Chapter Text
“Evening, brother,” says Dwalin as he, Fili and Kili enter Balin’s room quietly, unnoticed by anyone. “Care to tell us why we’re here at this late hour?”
“It’s about our king. Everyone’s discretion is advised.” Balin closes the door, and begins. “He doesn’t sleep. He barely eats. Buries himself in projects from evening till dawn, with zero efficiency. When things don’t get done, he just takes on more work. As for Thorin’s focus... he’s fine for an hour or two in the morning, then starts drifting. In meetings I sometimes have to repeat what is said to him.”
“And did you notice how often Uncle is on the ramparts these days?” puts in Fili. “Every evening, for an hour straight.”
“I did notice,” Balin replies. “Hence I wanted to ask: anyone know what’s going on with him?”
“Let’s see. Lousy performance in the ruling department and a daily exercise in self-loathing? Only one thing comes to mind,” says Dwalin.
“The hobbit. Or lack thereof,” laments Kili.
Balin nods. “Sometimes I wish one of us had made Bilbo aware of Thorin’s feelings before he left. Something could have come out of it.”
Dwalin makes a strangled noise, as if he’s just swallowed green food.
“We could still write to Bilbo. Or persuade Thorin to write to him. There is a chance Bilbo will accept his suit. Are you all right, brother?” Balin asks after Dwalin makes another tortured sound.
“I don’t think Bilbo will reciprocate, and I’ll leave it at that.”
Dwalin won’t reveal what he knows; but since the indiscretion Bofur committed between Erebor and Mirkwood, it’s been clear to him: if Master Baggins had been in love, he could have easily turned around.
“Then that’s that. I hate to say it, but there are dwarves just arrived from other kingdoms who are eager to try their chance at Thorin’s hand. Save for a handful of us, the rest of Erebor expects him to marry, or at least entertain the idea of a mate. With so many potential candidates, I think it’s wise to let them try to meet him; speak with him in private, maybe more.”
“That’s not going to change how Thorin feels.”
“No, it won’t. But it may improve his daily performance in crucial matters. Until that happens though,” Balin takes a firm stance, “I’m afraid that starting tomorrow you, Fili, will be present at all court meetings. It’s time for you to prepare for becoming king. Don’t worry, I will personally be training you. The training will revolve around your schedule: evenings, weekends... whenever you have free time.”
Fili yawns, suddenly overtired.
“As for you, Kili, you’ll get to attend meetings too. Be your brother’s second pair of eyes.”
Kili groans, suddenly in pain.
* * *
When Bilbo left, Thorin thought the kingdom’s demands - paperwork, alliances, reopening forges and mines - would take all his time.
He was right; but they don’t occupy all his mind. All it takes is a ray of light making its way into the Throne Room, and Bilbo is there: Thorin can see him, clear as daylight, golden curls in the afternoon sun, a smile, a frown, a simple gaze, it matters not; enough to remind Thorin he misses him. Then Thorin realizes he cannot even have the hobbit as a friend, or as a mere guest. Bilbo does not live here anymore.
Thus it is every evening Thorin visits the ramparts, and for an hour drinks in that fateful day, like medicine meant to tone his craving down. If he remembers what he did to Bilbo, Thorin will see not only that he can’t have him, but that it is not right to want him.
And every night he soaks the pillow with his tears, ashamed and terrified. For the memory of the ramparts is still alive: it takes everything out of him to face it. Then a new day begins, bringing back the same fleeting imaginings, leaving him so enraptured that daily activities are forgotten.
Thorin keeps going. One day he will find a way to harmonize the responsibilities of ruling Erebor with guilt, shame and pain, and a love that does not stand a chance.
* * *
“Mister Baggins, I presume?” the Eagle speaks, trying to force himself into Bag End past Bilbo, who hasn’t moved out of the way. “My name is Balthazar, son of Balthir.”
“I beg your pardon, but you’re not going to fit,” says Bilbo, pointing to his door, tiny by comparison to the mighty bird.
“Ah. Then we’ll just have to sort it all out here, won’t we?”
“Sort what out?”
“Well. The wizard Gandalf sent me. I ran into him in the Lonelands, on my way to visiting friends. He said you had urgent need to fly to Erebor.”
“He WHAT?”
“Yup. Now let me understand: you were just there, and now you want to go back? And what’s the deal with the dwarf king, Thorin Oakenshield? Gandalf said you have unfinished business with him.”
“Whoa, whoa, whoa,” Bilbo says, rapidly scanning the surroundings for any passers-by who may be privy to this TMI. “Slow down, Mister Balthazar. And could you not be so loud?”
“Fine,” says the Eagle in an annoyed tone. “By the way, Gandalf spoke highly of your bread rolls. Can I have some?”
“Y... yes.” Bilbo steps into the house, glad for a moment of privacy. Good gracious, what a bossy eagle! As for Gandalf... no comment. There is really no way to keep a secret anymore in Middle Earth.
“Mmm. This is very good,” munches Balthazar happily. “Now, let’s get logistics out of the way: for I’ll have to file a report to justify travel expenses and time. Why are you going to Erebor? And why couldn’t you stay there in the first place?”
Thus Bilbo goes briefly over the Quest, including his experience on the ramparts, which he thought left him scarred for life, except in the meantime he realized it’s possible to get over it, after all Erebor does hold things of interest
“Hold on,” Balthazar interrupts, red with rage. “You’re saying that demented king dangled you over a precipice? I know what will cure you in a hurry: have someone do the same thing to him!”
Bilbo laughs. He likes an eagle with a sense of humor.
“I’m serious! There’s no better therapy than giving this Thorin a taste of his own medicine!”
“Two wrongs don’t make a right,” replies Bilbo. “And I would not have anyone risk Thorin’s life, not for any therapy in the world.”
The eagle rolls his eyes. “Well? Are you going to get ready or not? Make sure to pack lots of food!”
“Wait, so... you’re actually going to take me there?”
Balthazar gives him an exasperated look, and Bilbo realizes: he hasn’t thought this through. What if I misheard? misunderstood Bofur’s or Gandalf’s words? Do I want to know how Thorin feels about me? First of all: Do I know what I feel for him...
Also, let’s not forget: I still don’t know what to say to him.
Bilbo goes back into the house, giving a side glance to the three ravens parked on his windowsill. Next time he’ll be more careful with his wishes; today, Bilbo can’t resist the one that came true. As for the above questions, he’ll have time to figure all that out on the way to Erebor.
* * *
Even while flying over mountains and valleys, the Eagle won’t stop talking. He tells memories of his encounters on these roads, always attentive to connect them with his passenger’s adventure. What did Bilbo do in Rivendell? Escape from orcs, duh. What happened next? Ugh, goblins. Eagles hate goblins too, did you know that? Oh, boy. Laketown. I’m not a fan of Men and their arrows. They don’t take kindly to us stealing their sheep. And don’t even get me started on Radagast, who puts such strong spells on his rabbits you can’t get close to catch one for a snack. He once sat me down for a full lecture about loving your neighbor, and I get it, we should have compassion for animals, but eagles need to eat!
Thus it is Bilbo has made zero progress on his main project: how to get the truth out of Thorin without revealing what Bofur said; and ideally without reference to his own feelings. Which, by the way, Bilbo still doesn’t completely comprehend. In his defense, ever since the Quest started he has had almost no alone time.
Thus one night during their journey, Bilbo stays awake to think. A plan is speedily born: as soon as he gets to Erebor and finds Thorin, he will 1. go to the ramparts with him, 2. look at Thorin with heart eyes, and 3. say: I thought of a way to erase the memory of the past. Create a new memory, here. A good one.
“I like it,” Bilbo whispers, positively enchanted. He gets up from his bedroll and approaches a tree, eager to give it a try. Pretend it’s Thorin, he tells himself, and let’s see if you remember what to say.
He remembers, all right.
“Oh, for the love of Manwë,” cries the Eagle, “could you please keep it down? Some of us need to sleep!”
“S... sorry,” says Bilbo, mortified. Oops. He’s been practicing his line out loud.
Balthazar chuckles sleepily. “As for your strategy... You’ve read too many sentimental novels, my good sir.”
“What? No good?”
“What you’re going for here is subtlety, which dwarves are not known for. I’d just give him the gist of it. Look, dude. I left this Mountain because of you, and guess what: I came back because of you.”
“That’s not bad. You are very perceptive, Mister Balthazar.”
“You’re welcome.”
“I still like mine more.”
“Suit yourself. I can only show you the way. Now sleep, Mister Baggins.”
* * *
...It is evening in Erebor. In the usual commotion approaching dinner time, when dwarves put away their tools and crafts, few notice their king drawing near a familiar place for his hour of self-discipline. Nori intercepts him: they’ve just spotted an eagle in the distance; looks like it’s coming here. Have Dwalin deal with it, says Thorin absently. Unless there’s a war, he’d rather not be disturbed.
But today he is meant to be disturbed.
It starts with intense chatter at the gate, then the noise moves inside. Where Thorin expected to be irritated, the noise soothes him; he can feel the tension in him dissipate, leaving peace in its wake.
Then, through heavy lidded eyes from tears and lack of sleep, he sees him: a figure that has haunted his many hours of wakefulness, tormenting him, for it is never real. Master Baggins is here, on the wall, with him.
“Hello, Thorin,” says Bilbo with a timid, innocent, most-captivating-in-the-world smile. “They told me I’d find you in this place.”
“Master Baggins... what are you doing here?” asks Thorin, ignoring the voice that says Do not engage, it is but a dream.
Then Bilbo gets closer, looks him in the eye with an undefined quality Thorin has never seen before, and says
“I thought of a way to erase the memory of the past. Create a new memory, here. A good one.”
Thorin’s eyes illuminate with hope.
Just then, an eagle appears into view, flying towards them. Is it possible Bilbo came all this way... could this be real. The eagle flies right above Thorin’s head and picks him up firmly in his claws. He pauses for a moment to settle the dwarf comfortably in his grip, then holds Thorin over the wall, swinging him to and fro.
“How are we feeling, Master Oakenshield? Not so pleasant, is it, to be the one dangled about! How do you like it now?”
“Please, stop! Put him down!” Bilbo rushes to the wall and holds out his hands; but even if Thorin could reach him, Bilbo is not strong enough to pull him to safety. Their eyes lock briefly in understanding this is a new memory, though unclear if what Bilbo had in mind. Then Bifur, Bofur and Dwalin run to the king’s rescue, ready to either pull him to safety or be pulled to their likely doom. Balthazar obliges them: he settles Thorin on the ledge, still holding him carefully in his talons. Dwalin manages to catch Thorin’s hand; only then, the eagle lets him go.
As soon as Thorin is safe, Bofur addresses him in an urgent tone.
“My King. An accident has happened at the lower levels. Three dwarves are trapped in a cave-in; you are needed there immediately.”
“A cave-in? I thought we saw to it this morning,” Thorin replies.
“This is a new one. I’ll tell you more on the way. Come. We have no time to waste,” says Bofur nervously, almost dragging Thorin with him.
The king turns to Bilbo, in vain trying to hide that he’s shaking in shock. “Welcome back, Master Baggins. I am sorry there is so much chaos upon your arrival.”
“I am sorry,” says Bilbo miserably. “What just passed... it’s all my fault.”
Thorin envelops him in an intense gaze. “I wish things had happened this way. That I had had my life hanging by a thread, before I could lay a hand on you.”
He turns to Bifur, says something in Khuzdul, and leaves.
“You’re under arrest for reckless endangerment and aggravated assault!” says Dwalin as he pulls a pair of handcuffs and approaches the eagle, who is still perched on the wall, grooming himself unperturbed. “You have the right to remain silent.”
Of course, the handcuffs are impossibly small for the giant bird; as for the “silent” part...
“Come on now, silly dwarf. You’re going to arrest me for this little display, that was part of much needed therapy for my client Mister Baggins here? I trust I managed to improve his associations with this blasted wall. Anyway, if anybody needs me, I’ll be chilling on top of this Mountain.”
“I won’t forget this!” Dwalin shouts after him.
* * *
On Thorin’s orders, Bifur is to take Bilbo to his guest room; which, by the sound of it, is supposed to be an upgrade from the past.
“So how are things going in Erebor? What did I miss?” Bilbo attempts some small talk.
But Bifur is not one for casual conversation.
“Oh, you know. The usual. Except Erebor is swarming with new faces: ladies and gents who have heard the king is still single and are queuing up to woo him as we speak.”
“You’re kidding.”
“It’s true. Even some of Thorin’s advisors think a partner would benefit him. They may not have a chance to win his hand, but could at least offer him some comfort at night. The guy needs a good night sleep.”
“What are you saying, that Thorin would go for a one night stand? Aren’t Dwarves supposed to have soul mates?”
“Aye. But Thorin is a king. Kings sometimes require... special treatment. And one of these dwarves may very well turn out to be his One.”
Right. Then why did I ever think that could possibly be me? Not to be mean, but Bifur did have an axe in his head for quite some time. It’s possible he’s a bit out of touch, not up to speed with Thorin’s love life. Bilbo will not let his confidence drop. At least, not until he’s close to his assigned room (which, it turns out, is situated next to the king’s suite), and his eyes detect the presence of dwarves and dwarrowdams circling the area like vultures: long haired, short haired, bearded, beardless, some fragile looking, some chiseled and fit, all uniformly handsome. Bifur shows Bilbo his room, pats him on the back and invites him for drinks later. “If you’re not too tired, of course. Otherwise, rest well, Master Baggins. And remember, if you hear any noise from the bedroom next door, don’t let it bother you. Those dwarves are here to amuse our king. You might just want to sleep with a pillow over your head.”
I need air, thinks Bilbo as he settles his pack on the floor. This will quite possibly be the shortest stay in Erebor attempted. Thank goodness Balthazar is still around.
* * *
Minutes later, Thorin is at his door.
“I am sorry I had to leave. Bofur’s concern was a false alarm. I should have known: something is not right with him.”
“Oh, no.” Bilbo has sworn he’s done lying to Thorin since the ramparts; ideally, he’s also done hiding things from him. “Did Bofur... say anything?”
“He just stopped on our way to the mines and, out of the blue, blurted some things out. That now that you’re here he senses something big is coming, and I’m probably going to have his head.”
Right. It figures it’s not just his king Bofur can’t keep a secret about, but also himself - though the accuracy of some of these secrets Bilbo begins to doubt.
“Master Baggins. I need to ask if Bofur caused any inconvenience to you.”
“I don’t... I wouldn’t put it like that. Thorin... shouldn’t we be talking about something else?”
Bilbo can’t look him in the eye, and Thorin thinks he knows why.
“You’re right. We should talk about what happened earlier on the wall. If that was meant to punish me for my grave misdeed against you, I accept it.”
“No!” Bilbo shouts in despair. “I would never allow such a thing! Mister Balthazar... he’s not really a barbarian, just a wanna-be therapist with some rather strong legalistic inclinations. I should have never told him what happened.”
“It is all right,” says Thorin. “I am glad you found someone to talk to.”
“It’s not that. It’s just... he needed to know why I left Erebor. And... why I wanted to come back.”
Thorin watches him intently, his sapphire eyes gently scrutinizing, never leaving him; it’s impossible to hide.
“And why did you come back?”
“I can’t... I can’t talk about this right now. I should never have come.”
Bilbo is on the verge of crying now. Thorin immediately rushes to his side.
“Anyway, don’t let me keep you from your activities. As I understand, your company is in high demand not just by day.”
“Master Baggins... Bilbo.” Without a further thought Thorin encloses him in his arms. “Whatever demands this kingdom has of me can wait, when it comes to you.”
What on earth am I doing here? I have no chance to compete against the best looking of your race currently lining up at your door. Gandalf must have been wrong about what dwarves use to court; or perhaps mithril is not very expensive after all. Bilbo’s mind is fired up something worse than that eagle chatterbox. Maybe I just heard what I wanted to hear. Thorin deepens his hold on him, and Bilbo can feel his own body almost dissolve, inundated with Thorin’s presence, with no line, no boundaries between them. It feels like something should happen here: maybe a new memory can still be created, but Bilbo is not in the mood to hope.
“Amrâlime... azrali mahashmur astû,” Thorin intones gently in his ear, and Bilbo can finally feel the noise inside him start to shut down, a feeling of calm drawing like a curtain over his mind. “What does it mean?” “It means...” Thorin hesitates. “Whatever it is you’re fighting, I will protect you.” Thorin’s hand reaches Bilbo’s hair and the nape of his neck, he lets his head drop on Bilbo’s shoulder and for a moment abandons himself - Bilbo is here, this is real, not one of those dreams that have tormented him the last three months, he is here, and Thorin would like nothing more than to press his lips against his skin and show him exactly what he means. “Can you protect me from what I want?” Bilbo asks. That’s right, Thorin still doesn’t know what that is, why Bilbo is here, if he will ever learn to live with this place. There’s danger in moving forward if such a question has not been addressed; but Thorin is not the best person to ask.
Bilbo pulls away from the hug, fixing him with his inquisitive gaze. “What I mean is... me wanting things has had a tendency to backfire as of late.” It’s meant to be playful, but Thorin can guess there’s much more behind.
He lets go and regards Bilbo with a smile. “I don’t believe I can protect anyone from what you want.”
Bilbo smiles in kind. “It’s good to see you, Thorin.”
“Likewise.”
“I’m feeling better now. I just need some time to process things. I’ve had... an interesting journey home and back again.”
“Of course.”
Thorin heads for the door, stops halfway, and turns.
“Master Baggins... For what it’s worth, I am happy that you came back.”
The door opens, closes, and Thorin fades from view; yet to Bilbo his body still feels connected to him. He pauses over where Thorin’s hand touched him, where his fingers caressed him in that moment of surrender, and wonders how is it possible Thorin is somewhere else now. Do I want to know how he feels... do I know what I feel for him. Finally, there is time to clarify his own feelings, to figure out what he wants; better get to it. Though now, Bilbo suspects, addressing the above questions won’t take that much time. He knows the answer to at least one of them.
