor with crates and complaints. The road to Dale should be widened near the second bend - not at once perhaps, but soon enough before someone attempts to send three wagons abreast through a path made for one and blames the Mountain when they wedge themselves there until winter.”

 

Despite himself, Thorin huffed a quiet laugh. Encouraged, Fíli continued, his thoughts gathering speed the more he spoke.

 

”Dale is growing too, faster than Bard’s council seems willing to admit, and if we do not plan with them rather than beside them, we will spend the next twenty years discovering that Men build roads precisely where Dwarves would prefer to place drainage channels.”

 

This time Thorin did not laugh, though some warmth passed through him at the shape of Fíli’s irritation. The younger dwarf was not reciting reports. He was seeing a kingdom in motion - roads not yet laid, halls not yet carved, difficulties not yet fully born but already requiring thought. Fíli stopped abruptly when he seemed to realise how long he had spoken.

 

”I am rambling.”

 

”No,” Thorin said. “you are not.”

 

The wind moved between the pillars behind them, carrying with it faint sounds from the waking Mountain. Somewhere deep below, a hammer struck metal. The note rose thinly through the morning air before it disappeared into the greater murmur of Erebor. Thorin looked upon his nephew and saw again the crowd gathered around the monument, the workers turning naturally towards him, the craftsmen explaining details he already knew, Dáin arguing with him not as one indulging a prince but as one answering another dwarf whose mind had become worth testing.

 

”When I look at Erebor,” Thorin said quietly. “I see what was restored.”

 

Fíli’s expression changed, not with understanding yet, but with recognition that the conversation had found its true road at last.

 

”I see halls rebuilt.” Thorin continued. “Mines reopened. Trade recovered. Debts honoured. Promises kept. I see the distance between exile and return, and I measure every stone against what was lost before the dragon came. That has been my work, and I do not regret it.”

 

”No one in their right mind would ask you to regret it, uncle.”

 

”No.” Thorin looked eastward at the last of the Iron Hills’ company had already put distance between them and the Mountain. “But you look upon the same halls and se what has not yet been made. That is not merely youth. It is vision.”

 

Fíli pushed himself away from the railing slightly, unease rising at last through his posture. 

 

"If this is another way of praising how i handled the council-“

 

"It is not.”

 

"Then what is it?”

 

Thorin did not answer immediately. For all the certainty that had carried him through the night, the words themselves remained heavy. Once spoken, they would not return to him unchanged. He thought briefly of Dís in the hall after the feast, of her careful hope and gentle talk of happiness and family. He thought of noble daughters placed near him through five years of feasts, councils and seasonal gathering - all of the courteous and intelligent, many of them admirable yet none of them stirring in him anything beyond the wary knowledge of what others expected him to want. For a long while he had assumed some desire would come in its proper season, as spring comes beneath snow. It had not come. After enough years, even absence takes on the shape of truth.

 

"When your mother speaks of marriage," Thorin said at last, "she does so because she believes I have merely delayed it."

 

Fíli blinked, thrown entirely.

 

"I suppose she does."

 

"So does half the Mountain. The other half discusses it less politely."

 

"That is, unfortunately, probably true."

 

"There was a time I believed them right. I thought the wish for such things would come when Erebor was secure, or when grief had passed, or when the work left space for anything beyond necessity." He kept his gaze upon the road while he spoke, not from shame necessarily, but because some truths are easier offered to distance than to another face.

 

"It did not." he then concluded.

 

Fíli said nothing for several moments. Beneath them, the last visible riders from the Iron Hills had disappeared beyond the first bend, their banners having folded into distance. When he finally spoke, his voice had quieted.

 

"You are saying you do not intend to marry."

 

"Yes."

 

"And there will be no children of yours."

 

"No."

 

The answer settled between them with a force Thorin had expected and still found difficult. Fíli looked down toward the road, and Thorin could almost see the pieces shifting in his mind: years of deflections, the careful efforts of Dís, the strange stillness that followed every conversation of heirs, the fact that everyone had treated Fíli's place in the succession as temporary - not because they doubted him, but because they assumed Thorin's line would eventually continue elsewhere.

 

"And because of that," Fíli said slowly, "you mean the line shall pass through me."

 

"Yes."

 

The younger dwarf absorbed it, then shook his head once sharply as though rejecting not the statement itself but the unseen thing gathering behind it.

 

"One day."

 

"Sooner than one day."

 

"No."

 

Thorin turned toward him fully then. Fíli's refusal came not as political resistance, nor even uncertainty of his own abilities. It came with the immediate force of a wound touched without warning.

 

"No." he repeated. "You do not get to stand her on a cold morning after too little sleep and tell me that the shape of our house has changed because you spent one night thinking too deeply beside a dark hearth."

 

"It was not one night."

 

"Then one week. One month. One year. I do not care." Fíli's voice rose, then lowered again when he seemed to remember the road below still held distant ears. "You are not too old. You are not failing. The Mountain is not turning against you. You are loved here, uncle."

 

"I know, Fíli."

 

"Then stay."

 

The simplicity of it struck Thorin more sharply than any argument might have done. Fíli looked at him with open frustration now, but beneath it lay fear, and beneath that something younger still.

 

"If this is because you feel restless, then be restless. If you cannot sleep, do not sleep. If the councils bore you, let Balin bury you in them until you come to your senses. If you need to leave Erebor for a season, then leave it for a season and return. Kings have travelled before without surrendering crowns."

 

"This is not about restlessness alone."

 

"Then explain it." Fíli pleaded.

 

"I am trying." Thorin replied with near equal frustration.

 

"Try plainly."

 

Thorin looked back toward the Mountain. Plainly, then. Yet plainness had never been as simple as dwarves often liked to claim, for the truest things often lay beneath words in caverns of their own. He took a slow breath followed by and let the morning air steady him.

 

"Erebor needs a king who knows where she is going." He finally stated in a soft yet secure voice.

 

Fíli stared at him ready to respond to the statement, but Thorin continued before the younger dwarf could answer.

 

"I know where she has been. I know every road between loss and restoration, every debt paid to bring these halls from ruin to life. I know how to defend what we reclaimed. I know how to remember. But when I look forward now, beyond the work already done, I see no road clearly enough to lead others upon."

 

"That cannot be true, uncle!"

 

"It is." Thorin spoke calmly and without bitterness. "Last night proved it to me."

 

"The monument?"

 

"The people around it."

 

Fíli's anger faltered slightly.

 

"I stood before a work that honoured everything I value: craft, labour, endurance, the making of a kingdom by many hands. I saw its worth and its beauty. I knew why the hall answered it with pride, yet I stood outside that joy as one might stand outside a closed gate and remember the path within without being able to enter." 

 

Thorin looked toward Fíli once more before continuing.

 

"But you were within it, Fíli. Not because you forced yourself there. Not because ceremony placed you there. You were part of the life moving through that chamber, and it answered you."

 

Fíli looked away quickly, his jaw tightening.

 

"That is not kingship, uncle."

 

"It is nearer to it than many things called by that name."

 

"You are making poetry of a crowd enjoying a sculpture."

 

"No," Thorin said. "I am making a judgment."

 

The word struck differently. Fíli looked back.

 

"A king's judgment?"

 

"Yes."

 

For a while the younger dwarf said nothing. Now all movement had vanquished from the roads beneath them, only a faint layer of dust lingered in the air. The silence left behind the departure of Dáin and his company seemed larger than ever, as if the Mountain had exhaled and now waited.

 

"I hate this." Fíli said at last.

 

"I know."

 

"You are asking me to take your place."

 

"No." Thorin shook his head. "I am asking you to take your own."

 

Fíli let out a sharp breath through his nose, almost a laugh, though there was no amusement in it.

 

"That sounds like something Balin would say when trying to make bad news seem inevitable."

 

"Balin would take longer."

 

Despite himself, Fíli's mouth twitched into a discreet smile. It was gone quickly, and in its place was a slight frown and worried eyes.

 

"You truly believe this?"

 

"I know it."

 

The younger dwarf turned again to the railing and gripped it with both hands. His gaze remained fixed upon the empty road below, though Thorin doubted he saw much of it.

 

"When I was young," Fíli said after a long silence. "I thought being king meant standing where all could see you. I thought the weight of it was in the crown, the hall, the songs. Later I learned that was the least of it."

 

"What frightens you now?"

 

"That I understand why you are asking."

 

The answer came quietly, and because it came quietly it carried further.

 

"If I thought this to be because of sorrow, I would fight you on this. If I thought this to be because of weariness, I would send for my mother and Balin and let them take turns speaking sense into you until even the stone begged for mercy. But I saw you last night."

 

He swallowed, but then continued even more firmly than before.

 

"No one else would have noticed. You smiled. You spoke. You honoured the work properly, but you looked at the hall as though the celebration were happening somewhere very far away. At the time I believed you were withholding feeling. Now, I understand that you were waiting for it."

 

Thorin did not reply, letting the silence settle between them answer.

 

"Did it come?" Fíli asked, looking up at his uncle with a mixture of hope and concern.

 

"No."

 

The younger dwarf nodded once, small and pained. He remained silent for a long while afterward, and Thorin did not press him. Acceptance, if it came, deserved space enough to arrive in its own shape. Below, a raven settled upon one of the lower walls and shook its feathers against the wind. From within Erebor, far behind them, came the faint sound of hammers working once more.

 

"One year." Thorin said at last. "I will not force this upon you and depart in the same breath. I wish to prepare what must be prepared, to teach you what I know - and if you do not wish to sit upon the throne by the next Durin's day then I shall remain on the throne until my last breath. But do not reject the crown because you think me more deserving of it. My desire to step down comes from pride and accomplishment, not doubt or restlessness."

 

"Alright. One year."

 

"Balin will teach you what I do not know. Dís will remind us both when we are being fools."

 

At that, Fíli's expression changed, grief and humour touching the same place.

 

"She will be furious."

 

"Yes."

 

"Mainly with you."

 

"Likely, but she will understand in time."

 

Fíli groaned and rubbed one hand across his face.

 

"A year is not long." 

 

"It is enough."

 

"And if at the end of it I still say no?"

 

"In a year, you will not." Thorin looked at the younger dwarf with a renewed strength to his posture and a steadiness in his eyes.

 

"That is arrogance, uncle."

 

"It is faith."

 

"That is often what arrogant people call it."

 

This time Thorin laughed, and Fíli did too, though softly and without much ease. The laughter did not mend what had opened between them, but it made the shape of it less terrible.

 

For a long while they stood without speaking. The road below lay empty now, pale in the morning, marked only by wheel-ruts and the fading trace of Dáin's departure. It ran eastward out of sight, but not only eastward. From the Mountain all roads eventually bent elsewhere: to Dale just below the mountain, to the Iron Hills, to Mirkwood, to old lands and to unknown lands. Thorin found himself looking at it with a feeling to slight yet to be named hope, but no longer only duty or memory.

 

At last Fíli drew a slow breath.

 

"One year." he said. "You stay. You teach me properly. Not only the matters written in ledgers or spoken in council, but the things no one writes down because everyone assumes kings are born knowing them. The mistakes. The bargains. The names that matter more than their titles. The old grudges that pretend to be policy. The doors you avoid opening until there is no choice."

 

"There are many of those."

 

"Then we shall need the year."

 

Thorin inclined his head.

 

"And at the end?"

 

Fíli kept his gaze upon the road a moment longer before answering. 

 

"At the end, if you still believe Erebor is better served with me upon the throne, and if I can stand before the Mountain without feeling I have taken something from you..." he stopped, then corrected himself with visible effort. "No. Not if. When."

 

The word settled between them like stone placed true.

 

"When." Fíli said again, more firmly. "Then I will take the crown."

 

The Mountain continued around them. Somewhere below, workers returned to scaffolds. Somewhere above, smoke lifted from chimneys into the pale morning. In the halls behind them, guests finished their farewells, children complained of cold breakfasts, and half of Erebor carried on unaware that the future of the throne had shifted quietly upon a balcony just above the road.

 

Thorin looked one last time toward the empty eastern path, then toward the younger dwarf beside him. The agreement stood between them newly forged and still hot enough to burn, but it stood. Neither of them spoke of farewell. Neither of them spoke of what must be grieved before the year ended.

 

For that morning, it was enough that the thing had been named.

⛰︎

Chapter 7: ⛰︎ Whoever Remains After

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

⛰︎

A year had passed, and the sixth anniversary of Erebor's reclamation came beneath a clear morning sky.

 

Above the Lonely Mountain the early light struck stone and snow with a brightness almost severe, and by the time the sun climbed fully above the eastern ridges the roads below had already filled with banners. They came from the Iron Hills, from Dale, from smaller halls and kin scattered across the North, from merchants' houses and guilds and families who had known the long years of exile and now came dressed not for mourning or remembrance, but for a coronation. The Mountain received them all with open gates.

 

Erebor had changed in the year since Thorin first spoke to Fíli upon the balcony above the eastern road. Not suddenly. Not in any way that might have seemed alarming to those living in her halls day by day. Yet change had moved through the kingdom like water through old channels newly cleared of stone - like fact of it was new but the movement felt ancient. 

 

At first Fíli stood beside Thorin in council as he had done for the past few years, listening, answering when asked, offering suggestions when the matter touched roads, guilds, trade or workers' grievances. Then, gradually, the questions had begun turning toward the younger dwarf before Thorin had even needed to redirect them there. Guildmasters sought his opinion on expansions. Dáin sent letters addressed to them both and replies meant plainly for Fíli's eyes. Messengers from Dale began waiting for Fíli if Thorin was delayed. Workers in the lower halls had long since ceased straightening in surprise when the prince appeared among them with questions of his own.

 

The transition had been felt long before it had been announced. By late winter, even those who disliked change had begun speaking of Fíli's future reign not merely as possibility but as approaching fact. By mid-spring, the councils had adjusted around him. By summer, the Mountain had begun answering to him in small ways no decree could have commanded. Thorin had watched it happen with careful attention and greater pain than he had expected, though not the pain of envy. It was stranger than that. Something nearer to the aching stretch of an old wound healing wrong and then, at last, being set properly.

 

Now the day had finally come.

 

The great hall chosen for the crowning stood deeper within Erebor than the chamber of the monument. It was older and more solemn, built in an age when the kingdom's pride had needed neither apology nor restraint. Its vaulted ceiling vanished into shadow high above, where lanterns hung like captured stars among carved ribs of stone. Pillars lined the hall in long ranks, each banded with metal and inscribed with names from the line of Durin. Along the walls hung banners of the gathered clans. Beneath them stood dwarves from every part of the restored kingdom, their voices lowered by the weight of the hour despite the excitement moving among them.

 

At the far end of the hall stood the throne beneath the Mountain. For five years Thorin had sat upon it as king. For one year he had sat upon it while teaching another how to rise toward it. Today he stood below it, not beside the throne but before the gathered people, dressed in dark ceremonial garments without the crown resting upon his brow.

 

The absence had drawn many eyes when he first entered.

 

Not shock. The announcement had been made a few months ago - after winter councils, after letters to allied halls, after long conversations with Dís, Dáin, Balin, Dwalin, and those whose support could not be taken for granted. Yet knowledge does not always lessen the force of seeing. Thorin could feel the moment pass through the hall when they looked upon him bareheaded. The King under the Mountain stood before them still, but already the image had begun changing into memory.

 

Fíli stood several paces away from him, speaking quietly with Glóin and one of the guild representatives before the ceremony began. That, more than the crown waiting upon its cushion, revealed the truth of the day.

 

He did not look untouched by nerves. No dwarf of sense could have stood at the edge of such an hour and felt none. Yet Fíli did not look misplaced. His shoulders held tension, yes, but not uncertainty. When a messenger approached with some last question concerning the order of oaths, Fíli answered without casting a glance toward Thorin. When Dáin leaned close to mutter something that made the younger dwarf's brows rise sharply, Fíli replied with quiet amusement and just enough firmness that the old lord of the Iron Hills barked a laugh and slapped him hard upon the shoulder.

 

Erebor already begun making room for him.

 

'Or perhaps', Thorin thought, 'she had made room long ago, and only now can I see the shape of it - the Mountain already knows its king'.

 

It was a comforting thought, but not one that Thorin was allowed much time to elaborate on as a horn sounded from the upper gallery and the hall stilled.

 

Balin stepped forward first. Age had bent him somewhat in the past year, though not in spirit, and his white beard had been braided and neatly tucked into a ceremonial belt for the occasion. In his hand he held the record of oaths, not because he needed to read from it, but because such things simply ought to be held. His voice, when it rose, carried clearly through the hall.

 

"People of Erebor, kin of Durin, friends and allies gathered beneath the Mountain," he began, "we stand this day upon a threshold few among our people have lived to see - not the crowning of a king after death, nor after ruin, nor war, but the passing of a crown from one living hand to another in a kingdom thriving."

 

A murmur moved faintly through the hall, solemn and low.

 

Balin continued.

 

"Thorin Oakenshield, sone of Thráin, son of Thrór, reclaimed the throne beneath the Mountain from the dragon Smaug and restored to Durin's Folk the halls long denied them. By his labour, by his endurance, and by the hands of all who stood beside him, Erebor lives. Yet no kingdom endures by memory alone. Stone must be maintained. Roads must be opened. Fire must be tended. Those who restore a hall must not always be the ones to fill it with the years to come."

 

Thorin heard the words without flinching. Once, perhaps, they would have cut. On this day, however, they settled with a strange gentleness. 

 

Balin turned toward him.

 

"My lord Thorin, King under the Mountain, do you come before your people by your own will?"

 

Thorin stepped forward.


"I do."

 

"Do you lay down crown and throne freely, without coercion, deceit, or failing of honour?"

 

"I do."

 

"Do you name before Durin's Folk the one who shall succeed you?"

 

Thorin then turned toward Fíli, and the hall seemed to draw breath.

 

For a moment he saw the boy from the quest - bright-haired, eager, impatient, too young to understand how close death walked beside all great purposes. Then he saw the prince beneath the monument scaffolds, charcoal upon his brow, giving orders with more ease than he knew. Then the dwarf in the council chamber turning argument into agreement. Then finally the one who had stood upon the balvony and spoken of roads, workshops, trade, valleys, and years yet unbuilt.

 

"I name Fíli, son of Dís, of the line of Durin." Thorin spoke. "Let him be named my heir. Let him be crowned King under the Mountain."

 

Fíli stepped forward.

 

He did not look at Thorin immediately. His gaze moved first over the hall, over the gathered clans, the workers, the nobles, the kin, the people who had become his before the crown ever touched him. Then at last he looked toward Thorin, and in that look remained everything the ceremony could not hold or make room for: grief, gratitude, fear and love.

 

Balin turned to him.

 

"Fíli, son of Dís, will you take up the crown of Erebor?"

 

Fíli's voice came steadier than Thorin had expected yet less steady than the hall perhaps heard.

 

"I will."

 

"Will you hold the Mountain not as treasure possessed, but as trust given into your keeping?"

 

"I will."

 

"Will you guard Durin's Folk in prosperity as in hardship, in peace as in war, remembering exile without making an idol of it, and seeking the good of those yet unborn beneath these halls?"

 

At that Fíli's jaw tightened faintly for only a second before he answered with steady security.

 

"I will."

 

Dís stood among the front ranks with both hands clasped before her. She had wept earlier, privately and angrily, and then warned both Thorin and her son that if either of them looked at her during the ceremony she would never forgive them. Naturally, they had both looked and now she was holding onto herself with the pride of one who had already lost enough to know that joy too could hurt.

 

The clan oaths followed.

 

Dáin came first, as lord of the Iron Hills and kin by blood. He approached heavily, all ceremony seeming to fit him poorly and yet magnificently at the same time. Like armour never polished because it had seen better use. He clasped Fíli's forearm instead of kneeling at once, holding him there long enough to speak too quietly for the whole hall to hear but not quietly enough for Thorin to miss.

 

"Do not grow too wise too quickly," Dáin muttered with a twinkle in his eye. "It makes young kings unbearable."

 

Fíli's mouth twithched.

 

"I shall attempt to remain foolish enough for your comfort."

 

"Good."

 

Then Dáin knelt before him.

 

The sight struck the hall more deeply than Thorin expected. Dáin Ironfoot, who bent easily to no one and complained of most things before agreeing to them, lowered himself before Fíli and swore the loyalty of the Iron Hills. His voice rang rough and strong across the hall, and when he rose again the approval that moved through the gathered dwarves was not polite but it was full-throated and sure.

 

After him came the other clans.

 

Some oaths were in Khuzdul, in ancient form, full of names older than Erebor. Some were briefer, offered by dwarves more comfortable with axe and ledger than ceremonial speech. Guildmasters came too, and though they did not swear as clans swore, they offered pledges of craft, labour and service. One old miner stumbled over half the formal wording, cursed softly under his breath, and finally said something that Thorin was too distracted to catch, but it caused the hall to break into laughter. The ring of laughter was warm and irreverent, and Fíli laughed with them.

 

Thorin watched.

 

He had wondered, in the year between decision and crowning, whether the final moment would reopen doubt. Not his own doubt, perhaps, but the doubt of others. Whether the clans would accept because duty demanded it rather than because their hearts did. Whether the hall would turn toward Fíli with respect but not yet love. Whether some part of Erebor would remain looking back over its shoulder toward the king who had reclaimed it.

 

But the Mountain did not hesitate. Thorin saw it in the faces before him. In the ease with which workers called Fíli's name when laughter swelled. In the solemnity of the clan oaths. In the way even those who had resisted the abdication months earlier now seemed not resigned but ready. Fíli had not replaced him. That was not the shape of it. Rather, the kingdom had widened toward its next age, and Fíli stood already within that widening, visible at last to all.

 

Balin approached the cushion upon which the crown rested.

 

He slowly lifted the crown, and the hall stilled so completely that even the distant forges seemed to pause.

 

Fíli knelt.

 

For one heartbeat, Thorin felt the old world and the new meet within the space between crown and brow. All the years of exile. The dragon's shadow. The road to Erebor. The battle. The rebuilding. The monument. The balcony. A year of teaching and arguments and ledgers and laughter caught unexpectedly in council rooms.

 

Then Balin set the crown upon Fíli's head.

 

"Behold Fíli, son of Dís, of the line of Durin," Balin said, and though his voice trembled faintly at the edges, it did not break. "King under the Mountain."

 

The hall erupted.

 

Not ceremonially. Not dutifully. Not with the careful respect owed to a title. The sound that rose from Erebor came from somewhere deeper. Voices struck the vaulted ceiling and returned doubled, tripled, until the whole chamber seemed to ring like an anvil beneath a thousand hammers. Dwarves shouted Fíli's name. Clan banners lifted. Dáin bellowed loud enough to overpower half the hall by himself. Dís covered her mouth for one brief moment and then seemed to give up all effort at restraint.

 

Fíli rose beneath the crown, and the noise did not falter. If anything, it grew.

 

And Thorin, standing aside at last, felt the force of it pass through him. Not around him this time. Through him.

 

For the first time in a long while, feeling came not as something he strained toward, but as something that found him where he stood. Grief first, sharp and deep, for no ending truly blessed came without sorrow. Pride followed, fierce enough to warm him where the grief had cut. Then relief, vast and quiet beneath them both, like a door opened after long years in a room too small to breathe within.

 

The Mountain had accepted another king. Not politely, and not because Thorin asked it, but wholeheartedly.

 

The knowledge did not diminish him. That was the wonder of it. He had feared, in some buried place too proud to confess itself, that seeing Erebor turn so fully toward another might leave him hollowed beyond repair. Instead he felt the strange, aching peace of a burden set down in the place prepared for it.

 

Fíli turned then.

 

Across the roar of the hall, their eyes met.

 

No words could have crossed such a distance in the loud and crowded hall, nor were any needed. Thorin inclined his head once, not as king to king, nor even as uncle to nephew alone, but as one craftsman acknowledging a work completed and handed on. Fíli's face changed in answer, the weight of the crown visible within him now, but so too the strength beneath it. Then the crowd surged closer, and the moment disappeared beneath celebration.

 

The coronation feast began almost before anyone formally declared the ceremony ended.

 

Music rose from the lower end of the hall. Tables were uncovered, casks opened, children released from ceremonial stillness with alarming speed. Dáin seized Fíli by both shoulders and began offering advice that sounded suspiciously like warnings against every mistake Dáin himself had ever made. Dís embraced her son, struck him lightly on the arm for standing too stiffly, and then embraced him again before he could protest. As soon as he let go, Kíli nearly tackled him into the ground in a rough and heartfelt embrace.

 

Thorin remained for a while.

 

He accepted hands clasped in gratitude. He endured praise he no longer needed and farewells not yet understood as farewells. some called him King still, then corrected themselves awkwardly. Others called him Thorin Oakenshield with such reverence that the name felt older than the crown he had laid down. He answered them all with what grace he could, and for once the words did not feel like armour. They were only words, warm and imperfect, exchanged between himself and the people he had loved enough to leave in better hands.

 

At length, as the celebration swelled beyond ceremony into true festivity, Thorin stepped back toward one of the side passages.

 

No one stopped him.

 

That, too, felt right.

 

The hall no longer required his presence to hold its shape. Its heart had shifted - not suddenly, nor by decree, but as rivers slowly alter their course until one morning the old channel stands quiet. Fíli stood surrounded by clan-lords, guildmasters, craftsmen and children bold enough to already tug at the sleeve of their new king. The Mountain had gathered naturally around him.

 

Thorin watched for one final moment, then he finally turned to leave.

 

Only Balin noticed.

 

The old dwarf stood a little apart from the greatest press of the celebration, a silver cup resting lightly in one hand. His eyes had followed Thorin almost from the moment he stepped back from the gathering, though he made no effort to detain him. When Thorin drew level with him, Balin merely regarded him with that familiar expression which had so often held patience enough for them both. 

 

For a heartbeat neither spoke.

 

Then Balin gave a small smile, scarcely more than a softening about the eyes, but filled with warmth and love.


"Go, laddie."

 

The words were quiet enough to vanish beneath the laughter and song filling the hall.

 

Thorin came to a halt.

 

It had been many years since Balin had last called him that. Long before crowns and councils. Before dragons, before exile had carved harder lines into every face they knew. The name belonged to another life, when mistakes were answered with correction instead of dire consequences, and the future still seemed wide enough that no one thought to measure it.

 

Something warm stirred unexpectedly beneath his ribs. Not grief, not quite. Home, perhaps.

 

He looked at Balin, and the old Dwarf only inclined his head, as though there were nothing more that needed saying. Thorin returned the gesture.

 

"Thank you." Thorin said quietly, and though he was not completely sure what exactly it was he was thanking Balin for, the overwhelming feeling of gratitude surging through his veins made the words come out as easy as a soft exhale.

 

Then, he turned away, and for the first time since Erebor had been reclaimed, Thorin Oakenshield left the centre of the Mountain without feeling that he had abandoned it.

⛰︎

Notes:

hope you enjoyed the erebor portion of the story <3

i can reveal so far that the story kind of consists of three different parts (this first part in erebor is the shortest part), and i'm reeeeeally excited for what i'm about to do with the second part of the story :)

hope you will enjoy it going forward!!

Chapter 8: ✉ An Unexpected Letter

Chapter Text

✉

Dear Bilbo,

 

On this sixth anniversary of our adventure it may be of interest for you to know that Fíli is now King under the Mountain. In the years since your return to The Shire, Erebor has become a sight to behold - grander even than that of my memories before the dragon. I now gaze upon the kingdom carved into the mountain with great pride as it continues thriving without my hand upon it. Fíli seems determined to see her greater still, and I have every reason to believe he shall.

 

None of it could have come to pass without you. Know that should you one day wish to see her again, the Mountain would welcome you as the most honoured of guests.

 

As for myself, I have chosen a path outbound from the Lonely Mountain, at least for now. Thus far I have wandered no farther than Dale, and for reasons unbeknownst to me I have been welcomed with open arms.

 

Dale, too, is a city of prosperity, growing perhaps even more rapidly than Erebor. Great tall buildings frame impressive craftsmanship and thriving trade. It seems yet another city permitted greatness all owing to a quaint burglar.

 

At the centre of the city stands an oak sapling. They told me you planted it.

 

Yours,

Thorin

✉

Chapter 9: ✉ A Welcome Reply

Chapter Text

✉

Dear Thorin,

 

Your letter brought me great joy, though I do admit its contents took me rather by surprise. I do not entirely understand this decision but i trust that you would not have made it lightly.

 

I am glad to hear that Erebor is thriving, I should very much like to see the mountain again one day. For now, however, a cup of tea in my armchair is adventure enough for me.

 

Not much has changed in The Shire since my return, though my cousin Lobelia insists upon visiting me weekly. Last week, shortly after one such visit, I noticed several pieces of silverware had mysteriously gone astray. I shall make sure all valuables are kept locked away and out of sight for her next visit.

 

Gandalf passed through about a year ago, and we actually reminisced about the quest for Erebor over some pipe-weed. Now that I think on it, it may have been right around Durin's Day that he knocked on my door. Strange, how things sometimes coincide.

 

I confess myself curious what other wonders you may stumble across on this new path you are treading.

 

If you happen upon Bard while in Dale, do send him my best wishes!

 

Your friend,

Bilbo

✉

Chapter 10: ✉ A Change of Roads

Chapter Text

✉

Dear Bilbo,

 

I hope you will forgive the delay of this reply to yours. I do at least possess a worthwhile excuse for it: I now write to you from Minas Tirith - the White City.

 

As the Lonely Mountain continued drawing ever closer to Dale, I realized it was time for me to move on. With Mirkwood lying to the west, the Grey Mountains to the north and the Iron Hills to the east, the natural course of progress seemed southward.

 

It brought me great amusement to receive your letter upon the very morning of my departure from Dale. I had begun suspecting either that my own letter had failed to reach The Shire, or that your response would arrive only after I had already continued onward. As I read your words upon the road, I found myself regretting greatly that I had not already arranged for replacement silverware to be sent to Bag End. Rest assured I shall correct this oversight as soon as possible, lest your cousin strip your home entirely bare before my next reply reaches you.

 

Perhaps the strangest thing about crossing the lands east of Mirkwood is how difficult it becomes to imagine that the Kingdom of Rhovanion ever stood there at all. One expects ruins at least. Broken fortresses reclaimed by vines. Crumbling monuments weathered by wind and time. Instead there is simply nothing. Had the forest edge not remained visible to the west, I might have lost all sense of direction entirely.

 

When at last I reached the Brown Lands, they proved no more hospitable than the emptiness preceding them. In my younger years I learned about how Sauron once laid waste to those lands before his defeat. It seems to me an unfair thing that evil should leave scars enduring through the ages, while all trace of a once great kingdom may vanish so completely into the earth that one begins to doubt it ever existed at all.

 

At last I reached the Anduin, where I was met by the Argonath - the Pillars of Kings. I had heard many tales regarding their vastness, yet none prepared me for the sight itself. They stand not merely as monuments, but as declaration. One feels less as though passing between stone figures and more as though entering into the memory of another age entire. I remained there longer than intended.

 

And having followed the river southward, I now find myself in Minas Tirith.

 

It is a city of Men that seems strangely dwarven at first glance. The way it rises back against the mountain. The way sunlight catches so fiercely upon the white stone that one sees it more clearly by narrowing the eyes. The seven great levels of the city standing above the next with near obsessive precision.

 

Yet, for all its grandeur, it does not feel ancient in the way of Erebor. It feels inhabited. Layer upon layer of people living atop one another like sediment built slowly over time.

 

If the looks I receive are anything to go by, it seems few outside the race of Men ever pass through this city. At first I found the attention tiresome, though after securing work within a forge upon the third level of the city, the whispers have shifted somewhat. "Thorin the Dwarf", they say now, as though the matter sufficiently explains itself. Though accurate in all the ways that matter, I find the name sits strangely upon me.

 

My work at the forge has been received warmly these past days. In the Mountain I worked the forge often enough, yet not since exile have I truly been a blacksmith. I do not think my stay here shall become permanent, though if fortune remains agreeable I may linger yet a few weeks longer before continuing onward.

 

I hope The Shire remains peaceful, and that no further acts of silverware-related villainy have occurred in my absence.

 

Yours,

Thorin

✉

Chapter 11: ✉ Many Things

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

✉

Dear Thorin,

 

I confess I spent rather a long while staring at your description of the White City before realizing my tea had gone entirely cold beside me. Seven levels! I cannot imagine climbing such a place willingly, let alone building it. Hobbits are sensible enough to avoid constructing anything that requires excessive staircases.

 

I was pleased to hear Minas Tirith has treated you kindly. Your description of the city reminded me somewhat of how you once spoke of Erebor during our journey. I attempted sketching what I imagined it must look like - seven white layers resting on the mountainside - though I fear the result resembled a wedding cake more than a city of Men.

 

No further silverware has vanished from Bag End since my previous letter, though I remain vigilant.

 

Your account of the lands east of Mirkwood sounded rather dreary indeed. Though perhaps it is simply the way of things that kingdoms disappear eventually. There are parts of The Shire where old hobbit families once lived that now contain nothing more remarkable than sheep and very opinionated geese. Though perhaps that is not entirely comparable to a fallen kingdom.

 

I was glad to hear you have found work at a forge once more. It must be pleasant, in its own way, shaping something with your hands again after so many years spent shaping rather larger matters. If you ask me, "Thorin the Dwarf" is a name very becoming for you. The thought of people whispering it around the city as though there might exist another Thorin wandering Minas Tirith strikes me as highly amusing.

 

Still, I believe I understand what you mean. Or perhaps not understand exactly, but enough to recognize the feeling of a thing sitting strangely upon oneself. Returning to Bag End after the quest often felt rather like wearing an old coat that still felt perfectly and yet somehow no longer sat quite the same upon the shoulders.

 

I am very glad to hear you intend to remain in Minas Tirith a while longer. You sound - though I hesitate to use the word for fear it may startle you back into the wilderness immediately - content there.

 

Your friend,

Bilbo

✉

Notes:

im posting these letter correspondence chapters a lot quicker than the prior chapters because the letters were actually the first thing i wrote for this story so i already have most of them pre-written.

once we reach the next part of the story and i start writing normal novel-style chapters again i will go back to publishing one chapter per week ish

Chapter 12: ✉ Another Letter

Chapter Text

✉

Dear Bilbo,

 

It seems a few weeks scaling staircases designed for Men nearly twice my height have succeeded where a lifetime of scaling dwarven staircases failed: I now find myself wondering if perhaps there is some wisdom to Hobbit sensibilities after all.

 

You were correct in your last letter that the city bears certain similarities to Erebor, though I have come to realize the resemblance lies more in stone than spirit. At first glance Minas Tirith appears built much like a dwarven city: proud walls, ordered levels, halls carved against the mountainside as though permanence itself had been the chief ambition of its builders.

 

Yet Men inhabit their cities very differently from Dwarves.

 

A dwarf who wants to build outward will still build outward from the mountain itself, as though the stone remains the true heart of the kingdom and all living things merely dwell within its protection. Men instead seem to build around one another. The city shifts constantly with them despite the unmoving stone beneath it. Markets appear where none stood the previous day. Children race through passageways intended for soldiers. Laundry hangs between ancient walls built for war and kingship. 

 

In this regard, they remind me strangely of Hobbits.

 

Do not misunderstand me - no hobbit would willingly construct a city upon seven towering levels, nor would Men possess the good sense to place meals at sensible intervals throughout the day. Yet there exists within both a certain refusal to allow greatness to become more important than living itself.

 

I think Dwarves sometimes forget this. Perhaps I, too, was in need of a reminder.

 

My work at the forge has continued steadily, though I find myself increasingly distracted by the roads leading southward. It seems I have grown accustomed once more to movement, and remaining too long in one place now produces the strange sensation that the walls themselves begin quietly drawing inward.

 

And so within the week I intend to depart for Pelargir. I have never before journeyed so near the sea, and after hearing half a hundred conflicting descriptions of it from Men within the city, I suspect the only solution is to see the thing myself and determine whether any of them speak truthfully.

 

There is a restlessness here of late that I do not believe entirely belongs to me alone. Though life within Minas Tirith continues much as before, I have noticed the guards upon the eastern walls seem wearier than when I first arrived. Travelers arriving from Ithilien speak more often now of uneasy silences, abandoned roads, and strange movements glimpsed at a great distance near the mountains bordering Mordor.

 

None appear greatly alarmed by such tales. Indeed, most speak of them as one speaks of poor weather returning after too many clear days. Still, I find myself glad I chose the southern road rather than the eastern one.

 

I look forward to seeing Pelargir, and suspect the journey south shall prove considerably more pleasant now that winter has finally begun loosening its grip. I suspect the mouths of Anduin may lead me to my first glimpse of the sea. Trust that I shall do my best to describe her to you if I make it to the Bay of Belfalas.

 

Though perhaps you have already stood upon her shores yourself.

 

Strange, after all this time, that I never thought to ask.

 

Yours,

Thorin

✉

Chapter 13: ✉ Southward

Chapter Text

✉

Dear Thorin,

 

First and foremost, I do hope this letter finds you safely arrived in Pelargir, and not hopelessly lost somewhere along the Mouths of Anduin attempting to determine which direction the sea ought to be.

 

As for your question - no, I have never stood upon its shores myself. Strange perhaps, after all the walking I once did. Yet I confess the thought of seeing the Sea one day has always lingered pleasantly somewhere in the back of my mind. One day perhaps I shall arm myself with my hiking stick once more and make the trek to see it with my own eyes.

 

Spring has settled gently over The Shire at last, and with it comes the annual Hobbit tradition of behaving as though no spring has ever arrived before this particular one. Every respectable Hobbit is presently occupied with pretending not to compare gardens while very obviously doing exactly that.

 

Preparations have already begun for the first proper spring celebrations upon the Green, and I have overheard no fewer than two deeply serious disagreements concerning flowerbeds whilst passing through the market.

 

As for myself, I remain slightly outside such matters still.

 

Most folk are perfectly polite nowadays, though there persists a certain tendency among most grown Hobbits to lower their voices dramatically whenever referring to me, as though I might at any moment disappear again with a company of Dwarves and return riding a dragon. Which is, of course, absurd. I trust that you would be the first to confirm that I did in fact conduct myself in a manner expected of a respectable Hobbit throughout out journey.

 

Still, I cannot claim I miss being drawn into every competitive springtime affair in The Shire. Being invited to the larger celebrations suits me perfectly well, particularly now that it leaves me free to tend my own garden in peace.

 

I have planted rosemary, thyme, foxgloves, marigolds, and a small patch of strawberries which I intend to defend vigorously against both birds and relatives alike once the season advances. The roses near the front path survived winter surprisingly well this year, though one particularly determined climbing vine continues advancing along the fence with ambitions far beyond its allotted territory.

 

You must tell me everything about Pelargir once you arrive there properly. Is it truly filled with ships beyond counting? And what are Men like beyond Minas Tirith? I realize now that prior to our journey I scarcely imagined Men at all unless one happened to be standing directly before me.

 

I hope the southern road treats you kindly, and that the sea proves worth the journey once you finally reach her.

 

Your friend,

Bilbo

✉

Chapter 14: ✉ A Matter of Weather

Chapter Text

✉

Dear Bilbo,

 

If my word should hold any weight, I shall be happy to verify to anyone who would question it that you are in fact a most respectable Hobbit and acted accordingly throughout our quest. In truth, your sensibility and caution saved us more than once upon the road.

 

I have now found myself in Pelargir, and thankfully the journey proved considerably shorter and more hospitable than my previous.

 

Here the world of Men has unfolded itself in ways I did not expect while in Minas Tirith. Despite being a place of constant movement, Pelargir feels to me more deeply shaped by time than the White City. I spoke with a man who claimed this city is older than Gondor itself, and I would not be surprised if he spoke truthfully.

 

Few Dwarves, I suspect, have walked these streets before me. I still receive my share of curious looks, yet my presence here seems less a matter of fascination than it did in Minas Tirith. I was even offered work assisting with the metalwork of ships. Some strange part of me enjoys shaping metals that shall see more parts of the world than I ever will.

 

Though the place appears more foreign, I find it easier to navigate as a foreigner than I ever did Minas Tirith.

 

What I did not anticipate, however, was the smell. The salted breeze drifting inward from the Great Sea is one thing, but the scent of tar, fish and seaweed left drying along the riverbanks is harder to grow accustomed to.

 

Though the strange feeling that settled upon my chest whenever I faced east in Minas Tirith has loosened somewhat, it seems another sort of unease lingers here as well. Nothing that interrupts everyday life, yet one hears small rumours passing quietly between Men - missing ships, increasingly clouded skies, heightened precautions along the riverways and coast.

 

Perhaps the Men of Gondor know something I do not, though I do not see myself remaining here long enough to discover it.

 

Though my experience in Pelargir has thus far been good enough, your letter has only strengthened to see the Sea properly, and from here it remains more presence than sight. Perhaps Linhir shall become the next destination upon my travels, though I have not decided fully and remain in no great hurry to depart just yet.

 

I do hope that as spring progresses you are able to ward off any incessant birds and relatives from your strawberries. Perhaps, should springtime madness within The Shire continue escalating, Sting may yet prove useful once more. Though I trust matters have not deteriorated quite so far.

 

Yours,

Thorin

✉

Chapter 15: ✉ What Was Not Written

Chapter Text

✉

Dear Thorin,

 

Your latest letter reach Bag End on a morning so remarkably ordinary that I felt almost guilty opening it. Outside my window, Hamfast Gamgee was attempting to persuade one particularly stubborn goose that it belonged upon his own land and not mine. The goose, I regret to report, proved the better debater. It seems that while you have been travelling through great lands, ancient monument, and the Sea itself, I have been defending my vegetable patch against poultry. 

 

I was pleased to read you have once again found yourself working metal. I do not know whether you intended to say very much by mentioning it, but your observations fascinate me. You have written beautifully of cities, mountains, rivers, old ruins, and the world of Men along the way, but there is a different sort of ease that finds its way into your writing whenever you mention hammer, fire and iron.

 

Perhaps I only imagine it.

 

There is one thing, however, that has occurred to me while reading these past letters. I know a fair amount now about the lands east of Mirkwood, the White City, Pelargir, and several other places you have written about. What I know rather less of is how you fare within them all.

 

Do not mistake me. I do not ask because I think you unhappy, nor because I believe your decision to leave Erebor requires defending. If you ever wish to explain it, I am more than willing to listen, but until then I trust your judgment.

 

It is only that, after all these months, I have caught myself wondering not merely what you have seen, but what these journeys have become to you. Do you ever find yourself missing the Mountain, or has the road itself begun to feel something like home?

 

Forgive me if I am overstepping, and you need not to answer any of my questions if you would rather not.

 

Wherever your next letter finds itself written, I hope you shall continue telling me about the places you discover there. I have travelled very little since returning home, and I suspect I have begun seeing rather more of the world through your eyes than I ever expected possible.

 

Take care of yourself, Thorin.

 

Your friend,

Bilbo

✉

Chapter 16: ✉ The Next Road

Chapter Text

✉

Dear Bilbo,

 

I have delayed this reply rather longer than I intended. When I departed from Pelargir, I found my steps carrying me farther south than I had first resolved, until at last there remained nothing before me but the Great Sea.

 

You asked what these journeys have become to me. I had always thought to answer that question as soon as I had looked upon the Sea with my own eyes. Instead I lingered upon the coast for several days. Only now, returned to an inn in Linhir beneath a proper roof once more, do I find myself taking up my pen.

 

The Great Sea was more than I had imagined, and less easily understood still. I watched ships pass beyond the horizon until they vanished from sight, though I knew they had not ceased to be. In some curious fashion, I found my thoughts returning to the lands I crossed east of Mirkwood on my way from Dale. There, I walked for weeks beneath open skies over lands that had once held the works of countless hands, though little now remained to bear witness to them. The Sea conceals by distance what time conceals upon the land. It seems the world has many ways of reminding us that what is beyond our sight is not therefore lost.

 

I do not think I was made for the Sea, and I have no longing to entrust myself to her waters. Yet to stand upon the shore and watch her waves break endlessly upon the land is to feel oneself diminished in a manner that is at once comforting and fearful. The Mountain makes one feel steadfast while the Sea reminds one that nothing stands forever.

 

You asked whether I miss Erebor.

 

I do.

 

Though not always, nor in the manner I should have expected.

 

There are mornings when I wake expecting the familiar sounds of the halls beneath the Mountain, before memory returns and reminds me where I lie. There are other mornings when I rise, shoulder my pack, and think only of the road before me. Which of these speaks more truly, I cannot yet say.

 

There is a curious freedom in travelling through lands that ask nothing of you, yet neither hold any place prepared for your coming. You wrote that I have written to you of cities, rivers, and old stones, but perhaps less of myself amongst them. It is true, but trust that it is not because I would keep such thoughts from you, but because I have not always known what they are.

 

Do not mistake me. I have never regretted leaving Erebor, and it eases my heart that you have not asked me to defend that choice. Yet there are evenings when it seems to me that I am not so much seeking a destination as learning what it is I should have been seeking all along. Whether such a thing can be found upon any road, I do not know.

 

The road has not become my home, but neither does it feel now as though I merely endure it.

 

That, more than anything else, has surprised me.

 

Linhir is a respectable town, and I can find little fault with it. Yet I am certain I shall not remain here much longer. There are places which one leaves because they are wanting, and there are others which simply are not meant to hold one. I believe this to be the latter.

 

My thoughts have turned north once more. Before long I intend to cross into Rohan, for I have heard much of Edoras throughout my life, yet somehow never stood within its halls. It seems as fitting a road as any. Should you still wish to indulge an old traveller's letters, I believe yours would find me there in due time.

 

Take care of your garden, and should the goose persist in claiming it, I recommend reminding it that you have, on at least one occasion, faced a dragon. Surely that ought to command some measure of respect.

 

Yours,

Thorin

✉

Chapter 17: ✉ Wandering Habits

Notes:

sry my computer stopped working and theres no way im writing on my slow ass phone, but i got a new computer woho

Chapter Text

✉

Dear Thorin,

 

I hope this letter finds you safely, wherever the road has carried you by now. Whether it reaches Edoras or some village beyond it, I trust it shall find you in the end as all of my letters have thus far. Your own letters have never failed to find Bag End, and for that I am more grateful than I have remembered to say.

 

You must forgive me if this reply contains rather little of interest. Life here remains wonderfully predictable. The seasons keep their accustomed order, my garden continues to prosper, and the kettle still has an unfortunate habit of boiling itself dry whenever your letters prove more interesting than my tea.

 

My neighbors remain as faithfully occupied with one another's affairs as ever, and I continue to provide them with no shortage of harmless speculation. Depending on who one asks, I spend too much time with books, too much time walking alone, disappear for hours without saying where I have gone, and have somehow reached my age without ever seeing fit to marry or fill Bag End with little Bagginses. They have long since accepted that I am unlikely to ever become a proper Hobbit, and I have long since accepted that they are probably right.

 

There is, in truth, very little else to report.

 

Still, I hope you do not mind.

 

For although my own life changes very little from one week to the next, your letters have become among the things I most look forward to. On the mornings when one arrives, I invariably leave my breakfast growing cold whilst I read it through, and then, more often than not, I find myself reading it once again. It is a curious comfort to hear of places I shall likely never see, simply because you have seen them.

 

I have begun to suspect that it is not the places themselves that hold my attention, but the memories your letters awaken.

 

It is not Smaug that I remember most often, nor the treasure, nor even the Battle. Instead I find myself thinking of evenings beside a dwindling fire, of Bombur insisting his feet had reached the limits of endurance the day's march had properly begun, of Bofur singing to himself when he believed everyone else asleep, and of all the little conversations that seemed so ordinary at the time that I never imagined they would one day become so precious to me.

 

It is a strange thing, memory. We expect the great moments to endure, yet it is often the quiet ones that remain most faithfully.

 

When I first returned to the Shire, and had gathered my furniture and other stolen goods back as they all believed I would not return, everything appeared exactly as I had left it. Bag End was unchanged. The Hill was unchanged. The lanes, the hedgerows, the voices at the market - everything stood waiting as though no time at all had passed. Everyone seemed to expect that the old Bilbo Baggins would simply step back into his place.

 

I think he never quite managed it.

 

Your friend,

Bilbo

✉

Chapter 18: ✉ Of Stone and Timber

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

✉

Dear Bilbo,

 

Your latest letter was waiting for me when at last I reached Edoras, and I confess it was received with more relief than I had expected. The crossing of the White Mountains proved slower than I had intended. The passes are fair in their own stern fashion, though less welcoming than those I have long called familiar. For several days I found myself with little company save the wind and the stone beneath my feet.

 

There are few places where a dwarf feels quite so much at home as among mountains, no matter whose they may be. Stone asks little of those who walk upon it. It simply endures.

 

Edoras itself is not a great city by the measure of Minas Tirith, nor does it seek to be. It stands upon its hill with a quiet confidence. Its Golden Hall is fair, though fashioned almost entirely of timber. At first I could not help wondering how Men could place such value upon a hall built of wood, when stone may endure for the ages, though after a few days here I believe I understand a little better.

 

The folk here do not speak of their hall as though it were something that has survived unchanged through countless years. They speak instead of those who have repaired its beams, renewed its roof, and kept its hearth burning through winter, It occured to me that perhaps there are things which endure not because they resist the passing of years, but because each generation has cared enough to mend what weather and time have asked of it. There is wisdom in that, I think.

 

Perhaps that is why your last letter has remained so much in my thoughts since my arrival.

 

You wrote that the old Bilbo Baggins never quite found his place again after returning home. I have read that sentence many times.

 

It struck me that, for all the years I spent longing to return to Erebor, I never once asked myself whether the Thorin Oakenshield who finally entered its gates could truly be the same one who had left them. I thought only of reclaiming the Mountain. I gave very little thought to what should come after.

 

You have always seemed more willing than I to notice such questions. I wonder now whether that is why you remember evenings beside the fire more readily than war.

 

You asked in an earlier letter whether the road had begun to feel like home. I believe I answered it had not.

 

Though that still remains true, I have begun to suspect that I have been asking the wrong question. The road is only a road. It is neither home nor kingdom, neither burden nor companion. It merely leads onward. Perhaps what matters is not where it leads, but who one is when one has no pressing need to follow it. I find I do not know the answer.

 

By my journey through the White Mountains I came to realise that I have spent much of my life measuring myself  by the steepness of the climb before me. When the road is difficult, one knows what is required: endure a little longer, walk a little further, bear a little more. Such things are easily understood.

 

It is the easier roads that leave me uncertain.

 

I do not mean that I long for hardship. Do not mistake me in that. But I have begun to wonder whether I have grown so accustomed to purpose born of necessity that I scarcely know how to recognize it when no necessity presents itself.

 

Forgive me. I fear have answered your thoughtful letter with thoughts no less untidy.

 

You wrote once that you had grown fond of the quiet life you have made for yourself. I find that sentence has lingered with me. I hope it remains as true now as when you put it to paper.

 

From here I intend to ride north. I have long heard tales of Fangorn Forest, and beyond it lies the Golden Wood, of which so many strange stories are told that I find myself wondering how many can possibly be true. Supposedly an ancient Elven city of grandeur over where a great Elven witch resides. If there is any place where old questions have long since found their answers, one might suppose it would be there.

 

Where the road shall lead me after that, I cannot yet say. Rather than guess poorly, I shall wait until I have found a place where I mean to remain for more than a night or two before I trouble you with another letter.

 

Until then, take care of yourself, Bilbo.

 

Yours,

Thorin

✉

Notes:

letters are getting longer and increasingly personal <33

Chapter 19: ✉ Golden Touch

Notes:

sry for the delayed chapter, started a new job and moved into a new apartment and generally life has just been doing what it does.

Chapter Text

✉

Dear Bilbo,

 

Though I did warn you beforehand that it might be a while before I can write you again, I do still wish to send my apologies for the delay of this letter. You have assured me more than once that my letters are welcome, and I have chosen to believe you. It is well that I do, for I have found yours no small comfort upon the road. More than once I have caught myself wishing you were beside me, if only because I knew you would have found words for sights that have so often escaped my own.

 

I now find myself beneath the roof of our old acquaintance Beorn. Whether he would extend the word "friend" equally to the two of us, I cannot say. Though he does not say much, based upon the few conversations we have had over the past few days I suspect you earned rather more of his esteem than I ever did.

 

Before leaving Edoras I was entrusted with a horse. He has proved a patient companion, and together we crossed the plains to the eaves of Fangorn. There are forests that invite a traveller beneath their boughs. Fangorn is not among them. One does not so much enter that wood as receive its reluctant permission to pass. Still, it possesses none of Mirkwood's malice - this forest feels alive and breathing in a different way than any other woods I have encountered before.

 

Even so, I found it less unsettling than what awaited beyond.

 

I set out to see the Golden Wood with my own eyes, but in the end I did not.

 

Whether I was not meant to, or whether I simply found no desire to cross its borders, I cannot rightly say. I remained among the trees at its edge, looking through trunks of silver and gold that seemed to belong more to memory than to the world beneath the sun.

 

It is difficult to describe what followed.

 

I neither saw the Lady Galadriel, nor heard any voice as one understands hearing, yet I have no doubt that I was, for a time, in her presence. Had another told me such a tale, I might have thought memory had embroidered the truth in its telling. Yet I know no plainer account to give you. I cannot even say how long I remained there. The light had changed when I turned away, though I could not have sworn whether a minute or an afternoon had passed.

 

She answered questions I had not spoken.

 

Or perhaps, and I do confess this thought troubles me more, it was not my questions she answered but instead my certainties she unmade.

 

Much of what passed between us now escapes me, as dreams often do upon waking. I remember no conversation in the ordinary sense. Rather, I recall thoughts arriving with a certainty that did not feel entirely my own.

 

She spoke, if she spoke at all, of people shaped by claws and by teeth. Of trees that shed their bark though their roots still run just as deep. Of rivers that do not struggle against their own course, changing and changing with the landscape. Of beasts whose strength was not diminished because they chose to lay down the hunt.

 

Your last letter was not far from my thoughts as I stood there. In particular, I found myyself returning to its final sentence, though I could not then have said why. I believe I understand it a little better now than I did upon first reading it.

 

I sought the Golden Wood for answers, yet when I stood upon its borders it felt clear to me that I would not find the answers I sought there. When I left those woods, I found that the questions I had carried with me altered.

 

For many years I believed that a life was measured by what one endured. Perhaps that was inevitable. Much of mine has demanded no other measure. It is a comforting thing, in its own fashion, to know what hardship requires of you. One need only endure a little longer, bear a little more, refuse to yield where yielding would be easier. I have known how to do those things for most of my life. What I have not known is what remains when there is no burden left to carry. 

 

As I rode northward, another memory returned with such persistence that I could no longer set it aside.

 

Beorn.

 

I remembered him as I first encountered him: a figure whom any sensible traveller would regard with caution, whose very presence suggested a violence best left undisturbed. Yet what had he chosen to make of such strength? Not a throne, nor a battlefield, nor glory. He made a house. He kept horses. Bread. Honey.

 

He greeted me with considerably less surprise than I had expected, as though dwarves simply have a habit of appearing upon his doorstep after long intervals. As expected, there was no great reunion. He looked at me for a moment, asked whether I intended to help him mend a fence before supper, and, upon receiving the only sensible answer, handed me a hammer.

 

I have remained here for the better part of a week. He has offered me no wisdom and no speeches. Indeed, I suspect he would find the very notion quite ridiculous.

 

Yet I cannot help feeling that I have learned more watching him mend a gate and tend his bees than I did standing at the borders of the fairest realm that still remains east of the Sea. I do not yet understand why. Perhaps I shall. Or perhaps understanding is rather less important than I once believed. 

 

I hope this letter finds you well, and that Bag End continues to reward your care with more strawberries than geese. Give my regards to your garden, if gardens are capable of receiving them. I have begun to suspect that they are.

 

Yours,

Thorin

✉

Chapter 20: ✉ Letters and Handwriting

Chapter Text

✉

Dear Thorin,

 

At the time I am writing this, it has only been a day since your latest letter reached Bag End. I am rather ashamed to admit that I neglected several perfectly respectable household duties in favour of reading it at once. The washing-up survived my neglect well enough, though the tea did not.

 

I must confess I was somewhat taken aback by what you wrote. There were moments whilst reading it when I found myself wondering whether I understood it at all, and others when I felt, if only for the briefest instant, that I understood it rather too well. I suspect the Lady of the Golden Wood would consider that an entirely satisfactory outcome.

 

I cannot say that I envy your encounter with her, nor can I say that I would have refused it. The thought of standing before such ancient wisdom is an enticing one. The thought of having every certainty quietly unmade is considerably less so.

 

I smiled, however, when I reached the part concerning Beorn. Not because I doubted your conclusion, but because it seems so entirely fitting that he should greet you with a broken fence rather than a revelation. Somehow I suspect that if the Wise possess any great secret, it is that they spend remarkably little time speaking of wisdom. Though perhaps I am unqualified to speculate upon the nature of wisdom.

 

There is, I am afraid, very little to report from Bag End.

 

A few days ago I spent the afternoon with Drogo Baggins and Primula Brandybuck. They insisted upon bringing enough food for twice our number, and I did my utmost to prove them entirely justified. I continue to find them excellent company, which is fortunate, for good conversation has become rather more difficult to come by than it once was. Whether that says something unfortunate about Hobbits or merely about me, I shall leave for wiser folk to determine.

 

Before their visit, another letter arrived which I think may interest you.

 

Balin writes that Erebor prospers. The markets are busy, the halls grow livelier with each passing season, and unless Balin's affection for your nephew has entirely overcome his judgement, King Fíli has settled comfortably into the burdens of his crown. Though I never truly doubted that he would, I confess I have struggled, from time to time, to picture anyone but you upon the throne beneath the Mountain. Balin's vivid descriptions brought me great comfort as I no longer struggle to imagine it that way.

 

One passage, however, gave me pause.

 

Toward the end he asked whether I had heard from you. He wondered if I knew where the road had carried you, for it seems no word has reached the Mountain since the day you departed.

 

I confess I had simply assumed that your letters to me were among many.

 

It never occured to me that they might not be.

 

I have not yet answered him. Your journey seems to me your own story to tell, and I do not think it my place to tell it on your behalf. I believe I shall merely assure him that you are well, and that the road, whatever else it may be teaching you, has not diminished your handwriting in the slightest. To tell the truth, I do not think he writes from worry so much as curiosity. He seems to trust the course you have chosen, even if he cannot yet see where it might lead you.

 

Wherever your next letter finds itself written, know that I shall await it with the same eagerness as always. 

 

Take good care of yourself, and do give Beorn my warmest thanks for his hospitality.

 

Your friend,

Bilbo

✉

Chapter 21: ✉ In Defence of Wilting Flowers

Notes:

sry for the delayed chapter. here's a long one. enjoy :)

Chapter Text

✉

Dear Bilbo,

 

Your letter found me still beneath Beorn's roof, though I expect this shall be the last I send from here.

 

Balin's news was welcome, though I had no doubt that Erebor would prosper under King Fíli. If I did, I would not have left. Still, there is pleasure in hearing of its well-being. Tell Balin, once you answer him, that his account pleased me greatly.

 

You may also tell him that I am well.

 

I fear I can offer no satisfactory explanation for why he has heard nothing from me directly, but trust that it is not for lack of trying. More than once I have sat down with the intention of writing to Erebor, yet I struggle to find words that seem more than something fit for a messenger to carry to a council, with nothing of real relevance.

 

Writing you has never presented the same difficulty. Whatever the reason may be, I hope you will endure the burden of remaining my sole correspondent a while longer. You have assured me often enough that my letters are welcome, and I intend to hold you to it.

 

Beorn, meanwhile, continues to provide remarkably little of what I came here seeking. 

 

He has offered no counsel, nor has he asked any question that pertains to anything other than daily life. Indeed, I suspect that if I told him I had crossed half the world in the hope of discovering some great truth beneath his roof, he would put a rake in my hands and tell me that the eastern field required discovering first.

 

My fingernails are black from soil as I write this, so perhaps he already has.

 

There is much here that would once have struck me as wasteful.

 

Beorn's strength has not lessened since I saw him last. Nothing about the quiet of his house has made the creature who fought before Erebor any less terrible. The same hands that quiet a frightened horse could break a neck with little effort. The same great shape bent over seedlings in the earth may become something before which armed Orcs once fled.

 

Yet the days pass without asking any of it from him. There are horses to feed at sunrise. Bread to make. Fences that lean after heavy rain and must be set upright again. Bees that care nothing for the strength of the hand tending their hives.

 

Beside the southern wall grow flowers whose name I have not learned. They opened only a few mornings ago, and Beorn tells me they will be gone before the summer is finished. There is something almost defiant in them - all that colour spent upon a thing which makes no attempt to endure.

 

I know that once I thought Beorn's strength wasted here. 

 

But perhaps strength is not diminished by having nothing to conquer.

 

Lady Galadriel's words have returned to me often here: claw and tooth, the hunt laid aside without either becoming blunt. Beorn has not made himself lesser in choosing this life. If anything, I begin to wonder whether it requires a surer knowledge of one's own strength to possess it without forever seeking occasion to prove it.

 

There is something in that which I cannot yet put properly into words. Perhaps you would understand it better than I. You always had a peculiar respect for small things, and I do mean that as high praise.

 

I have also thought of what you wrote of returning to Bag End, and of the Bilbo Baggins whom everyone expected to find there waiting for them.

 

When did you know that you had no wish to become him again?

 

Perhaps you never knew it all at once. Perhaps there are changes which announce themselves only when one looks backward and discovers that the old path has vanished behind him.

 

You need not answer if I presume too much. Yet I find myself curious about the years of your life. I did not witness. I know something of the hobbit who stepped out of Bag End and rather more of the one whose letters reach me now. There is a great deal between the two of which I know almost nothing.

 

My own stay here must soon come to its end.

 

Beorn has given no sign that my presence has become unwelcome, but his hospitality ought not to be mistaken for a desire for company. He has made a life here according to his own nature, and solitude is as much a part of it as the horses and the bees. There are those who are lonely because no one stays, and those who are content because no one needs to.

 

It would be a poor repayment for what he has shown me to overstay his welcome.

 

My horse, however, appears to disagree.

 

The gelding given to me in Rohan has taken readily to Beorn's pastures and, more importantly, to the other horses. Beorn has an ease with such creatures that I have neither the skill nor the vanity to imitate. I have therefore decided to leave him here and continue on foot. He carried me faithfully farther than I had any right to ask, and it seems a poor reward to pull him away from a place he has plainly chosen simply because I have not yet chosen one myself.

 

My own thoughts have turned toward Rivendell. Not because I expect answers there. I believe I have lately been cured of the notion that wisdom is something one may collect by travelling to sufficiently ancient places. 

 

But when last we entered that valley, everything before me was measured against Erebor. A place aided our purpose or delayed it. Counsel was useful or it was not. We required Elrond's learning, and so I valued it. We required rest, and so I endured it. Much else I dismissed before I had properly looked.

 

I have wondered for a while now how much of the world I passed in this manner.

 

Rivendell endured through long years of ruin without becoming either fortress or tomb. Memory is kept there, yet the house itself remains alive with songs and books and feasts. I understood preservation then chiefly as stone kept standing, names remembered, treasures reclaimed, and bloodlines continued. This time, I should like to see what I failed to see the first time.

 

Whether Lord Elrond will permit it is another question. I shall not presume that the hospitality once extended to a king upon Gandalf's business will necessarily be offered to a solitary dwarf arriving unbidden at his borders.

 

Still, there is only one way to discover it.

 

A few evenings ago the clouds broke over the mountains at sunset, and for a little while the whole western sky seemed aflame. My first thought was that I ought to remember it well enough to describe it in my next letter. My second thought was that description would not do.

 

I found myself wishing

 

No. That is not quite true. I do not know what I wished. Only that the sight seemed, for a moment, strangely incomplete.

 

You would have liked it.

 

Perhaps Rivendell will prove easier to put into words upon a second viewing, if Lord Elrond will permit me one.

 

And since I now know that Balin has taken to writing you behind my back, I must ask one favour. Should he, or any other dwarf with whom you have secretly established a correspondence, ask where I have gone - you are expressly forbidden from informing them that Thorin Oakenshield has willingly set out for Rivendell.

 

Fíli has enough to contend with as King without rumours that his uncle has lost his senses entirely.

 

I hope your next letter will find me there.

 

Until then, take care of yourself.

 

Yours,

Thorin

✉

Chapter 22: ✉ Imaginations of a Traveller

Chapter Text

✉

Dear Thorin,

 

I hope this letter reaches you safely arrived and welcomed in Rivendell. If so, I shall honour your request and keep your present destination from Balin. What I cannot promise, however, is the survival of the secret should you begin composing Elvish verse or develop an appreciation for their singing. Until then though, your dignity is safe with me.

 

On a more serious note, I actually quite enjoyed Rivendell when we visited last. I confess there was something in your wish to see it again as simply Thorin the Dwarf that pleased me greatly.

 

I think you were right to leave the horse with Beorn. There are certainly worse fortunes than finding oneself somewhere one had not intended to stay, only to discover, quite unexpectedly, that it suits one.

 

Though perhaps I need not remind a traveller of such things.

 

What you wrote of Beorn has remained with me. I remember being utterly terrified of him when we first met, though I rather liked him before we left. You saw strength where I saw kindness, perhaps, and I suspect we were both correct. I cannot imagine Beorn himself troubling to decide which is the truer description.

 

As for your question about myself in Bag End, I do not think there was ever a morning when I awoke and knew I had become someone different. There were only small discoveries, one after another, in the months following my return. Old conversations no longer interested me in the same way. Things I had once thought terribly important now seemed rather silly. Other things became dearer than I could have imagined.

 

I suppose one learns eventually not to demand that life resemble the one imagined for it.

 

There are still moments when the Shire seems too small. Not because I wish to leave it, at least not for now. And if I do, it shall not be for long. But sometimes I see the hills beyond my window and remember how vast the world is beyond them. 

 

Your letters do help with that, although I fear they have produced another difficulty.

 

The other evening I was sitting outside Bag End when the light caught the Hill in such a way that everything went gold for a few minutes. Without thinking, I began composing a description of it for you. Then I stopped myself, because you already know what the Shire looks like. Yet, for some reason, it did not seem to matter.

 

I believe I understand what you meant about some things losing something in the telling. Perhaps there are sights which are simply better shared. But I fear I am becoming sentimental with age.

 

Rivendell best be receiving you with kindness, Thorin. And please, try not to quarrell with the Elves before your next letter. I should hate to discover that all this newfound wisdom has been exaggerated.

 

Your friend,

Bilbo

✉

Chapter 23: ✉ Courteous Discourtesy

Chapter Text

✉

Dear Bilbo,

 

You may rest assured that Rivendell has received me with kindness, though I suspect this owes rather more to Lord Elrond's hospitality than to any great enthusiasm among his people. There were several looks upon my arrival which required no knowledge of Elvish to interpret.

 

Nonetheless, I have behaved with admirable restraint. You may be disappointed to learn that there has been no quarreling at all.

 

Lord Elrond received me with courtesy and, to my surprise, very little astonishment. Indeed, there was something almost unsettling in how unsurprised he seemed to find me at the borders of his realm. I had prepared myself to explain that I came neither as King under the Mountain nor upon any errand of Erebor, only as Thorin the Dwarf asking whether an old guest might be permitted to see the valley once more. He regarded me for a moment with that unreadable expression which I have begun to suspect Elves cultivate deliberately, before saying that he would be honoured to receive me as his guest.

 

It soon became apparent that Lord Elrond knew considerably more of my road than those I had left beneath the Mountain.

 

News of my abtication has evidently travelled farther than the realm of Dwarves, as has word of my departure from the Lonely Mountain. Stranger still, Lord Elrond asked about activity east of Minas Tirith under the assumption that I had been there recently. Another time, he asked whether I had found the shipwrights of Pelargir agreeable company.

 

When I questioned him, he told me only that news travels by many roads, and if the tales of my years at the forge during exile held any truth, a dwarf of my description working the iron fittings of ships far from any dwarven settlement was not so difficult a riddle as I imagined. I dislike being a riddle solved before I know I have been posed, though I imagine you would have enjoyed it immensely.

 

As for Rivendell itself, I find it much as we left it.

 

I remember thinking it was beautiful even upon our first visit, though back then its beauty seemed to me excessive, its ease frivolous, and its inhabitants more so. I still maintain that no proper meal ought to contain quite so many leaves. Fortunately, their bread remains tolerable.

 

In other matters, however, I hay have judged the place too quickly.

 

There is an ease here which I once mistook for idleness. Nothing seems hurried, yet very little is neglected. Songs are sung for no greater purpose than the pleasure of singing them. Books are copied which their scribes cannot possibly expect to finish quickly. Things are rmended with such care that one might think the act of mending mattered as much as the thing preserved.

 

There is sorrow here also, though I understand little of it.

 

As I do not understand their tongue, I may mistake what I see, but several among them appear to be making ready for the western road. Their possessions are strangely few for folk who have walked beneath the sun for so many years. There are farewells spoken in the halls, and sometimes songs whose words I cannot understand but whose meaning requires no translation. No one speaks of death, and yet there is mourning in it.

 

I have asked no questions. Whatever calls them across the Sea belongs to histories older than mine, and I have lately learned that not everything I fail to understand is therefore mine to uncover.

 

Lord Elrond and I have spent more time together than I would have thought either of us desired. 

 

There remains a certain sharpness between us. I have not forgotten his opinion on some of my choices, and I doubt he has forgotten mine on some of his counsel. Yet there is no hostility in it. He speaks plainly to me, which I value, and does not mistake disagreement for discourtesy. We have differed upon more than one matter and nevertheless returned to the same table afterward. There is something to be said for that.

 

He is strangely curious about my journey. Not merely where I have gone, of which he already seems to know more than I can reasonably explain, but why I chose to go at all. More than once I have had the uncomfortable suspicion that my answers told him something I had not intended to say. Such suspicions are difficult to escape in Rivendell.

 

Yesterday, quite without warning, he asked about you.

 

It was an ordinary enough inquiry. He asked whether we remained in correspondence, whether you were well, and whether the Shire remained much as you remembered it before the quest.

 

I told him that we did, that you were, and that I suspected the Shire would remain stubbornly itself long after both of us had ceased remarking upon it.

 

He smiled.

 

There was something in his expression I did not understand. He seemed pleased, though by which part of my answer I cannot say. For one uncomfortable moment I had the distinct impression that he expected me to say more.

 

I did not oblige him.

 

You may congratulate me upon successfully resisting whatever game an Elf-lord was attempting to play at my expense.

 

I shall remain here only a little longer. There are still parts of the valley I wish to see once more, and Lord Elrond has offered me the use of his library - an invitation which I confess has proved more tempting than I would once have admitted. 

 

After that, I shall take the road again.

 

Where it leads, I cannot yet say. Once, that uncertainty would have troubled me. Now it seems enough that there will be another road when I reach the end of this one.

 

I shall write again when I have found somewhere worth stopping. It has become a habit I am reluctant to break.

 

Until then, take care of yourself, Bilbo.

 

Yours,

Thorin

✉

Chapter 24: ✉ Back Again

Chapter Text

✉

Dear Bilbo,

 

I had not intended to come to Bree.

 

When I left Rivendell, I took the road with no greater purpose than I have had for some time now - to go where inclination would carry me and stop where there seemed reason enough to stop. Beneath my feet, however, the country grew familiar. Yesterday I passed three old figures upon a hillside which I had not expected to ever see again.

 

The trolls remain where morning found them.

 

I stopped there for a night. It is strange how differently one remembers an adventure when there is no longer any danger in it. While I was setting up my small tent I recalled the rain, our empty stomachs, Gandalf's timely return. Perhaps most clearly I remember a hobbit whom I had known scarcely long enough to trust, being sent ahead nonetheless to prove himself a burglar.

 

I remember thinking you had made a poor beginning of it.

 

Looking upon those three miserable creatures now, I find myself rather less certain who among us made the poorer showing.

 

I had forgotten how quickly you learned what the rest of us were slower to understand - that there were obstacles upon our road which neither axe nor sword would overcome. You had been among us only a short while, and already you were attempting to save thirteen dwarves who had spent much of the journey doubting whether you ought to be there at all.

 

You may consider this an acknowledgement some years overdue, and I ask that you do not grow accustomed to it.

 

Bree, on the other hand, is itself much as I remember it. I lived here only briefly and bore the place no particular affection, yet returning has stirred memories I had not thought of in many years.

 

It was here that Gandalf found me. Here we spoke of Erebor, of Smaug, and of a journey which until then had belonged more to longing than to roads. I remember thinking there could be no road more important than the one which led east.

 

Now I have returned upon it from the other direction.

 

There is something peculiar in returning here now. I have spent the evening thinking of the country between this inn and the Mountain. Of Rivendell, where I understood rather less upon my first visit than I believed. Of Beorn and his bees. Of the shadow beneath Mirkwood. Of the Long Lake and the ruins of Dale. There are places along that road I remember as clearly as though six years had been six days, and others which seem to belong to the life of another dwarf entirely.

 

For months I have written to you that I did not know where I was going, and every word of it was true. I chose each road as it came before me. There was no destination hidden upon a map, nor any plan I had neglected to tell you - and yet here I am. Perhaps my feet possess greater sense than I have credited them with.

 

You wrote once that my letters made the world beyond the Shire seem a little nearer. I have begun to wonder whether yours have done the opposite to me.

 

Strange, how one may wander half the world before realizing he has been following his own footsteps.

 

I think I should like to see your garden again.

 

Yours,

Thorin

✉

Chapter 25: ❦ Growing Things

Notes:

i have rewritten this chapter a million times, and im finally really happy with it

Chapter Text

❦

Bilbo Baggins had been engaged in a disagreement with the beans in his garden for the greater part of the morning, and by eleven o'clock it had become painfully clear that the beans were winning.

 

This was not, in and of itself, remarkable. Beans had several advantages over hobbits: they were numerous, entirely without shame, and possessed of that peculiar confidence common to growing things, which permits them to reach into places where they have not been invited and afterwards behave as though they had always belonged there. Bilbo, who had met much the same quality among goblins, dwarves, and Sackville-Bagginses, had been prepared for resistance - but he had underestimated the vivacity of the enemy.

 

"No," he said, disentangling one adventurous runner from the sugar snap peas for the second time. "You have a perfectly fine pole of your own, and there is no earthly reason for you to go bothering somebody else's."

 

The bean curled stubbornly around his finger.

 

Bilbo sighed.

 

Gardening had many advantages. Plants might be greedy, unreasonable, and forever trespassing over boundaries which had been plainly set before them, but at least they did not come to one's door expecting luncheon, nor inquire why one had not married, nor suggest that travelling east of Bree had produced some permanent weakness of the mind.

 

Bilbo had long ago discovered that being thought peculiar was not altogether an inconvenience. Indeed, once one's neighbours had abandoned hope of one's sensible behaviour, a great many liberties then became possible. One might walk at odd hours, purchase maps for no obvious reason, correspond with dwarves, and cultivate one's garden according to taste rather than whatever was thought of as fashionable that year.

 

The beans, however, remained unimpressed by his reputation.

 

Bilbo freed his finger, tucked the runner back towards its proper support, and sat upon his heels to admire the result. A small breeze travelled up the Hill and set the leaves stirring. Somewhere beyond the hedge a cart rattled along the road towards Hobbiton, and a lark sang over the fields with the tireless cheerfulness of a creature which had never been obliged to weed anything.

 

Bilbo had just reached for a length of string when a deep voice behind him spoke up.

 

"I see your foes have somewhat diminished in stature."

 

Bilbo froze.

 

"Though it appears your ferocity has not."

 

For one strange instant the morning seemed to continue without him. The bean remained between his fingers. The lark went on singing. A bee, having no understanding of dramatic occasions, buried itself industriously in the lavender by the path.

 

There are some thing which memory preserves very poorly. Faces alter in it, though one seldom catches them doing so. Rooms grow larger or smaller according to whether one longs for them. Colours fade until some chance glimpse restores them and makes one wonder how one had ever been content with the limitation.

 

Voices were no exception to that.

 

Bilbo had not thought that he had forgotten Thorin's voice. Had anyone asked, he would have said that he remembered it perfectly: deep, grave, rather too inclined to lend importance to ordinary remarks, and once accustomed to being obeyed by thirteen dwarves and one Hobbit.

 

Yet in that moment, Bilbo realized that what he had carried in memory was no more Thorin's voice than a thin brown line upon a map was a mountain. 


Slowly, he turned. 

 

Thorin Oakenshield stood beyond the garden gate, as if he physically could not open it unless invited - though that had certainly not been a problem for him at his last visit.

 

Time had been at work upon him. Bilbo noticed this first because memory had preserved him too stubbornly. His hair, already grey when Bilbo last saw him, had lightened considerably, and white ran thickly through it now as through his beard - not as snow hides a field but as summer grass pales towards harvest, changing the colour without diminishing what lies beneath. The road had browned his face and neck, and the years had deepened the lines around his eyes and mouth just subtly enough for Bilbo to take notice.

 

His sky-blue hood remained, faded somewhat and marked by travel, but there was no silver tassle. there was no gold, no heavy belt, no bright stone or chain. His clothes were good but plain, his boots dusty, and a travelling pack rested against fence next to the gate as though it had been sat there for weeks.

 

He looked neither like the dispossessed prince who had once come uninvited to Bag End, nor the King beneath the Mountain whom Bilbo had last known in Erebor - yet he looked unquestionably like himself. Like Thorin and only Thorin. The thought struck Bilbo with more force than seemed reasonable.

 

Then Thorin smiled.

 

Bilbo had seen that face proud, furious, exhausted, grief-stricken, and once terribly still. Uncomplicated happiness had never sat upon it often enough for Bilbo to grow accustomed to the sight. Apparently he remained unaccustomed to this day.

 

"Thorin." he said, but it came out more like a breath.

 

There was nothing clever to it, and that was perhaps why it was enough.

 

Bilbo got to his feet so quickly that the shears beside his knee were kicked into the thyme. He crossed the garden with considerably less dignity than one would have wished for at such a reunion, tripping over his own feet and forgetting all sensible things he might have otherwise done - brush the soil from his trousers, straighten his waistcoat, or consider whether hands black to the knuckles were fit to touch another person's clothes.

 

He fumbled only once with the latch before swinging the gate open. Welcome, perhaps. Or that it was good to see him. Or one of the dozen better sentences he had imagined at odd moments without ever admitting to himself that he was imagining them.

 

Instead, Bilbo threw his arms around the tall dwarf in front of him.

 

Thorin rocked half a pace backwards beneath the force of it, and the pack at his feet tipped against the hedge. It was then that Thorin's arms closed around Bilbo and drew him in tightly, and Bilbo discovered, with a shock almost absurd in its simplicity, that he had forgotten the physical fact of him. Memory had preserved shape without weight, had kept the breadth of Thorin's shoulders without the solidity of them, and had forgotten altogether the roughness of travelling wool beneath Bilbo's cheek and the warmth beneath that. There was dust in the cloth and the faint scents of leather, woodsmoke, and cold night air. There were very small things, but small things are often the ones which undo us.

 

Bilbo laughed softly.

 

"Oh," he said, and heard his voice crack slightly, "It is good to see you."

 

Thorin's answer came low beside his ear.

 

"And you, Master Baggins."

 

They remained like that for a while, and neither seemed in any hurry to be the first to alter it. Bilbo had thrown himself into the embrace and therefore, after what he thought a respectable interval, began to loosen his arms.

 

Thorin did not.

 

Bilbo stopped.

 

Thorin held him a moment longer, then tightened his arms once and drew a deep breath, letting it out slowly above Bilbo's head.

 

That was all - there was no great declaration in it, no gesture large enough to be noticed from the road, and yet the breath carried such weariness and such relief together that Bilbo's smile faded. He did not ask what it meant. He merely rested his cheek against Thorin's shoulder once more and let him have the moment. The garden rustled behind them. A bird called somewhere in the hedge. The ordinary morning went on around two people for whom, just then, very little felt ordinary.


At last Thorin released him, and Bilbo stepped back. For the first time they properly looked at one another from an arm's length, and something about that was almost more exposing than the embrace had been. Bilbo became aware of the earth upon his knees, the uneven roll of his sleeves, and a leaf caught against his waistcoat. Thorin's gaze moved over him with the peculiar attention of someone comparing a remembered place with the country itself, then returned to his face.

 

"You are well?" Bilbo asked.

 

"I am."

 

"Truly?"

 

Thorin's expression softened.

 

"Truly."

 

"Good." Bilbo answered with a nod.

 

The answer came more quietly than he intended, and for a moment he had nothing else. There were years behind them, well over half a decade in fact. Years in which one life had gone beneath stone and another beneath a green Hill. Yet with Thorin standing before him, none of that vanished. It simply ceased to be the most important thing in the garden.

 

Thorin looked at him in turn.


"And you?" he asked.

 

"I am well." Bilbo said and found, with some surprise, that he meant it. "Not entirely improved, but well enough."

 

Thorin smiled again, and Bilbo felt the old ease stir between them, not yet as quick or sharp as it had once been, but alive and well nonetheless.

 

"You look well." Thorin said.

 

"So do you." Bilbo began and realized that honesty, once begun, proved troublesome to stop. "Better than I expected, in fact."

 

"I am uncertain whether that is meant as praise or insult." Thorin's brows rose slightly.

 

"It was meant as praise."

 

"Then I thank you, my friend."

 

Bilbo looked at his hair again and immediately wished he had not. There was more white in it than he had first thought, and the morning sun seemed particularly fond of those strands, catching upon them whenever Thorin moved his head. Bilbo had known Thorin handsome once. No, handsome was too tidy a word, suitable for young Tooks at weddings or polished portraits in respectable halls. Thorin had always seemed made of something rougher. Striking, perhaps. Severe. Magnificent on occasion. Beautiful once or twice, though Bilbo had always found that word embarrassing even in private. Nearly seven years had not cured the problem, though this was a realization that Bilbo quickly decided to place firmly aside.

 

Thorin had turned towards the Hill.

 

"I had forgotten how green it is."

 

Bilbo followed his gaze. The Shire lay around them in its late summer abundance, hedges thick with leaf, fields folding one into another in long gentle slopes, trees standing dark where the road dipped and vanished between them. Green was so common here that most hobbits scarcely thought it remarkable, it belonged to the land in the same way roofs belonged to houses and smoke to chimneys.

 

"I suppose you might." Bilbo said. "There is rather a lot of it."

 

Thorin smiled faintly, but his gaze remained upon the fields.

 

"It is beautiful."

 

Bilbo looked at him.

 

There was no politeness in the words. Thorin did not say it because he stood in Bilbo's garden and thought his host might be pleased. He seemed, for the moment, to have forgotten Bilbo was watching him at all.

 

"Yes," Bilbo said after a while. "It is."

 

He loved the Shire. That had never ceased to be true, though others often seemed to think his affection must have been broken by the same journey that had broken his reputation. The trouble was only that the Shire had once seemed large enough to contain everything worth knowing, and Bilbo could no longer pretend this was so. He had seen mountains and great rivers, forests that swallowed the daylight, cities of Men and halls of Elves. He had discovered that a home might remain beloved after ceasing to be the whole world. At times this had troubled him, but now it seemed merely true.

 

Thorin's gaze came back towards the garden. His eyes travelled over the beds, taking in the cabbages, the roses, and the herbs that had been allowed to crowd rather too freely against the path. He did not merely glance over them, as Bilbo had half expected him to do, but looked with the same grave attention he might once have given a map laid out before the Company. Presently he stepped nearer the low border and bent to examine the rosemary, whose woody stems had grown thick with age and were spilling untidily over the stone.

 

Bilbo watched him pinch one narrow leaf between finger and thumb and rub it absently before lifting his hand to catch the scent. It was a small movement, and there was no earthly reason why Bilbo should have attended it so closely. Yet he found himself noticing the brown of Thorin's fingers against the pale green leaves, the little scars that crossed his knuckles, and the silver-white fall of his hair when he bent his head. The latter had escaped somewhat from beneath the blue hood and lay across his shoulder in a fashion Bilbo found unacceptably distracting.

 

He looked at the rosemary instead.

 

"You have done well with your garden." Thorin said.

 

It was a simple compliment, but Bilbo was absurdly pleased by it. There had been a time, he thought, when Thorin could scarcely have stood still long enough to notice a garden. Not because he had been blind to beautiful things, Bilbo knew better than that, but because there had always been something beyond the thing before him - another road to walk, another task unfinished, a Mountain drawing every thought eastward as surely as the moon draws the tide. Even in rest there had been purpose in him, and purpose had sat heavily upon Thorin in those days.

 

Now there was nothing at all to prevent him from spending a late summer morning smelling rosemary.

 

"Thank you." Bilbo replied before glancing towards the beans, one of which had already begun undoing his. morning's work. "Though I would reserve judgement until you have been properly acquainted with everything."

 

Thorin straightened and followed his gaze.

 

"They appear healthy."

 

"They are insubordinate."

 

The corner of Thorin's mouth moved, and a flicker of mischief appeared in his eyes.

 

"They learnt from the best."

 

"You have been here scarcely long enough to insult me." Bilbo stated and tried to give Thorin a stern look, though it was difficult to put much severity into it when Thorin was plainly pleased with himself.

 

"I did not insult you."

 

"You compared me to a bean."

 

"A healthy bean."

 

Bilbo made a sound of disgust and turned away, but not before he caught Thorin smiling. There were deeper lines around his eyes when he did that now. Bilbo had noticed them at the gate. Now he noticed them again, and something small and warm turned beneath his ribs before he could prevent it.

 

It was the reunion, he decided. One could hardly be expected to meet an old and dearly missed friend after so long and remain entirely unmoved by it.

 

This explanation seemed satisfactory enough, provided he did not examine it too closely.

 

Bilbo looked down at his boots only to notice the dust upon Thorin's boots and the great pack still resting against the fence.

 

"You must be weary," he said, turning towards it. "Here, allow me-"

 

"Do not strain yourself on my behalf, friend." 

 

"You have carried it far enough." Bilbo insisted, looking back up at Thorin.

 

"I am quite able to carry it a few steps further."

 

"And I am quite able to help." Bilbo stated stubbornly.

 

He seized the strap before Thorin could object further. The pack scarcely moved.

 

Behind him, Thorin said nothing, though this silence had. a quality to it.

 

Bilbo planted his feet more firmly and tried again. The pack rose perhaps the height of his hand before its weight dragged his shoulder down with it, and he was obliged to let it fall. Something inside struck something else with a heavy metallic knock.

 

"What on earth have you got in there?" He asked as he slowly straightened himself, attempting to regain some level of dignity.

 

"My belongings."

 

"Your belongings appear to have been quarried."

 

Thorin had folded his arms, and there was an expression upon his face which Bilbo knew perfectly well and did not care for in the least. Thorin's mouth twitched once more, in that way that made Bilbo's neck suspiciously heat up.

 

"Do not." Bilbo said with a frown, pointing warningly at the dwarf.

 

"I said nothing."

 

"You needn't."

 

Bilbo rubbed his shoulder and looked suspiciously at the pack. He had travelled with dwarves long enough to recognize the sound of metal that had no business being carried over several hundred leagues by a person claiming to have abandoned al unnecessary burdens.

 

His eyes narrowed.

 

"Thorin."

 

"Yes?"

 

"Are those tools?"

 

There was a pause so small that it amounted to confession.

 

"A few."

 

Bilbo stared blankly at him, then crouched again and pushed experimentally against the side of the pack. Something broad and solid resisted beneath the leather.

 

"You have carried smithing tools on your back?"

 

"Only those I wished to keep."

 

"Across half the world?"

 

"Yes."

 

There was not the least embarrassment int Thorin's face. If anything, he appeared faintly puzzled that the matter required discussion.

 

Bilbo stood and looked from him to the pack and back again.

 

"You left an entire kingdom behind" Bilbo said at last, "but apparently your favourite hammer was beyond sacrifice."

 

"It is an excellent hammer."

 

That did it.

 

Bilbo laughed out loud, he could not help it. The laugh came out whole and helpless, and the more affronted Thorin attempted to look, the worse it became. There was something wonderfully reassuring in the discovery. Thorin had changed - Bilbo could see that everywhere he looked. The change was written in the ease of his shoulders and the patience with which he had approached, in the plain clothes and the absence of gold, even in the quiet pleasure with which he had looked across the shire. Yet beneath all of it remained a dwarf who might abandon a throne more readily than a tool he considered well made.

 

Time had altered him without replacing him.

 

Perhaps Thorin understood what Bilbo found so funny, for his injured dignity lasted only a little while before it cracked. His own laughter joined Bilbo's, deep and warm in the bright garden, and something which had remained careful between them since the gate loosened at last.

 

"I am glad." Bilbo finally said, wiping at one eye.

 

"About the hammer?" Thorin, whose laughter had at last faded into a smile, asked.

 

"No." the answer slipped out of Bilbo before he had the chance to dress it in anything lighter.

 

Thorin looked at him.

 

Bilbo felt suddenly foolish, but he did not take it back. There was soil beneath his nails, Thorin's absurdly heavy pack at his feet, and a bean somewhere behind them undoing everything Bilbo had accomplished that morning- It seemed a poor setting for solemn declarations, which perhaps made honesty a little easier.

 

"I am glad you came."

 

Something changed in Thorin's face. It was not surprise exactly. The smile simply quieted, and the amusement in his eyes gave way to an affection so open that Bilbo felt it physically like the sensation of stepping unexpectedly from shade into sun.

 

"So am I." Thorin said.

 

There it was again - that traitorous movement beneath Bilbo's ribs.

 

Only this time it did not pass at once. His heart seemed to strike too hard against his chest, and warmth rose beneath his collar despite the breeze coming over the Hill. For a moment nothing existed but the way Thorin was looking at him.

 

When he managed to snap out of it, he turned towards Bag End.

 

'Food', he thought. 'Food is sensible.'

 

There was a traveller in his garden who had come a very long way, and Bilbo was standing about staring at him when any properly raised hobbit ought already to have put a kettle on.

 

"Well," he said, brushing the soil from his palms with rather more attention than was necessary. "Whatever you have been calling meals upon the road, I refuse to believe they would satisfy anybody with a proper pantry."

 

"I ate this morning."

 

"How many hours ago?"

 

"Not so many."

 

Bilbo narrowed his eyes and looked at the dwarf.

 

"Very well" Thorin surrendered with remarkably little resistance.

 

"Good. There is bread, and cheese, and I believe some cold turkey left from yesterday. Unless you have developed an objection to proper eating while travelling?"

 

"I have developed no such thing."

 

"I thought not."

 

Bilbo instinctively bent towards the pack, remembered its contents, and thought better of it. 

 

Thorin noticed, and this time he actually did laugh.

 

"Oh, carry your precious hammer yourself." Bilbo said, and went to retrieve the shears he had abandoned among the thyme. 

 

Behind him came the quiet shift of leather and metal as Thorin lifted the pack. When Bilbo turned again, Thorin had settled it over one shoulder and was waiting for him.

 

For an instant Bilbo simply looked.

 

It was a strangely ordinary sight. Thorin stood inside his garden gate, beneath the green branches of an apple tree, with a faded blue hood upon whitening hair and a travelling pack slung over one shoulder. No crown marked him. No Company gathered at his back. No song had foretold his comign, and no purpose greater than luncheon waited beyond the round door of Bag End.

 

Bilbo had never seen him look so little like a king. He had never, perhaps, seen Thorin the Dwarf look so entirely himself.

 

"Come along, then." Bilbo said, and they started up the path together.

 

The path from the gate to the door was not long. Bilbo had walked it so often that his feet knew every stone without assistance from his eyes - where the thyme had crept into the cracks, where one slab had sunk slightly at the edge, where rainwater would gather after a storm before slipping away into the grass. Yet he found himself walking more slowly than usual, and after several paces Thorin moved a little ahead of him.

 

That was when Bilbo made the mistake of looking again.

 

The blue hood passed beneath the low branch of the apple tree. Thorin ducked his head without seeming to notice that he had done so, and the movement brought one hand up to steady the pack upon his shoulder. Bilbo's eyes followed it - the broad hand upon the strap, the strength in the wrist, the white and iron-grey of his hair bright against the summer green - and something in him tightened with such sudden familiarity that he stopped.

 

It was not the first time that morning, and the realization came upon him rather unpleasantly. There had been the gate, and the warmth of Thorin's body when he had held Bilbo longer than Bilbo expected. There had been the sunlight in his hair, the lines around his eyes when he laughed, the ridiculous heat in Bilbo's neck when Thorin had nearly smiled at him over the pack. 

 

And now this.

 

Bilbo stood halfway up his own garden path with shears in one hand and watched Thorin waslk towards his front doot.

 

Distance, he thought suddenly, had been a very useful thing.

 

It had a habit of softening what it held. A person became memory. Memory, with time, became something that might be carried quietly. Even when the letters had begun again and Thorin had returned to Bilbo's days by way of ink and paper, there had remained forests and rivers and mountains between them. Bilbo might read a couple of times, or smile over it at breakfast, or think rather longer than necessary about some sentence before folding the page and putting it away.

 

Paper had edges and could be folded. A letter did not stand in one's garden laughing.

 

It did not smell of leather and woodsmoke when it embraced you. It did not grow more silver in the hair and, most unfairly, become more pleasing for it. It did not stand close enough that one could see the little scars upon its hands.

 

Bilbo had made his peace with loving Thorin long ago. He had thought the feeling would pass one day, and when it did not, he had eventually ceased demanding that it should. There was no shame in loving a friend more deeply than that friend could answer in kind, provide one did not turn affection into a debt. Thorin had given Bilbo a friendship dearer than most things in his life. Bilbo had learned to take it for what it was and ask for nothing beyond it.

 

He had become very sensible about the matter.

 

Standing in the garden, Bilbo began to suspect that sensibility had received rather more assistance from geography than he had previously acknowledged. 

 

Thorin reached the top of the path.

 

The round green door stood before him. For a moment he looked at it, and Bilbo wondered what he saw - whether he remembered the first time he had crossed that threshold with twelve other dwarves already inside and an adventure already gathering, or whether the door was only a door to him now, green and round and presently standing betweem him and luncheon.

 

Then Thorin turned.

 

"Bilbo?"

 

Bilbo had not moved.

 

There was no suspicion in Thorin's face, only a mild quesition.

 

"Yes," Bilbo replied, perhaps a bit too quickly. "Coming."

 

He started up the path.

 

There were winters which loosened their hold slowly. Rain came, and then frost returned - patches of old snow survived in the hollows long after the fields had begun to soften, and one might watch spring approaching for weeks without being able to name the morning upon which it arrived. Other winters seemed to end all at once. One looked away from the earth for a little while and, upon looking back, discovered green shoots where yesterday there had apparently been none.

 

Bilbo had thought this particular patch of ground safely dormant. Not dead, never dead. He had known better than that. Only quiet, and he had perhaps mistaken quiet for obedience.

 

By the time he reached the door, Thorin had stepped aside to let him pass. Bilbo went beneath his arms and into Bag End, acutely aware of the dwarf standing close beside him and determined not to be aware of it at all.

 

He would manage, of course he would.

 

Behind them, in the garden, the bean Bilbo had tied twice that morning had already stretched once more towards the neighbouring pole. It had been given perfectly clear instructions. 

 

Growing things, unfortunately, had never cared much for those.

❦

Chapter 26: ❦ Tea After Supper

Notes:

thank you for all of your kind comments, i am putting a ridiculous amount of time and effort into these last chapters to make sure they are absolutely perfect, and the support really motivates me!

Chapter Text

❦

The remains of supper had disappeared some hours ago, but the remains of what Bilbo had firmly maintained was not a second supper still occupied one end of the kitchen table.

 

Supper was supper, while the bread and cheese brought out several hours later belonged to that broad and respectable category of food which existed simply because one happened to still be awake - but Thorin, who had watched Bilbo disappear into the pantry after declaring that neither of them could possibly want another thing, had greeted his return with an expression of such quiet amusement that Bilbo had nearly taken the plate back again.

 

He had not, of course. There were principles involved.

 

Thorin had been at Bag End only a few days, and there was as of yet none of the blind ease that comes when two people have shared rooms long enough to know which board creaks beneath the other's foot and which cup he reaches for without thinking. Thorin still asked where things belonged before putting them away. Bilbo occasionally opened a cupboard and remembered, with a small start, that a dwarf slept in the room at the end of the passage.

 

Yet some of the formality had begun to wear thin around the edges. Not enough to be called habit, only enough that neither now seemed compelled to fill every silence.

 

Perhaps it was the hour. Bilbo had always thought there was something dangerous about kitchens after midnight. Parlours expected good behaviours, drawing-rooms expected conversation to sit upright. Kitchens, once the dishes had been pushed aside and the fire had settled itself for the night, had no such ambitions. Words loosened there. One might say a thing across a kitchen table which would never have survived the journey to a writing-desk.

 

Thorin sat opposite him with one arm resting upon the table, and Bilbo had been trying for the better part of an hour not to find this distracting.

 

He was failing.

 

It was not Thorin's fault. Indeed, Thorin seemed entirely unaware that he had committed any offence. His boots and travelling clothes had been abandoned for the evening, leaving him in a dark tunic loose at the throat and plain trousers, with a pair of slippers Bilbo had unearthed from a cupboard after some searching. They were fractionally too large and should have made him ridiculous.

 

They did not.

 

His beard remained long and proud, because apparently civilisation had certain boundaries even in Bag End. His hair had fared less well. He had twisted it behind his head into a rough knot which had begun the evening respectably enough and had since yielded several pale strands about his temples and neck. In the lamplight the white among the grey caught gold at the edges, like frost upon grass when morning first touches it.

 

Bilbo had known Thorin in armor. He had known him soaked through on the road, half starved beneath Mirkwood, dishevelled after imprisonment, and dressed in all the heavy dignity of Erebor.

 

He had not known him in slippers, and there was something deeply unreasonable about discovering that this was worse.

 

Bilbo raised his cup, found it empty, and set it down again.

 

"You did not even bring a handkerchief." Thorin said from across the table, with the air of a man producing evidence long kept in reserve.

 

"I had hoped that, after all these years, you might have found some more flattering detail of my conduct to preserve." Bilbo muttered as he looked over the rim of his cup at the dwarf in front of him.

 

Thorin's eyes had that dark, amused gleam which Bilbo remembered from rare evenings upon the road.

 

"You have forgotten?"

 

"Certainly not. I was merely wondering why you had chosen to resurrect one of the less dignified moments of my life at this hour."

 

"One of them?" Thorin continued, and there was such satisfaction in the recollection of the moment that Bilbo could not even pretend to be offended for that long.

 

Looking backwards, the beginning of the Quest had acquired a ridiculous innocence. There had ben Bilbo Baggins tearing down the lane towards Bywater with no hat, no proper breakfast, and not even a handkerchief, while thirteen dwarves waited impatiently upon ponies for the burglar who was supposed to help them rob a dragon. Nobody would have believed, seeing him then, that before the journey ended he would speak with Smaug beneath the Mountain, walk unseen through an elven fortress, and stand between armies with the fate of kingdoms tangled in his hands.

 

"I don't suppose I made a very impressive sight." Bilbo admitted.

 

"No." Thorin said at once.

 

"There is gratitude." Bilbo said as he looked up in mock outrage.

 

"You did not look like a burglar."

 

"I did not feel like a burglar."

 

"That was abundantly clear."

 

Bilbo reached for the teapot, more for something to do than from thirst.

 

"And yet Gandalf chose me."

 

"I thought he had lost his senses entirely."

 

"On that point we were agreed."

 

A small smile moved beneath Thorin's beard.

 

"I thought you soft."

 

Bilbo's fingers paused around the pot.

 

There was no insult in the words now. Thorin spoke of the old judgement almost as one might speak of an error in an old map - something plainly there, and plainly wrong.


"And were you very disappointed," Bilbo asked, "when I stubbornly refused to become sensible enough to prove you right?"

 

"Frequently" Thorin said, his smile deepening.

 

This startled a laugh from Bilbo. Thorin joined him, and the sound warmed the room more effectively than the fire had managed for some time.

 

For a little while they remembered the Quest in that fashion - not as songs remember things, all banners and battles and great deeds, but as travellers remember roads after the rain has dried from their cloaks. They argued mildly over whether Bilbo had truly been as miserable during those first days as Thorin remembered him, and Bilbo maintained that his misery had been both reasonable and dignified.

 

"You wished to turn back." Thorin said. 

 

"Repeatedly."

 

"You complained of the food."

 

"There was very little of it."

 

"You complained of the weather."

 

"Travelling in the rain instead of waiting out the storm is entirely unreasonable."

 

"You complained of us."

 

Bilbo regarded him over his cup.

 

"At last, something no one can dispute."

 

Thorin laughed, and Bilbo found himself looking at him again.

 

He had forgotten, or deliberately ceased remembering, what laughter did to Thorin's face. The new lines around his eyes deepened, severity did not vanish so much as open the way a dark hedge suddenly shows birds and blossoms when sunlight falls through it. 

 

"You did improve rather alarmingly." Thorin said. "By the time we reached the Mountain you had stolen keys from the Elvenking, escaped his halls, faced Smaug alone, and stolen from beneath my nose."

 

The amusement vanished from Thorin's face almost as soon as the words had left him.

 

Bilbo's thumb tightened against the handle of his cup.

 

Then Thorin began, carefully.

 

"The Arkenstone-"

 

Bilbo moved.

 

It was no more than the reaching of a hand towards the teapot, but it happened so quickly that the cup beside it knocked faintly against its sauceer.

 

The sound was tiny, yet in the hush of the kitchen it seemed enormous. 

 

For one treacherous instant the room beneath the Hill fell away, and another room rose in its place - vast, cold and glittering. Treasure lay beneath torchlight like frozen fire. Thorin's voice, stripped of everything Bilbo knew in it, rang against stone. There was a hand upon him - too hard - and behind him nothing but air and distance and the terrible knowledge that love could stand before you wearing the face of fury and not know you at all.

 

Bilbo's stomach drew tight.

 

The memory came with no order to it. Not a scene, only pieces - gold-light, stone beneath his feet, Thorin's eyes burning like lamps seen through smoke, the word traitor made larger by the kingdom around them.

 

He set the teapot down with care. Too much care.

 

"Well," he said, and heard the brightness in his own voice, "I did more or less steal the trolls' key."

 

Thorin went still, and Bilbo was afraid to look at him.

 

"The wood-elves' keys as well, come to that. So I think we may safely say my professional reputation improved after all."

 

"Bilbo."

 

"And there was the cup from Smaug, although I suppose that can hardly be called theft when one has specifically been hired to-"

 

"Bilbo."

 

The second time his name was quieter.

 

"I have not forgotten what I did to you." Thorin said.

 

There was no drama in the words, and perhaps that was what made them heavier. They settled over the table like the first frost upon a garden, silencing things which had been alive a moment before.

 

Bilbo's fingers curled once against the wood. He knew Thorin remembered, and that was precisely why he did not wish to speak of it.

 

Not here, with the smell of bread still in the room and Thorin sitting opposite him in a loose tunic, his hair falling out of its knot. Not tonight, when the Mountain was far away and Bag End was warm around them. Bilbo had no desire to draw that old darkness through the round door merely because they had happened to stumble across its name.

 

He had forgiven more than he had forgotten, which was a distinction he preferred not to examine too closely.

 

"Thorin." he said.

 

Thorin's face was very still now. Guilt had begun to gather there with terrible familiarity, like storm-clouds piling beyond a green horizon.

 

"No." Bilbo said, more firmly than before. "I know you have not forgotten it, and I am not asking you to. But I have no wish to lay that particular memory upon the table between the bread and the teapot tonight."

 

Thorin regarded him for a moment.

 

"You have the right to speak of it whenever you choose." he then said.

 

"Precisely. And tonight I choose not to."

 

A pause followed. Thorin regarded him for a long moment, and Bilbo forced himself not to glance away, though every instinct urged him towards the kettle, the cupboard, anything small and ordinary that might close the door again.

 

At last Thorin inclined his head.

 

"Very well."

 

Relief moved through Bilbo so swiftly that it almost hurt, so he stood at once.

 

"The tea is cold."

 

It was a transparent excuse, and both of them knew it. Thorin, to his credit, let it stand.

 

Bilbo carried the pot to the stove and occupied himself with water and flame. His hands were steady. He was pleased by that. The little domestic motions came easy - fill the kettle, set it down, find the fresh leaves. Behind him Thorin remained quiet.

 

Bilbo could feel the silence like a hand between his shoulder-blades.

 

Then, after enough time had passed for the kettle to begin its low murmur, Thorin spoke again.

 

"Did you steal anything else?"

 

Instinctively, Bilbo's hand was drawn to his pocket where the ring he found during the Quest resided. It was pure habit, a calming gesture, that Bilbo himself did not even notice he did as he looked over his shoulder.

 

The faintest smile had returned to Thorin's face, and Bilbo understood the kindness in it.

 

"Several meals, if you ask Bombur."

 

"Those were communal provisions."

 

"Try explaining that to Bombur."

 

And so the Mountain was put away again - not erased, not forgiven into nonexistence, but merely returned to the locked room where both of them kept certain memories until another day.

 

When Bilbo returned with fresh tea, the conversation found lighter ground. They spoke of the journey not as a history but as one remembers an old road in company - stopping where the recollection pleased them and passing quickly over what did not. Bilbo recalled the first night at Bag End and the ruinous enthusiasm with which the dwarves had attacked his pantry.

 

Their laughter returned slowly, then easily, like birds venturing back into a garden after a sudden noise had scared them off.

 

By the time the second pot of tea had cooled, the kitchen had grown sleepy around them. The lamp burned lower, throwing longer shadows across the table, and the fire had sunk into a red glow scarcely brighter than apples beneath autumn leaves.

 

Bilbo had stopped pretending not to look at Thorin.

 

Bilbo had known Thorin crowned. He had known him armed. He had known him dressed for court and dressed for the road. He had never known what Thorin looked like at the end of an ordinary evening when there was nowhere to go afterward but bed. There was something startlingly intimate in seeing him so reduced in splendour and so entirely undiminished by it.

 

That ought not to have mattered, yet it mattered enormously.

 

Bilbo became aware that he was watching the line of Thorin's forearm where the tunic sleeve had been pushed back, the tendons shifting beneath weathered skin as he turned his cup. His attention travelled upward, caught briefly upon the loose hair at Thorin's neck, and was approaching territory Bilbo had no intention of exploring when Thorin glanced up.

 

Bilbo looked at the breadboard.

 

The breadboard had proved a loyal friend that evening.

 

At last Thorin glanced towards the clock.

 

His brows rose, causing Bilbo to follow his gaze and discover that the evening had disappeared entirely.

 

"I should sleep." Thorin said.

 

He stretched the stiffness from his shoulders, raising both arms for a moment. The loose tunic pulled across his chest and waist before falling again.

 

Bilbo's gaze dropped with such determination that it landed upon the abandoned cheese rind. He studied it. There was probably much to be learned from cheese.

 

"Yes," Bilbo replied, contemplating the rind. "You should."

 

Thorin rose from his chair then walked around the table.

 

Bilbo assumed he meant to collect his cup. 

 

Instead the soft scrape of slippers stopped beside his chair, so he looked up.

 

Thorin stood close enough that Bilbo had to tilt his head back. The lamplight had softened him strangely. His face was tired, though not with the old exhaustion Bilbo remembered from the road - this was only the weariness of a late hour after food and warmth and conversation. Silver hair had escaped almost completely around his face, and his eyes in the low light seemed brighter than usual, shining beneath his brows like an owl's caught among moonlit branches.

 

"Goodnight, Bilbo."

 

Without hesitation, Thorin lifted one hand. His palm settled against the back of Bilbo's head, broad and warm, fingers curving lightly where Bilbo's hair met the nape of his neck. It was a simple gesture, so natural in its affection that Bilbo had no time to contemplate it before Thorin bent.

 

Then Thorin kissed the crown of his head.

 

Bilbo's breath caught as if the world seemed to narrow to that single point of warmth.

 

The kiss itself was brief and innocent, almost familial in its tenderness like a parent would say goodnight to their child without thought.

 

Bilbo's body, however, received it as though struck by summer lightning.

 

He felt heat spread down the back of his neck beneath Thorin's hand. His heart gave one violent leap, then another, until it seemed less like a heart than a trapped bird beating itself against his ribs. Every sense sharpened absurdly - the warmth of Thorin's palm, the faint scratch of beard against hair, leather and soap and the dying fire.

 

Then the hand was gone, and Thorin straightened.

 

He left the kitchen, while Bilbo remained where he was.

 

Bilbo heard the soft shuffle of slippers receding into the passage, and for several seconds he could do nothing but sit with both hands flat upon the table and wait for his body to remember that absolutely nothing extraordinary had occurred. It refused.

 

Thorin had kissed his head, that was all.

 

A gesture of affection. A warm, innocent thing. Parents kissed children so, old friends might, kin often did. There was no reason whatsoever for Bilboto sit there with his breath shortened and every nerve in his neck apparently convinced that something catastrophic had happened.

 

The kitchen, mercifully, offered no judgement.

 

He remained until his heartbeat had begun to resemble something ordinarily found inside a hobbit rather than a frightened animal. Then he stood. The dishes could wait. The lamp could be put out. Morning would restore proportion to things as mornings often did.

 

Bilbo extinguished the light and stepped into the passage. The dark there was gentler, broken only by the small lamp left burning near the bedrooms. The cool air touched his face and seemed, for a moment, to clear it.

 

Then he heard the breathing.

 

Bilbo stopped, as he first thought it came from his own chest.

 

Then another breath sounded around the bend ahead - deep, ragged, pulled in too sharply, followed almost at once by another.

 

The warmth left Bilbo's skin in an instant.

 

"Thorin?"

 

No answer, so Bilbo went forward and rounded the corner.

 

Thorin stood with his back pressed against the wall, and for one terrible instant Bilbo thought he was dying.

 

The change was so complete that the kitchen seemed impossibly far away. Thorin's head rested against the wood behind him, eyes fixed somewhere beyond the passage as though he saw not Bag End at all but some sight invisible to Hobbits. One hand was spread against the wall while the other had closed in the fabric of his tunic over his chest.

 

His breathing came hard enough that Bilbo could see it shake him.

 

"Thorin."

 

This time, Thorin jerked violently and his eyes snapped to Bilbo.

 

Thorin simply looked at him, but the look changed as it rested there. His breath faltered. The colour already high in his face deepened. His eyes dropped for the smallest fraction of a moment - perhaps to Bilbo's shoulder, perhaps nowhere at all - and then returned to his face with such abruptness that Bilbo wondered whether he had imagined it.

 

Then, Thorin smiled as he pushed away from the wall and instead placed one hand on Bilbo's shoulder from a respectable distance.

 

"Goodnight, Bilbo."

 

The words were quieter than before.

 

Bilbo felt something odd move through him, though whether concern or confusion or the lingering wreckage of the kitchen he could not have said.

 

"Goodnight." He responded.

 

With that, Thorin let go of Bilbo's shoulder and turned towards the guest bedroom. His first step was steady, and so was the second. By the time he reached the guest-room door, nothing in his gait would have betrayed what Bilbo had just seen.

 

When the door closed softly behind Thorin, the passage became very still.

 

Bilbo remained where he was, looking at the shut door and listening to the silence settle over Bag End once more. It came slowly, like mist filling a hollow after sunset, obscuring first the edges and then the shapes of things until one could no longer be quite certain what had been seen.

 

He did not know what had happened, and was reluctant to attempt at naming it.

 

There had already been enough naming things for one evening.

❦

Chapter 27: ❦ A Cart

Notes:

update:
i published this chapter yesterday but i may have been too eager to post, and when i reread it i didnt like the writing - so i rewrote some of it. hope you enjoy <3

Chapter Text

❦

By the end of summer the Shire had begun to take on that comfortable look of a pantry filled for winter. The hedges were green yet, and thick enough to hide a wandering child or a covey of birds, but here and there a yellow leaf had lodged among them like the first copper coin in a green purse. Apples bent the orchard branches, barley stood pale upon the farther fields, and every second cart upon the road seemed to be carrying either something freshly gathered or something which had recently been made to fit within a jar.

 

The end-of-summer fair was therefore less an occasion of great ceremony than of general satisfaction. Hobbiton had spread itself across the field beside the water in striped awnings and wooden trestles, with baskets of late strawberries and early apples, wheels of cheese, jars of honey, ribbons, pipes, cakes, tools, preserves, and several objects whose usefulness Thorin could not determine at first glance. Somewhere beyond the stalls, a fiddle was playing very quickly and slightly out of tune. 

 

Bilbo had been talking since they left Bag End.

 

"The honey from the Twofoot stall is not worth buying, whatever they tell you. It is perfectly good honey, you understand, but they charge as though their bees had personally negotiated with the flowers. Mrs. Chubb makes the better seed-cake, though she puts too much cinnamon in it these days. And if anyone offers you elderberry wine before noon, say no."

 

"Why?"

 

"Because it is elderberry wine before noon."

 

Thorin considered this with the gravity he might once have given to counsel concerning a mountain-pass.

 

"I see."

 

"You do not."

 

"No, not entirely."

 

Bilbo gave him a suspicious glance, but Thorin's expression remained grave, and there was nothing to be got from it.

 

They had not gone twenty yards among the stalls before Bilbo discovered that his companion was attracting rather more notice than the honey.

 

Thorin took longer to acknowledge it. He had spent the better part of the past year upon roads where Men had turned to look at a Dwarf travelling alone and Elves had watched him with that peculiar curiosity which they seemed to consider less conspicuous than staring. The glances of Hobbiton therefore troubled him little. Bilbo, who knew precisely what each glance meant and very often who was doing the glancing, found them considerably harder to forgive.

 

Hobbits were not, as a rule, subtle when confronted with anything they considered unusual. They were excellent at pretending not to stare, but unfortunately their method consisted chiefly of turning their heads away very quickly whenever Thorin looked toward them. Conversations developed curious pauses as he passed. A child pointed until his mother pushed his hand down, and an elderly hobbit nearly walked into a basket of onions through attempting to look in two directions at once.

 

Thorin endured all this with considerably greater patience than Bilbo.

 

"Morning, Mr. Baggins!" called a round-faced fellow behind a stall of preserves. His cheerful expression faltered only slightly when his eyes travelled past Bilbo. "Er- morning."

 

"Good morning." said Thorin, inclining his head.

 

The hobbit blinked, as though this answer had upset some private expectation.

 

"And you won't be going off again, I hope, Mr. Baggins?" he added, recovering himself with a laugh. "Not another adventure brewing?"

 

Bilbo's mouth drew itself into the polite smile he reserved for remarks he had heard far too often.

 

"No, Mr. Grubb. I believe one adventure has furnished the Shire with sufficient conversation."

 

Mr. Grubb laughed again, somewhat less certainly, and Bilbo carried Thorin onward before the matter could be enlarged upon.

 

"You need not glare at him." Thorin insisted when they were safely beyond the preserves.

 

"I did not glare, I merely looked at him."

 

"Severely."

 

Bilbo sniffed.

 

"You would think they have never seen a Dwarf."

 

"I would venture to guess that of them have not."

 

"That is hardly the point."

 

The corner of Thorin's mouth twitched.

 

It was not the last such encounter. Mrs. Bracegirdle wished Bilbo a very pleasant morning, inspected Thorin from boots to brow, and asked whether his guest would be staying 'for some time yet', with the careful concern of one enquiring after a spell of rain that had already lasted several days. Two young hobbits whispered behind their hands in a manner Bilbo thought both crude and remarkably ineffective. Another asked Thorin whether his home was 'very far', and seemed alarmed when he answered truthfully.

 

None were openly rude. Indeed, by the standards of Hobbiton they were making heroic efforts as courtesy - but there is a sort of politeness which places a stranger outside the gate even while asking whether he would care for tea, and Bilbo knew it well enough to hear the latch fall each time.

 

Thorin, to his irritation, appeared more amused than offended.

 

Bilbo was beginning suspect this made it worse.

 

He had just been explaining, with some force, why the cheese at the next stall was superior to the cheese they had passed three stalls ago - an argument Thorin had not requested but was receiving nonetheless - when somebody spoke up behind him.

 

"Bilbo?"

 

He turned.

 

"Drogo!"

 

The hobbit approaching them was younger than Bilbo by some years, broad through the shoulders and comfortably built elsewhere, with brown hair and an expression that suggested he had already found something amusing in the morning and had every confidence that the day would provide more before luncheon.

 

Bilbo greeted him warmly.

 

"I had wondered whether you would come. I nearly sent word yesterday, but then I thought if you had forgotten there was no use rescuing you from the consequences. Drogo, this is-"

 

"Thorin Oakenshield." said Drogo.

 

Thorin raised an eyebrow while Bilbo looked from one to the other.

 

"Well. That has saved me an introduction."

 

Drogo laughed and offered his hand. Thorin considered it for no more than an instant before taking it.

 

"I have heard rather a lot about you." Drogo said.

 

"Have you?" Thorin asked, amused, as his glance slid towards Bilbo.

 

"Oh, don't look at me like that." said Bilbo. "I have hardly spent seven years giving lectures upon the subject."

 

"No." Drogo replied. "Only six."

 

Bilbo struck him lightly on the arm.

 

Drogo, unlike several hobbits Thorin had encountered that morning, appeared neither troubled nor particularly fascinated by the bare fact that Thorin was a Dwarf. He was curious about the Lonely Mountain, certainly, and asked whether the roads east had changed much since Bilbo's journey - but he asked in much the same tone with which, not five minutes later, he asked Bilbo whether he had tried the plum tart at the far end of the field. Erebor was interesting. So was a plum tart. There seemed no reason in Drogo's mind why either should make ordinary conversation impossible.

 

Thorin warmed to him.

 

Within a quarter of an hour he had attached himself to them without anybody deciding that he should, which was a talent Bilbo suspected he had not inherited from the Baggins' side of their family, though he could not immediately have said from where this ability had been passed down.

 

It was Drogo who first noticed the commotion beside the lane.

 

A cart stood there at an unhappy angle, leaning towards the hedge as though it had grown suddenly weary of carrying its load and meant to lie down. Several baskets had already been rescued from it, and beside the troublesome wheel crouched a youn hobbit wearing he expression of someone personally betrayed by something upon whose loyalty he had hitherto depended.

 

Bilbo peered past Drogo.

 

"Hamfast?"

 

The young hobbit looked up.

 

"Mr. Baggins! Afternoon, sir."

 

"What's happened?"

 

"Wheel's near come off."

 

"I had gathered that much."

 

Hamfast stood and wiped his hands upon his breeches. He was a sturdy young fellow, sun-browned from outdoor work, with honest earth so firmly settled into the creases of his hands that no amount of washing was likely ever to persuade all of it away.

 

"Thorin," Bilbo said, "this is Hamfast Gamgee. His father tends a good many of the gardens hereabouts. Hamfast, Thorin Oakenshield."

 

Something changed in Thorin's face.

 

"Gamgee?"

 

"Aye, sir." Hamfast replied, politely enough, though with some uncertainty.

 

"The goose."

 

Bilbo closed his eyes and exhaled deeply while Drogo brightened visibly beside him.

 

"Pardon?" Hamfast stared, confusion now furrowing his brows further.

 

"Nothing," Bilbo said at once. "Absolutely nothing. An old incident of no importance whatsoever."

 

"It was one of the more amusing anecdotes from your letters." Thorin informed him.

 

Bilbo opened his eyes.

 

"Was it indeed?"

 

"From your account, it was an unusually obstinate goose."

 

Recognition dawned upon Hamfast.

 

"Oh! Father's grey one."

 

"Yes." Bilbo said darkly. "Your father's grey one."

 

"She gets about."

 

"So I discovered."

 

Thorin had already turned his attention to the cart.

 

"What happened?"

 

"Hit a rut coming down." Hamfast explained, crouching once more. "Thought it was only the wheel, but-"

 

Thorin knelt beside him.

 

It was a small thing, perhaps, but Bilbo noticed how completely the curious fair disappeared from Thorin's attention the moment there was a practical problem beneath his hands. He put one palm beneath the hub, examined the end of the axle and ran his thumb along the bent iron pin.

 

"The iron linchpin is badly bent." he said.

 

He worked it loose and turned it towards the light. A fine crack had begun where the metal had taken the strain.

 

"And cracked. I would not trust it again." he continued before looking to Hamfast once more. "I could mend it for you, if you'd like."

 

Hamfast stared.

 

"You can?"

 

Bilbo coughed while Drogo made a peculiar sound which might, with charity, have been mistaken for clearing his throat.

 

"I am a Dwarf," he said. "and a blacksmith by trade."

 

"Yes, sir." Hamfast replied hastily.

 

"There is a smith here?"

 

What followed occupied rather less time than Bilbo expected and attracted rather more attention than he would have preferred.

 

The smith, a thick-armed hobbit from Bywater, surrendered the use of his small fair-forge after only a moment's astonishment. He inspected the damanged linchpin himself before he did so, turning it between fingers blackened by many years of coal and iron.

 

"Could straighten it." he said. "Might hold well enough to get the cart home."

 

"It might." said Thorin.

 

The smith looked up at him.

 

"I would not trust a loaded cart to might."

 

There was no pride in the judgeement and no challenge either - he said it simply as one might say that rain fell downward. Hamfast, who had been looking hopefully towards the road home, immediately looked less hopeful.

 

"I've some bar stock," the smith said. "if you're meaning to make another."

 

"That would be better."

 

The smith fetched it as Thorin removed his coat and laid it aside.

 

This, Bilbo discovered shortly afterward, was unfortunate.

 

He had known, of course, that Thorin was a smith. He had known it during the Quest, in the distant and rather abstract manner in which he had known that Balin had once been a warrior, that Bombur could swim if sufficiently compelled, and that somewhere beneath all the mud, rain, hunger and peril the Dwarves possessed professions which did not involve being pursued by goblins. Thorin had worked at the forge during the years of exile, though he spoke seldom of those years. In the letters of his more recent wandering there had appeared anvils throughout much of the realm of Men, wherever he had lingered long enough to seek one out. Bilbo had read all this without the least difficulty.

 

Watching it was another matter.

 

Thorin rolled his sleeves above his elbows.

 

Bilbo looked very firmly at the fire.

 

There was nothing remarkable in a pair of forearms. Bilbo himself possessed two and had managed nearly sixty years without making an event of them. Thorin's were browned from the road and crossed here and there with old scars, and when he took up the hammer the muscles shifted beneath the skin in a manner Bilbo considered entirely unnecessary.

 

He looked at the fire harder.

 

The smith had given Thorin a length of iron and the freedom of his forge, but no instruction. Thorin required none. He tested one hammer in his hand, exchanged it for another, adjusted his grip upon the tongs and cast a brief assessing glance at the coals before altering the fire with two economical movements.

 

The hobbit smith, who had begun by watching with the polite concern of a man permitting a stranger to handle his tools, folded his arms.

 

Thorin put the iron into the coals.

 

Something in him settled.

 

The watchfullness he had carried through the fair fell from him as naturally as his coat had done. All morning some part of him had remained conscious of the glances following him between the stalls. Though he had borne them lightly, he now seemed to forget that there was anybody present to look. His shoulders loosened. His hands moves without haste and without uncertainty. The forge was not his, nor the hammer, nor the anvil, yet Bilbo had the curious impression that Thorin knew them already, as one knows the words of an old song even when another voice begins it.

 

Then the hammer fell.

 

The clear ring of iron carried beyond the little forge and through the noise of the fair, causing several hobbits to turn.

 

By the fourth blow, the smith had unfolded his arms.

 

Bilbo knew nothing about forging linchpins. This deficiency had never troubled him before, and he had expected to pass the remainder of his life without correcting it. He could therefore not have said what Thorin did differently from another smith. He knew only that there was no wasted movement in it. Thorin never seemed to consider where the hammer ought to fall - it simply fell where it needed to. He turned the glowing iron before Bilbo had quite percieved that it required turning, returned it to the heat at what seemed precisely the moment before its colour began. to die, and drew it forth again with the calm certainty of one who had long ago ceased needing to think about what his hands already knew.

 

The Bywater smith had stopped watching the iron. He was now watching Thorin's hands.

 

That, more than anything, told Bilbo that there was something here worth seeing.

 

Others had noticed as well. The hammer had drawn them first, but they did not wander away again. Two lads carrying a basket of apples stopped beside Hamfast and presently set the basket down altogether. An elderly hobbit who had spent the morning selling pruning-hooks stood with one hand shading his eyes. A woman with a pie beneath one arm paused on her way past and remained there. Even those who had watched Thorin earlier because there was a Dwarf at their fair now watched for quite another reason.

 

Thorin noticed none of them.

 

Bilbo swallowed.

 

It was really most inconsiderate.

 

He had spent the better part a week becoming accustomed, or attempting to become accustomed, to Thorin occupying his kitchen in shirtsleeves, Thorin asleep beneath his roof, Thorin laughing over supper and standing barefoot in the passageway and doing all manner of perfectly ordinary things which Bilbo had discovered, to his considerable annoyance, did nothing whatsoever to diminish his appearance. 

 

Apparently putting a hammer into his hand did not improve matters.

 

The forge-light caught the silver in Thorin's hair and made pale fire of its edges. Soot had found its way onto one cheek. His face had grown still beneath the concentration of his work, his attention narrowed entirely to the small length of glowing iron beneath his hammer. Every time he struck, the movement travelled from shoulder to wrist with an ease which suggested that the hammer belonged there as naturally as a pipe belonged in Bilbo's own hand.

 

It was absurd.

 

Bilbo had seen Thorin wield swords. He had seen him charge an army. He had seen him upon the walls of Erebor with gold and dragon-fire behind him, terrible and magnificent enough that Bilbo had somehow found room amid fear, anger and desperation to notice it.

 

Those occasions, however, had possessed the decency to include mortal peril.

 

This was worse.

 

Perhaps it was the very lack of danger that did it. Nothing terrible or grand stood between Bilbo and the simple fact of Thorin's body moving through familiar work. This was not Thorin made beautiful by battle or kingship or memory. It was merely Thorin doing something he had done a thousand times before, soot gathering upon his hands, a strand of silver-white hair escaping beside his temple, entirely unaware that Bilbo Baggins was being put through an unreasonable trial.

 

Bilbo decided he disliked blacksmithing.

 

This was unfortunate, because Thorin seemed so very fond of it.

 

"You're staring." 

 

Bilbo was startled by the low yet amused whisper from Drogo, who had apparently been standing beside him all along.


"I am watching."

 

"I see."

 

"There is a difference."

 

"Of course."

 

Bilbo gave him a warning look and returned his attention to the work with considerable more dignity.

 

His dignity lasted approximately three seconds.

 

Thorin chose that moment to brace the iron against the anvil and bring the hammer down hard.

 

Drogo said nothing, which was somehow worse than if he had laughed.

 

At the anvil Thorin was shaping the head of the pin. The smith stepped nearer and said something too low for Bilbo to hear. Thorin answered without looking up, altered the angle of the iron by a fraction, and struck twice more. The smith nodded slowly.

 

There was nothing grand in what emerged. It was a linchpin - a stout little piece of iron intended to spend its useful life keeping a wheel upon an axle, and no bard was ever likely to compose a song about it.

 

Thorin nevertheless made it beautiful.

 

There was no ornament upon it, for ornament would have served no purpose. Its beauty lay instead in the rightness of it - the head cleanly formed, the taper even, every line seeming deliberate and inevitable, as though the iron had always intended to become precisely this and Thorin had merely persuaded it to remember.

 

When at last he quenched it and offered it over, the Bywater smith took the pin and weighed it thoughtfully in his palm.

 

"You've done a bit of this before."

 

Drogo made a choking noise, and for the first time since taking up the hammer Thorin seemed to remember that there were other people present.


"A little."

 

"A little." the smith repeated, entirely unconvinced.

 

"I was a smith for many years."

 

"That," said the hobbit, turning the pin once more in his hand, "I believe."

 

Hamfast had edged closer too. He looked at the small piece of iron as though it had somehow become a considerably more important object than the one which had failed him half an hour before.

 

"All that for a cart-pin?"

 

Thorin frowned slightly, and Bilbo could tell that the Dwarf genuinely did not understand the question.

 

"It still has to hold the wheel."

 

"Aye." the smith agreed with a deep smile. "That it does."

 

He handed the pin to Hamfast.

 

"Keep that one. You'll wear through the cart before you wear through that pin."

 

Hamfast looked from the pin to Thorin with considerably more respect than he had possessed half an hour earlier.

 

Behind them, one of the apple-carrying lads whispered something to his companion, though Bilbo heard only the answer.

 

"Well, he is a Dwarf."

 

There was something different in the way it was said now.

 

The four of them returned to Hamfast's cart, where Thorin insisted upon fitting thenew himself. Bilbo, who had spent the last half-hour rather nearer a forge than was sensible in late summer, discovered a black streak had appeared upon the front of his waistcoat.

 

"Oh, bother."

 

Drogo looked over.

 

"What now?"

 

Bilbo brushed at the mark.

 

Instead of vanishing, it spread.

 

"This was clean when I left the house." he complained, pulling the front of the waistcoat outward in a vain attempt to inspect the damage properly.

 

"It isn't even noticeable." said Drogo.

 

"It is plainly noticeable."

 

"Only because you know it's there.

 

"Everyone will know it's there! It is directly in the middle."

 

Hamfast, who was holding the wheel steady while Thorin fitted the pin, glanced politely away from the dispute.

 

"You could turn it inside out" Drogo suggested.

 

Bilbo glared at him.

 

"What a splendid idea, to wear my waistcoat inside out at the fair!"

 

"It would give them something new to talk about."

 

"They have more than enough."

 

"Anyone looking at you has better things to admire than the waistcoat." said Thorin.

 

The sentence entered the conversation as easily as any other.

 

Then it seemed to encounter something in the air and stop.

 

Bilbo's fingers remained pinched around the offending fabric.

 

Drogo's eyebrows rose.

 

Hamfast looked at Thorin, then at Bilbo, and with the swift instinct of a well-bred hobbit discovered an urgent interest in the wheel.

 

Thorin had gone perfectly still.

 

Only for a heartbeat. Only long enough for Bilbo to know that he had heard his own words at precisely the same moment everyone else had. 

 

Then Thorin lowered his eyes to the fastening.

 

Bilbo could feel the heat rising from his collar until it reached the tips of his ears. He released the waistcoat. 

 

Beside him Drogo had acquired the expression of a hobbit upon whom providence had bestowed a magnificent gift and who was struggling, at considerable personal cost, not to unwrap it in company.

 

Thorin tightened the fastening.

 

"There." he said in quite a steady voice as he rose.

 

Hamfast tested the wheel, perhaps more thoroughly than necessary.

 

"That's- yes. That's grand, sir. Better than grand. Thank you!"

 

"It was a small repair."

 

"Not if I'd had to get the cart home without it."

 

Thorin seemed prepared to dismiss this, as was his habit whenever gratitued exceeded what he considered the proper measure of the deed. Then his gaze went briefly to the repaired wheel, and something in his expression softened.

 

"You are welcome."

 

Hamfast held out his hand, and Thorin took it.

 

"If ever Father's goose gets into your garden again, Mr. Baggins," Hamfast said, turning to Bilbo, "send for me."

 

"I shall hold you to that."

 

They parted there. Hamfast went away with his cart rolling obediently, and from across the lane the Bywater smith lifted one blackened hand towards Thorin. Thorin returned the gesture.

 

Then the fair closed around them once more.

 

Children ran past trailing ribbons. Somewhere a woman called that the pies were half-price. The badly played fiddle had acquired a companion and become, against all expectation, worse. The smell of apples and warm pastry returned where coal-smoke had been, and Hobbiton went about its afternoon as though nothing of consequence had occurred.

 

Bilbo adjusted his waistcoat.

 

Drogo saw him do it.

 

"Not one word." Bilbo said, pointing a warning finger at him.

 

"I was merely thinking."

 

"Don't."

 

Thorin cleared his throat, causing Bilbo's heart to give a thoroughly unnecessary leap.

 

"I believe," Thorin said, with great dignity. "you intended to show me where the better honey was sold."

 

Bilbo looked at him.

 

Thorin met his eyes.

 

There was the faintest colour high upon his cheekbones. It was entirely possible that this was merely the heat of the forge.

 

Bilbo seized upon this explanation with the enthusiasm of a drowning hobbit finding a branch.

 

"Yes." Bilbo said. "I did."

 

And so they went.

 

The honey had not sold out. Neither had the seed-cake. Bilbo bought both, along with apples he did not need because an apple-tree stood perfectly healthy in his own garden, and a small jar of mustard which he insisted could not be got elsewhere, despite Drogo maintaining that he had seen precisely the same mustard in Bywater the week before.

 

People continued to look at Thorin.

 

Mrs. Bracegirdle looked twice.

 

A child followed them for nearly the length of the field before being retrieved by an embarrassed father. One old hobbit asked Bilbo, in a voice that carried remarkably far, whether Dwarves ate mushrooms, and appeared gently relieved when Thorin assured him that they did.

 

Nothing had greatly changed.

 

The sun had begun its descent towards the western fields, laying long bars of gold between the stalls and setting the upper leaves of the hill aglow. Soon awnings would be folded, baskets stacked and the last cakes sold cheaply rather than carried home. Carts would rattle away lighter than they had come, children would be gathered unwillingly from the grass, and another summer would begin quietly putting away its things.

 

Drogo left them near the lane with a paper parcel of cakes beneath his arm and the expression of a hobbit who possessed information of enormous value and had, through heroic restraint, chosen not to make use of it.

 

Bilbo watched him go.

 

"I shall regret introducing you."

 

"I liked him."

 

"That is precisely the difficulty."

 

They walked on.

 

For several paces neither spoke, and the silence between them was not uncomfortable exactly. Bilboo rather wished that it were. An uncomfortable silence could be attacked. One could complain about it, fill it with remarks about supper, or point out that the road required attention.

 

The silence merely walked beside them.

 

So did Thorin.

 

Bilbo was acutely aware of both.

 

He became, in consequence, acutely aware of his waistcoat as well, and glanced down at the black mark still staining its front.

 

Thorin's gaze followed his.

 

Bilbo looked forward at once.

 

Neither said anything.

 

Behind them the two fiddles struck up another tune - or at least appeared to agree that this was what they were doing - and somewhere across the field a goose began to shout with great indignation at the ending of the day.

 

Bilbo decided, without looking back, that it was almost certainly not the same one.

❦

Chapter 28: ❦ Of Certainty and Change

Chapter Text

❦

There are few sounds more alarming in a quiet hobbit-hole than the breaking of porcelain.

 

Bilbo had been walking down the passage with a cup of tea balanced comfortably in one hand, thinking with great seriousness about whether the remains of seed-cake might be improved by toasting, when his eye caught the open door of the guest-room as he passed.

 

The cup had slipped from his fingers and shattered upon the floor with a crack so sharp that, for one strange instant, the sound seemed to travel through every tunnel and chamber beneath the Hill. White china scattered over the dark boards while tea ran in a thin brown sheet towards the skirting, and Bilbo stood above the wreckage without moving, as though the disaster at his feet required some explanation which had not yet reached him.

 

Thorin turned.

 

Bilbo did not look at him.

 

His gaze was fixed on what stood behind the dwarf.

 

Beyond Thorin, a travelling pack stod open and Bilbo's eye moved unwillingly from it to the things gathered around it - the folded cloak, the spare shirt, the whetstone, the comb, the leather roll of tools. None of them ought to have mattered. They were only belongings, after all, and not even many of them, yet seeing them assembled there gave the room the peculiar look of a place already beginning to forget its occupant.

 

It was astonishing how much presence could be measured by absence. A pipe removed from a table. Boots no longer beneath the bed. A coat gone from its hook. Over the past weeks Thorin had quietly taken root in Bag End without seeming to do anything so presumptuous as unpacking his life, and Bilbo had become accustomed to those little signs as one becomes accustomed to bird song outside an open window - only when it ceased did one understand how much silence had always waited beneath it.

 

Bilbo had always known Thorin would leave. He had arrived in the Shire with the road still clinging to him, after all, and there had never been any promise that Bag End was more than a stopping-place. In the first few days Bilbo had been perfectly sensible about this. Thorin would stay a little while, they would talk, eat, perhaps walk into Hobbiton, and then one morning there would be a pack at the door again.

 

Only the mornings had kept passing without it. Somewhere in the comfortable repetition of breakfast cups, coffee, boots in the passage and another voice answering from down the hall, Bilbo had ceased to picture the part where the repetition ended.

 

Bilbo had simply become very accomplished at refusing to look in its direction.

 

Apparently tomorrow had looked back.

 

"Bilbo?"

 

Thorin's voice reached him gently.

 

Bilbo blinked.

 

"Damn."

 

He crouched at once and began gathering the broken pieces.

 

Thorin crossed the room in two strides.

 

"Leave it."

 

"It is not the first cup I have broken."

 

"So I can see."

 

"There is no need to sound quite so pleased about it."

 

"I am not pleased, I am concerned you may cut your hand."

 

Bilbo ignored him and and reached for the largest fragment, promptly catching his thumb upon the sharp edge.

 

Thorin made a dissatisfied sound which somehow managed to contain both concern and vindication.

 

Bilbo put the piece down with exaggerated dignity.

 

"There is something deeply unpleasant about how much you enjoy being right."

 

"I said nothing."

 

"You made a noise."

 

"It was a deserved noise."

 

Bilbo glared at him, fetched the dustpan, and returned before Thorin could take over the task entirely. He swept the fragments together with the grim concentration of someone attempting to defeat an enemy army by means of a household brush.

 

"You're packing."

 

Thorin glanced back towards the bed.

 

"Yes."

 

Bilbo pushed another painted shard into the pan.

 

"When?"

 

"Tomorrow morning."

 

Bilbo's brush paused against the rug, but only for a moment before he forced it onwards.

 

"Tomorrow."

 

"Yes."

 

"And where are you going?"

 

Thorin considered the question with an aggravating seriousness, as though the answer concerned some distant road rather than the sudden absence opening at Bilbo's feet.

 

"I have not decided."

 

Bilbo looked up.

 

"You have not decided."

 

"No."

 

"But you are leaving."

 

A faint crease appeared between Thorin's brows.

 

"Yes."

 

Bilbo returned his attention to the floor.

 

There was something almost offensive in the vagueness of it. Had Thorin said Rivendell, Bilbo might have resented the Elves. Had he said Dale, there would at least have been mountains enough to blame. But there was no destination, only departure itself. An empty room waiting patiently at the end of a sentence Bilbo had refused to finish reading.

 

He gathered the last fragments, carried them to the kitchen, and tipped them into the bin with rather more force than china deserved.

 

When he turned around, Thorin had followed.

 

Naturally.

 

"You might have mentioned it."

 

Thorin looked honestly puzzled.

 

"I was intending to."

 

"Well," said Bilbo, seizing a cloth from beside the sink, "congratulations upon your impeccable timing."

 

He marched back towards the passage and knelt upon the rug where the tea had spilled.

 

Thorin remained standing nearby.

 

For a little while only the sound of Bilbo blotting tea from wool filled the silence. 

 

Then Thorin spoke.

 

"I have remained longer than I intended."

 

The cloth stopped moving.

 

Thorin continued quietly, choosing his words with the grave care Bilbo remembered from the Quest.

 

"I came without invitation. You offered me your home, your table, and every comfort a wanderer might hope to find. It would not be right to presume upon such kindness merely because I have found it difficult to leave."

 

Bilbo's fingers tightened around the damp cloth. Kindness. Generosity. Hospitality. Thorin offered the words like polished silver, honourable and bright and entirely incapable of holding any warmth.

 

Bilbo rose.

 

"You are not imposing upon me."

 

"I did not say-"

 

"You were about to."

 

"I said only that i ought not take advantage of the hospitality of a friend."

 

A friend. 

 

Bilbo looked away.

 

Friend had once been one of the safest words he possessed, broad enough to shelter every affection he dared not name and sturdy enough to survive both distance and silence.

 

Yet now, with Thorin's belongings gathered upon the bed and tomorrow suddenly sharpened into a real thing, the word seemed to shrink around him and restrict him until there was scarcely room enough to breathe.

 

"You are not taking advantage of anything." he repeated.

 

Silence stretched until Bilbo dared to look. Recognition had entered Thorin's eyes - not complete understanding, perhaps, but enough. Enough that Bilbo felt something inside himself finally surrender.

 

"You do not want me to leave." Thorin observed with an unreadable expression.

 

For a heartbeat Bilbo stood perfectly still.

 

There were answers waiting. Respectable answers. He would miss Thorin's company. Bag End would be quieter. One always disliked saying farewell to an old companion.

 

All true.

 

None large enough.

 

"No."

 

The word scarcely disturbet the air.

 

When he turned, Thorin had not moved.

 

Something uncertain had entered his face - not hope exactly, for Thorin had never been foolish enough to leap before certainty, but the first pale light before dawn.

 

"Then why have you never said so?" he asked gently.

 

Bilbo laughed.

 

It escaped him without humour.

 

"What precisely was I supposed to say?"

 

"The truth."

 

"Oh, splendid." Bilbo threw the cloth onto the counter. "Why did I never think of that?"

 

Thorin took a step nearer.

 

"Bilbo."

 

There was something in the way he said the name which made all further attempts at evading the topic feel suddenly childish.

 

Bilbo looked down.

 

"There are some things, Thorin," he said quietly. "which are better left unsaid."

 

Thorin regarded him in silence, and the room seemed to quiet around that look until Bilbo could hear the faint tick of the clock beyond the passage and a bee blundering against the lavender outside. Thorin had always possessed an alarming talent for waiting longer than Bilbo could comfortably endure.

 

At last Thorin asked him the one simple question Bilbo was absolutely dreading.

 

"Why?"

 

Bilbo closed his eyes.

 

There were days when Thorin's persistence reminded him of an oak-root splitting stone. Patient. Silent. Entirely incapable of understanding that some walls had been built precisely because someone wished to remain on the other side.

 

He opened his eyes again.

 

"Because I happen to value your friendship more than I value the satisfaction of saying every damned thing that enters my head."

 

The words seemed to ring louder than the cup had.

 

Silence stretched

 

When Bilbo at last dared to look, he saw recognition had entered Thorin's eyes. Not complete understanding, just enough. Enough that Bilbo felt something inside himself finally surrender.

 

He smiled faintly, though it hurt.

 

"I should have thought it obvious by now."

 

"Bilbo-"

 

"If you wish to leave, I understand."

 

Thorin stepped forward.

 

Bilbo shook his head before he could speak again.

 

"No. You wanted honesty. There it is." he drew a breath, and it trembled despite his best efforts. "I think the world of you, you impossible creature, and I am not prepared to risk-"

 

Before Bilbo could finish, Thorin kissed him.

 

For half a heartbeat Bilbo forgot how the world worked at all - seven years of certainty broke apart so swiftly that he could almost have heard it, like ice giving way beneath sudden spring water. Thorin's hand was warm at the back of his neck, his mouth firm against Bilbo's, and there was nothing in the gesture which could be folded back into friendship afterwards.

 

There was nothing measured in the kiss.

 

No caution, no hesitant question seeking permission after the fact. It carried all the bewildered force of a river finally breaking through the bank which had contained it for too long. Bilbo felt himself stumble forward into it before thought could intervene.

 

Then his hand seized the hem of Thorin's shirt.

 

He kissed him back.

 

Beard brushed his cheek. Their noses collided inelegantly. Thorin's other arm came around Bilbo's waist with such instinctive certainty that Bilbo forgot entirely which one of them had begun it. He had imagined kissing Thorin before, of course had. Lonely hearts were imaginative creatures, after all.

 

Reality was much less graceful.

 

And infinitely more wonderful.

 

When they parted, neither seemed willing to travel very far. Their breathing mingled in the narrow space between them. Thorin smiled first. It was small and almost disbelieving.

 

"I had not intended to do that."

 

Bilbo's heart promptly plummeted through the floor.

 

His fingers released the shirt at once.

 

Of course.

 

Of course the moment had simply overtaken Thorin. A foolish impulse. A tenderness misplaced. Bilbo. began speaking before dignity could gather its belongings.

 

"Well, naturally, one cannot always be expected to account for every moment of temporary insanity, and I assure you I have no intention of making this unnecessarily awkward. I can still be a perfectly good and loyal friend, and I shall certainly not-"

 

"Bilbo."

 

"-overstep again, because goodness knows I have managed perfectly well for years and there is absolutely no reason-"

 

"Bilbo."

 

He stopped.

 

Thorin's thumb had found the inside of his wrist.

 

"I do not regret it."

 

The words entered quietly.

 

Bilbo stared.

 

"I said," Thorin continued. "that I had not intended it, at least not like this. I did not say I wished it undone."

 

For perhaps the first time in his life Bilbo Baggins found himself entirely without language.

 

"Oh." he managed eventually.

 

Thorin laughed under his breath.

 

Bilbo glared.

 

"Don't become accustomed to that."

 

"To what?"

 

"Winning arguments."

 

"I believe you interrupted yours with kissing."

 

"That was your doing."

 

"I seem to recall considerable assistance."

 

Bilbo tried very hard to remain offended, but failed almost immediately.

 

The smile upon Thorin's face faded into something gentler.

 

"I was packing because I thought I ought to leave." he said. "Not because I wished to."

 

Bilbo glanced past him towards the open doorway.

 

The abandoned pack seemed suddenly to belong to another afternoon entirely.

 

"I thought your kindness was simply kindness." Thorin went on. "That you welcomed me because I was your friend, and that remaining beneath your roof while wanting more than friendship was a selfishness I had no wish to indulge."

 

Bilbo listened.

 

It was strangely moving to discover that while he had spent days fearing departure, Thorin had spent those same days fearing himself.

 

"I thought," Thorin said more quietly, "that if I stayed much longer, I would ruin what we had."

 

Bilbo considered this gravely, before a smile broke out across his face.

 

"You nearly did." he said with a great grin.

 

Thorin's brows rose.

 

Bilbo caught the front of his shirt again.

 

"Come here."

 

The second kiss was softer.

 

The first had been thunder. This was rain afterwards, falling steadily over thirsty earth.

 

Thorin's palm cupped Bilbo's cheek as though memorising it. Bilbo loosened his fist in the linen but did not let go entirely. Their lips met once, parted, and returned with a tenderness almost more frightening than passion, because tenderness suggested mornings. It suggested ordinary things. It suggested there might be time enough to learn one another without fear.

 

When they drew apart, Bilbo remained close.

 

"I knew you loved me."

 

Thorin went still.

 

Bilbo, intent upon explaining rather than confessing, scarcely noticed.

 

"During the Quest, I mean. Afterwards too." He smiled faintly. "I never thought otherwise. Only, it was not the same way that I loved you."

 

There.

 

The word had escaped so naturally that Bilbo almost continued speaking before he understood what he had done.

 

Thorin understood perfectly.

 

His expression brightened with such quiet delight that Bilbo immediately narrowed his eyes.

 

"Oh, do not."

 

"I have said nothing, I am merely listening."

 

"With your entire face."

 

Thorin's smile deepened.

 

Bilbo sighed dramatically and continued before he could lose courage.

 

"I believed you loved me as your friend. Perhaps as something akin to family, after all we endured together. I knew I mattered to you." his fingers traced an idle crease in Thorin's shirt. "That was enough."

 

He looked down.

 

"At first I thought what I felt would pass when I came home. It seemed reasonable. Everything during the Quest had been enormous - dragons, goblins, mountains, death. One might easily mistake a heart carried through such things for something grander than it truly was."

 

"And did it pass?"

 

"Obviously not." Bilbo responded, gesturing between them before looking down again. "It simply learned to live quietly."

 

"There are worse things," he said softly. "than loving someone who loves you differently."

 

Thorin looked at him for a long while.

 

"And that truly became enough?"

 

Bilbo considered.

 

"I have not lived in misery since leaving Erebor, if that's what you're asking. With time, I found a certain comfort in my affection that did not demand reward simply because it had become part of me. Longing became kin to nostalgia over the years. It had to."

 

Bilbo squeezed his hand.

 

"And when did you know?" he then asked. "Was it only after you came here?"

 

Thorin did not answer at once. His eyes had gone somewhere beyond the room, following a road Bilbo could not see.

 

"I have been trying to answer that myself."

 

Bilbo waited.

 

"There are things I remember differently now." Thorin's thumb moved absently across the back of Bilbo's hand. "I remember looking for you when we made camp. I remember knowing your step behind me before i knew half the Company's. In Mirkwood, when I could not see you, I knew precisely how long it had been since I had heard your voice."

 

Bilbo's heart gave a small, painful turn.

 

Thorin frowned, not at him but at the memory.

 

"None of it seemed remarkable to me then."

 

That, more than anything he might have said, hurt.

 

Not cruelly. It was the ache of finding an old letter years too late and discovering that the answer had been written upon it all along.

 

"And afterwards?" Bilbo asked.

 

"Afterwards I missed you."

 

"Well, I should certainly hope so."

 

A faint smile touched Thorin's lips.

 

"I told myself it was because you were my friend."

 

"And the letters?"

 

"I wished to hear from my friend."

 

Bilbo's smile began despite himself.

 

"And crossing half the world in roughly my direction?"

 

Thorin gave him a look.

 

"By then I had ceased believing myself."

 

Bilbo laughed, and Thorin did too, though more quietly. There was something wonderfully absurd about it when laid out in such a fashion - all those miles of solemn wandering, all those carefully reasoned letters, while somewhere beneath the whole business Thorin Oakenshield had apparently been making his way towards Bag End with the stubbornness of a migrating bird and rather less understanding of what compelled him.

 

It was a strange thing, to be handed one's own past again with some secret writing now made visible upon it.

 

Bilbo wondered, suddenly and unwisely, what might have happened if Thorin had understood himself during the Quest - upon some cold night beneath the stars, or in Beorn's hall, or during those strange peaceful days in the early parts of the journey before the Mountain had risen before them and swallowed everything else.

 

It was a useless thought. Roads looked very different when viewed from their ending.

 

Still, for one moment, Bilbo mourned a happiness neither of them had known enough to miss.

 

"You were very certain of yourself in those days" he said.

 

Thorin's mouth curved faintly.

 

"About many things."

 

There was enough ruefulness in it to make Bilbo smile.

 

Then Thorin's thumb stopped moving.

 

Bilbo noticed because his own hand had grown accustomed to the motion.

 

Thorin was looking down at their joined hands, but the faint smile had gone from his face. Something had closed behind his eyes so quietly that Bilbo could not have said when it happened. A moment ago they had been wandering together through old memories as one might walk an abandoned road in summer, finding flowers grown over the ruts and laughing at how steep the hills had once seemed. Thorin, it appeared, had reached a place where nothing grew.

 

Bilbo waited.

 

Thorin let go of his hand.

 

He crossed the few steps to the bed, though there was nothing there he seemed to want. For a moment he stood before the half-packed bag, one hand resting upon its open flap. The room had grown very quiet. Even the ordinary sounds of Bag End, like the clock somewhere down the passage and the faint rustle from the garden beyond the window, seemed suddenly to belong on the other side of a great distance.

 

Bilbo's happiness did not vanish. It drew upon itself, like a flame when a door is opened upon winter.

 

"Thorin?"

 

Thorin sat down upon the edge of the bed.

 

Bilbo watched his hands come together between his knees. 

 

Only then did he understand that whatever Thorin was seeing, it was no longer a camp beneath the stars.

 

When he spoke, all the softness had gone from his voice.

 

"I tried to kill you."

 

There was no need to say where.

 

The Mountain entered the room between them.

 

Bilbo remembered the cold before he remembered anything else - cold stone beneath his feet, cold air against his face, and Thorin's eyes stranger than any dragon's treasure had ever made them. For seven years the memory had faded at its edges, as memories mercifully do, but it had never disappeared. Some things did not need to be often visited to remain exactly where one had left them.

 

He crossed the room and sat beside Thorin.

 

"Yes." he said.

 

Thorin flinched.

 

Only slightly, but Bilbo saw it.

 

He had not softened the answer. He would not. Whatever forgiveness was worth between them depended upon neither pretending there had been nothing to forgive.

 

For a while Thorin said nothing. His gaze remained upon his hands.

 

"I remember your face."

 

Bilbo's throat tightened.

 

"I know."

 

"I remember what I called you. I remember believing it." Thorin swallowed. "And now you tell me that even then-"

 

He stopped.

 

That was when Bilbo understood.

 

It was not merely the old guilt returning.

 

They had spent the last several minutes uncovering the possibility that this thing between them had roots reaching all the way back to the Quest. Bilbo had looked upon that discovery and seen lost years, certainly, but also something tender - proof that perhaps he had not been quite so alone beneath those distant stars as he had believed.

 

Thorin had followed the same roots backwards and found them running beneath the wall of Erebor.

 

The happiness of a moment before had not been false. That almost made it worse.

 

Bilbo reached for his hand again.

 

Thorin looked at it before allowing their fingers to close.

 

"I forgave you." Bilbo said

 

The words did not seem to bring Thorin any comfort. If anything, his face tightened.

 

"I do not know how you could."

 

"Well, fortunately, I did not require your assistance."

 

Thorin looked at him then, and Bilbo saw at once the attempt at lightness had come too soon. The old pain remained too near the surface for teasing to find purchase upon it.

 

Bilbo's thumb moved slowly across Thorin's knuckles.

 

"I am not saying it did not matter."

 

"I know."

 

"No." Bilbo waited until Thorin met his eyes again. "I don't think you do."

 

The afternoon light had shifted while they spoke. It no longer lay golden across the room but had climbed halfway up the opposite wall, leaving the floorboards in the first grey-blue hint of evening. Thorin's face had fallen partly into shadow.

 

"You frightened me." Bilbo said. "More than the goblins did, I think. More than the spiders. Perhaps even more than Smaug."

 

Nothing moved in Thorin's expression.

 

Bilbo went on more softly.

 

"Because I knew what all of those things were."

 

Thorin's eyes closed.

 

Bilbo let the silence remain. There were hurts which became smaller when spoken of, and others which deserved the dignity of not being hurried towards a pleasant conclusion. He had no wish to make that day beneath the Mountain harmless merely because they were sitting now beneath a gentler hill.

 

"I looked at you," he said at last. "and for a little while I could not find you."

 

Thorin bowed his head.

 

Bilbo's hand tightened around his.

 

"But I did."

 

Thorin opened his eyes.

 

"Not upon the wall. Not all at once." Bilbo looked down at their joined hands. Thorin's was broad and scarred, the same hand which had once gripped a sword in anger and had, a little over a week ago, shaped a bit of iron for a hobbit's cart. "Afterwards."

 

The word opened years between them.

 

Bilbo thought of letters arriving beneath the round green door. Of Thorin laying aside a crown. Of roads travelled without armies behind him or kingdoms waiting at their end. Of a Dwarf standing at a little forge and treating a farmer's broken linchpin as though its usefulness were reason enough to make it well.

 

There had been no single moment in which Thorin became worthy of forgiveness. Bilbo would have distrusted such a thing if there had been. Mountains changed by inches - frost in their cracks, rain upon their slopes, roots finding patient purchase where stone had seemed impenetrable. One might look away for years and return to find the same mountain beneath the sky, yet discover that its whole face had altered.

 

"You have spent a very long time answering for what happened." Bilbo said.

 

"Not to you."

 

"Especially to me."

 

Thorin frowned.

 

Bilbo almost smiled, but this time he kept it small.

 

"You think an apology is the only answer a person can give.

 

"What other answer is there?"

 

"The life he lives afterwards."

 

That silenced him.

 

Bilbo did not fill the quiet. He could see Thorin turning the words over with the same grave attention he gave anything he did not immediately accept.

 

At length Thorin shook his head.

 

"That does not undo it."

 

"No."

 

"I cannot become a man who never stood upon that wall."

 

"No."

 

"And you would have me simply forgive him?"

 

There it was - the old mercilessness, turned inward now. Thorin had once demanded impossible payment from the world. He had become gentler with nearly everyone except himself.

 

Bilbo shifted upon the bed until he was facing him properly.

 

"I would have you stop deciding whether I am allowed to."

 

Thorin stared at him.

 

Bilbo held his gaze.

 

"You may regret it until the end of your days if you must. I cannot prevent you, though I reserve the right to complain about it when you become particularly tiresome." his fingers tightened around Thorin's. "But my forgiveness belongs to me. You do not get to refuse it on my behalf."

 

For the first time something in Thorin's expression gave way.

 

Not dramatically. Thorin had never been a man whose deepest hurts departed with convenient tears and declarations. It was smaller than that - the hard line of his mouth loosened, and his shoulders lowered by some fraction Bilbo might not have noticed had he not spent so many years remembering them.

 

"I do not know what to do with that." Thorin's voice came out almost like a whisper.

 

Bilbo's heart ached.

 

"You needn't do anything with it tonight."

 

Thorin looked at him.

 

"Keep it somewhere inconvenient, if you like. Dwarves seem fond of storing precious things in mountains."

 

A breath escaped Thorin which might, in kinder circumstances, have become a laugh.

 

Bilbo felt the first small loosening in his own chest.

 

"There." he murmured. "That's better."

 

"I did not laugh."

 

"You very nearly did."

 

"I breathed."

 

"In a suspiciously cheerful manner."

 

That earned him the faintest movement at the corner of THorin's mouth, but it vanished almost at once.

 

Bilbo did not chase it.

 

Instead he shifted nearer until their shoulders touched.

 

For a while that was all.

 

Outside the window, the evening had deepened. A blackbird called somewhere in the garden, then another answered farther down the Hill. The clock in the passage ticked steadily onwards, indifferent to mountains and dragons and seven lost years. Bag End gathered its familiar shadows around them.

 

Thorin's hand remained in Bilbo's.

 

Eventually his grip loosened.

 

Then his shoulder leaned, almost imperceptibly, against Bilbo's.

 

Bilbo stayed still.

 

A little more weight followed.

 

At last Thorin bowed his head and rested it against Bilbo's shoulder.

 

Something in Bilbo's chest broke open then, but gently this time.

 

He lifted an arm and put it around Thorin.

 

There was no triumph in the gesture, no sense that some old wound had at last been healed and neatly put away. The Mountain remained behind them. It always would. But memory was a country large enough to contain more than one thing, and here, now, Thorin's silvering head rested beneath Bilbo's cheek while their hands lay joined between them.

 

Bilbo rubbed his thumb once over Thorin's shoulder.

 

Thorin exhaled.

 

THe sound was long and tired, like wind leaving a house after rattling all night at its shutters.

 

Neither spoke.

 

Slowly the room became Bag End again.

 

The cold stone beneath Bilbo's memory gave way to a mattress beneath his legs. The remembered winter air became the faint evening breeze slipping through the open window. Somewhere in the kitchen sat the remains of a seed-cake which Bilbo had intended, what seemed several lifetimes ago, to consider toasting.

 

His eyes wandered towards the pack.

 

It still stood open.

 

For the first time since seeing it, Bilbo did not feel the same terrible drop beneath his ribs.

 

Beside him Thorin stirred.

 

"I have made rather a disaster of this afternoon." Thorin stated with a sigh.

 

Bilbo considered the broken cup, the confession, the kisses, the attempted departure, the resurrection of one of the worst memories of his life, and Thorin presently folded against his side.

 

"I have had worse."

 

Thorin's quiet laugh warmed Bilbo's shoulder.

 

It was not happiness returned whole, as though nothing dark had passed between them. Something better, perhaps - happiness which had gone down into the dark with them and come back carrying it.

 

Bilbo rested his cheek against Thorin's hair.

 

For some time they simply sat there.

 

The open pack waited patiently upon the floor.

 

Somewhere beyond the Hill a blackbird began singing its evening song, each clear note rising through the golden quiet of the Shire.

 

After a while, Thorin's thumb began making calm, absent-minded patterns on Bilbo's hand once more.

 

Bilbo became aware that he was smiling from ear to ear.

 

Thorin, judging by the faint movement of his cheek against Bilbo's shoulder, was suffering from precisely the same affliction.

 

"You're grinning."

 

"So are you."

 

Bilbo laughed softly.

 

After a while his gaze drifted once more towards the half-packed belongings.

 

"You know," he said. "for all your solemn speeches about hospitality, I think you've misunderstood Bag End entirely if you believe yourself to be a mere guest beneath this roof."

 

For a moment Thorin said nothing.

 

His eyes travelled over the folded cloak, the travelling pack, the little gathered pieces of a wandering life. Then they returned to Bilbo, and something in them became wonderfully still.

 

Not uncertainty.

 

Recognition.

 

Like a traveller reaching the crest of a hill and seeing, at last, the chimney smoke he had spent years searching for without knowing its location.

 

"I believe," Thorin said quietly. "my wandering days are over."

 

Bilbo forgot to breathe.


Thorin smiled then - not as a king, nor as the stern leader Bilbo had first met quite unexpectedly years ago, but simply as himself.

 

"If you will have me."

 

Bilbo stared at him.

 

Then every careful defence he had ever constructed surrendered at once.

 

"Oh, you impossible creature!"

 

He caught Thorin's face between both hands and pressed their lips together.

 

Thorin laughed against his mouth before returning the kiss, and somehow the laughter became kisses and kisses became the two of them tumbling backwards on the bed with considerably less elegance than either might later claim. The folded cloak survived. The pack did not protest.

 

Bilbo's fingers disappeared into silver hair while Thorin held him as though the whole wide world had finally ceased insisting they stand apart.

 

Outside, evening gathered over the Shire without ceremony. Smoke rose straight from the chimneys of Hobbiton before the cooling air bent it westward. The water slipped beneath its bridges, windows brightened one by one, and somewhere beyond the Hill a gate banged shut before supper. From the lane, Bag End would have looked exactly as it had that morning, its round windows glowing beneath the turf and its green door closed against the dusk.

 

By morning the broken cup would still be broken, the Hill would still be green, and the road would still run beyond Hobbiton. The kettle would require filling, breakfast would require making, and Thorin's boots would still be where Bilbo had grown accustomed to finding them.

 

Tomorrow, Bilbo thought, might come when it pleased.

❦

Chapter 29: ❦ Of Writing in the Garden

Notes:

releasing the last two chapters together, hell yeah.

Chapter Text

❦

Autumn had not yet properly come to the Shire, but it had begun sending notices ahead of itself.

 

There were yellow leaves in the hedge beside Bag End where there had been none upon Thorin's arrival, and beneath the apple-tree the grass had acquired three windfalls which Bilbo had declared perfectly good despite the bruising. The bean-poles stood nearly bare now. Most of the onions had been lifted and laid out to dry, the potatoes had left dark hollows in the earth, and one enormous marrow remained beneath its leaves with the complacent air of something which had escaped notice and intended to continue doing so.

 

Primula Brandybuck had taken most of the beans.

 

Bilbo's young cousin had come to help with the picking two morenings earlier and departed with a basket so heavily laden with vegetables that Thorin had carried it as far as the lane despite her increasingly indignant objections. Primula, he had discovered, bore being ignored remarkably badly.

 

He liked her.

 

Bilbo had watched the argument from the garden gate with his arms folded and an expression of such unconcealed amusement that Thorin had found himself prolonging it.

 

Thorin sat beneath the apple-tree with a sheet of parchment resting upon a board across his knees. His sleeves were rolled above his elbows, his hair tied loosely away from his face, and the pleasant weariness of a day's work had settled heavily through his shoulders.

 

He had washed before coming up the Hill. At least, he had washed sufficiently by his own estimation. There was still pale mortar in the creases of one hand and a streak of soot near his elbow, while his shirt clung damply between his shoulder-blades. A shallow scrape crossed one knuckle where a stone had shifted while he was setting it.

 

The forge was beginning to look like a forge.

 

That pleased him enormously.

 

Yesterday it had possessed three walls, half a chimney and a roof which existed chiefly as timber stacked upon the ground. Today the chimney stood another four courses higher, the stone around the hearth was finished, and two roof-beams were where Thorin intended them to remain for considerably longer than he himself expected to live.

 

They were somewhat heavier than necessary.

 

Bilbo had pointed this out.

 

Thorin had pointed out that the roof would therefore not fall down.

 

Bilbo had replied that most roofs achieved this distinction without being prepared to withstand a siege.

 

Thorin saw no fault in being certain.

 

Hobson Tunnelly, the Bywater smith whose name Thorin had finally learnt, had come by that afternoon with a keg of nails he claimed to have no present use for. Thorin had not insulted either of them by questioning this explanation. Hobson had only meant to look at the work and had somehow remained for the better part of an hour, talking over the hearth, the chimney, and the placement of the anvil while lending a hand here and there when one was useful.

 

Hobson knew his craft well, though differently from Thorin. He knew the needs of this country - which hinges would be mistreated, which cart-parts would fail first, which farmers would arrive insisting that a breakage had occurred entirely on its own. Thorin had found himself listening.

 

Thorin hoped he would come again.

 

The thought surprised him only because he could not remember the last time he had made a friend without war, exile, kinship or necessity having anything to do with it.

 

He smiled at the recollection and dipped his pen.

 

The letter had not progressed as quickly as he had expected.

 

There was no shortage of things to tell, and perhaps that was the difficulty.

 

Thorin looked down at the last unfinished line, then out across the Hill.

 

Below the garden wall, the Hill rolled gently towards Hobbiton. Smoke climbed lazily from the chimneys, and somewhere near the water a dog was barking with tremendous conviction at something which did not appear to be answering. A cart moved along the road towards Bywater, small at thsi distance, its driver raising one hand to another hobbit coming the opposite way.

 

Thorin watched until the hedge hid them.

 

Then he bent over the parchment and wrote.

 

A breeze stirred the apple-tree above him. One of the yellow leaves came spinning down and settled squarely across the wet line of ink.


Thorin stared at it.

 

"You have poor timing." he informed the leaf.

 

It remained unapologetic.

 

He lifted it carefully by the stem and laid it beside him to dry.

 

His hands were sore. He became aware of it when he shifted the pen between his fingers, and the muscles of his forearm protested. It was a satisfying soreness. Tomorrow there would be another roof-beam to raise. After that the floor, and then the bellows.

 

There was already a ploughshare waiting once the hearth was lit, and a farmer farther along the water had sent word about a kettle whose handle had come loose.

 

Once Thorin had lain awake thinking of armies.

 

Now he was looking forward to a kettle.

 

The wants came easily now.

 

Thorin closed his eyes for a moment and listened to the leaves moving overhead.

 

From somewhere inside Bag End came the muffled closing of a cupboard.

 

His eyes opened.

 

Bilbo had been in and out of the garden for much of the afternoon. Thorin had watched him without pretending otherwise.

 

That, too, was something he was growing accustomed to.

 

He liked the copper sun found in Bilbo's curls, the quick movement of his hands when he talked, the small lines beside his eyes. Lately he had discovered other things - the warmth of Bilbo's body beside his own before the fire, the soft weight of him when he leaned against Thorin to read, and the particular shape his waist made beneath Thorin's hand.

 

These were not observations Thorin had any intention of defending.

 

Thorin's gaze drifted towards the kitchen window.

 

He had spent seven years finding other names for things which, in retrospect, had required very little naming at all.

 

There had always been a reason.

 

Bilbo had been inexperienced, and Thorin had therefore watched for him upon the road. A leader ought to know the habits of his Company - naturally he had learned Bilbo's step. In Mirkwood, losing sight of anyone might mean losing them altogether. Afterwards, Bilbo's letters mattered because Bilbo was his friend, and Thorin missed his friend.

 

Thorin still thought these excellent reasons.

 

That was the troublesome thing. They had always been true.

 

He had never needed to lie to himself. He had only needed to stop the truth a little too soon.

 

None of it explained why, among thirteen companions, Bilbo's step had become unmistakable. Why his eyes found him first across a camp. Why hearing Bilbo laugh had always pleased him quite so much. Friendship explained much, responsibility explained some, but neither could account for everything.

 

At the time he had noticed it only in pieces and given each piece another name.

 

Bright eyes had been cleverness. Long fingers had been the hands of a burglar. 

 

Thorin knew those hands better now.

 

Now there was no need to rename anything.

 

Bilbo was beautiful.

 

There had been remarkably little time to become accustomed to wanting Bilbo and being permitted to show it. Thorin had discovered a tendency to touch him whenever the opportunity presented itself - a hand at his waist when passing behind him, fingers lingering at the nape of his neck, Bilbo's feet finding his beneath the table and remaining there.

 

Bilbo had already accused him of attempting to make up seven years in three days. Thorin saw no particular reason not to try.

 

He bent over the letter again, still smiling.

 

"Thorin!"

 

He was interrupted by Bilbo's voice from the open kitchen window.

 

Bilbo leaned out between the pots of herbs upon the sill, sleeves rolled untidily above his elbows. His curls had been pushed backwards at some point and had already escaped whatever discipline had been attempted upon them, and there was flour upon one cheek.

 

Thorin forgot the sentence he had been writing.

 

"I hear you."

 

"That was not the question."

 

"I was about to."

 

"Then I have saved you the trouble."

 

Bilbo regarded him severely, and Thorin looked at the flour on his cheek.

 

It had become difficult not to smile when Bilbo looked at him, though this was inconvenient. Thorin had spent a great many years cultivating a face capable of discouraging questions, arguments and unsolicited advice. Bilbo Baggins had undone the work with alarming efficiency.

 

"Supper," Bilbo said. "shortly."

 

"I'll be there in a moment."

 

Bilbo smiled, and Thorin let himself look at the curls made copper at their edges by the evening sun. At the flour upon Bilbo's cheek. At those small lines beside his eyes, deepening now.

 

The freedom of it had not yet ceased to astonish him. He could look. Bilbo knew why. When Bilbo caught him doing it, Thorin no longer had to turn away.

 

Bilbo's smile faltered beneath his gaze, becoming something smaller and softer.

 

"What?"

 

"Nothing."

 

"That is plainly untrue."

 

Thorin considered him for a moment.

 

"You have flour on your face."

 

Bilbo immediately wiped the wrong cheek.

 

As Thorin's smile widened, Bilbo rolled his eyes in annoyance.

 

"Oh, very helpful." he said.

 

"You missed it."

 

"I gathered that."

 

Bilbo tried the other side and succeeded only in spreading the flour towards his ear. 

 

Thorin watched this for as long as conscience allowed before he stood.

 

Bilbo blinked as Thorin crossed the short distance to the window.

 

"What are you-"

 

Thorin reached through, caught him gently beneath the chin and wiped the flour away with his thumb.

 

Bilbo went quiet.

 

Thorin did not immediately remove his hand, instead passing his thumb once over the newly clean cheek and enjoying the warmth of Bilbo's skin.

 

"Thorin."

 

There were remarkable differences in the ways Bilbo said his name, and this particular one was among Thorin's favourites.

 

He leaned through the window and kissed him.

 

Bilbo made a startled noise against his mouth which became a laughter almost immediately, one hand catching Thorin's wrist through the open window. The angle was absurd. A pot of rosemary pressed against Thorin's chest. Bilbo's nose bumped his.

 

Thorin did not care.

 

When he drew back, Bilbo was staring at him.

 

"You could use the door." Bilbo said, slightly breathlessly.

 

"It was farther away."

 

Bilbo's mouth twitched, and his hand had not left Thorin's wrist.

 

Thorin became acutely aware of the thumb resting against his pulse.

 

"Five minutes." Bilbo said.

 

"I'll be there."

 

Then Bilbo squeezed once and let go. 

 

When Thorin returned to the apple-tree, he found that the sentence which had resisted him earlier no longer did.

 

He bent over the page once more, and this time the words came easily.

 

By the time he set down his pen, the evening had begun to cool down.

 

From inside came the familiar sounds of Bilbo putting supper upon the table. A cupboard opened. Porcelain touched wood. Something metallic fell, followed by a muffled exclamation which Thorin suspected was not intended to carry through the window.

 

His first instinct was to rise, yet he stopped himself. There was no crash afterwards, nor any call for assistance. Bilbo was perfectly capable of dropping a spoon without Thorin Oakenshield coming to his rescue.

 

Thorin settled back against the tree.

 

A smile remained upon his face.

 

Down the hill, the road towards his forge shone pale between the hedges. Tomorrow he would take it early. There was a roof-beam still to raise. He wanted the mortar mixed before the sun reached the forge, and if the weather remained dry he might begin the floor before evening. After that came the bellows. Then the hearth could be lit.

 

It was not a large forge.

 

Thorin had already considered how he might make it larger.

 

There was room enough along the eastern wall for another bay. The roof could be carried farther out and another workbench set beneath it. In time he might build a proper store for charcoal behind the chimney. If there proved to be enough work for it, a second hearth would not be impossible. Given sufficient room-

 

Thorin stopped.

 

There was, he realised, the beginning of an entire smithy-yard forming in his imagination.

 

Perhaps one day.

 

For now there would be one hearth, one anvil and enough room to swing a hammer without striking the wall. His tools would fit. The work already beginning to find its way towards him would fit. So would he. The eastern wall could remain where it was.

 

For now, it was enough.

 

Thorin, who had once possessed a rather complicated relationship with that word, found no bitterness in it at all.

 

There was a ploughshare waiting once the hearth was lit, then the kettle. Beyond them would come hinges, axles, knives gone dull and tools broken through misuse whose owners would swear faithfully that they had done nothing of the kind. Hobson would come by again, Thorin hoped.

 

Next spring the apple-tree would flower.

 

Perhaps Bilbo would let him plant something.

 

Onions, maybe.

 

"Thorin!" Bilbo yelled again from somewhere within.

 

"Yes, Bilbo. I am coming."

 

He did not immediately move.

 

The garden had grown very quiet. The first yellow leaves trembled among the hedge. The empty potato beds were dark against the grass, and the last marrow still crouched beneath its leaves - triumphant in its continued obscurity. Beyond the wall, Bag End settled towards supper. Smoke rose from the chimney.

 

Thorin breathed in.

 

He wanted to go inside.

 

That was the curious thing. He was not lingering because there was anything outside he preferred. In a moment he would go to Bilbo. There would be supper and probably tea afterwards. Bilbo might read before the fire while Thorin worked at the handle of one of his tools, their feet touching beneath the table. Later the lamps would be put out, and there were hours beyond that which belonged to neither Erebor nor the Shire, nor indeed to anyone but themselves.

 

Thorin wanted those too.

 

He wanted that life with a fierceness which no longer felt anything like hunger.

 

And tomorrow morning he wanted to leave Bag End for the day.

 

He wanted to walk down the hill with his tools over his shoulder and spend the day beneath an unfinished roof. He wanted stone dust in his hair and iron beneath his hands. He wanted farmers to arrive carrying things they had broken. He wanted to come home tired.

 

Tomorrow contained no throne, no council, no battle. Instead, it contained a roof-beam, a troublesome kettle, and whatever Hobson might find to disagree with him about. Thorin found himself looking forward to it.

 

And tonight there was Bilbo.

 

Thorin let himself remain beneath the tree for one moment longer.

 

Hobson's nails waited down at the forge. Primula's beans were gone from their poles. Bilbo's fork stood forgotten in the earth, and through the open window came the faint sounds of supper being laid.

 

Far beyond the eastern horizon stood a Mountain to which the letter upon his knees would eventually return.

 

Thorin folded the parchment.

 

He gathered his pen and ink and rose. His knees complained. His shoulders complained. Somewhere beneath the mortar one hand had acquired a blister which would undoubtedly complain tomorrow. Thorin considered this a satisfactory state of affairs.

 

Warm light lay across the path from the round green door as he crossed the garden towards it.

 

At the threshold he stopped and looked back once. The Shire stretched beneath the evening sky, untidy and cultivated and alive. Smoke rose from its chimneys. The road curved between hedges and disappeared.

 

Tomorrow he would walk down it.

 

Tonight there was Bilbo.

 

"Thorin!"

 

He smiled.

 

"Coming."

 

Thorin stepped through the doorway.

 

The green door swung quietly shut behind him.

❦

Chapter 30: ✉ Taking Shapes

Notes:

releasing the last two chapters together, so if you didn't catch the previous one go read that first :)

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

✉

Dear Fíli,

 

I have owed you a letter for longer than I care to reckon.

 

I tried more than once upon the road. I could never decide what ought to be said, and a blank page proved a more stubborn adversary than many I have faced. I cannot claim to understand why the words come more easily now, except that for the first time since leaving Erebor I know where I shall remain.

 

I am at Bag End.

 

The road has brought me farther than i intended to go and, in the end, back to more familiar country. I have seen the Sea, slept beneath more skies than I could name to you, and learned that wandering loses much of its purpose once one has found somewhere he would rather linger.

 

There is a forge taking shape farther down the Hill. It has no roof yet, but there is already work waiting for it, which I take as a good omen. By the time winter comes I expect to have smoke above the chimney and iron beneath my hammer.

 

Should the road ever bring you westward, there is room for you. In fact, you should bring Kíli, Dís, and whoever else may want to visit. Bilbo insists that you would all be welcome, though I advise you send word ahead. The last time all of us appeared unexpectedly upon his doorstep we ate his supper and emptied a considerable portion of his pantry. Time has softened his account of that evening very little.

 

The guest-room I occupied upon my arrival is no longer occupied.

 

The morning I asked you to take the throne after me, I told you that I had come to accept that the wish to marry and produce heirs would never come to me, though for most of my life I had expected it would follow the restoration of Erebor. That remains true. Yet it seems I knew less about the shape of my desires than I believed at the time.

 

Bilbo and I have fallen into a life together with remarkable ease. He still objects to my leaving tools upon his table, and I still object to his belief that every task may be interrupted merely because it is time to eat. These disagreements have proved survivable. There is a particular comfort in coming up the Hill at evening and seeing the round windows lit among the grass, knowing before I open the door whose voice I shall hear beyond it.

 

He is dearer to me than I know how to put gracefully into a letter.

 

While I was still travelling, Balin wrote to Bilbo. It was from that letter that I learned Erebor prospered under your rule. Though I had no doubt it would, I was glad of the news and prouder of you than perhaps Balin's account gave me any right to be.

 

I have wondered since how you fare beneath all that stone and ceremony. I hope that Kíli has not become so respectful of the crown that he has ceased being a nuisance. I have no such hope of your mother.

 

I miss her. There are things I would say differently to Dís now than I did before I left, though I expect she would take an intolerable satisfaction in hearing most of them. Give her my love, and tell her that Bilbo has acquired the habit of ordering me indoors when I have worked too long. She may find some comfort in knowing that the task has not gone entirely unattended in her absence.

 

I miss all of you. There are days when the memory of thirteen Dwarves seems a very noisy thing to carry through so quiet a country.

 

Bilbo carries it too.

 

I do not yet wish to return to Erebor, but I hope I shall see the mountain again one day. Perhaps after enough years have passed that my coming through the gate need not mean anything beyond my having come a very long way to see my family. I think I should like to see Erebor again on such terms.

 

Until then I shall content myself with being your uncle from a troublesome distance, which entitles me to at least a little unwanted counsel.

 

Speaking of, do listen to Balin. I did not always do so, and age has made his wisdom considerably easier to recognise in retrospect. Listen also to your mother, particularly when she forgets that she is speaking to a King. There will be no shortage of others to remember it for her.

 

Give my love to Kíli, and my greetings to Balin, Dwalin and the others. And please do write me when you have the leisure. It would be good to hear from you.

 

Your uncle,

Thorin

✉

Notes:

thank you all for this ride, it is the first time i actually posted a story on here and i've been overwhelmed by the positive feedback!

i had more than half of this story pre-written and every chapter planned out when decided to post, but i did not anticipate for so many kind comments! <33

turned this into a series because i have some smaller continuations and spinoffs planned, but nothing as long as this story.

still, if you're interested in reading more - stay tuned ;)

Series this work belongs to: