Actions

Work Header

Westward

Chapter 21: ✉ In Defence of Wilting Flowers

Notes:

sry for the delayed chapter. here's a long one. enjoy :)

Chapter Text

✉

Dear Bilbo,

 

Your letter found me still beneath Beorn's roof, though I expect this shall be the last I send from here.

 

Balin's news was welcome, though I had no doubt that Erebor would prosper under King Fíli. If I did, I would not have left. Still, there is pleasure in hearing of its well-being. Tell Balin, once you answer him, that his account pleased me greatly.

 

You may also tell him that I am well.

 

I fear I can offer no satisfactory explanation for why he has heard nothing from me directly, but trust that it is not for lack of trying. More than once I have sat down with the intention of writing to Erebor, yet I struggle to find words that seem more than something fit for a messenger to carry to a council, with nothing of real relevance.

 

Writing you has never presented the same difficulty. Whatever the reason may be, I hope you will endure the burden of remaining my sole correspondent a while longer. You have assured me often enough that my letters are welcome, and I intend to hold you to it.

 

Beorn, meanwhile, continues to provide remarkably little of what I came here seeking. 

 

He has offered no counsel, nor has he asked any question that pertains to anything other than daily life. Indeed, I suspect that if I told him I had crossed half the world in the hope of discovering some great truth beneath his roof, he would put a rake in my hands and tell me that the eastern field required discovering first.

 

My fingernails are black from soil as I write this, so perhaps he already has.

 

There is much here that would once have struck me as wasteful.

 

Beorn's strength has not lessened since I saw him last. Nothing about the quiet of his house has made the creature who fought before Erebor any less terrible. The same hands that quiet a frightened horse could break a neck with little effort. The same great shape bent over seedlings in the earth may become something before which armed Orcs once fled.

 

Yet the days pass without asking any of it from him. There are horses to feed at sunrise. Bread to make. Fences that lean after heavy rain and must be set upright again. Bees that care nothing for the strength of the hand tending their hives.

 

Beside the southern wall grow flowers whose name I have not learned. They opened only a few mornings ago, and Beorn tells me they will be gone before the summer is finished. There is something almost defiant in them - all that colour spent upon a thing which makes no attempt to endure.

 

I know that once I thought Beorn's strength wasted here. 

 

But perhaps strength is not diminished by having nothing to conquer.

 

Lady Galadriel's words have returned to me often here: claw and tooth, the hunt laid aside without either becoming blunt. Beorn has not made himself lesser in choosing this life. If anything, I begin to wonder whether it requires a surer knowledge of one's own strength to possess it without forever seeking occasion to prove it.

 

There is something in that which I cannot yet put properly into words. Perhaps you would understand it better than I. You always had a peculiar respect for small things, and I do mean that as high praise.

 

I have also thought of what you wrote of returning to Bag End, and of the Bilbo Baggins whom everyone expected to find there waiting for them.

 

When did you know that you had no wish to become him again?

 

Perhaps you never knew it all at once. Perhaps there are changes which announce themselves only when one looks backward and discovers that the old path has vanished behind him.

 

You need not answer if I presume too much. Yet I find myself curious about the years of your life. I did not witness. I know something of the hobbit who stepped out of Bag End and rather more of the one whose letters reach me now. There is a great deal between the two of which I know almost nothing.

 

My own stay here must soon come to its end.

 

Beorn has given no sign that my presence has become unwelcome, but his hospitality ought not to be mistaken for a desire for company. He has made a life here according to his own nature, and solitude is as much a part of it as the horses and the bees. There are those who are lonely because no one stays, and those who are content because no one needs to.

 

It would be a poor repayment for what he has shown me to overstay his welcome.

 

My horse, however, appears to disagree.

 

The gelding given to me in Rohan has taken readily to Beorn's pastures and, more importantly, to the other horses. Beorn has an ease with such creatures that I have neither the skill nor the vanity to imitate. I have therefore decided to leave him here and continue on foot. He carried me faithfully farther than I had any right to ask, and it seems a poor reward to pull him away from a place he has plainly chosen simply because I have not yet chosen one myself.

 

My own thoughts have turned toward Rivendell. Not because I expect answers there. I believe I have lately been cured of the notion that wisdom is something one may collect by travelling to sufficiently ancient places. 

 

But when last we entered that valley, everything before me was measured against Erebor. A place aided our purpose or delayed it. Counsel was useful or it was not. We required Elrond's learning, and so I valued it. We required rest, and so I endured it. Much else I dismissed before I had properly looked.

 

I have wondered for a while now how much of the world I passed in this manner.

 

Rivendell endured through long years of ruin without becoming either fortress or tomb. Memory is kept there, yet the house itself remains alive with songs and books and feasts. I understood preservation then chiefly as stone kept standing, names remembered, treasures reclaimed, and bloodlines continued. This time, I should like to see what I failed to see the first time.

 

Whether Lord Elrond will permit it is another question. I shall not presume that the hospitality once extended to a king upon Gandalf's business will necessarily be offered to a solitary dwarf arriving unbidden at his borders.

 

Still, there is only one way to discover it.

 

A few evenings ago the clouds broke over the mountains at sunset, and for a little while the whole western sky seemed aflame. My first thought was that I ought to remember it well enough to describe it in my next letter. My second thought was that description would not do.

 

I found myself wishing

 

No. That is not quite true. I do not know what I wished. Only that the sight seemed, for a moment, strangely incomplete.

 

You would have liked it.

 

Perhaps Rivendell will prove easier to put into words upon a second viewing, if Lord Elrond will permit me one.

 

And since I now know that Balin has taken to writing you behind my back, I must ask one favour. Should he, or any other dwarf with whom you have secretly established a correspondence, ask where I have gone - you are expressly forbidden from informing them that Thorin Oakenshield has willingly set out for Rivendell.

 

Fíli has enough to contend with as King without rumours that his uncle has lost his senses entirely.

 

I hope your next letter will find me there.

 

Until then, take care of yourself.

 

Yours,

Thorin

✉