Actions

Work Header

Westward

Chapter 23: ✉ Courteous Discourtesy

Chapter Text

✉

Dear Bilbo,

 

You may rest assured that Rivendell has received me with kindness, though I suspect this owes rather more to Lord Elrond's hospitality than to any great enthusiasm among his people. There were several looks upon my arrival which required no knowledge of Elvish to interpret.

 

Nonetheless, I have behaved with admirable restraint. You may be disappointed to learn that there has been no quarreling at all.

 

Lord Elrond received me with courtesy and, to my surprise, very little astonishment. Indeed, there was something almost unsettling in how unsurprised he seemed to find me at the borders of his realm. I had prepared myself to explain that I came neither as King under the Mountain nor upon any errand of Erebor, only as Thorin the Dwarf asking whether an old guest might be permitted to see the valley once more. He regarded me for a moment with that unreadable expression which I have begun to suspect Elves cultivate deliberately, before saying that he would be honoured to receive me as his guest.

 

It soon became apparent that Lord Elrond knew considerably more of my road than those I had left beneath the Mountain.

 

News of my abtication has evidently travelled farther than the realm of Dwarves, as has word of my departure from the Lonely Mountain. Stranger still, Lord Elrond asked about activity east of Minas Tirith under the assumption that I had been there recently. Another time, he asked whether I had found the shipwrights of Pelargir agreeable company.

 

When I questioned him, he told me only that news travels by many roads, and if the tales of my years at the forge during exile held any truth, a dwarf of my description working the iron fittings of ships far from any dwarven settlement was not so difficult a riddle as I imagined. I dislike being a riddle solved before I know I have been posed, though I imagine you would have enjoyed it immensely.

 

As for Rivendell itself, I find it much as we left it.

 

I remember thinking it was beautiful even upon our first visit, though back then its beauty seemed to me excessive, its ease frivolous, and its inhabitants more so. I still maintain that no proper meal ought to contain quite so many leaves. Fortunately, their bread remains tolerable.

 

In other matters, however, I hay have judged the place too quickly.

 

There is an ease here which I once mistook for idleness. Nothing seems hurried, yet very little is neglected. Songs are sung for no greater purpose than the pleasure of singing them. Books are copied which their scribes cannot possibly expect to finish quickly. Things are rmended with such care that one might think the act of mending mattered as much as the thing preserved.

 

There is sorrow here also, though I understand little of it.

 

As I do not understand their tongue, I may mistake what I see, but several among them appear to be making ready for the western road. Their possessions are strangely few for folk who have walked beneath the sun for so many years. There are farewells spoken in the halls, and sometimes songs whose words I cannot understand but whose meaning requires no translation. No one speaks of death, and yet there is mourning in it.

 

I have asked no questions. Whatever calls them across the Sea belongs to histories older than mine, and I have lately learned that not everything I fail to understand is therefore mine to uncover.

 

Lord Elrond and I have spent more time together than I would have thought either of us desired. 

 

There remains a certain sharpness between us. I have not forgotten his opinion on some of my choices, and I doubt he has forgotten mine on some of his counsel. Yet there is no hostility in it. He speaks plainly to me, which I value, and does not mistake disagreement for discourtesy. We have differed upon more than one matter and nevertheless returned to the same table afterward. There is something to be said for that.

 

He is strangely curious about my journey. Not merely where I have gone, of which he already seems to know more than I can reasonably explain, but why I chose to go at all. More than once I have had the uncomfortable suspicion that my answers told him something I had not intended to say. Such suspicions are difficult to escape in Rivendell.

 

Yesterday, quite without warning, he asked about you.

 

It was an ordinary enough inquiry. He asked whether we remained in correspondence, whether you were well, and whether the Shire remained much as you remembered it before the quest.

 

I told him that we did, that you were, and that I suspected the Shire would remain stubbornly itself long after both of us had ceased remarking upon it.

 

He smiled.

 

There was something in his expression I did not understand. He seemed pleased, though by which part of my answer I cannot say. For one uncomfortable moment I had the distinct impression that he expected me to say more.

 

I did not oblige him.

 

You may congratulate me upon successfully resisting whatever game an Elf-lord was attempting to play at my expense.

 

I shall remain here only a little longer. There are still parts of the valley I wish to see once more, and Lord Elrond has offered me the use of his library - an invitation which I confess has proved more tempting than I would once have admitted. 

 

After that, I shall take the road again.

 

Where it leads, I cannot yet say. Once, that uncertainty would have troubled me. Now it seems enough that there will be another road when I reach the end of this one.

 

I shall write again when I have found somewhere worth stopping. It has become a habit I am reluctant to break.

 

Until then, take care of yourself, Bilbo.

 

Yours,

Thorin

✉