Actions

Work Header

Westward

Chapter 28: ❦ Of Certainty and Change

Chapter Text

❦

There are few sounds more alarming in a quiet hobbit-hole than the breaking of porcelain.

 

Bilbo had been walking down the passage with a cup of tea balanced comfortably in one hand, thinking with great seriousness about whether the remains of seed-cake might be improved by toasting, when his eye caught the open door of the guest-room as he passed.

 

The cup had slipped from his fingers and shattered upon the floor with a crack so sharp that, for one strange instant, the sound seemed to travel through every tunnel and chamber beneath the Hill. White china scattered over the dark boards while tea ran in a thin brown sheet towards the skirting, and Bilbo stood above the wreckage without moving, as though the disaster at his feet required some explanation which had not yet reached him.

 

Thorin turned.

 

Bilbo did not look at him.

 

His gaze was fixed on what stood behind the dwarf.

 

Beyond Thorin, a travelling pack stod open and Bilbo's eye moved unwillingly from it to the things gathered around it - the folded cloak, the spare shirt, the whetstone, the comb, the leather roll of tools. None of them ought to have mattered. They were only belongings, after all, and not even many of them, yet seeing them assembled there gave the room the peculiar look of a place already beginning to forget its occupant.

 

It was astonishing how much presence could be measured by absence. A pipe removed from a table. Boots no longer beneath the bed. A coat gone from its hook. Over the past weeks Thorin had quietly taken root in Bag End without seeming to do anything so presumptuous as unpacking his life, and Bilbo had become accustomed to those little signs as one becomes accustomed to bird song outside an open window - only when it ceased did one understand how much silence had always waited beneath it.

 

Bilbo had always known Thorin would leave. He had arrived in the Shire with the road still clinging to him, after all, and there had never been any promise that Bag End was more than a stopping-place. In the first few days Bilbo had been perfectly sensible about this. Thorin would stay a little while, they would talk, eat, perhaps walk into Hobbiton, and then one morning there would be a pack at the door again.

 

Only the mornings had kept passing without it. Somewhere in the comfortable repetition of breakfast cups, coffee, boots in the passage and another voice answering from down the hall, Bilbo had ceased to picture the part where the repetition ended.

 

Bilbo had simply become very accomplished at refusing to look in its direction.

 

Apparently tomorrow had looked back.

 

"Bilbo?"

 

Thorin's voice reached him gently.

 

Bilbo blinked.

 

"Damn."

 

He crouched at once and began gathering the broken pieces.

 

Thorin crossed the room in two strides.

 

"Leave it."

 

"It is not the first cup I have broken."

 

"So I can see."

 

"There is no need to sound quite so pleased about it."

 

"I am not pleased, I am concerned you may cut your hand."

 

Bilbo ignored him and and reached for the largest fragment, promptly catching his thumb upon the sharp edge.

 

Thorin made a dissatisfied sound which somehow managed to contain both concern and vindication.

 

Bilbo put the piece down with exaggerated dignity.

 

"There is something deeply unpleasant about how much you enjoy being right."

 

"I said nothing."

 

"You made a noise."

 

"It was a deserved noise."

 

Bilbo glared at him, fetched the dustpan, and returned before Thorin could take over the task entirely. He swept the fragments together with the grim concentration of someone attempting to defeat an enemy army by means of a household brush.

 

"You're packing."

 

Thorin glanced back towards the bed.

 

"Yes."

 

Bilbo pushed another painted shard into the pan.

 

"When?"

 

"Tomorrow morning."

 

Bilbo's brush paused against the rug, but only for a moment before he forced it onwards.

 

"Tomorrow."

 

"Yes."

 

"And where are you going?"

 

Thorin considered the question with an aggravating seriousness, as though the answer concerned some distant road rather than the sudden absence opening at Bilbo's feet.

 

"I have not decided."

 

Bilbo looked up.

 

"You have not decided."

 

"No."

 

"But you are leaving."

 

A faint crease appeared between Thorin's brows.

 

"Yes."

 

Bilbo returned his attention to the floor.

 

There was something almost offensive in the vagueness of it. Had Thorin said Rivendell, Bilbo might have resented the Elves. Had he said Dale, there would at least have been mountains enough to blame. But there was no destination, only departure itself. An empty room waiting patiently at the end of a sentence Bilbo had refused to finish reading.

 

He gathered the last fragments, carried them to the kitchen, and tipped them into the bin with rather more force than china deserved.

 

When he turned around, Thorin had followed.

 

Naturally.

 

"You might have mentioned it."

 

Thorin looked honestly puzzled.

 

"I was intending to."

 

"Well," said Bilbo, seizing a cloth from beside the sink, "congratulations upon your impeccable timing."

 

He marched back towards the passage and knelt upon the rug where the tea had spilled.

 

Thorin remained standing nearby.

 

For a little while only the sound of Bilbo blotting tea from wool filled the silence. 

 

Then Thorin spoke.

 

"I have remained longer than I intended."

 

The cloth stopped moving.

 

Thorin continued quietly, choosing his words with the grave care Bilbo remembered from the Quest.

 

"I came without invitation. You offered me your home, your table, and every comfort a wanderer might hope to find. It would not be right to presume upon such kindness merely because I have found it difficult to leave."

 

Bilbo's fingers tightened around the damp cloth. Kindness. Generosity. Hospitality. Thorin offered the words like polished silver, honourable and bright and entirely incapable of holding any warmth.

 

Bilbo rose.

 

"You are not imposing upon me."

 

"I did not say-"

 

"You were about to."

 

"I said only that i ought not take advantage of the hospitality of a friend."

 

A friend. 

 

Bilbo looked away.

 

Friend had once been one of the safest words he possessed, broad enough to shelter every affection he dared not name and sturdy enough to survive both distance and silence.

 

Yet now, with Thorin's belongings gathered upon the bed and tomorrow suddenly sharpened into a real thing, the word seemed to shrink around him and restrict him until there was scarcely room enough to breathe.

 

"You are not taking advantage of anything." he repeated.

 

Silence stretched until Bilbo dared to look. Recognition had entered Thorin's eyes - not complete understanding, perhaps, but enough. Enough that Bilbo felt something inside himself finally surrender.

 

"You do not want me to leave." Thorin observed with an unreadable expression.

 

For a heartbeat Bilbo stood perfectly still.

 

There were answers waiting. Respectable answers. He would miss Thorin's company. Bag End would be quieter. One always disliked saying farewell to an old companion.

 

All true.

 

None large enough.

 

"No."

 

The word scarcely disturbet the air.

 

When he turned, Thorin had not moved.

 

Something uncertain had entered his face - not hope exactly, for Thorin had never been foolish enough to leap before certainty, but the first pale light before dawn.

 

"Then why have you never said so?" he asked gently.

 

Bilbo laughed.

 

It escaped him without humour.

 

"What precisely was I supposed to say?"

 

"The truth."

 

"Oh, splendid." Bilbo threw the cloth onto the counter. "Why did I never think of that?"

 

Thorin took a step nearer.

 

"Bilbo."

 

There was something in the way he said the name which made all further attempts at evading the topic feel suddenly childish.

 

Bilbo looked down.

 

"There are some things, Thorin," he said quietly. "which are better left unsaid."

 

Thorin regarded him in silence, and the room seemed to quiet around that look until Bilbo could hear the faint tick of the clock beyond the passage and a bee blundering against the lavender outside. Thorin had always possessed an alarming talent for waiting longer than Bilbo could comfortably endure.

 

At last Thorin asked him the one simple question Bilbo was absolutely dreading.

 

"Why?"

 

Bilbo closed his eyes.

 

There were days when Thorin's persistence reminded him of an oak-root splitting stone. Patient. Silent. Entirely incapable of understanding that some walls had been built precisely because someone wished to remain on the other side.

 

He opened his eyes again.

 

"Because I happen to value your friendship more than I value the satisfaction of saying every damned thing that enters my head."

 

The words seemed to ring louder than the cup had.

 

Silence stretched

 

When Bilbo at last dared to look, he saw recognition had entered Thorin's eyes. Not complete understanding, just enough. Enough that Bilbo felt something inside himself finally surrender.

 

He smiled faintly, though it hurt.

 

"I should have thought it obvious by now."

 

"Bilbo-"

 

"If you wish to leave, I understand."

 

Thorin stepped forward.

 

Bilbo shook his head before he could speak again.

 

"No. You wanted honesty. There it is." he drew a breath, and it trembled despite his best efforts. "I think the world of you, you impossible creature, and I am not prepared to risk-"

 

Before Bilbo could finish, Thorin kissed him.

 

For half a heartbeat Bilbo forgot how the world worked at all - seven years of certainty broke apart so swiftly that he could almost have heard it, like ice giving way beneath sudden spring water. Thorin's hand was warm at the back of his neck, his mouth firm against Bilbo's, and there was nothing in the gesture which could be folded back into friendship afterwards.

 

There was nothing measured in the kiss.

 

No caution, no hesitant question seeking permission after the fact. It carried all the bewildered force of a river finally breaking through the bank which had contained it for too long. Bilbo felt himself stumble forward into it before thought could intervene.

 

Then his hand seized the hem of Thorin's shirt.

 

He kissed him back.

 

Beard brushed his cheek. Their noses collided inelegantly. Thorin's other arm came around Bilbo's waist with such instinctive certainty that Bilbo forgot entirely which one of them had begun it. He had imagined kissing Thorin before, of course had. Lonely hearts were imaginative creatures, after all.

 

Reality was much less graceful.

 

And infinitely more wonderful.

 

When they parted, neither seemed willing to travel very far. Their breathing mingled in the narrow space between them. Thorin smiled first. It was small and almost disbelieving.

 

"I had not intended to do that."

 

Bilbo's heart promptly plummeted through the floor.

 

His fingers released the shirt at once.

 

Of course.

 

Of course the moment had simply overtaken Thorin. A foolish impulse. A tenderness misplaced. Bilbo. began speaking before dignity could gather its belongings.

 

"Well, naturally, one cannot always be expected to account for every moment of temporary insanity, and I assure you I have no intention of making this unnecessarily awkward. I can still be a perfectly good and loyal friend, and I shall certainly not-"

 

"Bilbo."

 

"-overstep again, because goodness knows I have managed perfectly well for years and there is absolutely no reason-"

 

"Bilbo."

 

He stopped.

 

Thorin's thumb had found the inside of his wrist.

 

"I do not regret it."

 

The words entered quietly.

 

Bilbo stared.

 

"I said," Thorin continued. "that I had not intended it, at least not like this. I did not say I wished it undone."

 

For perhaps the first time in his life Bilbo Baggins found himself entirely without language.

 

"Oh." he managed eventually.

 

Thorin laughed under his breath.

 

Bilbo glared.

 

"Don't become accustomed to that."

 

"To what?"

 

"Winning arguments."

 

"I believe you interrupted yours with kissing."

 

"That was your doing."

 

"I seem to recall considerable assistance."

 

Bilbo tried very hard to remain offended, but failed almost immediately.

 

The smile upon Thorin's face faded into something gentler.

 

"I was packing because I thought I ought to leave." he said. "Not because I wished to."

 

Bilbo glanced past him towards the open doorway.

 

The abandoned pack seemed suddenly to belong to another afternoon entirely.

 

"I thought your kindness was simply kindness." Thorin went on. "That you welcomed me because I was your friend, and that remaining beneath your roof while wanting more than friendship was a selfishness I had no wish to indulge."

 

Bilbo listened.

 

It was strangely moving to discover that while he had spent days fearing departure, Thorin had spent those same days fearing himself.

 

"I thought," Thorin said more quietly, "that if I stayed much longer, I would ruin what we had."

 

Bilbo considered this gravely, before a smile broke out across his face.

 

"You nearly did." he said with a great grin.

 

Thorin's brows rose.

 

Bilbo caught the front of his shirt again.

 

"Come here."

 

The second kiss was softer.

 

The first had been thunder. This was rain afterwards, falling steadily over thirsty earth.

 

Thorin's palm cupped Bilbo's cheek as though memorising it. Bilbo loosened his fist in the linen but did not let go entirely. Their lips met once, parted, and returned with a tenderness almost more frightening than passion, because tenderness suggested mornings. It suggested ordinary things. It suggested there might be time enough to learn one another without fear.

 

When they drew apart, Bilbo remained close.

 

"I knew you loved me."

 

Thorin went still.

 

Bilbo, intent upon explaining rather than confessing, scarcely noticed.

 

"During the Quest, I mean. Afterwards too." He smiled faintly. "I never thought otherwise. Only, it was not the same way that I loved you."

 

There.

 

The word had escaped so naturally that Bilbo almost continued speaking before he understood what he had done.

 

Thorin understood perfectly.

 

His expression brightened with such quiet delight that Bilbo immediately narrowed his eyes.

 

"Oh, do not."

 

"I have said nothing, I am merely listening."

 

"With your entire face."

 

Thorin's smile deepened.

 

Bilbo sighed dramatically and continued before he could lose courage.

 

"I believed you loved me as your friend. Perhaps as something akin to family, after all we endured together. I knew I mattered to you." his fingers traced an idle crease in Thorin's shirt. "That was enough."

 

He looked down.

 

"At first I thought what I felt would pass when I came home. It seemed reasonable. Everything during the Quest had been enormous - dragons, goblins, mountains, death. One might easily mistake a heart carried through such things for something grander than it truly was."

 

"And did it pass?"

 

"Obviously not." Bilbo responded, gesturing between them before looking down again. "It simply learned to live quietly."

 

"There are worse things," he said softly. "than loving someone who loves you differently."

 

Thorin looked at him for a long while.

 

"And that truly became enough?"

 

Bilbo considered.

 

"I have not lived in misery since leaving Erebor, if that's what you're asking. With time, I found a certain comfort in my affection that did not demand reward simply because it had become part of me. Longing became kin to nostalgia over the years. It had to."

 

Bilbo squeezed his hand.

 

"And when did you know?" he then asked. "Was it only after you came here?"

 

Thorin did not answer at once. His eyes had gone somewhere beyond the room, following a road Bilbo could not see.

 

"I have been trying to answer that myself."

 

Bilbo waited.

 

"There are things I remember differently now." Thorin's thumb moved absently across the back of Bilbo's hand. "I remember looking for you when we made camp. I remember knowing your step behind me before i knew half the Company's. In Mirkwood, when I could not see you, I knew precisely how long it had been since I had heard your voice."

 

Bilbo's heart gave a small, painful turn.

 

Thorin frowned, not at him but at the memory.

 

"None of it seemed remarkable to me then."

 

That, more than anything he might have said, hurt.

 

Not cruelly. It was the ache of finding an old letter years too late and discovering that the answer had been written upon it all along.

 

"And afterwards?" Bilbo asked.

 

"Afterwards I missed you."

 

"Well, I should certainly hope so."

 

A faint smile touched Thorin's lips.

 

"I told myself it was because you were my friend."

 

"And the letters?"

 

"I wished to hear from my friend."

 

Bilbo's smile began despite himself.

 

"And crossing half the world in roughly my direction?"

 

Thorin gave him a look.

 

"By then I had ceased believing myself."

 

Bilbo laughed, and Thorin did too, though more quietly. There was something wonderfully absurd about it when laid out in such a fashion - all those miles of solemn wandering, all those carefully reasoned letters, while somewhere beneath the whole business Thorin Oakenshield had apparently been making his way towards Bag End with the stubbornness of a migrating bird and rather less understanding of what compelled him.

 

It was a strange thing, to be handed one's own past again with some secret writing now made visible upon it.

 

Bilbo wondered, suddenly and unwisely, what might have happened if Thorin had understood himself during the Quest - upon some cold night beneath the stars, or in Beorn's hall, or during those strange peaceful days in the early parts of the journey before the Mountain had risen before them and swallowed everything else.

 

It was a useless thought. Roads looked very different when viewed from their ending.

 

Still, for one moment, Bilbo mourned a happiness neither of them had known enough to miss.

 

"You were very certain of yourself in those days" he said.

 

Thorin's mouth curved faintly.

 

"About many things."

 

There was enough ruefulness in it to make Bilbo smile.

 

Then Thorin's thumb stopped moving.

 

Bilbo noticed because his own hand had grown accustomed to the motion.

 

Thorin was looking down at their joined hands, but the faint smile had gone from his face. Something had closed behind his eyes so quietly that Bilbo could not have said when it happened. A moment ago they had been wandering together through old memories as one might walk an abandoned road in summer, finding flowers grown over the ruts and laughing at how steep the hills had once seemed. Thorin, it appeared, had reached a place where nothing grew.

 

Bilbo waited.

 

Thorin let go of his hand.

 

He crossed the few steps to the bed, though there was nothing there he seemed to want. For a moment he stood before the half-packed bag, one hand resting upon its open flap. The room had grown very quiet. Even the ordinary sounds of Bag End, like the clock somewhere down the passage and the faint rustle from the garden beyond the window, seemed suddenly to belong on the other side of a great distance.

 

Bilbo's happiness did not vanish. It drew upon itself, like a flame when a door is opened upon winter.

 

"Thorin?"

 

Thorin sat down upon the edge of the bed.

 

Bilbo watched his hands come together between his knees. 

 

Only then did he understand that whatever Thorin was seeing, it was no longer a camp beneath the stars.

 

When he spoke, all the softness had gone from his voice.

 

"I tried to kill you."

 

There was no need to say where.

 

The Mountain entered the room between them.

 

Bilbo remembered the cold before he remembered anything else - cold stone beneath his feet, cold air against his face, and Thorin's eyes stranger than any dragon's treasure had ever made them. For seven years the memory had faded at its edges, as memories mercifully do, but it had never disappeared. Some things did not need to be often visited to remain exactly where one had left them.

 

He crossed the room and sat beside Thorin.

 

"Yes." he said.

 

Thorin flinched.

 

Only slightly, but Bilbo saw it.

 

He had not softened the answer. He would not. Whatever forgiveness was worth between them depended upon neither pretending there had been nothing to forgive.

 

For a while Thorin said nothing. His gaze remained upon his hands.

 

"I remember your face."

 

Bilbo's throat tightened.

 

"I know."

 

"I remember what I called you. I remember believing it." Thorin swallowed. "And now you tell me that even then-"

 

He stopped.

 

That was when Bilbo understood.

 

It was not merely the old guilt returning.

 

They had spent the last several minutes uncovering the possibility that this thing between them had roots reaching all the way back to the Quest. Bilbo had looked upon that discovery and seen lost years, certainly, but also something tender - proof that perhaps he had not been quite so alone beneath those distant stars as he had believed.

 

Thorin had followed the same roots backwards and found them running beneath the wall of Erebor.

 

The happiness of a moment before had not been false. That almost made it worse.

 

Bilbo reached for his hand again.

 

Thorin looked at it before allowing their fingers to close.

 

"I forgave you." Bilbo said

 

The words did not seem to bring Thorin any comfort. If anything, his face tightened.

 

"I do not know how you could."

 

"Well, fortunately, I did not require your assistance."

 

Thorin looked at him then, and Bilbo saw at once the attempt at lightness had come too soon. The old pain remained too near the surface for teasing to find purchase upon it.

 

Bilbo's thumb moved slowly across Thorin's knuckles.

 

"I am not saying it did not matter."

 

"I know."

 

"No." Bilbo waited until Thorin met his eyes again. "I don't think you do."

 

The afternoon light had shifted while they spoke. It no longer lay golden across the room but had climbed halfway up the opposite wall, leaving the floorboards in the first grey-blue hint of evening. Thorin's face had fallen partly into shadow.

 

"You frightened me." Bilbo said. "More than the goblins did, I think. More than the spiders. Perhaps even more than Smaug."

 

Nothing moved in Thorin's expression.

 

Bilbo went on more softly.

 

"Because I knew what all of those things were."

 

Thorin's eyes closed.

 

Bilbo let the silence remain. There were hurts which became smaller when spoken of, and others which deserved the dignity of not being hurried towards a pleasant conclusion. He had no wish to make that day beneath the Mountain harmless merely because they were sitting now beneath a gentler hill.

 

"I looked at you," he said at last. "and for a little while I could not find you."

 

Thorin bowed his head.

 

Bilbo's hand tightened around his.

 

"But I did."

 

Thorin opened his eyes.

 

"Not upon the wall. Not all at once." Bilbo looked down at their joined hands. Thorin's was broad and scarred, the same hand which had once gripped a sword in anger and had, a little over a week ago, shaped a bit of iron for a hobbit's cart. "Afterwards."

 

The word opened years between them.

 

Bilbo thought of letters arriving beneath the round green door. Of Thorin laying aside a crown. Of roads travelled without armies behind him or kingdoms waiting at their end. Of a Dwarf standing at a little forge and treating a farmer's broken linchpin as though its usefulness were reason enough to make it well.

 

There had been no single moment in which Thorin became worthy of forgiveness. Bilbo would have distrusted such a thing if there had been. Mountains changed by inches - frost in their cracks, rain upon their slopes, roots finding patient purchase where stone had seemed impenetrable. One might look away for years and return to find the same mountain beneath the sky, yet discover that its whole face had altered.

 

"You have spent a very long time answering for what happened." Bilbo said.

 

"Not to you."

 

"Especially to me."

 

Thorin frowned.

 

Bilbo almost smiled, but this time he kept it small.

 

"You think an apology is the only answer a person can give.

 

"What other answer is there?"

 

"The life he lives afterwards."

 

That silenced him.

 

Bilbo did not fill the quiet. He could see Thorin turning the words over with the same grave attention he gave anything he did not immediately accept.

 

At length Thorin shook his head.

 

"That does not undo it."

 

"No."

 

"I cannot become a man who never stood upon that wall."

 

"No."

 

"And you would have me simply forgive him?"

 

There it was - the old mercilessness, turned inward now. Thorin had once demanded impossible payment from the world. He had become gentler with nearly everyone except himself.

 

Bilbo shifted upon the bed until he was facing him properly.

 

"I would have you stop deciding whether I am allowed to."

 

Thorin stared at him.

 

Bilbo held his gaze.

 

"You may regret it until the end of your days if you must. I cannot prevent you, though I reserve the right to complain about it when you become particularly tiresome." his fingers tightened around Thorin's. "But my forgiveness belongs to me. You do not get to refuse it on my behalf."

 

For the first time something in Thorin's expression gave way.

 

Not dramatically. Thorin had never been a man whose deepest hurts departed with convenient tears and declarations. It was smaller than that - the hard line of his mouth loosened, and his shoulders lowered by some fraction Bilbo might not have noticed had he not spent so many years remembering them.

 

"I do not know what to do with that." Thorin's voice came out almost like a whisper.

 

Bilbo's heart ached.

 

"You needn't do anything with it tonight."

 

Thorin looked at him.

 

"Keep it somewhere inconvenient, if you like. Dwarves seem fond of storing precious things in mountains."

 

A breath escaped Thorin which might, in kinder circumstances, have become a laugh.

 

Bilbo felt the first small loosening in his own chest.

 

"There." he murmured. "That's better."

 

"I did not laugh."

 

"You very nearly did."

 

"I breathed."

 

"In a suspiciously cheerful manner."

 

That earned him the faintest movement at the corner of THorin's mouth, but it vanished almost at once.

 

Bilbo did not chase it.

 

Instead he shifted nearer until their shoulders touched.

 

For a while that was all.

 

Outside the window, the evening had deepened. A blackbird called somewhere in the garden, then another answered farther down the Hill. The clock in the passage ticked steadily onwards, indifferent to mountains and dragons and seven lost years. Bag End gathered its familiar shadows around them.

 

Thorin's hand remained in Bilbo's.

 

Eventually his grip loosened.

 

Then his shoulder leaned, almost imperceptibly, against Bilbo's.

 

Bilbo stayed still.

 

A little more weight followed.

 

At last Thorin bowed his head and rested it against Bilbo's shoulder.

 

Something in Bilbo's chest broke open then, but gently this time.

 

He lifted an arm and put it around Thorin.

 

There was no triumph in the gesture, no sense that some old wound had at last been healed and neatly put away. The Mountain remained behind them. It always would. But memory was a country large enough to contain more than one thing, and here, now, Thorin's silvering head rested beneath Bilbo's cheek while their hands lay joined between them.

 

Bilbo rubbed his thumb once over Thorin's shoulder.

 

Thorin exhaled.

 

THe sound was long and tired, like wind leaving a house after rattling all night at its shutters.

 

Neither spoke.

 

Slowly the room became Bag End again.

 

The cold stone beneath Bilbo's memory gave way to a mattress beneath his legs. The remembered winter air became the faint evening breeze slipping through the open window. Somewhere in the kitchen sat the remains of a seed-cake which Bilbo had intended, what seemed several lifetimes ago, to consider toasting.

 

His eyes wandered towards the pack.

 

It still stood open.

 

For the first time since seeing it, Bilbo did not feel the same terrible drop beneath his ribs.

 

Beside him Thorin stirred.

 

"I have made rather a disaster of this afternoon." Thorin stated with a sigh.

 

Bilbo considered the broken cup, the confession, the kisses, the attempted departure, the resurrection of one of the worst memories of his life, and Thorin presently folded against his side.

 

"I have had worse."

 

Thorin's quiet laugh warmed Bilbo's shoulder.

 

It was not happiness returned whole, as though nothing dark had passed between them. Something better, perhaps - happiness which had gone down into the dark with them and come back carrying it.

 

Bilbo rested his cheek against Thorin's hair.

 

For some time they simply sat there.

 

The open pack waited patiently upon the floor.

 

Somewhere beyond the Hill a blackbird began singing its evening song, each clear note rising through the golden quiet of the Shire.

 

After a while, Thorin's thumb began making calm, absent-minded patterns on Bilbo's hand once more.

 

Bilbo became aware that he was smiling from ear to ear.

 

Thorin, judging by the faint movement of his cheek against Bilbo's shoulder, was suffering from precisely the same affliction.

 

"You're grinning."

 

"So are you."

 

Bilbo laughed softly.

 

After a while his gaze drifted once more towards the half-packed belongings.

 

"You know," he said. "for all your solemn speeches about hospitality, I think you've misunderstood Bag End entirely if you believe yourself to be a mere guest beneath this roof."

 

For a moment Thorin said nothing.

 

His eyes travelled over the folded cloak, the travelling pack, the little gathered pieces of a wandering life. Then they returned to Bilbo, and something in them became wonderfully still.

 

Not uncertainty.

 

Recognition.

 

Like a traveller reaching the crest of a hill and seeing, at last, the chimney smoke he had spent years searching for without knowing its location.

 

"I believe," Thorin said quietly. "my wandering days are over."

 

Bilbo forgot to breathe.


Thorin smiled then - not as a king, nor as the stern leader Bilbo had first met quite unexpectedly years ago, but simply as himself.

 

"If you will have me."

 

Bilbo stared at him.

 

Then every careful defence he had ever constructed surrendered at once.

 

"Oh, you impossible creature!"

 

He caught Thorin's face between both hands and pressed their lips together.

 

Thorin laughed against his mouth before returning the kiss, and somehow the laughter became kisses and kisses became the two of them tumbling backwards on the bed with considerably less elegance than either might later claim. The folded cloak survived. The pack did not protest.

 

Bilbo's fingers disappeared into silver hair while Thorin held him as though the whole wide world had finally ceased insisting they stand apart.

 

Outside, evening gathered over the Shire without ceremony. Smoke rose straight from the chimneys of Hobbiton before the cooling air bent it westward. The water slipped beneath its bridges, windows brightened one by one, and somewhere beyond the Hill a gate banged shut before supper. From the lane, Bag End would have looked exactly as it had that morning, its round windows glowing beneath the turf and its green door closed against the dusk.

 

By morning the broken cup would still be broken, the Hill would still be green, and the road would still run beyond Hobbiton. The kettle would require filling, breakfast would require making, and Thorin's boots would still be where Bilbo had grown accustomed to finding them.

 

Tomorrow, Bilbo thought, might come when it pleased.

❦