Actions

Work Header

Westward

Chapter 18: ✉ Of Stone and Timber

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

✉

Dear Bilbo,

 

Your latest letter was waiting for me when at last I reached Edoras, and I confess it was received with more relief than I had expected. The crossing of the White Mountains proved slower than I had intended. The passes are fair in their own stern fashion, though less welcoming than those I have long called familiar. For several days I found myself with little company save the wind and the stone beneath my feet.

 

There are few places where a dwarf feels quite so much at home as among mountains, no matter whose they may be. Stone asks little of those who walk upon it. It simply endures.

 

Edoras itself is not a great city by the measure of Minas Tirith, nor does it seek to be. It stands upon its hill with a quiet confidence. Its Golden Hall is fair, though fashioned almost entirely of timber. At first I could not help wondering how Men could place such value upon a hall built of wood, when stone may endure for the ages, though after a few days here I believe I understand a little better.

 

The folk here do not speak of their hall as though it were something that has survived unchanged through countless years. They speak instead of those who have repaired its beams, renewed its roof, and kept its hearth burning through winter, It occured to me that perhaps there are things which endure not because they resist the passing of years, but because each generation has cared enough to mend what weather and time have asked of it. There is wisdom in that, I think.

 

Perhaps that is why your last letter has remained so much in my thoughts since my arrival.

 

You wrote that the old Bilbo Baggins never quite found his place again after returning home. I have read that sentence many times.

 

It struck me that, for all the years I spent longing to return to Erebor, I never once asked myself whether the Thorin Oakenshield who finally entered its gates could truly be the same one who had left them. I thought only of reclaiming the Mountain. I gave very little thought to what should come after.

 

You have always seemed more willing than I to notice such questions. I wonder now whether that is why you remember evenings beside the fire more readily than war.

 

You asked in an earlier letter whether the road had begun to feel like home. I believe I answered it had not.

 

Though that still remains true, I have begun to suspect that I have been asking the wrong question. The road is only a road. It is neither home nor kingdom, neither burden nor companion. It merely leads onward. Perhaps what matters is not where it leads, but who one is when one has no pressing need to follow it. I find I do not know the answer.

 

By my journey through the White Mountains I came to realise that I have spent much of my life measuring myself  by the steepness of the climb before me. When the road is difficult, one knows what is required: endure a little longer, walk a little further, bear a little more. Such things are easily understood.

 

It is the easier roads that leave me uncertain.

 

I do not mean that I long for hardship. Do not mistake me in that. But I have begun to wonder whether I have grown so accustomed to purpose born of necessity that I scarcely know how to recognize it when no necessity presents itself.

 

Forgive me. I fear have answered your thoughtful letter with thoughts no less untidy.

 

You wrote once that you had grown fond of the quiet life you have made for yourself. I find that sentence has lingered with me. I hope it remains as true now as when you put it to paper.

 

From here I intend to ride north. I have long heard tales of Fangorn Forest, and beyond it lies the Golden Wood, of which so many strange stories are told that I find myself wondering how many can possibly be true. Supposedly an ancient Elven city of grandeur over where a great Elven witch resides. If there is any place where old questions have long since found their answers, one might suppose it would be there.

 

Where the road shall lead me after that, I cannot yet say. Rather than guess poorly, I shall wait until I have found a place where I mean to remain for more than a night or two before I trouble you with another letter.

 

Until then, take care of yourself, Bilbo.

 

Yours,

Thorin

✉

Notes:

letters are getting longer and increasingly personal <33